Would like to say that I’ve finally sub’s to you guys after watching your channel pop up every now and then. There are so many reaction channels but a lot of them just don’t seem authentic, like maybe they are pretending to watch it for the first time even though they’ve probably already have. I’ve only come across a few reactions that seem authentic and you guys are one of them. Keep up the great content and thank you 😊
Please react to Saving Private Ryan. Y'all will love it if y'all like Band of Brothers and this movie. It's the best ww2 film and the accurate film depicting ww2 battles like the famous d day beach landing scene. Also if y'all love Game of Thrones, please react to the Lord of the Rings trilogy. It's considered the best epic fantasy film trilogy ever.
Something that tragically isn't mentioned in the movie is that he was also a vegetarian as part of his religious beliefs. Much of the army's rations consisted of potted meat and such. So through his service he mainly survived on a diet of crackers, bread, jams, butters, and dried fruit that he would trade his meat for. By his own admission he was often very hungry, weak, and demoralized.
He tried to eat coconuts that had fallen on the ground, but they gave him dysentery. So one evening he climbed a tree to pick fresh and came under enemy fire. Luckily, the Japanese soldiers were drunk and couldn't shoot straight.
@@JeshuaSquirrel It's not just the fallen coconuts that will give you dysentery. Coconut milk also contains fermentable carbohydrates. These can cause digestive issues, such as diarrhea or constipation.
The actual Desmond Doss story is even more amazing. Mel Gibson toned it down for fear that no one would believe it. Hacksaw Ridge wasn’t the only battle he did stuff like this. He was hardcore
That answered one question for me was if he actually went home after hacksaw cause his Cpt said "your going home" and without googling I was curious if he actually stayed in the army after his injuries and had more battles. What a guy
There was actually more than 75 around That Desmond Doss saved. The big rope ladder you saw Desond was one of the Guys who tied it up there. There was more battles Doss fought in and saved men there also. He Carried more man than the movie should. There was a lot of times when the Japanese whent to Shoot Desmond Doss and their guns jammed up. Other time The bullets went around Desmond doss and then continued on the same path they were headed towards. So meaning they was head Towards Doss and was redirected around him. When Doss was Wounded and the stretcher medics was taken them to safety. Dos saw a more severed injured soldier and told them to take him. When Doss was banging him up Doss got shot in the arm. He than made a Split out of a rifle stock and crawled three hundred yards to a aid station. So yea Doss was amazing and God truly Protected him through the battle. Doss got shot there he had the Bible. The Bible saved his life. I don't think he kicked the Grenade. When I was younger I met Doss in person. When he was on the Medic boat that is when he realized he lost his Bible. He got in Contact with his unit and they searched until they found his Bible. The return it to hime. That is just few more things about him. There is book about his life and a Documentary also.
not to be an contrarian but the "hacksaw ridge" was 10 mts tall. and by this time, doss was a blooded veteran of 2? battles i think. he was no rookie or virrgin but a recognized hero
The look that Hugo Weaving's character gave his son at the cemetery was anger, pain, sadness, and fear all rolled into one. My dad gave that same look when I told him I was enlisting in the army, and all I could do was try and tell him I was going to be fine. Every father whose child enlists well have that look on their face no matter how proud they are of them.
The real story is way worse. After getting hurt, he continued saving people. He saved 200+ over the whole war. This looks like a single event, but Doss was in other battles, but Hacksaw Ridge was his prime moment.
They intentionally give a very false representation of the hacksaw ridge battle though. They make it look like the entire thing happened over three days, and that he recovered an entire battlefield full of injured in one night. That simply did not happen. And while there was a period where he remained on the battlefield recovering wounded after everyone else had retreated it wasn't some kind of 12 hour constant stream of wounded being lowered down one after the other for an entire night. His heroics at hacksaw ridge took place over the course of almost a month and the 75 number includes everyone he helped evacuate from the battlefield over that whole period.
On more thing. The action depicted in this movie was VERY truncated. This battle was over 4 DAYS long. Officially he was credited with saving 75 men. Unofficially the number was closer to 150. His full story is simply unbelievable in this day in age
@@davidnobre5660 with God all things are possible. This real life young man believed in bet his life on his faith in God instead of ground when he thought he was obeying God. The Lord God in this kindness blessed this man's abilities and made him do what we would call superhuman things nowadays. How is God's strength and love for his fellow man he accomplished what can only be called miraculous feats of heroism.
It was actually about 100. But he himself said it couldn't have been more than 50. So they sit the difference. That's where they got the official number.
@@cosdead46 Only two others, both during the Vietnam War, Thomas W. Bennett and Joseph G. LaPointe both had religious convictions that led to them serving as medics in the field. Neither survived the war. Bennett’s platoon was ambushed and everyone dove for cover except Bennett who went to help the injured. He aided the wounded under near-constant enemy fire for over a day before getting shot in the head while rushing across an open field to another platoon of injured and pinned down soldiers. LaPointe was assigned to the 101st Airborne Division. While on a combat helicopter assault mission, he crawled through withering enemy machine gun and grenade fire to aid two injured soldiers, covering them with his own body to protect them. LaPointe was repeatedly shot and peppered with shrapnel, but he never left the two soldiers he was assisting. Finally a grenade landed at his feet and killed all three men before LaPointe could stabilize the soldiers and move them to safety. Their Medals were awarded by the President of The United States in 1970 and 1971 respectively.
The part where Desmond heard the call for medic and the explosions from the Battleship’s Shells are everywhere, and he understands and he starts walking towards his call. I cried and that reminds me of Psalm 23:4 “Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for you are with me; your rod and your staff, they comfort me.”
@@Strider91 I'm not religious. But if someone was to tell me Jesus has already returned but this time his name was Desmond Doss, I wouldn't question it.
My Great Uncle was at Iwo Jima. He never talked about the war, but we convinced him to when he was getting old, because it was important to preserve his story for the family. He saw all the bodies of young 18 year olds stacked up on the beach. He said it was the most appalling waste of life he had ever seen.
Another true fact is that many Japanese had him in their sights, but whenever they went to shoot, their guns jammed every time. I’m not religious, but knowing this stuff makes me a little more hopeful.
God pdotected desmond. Nothing short of divine intervention should have made his survival possible. I challenge you my friend to ask God into your life. Find him. Hs who seek truly with a whole heart always do.
EXACTLY! I was losing my faith like 2 years ago but now this for the first time hearing this story about a year ago I regained it and never felt better
If I remember right Doss MET one of the Japanese that had him in his sights. And that's exactly what he said. He has no idea why. His gun just wouldn't fire.
Officially, he saved 75, unofficially it was closer to 150, there are no words to describe his bravery, this movie as good as it is, does not capture all of what Medic Doss did. My Dad who is going to be 97 this year, and hopes to live to be 100, was in WWII, he drove supply truck, a target for sure, always on the front line. He was one of the eight men of 100 drivers who walked out of their own volition. Dad landed on D-Day, two days after his B-Day. He said he'd seen things in that war, no young man should ever see. He never talked about the war while Mom was alive, once she passed, he started opening up and talking about it. I know he is still keeping things to himself. Found out that he made a promise to Mom that he would not talk about the war, married 62 years, until she passed, he kept his word. These men/women were of the greatest generation, for many reasons.
I love this movie, one of my top 10. I also wish Garfield would have receive an Academy award for this. I also wonder how much physical exercise went into Garfield's training for this role. I would imagine it would involver pushing and pulling heavy sleighs, squatting with weight, and running around with people on his back. Knowing how Garfield is actually pretty religious, I would imagine this role meant a lot for him and it seems he invested a lot into it. Great movie.
@jonabank Andrew Garfield is Jewish on his father's side; Garfield had a secular upbringing, and has referred to himself as an "agnostic pantheist", though he identifies as Jewish. However, he had been in three major religious features with both Hacksaw Ridge (Mel Gibson directed) and Silence (Martin Scorsese directed) in 2016 and the current The Eyes of Tammy Faye (2021).
@@NikkiStevenReact the movie was directed by Mel Gibson! Filmed in Australia! It was interesting recognizing all the Australian actors putting on their best American accents! Australian Hugo Weaving played his dad! 🥰💕from Australia!
As a Brit, I know all about Desmond Doss as we studied war at school. 12 hours on that ridge over 70 soldiers and the Congressional Medal of Honour - unarmed and was about to be jailed as he wouldn't carry a gun. That's what I like about these reaction videos. Take a look guys at what it takes to win the British Victoria Cross, it's so good for us to not just watch movies and believe, but to know what heroes we both had that neither of us would know if it wasn't for the internet and suggestions. Johnson Beharry is one of VERY few like this wonderful man to be alive to receive it, he won his recently with half his skull and part of his brain missing and still rescuing and going back in to save others in Afghanistan. He freaked out when everyone was looking at him asking him 'Are you OK???' He was SAVING THEM! He should NEVER be alive after what he did. New Subscriber BTW and god bless from across the pond.
Movies like this are important, in my opinion, because I hear people disrespect older veterans that have PSD, or are passionate about what they saw and survived. People just don't get it until they see something like this, and get an inkling of what these men endured, and continue to endure. Love that you guys reviewed this, and appreciate it!
Mr. Doss lived in our small town in Alabama his last few years. Occasionally, he would eat breakfast with a crew of older men in the local restaurants. My dad was usually in there and I would eat with them sometimes. I knew he was a CMOH recipient, but didn't know the full story like now. He was a quiet, humble and friendly man and I wish I'd known more about him so I could have appreciated him more when I was around him.
