Hey so I literally JUST added a couple super cool backing tracks to the Instant Piano Guide, so go get that and check them out, it's free so why not have a great time thank you enjoy ok bye: cornell.academy/instant-piano-guide-YLIA
Another Awesome anime video. Please could you do one on 'one piece? So much great music like aim for one piece, memories, gold and oden. Binks sake, Thanks
Have you looked at the music for ChronoTrigger or ChronoCross? I will keep commenting until I see these!!! Love your videos. Love the breakdowns. Keep up the great work!
as a violinist, I can say yes the animations for the violin playing is also spot on! This anime was actually one of the first ones I watched that made me get into the anime world :)
The thing I love about YLIA is not necessarily the drama or the accuracy of the playing, but the combination of the two. The backbreaking practicing, the anxiety in the back rooms before the ultimate zone you get into on stage, all of it was spot on. It definitely reached me 🙏
The difference between the backstage anxiety, to the zone on stage where it feels like 3 minutes has passed, then to the comedown, is always such a crazy ride of emotions. I'm just a dude in a band, nowhere near concert pianist level, but I can see how people get addicted to the feeling and fall into depressions between big performances.
I got my orchestra conductor friend to watch this with me, and he kept gushing about the context of the pieces chosen for each part of the show. He explained how certain pieces were “odd” or “interesting” choices for a competition, but in the context of what’s happening in the show… the back story of the composer, like Chopin, and how and when he composed it played as EXTRA backstory to what was happening in the anime. He said it was such a treat for music history nerds as well.
Y'know, I recently bought a collection of piano and violin sonatas by Mozart, and theres a near perfect match of the more complicated piano lines from the Twinkle Twinkle variations scene in Sonata No.23 in D major KV306. Im not sure if those lines are actually in the Mozart Variations or if it was an addition by Kousei, but it was a really cool thing to hear! I love YLIA ❤️ Edit: listened to both back to back, different key and different lines overall, but very similar shapes. Guess Mozart was stealing from the best; himself
This Anime should’ve been done in 60fps, it would’ve made especially the piano playing look super realistic, but sadly it wasn’t, but thankfully, you can just upscale it, playing it back on a modern TV with upscaling technology, or upscale it with AI upscaling software.
I recently RE-watched this one and while the “internal monologues” of the main character can sometimes seem like “I’m trying to write poetry into my character’s thought process” in a somewhat forced way, the overall story, animation, music, and EMOTION of it make it totally worth watching. You will cry C
The finger animation is actually rotoscoped. Meaning that there is a real life piano reference they used to make it look so accurate. If you want to see another well done musical rotoscope scene, check out the "God Knows" music scene from "The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya".
@@TheBaldrickk In theory sure, but you have to remember this is a frame by frame process. The Haruhi Suzumiya scene I referenced took several months to complete and that one was with static camera angles. You should note that all the camera shots with realistic and accurate hand motions in the Haruhi Suzumiya scene are completely still. I'm not in the animation industry, so I can't even wager to take a guess how they achieved the same rotoscoping effect with the camera in motion and that close to the players hands in Your Lie in April. BONUS TRIVIAL KNOWLEDGE: Rotoscoping can also be done in reverse to insert an animated effect into live action. If you have seen the original Star Wars trilogy, you have seen this effect in action as this is how Industrial Light and Magic created the light saber visual effects.
@@Syncr0w I thought for the light sabers, they went frame by frame scratching out the wooden stick props the actors were holding, and then re-captured the footage from the frames with the now transparent sabre blades lit from behind?
Not necessarily rotoscoped, but they definitely recorded the actual person playing in video and audio, and either rotoscoped that or just referenced it in excruciating detail. Only reason I say that is because the animation is definitely stylized a bit, so they didn't follow the real world motion exactly.
The anime is really good. I think the MC has some trauma‐induced pitch deafness. When he's relaxed, he can play extremely complex arrangements with ease and naturality, but when there are some of his triggers involved, or in particularly stressing situations, he stops hearing the notes. The animators did a brilliant move on the visualization of his symptoms: when it starts, the piano gets submerged, and suddenly, he's playing underwater, with muffled, dampened notes and bubbles rising from between keys. I remember crying a lot when I watched it.
