Revolt Against Award To TM Krishna | Star After Star Attacks Music Academy | 6PM Prime
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 มี.ค. 2024
- Recently, TM Krishna won the Sangita Kalanidhi by the Music Academy. Carnatic vocalists Ranjani-Gayatri and Harikatha exponent Dushyanth Sridhar withdrew from the Music Academy conference this year because of Krishna's participation.
#indiatoday #indiatodaylive #carnaticmusic #carnatic #tmkrishna #sangeethakalanidhi #ranjanigayatri #akshitanandagopal #6pmprime
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va2A...
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
![ถ้าพี่วุ้นท้อง แป้งจะท้องไปด้วยกัน !!!! [ดูคลิปเต็มหน้าช่อง] #Short | PANG ORNHIRA](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FeyEnVMwitA/mqdefault.jpg)
The answer is simple. The video opens with a bit of song
" Jagadhaanandha Kaaraka" which is praise of Lord Ram composed by Swami Thiagaraja. T M Krishna might have sung hundreds of such songs of Thiagaraja Swamigal and other great composers in praise of Gods and Goddesses of Hinduism and would have earned lakhs of rupees as remuneration.
The same T M Krishna chose to sing co😊mpositions eulogising one E V Ramaswamy who insulted Lord Ram by garlanding his portrait with chappals and slapping the portrait with chappals and raising abusive and obscene slogans against
Lord Ram and Sita. He had the audacity to sing such compositions side by side with the compositions of great composers. He verbally abused his music bretheren who belonged to his own community that they are casteists. To simply put he is a brat. The anger of the musicians is against only the Music Academy while they acknowledge his artistry.
Such types of persons ( likes of TMK) are called criminally intelligent and perverted ones.
TMK is not "sangeetha kalanidhi"; the apt recognition would be "sangeetha karunanidhi".
Very correct.
😂😊😅😮
No one has a right to insult sanatana dharma and no award should be given to a person who openly criticises the basis of carnatic music does not deserve any award True lovers of music should boycott his concerts . Does he want to get into Tamilnadu politics by passing such remarks .
yes, see who is supporting him... Stalin🤣
@@malathirajan226
Do not worry. DMK is not that foolish to put him even in a ward election or appoint him in any board for the simple reason he is a Brahmin. See what happened to Kamal. Whether he disowns or not the tag will always get attached to him.
This is a kind of yuddha between dharma and adharma. Stalin is on TM Krishna’s side… so we know which side is adharma.
My sincere gratitude to all the eminent artists who have raised the issue.
धर्मो रक्षति रक्षितः
Forget Dharma ,it is a far-fetched fruit for Karunanidhi clan. Is there basic honesty and thought process ? TMK was a privileged spoilt kid and still so barring his age.
TMK is given award just because he comes from TTK family. Why TMK engage Brahmin artists for accompaniment. He talks a lot but didn't follow any of his statements. He is just a politician, preaching something but following just the opposite. If TMK is really follows what he says, he should not accept this award. He earned fame, money with all Mahaan Vaggeyakaras but insults them. Music Acadamy should be ashamed to offer this award to TMK on influential basis only
On that note, we also know how Trichur Ramachandran was lobbying as well. These awards are mockery for the art but fame for artist.
To put it in other way Classical Music and Dance and two streams where brahminical dominance is not broken yet. If we accept what they think is right...untouchability, not allowing other castes to study vedas is right..
@@sujan4cs Similarly, Islamic domination of Qawwali , Ghazal, Bollywood is not broken yet.
@@sujan4cs has anyone stopped you from learning.... In this age of internet / social media, there is equal opportunity for everyone to learn and demonstrate their capabilities.
Instead of cribbing that some discrimination happened ages ago why don’t you move forward.
Does anyone who listens to music start by looking at the cast of the singer before listening... same goes to those who teach.... do you mean teachers check the cast of the person who comes for training.... nonsense....
Rubbish argument
Hats off to TM krishnaa... He is against Brahmin supremacy that's problem
Please give an award from all Television news channels for Dushyanth for airing his crisp views to the viewers of your channel
Giving award to TMK, is an insult to carnatic music. Never knew that Music Academy can stoop down to this extent.