I've watched this through twice and have seen a few different reaction vids and at this point, I have to agree. This, Ryan, and Glory are god-tier. Platoon and Black Hawk Down are runners up.
He is an amazing example for Christianity. In a world full of so much hate, too much of it coming from Christians themselves sometimes, it’s important to remember what he did and what he stood for. It didn’t matter who you were, whether you were fighting for or against him. He saved every human he could
I'm not a big fan of war movies tbh, but this has always been one of my favorite movies, and to this day I can't watch it without getting at least teary. Knowing that it is a true story, and that there was someone out there who did this, that this happened. It is just so moving.
The funny part is that most of this feats shown was literally watered down to make it believable, from apparently over 100 and not 75 he saved, and the fact after that grenade did his leg, he actually pushed on to do his duty as a medic, like damn
I'm not religious at all but Doss really, really is a shining example of faith in humanity. What an incredible piece of war history. It's heartbreaking that there are countless heroic moments in war that will never be told.
@FannyBashing247God isn’t based on religion my friend it’s based on relationship humanity made religion… so yes it is based on faith in God and that’s the prime lesson and literally the essence in this movie that doss displayed continuously. And just a note many atheist and even high satanic worshippers lately have come to say Jesus Christ is real and is lord.
@FannyBashing247 hmmm you blame and question God with those statements but the answer is always right in front of you and is and will remain the same… you ask how can he allow this to happen as if he never gave his creation ways to stop it but humanity chooses to do what it wants… you then ask why does he give us “free will” then that’s because if their wasn’t free will the man we wouldn’t choose to love him and you can relate to that just like you wanting someone to choose to love you than forcing them. But then he have his only son a sacrifice to allow us another chance to be with him but nah people don’t believe in that… bc there’s no way someone could love us like tat even though there is and he loves you that way, you can’t say thing like that without giving God a chance and before you say you have you haven’t given him a chance to work on you and move in his timing and how he wants to that’s were patience and enduring comes in, plus he never said this life would be easy bc they hated him so they will surely hate his people. The Bible is a love letter and an history instruction Manuel.
I remember watching a documentary on Doss called "The Conscientious Objector" and thinking, how is this not a movie? When this came out I knew they wouldn't be able to put everything into it since they only have about 2 hours or less to work with. I thought the movie was amazing but I highly recommend watching the documentary if you can find it. There is so much more that this man did that is hardly believable.
75 is the average of the number of personnel saved by Doss during Hacksaw Ridge. Reports were of 100+ saved, though Doss humbly claimed only 50, so they met in the middle. Okinawa saw the hardest fighting in the Pacific theater and convinced the US command that an invasion of the Japanese mainland would be almost impossible. They theorized that the fighting with the invasion would so horrific that every battle would be a repeat of Okinawa. So instead command decided to drop two bombs as the estimates of those casualties would be considered less than what either side would end up losing doing it the other way.
I always wondered if a mainland invasion of Japan was truly "necessary" to win the war if the US didn't have the bomb. One of the initial reasons the Japanese were so aggressive initially was that they knew they didn't have the resources to last long term against the Allies. The day the Nagasaki bomb dropped, there were over half a million Russian troops that invaded Manchuria, so taking the bombs out of the equation, Japan would've been pretty much surrounded and you could essentially lay siege to the mainland, as you carpet bomb them back to the stone age. Basically a "slow burn" instead of a brief 15-25 megaton vaporizing nuclear blast. It would've taken significantly more time, but you have to figure it certainly would've cost less in terms of allied casualties compared to a full on amphibious invasion.
@@shadypelican It's always gonna be in the realm of fantasy, since we can't truly know the minds of the people in charge at the time, but i'm of the belief that Japan would eventually have surrendered anyway, without the use of the bombs. Remember, just about the same time the US dropped the bombs, the Soviet Union invaded the Japanese possessions in mainland Asia, which would have meant all but complete doom for Japan. So some historians argue that the main catalyst for Japan's surrender was the invasion by the Soviet Union, not necessarily the atomic bombs.
@@TheArrowedKnee I've heard that as well--that factions within the inner circle of the Japanese military could much more easily wrap their brains around the idea of Russian soldiers swamping them, than they could of one bomb leveling an entire city in the blink of an eye. And speaking of the Russian, I do also think one of the reasons the bombs were dropped was to say to the Russians "Hey! Don't get any ideas! Look at what we got." (which would explain why the Russians, not to be outdone, would later make the absurdly powerful Tsar Bomba)
@@shadypelican yeah but then again, the japanese did have their "kamikaze" tactics. would they have peacefully surrendered to the russians, or was the spectacle of the bomb what made them realize "ok yea we have no chance of winning, and we cant even suicide bomb our enemies when they are thousands of feet in the air"
Personally I believe dropping the 2 nuclear bombs saved the Japanese people. Any invasion by the Allies or just the Soviets, and the Japanese would have destroyed themselves in defense of the Home Islands. The losses would have been mindboggling on both sides. For the planners, at the time, even the "best case scenario" would have resulted in insane losses. The question of should or shouldn't they have dropped the nukes is today largely looked at from our point of view, but we must also understand the contemporary view. The Allies were staring down the barrel of what had the potential to be the most nightmarish campaign in human history. So they pinned their hopes on the then newfangled "atom bombs" and prayed the Japanese saw reason. And in fact they almost did not! The Emperor himself had to intervene to end the madness.
During the late 1960's and early 70's, my family and I became good friends with Desmond Doss and his family. As amazing as this movie is, it isn't as amazing as his true story. He accepted the medal of honor on behalf of those who didn't come home.
@@BuntingClipClop He was a very humble person. When he told his story, he didn't take credit for his actions. He believed it was his duty to care for his fellow soldiers. He really didn't like the attention, and only allowed his story to be told in hopes that it would strengthen people's faith, as well as give them an understanding of the horrors of war. It was an honor to know him.
Desmond Doss had actually contracted tuberculosis six months earlier, but he wasn't diagnosed with it until after the war, which resulted in surgery to remove one lung. The guy was probably suppressing his coughing to stay quiet while doing all the things that he did, as well as gasping from all the effort that he was expending. 19:20 Flamethrowers were used by the US military until 1978.
Been waiting for you guys to see this one! I was a Navy FMF Corpsman (counter part to Desmond Doss and all Army medics) 10 years in Navy I spent 8 years with Marines. Desmond's story was well known to me. When I was stationed in Okinawa, I was fortunate enough to stand on Hacksaw Ridge. Every hair on me stood straight up that entire day. Honored to have followed in the footsteps of men such as him.
i think one of my favorite stories about doss was that when the japanese who fought against his regiment were interviewed, some shared that they actually *tried* shooting at him, only for their guns to suddenly jam or have dirt in the sights, rendering the shot useless. either doss was just really lucky, or someone up there was really looking out for him.
Desmond's ,father in the movie, held the Distinguished Service Cross and the Silver Star. The 2ed and 3rd highest award for valor in combat as well as the Croix De Guerre, thee highest honor for bravery from France.
My grandpa served in Europe as infantry during ww2. He was kind and could make a room laugh with ease. He never talked about the war and was extremely humble. I was still a young teenager when he died . . . I didn't understand. He had went through hell. I stayed up one night reading through journal entries and stories from his unit, some from him. I cried my eyes out, I never gave that man the respect he deserved. That generation was a different breed of man. He amassed a good bit of wealth later in life, not because he had a high paying job white collar job, but because he worked hard and invested what he could. My grandma and him never lived lavishly. They retired, went on vacations to see the world and then gave all the money to their son and daughter when they died. It is easy to to forget where we came from, the people who bear the foundation of where we are now.
Hard to believe they actually scaled down what Desmond Doss did in this movie. Hacksaw Ridge wasn't his or his units first foray into combat, and he was constantly on the go in the thick of it saving his brothers in arms. And you're right. The WWII generation was simply made of tougher stuff.
Every time I see someone react to this movie I get teary eyed. The actions in this movie really help you look at the better side of humanity and society itself. Andrew portrays this man perfectly, Doss was a true genuine soul and his name is a legendary symbol and meaning of true strength, never giving up. The sheer will power be had back then was just insane. Outstanding man, outstanding movie.
25:10 "Is he like the greatest human being to ever live?" Yeah, that was Desmond Doss in a nutshell. Very few come close to his level. But he was one of the greatest ever.
Doss was part of the 77th US Army Infantry Division. Known as "The Old Bastards". They were so good at their work that the Marines that they were attached to in the Pacific started calling them "The 77th Marine Division". See the great video "The Fat Electrician" has on his yt channel "Old Age & Treachery - The Unstoppable 77th Infantry Division".
He actually almost got in trouble because he was just as likely to aid Japanese wounded as his wounded fellow Americans. All the while knowing if he was ever captured by the Japanese, he could expect to die in the cruelest of ways, or go through the unimaginable hell of a Japanese run POW camp.
I would imagine he wouldn't get in trouble; yes, he rescued Japanese soldiers, but after receiving treatment, the POWs could be interrogated on manpower, equipment, plans, and used for general labor. There's not really a downside to taking POWs if you're able to take care of them, regardless of how you feel about the war overall. Only thing I can see him getting reprimanded for would be if he took Japanese before Americans, as you could lose an American life while saving a Japanese one.
