@@ricardobarahona3939 Are you implying that just because Hitler thought it a good idea to build Autobahns, we should therefore stop driving on the freeway? Because that's what banning Björn Höcke from saying "Everything for Germany" is equal too... if any national socialist did or said something in the past... it must be wrong and banned... if so... get out of your volkswagen and stop driving on freeways/motorways/autobahns... practice what you preach and don't cherry pick...
@@ricardobarahona3939 You're right, I don't know any history whatsoever about the Second World War(sarcasm, because it definitely isn't taught in every U.S. school)(what's more concerning is that I got 4's on the APUSH and APWorldHistory tests, and I still made that comment lol) . Regardless of historical knowledge, freedom of speech shouldn't be restricted unless it puts in question the safety of another individual. The phrase was used during the Nazi Regime for nationalistic propaganda, but that's my opinion. Now the Nazi's decided to utilize mass genocide, which I don't support, as a way of "getting rid of a problem." The economic status of Germany sucked, lost the war, paying reparations, it just sucked, and it wasn't the Jewish peoples' fault. However, if you want to control the freedom to voice an opinion, that is in fact very concerning.
@@Eikenhorst Not really, all Western European governments, the US and Canada, have iron clad support for Israel and will defend it's right to do whatever it likes. This goes for all parties, all mainstream TV channels, all newspapers. That's real freedom and democracy
@@clavichord All western European countries have an iron clad support for Israel? Are you sure? The only one that gives iron clad support is the USA and Canada. But to be fair, the support of the USA is all that matters, since that means they have a veto in anything. But right now a bunch of western European countries have formally accepted Palastinian statehood and before that a lot of European countries supported various motions against Israel, but none of that matters because of the USA.
@@Eikenhorst So you've not followed the news about British, Dutch and other air forces and navies going to the middle east and guarding and shooting down all threats airborn or otherwise to Israel while it genocides Gaza... and firing into Yemen.... all in our interests right? Yes, the US is all that matters but the smaller puppets seem so compelled to show their submission... I mean freedom and democracy,... towards big chief maffia boss Biden
Germany should not be damned for the past, we all should learn how one person given the right environment can push a ideology and change history. We must never forget and we must learn from our human history
This was not one person. Till now the germans managed to hide their genocide on the Poles under the carpet and increasingly try to frame them as the perpetrators. Nothing learned. Germans are ready to commit the same crimes in the near future out of a chauvinistic feeling of superiority.
Germany doesn't claim to have unrestricted freedom of speech. They very purposefully have banned speech related to Nazism because they refuse to repeat that history.
@@xoxamyyyx They may not have punished every member but regardless, even if they did, punishment does not change somebodies heart & that’s we need a practice to change humanity for the good.
@@susie4045 then the go on to have children that are racist holding hitler photos and nadsee flags. Dont forget the kkk where they claimed to be doing gods work hanging black children from trees. Anyway non of this matters climate activists are saying uk will be under water in a few years.
Thank you for pointing that out. A lot of people are not aware of that context and have never heard of the american nazi party, but everyone has heard of the Lindbergh baby. I ramble a lot about Volkswagen and Porsche and their influence on american pop culture and so on. But remember: both were literally founded because Hitler was a fan of Henry Ford.
Thank you. I came to point out this same fact, that it, too, was an American Nazi slogan (German American Bund) and that It is also still used by the KKK.
They havent arrested every single nadsee member or every single leader who was complicit in killing jews. then the go on to have children that are racist holding hitler photos and nadsee flags. Dont forget the kkk where they claimed to be doing gods work hanging black children from trees. Anyway non of this matters climate activists are saying uk will be under water in a few years.
@@matthazelnut707 countries in africa asked for its independence and the uk said no. The army really refused to leave. Then the odd timing of the right wing racists protests happen coz a black man was on mass murder spree. The timing is odd
Of course a neonazi will disagree 😅 Everything you believe in is a lie, pal. It will take some time to recover from your mental illness. Get well soon!🙏
4:21 no dude. Trump saying “America First” and purposely using Nazi populist rhetoric to push the overton window is not the same. I support free speech and she shouldn’t be restricted in mixing his pro nationalist speech with nazi slogans. He knows damn well what he doing. He is trying to reclaim hitler’s rhetoric and bring it into the mainstream. Tbh, all you’re going to do is piss people off and inflame people to become radicalized with words, and the words will lead to violence. You have a responsibility to not use nazi slogans out of respect for those in your country. In America, we have the right to say whatever we want to protect ourselves against fascists like Joe and Kamala Harris who are still working on censoring free speech on the internet to control information to control what voters see and think. They approve of France and Brazil jailing journalist, and people who promote dissent against the government’s narrative. Just because I have freedom or speech doesn’t mean I should abuse it. I have a duty to be mindful of what I say because my enemies are always ready to use it against me. Believe it or not, Joe, Kamala, Gavin Newsom want political violence, assassinations, they are looking for the right opportunity to scare the problem from people who have different ideas and ready to release a bill to attempt to reel back on our freedom. Just like they did with the patriot act.