We all know why the award is given to T M Krishna. We are against that cause
Many Brahmin musicians worshipped music, lived and died for it. They spent very poor lives and took forward the legacy of great kriti kartas of Carnatic music inspite of their hardships. Without them Carnatic music would have already been extinct.
1000% Truth.❤
good question Dushyanth Sridhar....
This guy is maverick
Congrats Shri TMK
Congrats TMK on getting Stalin's support
Can this sister's challenge tmks talent.he is great musician
Not challenge,but did TMK said and done anti Sanatana speeches?
She's basically equivalent to his mother in terms of knowledge
@@LetsbeHonest97 😂😂
No one wants to stoop to the levels of tmk. He comes from a privileged family - his ancestor was one of the founders of music academy. He got everything easy in life, obviously does not know the value of the art he has . And is throwing it away. Doesn't that make this award due to nepotism?? The laughable irony is that tmk wanted to eliminate nepotism 😂😂 . Such behavior of forcing others to act a certain way but never practicing it oneself is a leftist disease, and he seems to have it in abundance
Yes - TMK ஸங்கீதம் ரொம்ப ரொம்ப ஒஸ்த்தி - அந்தராத்மாவ தொடும்.
TM krishna is part of Tukade Tukade gang. Go back and watch his past statements and words.
You are from jodo batch it seemsm😊
TM Krishna.He is a legend and best human.
He is capable of spitting in the plate he is eating.😂😂
yes, legendary for mindless blabbering
There is a statement on screen here, "withdrawing from music industry" which is wrong
The award is just shameful, absolutely shameful.
Yes Maaamaa
Padhmashri Kunnakudi Vaidyanathan took the Carnatic music to common man without offending anyone. T M Krishna I had offended everyone leave alone the music industry. Music Academy had snubbed Kunnakudi for doing a Devine work but now they are claiming to support T M Krishna? Music Academy is a hopeless organisation which claims to be superior but to the contrary, it is a very prejudiced organisation.
The double standards of Academy is well known.
The academy did not honour
Madurai Soma Sundaram who was ten times talented than Krishna. Similarly it chose not to recognise such stalwarts like M M Dandapani Desikar ( vocalist and composer), Sirkazhi Govindarajan,
T M Soundararajan, Nadaswaram Vidwans
Karukurichi Arunachalam,
Namagiripettai Krishnan to mention few. Definitely he got the award because of his association with Anti Hindu N Ram. The academy has lost its sheen and prestige.
Majority Is Reality ❤
TM krishna support all kerala people
It is time that Carnatic Music be spread across the nation and world and be learned and performed across different communities, cast etc. TM Krishna in the pretext of this notion is only hurting sentiments of Brahamin community and also the roots of Carnatic music which stems from sanathana dharma. The best way to respond to TM Krishna is simply ignore him and not boycott or talk about him in the media. He seems to be Media savvy person like Kardhasians who likes to get media time by giving controversial statements. Having said that one should address the criticism by being proactive in spreading the Carnatic music to other communities and cast and also learn from Hindustani Music which was performed equally by both Muslims and Hindus.
Please check the history- all those Hindustani Muslim singers were converted Brahmins in Mughal era. I rest the case😀
@@srinivask2485 I am not sure about your case you are making. If all Muslims are converted Brahmins do you think Ajmal Kasab was also converted from Brahmin. Also do you think only Bramins can be musicians. If which Brahamin, Iyengar,Iyer,Sankethi,BK,Madhava. Please keep these thoughts in dirty politics and Please Please leave Music alone.
First, we were talking about Muslim musicians in India, not every Muslim. What you said first applies to TMK. It was he who dragged caste angle into Indian classical discourse and started all mudslinging tarnishing one community. Btw, no need to teach me about focusing on music- I listen to Iranian classical music of Mohammed Reza Lofti also. Every music has an image and it’s the patrons of that art form that decided who to support or not. Some classical music rasikas (you may be one) support him but I think the majority don’t like him due to his rantings and denigrating people who they hold in high regard.