I cried so hard watching this anime... a really beautiful story. The fact that the animation was accurate here just helped keep me immersed. I find when music performance imagery is off I suddenly realize "oh, I'm watching a cartoon" so I think the extra effort was worth it... for sure
As I remember the animation uses a technique called Rotoscoping where real piano and player is used then animated over , if its done well you cant tell which are which. The Pianist is Yuta Matsumura. So you are already familiar with Yoko Kanno would be good to see more of her catalogue to react to, however another favorite is Kenji Kawai
FINALLY. Been waiting for this one for YEARS. This series helped me cope with the death of my college piano professor (who passed away suddenly at the age of 54 from a massive heart attack while doing yoga, of all things). He lived an extremely healthy lifestyle so it was completely unexpected. We became so close that I began to view him as the father that I never had. I didn’t touch the piano for four years after he passed away. This series taught me that I’m not alone.
With this anime it definitely matters that it is correct! There's so much emotional importance to the piano playing and the fact you can clearly see him play immerses you into the story so much you won't stop crying. One of the best anime series in my opinion.
I 100% agree that it matters. Perhaps to the casual viewer it matters less but seeing correctness just adds a layer that everyone can appreciate. And when you get to see your own instrument animated so accurately to match the anime plot which focuses SO much on Kousei being this perfect robot performer with perfect accuracy.. It needs to be done and I wish more shows about music would put an emphasis on accuracy. To the musicians watching it really elevates everything about it.
@@scopie49 Yes! Also we didn't talk about the nuances in his play, when Kousei struggles with the tempo etc. The fact you can hear that in the performances they recorded is so amazing. I will rewatch it soon. I get goosebumps only thinking about that anime. It's crazy. :D
@@MaxxMcGeePrivate I'd love to give it a re-watch but I don't think I could handle the emotional roller coaster and knowing how it ends. A second time going through that is like being a glutton for punishment.
It's PHENOMENAL how accurate this, this is so accurate, and even the rebounds like WHAT, you can literally not see that, such a small attention to details, IT'S PERFECT! ❤
This show is immaculate in almost every way. It has a lot of that anime drama, sure, but in context of the plot it really draws you into the pain the kids need to go through to become this good at playing
Not only that.. the pain of lost love, be it that of a parent fighting for their lives, aching to leave with the tools to survive or that of losing a dear friend or soulmate.. it hits you right in the feels like no other medium can.. also, the beautiful banter and friendships wrapped in Japanese culture is just soothing and pleasant to watch..
I love when this anime get’s some recognition. The story was interesting and the ending emotional. But the way it brought light to some amazing classical pieces was a joy. I would never have known of Chopin’s Ballad in G minor which is one of my favourite piano pieces to date. And as a terrible self-taught piano player, it’s so hard to learn and play!
well YLIA it's one of the most well loved and recognized anime, so I wouldn't say it needs recognition but yea, It ignited a love for classical music in me that it's on to this day 8 years after it's aired
This is one of the reasons why i love this anime. The animation, the story, the voice acting, everything about it is so wonderful. Glad you shared your take on this, Charles. 🥰
trying.. not.. to cry!... Thank you for reviewing the music in this one! it's a stunning anime that really had an impact on me. Without giving too much away, the blonde girl (Kaori Miyazono) helps black-haired boy (Kousei Arima) through emotional trauma that made him stop playing piano. it's a deep and emotional story that is beautiful and sad. Captivating and devastating. For me, it's a masterpiece that made me love music even more.
Honestly, this show got me into classical music 7-8 years ago, this was my 2nd ever anime. I didn't really have a piano or violin back then, so i self taught myself the guitar. Classical pieces are hard to play, but they are so worth it the moment you learn to play them correctly, then later play them in your style! For me YLIA is one of the best animes to exist. Thank you for reviewing the musical accuracy of this masterpiece, hope you watch it!