Old enough to remember Poland, saying they didn't help the Nazi's and give up their Jewish population for extermination and genocide...that didn't go over well either.
I had Polish family members that where not Jewish and put in concentration camps. If you where in Poland and you told the NAZIS NO, what do you think they would do? Just say ok have a good day? NO, THEY WOULD KILL YOU TOO!
Once again, thank you PBS. If I had seen his answer in the interview earlier, my opposition to him would be stronger even though I partly agree with the content. I don't think just saying "Alles für Deutschland" should result in a jail sentence. But I do think anyone who takes this completely serious shouldn't be allowed to run for public office. And to answer a question like "why did you rob the bank?" with "you are completely correct, Germany's bank robbery laws are way to strict" shows pure disrespect, not only for the journalist making the interview, but also for the rule of law and democracy as a whole.
For someone like myself to be so irreverent with institutions and words. I was actually 2nd hand embarrassed of his knowing lack of self awareness to sensitivities of others given that he knows history. Grifter flags and opportunism alarm bells go off. Ironically, those were two traits of hitler. I ain’t calling this man hitler. But he is treading dangerous territory by opening the can of worms of nationalist rhetoric in the name of free speech….and he knows that. As an American, I would never think to suggest anything Ill or bad about our many memorials, museums to the slaves. It would never cross my mind to think of my strong nationalism having anything to do with forgetting about those historical places. It was hitler spoke to depressed Germans about how they were foolish to let the world disrespect them because of WW1. He isn’t really too far from the rhetoric from what I am hearing him say. I can see the slippery slope if it goes out of control. I think there is a way to communicate Germany first without repeating Hitlers rhetoric. It like trying to reclaim the mustache. It is never happening,
Germany committed the Herero and Nama genocide in German South West Africa, which is now Namibia, between 1904 and 1907. The genocide was a campaign of ethnic extermination and collective punishment that killed between 50,000-65,000 Herero and 10,000 Nama people. And nobody wants to talk about. Why? 🤔
One: You don't know what you're talking about. It's on the agenda several times a year in Germany, no need for your Wikipedia dumping. Two: It hardly qualifies as a genocide. The Herero systematically hunted and killed german settlers, committing severe acts of savagery against ordinary civilians. The Empire sent soldiers to quell the violent uprising. The Herero fled into the desert and succumbed to dehydration and exhaustion. Almost none of them died as a direct result of german action and the ones that did, died in the open combat they initiated.
For most germans it's quite irrelevant. You can see both world wars as colonial wars and the impact it had on germany, the germans and the world are much bigger. Of course a part of society will adress it, but it is not a big deal.
USA was created by White Christians, British, French, Spanish, invading and slaughtering 12+ MILLION native people. Then they herded the rest into reservations where they still languish. Then USA dropped nuclear bombs on 100% civilians, twice. Nobody wants to talk about these massacres either.
He probably should have said, "Germany First," instead of the Nazi slogan. As a history teacher he is embarrassing, and so deserves the $30,000 fine !! 🙄
That was my exact thought. If you wanted to say Germany First, like Trump, you should have said that. Except you didn't, you used a known nazi slogan lol. Facetious bastard.
I am against the concept of paying fines for saying gross stuff. But he deserves shame in the public square. He knew what he was doing, and that makes him scary to me. All it takes is his successor to say “You know what, we want more than Hitlers 5 greatest hits. We want all his slogans”. Perhaps his successor doesn’t know history as well and doesn’t know what lines not to cross and in pursuit of power gets innocent people killed my hateful ignorant people who thought they were the victims.
Germany: We've done horrible things in the past. And we must alwyas remember them so that we never do it again Some guy quoting Nazi slogans: Nah we dont gotta do that stop living in the past bro
Is Mongolia saddled with the guilt of Genghis Khan? How about modern day Islam for the occupation of Iberian Peninsula for hundreds of years following their conquest in the 700s?
Not many countries have committed Genocide on that scale either. Rwanda is indeed comparable, although not quite. I would say Japan should have such a memorial and that they are now even try to claim they are the victim of the first nuclear bombs is sickening. Second of course should be Turkey, where their actions against Armenians are the origin of the word Genocide. Both countries are too proud to do such a thing, showing their true weakness.
It's important to understand that much of this party's success is a pushback against Merkel's liberal/socialist policies of excessive immigration, ... At a certain point the electorate says enough and votes the bums out. And that means voting for the other parties, especially the ones opposing the excesses.
If you are capable of killing over 20 millions people and turns the entire world into a horror movie.. Yes, I thinks people should be concern about some speach...
This situations are very interesting for Koreans. As a South Korean, we also still divided our country and reunite will happen in the future. Economy gap, Second Class citizen problem, Immigrants problem, Different Ideology background, Etc. Personally think, East germans are not Evil. The combination of problems that They treated slightly bad than West Germans, Shortage of Public rental, Inflations and more things make conflict and show the result of AFD rising. But I think Many things change after WW2 in Germany, so they will solve or relax matters near future.
