Kousei couldn't hear what he was playing in that scene you watched. That's why he was sweating. Because he was like OG pianist until her mother died, thats why he wasnt able to hear his own music since then.
also this is after his "wake up", so they've had a first run of the piece already, he messed it up bad (by that point probably sweating) and now it's the 2nd run and he's purely imagining his sound for the first time, so that would require some amount of focus :D
I want to see them review the last song Kousei plays. (Chopin’s ballad in g minor number 1 op. 23) I’m obsessed! I picked up the violin again after years of not playing just so I can get to the point where I can play along to that song with kousei haha.
Ironically people hated Piano no Mori (Forest Piano) because of its 3d animation lmao. I'm really happy that you appreciated as well as i the quality of the 3d while playing the pieces
You should really check out Kids on the Slope. It's more Jazz, but the main character starts off as a classically trained pianist. It's rotoscoped so the drumming animation and the piano playing are spot on. So amazing!
I absolutely loved Forrest of Piano...I thought it was slightly disparaging on the Chinese participant though...but the description of the emotions and Kai's growth was really fun to watch.
My Lie In April made me cry SO hard, I can't watch it ever again. Cheers from Finland. PS. I watch Nodame Cantebile anime once a year cos' it's THE BEST.
For the Nodame Cantabile scenes, I can say as an Animator who studies animation and loves classical music, those aren’t rotoscoped- those are CGI-ed similar to Forest Piano 🤣😅 Motion capture was created in 1919 and CGI was made in 1973 so it’s not surprising for Nodame Cantabile to be using this technology in the anime- which is absolutely awesome of course, taking into account and respecting classical music and it’s musicians in a way by this means. Rotoscoping is mostly for 2D whilst CGI is used for 3D. Nodame used 3D so it’s CGI:D
Im a violinist, and i can say that the violin in ylia was almost completely accurate. Thats a lot to say. Its probably even harder animating a violin, you need to put in the bow AND the fingering, you need to do the string changing, the shifts, the bow postitioning, bow direction, vibrato, bow techniques, aggresiveness of the playing and even the movement of the violinist to match the playing. Us violinists move A LOT while playing. And they did it all perfectly 👏
How dare these mortals make fun of/criticize arima kousei. Obviously I’m joking, but to be fair he’s insanely nervous and hasn’t played in years + he couldn’t hear the sound of his piano anymore…
Gotta watch the rest of these animes for sure... 'Your lie in april' is a goat series hands down so im looking forward to the rest of these. and poor Kousei dont drag the poor boy he hasnt played in 2 years, cant hear the sound and was extremely nervious and traumatized 😢
Yeah I cried at YLIA. Not as much as Violet Evergarden, but it definitely hit hard at the end. I felt a connection with Kousei due to having lost the ability to play an instrument I had played for most of my life at that point. Watching the whole show felt like rubbing salt into an open wound, but at the same time, it was a beautiful experience.
I just discovered you guys a couple days ago and immiedietly started to feel strange connection to you, even though I have no experience with playing an intrument. I'm about to start playing the piano (actually I'm after my second lesson). keep it up guys, I feel very comfortable here. (sorry for my bad english!)
I got spoiled so completely before I watched Your Lie in April. I knew who had what secret, what was going to happen, to whom, when, what other characters were doing and where, and even what imagery was used to convey the event... so of course I bawled my eyes out all the same.
"Thumbs up if you watched 'Your Lie in April' and you cried" - ???? Thumbs up if you watched 'Your Lie in April' and you were able to keep yourself from crying! By the way, thanks for all of the advice on how hand positions affect a pianist's sound. Thanks for the video.
Nodame Cantabile is for me the number one in manga and anime for classical music. You are right, everyone should know Nodame Cantabile, specially those who are studying music. And about Your Lie in April, it is good as well, but the story is more focused in the drama and the cute Kaori than in the music itself. Yeah, you cry, but because of the cute Kaori and the heartbroken Kousei.
I loved the Nodame Cantabile anime from start to finish. Every season was so good. It reminds me of Maison Ikkoku with music playing as the center focus. Gya-bo!!
In Forest of Piano, his shoulders were bouncing so much because he didn't yet know how to play and was pounding the keys. The piano was magically producing music beyond his actual skill.
14:32 It didn't, once you see the whole episode you'll understand They played and because of his problem, i.e he can't hear dhat he's playing after he plays some of the piece. The place where you started watching was when they re-started playing the piece
Everyone is talking about You Lie in April but honestly, at out these, it was my least favourite. Nodame Cantabile is my ultimate favourite anime and it seriously got me consider to pick up piano. Piano no Mori is seriously underrated.