Fun fact: The people who played for piano and violin are actually professionals and have competed before. All violin are played by Yuna Shinohara and most of piano pieces are played by Tomoki Sakata and other pianists are Eriko Kawachi and Taiji Koga.
Your lie in april is such a great story and only 24 episodes, no spoilers but it makes you feel so much, i still tear up when i hear the opening theme, words aren't enough, 10/10 would recommend
I love this anime so much. The story goes really deep and gets a dark turn. But yes it exaggerates everything including some silly moments that are weird for non anime fans :p but you'll get used to it and it'll suck you in, as if you can almost feel the emotion the pianist is going through ♡
Your lie in april is one of the animes I recommend to anyone that hasn't watched anime. Its incredible even to non musicians, but even better if youre in the scene, and have experience with performing!
This is a perfect example of why so many get really into anime, and even more into certain studios or directors etc. etc. for the shear dedication to the fine minute details
That one has as close to 100% accurate depictions of concert band instrument fingerings of any anime I've ever seen. Plus, it's my favorite all-time anime, and I'm a tubist and euphonist. I love that the least recognized brass voice in a concert band has the spotlight on it in this title.
@@Mahomie_15 It's one of my all-time favourites, too. I'm no musician, but the characters and their struggles ring true. There's a great video about it, called 'How warm it sounds' by Under the Scope. Do you know the Kyoto Tachibana SHS Band? As the anime is by KyoAni, it might have been an inspiration. There are great video of the SHS Band on YT.
@@bastiangugu4083 I do know about Kyoto Tachibana SHS, along with other high school marching bands from Japan, mostly from the Rose Bowl parades in which the parade committee almost always includes one marching band from Japan in their lineup. Also, watching them on TH-cam from time to time. Their marching style is even more active than even HBCU bands, and that blows my mind as a veteran Sousaphone player during marching season in a "PWI" or Corps-style band in high school and college.
@@kaitlyn__L Just do it. 🙂 Seriously, it's great. A very nice video about the series by 'under the scope' named How warm it sounds can be found here on YT.
One of my all time favourites. I loved this series. Its touching, inspiring and detailed. It actually got me back into playing the piano after a long break that I took because of my grieving process.
It is impresive. I mean, even in movies they just tell the actor to press keys randomly and they put the music over it. To take the time (and in animation it is TIME) to accurately show the right notes is amazing.
Tomoki Sakata did the recordings for this piece, along with Yuna Shinohara on violin. Sakata got to the finals of the Queen Elizabeth competition in 2021! What I find most amazing about this anime is how the OST recordings differ from the ones used in the anime. For instance, there are moments when the main character is shown to be rushing (due to his inability to hear his own notes) and that's reflected in the music itself, it literally speeds up and is more clunky. The direction on these recordings were very attentive to detail as well, not just the animation!
Charles doing his best not to laugh out loud at the melodrama of this show (and anime) LOL, this show definitely is thick on the drama but i enjoy it. All good, definitely out of context it's really silly (and in context it can be funny how serious it is) lololol
@@ronhutcherson9845 That’s all subjective though. I prefer dubs in most contexts and don’t find them grating at all. It’s fine if you prefer the Japanese audio, but it’s bold if you to make sweeping pronouncements about what is an enjoyable experience for others.
This anime is one of the main reasons why I love classical so much, they always had great peices that went well with the plot and it really immersed me into the anime and music. This isnt an anime I have watched recently but it is my number one favorite show and i have watched it countless times. There are not many things I suggest watching but this is something I'll suggest until watched.
Getting pushed to watch this show in high school literally pushed me into getting into pianos with how great it does to show the emotion that goes into playing instruments. Still my favourite musical animes.
Loved this anime before but you have made really appreciate it on a whole other level. Thank you and thank you to everyone involved in making this anime
“Anticipation” is one of the principles of animation. Those keys moving before the fingers hit them will help keep things from feeling more rigid especially at the frames per second that animation uses. If you were going to film this you would probably go 60fps or more and then manipulate the motion blur for a similar effect.
What’s really crazy is that everything is drawn by hand, that - along with the direction - just gives you another perspective on the talent and effort it takes to make such a masterpiece.