AFD is a legal political party that USA wants to ban, under orders from Israel. Background: In spite of USA roasting alive thousands of German women and children in cities like Dresden... Germans are subservient to USA. Why? Because 70% Germans were killed by Russian fire. The spanking from Russia was so hard that Germans decided to beg USA to save them from Russian wrath. Modern day: Germans are sick of lacking a pair. They want to stop the muslimization of their country. But Israel wants Germans to remain subservient to USA. PBS, under orders from Isrealis is making misleading propaganda against AFD. Sad day for Germans.
We cannot access the full documentary of Germany's Enemy Within, neither directly nor indirectly via TH-cam. And we live in Germany. Can you please see to it that this problem is fixed, especially as state elections are coming up in September? Thank you.
Das liegt im Prinzip an uns, hat meine ich was mit EU und irgend nem Datenschutz zutun& weil Europäer im Endeffekt nicht die Zielgruppe sind, werden wir quasi direkt ausgeschlossen. Brauchst einfach nur nen VPN, dann klappts. Ist sowieso ratsam, entweder du gönnst dir ein Abo (ich nutze NordVPN, kann man eigentlich sehr gut empfehlen) oder du musst mal im Appstore schauen, es gibt meine ich auch kostenlose. Dort musst du im Endeffekt Werbung schauen, jede Werbung steht dann für Zeit X die du den VPN nutzen kannst. Geht eigentlich auch fit.
@@SweetChicagoGatorI dont agree with his statements, but if you dont believe in freedom of speech and the First Amendment, which permits people to say offensive things, you should leave America (your username, ironically, refers to Chicago of all places). The government should not have the authority to punish people for speech you or anyone else deems offensive. People like you, with authoritarian instincts, are also a threat to democracy.
The guys views are a bit weird but saying “everything for your country” and being fined for it is a bit much. It’s not like he performed those atrocities of years past. He’s a nationalist and his closing statement comparing the US is right.
The documentary is very much in line with the mainstream narrative, which isn't completely wrong, but very one-sided. The experts cited here aren't exactly beacons of neutrality. Unlike the election results would have you believe, very few Germans want to return to any form of Nazism, however the AfD is the only relevant right-wing party in Germany at the moment, hoovering up the protest votes against an out-of-control left-wing government. The AfD has members who should never be given political power, so it would be wise for the established parties to take AfD voters' concerns more seriously.
Currently German history in schools is 10% of actual history and 90% "we are bad Nazis" history. This creates a culture of shame and loss of patriotism. Which is especially sad when one remembers that many Jewish People who have been murdered by the Nazis were proud German Patriots who fought bravely for Germany in WW1. Unfortunately nowadays our goverment consists of mostly criminal people who literally hate germany and even stated this even several times before gaining power. The AfD cannot and will not revert the history of germany. But they will hopefully reduce the ideology of shame for future generations. By the way. If saying "Alles für Deutschland" is punishable by law where do we stop then? Hitler said "Guten Morgen" every day. Should we forbid that now too? Hitler introduced Animal Rights in Germany. Should we take them back? By allowing Left-Radical Elements to use Language as an weapon against others, how exactly are we better than the Nazis? More than 50% of all germans already have a migration background. Therefore i find it very hard to believe that AfD will be able to create a new Nazi State. But they will remove all illegals in germany. That is for sure. And it will be ok.
@@marsburner No, you were not hurting my feelings. Höcke does. You are just obviously lying, and from my experience it is waste of time to engage with types like you. People from other countries might not be able to see that and I wanted to give them a heads up.
@@guidobolke5618I only read assumptions and no prove at all. At first how can you know that höcke was lying the first time? The slogan "Alles für Deutschland" is so unknown that 99% of germans don't even know it was used by the SA. Even the Verfassungschutz didn't listed that sentence as nazi speech on their website and corrected it while this case was going on. History is also not just about ww2 and slogans nobody cares. The SPD used that in their 30s and 40s and Ludwig the first also used this quote in the 19 century. Btw this quote is not basicly forbidden and it depends on the context. Since höcke didnt glorify the nazis and was just talking about making good politics for his state and germany i don't see any problem here. I rather find it crazy that somebody get such a heavy fine for a actual positiv quote while sombody who was member of spd got a fine of 5000€ for child pornography. Just let that sink in.
What about the British and the French or maybe the Italians or Belgium or maybe the Japanisch at das East what about them they committed atrocities aswell.
I'd made some comments about this short documentary...Some not really politically correct comments...And TH-cam censores had removedvthose comments ride away! The Big Brother is really watching!!!😂
Can anyone recommend a good German right-wing media channel with videos in English; to compensate for the IQ points I lost by watching this socialist nonsense?
Im gonna come back later to comment must calm down first because that crap really p’s me off How is that even allowed? All that the Nazis did how is that kinda talk even allowed in 2024 I watch a ton of documentaries alot are ww2 i feel like it was the greatest generation the men made in that time period will never be matched because of the war they went thru the soldiering they had to do for the world . War will never be like that again because of the tech now. Great men fought that! Americans Italians Russia gave so much fighting that stuff over 25 million people Russia gave. I dont see how guys like this are even allowed now!