@@srinivask2485 Ready my comment again and tell me where did I support TM Krishna. I clearly said ignore him which is the best thing to do. At the same time do not hurt others sentiment by telling them they were converted from Brahmins to Muslims.
Sorry, yes, I agree with you. I made a comment only about your last statement about Muslims. That’s it.
Btw, no Muslim Hindustani classical musician will be hurt to hear they are converted Brahmins. It’s an open secret- go search online. I was told by one student of a renowned Hindustani Muslim musician that his guru puts the sacred thread (yajnopaveeta) in a talisman and wear it to a thread around the waist and also offer tarpanams on amavasya. That parampara is fortunately continuing but once Islamization is complete, they may slowly move away from this art that is closely associated with sanatana dharma. Hope the tradition of Dagars, Asad Ali Khan, Bismilla Khan etc. continues- I don’t care if they are now Muslims/Brahmin etc. I die for their music. Take care.
TMK is an ingrate
all these people are still living in the 12th century and having a massive having a meltdown.
இன்றைய கர்நாடக இசை என்பது தமிழ்நாட்டு இசை தமிழ் இசை
கார் நாடக இசை என்பதுபுதிய பெயர்தான்
ஆனால் இது தமிழ் பண் இசை
இந்த இசை மரபினை பல நூறு ஆண்டுகளாய் பாதுகாத்தவர்கள் தேவரம் இசை பாடிய தேசிகர் குடும்பத்தினர் &
நாதஸ்வரம் தவில் இசைத்த இசை வேளாளர் குடும்பத்தினர் ஆவார்கள்
ஆனால் கி.பி 1600 க்கு பிறகு இதனை கற்றுக்கொண்ட ஒரு கூட்டம்
இதனை அவா சொத்து போல காட்டி கொள்கிறது
தமிழக மக்களுக்கும் உண்மை தெரிவதில்லை
Will a musician who is a follower of Hitler, praises him and supports his ideology be given a Grammy Award even though he maybe the best musician. Ramasamy Naicker was a hate preacher who has even insulted the Tamil language. He was not just against the unwholesome practices in Hinduism but also hated it wholesale. He was a separatist and Nehru called him a madman who should be locked away in a lunatic asylum. The blessed Carnatic music is not just music but is based on Hindu values & culture. One of the iconic & leading exponents of it was Tyagaraja who was a Rama bhaktha. There were others like him. To extol a man who supports EVR, who threw slippers on Rama & other Hindu idols is to disrespect this genre of music.
Though I empathise with Chinmoy personally I cannot go along with her stand taken on this matter unless those whom she accuses have been proven guilty. Her support for this guy is just quid pro quo & not based on objective assessment of principles. He supported her then & she owes him.
Simple: it is an award for the artist by an Art Academy. Keep everything else away from the art.
Sangeetha kalanidi award is equal to Oscar but it is not Oscar is equal to sangeetha kalanidhi as while anchoring you equated the two awards , but sangeetha kalanidhi is much more great than oscar
What do you smoke? 😂
Political leaders wanted this to stop catnatic music boycotted from carnatjc musucians....let gana take that place.....
What do you mean by "openly"
He is against his own community
His community never spoke Ill of Periyar though Periyar spoke ill of Brahmins.
If he is against His own community what about in other states like kerala karnataka andhra brahmins.
Carnatic music is universal all over India and all over world.
People other than brahmins community are veterans exponents in carnatic music to name a few
Madurai somu, seergazhi, namagiri, chinna moulana, neyyatinkara, kaavalam, MG Radhakrishnan, omanakutti amma, thiruvizha, Pala ramachandran, finally our respectful M S Amma.
He is like dog barking against Sun.
TMK is not speaking
DMK is speaking in his voice
DMK used him to speak against his community...like padmasuran story
Of course I like his carnatic singing but dislike his approach against his own community.....shameful attitude
It's nothing like Oscar! Fans don't have a say at all. Just a committee sitting and awarding it headed by an atheist president, who announced the award 3-4 months ahead for no rhyme or reason
Arts specially classical music and dance is not being best artist ,but the humblesness and the whole character .Many won't understand this as the generation now is only concentrated on one skill which is only a part of a person ,bur classical arts see the artist as a whole .
and creating a divisive future for India....so you have everything to lose ....wake up before somebody rules you and TMK.