One of the primary reasons why Medics in the Pacific Theater carried sidearms was because the Japanese placed a high priority in killing them, even though it was against the Geneva Convention to target personnel or vehicles or buildings with a red cross. You can't save your buddies if you're dead. That weapon was your only defense.
The Japanese were not signatories to the Geneva Conventions, which technically only applies between fellow signatory nations. The last war America fought another Geneva Convention power was against the Nazis.
@@heathercontois4501 I know I'm necro-ing this comment, but I looked it up. There are multiple GCs. The first (the one barring targeting medical staff) was signed in 1864, but wasn't widely adopted until the 1920s (shortly after WW1). At the time, Japan was not part of the accords. It wasn't until after WW2 that MOST nations adopted the Geneva Conventions, and other versions of these laws were signed, as well, including the use of chemical weapons, mistreatment of POWs, and even certain types of AMMUNITION. That is why military forces cannot use anything more wounding to a person than FMJ ammo, which is designed to go right through someone. Flamethrowers (as seen in the movie) were banned by virtually all signatories after WW2, though napalm dumps were still allowed (for some reason) until after Vietnam, I believe.
The entire cinema was on emotional roller coaster because of this movie. Nobody was upset because of the father character - we all undesrtood his pain. And we cheered for him when He took his uniform again. People were holding tears when Doss repeated the line "God help me save one more" and then..in the final titles we saw that he lived a long and good life and we went crazy. Beautiful movie.
This is the only film that comes close to approaching how absolutely horrifying combat in some areas of the Pacific theater was. Specifically the small islands. The end result of many battles resembled the carnage of car or train crashes because of how densely packed the battlefields were.
... shit. You know a person is far beyond any definition of a hero, when his life story is too badass for a movie to show fully without it seeming impossible. I watched him lower like 2 dozen people and thought that was insane, he did that 75 TIMES! Then did stuff that would make movie heroes think him have the will of a God. Desmond Doss: Certified Legend and Saviour of life
I'm not big on war/combat movies, but this movie is in my top five. Andrew Garfield was great, and man, Mel Gibson outdid himself directing. Incredible movie.
I served 10 years as a Navy Corpsman (medic) and served in the Gulf War. I appreciate everything you said. Medics do take pride in what we had to do, whatever it took, because we learned from men like Doss. I did cary a 9mm, and yes medics have always been a target for the enemy, because if you take him out the wounded would all die. There are men just like him, who have done incredible things during the heat of battle. I wish more Americans stood behind our young men and women who serve. They don't want War anymore then anyone else, but will do their duty if ordered. Unfortunately our government spends our tax dollars on wasteful things, while they advise service members to go on food stamps. We have professional sports people making millions to play a game, when our military should be getting payed far better.
Loved your reaction guys, I cried as well when I saw it back in 2017. Desmond Doss will forever be etched in my mind for As long as I'm on this planet. Much love from New Zealand.
I love watching people discover this story. When Doss came down after his night on the ridge, he was plenty injured, but not wounded - not a scratch from the Japanese while he was saving those men. Desmond Doss is one of my heroes, and I hope that, someday, I can have even half of the faith that he showed on the ridge that night. Unfortunately, on YT, I can no longer find the documentary ("The Conscientious Objector", about 1 hour and 40 minutes) that inspired Mel Gibson to make this movie. If I could, I'd include the link.
For having family that made it through the Leningrad siege in the Eastern Front , I solute this soldier! He is everything a soldier and a man should be. True to his morals, true to his word , true to God and having a conviction of a Templar knight. It's so sorry that these people are being lost to obscurity and history is forgotten.
As a Combat veteran of 2 tours.... this is as real as it gets...Doss is a hero amoung Heros a Man amoung men..All Medics were our Heros.with out them we never would have come home I salute them all..
Your reaction to this film is exactly what all Americans should have. I have spent 39 years in the military. I have fought in every war from Desert Storm forward. I always feel uncomfortable when people thank me for my service. I always tell them "thank you for paying your taxes". Most combat veterans are uncomfortable with people who say thank you for your service. The scenes in this movie were created with dramatic liberty. The one that has always stood out with me is the actual Hacksaw Ridge battle or as it was called on the map, the Battle of the Okinawa Maeda Escarpment. The first battle took place two weeks before the second battle. So when they climbed the rope ladder and advanced, the Japanese commander order his men to hold fire until most of the unit was on the plateau. This would allow for his men to kill or injure the maximum amount of Americans. This is the night that Desmond earned his first Medal of Honor recommendation by continuously saving wounded soldier after soldier. After saving his Sergeant, Doss had sustained minor injuries and the command decided to change the launching point for the next attack by approximately 3 miles. During the second attack, the company commander held his attack waiting for Doss to finish praying as it was Doss's sabbath day. During the battle as Doss was collecting the wounded, a Japanese grenade was thrown towards Doss. This is the one he swatted down with his hand. Doss continued to collect the wounded in a foxhole when the second grenade was tossed into the foxhole. Doss tried to shield his wounded while at the same time tried to kick the grenade out of the hole. The grenade exploded and Doss ended up with 17 pieces of shrapnel in his legs and torso. Doss remained cool and actually treated his on wounds and treated himself for shock. As the litter bearers were caring Doss back to the collection point, Doss saw a soldier who he felt was more severely wounded than he was. Doss rolled off the litter and allowed the other soldier to be evacuated. While waiting for help to return, a Japanese sniper shot Doss through and shattering his left arm. Knowing he was in dire straights, Doss crawled 300 yards to the aid station. During his heroic self rescue was when he lost his bible. All of the remaining men searched all night and finally found his bible. The sent it by carrier to the hospital ship USS Mercy where Doss received it. Doss was recovering well after the war until he was diagnosed with Tuberculosis in 1946. He fought this for 5 1/2 years eventually loosing a lung and five ribs and stilled lived to the age of 87. Mel Gibson directed the film and decided to leave all of this out because he felt no one would believe that it was true.
Hacksaw Ridge is an Amazing film about everything it means to not only stand up for our country but also for what it means to stand up for what you ( all of us ) believe in . As much as I Love this film Hacksaw Ridge.... and I do Love this.... Nikki & Steve your reactions and commentary made this touch me more . I have appreciated your channel since I subscribed back when Game of Thrones started and I still am trying to keep up . Thank you so much for your channel with all the work and fun you bring to it .
That moment on the precepice, when Doss prays "I can't hear you.", when the sounds of the wounded are carried across the battlefield to him, that moment was masterful film making. Desmond Doss performed a God given miracle and no amount of skeptics will ever convince me otherwise.
Regarding the scene with the brick at the start, where the boys just go off to bed, bear in mind there was no such thing as concussion protocol back then.
This is Okinawa. The same and last island Eugene Sledge was on from the series The Pacific. My Grandpa was in the Navy on a ship called the USS Granville on the waters of Okinawa. Okinawa caused 12,520 American deaths, around 5,000 of them at sea from kamikazes.
Yep my 96 year old grand pa was medic during that war in the Pacific. What they said that the medics were being targeted was true but there was a lot more to it then just that.
I never get tired of watching this movie. It moves me and makes me cry everytime. It renews my spirit knowing his faith. I love your reaction. Keep it up :)
As a Seventh Day Adventist child I learned about Desmond Doss in pathfinders (it's basically boy /girl scouts) we were taught survival techniques but mostly we were taught to give medical aid. Basically every single seventh-day Adventist child in the Pathfinder program was trained as a field medic. We are taught that you don't have to be the sun to brighten the corner where you are. You don't have to save the world, just save one more. Doss was our example.
You know what’s insane? This battle actually happened and this ridge still exists. The entire base and bottom level is now a resort town.. the bunkers are still there and the blood is still residual on some parts. The pacific was an absolute blood bath and I’m thankful I got to hear the stories first hand. Thank god for the USMC.
I love this movie. And I never hear anyone mention the insanely good casting for Hal. Nate Buzolic really looks so much like Andrew Garfield. I read a biography of Desmond Doss after watching this and the amount they've omitted to make it "believable" is actually insane
You dont mess with doc! I am fortunate to be here because of our medics. I was injured by IED in Afghanistan in 2006. I woke up in Germany in the hospital. Closed brain injury and many broken bones and internal injuries. Thank u for supporting our troops and our country! U folks are the reason we do what we do!
Desmond was an incredible human being and a man of God. Truly one of humanity's best. We need more like him. I highly recommend watching these next: 13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi (True story) Make this one top priority! We Were Soldiers (Vietnam True Story) American Sniper (Iraq War True Story) The Outpost (Afghanistan True Story) The Thin Red Line (WW2 Pacific War film) 12 Strong (Afghanistan True Story) Black Hawk Down (Somalia 1993 True Story) Lone Survivor (Afghanistan True Story) The Patriot (Revolutionary War) Defiance (WW2 Resistance) Patriots Day (Boston Bombing) Flags of Our Fathers. All good films.
Its really an honor to really watch this incredible story of Dessmond Doss. Thank you for the great reaction. Btw Teresa Palmer is one of the underrated actreses out there... We all knew that Andrew Garfield is topnotch when it comes to acting but Palmer was able to achieve the high level of acting Garfield puts in. Not just in one scene but all of it. And thats a really good casting. Plus the chemistry between them is so perfect. I really wish to see them again in another intense and emotional movie.