I understand his position that saying the same words under new political conditions 79 years later is not the same as it was meant to mean back in 1933-45. If he was to show a Nazi Flag or use the Seig Hiel salute, that I could understand being a crime.
Yes, but he is lying, he knows what he is doing and he is doing it deliberately to push the boundaries. It is not the first time and he and his party have been doing that for years. They are having fun to violate the taboo, to desecrate the holy, they are fundamently indecent.
AFD is a legal political party that USA wants to ban, under orders from Israel. Background: In spite of USA roasting alive thousands of German women and children in cities like Dresden... Germans are subservient to USA. Why? Because 70% Germans were killed by Russian fire. The spanking from Russia was so hard that Germans decided to beg USA to save them from Russian wrath. Modern day: Germans are sick of lacking a pair. They want to stop the muslimization of their country. But Israel wants Germans to remain subservient to USA. PBS, under orders from Isrealis is making misleading propaganda against AFD. Sad day for Germans.
If I would visit you and your mum at our place for the first time and I would start calling you a hrsn, würde ich dann soziale Konsequenzen spüren? Wieder jemand der nicht weiß was Meinungsfreiheit ist lmao.
@@USEismydream 1. I said in public. 2. What does society care about my mother? It's about politically relevant topics... Nächstes mal nachdenken bevor man sich hier zum Affen macht..
Not having freedom of speech is crazy, yeah ik you can’t make threats in the US, but saying “Everything for Germany” shouldn’t be a crime
Freedom of speech and open debate is dangerous for those with weak arguments
You're lack of historical knowledge is concerning.
@@clavichord Bro the AfD get a slap on the wrist all the time. The good old dog whistle always gets the job done over directly saying things.
@@ricardobarahona3939 Are you implying that just because Hitler thought it a good idea to build Autobahns, we should therefore stop driving on the freeway? Because that's what banning Björn Höcke from saying "Everything for Germany" is equal too... if any national socialist did or said something in the past... it must be wrong and banned... if so... get out of your volkswagen and stop driving on freeways/motorways/autobahns... practice what you preach and don't cherry pick...
@@ricardobarahona3939 You're right, I don't know any history whatsoever about the Second World War(sarcasm, because it definitely isn't taught in every U.S. school)(what's more concerning is that I got 4's on the APUSH and APWorldHistory tests, and I still made that comment lol) . Regardless of historical knowledge, freedom of speech shouldn't be restricted unless it puts in question the safety of another individual. The phrase was used during the Nazi Regime for nationalistic propaganda, but that's my opinion. Now the Nazi's decided to utilize mass genocide, which I don't support, as a way of "getting rid of a problem." The economic status of Germany sucked, lost the war, paying reparations, it just sucked, and it wasn't the Jewish peoples' fault. However, if you want to control the freedom to voice an opinion, that is in fact very concerning.
Germany for Germans.
I didn't know wanting a country of your own was far-right. Maybe someone should tell Israel
I don't know where you are from, but Israel's policy is considered far right and basically equal to Apartheid. So you are not wrong.
Everyone does?
@@Eikenhorst Not really, all Western European governments, the US and Canada, have iron clad support for Israel and will defend it's right to do whatever it likes. This goes for all parties, all mainstream TV channels, all newspapers. That's real freedom and democracy
@@clavichord All western European countries have an iron clad support for Israel? Are you sure? The only one that gives iron clad support is the USA and Canada. But to be fair, the support of the USA is all that matters, since that means they have a veto in anything. But right now a bunch of western European countries have formally accepted Palastinian statehood and before that a lot of European countries supported various motions against Israel, but none of that matters because of the USA.
@@Eikenhorst So you've not followed the news about British, Dutch and other air forces and navies going to the middle east and guarding and shooting down all threats airborn or otherwise to Israel while it genocides Gaza... and firing into Yemen.... all in our interests right? Yes, the US is all that matters but the smaller puppets seem so compelled to show their submission... I mean freedom and democracy,... towards big chief maffia boss Biden
Germany should not be damned for the past, we all should learn how one person given the right environment can push a ideology and change history. We must never forget and we must learn from our human history
This was not one person. Till now the germans managed to hide their genocide on the Poles under the carpet and increasingly try to frame them as the perpetrators. Nothing learned. Germans are ready to commit the same crimes in the near future out of a chauvinistic feeling of superiority.
You can’t say “everything for Germany” or it’s a criminal charge yeah Germany has freedom of speech alright….
Germany doesn't claim to have unrestricted freedom of speech. They very purposefully have banned speech related to Nazism because they refuse to repeat that history.
Fine’s & punishments only go so far. It’s the heart that needs to change. Addressing this in the sad, sick world right now should be the focus.
they havent arrested every single member of nadsees or every single leader that was complicit
@@xoxamyyyx They may not have punished every member but regardless, even if they did, punishment does not change somebodies heart & that’s we need a practice to change humanity for the good.