@nandiniisanjjeev5613
What right u don't have that the so called upper caste do in constitution???
Divisive India?? Hating Brahmins today who has nothing to do with what happened before is also reverse castiesm...practiced and proopaget by pigs like Periyar. He survived only bcoz it was hindu God. A human wouldn't have garlanded Rama with chappal
@@ns86532 what is there to divide in this. It was TMK who started with his mindless blabbering
TMK boycotted Music Academy functions accusing them of Brahminism...but he accepts the award now! What has changed? Has MA become changed or the original premise of MA being Brahministic is false? TMK is a hypocrite.
Hats of to T M Krishna.
for what... for getting Stalin's support🤣
This country has lost word called dissent after 2014.
Wow! How profound? Every day there is dissent. It is not about dissent but about power and disliking current dispensation. Most
Of the people who crib do not see reality and it is only their political
orientation that matters. Unfortunate.
@@arkay292 That's your point.
Yes we too have a point
@@nandakumarkrishnapillai3126 Your point is being heard in all quarters sir, but ours is not being heard.
Stop sleeping
Tamilnadu Musical Academy honouring TM Krishna because he is collnded with DMK dynasty & now he is speaking their Language.there fore they awarded TM Krishna. I appeal all carnati C Musicians to boycottis Tamilnadu Classical Musical Academy
What's his contribution to Carnatic Music?
Read the statement of music academy 😁😁
He exposed you perverts
He sang a Thyagaraja Krithi for Jesus.... That's his biggest contribution and whining and charting malicious campaigns against Hindus using the "Hindus for Human rights" organisation. It is a bullshit organisation filled with Anti Hindus
@@jayaseelanmathara also read about Stalin's support for him
It is facade for dmk to shift attention from their drugs scam
A man who is in a dying condition married a girl who is 35 years younger than him.
Can that Dravidian be called a social reformer? Economist? Jurist?
Can the government, which is influenced by that Dravidian, provide safety and security to the girls?
*** Another man, Ambedkar, who is in a dying condition, married a girl who is 25 years younger than him. Can that Indian be called a social reformer? Economist? Jurist?
Can the government(s), to whom that Indian is an ideal person, provide safety and security to the girls? Do the literary personalities, MUSCIANS etc., raise their voice or open their pen and question the indifference of the government towards the victimised girls?
Can TM Krishna disciples or Madras Music Academy... react?XXX
TMK partly owns MA - obviously, he is giving himself!
Bharathiyar was also criticized by his back then for being broad minded and revolutionary. Now they own him after he became National icon. I’m not comparing them here but pointing that his inclusiveness, unconventional thoughts and poetry were criticized during his time.
Muslims and Brahmins are hated by most of the people especially in our country because of the wrong deeds done by them in the past.
Inclusiveness should start from home.
He can do his bit without villifying others.
@@sumathimanjunath1315 Yes… it should happen. Do you really want him to or just a counter? Will you appreciate and follow him if he does?
TM KRISHNA is undoubtedly an accomplished and erudite vocalist about whom none of his detractors have any thing adverse to say about his music credentials. His singing is devotional, soulful and mesmerising and he praises the Lord and his avatars with all reverence like any other musician.
Awards are given on the basis of the merit of a Person's excellence in his field and not based on his personal views which may be anti traditional . Many of the music stalwarts had a nasty , tarnished and sullied personal morality in their lifetime and their personal integrity is debatable . Yet they were honoured !
The opposition is only to Krishna's modern views against conventional Carnatic heritage and customs, and its Brahminical mode of adherence to age old tradition.. Unlike the other musicians who have become famous because of their talents only , TMK stands as an intellectual colossus with an analytical mind to study the dynamics of Carnatics music. Hence he has been awarded the prestigious Magsaysay Award.