Another movie that was somewhat similar to religious issues is Chariots of Fire where Eric Liddel wouldn't compete in an Olympic event on a Sunday. The setting was the 1924 Summer Olympics in Paris.
The number 75 was a compromise. Desmond said he saved about 50 men, witnesses around him said it was between 100 and 200, the Army chose to settle with 75. Also, this story was toned down from everything he had done because it was thought that no one would believe it all. I remember going through basic training at Fort Jackson back in 84 and we had one conscientious objector, in our platoon, that told us Desmond Doss' story, it was captivating and inspired us all. This will forever be one of my favorite movies and yes, I get teary eyed every time I watch it. Loved your reactions keep up the great work.
He was born in Lynchburg, VA, not far from me, and I remember the wonderful outpouring of love for him when he died, even though after the war he lived in Georgia and Alabama. Just a bit of a more lighthearted note, he stayed just as scrawny as he was in WWII. A stiff breeze would have knocked him over.
22:22 For me this shot alone stands on par with Jon Snow raising his sword when the horses charge him during the battle of the bastards. Instant goosebumps
As a veteran I am proud to see today’s interest in the military genre of movies. The advances in special effects have presented such an immersive visual effect, those without military experience can get a little idea of the “HARSH REALITY” our military can face. I had the honor to attend a special showing of “Saving Private Ryan” the second week of its theatrical release. The first two rows (floor level and one up) were reserved for WWII veterans & family. Just before the coming attractions showed, approximately 20 people were ushered to their seats. At the end only subdued sniffles and sobs could be herd with NOONE moving to leave. After a brief pause the first of the veterans got up to leave, while the rest of us in attendance gave them ALL a standing ovation as they left. There seems to be a flow-over effect of people watching some older movies; “Full Metal Jacket”, “Platoon”, “M*A*S*H”, “Apocalypse Now” etc. I think these movies are great but need to be viewed with the filter of social commentary for the time they were made. I would like to see reactions to two older movies, based on two of the most decorated war heroes. These movies, though not posing the fantastic special effects of today’s movies, contain just as much interest by the simple act of storytelling. The first is the story of one of the most decorated soldiers of WWI. The main character of the story (Alvin C York) chose actor Gary Cooper to portray him. Released in September 1941, just before America entered WWII, “Sargent York”. The second story is about the MOST DECORATED soldier of WWII. The movie not only adapted from his autobiography (Audie Murphy) but starred him as well. From October 1955, just over ten years after the end of the war “To Hell and Back”.
Flamethrowers were used by all the warring nations during WW2. The US used them quite extensively in the Pacific. Flamethrowers were also used during WW1.
I remember seeing a video this year about some WW2 veterans speaking about what they went through during the landing on Ohama Beach. They said that they are the witnesses, the heroes were laid to rest there. Desmond Doss would have definitely agreed with what they have said.
Dearest Nikki and Steven, I really love watching your movie reactions to movies I have not seen! I get the gist of the plot, and enjoy being scared, shocked, and crying along with you guys. It’s really wonderful to experience movies so honestly with you, and for you to share that part of yourselves with others. Thank you! Aside…. My Dad was a WWII veteran who flew The Hump (The Himalayas-gasoline from India to China) for the Army Air Corps. He would never speak of his service, and it was known not to ask him. After the war, after his experience, and for the remainder of his life, he was an atheist, an isolationist, and a pacifist. Movies like this one that accurately portray the horrors of warfare and the terrifying ways humans can and have treated each other, helps me understand why. ❤️ RIP Papa 1920-2011 ❤️
Not watched this reaction yet but I'm sooo hyped. One of my favourite films from the past 10 years. Love it and huge fan of Garfield. Ok, gonna watch now.
The flame thrower tanks exploding was 100% movie only. Those tanks were designed NOT to explode when pierced so it was EXTREMELY rare for the flamethrower guy to die like that.
I might have to watch the full reaction to this. It’s an incredible film and the fact it’s all true is astonishing. I’ve cried every time I’ve seen it. I adore Andrew Garfield in everything, but this was a beautiful performance and I was sad it was a tough year for oscars, as he really was so worthy of it.
I will always love the tourniquet scene and the sudden gore shift. When I watched this for the second and third time with my ex and my co-workers respectively, they all had the same "Is this really R-Rated???" face.... THEN BOOM! Headshot!
“Brothers” (2009) is another great movie that demonstrates just some of the physiological effects that military people experience through some incredible acting. Movie starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Tobey Mcguire. Should definitely watch this one. Love seeing you guys react to war films.
My Charlie fought in the Pacific in WWll. He was on Bougainville, Guam and Iwo Jima with the Third Marine Division. Unbelievable horror was beaten back by uncommon valor in that terrible war. Desmond Doss was the most uncommon of all. Amazing story.
If you think about it Doss actually fought 2 battles first was basic training his fellow soldiers his officers and the military in general and then Hacksaw Ridge a true hero is not enough to describe him RIP Desmond Doss!
Incredible movie and reaction. This man's beliefs and dedication is just legendary. If you liked this kind of story you should check out The Pacific which is the follow up to Band of Brothers you reacted to.
I love your channel more than any other on TH-cam because of the raw emotions you guys have. This is one of my favorite movies of all time. I cried throughout the entire film, and then I cried throughout your entire video. Thank you guys for watching this movie and doing a reaction to it. I love our veterans, and I love you guys. Take care. Your friend Greg.
I have said this to others but I thank you. I am an old man that lives alone. Watching movies I enjoy while watching your reactions makes me feel like I am watching the movie with you. I don't feel so alone. Thank you for that!
If you guys want to react to more WWII films I recommend the following: - The Great Escape - Letters from Iwo Jima/Flag of our Fathers - Inglorious Basterds - Saving Private Ryan - Dunkirk
full watch-a-long reaction: bit.ly/31CFdfr
You guys should react to
The Monuments Men
World War 2, European theatre, not really action packed, but had a few emotional moments
You guys should react to netflix arcane
Would like to say that I’ve finally sub’s to you guys after watching your channel pop up every now and then. There are so many reaction channels but a lot of them just don’t seem authentic, like maybe they are pretending to watch it for the first time even though they’ve probably already have. I’ve only come across a few reactions that seem authentic and you guys are one of them. Keep up the great content and thank you 😊
I highly recomend for you both to watch Midway :)
Please react to Saving Private Ryan. Y'all will love it if y'all like Band of Brothers and this movie. It's the best ww2 film and the accurate film depicting ww2 battles like the famous d day beach landing scene.
Also if y'all love Game of Thrones, please react to the Lord of the Rings trilogy. It's considered the best epic fantasy film trilogy ever.
Something that tragically isn't mentioned in the movie is that he was also a vegetarian as part of his religious beliefs. Much of the army's rations consisted of potted meat and such. So through his service he mainly survived on a diet of crackers, bread, jams, butters, and dried fruit that he would trade his meat for. By his own admission he was often very hungry, weak, and demoralized.
Wow. Dude was beyond the definition of mentality tough.
He tried to eat coconuts that had fallen on the ground, but they gave him dysentery. So one evening he climbed a tree to pick fresh and came under enemy fire. Luckily, the Japanese soldiers were drunk and couldn't shoot straight.
@@JeshuaSquirrel It's not just the fallen coconuts that will give you dysentery.
Coconut milk also contains fermentable carbohydrates. These can cause digestive issues, such as diarrhea or constipation.
thats insane, poor guy
He, actually, told Smitty, in the foxhole, that he didn't eat meat, to which Smitty replied, " of course, you don't".
The actual Desmond Doss story is even more amazing. Mel Gibson toned it down for fear that no one would believe it. Hacksaw Ridge wasn’t the only battle he did stuff like this. He was hardcore
That answered one question for me was if he actually went home after hacksaw cause his Cpt said "your going home" and without googling I was curious if he actually stayed in the army after his injuries and had more battles. What a guy
@@wildboarps he was also part of the USO war bond drive but it wasn’t short lived. So yes he continued service in battle and at home.
There was actually more than 75 around That Desmond Doss saved. The big rope ladder you saw Desond was one of the Guys who tied it up there. There was more battles Doss fought in and saved men there also. He Carried more man than the movie should. There was a lot of times when the Japanese whent to Shoot Desmond Doss and their guns jammed up. Other time The bullets went around Desmond doss and then continued on the same path they were headed towards. So meaning they was head Towards Doss and was redirected around him. When Doss was Wounded and the stretcher medics was taken them to safety. Dos saw a more severed injured soldier and told them to take him. When Doss was banging him up Doss got shot in the arm. He than made a Split out of a rifle stock and crawled three hundred yards to a aid station. So yea Doss was amazing and God truly Protected him through the battle. Doss got shot there he had the Bible. The Bible saved his life. I don't think he kicked the Grenade. When I was younger I met Doss in person. When he was on the Medic boat that is when he realized he lost his Bible. He got in Contact with his unit and they searched until they found his Bible. The return it to hime. That is just few more things about him. There is book about his life and a Documentary also.
Yea the movie made it seem like Hacksaw was Desmond’s first battle but I think he was in at least 2 prior to it.
not to be an contrarian but the "hacksaw ridge" was 10 mts tall. and by this time, doss was a blooded veteran of 2? battles i think. he was no rookie or virrgin but a recognized hero
the way Hugo Weaving portrayed someone suffering from post traumatic stress and survivor guilt in this movie is highly underrated
Very true. Incredible acting.