@@susie4045 then the go on to have children that are racist holding hitler photos and nadsee flags. Dont forget the kkk where they claimed to be doing gods work hanging black children from trees. Anyway non of this matters climate activists are saying uk will be under water in a few years.
keep seething hole
America First has long ties to Nazism in America. So, that doesn't really help his case.
Nazis introduced animal rights for the first time. Let's get rid of animal rights
He doesn't need help. For normal people. For you and the like...
Thank you for pointing that out. A lot of people are not aware of that context and have never heard of the american nazi party, but everyone has heard of the Lindbergh baby. I ramble a lot about Volkswagen and Porsche and their influence on american pop culture and so on. But remember: both were literally founded because Hitler was a fan of Henry Ford.
Thank you. I came to point out this same fact, that it, too, was an American Nazi slogan (German American Bund) and that It is also still used by the KKK.
Those who forget the past are condemned to repeat it👈
This is how it starts...once you get on that slippery slope, there's no turning back....🙄
The same on the opposite side, Europe will be completely demographically displaced and the changes are already beginning to be seen
Why don't you make up your own saying instead of repeating something that people have heard millions of times
They havent arrested every single nadsee member or every single leader who was complicit in killing jews.
then the go on to have children that are racist holding hitler photos and nadsee flags. Dont forget the kkk where they claimed to be doing gods work hanging black children from trees. Anyway non of this matters climate activists are saying uk will be under water in a few years.
@@matthazelnut707 countries in africa asked for its independence and the uk said no. The army really refused to leave. Then the odd timing of the right wing racists protests happen coz a black man was on mass murder spree. The timing is odd
@@xoxamyyyx and look at Africa now
Alles für Deutschland!!!
Glad to see so many people here not believing this nonsense
Says a guy who has "Time to clean up Europe" on his page and 88 in his name.
@@l0wrid3r88 typical example of Antifa. The are banned in USA for a reason;)
Of course a neonazi will disagree 😅 Everything you believe in is a lie, pal. It will take some time to recover from your mental illness. Get well soon!🙏
@@l0wrid3r88yeah, the wehraboos/neo-nazis are running rampant in these youtube comment sections
@@l0wrid3r88 yeah nazis are all the same
An actually innocent response would be, "Oh shit, really? I'm so, so sorry. I will find some other way to say what I was trying to say."
They never are that introspective, they always double down since having second thoughts would be seen as "weak" and caving in.
Gob Bless Bjorn Hocke.
The Governor of Florida did the same!! You can teach the Slavery in the classroom!
4:21 no dude. Trump saying “America First” and purposely using Nazi populist rhetoric to push the overton window is not the same. I support free speech and she shouldn’t be restricted in mixing his pro nationalist speech with nazi slogans. He knows damn well what he doing. He is trying to reclaim hitler’s rhetoric and bring it into the mainstream. Tbh, all you’re going to do is piss people off and inflame people to become radicalized with words, and the words will lead to violence. You have a responsibility to not use nazi slogans out of respect for those in your country. In America, we have the right to say whatever we want to protect ourselves against fascists like Joe and Kamala Harris who are still working on censoring free speech on the internet to control information to control what voters see and think. They approve of France and Brazil jailing journalist, and people who promote dissent against the government’s narrative. Just because I have freedom or speech doesn’t mean I should abuse it. I have a duty to be mindful of what I say because my enemies are always ready to use it against me. Believe it or not, Joe, Kamala, Gavin Newsom want political violence, assassinations, they are looking for the right opportunity to scare the problem from people who have different ideas and ready to release a bill to attempt to reel back on our freedom. Just like they did with the patriot act.
Old enough to remember Poland, saying they didn't help the Nazi's and give up their Jewish population for extermination and genocide...that didn't go over well either.
We killed a quarter of their population. Nowadays I think they can remember it however they want.
I had Polish family members that where not Jewish and put in concentration camps. If you where in Poland and you told the NAZIS NO, what do you think they would do? Just say ok have a good day? NO, THEY WOULD KILL YOU TOO!
Once again, thank you PBS. If I had seen his answer in the interview earlier, my opposition to him would be stronger even though I partly agree with the content.
I don't think just saying "Alles für Deutschland" should result in a jail sentence. But I do think anyone who takes this completely serious shouldn't be allowed to run for public office. And to answer a question like "why did you rob the bank?" with "you are completely correct, Germany's bank robbery laws are way to strict" shows pure disrespect, not only for the journalist making the interview, but also for the rule of law and democracy as a whole.
For someone like myself to be so irreverent with institutions and words. I was actually 2nd hand embarrassed of his knowing lack of self awareness to sensitivities of others given that he knows history. Grifter flags and opportunism alarm bells go off. Ironically, those were two traits of hitler. I ain’t calling this man hitler. But he is treading dangerous territory by opening the can of worms of nationalist rhetoric in the name of free speech….and he knows that. As an American, I would never think to suggest anything Ill or bad about our many memorials, museums to the slaves. It would never cross my mind to think of my strong nationalism having anything to do with forgetting about those historical places. It was hitler spoke to depressed Germans about how they were foolish to let the world disrespect them because of WW1. He isn’t really too far from the rhetoric from what I am hearing him say. I can see the slippery slope if it goes out of control. I think there is a way to communicate Germany first without repeating Hitlers rhetoric. It like trying to reclaim the mustache. It is never happening,
Germany committed the Herero and Nama genocide in German South West Africa, which is now Namibia, between 1904 and 1907. The genocide was a campaign of ethnic extermination and collective punishment that killed between 50,000-65,000 Herero and 10,000 Nama people. And nobody wants to talk about. Why? 🤔
Many people talk about it. Germany paid reparations to Namibia and regularly apologizes for its own colonial politics.