There's _always_ gonna be a bend in the wrist even if you try to keep them flat because your fingers are applying pressure to the keys. It's just biology. Specially in that downward side angle (because your forearm goes to a slope when you play the piano, si ce it's lowe that you, you can't exactly flat that down unless the piano's to you mid chest level). Also speaking as an animator.
Idk if you guys like jazz, but I highly suggest reacting to Kids on the Slope. The Animation is truly exceptional, never seen a musical anime with a better animation than KOTS (yet). I hope you guys will do a video about it, but if you don’t, it’s alright.
I gave this one a "Like", although I owe everyone still me watching "Your Lie in April". One thing that called my attention were the mostly rigid, stony facial expressions. A real pianist's face (even someone's who played as fully relaxed and focused as Arthur Rubinstein) is in constant, small motion. But I guess that this is difficult to achieve in Anime, even with the best software...? Very well observed, great job as always! :)
In Piano no mori kai was playing like that because it was old abandoned piano in the forest which was scustom made. He can't play normal piano. (I'm not pianist) I didn't like the anime but manga was one of the best for me.
I loved every song in Your Lie in April, but Winter Wind is my favorite of them all, of all the Chopin classics actually. It shows sadness and lonelyness soooo well.
Your lie in April girl with blonde playing violin has the same energy as a girl in my school when I was younger she also had blonde hair and had the same energy as the blonde girl in the anime tho she change school and spoiler alert The blonde girl dies in the anime it reminds me so much of the girl that was in my school I still remember her name Ashley she also nickname me and my friend It just reminded me so much of the violin girl
10:36 Yesss I watched your lie and April and cried all night then the next morning my eyes where burning because I didn’t wip my tears away I just left them, 😭 but it was worth it and worth the watch 😤🤚
Oh, you haven’t watched Your Lie in April, have you? The first half of the show focused on his mental and emotional trauma from his mother being verbally and emotionally abusive to make him be the best pianist ever. He was terrified of playing and couldn’t even hear his own playing. Kaori wanted him to accompany her and he was freaking out because of that, she was depending on him and he was scared of not being able to be relied on by someone he cared about.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 88 | คู่เอก "ป้อมเพชร vs อัสลามจอน"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1ZqTVVbMgbo/mqdefault.jpg)
Kousei couldn't hear what he was playing in that scene you watched. That's why he was sweating. Because he was like OG pianist until her mother died, thats why he wasnt able to hear his own music since then.
Damn that's harsh.
My bad she knows about the Anime.😂
@@ItachiUchiha-bi4if How much can you see?
@@indrajeetshinde7872 I see you lying at my feet. 🗿
Yea you tell them!!! You can tell they never finished your lie in april 😖
"it's just starting, why are u sweating"
kousei was almost sight reading and reviving his trauma 😩 i would be sweating too dude
also
this is after his "wake up", so they've had a first run of the piece already, he messed it up bad (by that point probably sweating) and now it's the 2nd run and he's purely imagining his sound for the first time, so that would require some amount of focus :D
Your Lie In April inspired me to play the piano and it's the best thing happened to me 😁
Literally leaned the ballade in 3 months afterwards but I do have a long way to go
@@d2kinu874 just keep it up man!
exactly the same for me i also was inspired by your lie in april therefore i also started playing the piano a few years ago😁
It gave me depression
Me too
I love how the your lie in april one is about details such as posture and hand placement because the rest is friggin perfect.
Too melodramatic. It's not one of my favorite romantic anime.
@@viharsarok why tf would you warch your lie in april to expect romance lmao. Thats like watching attack on titan and expecting comedy.
@@V1xtory What should I have expected? It was touted as a good (or even the best) romantic anime.
@@viharsarok where did you get those sources from? It’s very misleading. I don’t blame you though, i blame them.
@@V1xtory Recommendations in anime channels, YT comments, MAL recommendations etc. So what is it you think people should expect again?
Everyone’s talking about your lie in April, but I think forest of piano is so underrated 😢
Literally
Sameee. I just finished forest of piano and its was so wholesome! Kai smiling hits different man
@@Hi-tf3tj I agree, his playing style brings us too in the Forest
I love the show until it got to that one episode where there was violin playing and the bow was on the fingerboard 😭
@@acertainhuman9726 same as a violinist...lol 😂
The first piano anime I watched was in Your Lie in April, the Kreutzer Sonata.