His rational view about the Mridhangam having cow skin with leather straps, and his views about the legendary MS having been born in a Dasi family of non Brahmins are true and factual. These are irritating data to the Gomatha and Hindutva fanatics who are RSS BJP stooges . However a large section of the music lovers are behind TM KRISHNA and because of this episode are going to vote against the BJP.
If Carnatic Music is so sacrosanct why are they bothered about criticism against it ?
At the best a talented Guy but wanted that fame playing to all galaries and wanted to be a standout candidate in the lot . Thinks he is the sole candidate in his community who has authority to speak for all human beings
Chinmayi dont paint everyone with the same brush....while what you have gone through is deplorable definitely... but your case and this with TMK are not comparable. Why bring a different case into what TMK has done. Compare apples to apples. Chinmayi you must fight your battle but getting your case here and muddling up issues your style I guess, a controversy theory you like to build...it is a divisive ideology.
60% to 70% of the Performing musicians are from the brahmin Community but they are not legitimate winners like Rahman, Ilayaraja and Yesudas. TM Krishna wants equality in his profession and that is not wrong.
Can you name 10 great vidwans who are or were not Brahmins but they were as good as anyone else before making such comments. Also,name the Gurus of both Yesudas , Ilayaraja and Rahman , please before you make such comments.
He can bring the equality with out hurting other artists, any community, without disrespecting the inherited culture, but he is doing all the things,
@@arkay292earlier this owned by Brahmins don't have a chance for any other castes. So mostly teachers will be Brahmins.
@@latvork3044 no question of owning. Any body can do with adequate interest
I would like to see Sridhar, RAGA sisters, Hari and others come out and openly denounce Ravikiran and other musicians accused of molesting young girls. I will then accept your outrage as genuine.
Brahami terrorism and chauvinism...
Congratulations to tm Krishna 🎉
It's small fight dear. Only very few sing carnatic
My observation from childhood.....only brahmins and their kids could only sing n learn carnatic music....why not others....?? Because they dint allow this knowledge to other communities from ages....that's a brahmin domination.....music is for everyone.....it connects with Soul in ourselves....that's why called naadabrahma
உசத்தி சங்கீதம் உசத்தி பட்டம் பற்றி உசத்தி பாஷையில் உசத்தி மனுஷா பேசிக்கொள்கிறார்கள்......
எங்களுக்கு தமிழ்தான் புரிகிறது...TM.கிருஷ்ணா பாமரன் பக்கம் பேசி இருப்பார் என்று புரிகிறது.....
எதுக்கு பெரியார், சனா தனம், கம்மூனிட்டி என்றெல்லாம்
பேசிக்கறாங்க...
புரியலீங்கோ......
He is a great musician beyond any doubts.his talent should not be underestimated for his opinion and his views.he fully desrerves the award
These sisters are so perfect in music 😁
Music academy's new low.
The reason the Music Academy (now controlled by DMK) has decided to give the award to TMK at this time is only to raise a controversy based on DMK and its patron Saint EVR’ caste based politics. They have built their entire political career on Hindu, Bharat and Brahmin hatred. DMK plans, (by raising this controversy) to project itself as a crusader against Brahmins and Sanathana Dharma. CLASSICAL Carnatic Music is, unlike other genres, based solely on Sanathana Dhrama and all performances are devoted to the praise of our deities. The Music Academy, for example, has no room for people who are anti-Sanathana Dharma. It is not a social club. To honor a confessed anti-Sanathana person by MA is something we, the devotees of Classical Carnatic music cannot accept.
Ranjani gaayathri
Perfect
Please don't perform.
I doubt whether he is brahmin or not.
Secondly, by abusing about GREAT THYAGARAJA he has made sin . No pparihaara for that.
Always ❤with
Ranjani Gayatri and dushyanth
TM Krishna is a 💎. Even if many people disagree, his thoughts will be appreciated after 100 of years. Humanbeing who value talent over caste will recognize him for sure.
Great to see hatred against a talented artiste being spread by other "artistes" including a particular sect oh lf various k"kalasi". Comoin together and not comng to blow.