One: You don't know what you're talking about. It's on the agenda several times a year in Germany, no need for your Wikipedia dumping.
Two: It hardly qualifies as a genocide. The Herero systematically hunted and killed german settlers, committing severe acts of savagery against ordinary civilians. The Empire sent soldiers to quell the violent uprising. The Herero fled into the desert and succumbed to dehydration and exhaustion. Almost none of them died as a direct result of german action and the ones that did, died in the open combat they initiated.
who cares
For most germans it's quite irrelevant. You can see both world wars as colonial wars and the impact it had on germany, the germans and the world are much bigger. Of course a part of society will adress it, but it is not a big deal.
USA was created by White Christians, British, French, Spanish, invading and slaughtering 12+ MILLION native people. Then they herded the rest into reservations where they still languish. Then USA dropped nuclear bombs on 100% civilians, twice.
Nobody wants to talk about these massacres either.
Never have I seen such a spineless country
Sprich für dein selbst
He probably should have said, "Germany First," instead of the Nazi slogan. As a history teacher he is embarrassing, and so deserves the $30,000 fine !! 🙄
That was my exact thought. If you wanted to say Germany First, like Trump, you should have said that. Except you didn't, you used a known nazi slogan lol.
Facetious bastard.
This is not embarrassing. You're just another normie
I am against the concept of paying fines for saying gross stuff. But he deserves shame in the public square. He knew what he was doing, and that makes him scary to me. All it takes is his successor to say “You know what, we want more than Hitlers 5 greatest hits. We want all his slogans”. Perhaps his successor doesn’t know history as well and doesn’t know what lines not to cross and in pursuit of power gets innocent people killed my hateful ignorant people who thought they were the victims.
He looks and acts like a reincarnated Nazi officer😥
Funny, was thinking exactly the same. The look in his eyes does not hide his intent.
Maybe he has a MAGA hat.
It's the cynical smile when he lies to you in the face.
And quoting tr💩mp, NOT a good sign, either!!!
@@gingerc5292 What drugs are you taking?
Germany: We've done horrible things in the past. And we must alwyas remember them so that we never do it again
Some guy quoting Nazi slogans: Nah we dont gotta do that stop living in the past bro
Is Mongolia saddled with the guilt of Genghis Khan? How about modern day Islam for the occupation of Iberian Peninsula for hundreds of years following their conquest in the 700s?
You even know what the so called nazi slogan is? I guess not.
"the only people in the world to have planted a memorial of shame in the heart of its capital"
Um, what about Rwanda?
Also, London is going to (or already has?) create memorials to the transatlantic slave trade.
Not many countries have committed Genocide on that scale either. Rwanda is indeed comparable, although not quite. I would say Japan should have such a memorial and that they are now even try to claim they are the victim of the first nuclear bombs is sickening. Second of course should be Turkey, where their actions against Armenians are the origin of the word Genocide. Both countries are too proud to do such a thing, showing their true weakness.
It's important to understand that much of this party's success is a pushback against Merkel's liberal/socialist policies of excessive immigration, ... At a certain point the electorate says enough and votes the bums out. And that means voting for the other parties, especially the ones opposing the excesses.
That phrase was used by other politicians in the last 40 years
Germany has no freedom of speech ??😂😂
Social consequences or maybe lose your job if you would say the truth in public...
@@mr.tobson6510 damn that’s horrible 🤦♂️
If you are capable of killing over 20 millions people and turns the entire world into a horror movie.. Yes, I thinks people should be concern about some speach...
This situations are very interesting for Koreans. As a South Korean, we also still divided our country and reunite will happen in the future.
Economy gap, Second Class citizen problem, Immigrants problem, Different Ideology background, Etc.
Personally think, East germans are not Evil. The combination of problems that They treated slightly bad than West Germans, Shortage of Public rental, Inflations and more things make conflict and show the result of AFD rising.
But I think Many things change after WW2 in Germany, so they will solve or relax matters near future.
Whatever. It's ok to be German. Go AfD.
Germanys current laws are completely ridiculous
God bless Germany.
@@catholicdevotee_119 Oh yes. Clown world.
In the memory of my Uncle Bernard Whitney O'Neill.
"The World has gone Mad."
I was expecting the audiences to start shouting sieg heil.
Yes, I personaly did! But TH-cam's censores have erased my comments! "The Big Brother is really watcing you!"😂
And Elon Musk is pushing him and other fascists and giving them his twitler stage, even reposting him.
AFD is a legal political party that USA wants to ban, under orders from Israel.