Most accurate anime ever! (Not to mention the beautiful violinist)
I really love your lie in April,
But then Kaori died....
KAORI!!!!!!!!
It was a spoiler, but I don't really care since I don't watch anime :)
@@julianmarcusong5176 there are some really good ones out there lol just saying
@@beyondviolet ya i agree, i started watching anime a month ago, and i wasn't expecting such a beautiful story and animation.
Same here!
Your lie in april had real musicians performing piano+violin and then the animators copied their movements sometimes using a rotoscope.
Thats so cool. I didn't know that 😮
rotoscopes aren't objects, rotoscoping is an animation technique.
@@noakinn You are right, I made a mistake.
Your lies in April is a masterpiece
And i watched it 12 times and every time i love it
Its going off nexflix :(
The amount of emotional damage you can endured is truly respectable :)
@@phuongnamnguyen904 thanks bro
I appreciate your kindness
And now I completed my 14th time watching it
i tried watching it again multiole times but uts too sad for me to watch the whole thing again haha
@@rain3834 I understand your feelings bro. I also feel the same way 🥲
Just look at Twosetviolin video on her playing. They said that violinist was pretty accurate and they're critical on all violin playing lol.
Eddy said it is the best violin playing in the whole anime world and it shows that this reactors are not violinists.
I want to see them review the last song Kousei plays. (Chopin’s ballad in g minor number 1 op. 23) I’m obsessed! I picked up the violin again after years of not playing just so I can get to the point where I can play along to that song with kousei haha.
That is funny and apparently common as I felt the same way and was inspired to learn what I could on this Ballad..
Actually I started playing last sunday and The first thing i learned was Chopins ballad in g minor number 1 op.23 its just so beautiful
You go, girl!
@@BudgetKlee last sunday? Ballade needs like 8-10 years of experience to be played well lol
@@susabove Wth if you play good no,please just cause others cant do it it doesnt mean i cant bruh
Ironically people hated Piano no Mori (Forest Piano) because of its 3d animation lmao. I'm really happy that you appreciated as well as i the quality of the 3d while playing the pieces
You should really check out Kids on the Slope. It's more Jazz, but the main character starts off as a classically trained pianist. It's rotoscoped so the drumming animation and the piano playing are spot on. So amazing!
I love kids on the slope, severely underrated and we need more jazz piano anime specifically!!
Your lie in April is the most accurate in the violin, but the did really good on piano
I absolutely loved Forrest of Piano...I thought it was slightly disparaging on the Chinese participant though...but the description of the emotions and Kai's growth was really fun to watch.
The manga used to make me cry and it was magical to see it come to life as an anime more than two decades later.
Piano no Mori is my favourite of these
Well... Anime is very fun to observe, but live action Nodame Cantabile is truly a goldmine :)
It absolutely is ❤️❤️❤️❤️! - Michelle
Your lie and The piano in the forest are the reason I started learning piano. I am at 1 year of learning now
Piano no mori is just epic to me 😊
I love Your lie in April but the anime that made me start piano classes was the forest of piano and i love the 3d scenes
My Lie In April made me cry SO hard, I can't watch it ever again. Cheers from Finland. PS. I watch Nodame Cantebile anime once a year cos' it's THE BEST.
I'm just a karaoke host and singer BTW
I like Nodame Cantabile as well, both the manga and anime opened my music perspective.
Ryotaro's lack of wrist rotation in 'La Campanella' is one thing, but can we take a moment to appreciate his hair/jacket colour combo? Phew!
Last time I was this early I got yelled at by the conductor
xDDD
For the Nodame Cantabile scenes, I can say as an Animator who studies animation and loves classical music, those aren’t rotoscoped- those are CGI-ed similar to Forest Piano 🤣😅 Motion capture was created in 1919 and CGI was made in 1973 so it’s not surprising for Nodame Cantabile to be using this technology in the anime- which is absolutely awesome of course, taking into account and respecting classical music and it’s musicians in a way by this means.
Rotoscoping is mostly for 2D whilst CGI is used for 3D. Nodame used 3D so it’s CGI:D
Thank you for your insight! We love hearing from people in different fields! ☺️
I cried so much on "Your lie in April" bc at first I didn't understand why it's called that but I knew what it meant I started crying 😭
Why is called that
*I just googled it i also started crying
Im a violinist, and i can say that the violin in ylia was almost completely accurate. Thats a lot to say. Its probably even harder animating a violin, you need to put in the bow AND the fingering, you need to do the string changing, the shifts, the bow postitioning, bow direction, vibrato, bow techniques, aggresiveness of the playing and even the movement of the violinist to match the playing. Us violinists move A LOT while playing. And they did it all perfectly 👏
I was about to say the same! I was so amazed to see them making it so accurate
i used to play clarinet, and i couldn't stop laughing when i saw the mouthpiece was just sitting on their lips
just lie in april just hearing them play i wanna cry
Forest of Piano is probably one of my favourites. However, I'm a big Chopin fan, so... I may be a tad biased
Forest of piano is just too underrated
Your Lie In April really got my ass in gear to practice lol. I love how much care they put into all the animation of the instruments.