Calm down you guys. TM Krishnan is putting a mirror in front of the Carnatic community and pointing out the hypocrisy of gender discrimination and selective admission by the gate keepers. We will all be well advised to weigh the facts and evidence instead of destroying each other. Musicians like Ravi Kiran inappropriately behaved with two of his students and all of you were no were to be seen. We are all hypocrites and he has the courage to tell us we need to make it alright.
T.N. Govt played a master stroke on BJP.
As a person aware of how the Music Academy and the Musicians who claim to boycott TMK have come to this point, I believe that the award to TMK is a stepping stone towards making Carnatic music more universal. The boycots dont make them lesser musicians but definitely make them lesser humans. Their tunnel vision hasn't developed with their years. His words are not why he is being given the award. If we decide to nitpick what all these awardees have said, surely we would find fault with all of them as no human is perfect.
TMK is a great singer. And he is a bilion times better person and a trillion times virtuous person who is spiritual, rationalist, against discriminations... Why he himself alains with the racist periyar? That could be to provoke the evil fascists of caste or class order. I like TM Krishna, more than those who criticises him. But i am sure periyar too mean racist& a person of no merit of any worth. Anybody in any walks of life cannot be worse than periyar . We have ni dearth of mean persons. Periyar was vocal. That is the difference. Even Hitler is less mean than Periyar, though they resemble in their ideology.
TM krishna is actually Blade Pakkiri.
Both the main parties in Tamil Nadu, DMK and AIADMK are allied to the ideology of Periyar. Do these artists also boycott the state government? It seems TM Krishna only performed a song related to Periyar and so much meltdown.
Krishna has lengthy student line he is developing carnatic musics , if dhushyanth boycott nothing to loose
he is building a larger divisive army. we have enough dividing the country.
time has come for them to look for another teacher
Will this hypocrite who used the most disgustingly obnoxious and utterly obscene language while writing on the LEGENDARY EMPRESS OF CARNATIC MUSIC , BHARAT RATNA M S AMMA, have the moral right to receive the M S Subbulakshmi award along with sangeeta kalanidhi??? Have the so called 'elite' group at the helm of affairs even thought about this in the first place??? Moral values and ethics obviously have disappeared .I see a total downfall of the Music Academy which was nurtured by greats like Dr V Raghvan. As a school child ,I have had the privilege of not only hearing great carnatic musicians but have also seen and heard the likes of Pandit Omkar Nath Thakur, Kathak daneuse the great Roshan Kumari ( the singing was done by her mother the legendary Zohra bai ambala Wali, whose songs in film ratan are still a rage !) and the jhaveri sisters perform Manipuri dance. Does the same culture still exist at the Academy??? I doubt very much.
What is Tamil Isai and why was it transformed into Carnatic music by Brahmins.
Does changing the name make it Brahmin's?
Shame on academy
Thyagaraja Swamiji is not with T M Krishna
Shame T. M. K.... Shame on you... ... He has Changed Now!...... Not The T. M. K.... Of his Peak Times..
Just because he dont support u r loveable party
Both Rajani and Gayatri and Tm krishna are 'call singers'.They are not melodious like BMk .But award is.ok .
This will be the beginning of the end of Chennai Music Academy... विनाशकाले विपरीतबुद्धिः
Those great composers did not take a single rupee and even rejected the offerings by kings.
But we perform for money.
Saint Tyagaraja's life style and how he fed his family in dire poverty ,we have nothing to learn from these people.Having that situation,the saint has composed all these krithis.
Now a days bhakti is a relative term.
I support him but all of u make money out of our ancestors like saint tyagaraja, dikshitar and syamasastry.i cant say it is wrong but
We should learn a bit from them rather than fighting like this.
In the vast time,who recognises this sangita kalanidhi.Leave him.
It appears that many musicians in academy are tamilians.Dilute the mixture and there may be a different flavour or ruckus to fight for.
H exposed the hypocrisy of brahmins in his book. Deep prejudice. Now they are maligning him.