Background: In spite of USA roasting alive thousands of German women and children in cities like Dresden... Germans are subservient to USA. Why? Because 70% Germans were killed by Russian fire. The spanking from Russia was so hard that Germans decided to beg USA to save them from Russian wrath.
Modern day: Germans are sick of lacking a pair. They want to stop the muslimization of their country. But Israel wants Germans to remain subservient to USA.
PBS, under orders from Isrealis is making misleading propaganda against AFD. Sad day for Germans.
Based Elon
Communists hate freedom of speech
We cannot access the full documentary of Germany's Enemy Within, neither directly nor indirectly via TH-cam. And we live in Germany. Can you please see to it that this problem is fixed, especially as state elections are coming up in September? Thank you.
Das liegt im Prinzip an uns, hat meine ich was mit EU und irgend nem Datenschutz zutun& weil Europäer im Endeffekt nicht die Zielgruppe sind, werden wir quasi direkt ausgeschlossen.
Brauchst einfach nur nen VPN, dann klappts. Ist sowieso ratsam, entweder du gönnst dir ein Abo (ich nutze NordVPN, kann man eigentlich sehr gut empfehlen) oder du musst mal im Appstore schauen, es gibt meine ich auch kostenlose.
Dort musst du im Endeffekt Werbung schauen, jede Werbung steht dann für Zeit X die du den VPN nutzen kannst. Geht eigentlich auch fit.
Try a VPN.
You cant kill wotan his grand daughter is the godess of death. That is inpractical.
“A political extremism expert”
🙄 ok
People like this are very dangerous and hateful, They need to know that.
Nope
Not a very bright history professor in choice of words for Germany. Stupidly, must pay $30,000 fine as a consequence. Hopefully lesson learned?!
@@SweetChicagoGator No freedom in Germany
@@SweetChicagoGatorI dont agree with his statements, but if you dont believe in freedom of speech and the First Amendment, which permits people to say offensive things, you should leave America (your username, ironically, refers to Chicago of all places). The government should not have the authority to punish people for speech you or anyone else deems offensive. People like you, with authoritarian instincts, are also a threat to democracy.
The guys views are a bit weird but saying “everything for your country” and being fined for it is a bit much. It’s not like he performed those atrocities of years past. He’s a nationalist and his closing statement comparing the US is right.
Did he just praise Trump ? 😞
Obviously, even though people like him prefer Putin over Trump. The far right in Germany are pro Russian lmao.
😂 Frontline because of us he was fined 30k dollars 💸 freedom 😅😂🎉
The documentary is very much in line with the mainstream narrative, which isn't completely wrong, but very one-sided. The experts cited here aren't exactly beacons of neutrality. Unlike the election results would have you believe, very few Germans want to return to any form of Nazism, however the AfD is the only relevant right-wing party in Germany at the moment, hoovering up the protest votes against an out-of-control left-wing government. The AfD has members who should never be given political power, so it would be wise for the established parties to take AfD voters' concerns more seriously.
The Holocaust memorial is a monument of pride, victory and positivity then? Oh Stephan Kramer. The Antifa Fan boy haha.
Considering Antifa is short for anti-fascism, and Nazism was a type of fascism, should it not be the other way round?
@@pokechatter Fuck Antifa
Alles für Deutschland
I look forward to the full episode!
it's out now
@@maywecare I watched it last night. Thank you for the heads up!
Hard to believe a history teacher doesn't want to learn from his education/career....👎🤬
This is one of the dangers of Trumpism.
Currently German history in schools is 10% of actual history and 90% "we are bad Nazis" history. This creates a culture of shame and loss of patriotism. Which is especially sad when one remembers that many Jewish People who have been murdered by the Nazis were proud German Patriots who fought bravely for Germany in WW1. Unfortunately nowadays our goverment consists of mostly criminal people who literally hate germany and even stated this even several times before gaining power.
The AfD cannot and will not revert the history of germany. But they will hopefully reduce the ideology of shame for future generations.
By the way. If saying "Alles für Deutschland" is punishable by law where do we stop then? Hitler said "Guten Morgen" every day. Should we forbid that now too? Hitler introduced Animal Rights in Germany. Should we take them back? By allowing Left-Radical Elements to use Language as an weapon against others, how exactly are we better than the Nazis? More than 50% of all germans already have a migration background. Therefore i find it very hard to believe that AfD will be able to create a new Nazi State. But they will remove all illegals in germany. That is for sure. And it will be ok.
This man is not saying the truth.
And then there's Zionist Israel committing genocide on the Palestinian people.
@@guidobolke5618 Do you mind sharing where you see any false statements or did i just hurt your "feelings"'?
@@marsburner No, you were not hurting my feelings. Höcke does. You are just obviously lying, and from my experience it is waste of time to engage with types like you. People from other countries might not be able to see that and I wanted to give them a heads up.
@@guidobolke5618I only read assumptions and no prove at all.