This is exactly why I love sports anime. And while this isn't sports, it has the same accuracy and beautiful animations. How light their hands are while playing, the bounce of the keys, it's all so beautiful 😭😭😭
Hey! is good to see that you are reviewing my favorite Anime, literally this Anime made me find out that I wanted to dedicate my life to music. The music of this Anime is incredible, and I'm not talking only about the classical music, I'm also talking about its original score, which pushed me to wanting to become a composer. I would really like if you could review it as well.
This anime is just perfection the plot itself is heartbreaking and they give every character some development also the animation is correct as someone who plays both the violin and piano they animated every single part correctly
I feel like they hired a real pianist as a reference for the animation, I really appreciate the amount of effort they put into this and I really mind if instruments plays the right note in anime as someone who knows musical instruments too. And also great review! Thanks for putting up a video like this ^_^
This stpry is so rich and beautiful. Made me fall in love with orchestral music. Also, not really Piano related, but Oshi no Ko has a phenomenal opening and ending song.
To answer your question, the pianists for the show are Tomoki Sakata and Eriko Kawachi. I don't know anything beyond their names and I'm not sure if there are any recordings of them playing for the OST, but since I know you talked about Kids on the Slope as well, there's definitely footage of the pianist and drummers recording for the show floating around somewhere online. I used to have the blu-ray for the show and it came with a behind-the-scenes video of the recording and rotoscoping process so maybe someone's uploaded it.
I’m just here to comment on how excited Charles is getting over one of my favorite anime (Your Lie In April) And to hear him describe music the exact same way I do (“itching that part of your brain”)
Looks to me like the piano is 3d rendered. The hands might be as well (with a hand drawn rendering style), or possibly they're hand drawn but traced over the 3d rendering.
@@dunerat42 that would be rotoscoping, which is where animators draw over filmed footage and use that as a base to drive their actual poses/frames. This is most certainly the technique used in YLiA as well as having all the reference footage of players actually playing the pieces to guide the animation. None of that means any of what's seen is any less impressive or any less insanely time and effort consuming to do
This was one of the first few anime that I ever watched over a decade ago, and I really need to rewatch it now that I've seen many more anime and have a deeper understanding of the music that it showcased.
I loved watching your reaction to these scenes!! This anime is really something special and it’s more of an experience than anything. I just finished Trigun Stampede and there’s a couple scenes I’d love to see your reaction to when it comes to the piano! A beautiful piece is played in that show a couple times and I think you’d really enjoy it!
The love and attention that went into this show is what elevated. And I agree I watched more for the beautiful piano section than the actual story. Though dont get me wrong the story its self though simple is fantastically told. Heartbreaking. Lastly such a shame you only teased us with the Twinkle Twinkle little star part. One of my favorite pieces to listen to.
I highly recommended the whole anime !! The context here is emotional. Everyone there has something to overcame, and something that they wanna show to others. A feeling that they wanna share with the world. The overreactions feel surprisingly immerisive while you're actually watching the whole show
As an animator, my assumptions is that they had a 3D model of the piano that would play the song (with the little piano keys bouncing included). Then they recorded someone actually playing the song at different camera angles to the music, matched the camera angles to the 3D model, and then they drew each hand frame on top of that (also known as rotoscoping). The truth is that, with traditional hand-drawn 2D animation, a piano and the innerworkings of the piano are incredibly difficult to draw let alone animate. It's simply too complicated and would require a lot of people and/or time to animate it frame-by-frame. Perhaps it may be possible with a high-budget movie, but the camerawork of this TV series is so complex with such a detailed piano that it looks to be 3D-animated to me, and I'm pretty sure the hands are rotoscoped. You'll notice in things like the Tom and Jerry piano cartoon (which is all hand-drawn) that they use angles that can reuse animations of the piano keys falling down (or sometimes they don't show the piano keys at all). They don't have the camera move dynamically on purpose because that would be so difficult to animate by hand. As for the frames looking strange, that's likely the result of video interpolation, which was probably by the person who uploaded the video onto TH-cam or TH-cam itself. Usually the frames of an animation runs at 24 frames per second (and this depends on region and country, of course), but when the video codec is at 30 fps or 60 fps, it can cause wonky stuff to happen. Also, the video itself may be running at 24 fps while the animation is running at 12 fps, or on twos. What's likely is that they had both the background (piano) and the foreground (hand) run at 12 fps but on different frames, so when the background moves on Frame 1, for example, it will pause for two frames until Frame 3. Then they would have the foreground moving on Frame 2 and pause until Frame 4. This gives an illusion of running at 24 fps while simultaneously taking half the work to draw or half the time to render. With the complexity of the 24 fps running on opposing frames, interpolating the footage in any way would cause it to be very wonky. That being said, this scene has a lot of attention to detail to have a 3D model of a piano simulated to play the exact notes played by the musician. Pretty cool stuff!