On what basis you're saying this .There is something called as Principle, character which transcends all this .BTW who stopped other caste people to learn classical ,no one is interested to learn ,
every caste has hypocrisy. WHy dont you join the Nadar Sangam and check if they admit you or join the some muslim group or christian group and find out how they treat you? Brahmiins are easy target because they are too soft and tolerant. Have you dealt with Devars and Vanniyars. you should try and come back and tell us.
Today all people want to sing is filmy music only. Which non Brahmin wants to learn Carnatic? And btw who can stop them from doing it or why? Be truthful!
@@shalinig.agasthi818 the upper class had created the same narrative for education that Dalits are not interested. The real fact was you people never allowed them to learn or educated or transferred knowledge any lower caste people. In fact u treated them as untouchable and never considered us as human beings.
Now when they got the chance they started doing well and outperformed you.
How many of the Brahmin scholars have taught music to a sc or ST kid??
@@lijochathelijacob7766 educate yourself and dont live in stoneage.....havent you heard of Palani Subramanya Pillai....Most of the instrumentalists are from non-brahmin community only until few decades back. Apart from Madurai Somu (Vocal), there were number of instrumentalists like Dwaram Venkataswami Naidu (Violin), Nadaswara vidwans Thiruvadudurai Rajarathinam Pillai, Thiruveezhimalai Brothers, Namagiripettai Krishnan, Thavil Vidwans Valayappatti,Haridwaramangalam, Viswa (Flute) were dominating this carnatic music world.
When the Dravidian parties started dominating the political scene, many people thought that carnatic music is not for them and non-brahmins considered that this genre is meant only for brahmins and left the scene. Otherwise it is not due to the domination of the brahmins. read this snippet.....from Sundararaman Chintamani ........ reposted here......
·
Follow
Good...Please withdraw.That would be your best choice so other talented people can also get opportunities wide open!... Sad to see such a narrow minded person!...If nobody bans other communities, then why are there so many students from govt. fine arts colleges have not performed in the music academy. Don't they have talents. What a nice show off speech!
He was given award for his great singing only.
Others should shut up
Dushyant is good and very good as for as narations and discourse of ramayana Mahabharata et etc we appreciate them for it
TMK is the best and others only runner up he may have his edosicaracy please accept and go ahed
Ranjini Gayatri are just ok as we are use to DKB Semmangudi MS and Maharajapuram.
Citation to T.M. Krishnan says about his social activity, too, in a big way.
Simply saying it is like nominating Dawood Ibrahim for Dhadha Sahib Phalke award for promoting Indian Cinema
TMK is fame hungry and award hungry....he thinks he is the supreme court of Carnatic music.
TMK is a DMK politician !
TMKrishna has only attained fame n money all these years singing famous compositions like Jagadjara not sure he would have dared to sing a composition on periyaar or some Abrahamic religious compositions and gained this name n fame.😅
He is very controversial.. Always brings caste politics to fore rather than music. Let him remain as activist rather tham muscian. DMK wants only such people.
Is casteism okay ? Isn't music of all kinds universal?
TM Krishna is the real krishna.
Find out who tyagaraja is , Ramadasu is . Everything is not about caste , something is about principle too .Which no one understands this in this generation
@@shalinig.agasthi818 okk aunty may be you are outdated
@shalinig.agasthi818 true...
People who doesnt know what is carnatic/classical would only see it as award-controversy.
TMK is selfish and perverted and things he is a scholar in music.
Music is for expressing bakthi, which bharat Ratna awarded MS amma did in her life. She is so blessed by Swami srinivasa today venkatesha subrabatham and Vishnu sahasranama resonates, it is direct blessing of God.
TM Krishna is musically egoistic and he things he attained scholarship, poor ignorant being. Let God forgive him and I pray God to give him sudhbhukthi.
We need to just ignore such people and the current music acedamy and boycott them.
Music is essentially from veda and shall be used for bhakti.
Music is not industry
Dushyandh is real fraud😂😂😂
TMK may be a good musicians....BUT he should not be a parrot from J.Krishnamurti foundation because he should stick to his area of expertise. TMK is no JK, obviously, but when he acts like one, it is problem.
Just because his music transcends your caste bars. We understand why these sisters protest so much. How petty!