I wonder if he talked to any of us because he nailed my feelings to a T
A list actor.
It's arguably his single best performance.
The look that Hugo Weaving's character gave his son at the cemetery was anger, pain, sadness, and fear all rolled into one. My dad gave that same look when I told him I was enlisting in the army, and all I could do was try and tell him I was going to be fine. Every father whose child enlists well have that look on their face no matter how proud they are of them.
The real story is way worse. After getting hurt, he continued saving people. He saved 200+ over the whole war. This looks like a single event, but Doss was in other battles, but Hacksaw Ridge was his prime moment.
Yes, he also received two bronze star medals for his actions in Guam and the Philippines as well.
Yeah the fact he was fighting in three battles without a weapon is a very dangerous and insane thing to imagine
@@pepethefrog6809 jesus what a legend
They intentionally give a very false representation of the hacksaw ridge battle though. They make it look like the entire thing happened over three days, and that he recovered an entire battlefield full of injured in one night. That simply did not happen.
And while there was a period where he remained on the battlefield recovering wounded after everyone else had retreated it wasn't some kind of 12 hour constant stream of wounded being lowered down one after the other for an entire night. His heroics at hacksaw ridge took place over the course of almost a month and the 75 number includes everyone he helped evacuate from the battlefield over that whole period.
This is the first I've ever heard of this@@Rowgue51
On more thing. The action depicted in this movie was VERY truncated. This battle was over 4 DAYS long. Officially he was credited with saving 75 men. Unofficially the number was closer to 150. His full story is simply unbelievable in this day in age
something impossible for just a man
Damn, god had his eyes on him the whole time, u don't find men like this ever
@@davidnobre5660 through the lord all things are possible
@@davidnobre5660 with God all things are possible. This real life young man believed in bet his life on his faith in God instead of ground when he thought he was obeying God. The Lord God in this kindness blessed this man's abilities and made him do what we would call superhuman things nowadays. How is God's strength and love for his fellow man he accomplished what can only be called miraculous feats of heroism.
It was actually about 100. But he himself said it couldn't have been more than 50. So they sit the difference. That's where they got the official number.
RIP Desmond Doss (February 7, 1919 - March 23, 2006), aged 87
You will be remembered as a hero.
He and his wife died in a car accident in 1991
@@thythyy7633 where did you get this information? That is entirely incorrect.
The first Congressional Medal of Honor given to a Conscience Objector.
Are there more? Genuinely curious
@@cosdead46
Very few, but yes.
@@cosdead46 Only two others, both during the Vietnam War,
Thomas W. Bennett and Joseph G. LaPointe both had religious convictions that led to them serving as medics in the field. Neither survived the war.
Bennett’s platoon was ambushed and everyone dove for cover except Bennett who went to help the injured. He aided the wounded under near-constant enemy fire for over a day before getting shot in the head while rushing across an open field to another platoon of injured and pinned down soldiers.
LaPointe was assigned to the 101st Airborne Division. While on a combat helicopter assault mission, he crawled through withering enemy machine gun and grenade fire to aid two injured soldiers, covering them with his own body to protect them.
LaPointe was repeatedly shot and peppered with shrapnel, but he never left the two soldiers he was assisting. Finally a grenade landed at his feet and killed all three men before LaPointe could stabilize the soldiers and move them to safety.
Their Medals were awarded by the President of The United States in 1970 and 1971 respectively.
The dude was so badass he didn't have to kill to make a major difference. Plenty of others were already doing that.
Conscientious
The part where Desmond heard the call for medic and the explosions from the Battleship’s Shells are everywhere, and he understands and he starts walking towards his call. I cried and that reminds me of Psalm 23:4
“Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for you are with me; your rod and your staff, they comfort me.”
Same here what an amazing scripture!
Amen!
"Whatever the word above Hero is, he's that."
The word you're looking for Steve is: "Legend."
Amen - a Doss Legend!
Doss is such a legend they even teach us about him in the British Army Medical Training.
I prefer the term Paragon
@@Strider91 I'm not religious. But if someone was to tell me Jesus has already returned but this time his name was Desmond Doss, I wouldn't question it.
@@realburglazofficial2613 You should see the movie The Passion of Christ also by Mel Gibson.
My Great Uncle was at Iwo Jima. He never talked about the war, but we convinced him to when he was getting old, because it was important to preserve his story for the family. He saw all the bodies of young 18 year olds stacked up on the beach. He said it was the most appalling waste of life he had ever seen.
Another true fact is that many Japanese had him in their sights, but whenever they went to shoot, their guns jammed every time. I’m not religious, but knowing this stuff makes me a little more hopeful.
God pdotected desmond. Nothing short of divine intervention should have made his survival possible.
I challenge you my friend to ask God into your life. Find him. Hs who seek truly with a whole heart always do.
EXACTLY! I was losing my faith like 2 years ago but now this for the first time hearing this story about a year ago I regained it and never felt better
If I remember right Doss MET one of the Japanese that had him in his sights. And that's exactly what he said. He has no idea why. His gun just wouldn't fire.
Proof God is real my friend. God had plans for him
God had His hand on Doss. That blessed his group.
Officially, he saved 75, unofficially it was closer to 150, there are no words to describe his bravery, this movie as good as it is, does not capture all of what Medic Doss did. My Dad who is going to be 97 this year, and hopes to live to be 100, was in WWII, he drove supply truck, a target for sure, always on the front line. He was one of the eight men of 100 drivers who walked out of their own volition. Dad landed on D-Day, two days after his B-Day. He said he'd seen things in that war, no young man should ever see. He never talked about the war while Mom was alive, once she passed, he started opening up and talking about it. I know he is still keeping things to himself. Found out that he made a promise to Mom that he would not talk about the war, married 62 years, until she passed, he kept his word. These men/women were of the greatest generation, for many reasons.
I love this movie, one of my top 10. I also wish Garfield would have receive an Academy award for this. I also wonder how much physical exercise went into Garfield's training for this role. I would imagine it would involver pushing and pulling heavy sleighs, squatting with weight, and running around with people on his back.
Knowing how Garfield is actually pretty religious, I would imagine this role meant a lot for him and it seems he invested a lot into it. Great movie.
At least he was nominated for an academy award dude was awesome in the movie.
He was great
@jonabank Andrew Garfield is Jewish on his father's side; Garfield had a secular upbringing, and has referred to himself as an "agnostic pantheist", though he identifies as Jewish. However, he had been in three major religious features with both Hacksaw Ridge (Mel Gibson directed) and Silence (Martin Scorsese directed) in 2016 and the current The Eyes of Tammy Faye (2021).
I think Hugo weaving deserved one to. Incredible performance
@@NikkiStevenReact the movie was directed by Mel Gibson! Filmed in Australia! It was interesting recognizing all the Australian actors putting on their best American accents! Australian Hugo Weaving played his dad! 🥰💕from Australia!
As a Brit, I know all about Desmond Doss as we studied war at school. 12 hours on that ridge over 70 soldiers and the Congressional Medal of Honour - unarmed and was about to be jailed as he wouldn't carry a gun. That's what I like about these reaction videos. Take a look guys at what it takes to win the British Victoria Cross, it's so good for us to not just watch movies and believe, but to know what heroes we both had that neither of us would know if it wasn't for the internet and suggestions. Johnson Beharry is one of VERY few like this wonderful man to be alive to receive it, he won his recently with half his skull and part of his brain missing and still rescuing and going back in to save others in Afghanistan. He freaked out when everyone was looking at him asking him 'Are you OK???' He was SAVING THEM! He should NEVER be alive after what he did. New Subscriber BTW and god bless from across the pond.
Movies like this are important, in my opinion, because I hear people disrespect older veterans that have PSD, or are passionate about what they saw and survived. People just don't get it until they see something like this, and get an inkling of what these men endured, and continue to endure. Love that you guys reviewed this, and appreciate it!
Too bad the only pain that matter is the white American one since they keep making awarding those one
@@fembrucewayne1904 Shut. Up.
@@fembrucewayne1904 bro …
@@fembrucewayne1904 tell us you’re racist without Telling us you’re racist
@@fembrucewayne1904 you’re the type to call everyone racist when ur the only one that sees color...
Mr. Doss lived in our small town in Alabama his last few years. Occasionally, he would eat breakfast with a crew of older men in the local restaurants. My dad was usually in there and I would eat with them sometimes. I knew he was a CMOH recipient, but didn't know the full story like now. He was a quiet, humble and friendly man and I wish I'd known more about him so I could have appreciated him more when I was around him.
Interesting interaction. Strange how much we don't know about the people we brush up against in life.
With the possible exception of "Saving Private Ryan", I honestly consider this to be the best war film ever made.
I've watched this through twice and have seen a few different reaction vids and at this point, I have to agree.
This, Ryan, and Glory are god-tier. Platoon and Black Hawk Down are runners up.
part where he is volleying the hand grenade like messi was embarrassing to watch
@@dzekadzenan6977 I might agree…if it didn’t _actually_ happen.
@@SliderFury1 black hawk down is god tier in the modern war genre
American feel-good movie, emotional manipulation made film.