You should also break down the instrument fingering animations in Hibike! Euphonium. They are ALL spot-on, every instrument, every time. It's insane, and it's my favorite anime of all time, being a band geek.
Oh there's definitely context for why it's all so dramatic and emotional lol. You should watch the series, it's all one season so easy to binge, and you will feel all the emotions 😅
great vid as always! Quick note about the "frames blending into each other". That's not how it looks like in the original uncrompressed video of the animation 😄 to me that looks like a very common video framerate conversion error from the original 23.976fps to probably something like 30fps ✨ oh and frame blending is rarely an intentional choice in 2D animation. If at all, it's mainly due either the animator wants to make things more smooth with the easiest and worst looking method or it's used as an intentional dramatic effect like slomotion and simulation of a high shutter speed of real cameras.
I have a habit of looking at the fingers of pianists in movies, animations, etc. to see if they are playing to see if they are playing the correct notes. Super impressed at the level of accuracy and detail of the pianists in this anime.
I'm not Violonist but Animator and I can tell that this animation of the violon is absolutely stunning, even more impressive than the Piano ! It's incredibly hard to animate and those guys just gave us a lesson.
Seeing this man be so happy about one of my favorite animes made my day! Also the show is good, and I definitely reccomend it if you're willing to cry from an anime
That shot of the internals of the Steinway looks like a top-down shot of an actual performance of the piece (at least that section) but warped and stylized in a way that you can merge it into a scene and its not too jarring but you retain the accuracy of the visuals. Also I wonder what their arrangement was with Steinway to have so much product placement lol
Glad to see that you're checking out the animation on this show! other than the music, and visuals; the story itself is pretty nice! just watch out for spoilers if you plan on watching it; it's a decent 8/10 Anime (some even give it a 9/10 or 10/10)
I hope you consider watching the entire anime... it's one of my favorites of all time. It has some campy comedy... but it's probably one of the best dramas ever animated... and I'm weeping as I type this because of the emotional impact it had on me as a musician and artist.
Your Lie In April might be my favorite series, since it reverberates so deep in my soul.. Please allow yourself to watch this show; it is simply beautiful and a heart-wrenching story.. it won't leave you untouched.. trust us on this one
the concerts were what got me to sit through the painful and sad moments of this anime. its pretty much like oh god these people are getting so heartbroken...but its ok, theres gonna be an incredible concert after this!
When looking at anime as an outsider who hasn’t really dove in and given it a chance it DEFINITELY seems OVERLY dramatic and melodramatic and well… that’s because it IS. The strange part is that, after watching a few different shows (in Japanese dub, in particular, so you can avoid the mostly cringe English VO) you come to completely accept the drama of it and even love it. It becomes completely normal to you. I truly think there’s an anime out there for everyone. “A Silent Voice” is probably the first one I would show any non-anime watching adult. I’m 33 and have been watching anime since Pokémon was first airing in the US lol (for context).
i left my 2D animation course last year for illustration, because as much as i love animation for all its intricacies i just don't have it in me mentally to do this much technical work. This is absolutely crazy especially since they're drawing HANDS 12 times a second, in strange positions and angles, and it's all so accurate. Add everything you said to that- and let's not even think about animating the piano itself in so much detail. Blows my mind lol
Good one - as a pianist i got hooked onto this show so hard that i watched it in one sitting. Watch out for the die hards though because apparently theres another show that this one mimics and folks love to tell you how “ThAtS nOt ThE oRiGiNaL”.
as someone who doesnt really watch anime either I highly recommend your lie in april it's short and incredibly beautiful and a huge part of it is about passion in music and classical musicians that resonates a lot with any musician imo
4:19 It's actually a common technique in animation, to have effects happen *before* the cause, especially in simulation VFX. I don't know if there's a name for it, but I've seen it a couple times here and there.