I don't think you understand what you're even talking about
He is a character assasin. His disrespectful remarks about St. Thiagaraja n Bharatha Rathna MS Amma r unpardonable. He earns his living the kruthis of the Saint Composer. And he does not know perhaps that Smt M S Amma is one of the main contributors for the establishment n growth of Music Academy through her benefit performances. The sad part is that the Hindu paper owners n DMK r trying to gain petty publicity thro this TMK episode.
Dharma vs adharma cudos to boycotting team
Aren't you the guys who disrespected Jesudas, ARRehman, Ilayaraaja because they are non-brahmins. Carnatic music is not your private property....get lost guys
Perfectly written
Dushyanth S anyways is a 12th man . He should be rested
Tm krishna is a Rogue artiste , not a decent and capable desering reciepient for that award.
It's an insult to music world jambhavans and past reciepients
Also , communist anti Hindu / ram recommended this rogue artist
Short story - music academy has become a cheap place like dravidar pinnetra kazhagam- don't go there any more
The problem is that the 'Bhraminical forces' are not united like 'Jihadi forces' or the 'Evangelical forces'
Bhraminism is beyond caste, and TMK is a shame for music and Indic civilizational ethos and beliefs. He is anti national
You sir are the anti national
@@surebjk1 On what grounds ?
@@laya0srinivas For labelling fellow countrymen anti- national. He may have a different viewpoint than you and you may or may not concur with it but labelling him as terrorist or anti- national only inflames hatred. Just like you change the channel on TV when you don't like a program, you are free to listen and enjoy a musician of your choice if you don't like the views of one. Just understand that there may be others that understand and appreciate what he is trying to achieve.
Shameless dirtiest academy.
Brahmin communities stranglehold has deprived carnatic music of organic growth.
TMK is not an isolated incident.
Since Social media is prominent we come to know of these kind of orchestrated villification of an artist who doesnot conform to their dictacts.
In the past they did this to no less than M.S.Subbulakshmi. To appease the brahmins Mr.Sadasivam have to marry her and give her social recognition.
Veena Doyen S.Balachandar was slighted simply because he was not in conform.
Madurai Somu is another.
So it is a deliberately played game
Atleast in Kerala, the following for Carnatic Music transcends Caste, Religion, ideology. You could in a Concert have a Mr Chacko or a Joseph as a neighbour appreciating the nuances of Carnatic Music. This is something worth pondering.
Nothing revolt! Certain bramins are jumping here and there! That's all! Music, Music Academy are NOT bramins assets!
Just because TMK wanted equality in a domain dominated by the Brahmins all these Sanatanis join and want to malign his heritage. Why shouldn’t he sing what he wants. The very name of Periyar literally strikes fear among these guys. Shame on the Indian version of Jews
Lijo mone, you speak bout the pedophilic priests ... That's the domain you are accustomed to... Sanatana not your domain and you wouldn't understand the ethos of Sanatanis so don't go there.
Hope as President of the current year festival, he will provide stage to lot of under privileged dalit artists to perform concerts in the festival.
Too harsh to compare with Jews. Kerala is unique that the following for Carnatic Music cuts across Caste and Religion. There are many from the non Brahmin Castes in Tamil Nadu who have contributed immensely to Carnatic Music. During the Marghazi Season artists like Saket Raman are trying to take the Music to the common Man. Over the years I am sure that the new generation in TN will take to Carnatic Music like their brethen in Kerala.
@@raghunathansrinivasaraghav6455Excellent.
Have you been stopped from carnatic music ? Read about E V Ramaswamy Naicker and the vile acts he committed and then talk about any 'fear'. TMK sings songs and compositions on the Lord and then sings and praises Periyar who insulted the Gods (only Hindu Gods mind you, in Dravidian movement hypocrisy). One of the many shocking contradictions of TMK. Have other artists stopped or halted equality ? You do not seem to know or understand the subject. You call Indian version of Jews and why the hatred (calling them shame) like Hitler ?
How come you don’t interview the other part of the story. As usual one sided Sanghi supporting journo happily taking money to promote one side.
t m krishna is a great person
he is a great touser pandy.