For best war movies, you have to go outside the USA. Das Boot, Stalingrad, Come and See…
He is an amazing example for Christianity. In a world full of so much hate, too much of it coming from Christians themselves sometimes, it’s important to remember what he did and what he stood for. It didn’t matter who you were, whether you were fighting for or against him. He saved every human he could
Maybe it's already been mentioned, Desmond thought he lowered 50 wounded, but the unit below said he lowered over 100, so they compromised on 75.
Wow - excellent detail to share. Thanks!
I'm not a big fan of war movies tbh, but this has always been one of my favorite movies, and to this day I can't watch it without getting at least teary. Knowing that it is a true story, and that there was someone out there who did this, that this happened. It is just so moving.
You might also like 1917. Its on my Top 5 including Hacksaw Ridge.
The funny part is that most of this feats shown was literally watered down to make it believable, from apparently over 100 and not 75 he saved, and the fact after that grenade did his leg, he actually pushed on to do his duty as a medic, like damn
It’s like the line from Gladiator: "What we do in life echoes in eternity."
YUS!
I'm not religious at all but Doss really, really is a shining example of faith in humanity. What an incredible piece of war history. It's heartbreaking that there are countless heroic moments in war that will never be told.
you don't have to be religious but faith in God gives you a lot of strength to fight and never give up.
@FannyBashing247God isn’t based on religion my friend it’s based on relationship humanity made religion… so yes it is based on faith in God and that’s the prime lesson and literally the essence in this movie that doss displayed continuously. And just a note many atheist and even high satanic worshippers lately have come to say Jesus Christ is real and is lord.
@FannyBashing247 hmmm you blame and question God with those statements but the answer is always right in front of you and is and will remain the same… you ask how can he allow this to happen as if he never gave his creation ways to stop it but humanity chooses to do what it wants… you then ask why does he give us “free will” then that’s because if their wasn’t free will the man we wouldn’t choose to love him and you can relate to that just like you wanting someone to choose to love you than forcing them. But then he have his only son a sacrifice to allow us another chance to be with him but nah people don’t believe in that… bc there’s no way someone could love us like tat even though there is and he loves you that way, you can’t say thing like that without giving God a chance and before you say you have you haven’t given him a chance to work on you and move in his timing and how he wants to that’s were patience and enduring comes in, plus he never said this life would be easy bc they hated him so they will surely hate his people. The Bible is a love letter and an history instruction Manuel.
Another good true story war film is “We Were Soldiers”. It took place in Vietnam. Mel Gipson stars in it. I think it’s a really good one.
That's a great movie.
"Casualties of war" too starring Michael J Fox and Sean Penn
My dad was a Vietnam Veteran and that movie brought him to tears. I'll never forget it.
One of My favorite movies
I remember watching a documentary on Doss called "The Conscientious Objector" and thinking, how is this not a movie? When this came out I knew they wouldn't be able to put everything into it since they only have about 2 hours or less to work with. I thought the movie was amazing but I highly recommend watching the documentary if you can find it. There is so much more that this man did that is hardly believable.
Thanks for the recommend
75 is the average of the number of personnel saved by Doss during Hacksaw Ridge. Reports were of 100+ saved, though Doss humbly claimed only 50, so they met in the middle. Okinawa saw the hardest fighting in the Pacific theater and convinced the US command that an invasion of the Japanese mainland would be almost impossible. They theorized that the fighting with the invasion would so horrific that every battle would be a repeat of Okinawa. So instead command decided to drop two bombs as the estimates of those casualties would be considered less than what either side would end up losing doing it the other way.
I always wondered if a mainland invasion of Japan was truly "necessary" to win the war if the US didn't have the bomb. One of the initial reasons the Japanese were so aggressive initially was that they knew they didn't have the resources to last long term against the Allies. The day the Nagasaki bomb dropped, there were over half a million Russian troops that invaded Manchuria, so taking the bombs out of the equation, Japan would've been pretty much surrounded and you could essentially lay siege to the mainland, as you carpet bomb them back to the stone age. Basically a "slow burn" instead of a brief 15-25 megaton vaporizing nuclear blast. It would've taken significantly more time, but you have to figure it certainly would've cost less in terms of allied casualties compared to a full on amphibious invasion.
@@shadypelican It's always gonna be in the realm of fantasy, since we can't truly know the minds of the people in charge at the time, but i'm of the belief that Japan would eventually have surrendered anyway, without the use of the bombs. Remember, just about the same time the US dropped the bombs, the Soviet Union invaded the Japanese possessions in mainland Asia, which would have meant all but complete doom for Japan. So some historians argue that the main catalyst for Japan's surrender was the invasion by the Soviet Union, not necessarily the atomic bombs.
@@TheArrowedKnee I've heard that as well--that factions within the inner circle of the Japanese military could much more easily wrap their brains around the idea of Russian soldiers swamping them, than they could of one bomb leveling an entire city in the blink of an eye. And speaking of the Russian, I do also think one of the reasons the bombs were dropped was to say to the Russians "Hey! Don't get any ideas! Look at what we got." (which would explain why the Russians, not to be outdone, would later make the absurdly powerful Tsar Bomba)
@@shadypelican yeah but then again, the japanese did have their "kamikaze" tactics. would they have peacefully surrendered to the russians, or was the spectacle of the bomb what made them realize "ok yea we have no chance of winning, and we cant even suicide bomb our enemies when they are thousands of feet in the air"
Personally I believe dropping the 2 nuclear bombs saved the Japanese people. Any invasion by the Allies or just the Soviets, and the Japanese would have destroyed themselves in defense of the Home Islands. The losses would have been mindboggling on both sides. For the planners, at the time, even the "best case scenario" would have resulted in insane losses. The question of should or shouldn't they have dropped the nukes is today largely looked at from our point of view, but we must also understand the contemporary view. The Allies were staring down the barrel of what had the potential to be the most nightmarish campaign in human history. So they pinned their hopes on the then newfangled "atom bombs" and prayed the Japanese saw reason. And in fact they almost did not! The Emperor himself had to intervene to end the madness.
During the late 1960's and early 70's, my family and I became good friends with Desmond Doss and his family. As amazing as this movie is, it isn't as amazing as his true story. He accepted the medal of honor on behalf of those who didn't come home.
That's amazing. What was he like to talk to?
@@BuntingClipClop He was a very humble person. When he told his story, he didn't take credit for his actions. He believed it was his duty to care for his fellow soldiers. He really didn't like the attention, and only allowed his story to be told in hopes that it would strengthen people's faith, as well as give them an understanding of the horrors of war. It was an honor to know him.
Wow. What a privilege. Thank you for answering.
I remember reading somewhere that when this movie premiered it received a 15 minute standing ovation.
Desmond Doss had actually contracted tuberculosis six months earlier, but he wasn't diagnosed with it until after the war, which resulted in surgery to remove one lung. The guy was probably suppressing his coughing to stay quiet while doing all the things that he did, as well as gasping from all the effort that he was expending.
19:20 Flamethrowers were used by the US military until 1978.
Been waiting for you guys to see this one! I was a Navy FMF Corpsman (counter part to Desmond Doss and all Army medics) 10 years in Navy I spent 8 years with Marines. Desmond's story was well known to me. When I was stationed in Okinawa, I was fortunate enough to stand on Hacksaw Ridge. Every hair on me stood straight up that entire day. Honored to have followed in the footsteps of men such as him.
Corpsmannnn!!!
WOW....THAT'S AMAZING
That story is cool as heck.
Thank you for serving
Many thanks for your service
i think one of my favorite stories about doss was that when the japanese who fought against his regiment were interviewed, some shared that they actually *tried* shooting at him, only for their guns to suddenly jam or have dirt in the sights, rendering the shot useless. either doss was just really lucky, or someone up there was really looking out for him.
Desmond's ,father in the movie, held the Distinguished Service Cross and the Silver Star. The 2ed and 3rd highest award for valor in combat as well as the Croix De Guerre, thee highest honor for bravery from France.
Excellent info - thanks for the share!
I had no idea. Valuable comment, thanks for the post.
My grandpa served in Europe as infantry during ww2. He was kind and could make a room laugh with ease. He never talked about the war and was extremely humble. I was still a young teenager when he died . . . I didn't understand. He had went through hell. I stayed up one night reading through journal entries and stories from his unit, some from him. I cried my eyes out, I never gave that man the respect he deserved. That generation was a different breed of man. He amassed a good bit of wealth later in life, not because he had a high paying job white collar job, but because he worked hard and invested what he could. My grandma and him never lived lavishly. They retired, went on vacations to see the world and then gave all the money to their son and daughter when they died. It is easy to to forget where we came from, the people who bear the foundation of where we are now.
Much respect. You must be very proud to have his blood in your veins.
Hard to believe they actually scaled down what Desmond Doss did in this movie. Hacksaw Ridge wasn't his or his units first foray into combat, and he was constantly on the go in the thick of it saving his brothers in arms. And you're right. The WWII generation was simply made of tougher stuff.
Every time I see someone react to this movie I get teary eyed. The actions in this movie really help you look at the better side of humanity and society itself. Andrew portrays this man perfectly, Doss was a true genuine soul and his name is a legendary symbol and meaning of true strength, never giving up. The sheer will power be had back then was just insane.
Outstanding man, outstanding movie.
25:10 "Is he like the greatest human being to ever live?"
Yeah, that was Desmond Doss in a nutshell. Very few come close to his level. But he was one of the greatest ever.
Yes - he was Legendary!