I cried watching you lie in april. but the music in zankyou no terror aka terror in resonance. had me feeling all existential crisis like...
Ah, so that's how you move your shoulders when playing minute waltz. Learning from anime, so educational xD
How dare these mortals make fun of/criticize arima kousei. Obviously I’m joking, but to be fair he’s insanely nervous and hasn’t played in years + he couldn’t hear the sound of his piano anymore…
I watched "Your Lie In April" and cried. Such a good show.
I also really enjoyed Forest of Piano.
They should watch your lie in April but the final performance:3
We wanted to but we also didn't want to pick content that might spoil things for those who haven't seen it ❤️
Gotta watch the rest of these animes for sure... 'Your lie in april' is a goat series hands down so im looking forward to the rest of these. and poor Kousei dont drag the poor boy he hasnt played in 2 years, cant hear the sound and was extremely nervious and traumatized 😢
Yeah I cried at YLIA. Not as much as Violet Evergarden, but it definitely hit hard at the end. I felt a connection with Kousei due to having lost the ability to play an instrument I had played for most of my life at that point. Watching the whole show felt like rubbing salt into an open wound, but at the same time, it was a beautiful experience.
I just discovered you guys a couple days ago and immiedietly started to feel strange connection to you, even though I have no experience with playing an intrument. I'm about to start playing the piano (actually I'm after my second lesson). keep it up guys, I feel very comfortable here. (sorry for my bad english!)
Your English is fine don’t worry 😁
@@ilikeudonnoodles oh, thank you! that means a lot for a non native english speaker.
You guys are amazing! It surprises me you guys have 1.7 k subs, you deserve much love. I love this channel so much.
I was saying "Ikr?" so many times throughout this video. Lol
Your lie april : accurate + no need CGI movement that why I love it
P /s : somepart really like dinosaur hands XD
I got spoiled so completely before I watched Your Lie in April.
I knew who had what secret, what was going to happen, to whom, when, what other characters were doing and where, and even what imagery was used to convey the event... so of course I bawled my eyes out all the same.
Nodame did wonders considering it was 11 years ago. I wish they rebooted it with better animation and the full manga storyline
100 times yes! I agree with this! I would totally watch the reboot! ❤️❤️❤️- Michelle
Didn't knew twoset piano exist
Your Lie in April is my favorite! I’m trying to learn Rachmaninov’s arr of liebesleid which is featured on episode 13
"Thumbs up if you watched 'Your Lie in April' and you cried" - ???? Thumbs up if you watched 'Your Lie in April' and you were able to keep yourself from crying!
By the way, thanks for all of the advice on how hand positions affect a pianist's sound. Thanks for the video.
Nodame Cantabile is for me the number one in manga and anime for classical music. You are right, everyone should know Nodame Cantabile, specially those who are studying music.
And about Your Lie in April, it is good as well, but the story is more focused in the drama and the cute Kaori than in the music itself. Yeah, you cry, but because of the cute Kaori and the heartbroken Kousei.
100% agree with you, homie
I 100% agree with you about Nodame Cantabile ❤️☺️. It's one of my favourite music inspired drama/manga! - Michelle
i share your sentiment when it comes to Nodame 😂, nothing can beat it
Kowri's death was so sad I totally cried
Me who never cried while watching your lie in April: :)
(I like piano no mori)
I loved the Nodame Cantabile anime from start to finish. Every season was so good. It reminds me of Maison Ikkoku with music playing as the center focus. Gya-bo!!
In Forest of Piano, his shoulders were bouncing so much because he didn't yet know how to play and was pounding the keys. The piano was magically producing music beyond his actual skill.
love nodame and LOVE how they did they live action. so good.
The first clip is actually amazing. All the right notes were hit!
14:32 It didn't, once you see the whole episode you'll understand
They played and because of his problem, i.e he can't hear dhat he's playing after he plays some of the piece. The place where you started watching was when they re-started playing the piece
Yeah, your lie in april was so much emotional and sad but I love de piano pieces.