At first how can you know that höcke was lying the first time? The slogan "Alles für Deutschland" is so unknown that 99% of germans don't even know it was used by the SA. Even the Verfassungschutz didn't listed that sentence as nazi speech on their website and corrected it while this case was going on. History is also not just about ww2 and slogans nobody cares. The SPD used that in their 30s and 40s and Ludwig the first also used this quote in the 19 century. Btw this quote is not basicly forbidden and it depends on the context. Since höcke didnt glorify the nazis and was just talking about making good politics for his state and germany i don't see any problem here.
I rather find it crazy that somebody get such a heavy fine for a actual positiv quote while sombody who was member of spd got a fine of 5000€ for child pornography. Just let that sink in.
Must be a distant relative😂
Is this new??
Sounds like a cool guy, if not a little liberal for my taste. 🙂
Gross
he's based as fuck for that
The man is a neo-Nazi. That means you are pro-Nazi.
💰
What about the British and the French or maybe the Italians or Belgium or maybe the Japanisch at das East what about them they committed atrocities aswell.
Germany industrialized murder... THAT'S WHY whataboutism and pointing the finger isn't appropriate.
I'd made some comments about this short documentary...Some not really politically correct comments...And TH-cam censores had removedvthose comments ride away! The Big Brother is really watching!!!😂
😲
Can anyone recommend a good German right-wing media channel with videos in English; to compensate for the IQ points I lost by watching this socialist nonsense?
What a guy
More public access propaganda. So glad my tax dollars pay for this.
Germany will never be a World Power like great britian was
We dont want to be a world power, we just want to live in peace and prosperity. This is what the AfD wants.
...was...
Im gonna come back later to comment must calm down first because that crap really p’s me off
How is that even allowed?
All that the Nazis did how is that kinda talk even allowed in 2024
I watch a ton of documentaries alot are ww2 i feel like it was the greatest generation the men made in that time period will never be matched because of the war they went thru the soldiering they had to do for the world . War will never be like that again because of the tech now.
Great men fought that! Americans Italians Russia gave so much fighting that stuff over 25 million people Russia gave. I dont see how guys like this are even allowed now!
FCKAFD
Cry hrder
Sounds pretty cool . Good work AFD
Hocke was thrown out from the Alternative fur Deutschland in 2020.
Why are you spreading fake news? I'm pretty sure that's a crime in Germany.
PBS you are using comment booster i see lots of fake and irrevelant comments
Welcome to russia trying to run over europe. These comments are everywhere when the topic is about afd. Afd is a proxy party financed by russia.
Yup. PBS got bought out years ago. A sellout.
Germany is lost again
I understand his position that saying the same words under new political conditions 79 years later is not the same as it was meant to mean back in 1933-45. If he was to show a Nazi Flag or use the Seig Hiel salute, that I could understand being a crime.
Yes, but he is lying, he knows what he is doing and he is doing it deliberately to push the boundaries. It is not the first time and he and his party have been doing that for years. They are having fun to violate the taboo, to desecrate the holy, they are fundamently indecent.
@@guidobolke5618 What did he lie about?
@@cm-bp4ow "saying the same words under new political conditions is not the same as it was meant to mean back in 1933-45".
Looks like a solid documentary, of course people will call Frontline politically leaning? Frontline just presents the FACTS AND NOTHING BUT THE FACTS!
AFD is a legal political party that USA wants to ban, under orders from Israel.
Background: In spite of USA roasting alive thousands of German women and children in cities like Dresden... Germans are subservient to USA. Why? Because 70% Germans were killed by Russian fire. The spanking from Russia was so hard that Germans decided to beg USA to save them from Russian wrath.
Modern day: Germans are sick of lacking a pair. They want to stop the muslimization of their country. But Israel wants Germans to remain subservient to USA.
PBS, under orders from Isrealis is making misleading propaganda against AFD. Sad day for Germans.
Leaving out facts and presenting only one side may be ‘presenting facts’. Just not all of them and highlighting only certain ones.
@@dant.e. BLAH BLAH BLAH 😆😅😂🤣
@@ZMAN_420
That‘s all you have to offer? 👻
Seems like i was just beaten by an authentic leftist.
I am a German and I’m pretty sure we have freedom of speech.
Really? So if i would criticize migration in public i wouldn't experience any social consequences? Come on...
If I would visit you and your mum at our place for the first time and I would start calling you a hrsn, würde ich dann soziale Konsequenzen spüren?
Wieder jemand der nicht weiß was Meinungsfreiheit ist lmao.
@@USEismydream 1. I said in public. 2. What does society care about my mother? It's about politically relevant topics... Nächstes mal nachdenken bevor man sich hier zum Affen macht..
@@USEismydream Well I really don't care tho what you say about holes
@@mr.tobson6510 sorry for the misunderstanding I meant we have “freedom” of speech to criticise the migration problem, I agree with you .
I thought whitewashing meant drawing characters with a too light skin tone
AfD is in a collation with Polish „Konfederacja” in the EU parliament.
Next, he will probably write a book talking about his 'struggle' 🥸 🖕
And why not! I think he's a very good person and he has a right to express his opinion. I wish him Good Luck!!🙏
He has already written it.