He’s reached sainthood status to me
Doss was part of the 77th US Army Infantry Division. Known as "The Old Bastards". They were so good at their work that the Marines that they were attached to in the Pacific started calling them "The 77th Marine Division". See the great video "The Fat Electrician" has on his yt channel "Old Age & Treachery - The Unstoppable 77th Infantry Division".
He actually almost got in trouble because he was just as likely to aid Japanese wounded as his wounded fellow Americans. All the while knowing if he was ever captured by the Japanese, he could expect to die in the cruelest of ways, or go through the unimaginable hell of a Japanese run POW camp.
I would imagine he wouldn't get in trouble; yes, he rescued Japanese soldiers, but after receiving treatment, the POWs could be interrogated on manpower, equipment, plans, and used for general labor. There's not really a downside to taking POWs if you're able to take care of them, regardless of how you feel about the war overall. Only thing I can see him getting reprimanded for would be if he took Japanese before Americans, as you could lose an American life while saving a Japanese one.
@@joecee6862 I guess for some, helping any Japanese soldiers at all may count as aiding and abetting the enemy.
Such a good movie, makes me tear up every time, Garfield did a phenomenal job
When you said “Vitoooooooo” I had a flashback to every family reunion I’ve ever been to haha.
Haha yeah bro
This is just 1 small part of what this man achieved! He actually saved over 200 people in his service. A true phenomenal American hero!!!
One of the primary reasons why Medics in the Pacific Theater carried sidearms was because the Japanese placed a high priority in killing them, even though it was against the Geneva Convention to target personnel or vehicles or buildings with a red cross. You can't save your buddies if you're dead. That weapon was your only defense.
I thought the Geneva Convention was after WW2. I know the Nuremburg trials set president for international law regarding a lot of things besides war.
@@heathercontois4501 there was an 1864 Geneva Convention that included the Red Cross. The Japanese were not signatories.
The Japanese were not signatories to the Geneva Conventions, which technically only applies between fellow signatory nations. The last war America fought another Geneva Convention power was against the Nazis.
@@heathercontois4501 I know I'm necro-ing this comment, but I looked it up. There are multiple GCs. The first (the one barring targeting medical staff) was signed in 1864, but wasn't widely adopted until the 1920s (shortly after WW1). At the time, Japan was not part of the accords. It wasn't until after WW2 that MOST nations adopted the Geneva Conventions, and other versions of these laws were signed, as well, including the use of chemical weapons, mistreatment of POWs, and even certain types of AMMUNITION. That is why military forces cannot use anything more wounding to a person than FMJ ammo, which is designed to go right through someone. Flamethrowers (as seen in the movie) were banned by virtually all signatories after WW2, though napalm dumps were still allowed (for some reason) until after Vietnam, I believe.
The entire cinema was on emotional roller coaster because of this movie. Nobody was upset because of the father character - we all undesrtood his pain. And we cheered for him when He took his uniform again. People were holding tears when Doss repeated the line "God help me save one more" and then..in the final titles we saw that he lived a long and good life and we went crazy. Beautiful movie.
We need more soldiers like Desmond Doss.
Actually, we doesn't need any soldiers. What we need is a f-ing peace!
We need more politicians like Doss. That's what will actually result in fewer need for soldiers and misery.
If peace were attainable, you’d be correct. Unfortunately human nature is not a peaceful one.
So we do need soldiers.
We need good leaders. Simple.
Be the change you want to see in the world.
I have a friend that met him and like Mel Gibson said, he did so much they couldn't put it all in the movie because nobody would believe it.
This is the only film that comes close to approaching how absolutely horrifying combat in some areas of the Pacific theater was. Specifically the small islands. The end result of many battles resembled the carnage of car or train crashes because of how densely packed the battlefields were.
... shit. You know a person is far beyond any definition of a hero, when his life story is too badass for a movie to show fully without it seeming impossible.
I watched him lower like 2 dozen people and thought that was insane, he did that 75 TIMES! Then did stuff that would make movie heroes think him have the will of a God.
Desmond Doss: Certified Legend and Saviour of life
I'm not big on war/combat movies, but this movie is in my top five. Andrew Garfield was great, and man, Mel Gibson outdid himself directing. Incredible movie.
I served 10 years as a Navy Corpsman (medic) and served in the Gulf War. I appreciate everything you said. Medics do take pride in what we had to do, whatever it took, because we learned from men like Doss. I did cary a 9mm, and yes medics have always been a target for the enemy, because if you take him out the wounded would all die. There are men just like him, who have done incredible things during the heat of battle. I wish more Americans stood behind our young men and women who serve. They don't want War anymore then anyone else, but will do their duty if ordered. Unfortunately our government spends our tax dollars on wasteful things, while they advise service members to go on food stamps. We have professional sports people making millions to play a game, when our military should be getting payed far better.
Loved your reaction guys, I cried as well when I saw it back in 2017. Desmond Doss will forever be etched in my mind for As long as I'm on this planet. Much love from New Zealand.
Directed by Mel Gibson! Filmed in Australia! Unbelievable movie!
I love watching people discover this story. When Doss came down after his night on the ridge, he was plenty injured, but not wounded - not a scratch from the Japanese while he was saving those men. Desmond Doss is one of my heroes, and I hope that, someday, I can have even half of the faith that he showed on the ridge that night.
Unfortunately, on YT, I can no longer find the documentary ("The Conscientious Objector", about 1 hour and 40 minutes) that inspired Mel Gibson to make this movie. If I could, I'd include the link.
I'd say 1/10 of his faith would absolve any man.
I watched that documentary after watching this film it was so good.
For having family that made it through the Leningrad siege in the Eastern Front , I solute this soldier! He is everything a soldier and a man should be. True to his morals, true to his word , true to God and having a conviction of a Templar knight. It's so sorry that these people are being lost to obscurity and history is forgotten.
Wow! The Eastern Front doesn't get talked nearly as much.
The Russians put up one hell of a resistance
Eastern front is where the real war took place. 70% Nazi casualty came from eastern front. Hell on earth.
As a Combat veteran of 2 tours.... this is as real as it gets...Doss is a hero amoung Heros a Man amoung men..All Medics were our Heros.with out them we never would have come home I salute them all..
"is gonna take all those dues that are still alive down by himself?!"
"Yes."
Your reaction to this film is exactly what all Americans should have. I have spent 39 years in the military. I have fought in every war from Desert Storm forward. I always feel uncomfortable when people thank me for my service. I always tell them "thank you for paying your taxes". Most combat veterans are uncomfortable with people who say thank you for your service.
The scenes in this movie were created with dramatic liberty. The one that has always stood out with me is the actual Hacksaw Ridge battle or as it was called on the map, the Battle of the Okinawa Maeda Escarpment. The first battle took place two weeks before the second battle. So when they climbed the rope ladder and advanced, the Japanese commander order his men to hold fire until most of the unit was on the plateau. This would allow for his men to kill or injure the maximum amount of Americans. This is the night that Desmond earned his first Medal of Honor recommendation by continuously saving wounded soldier after soldier. After saving his Sergeant, Doss had sustained minor injuries and the command decided to change the launching point for the next attack by approximately 3 miles.
During the second attack, the company commander held his attack waiting for Doss to finish praying as it was Doss's sabbath day. During the battle as Doss was collecting the wounded, a Japanese grenade was thrown towards Doss. This is the one he swatted down with his hand. Doss continued to collect the wounded in a foxhole when the second grenade was tossed into the foxhole. Doss tried to shield his wounded while at the same time tried to kick the grenade out of the hole. The grenade exploded and Doss ended up with 17 pieces of shrapnel in his legs and torso.
Doss remained cool and actually treated his on wounds and treated himself for shock. As the litter bearers were caring Doss back to the collection point, Doss saw a soldier who he felt was more severely wounded than he was. Doss rolled off the litter and allowed the other soldier to be evacuated. While waiting for help to return, a Japanese sniper shot Doss through and shattering his left arm. Knowing he was in dire straights, Doss crawled 300 yards to the aid station. During his heroic self rescue was when he lost his bible. All of the remaining men searched all night and finally found his bible. The sent it by carrier to the hospital ship USS Mercy where Doss received it.
Doss was recovering well after the war until he was diagnosed with Tuberculosis in 1946. He fought this for 5 1/2 years eventually loosing a lung and five ribs and stilled lived to the age of 87.
Mel Gibson directed the film and decided to leave all of this out because he felt no one would believe that it was true.
Hacksaw Ridge is an Amazing film about everything it means to not only stand up for our country but also for what it means to stand up for what you ( all of us ) believe in . As much as I Love this film Hacksaw Ridge.... and I do Love this.... Nikki & Steve your reactions and commentary made this touch me more . I have appreciated your channel since I subscribed back when Game of Thrones started and I still am trying to keep up . Thank you so much for your channel with all the work and fun you bring to it .
That moment on the precepice, when Doss prays "I can't hear you.", when the sounds of the wounded are carried across the battlefield to him, that moment was masterful film making. Desmond Doss performed a God given miracle and no amount of skeptics will ever convince me otherwise.
Regarding the scene with the brick at the start, where the boys just go off to bed, bear in mind there was no such thing as concussion protocol back then.
Very good point
This is Okinawa. The same and last island Eugene Sledge was on from the series The Pacific. My Grandpa was in the Navy on a ship called the USS Granville on the waters of Okinawa. Okinawa caused 12,520 American deaths, around 5,000 of them at sea from kamikazes.