Congrats on 1k subs!
Thank you! ❤️
loved the video. Been waiting for this one.
I cry every time that I watch YLIA!!! I haven’t been able to watch episode 20 (cat lover here), and then the last episode is absolutely heartbreaking…
Everyone is talking about You Lie in April but honestly, at out these, it was my least favourite. Nodame Cantabile is my ultimate favourite anime and it seriously got me consider to pick up piano. Piano no Mori is seriously underrated.
There's _always_ gonna be a bend in the wrist even if you try to keep them flat because your fingers are applying pressure to the keys. It's just biology. Specially in that downward side angle (because your forearm goes to a slope when you play the piano, si ce it's lowe that you, you can't exactly flat that down unless the piano's to you mid chest level). Also speaking as an animator.
The duke of his death and his maid also has piano playing parts
you need to review kousei's ballade in g minor
Idk if you guys like jazz, but I highly suggest reacting to Kids on the Slope. The Animation is truly exceptional, never seen a musical anime with a better animation than KOTS (yet). I hope you guys will do a video about it, but if you don’t, it’s alright.
It would been nice to see some staff of sakamichi no apollon here, to see other style of piano playing
love you guys
Thank you❤️ We love you too!
Don't worry, everyone does love classical music...they just don't know it lol.
Nodameeee!!! Amazing she started to play cause of Nodameeee!
Your lie in April is theeeeee bessssssttttt musical anime ever 🧡💛
I gave this one a "Like", although I owe everyone still me watching "Your Lie in April". One thing that called my attention were the mostly rigid, stony facial expressions. A real pianist's face (even someone's who played as fully relaxed and focused as Arthur Rubinstein) is in constant, small motion. But I guess that this is difficult to achieve in Anime, even with the best software...? Very well observed, great job as always! :)
i cried so hard from your lie in april
for YLIA, introduccion and rondo capriccioso:
that's their second go. the first time, the accompanist had a panic attack because of his trauma.
Exodus 20:7, Colossians 3:8-10, God bless ❤️
I loved forest piano so much🤪
Great show this week.
watching your lie in april when april comes to cry over Kaori again AND for inspiration to go practice
I love the choice of animes, though im surprised sakamichi no appolon didn't make it haha
yes this anime broke me IM more sensible since watching it
You should cover D. Gray-Man, musician’s score. Allen Walker is the character who plays the piano!
In Piano no mori kai was playing like that because it was old abandoned piano in the forest which was scustom made. He can't play normal piano.
(I'm not pianist)
I didn't like the anime but manga was one of the best for me.
Your lie in April I cried for 2 weeks
I loved every song in Your Lie in April, but Winter Wind is my favorite of them all, of all the Chopin classics actually. It shows sadness and lonelyness soooo well.
fuck yeah i cried when watching your lie in april
loves sorrow in your lie in april
You have to watch the full when you lie in april
Your lie in April girl with blonde playing violin has the same energy as a girl in my school when I was younger she also had blonde hair and had the same energy as the blonde girl in the anime tho she change school and spoiler alert
The blonde girl dies in the anime it reminds me so much of the girl that was in my school I still remember her name Ashley she also nickname me and my friend
It just reminded me so much of the violin girl
10:36
Yesss I watched your lie and April and cried all night then the next morning my eyes where burning because I didn’t wip my tears away I just left them, 😭 but it was worth it and worth the watch 😤🤚
Awesome vid! I wish you could've reacted to the piano duet scene from Evangelion 3.0 as well though! Have a good one!
You lie in April makes me cry but I absolutely love nodame contaible
4 words, ‘Kids on the slope’
try sakamichi no appolon or kids on the slope, its about jazz and the piano animation is the best ive seen in anime
cried alot in your lie in april
We all know why we are here. Hover over 10:45 and you will see it is the most replayed.
Oh, you haven’t watched Your Lie in April, have you? The first half of the show focused on his mental and emotional trauma from his mother being verbally and emotionally abusive to make him be the best pianist ever. He was terrified of playing and couldn’t even hear his own playing. Kaori wanted him to accompany her and he was freaking out because of that, she was depending on him and he was scared of not being able to be relied on by someone he cared about.
17:38 im whatching while practising 😂
Bro imagine nitpicking a traumatized mid-schooler's performance.
I needed this 🤣
Did you see Soul (2020)? I thought the piano animations there were amazing as well.
Check the keys bounce in super slow mo.
Hope you also watch Kids on The Slope and Takto Op. Both of them are quite accurate