Yep my 96 year old grand pa was medic during that war in the Pacific. What they said that the medics were being targeted was true but there was a lot more to it then just that.
Loved this reaction. As a vet, I appreciate yalls military reactions and support. Loved our medic Doc Wadkins. He was the GOAT
I never get tired of watching this movie. It moves me and makes me cry everytime. It renews my spirit knowing his faith. I love your reaction. Keep it up :)
As a Seventh Day Adventist child I learned about Desmond Doss in pathfinders (it's basically boy /girl scouts) we were taught survival techniques but mostly we were taught to give medical aid.
Basically every single seventh-day Adventist child in the Pathfinder program was trained as a field medic.
We are taught that you don't have to be the sun to brighten the corner where you are. You don't have to save the world, just save one more.
Doss was our example.
You know what’s insane? This battle actually happened and this ridge still exists. The entire base and bottom level is now a resort town.. the bunkers are still there and the blood is still residual on some parts. The pacific was an absolute blood bath and I’m thankful I got to hear the stories first hand. Thank god for the USMC.
I love this movie.
And I never hear anyone mention the insanely good casting for Hal. Nate Buzolic really looks so much like Andrew Garfield.
I read a biography of Desmond Doss after watching this and the amount they've omitted to make it "believable" is actually insane
This film made me proud to be an American. And I’m not even American.
You dont mess with doc! I am fortunate to be here because of our medics. I was injured by IED in Afghanistan in 2006. I woke up in Germany in the hospital. Closed brain injury and many broken bones and internal injuries. Thank u for supporting our troops and our country! U folks are the reason we do what we do!
Desmond was an incredible human being and a man of God. Truly one of humanity's best. We need more like him.
I highly recommend watching these next:
13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi (True story) Make this one top priority!
We Were Soldiers (Vietnam True Story)
American Sniper (Iraq War True Story)
The Outpost (Afghanistan True Story)
The Thin Red Line (WW2 Pacific War film)
12 Strong (Afghanistan True Story)
Black Hawk Down (Somalia 1993 True Story)
Lone Survivor (Afghanistan True Story)
The Patriot (Revolutionary War)
Defiance (WW2 Resistance)
Patriots Day (Boston Bombing)
Flags of Our Fathers.
All good films.
Nikki well done for sitting through (watching not covering your eyes) this, it is because of true stories like this that you must be able to watch!
Its really an honor to really watch this incredible story of Dessmond Doss. Thank you for the great reaction. Btw Teresa Palmer is one of the underrated actreses out there... We all knew that Andrew Garfield is topnotch when it comes to acting but Palmer was able to achieve the high level of acting Garfield puts in. Not just in one scene but all of it. And thats a really good casting. Plus the chemistry between them is so perfect. I really wish to see them again in another intense and emotional movie.
Another movie that was somewhat similar to religious issues is Chariots of Fire where Eric Liddel wouldn't compete in an Olympic event on a Sunday. The setting was the 1924 Summer Olympics in Paris.
This is quite simply a masterpiece. Thank you to all who have served or serve our country now and in the future.
The number 75 was a compromise. Desmond said he saved about 50 men, witnesses around him said it was between 100 and 200, the Army chose to settle with 75. Also, this story was toned down from everything he had done because it was thought that no one would believe it all. I remember going through basic training at Fort Jackson back in 84 and we had one conscientious objector, in our platoon, that told us Desmond Doss' story, it was captivating and inspired us all. This will forever be one of my favorite movies and yes, I get teary eyed every time I watch it. Loved your reactions keep up the great work.
You guys would LOVE the HBO miniseries "The Pacific"... the Pacific Theatre counterpart to Band of Brothers. Also done by Spielberg and Hanks.
He was born in Lynchburg, VA, not far from me, and I remember the wonderful outpouring of love for him when he died, even though after the war he lived in Georgia and Alabama. Just a bit of a more lighthearted note, he stayed just as scrawny as he was in WWII. A stiff breeze would have knocked him over.
22:22 For me this shot alone stands on par with Jon Snow raising his sword when the horses charge him during the battle of the bastards. Instant goosebumps
As a veteran I am proud to see today’s interest in the military genre of movies. The advances in special effects have presented such an immersive visual effect, those without military experience can get a little idea of the “HARSH REALITY” our military can face. I had the honor to attend a special showing of “Saving Private Ryan” the second week of its theatrical release. The first two rows (floor level and one up) were reserved for WWII veterans & family. Just before the coming attractions showed, approximately 20 people were ushered to their seats. At the end only subdued sniffles and sobs could be herd with NOONE moving to leave. After a brief pause the first of the veterans got up to leave, while the rest of us in attendance gave them ALL a standing ovation as they left. There seems to be a flow-over effect of people watching some older movies; “Full Metal Jacket”, “Platoon”, “M*A*S*H”, “Apocalypse Now” etc. I think these movies are great but need to be viewed with the filter of social commentary for the time they were made.
I would like to see reactions to two older movies, based on two of the most decorated war heroes. These movies, though not posing the fantastic special effects of today’s movies, contain just as much interest by the simple act of storytelling.
The first is the story of one of the most decorated soldiers of WWI. The main character of the story (Alvin C York) chose actor Gary Cooper to portray him. Released in September 1941, just before America entered WWII, “Sargent York”.
The second story is about the MOST DECORATED soldier of WWII. The movie not only adapted from his autobiography (Audie Murphy) but starred him as well. From October 1955, just over ten years after the end of the war “To Hell and Back”.
I’m so glad you guys reacted to this! I’m such a big fan of your content! Keep up the great work!
Flamethrowers were used by all the warring nations during WW2. The US used them quite extensively in the Pacific.
Flamethrowers were also used during WW1.
I remember seeing a video this year about some WW2 veterans speaking about what they went through during the landing on Ohama Beach. They said that they are the witnesses, the heroes were laid to rest there.
Desmond Doss would have definitely agreed with what they have said.
Dearest Nikki and Steven,
I really love watching your movie reactions to movies I have not seen! I get the gist of the plot, and enjoy being scared, shocked, and crying along with you guys.
It’s really wonderful to experience movies so honestly with you, and for you to share that part of yourselves with others.
Thank you!
Aside….
My Dad was a WWII veteran who flew The Hump (The Himalayas-gasoline from India to China) for the Army Air Corps.
He would never speak of his service, and it was known not to ask him.
After the war, after his experience, and for the remainder of his life, he was an atheist, an isolationist, and a pacifist.
Movies like this one that accurately portray the horrors of warfare and the terrifying ways humans can and have treated each other, helps me understand why.
❤️ RIP Papa 1920-2011 ❤️
Not watched this reaction yet but I'm sooo hyped. One of my favourite films from the past 10 years. Love it and huge fan of Garfield. Ok, gonna watch now.
The flame thrower tanks exploding was 100% movie only. Those tanks were designed NOT to explode when pierced so it was EXTREMELY rare for the flamethrower guy to die like that.
I might have to watch the full reaction to this. It’s an incredible film and the fact it’s all true is astonishing. I’ve cried every time I’ve seen it. I adore Andrew Garfield in everything, but this was a beautiful performance and I was sad it was a tough year for oscars, as he really was so worthy of it.
The bravery of someone willing to go into battle but not willing to kill because of his beliefs is something most people just cannot comprehend.
Dos is the definition of a legend. He will not be forgotten
I will always love the tourniquet scene and the sudden gore shift.
When I watched this for the second and third time with my ex and my co-workers respectively, they all had the same "Is this really R-Rated???" face.... THEN BOOM!
Headshot!
“Brothers” (2009) is another great movie that demonstrates just some of the physiological effects that military people experience through some incredible acting.
Movie starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Tobey Mcguire.
Should definitely watch this one. Love seeing you guys react to war films.
My Charlie fought in the Pacific in WWll. He was on Bougainville, Guam and Iwo Jima with the Third Marine Division. Unbelievable horror was beaten back by uncommon valor in that terrible war. Desmond Doss was the most uncommon of all. Amazing story.
28:08 How he leans his head into the hand
If you think about it Doss actually fought 2 battles first was basic training his fellow soldiers his officers and the military in general and then Hacksaw Ridge a true hero is not enough to describe him RIP Desmond Doss!
This movie is a masterpiece!!! ❤️
I really liked that she said her opinions so freely. Put a smile on my face.
Incredible movie and reaction. This man's beliefs and dedication is just legendary. If you liked this kind of story you should check out The Pacific which is the follow up to Band of Brothers you reacted to.
You should see "This is your life" of Desmond Doss. It features the folks that he saved.
What really is good about this is it's a true story.
I love your channel more than any other on TH-cam because of the raw emotions you guys have. This is one of my favorite movies of all time. I cried throughout the entire film, and then I cried throughout your entire video. Thank you guys for watching this movie and doing a reaction to it. I love our veterans, and I love you guys. Take care. Your friend Greg.
This movie is a masterpiece ❤🙌💥💯☮️
I have said this to others but I thank you. I am an old man that lives alone. Watching movies I enjoy while watching your reactions makes me feel like I am watching the movie with you. I don't feel so alone. Thank you for that!
If you guys want to react to more WWII films I recommend the following:
- The Great Escape
- Letters from Iwo Jima/Flag of our Fathers
- Inglorious Basterds
- Saving Private Ryan
- Dunkirk