Hey Charles, I highly recommend the choral music by Christopher Tin for his Civilization games and some of his other work. Its really great and I think you would find it really interesting. I recommend the pieces: Sogno di Volare, Baba Yetu and Waloyo Yamoni. they are all amazing and I'm sure there are other amazing pieces as well.
There's another anime named Kids on the Slope, where music also plays a major role. There's multiple scenes of musicians being accurately animated and it's incredible. I'm almost certain it's a forerunner to Your Lie in April, because you can definitely tell much of the budget went into those animations - whereas in Your Lie In April, accurate depiction of music isn't a priority, it's just an added bonus.
2:25 that's probably just an interpolated frame from the original animation being compressed and uncompressed onto TH-cam. Not an actual frame of the animation
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR COVERING MY FAVORITE ANIME OF ALL TIME, CHARLES!!! ❤❤❤❤❤ Edit: Also, I watched some of the behind the scenes footage of how they were able to recreate perfect piano (and all instruments played) in the anime. Put simply, they put musicians into mocap suits and tracked their movements and fingerings as they played, and the animators did the rest. It’s beautiful!
It certainly looked like they did mo-cap or watched a lot of video of musicians playing their instruments. They did a good job making it look accurate without looking TOO perfect. If that makes sense.
Hey so I literally JUST added a couple super cool backing tracks to the Instant Piano Guide, so go get that and check them out, it's free so why not have a great time thank you enjoy ok bye: cornell.academy/instant-piano-guide-YLIA
Hmm, I wonder if a musical analysis of the "Given" soundtrack is coming up anytime soon...
Another Awesome anime video. Please could you do one on 'one piece? So much great music like aim for one piece, memories, gold and oden. Binks sake, Thanks
Have you looked at the music for ChronoTrigger or ChronoCross? I will keep commenting until I see these!!! Love your videos. Love the breakdowns. Keep up the great work!
Not sure if you guys heard
RIP
Astrud Gilberto
Have you watch the anime? It is so beautiful.
as a violinist, I can say yes the animations for the violin playing is also spot on! This anime was actually one of the first ones I watched that made me get into the anime world :)
Same here, one of my favorites by far!
I thought it was very good but like most anime way too overdramatic lol
@@RobinsMusic what's the point of not making it overdramatic for a dramatic scene lol
I think I remember twoset checking it out as well, cool to hear that it's so well done!
imo it looks a bit weird at times but mostly very good
The thing I love about YLIA is not necessarily the drama or the accuracy of the playing, but the combination of the two. The backbreaking practicing, the anxiety in the back rooms before the ultimate zone you get into on stage, all of it was spot on. It definitely reached me 🙏
It reached me as well
The difference between the backstage anxiety, to the zone on stage where it feels like 3 minutes has passed, then to the comedown, is always such a crazy ride of emotions.
I'm just a dude in a band, nowhere near concert pianist level, but I can see how people get addicted to the feeling and fall into depressions between big performances.
I got my orchestra conductor friend to watch this with me, and he kept gushing about the context of the pieces chosen for each part of the show. He explained how certain pieces were “odd” or “interesting” choices for a competition, but in the context of what’s happening in the show… the back story of the composer, like Chopin, and how and when he composed it played as EXTRA backstory to what was happening in the anime. He said it was such a treat for music history nerds as well.
thats really cool!
Im so sad I didnt know music history to know that when I first watched it! Guess Im studying music history now lol
@@abigaildiamante9096wow really nice, an anime wrote for musicians basically
Y'know, I recently bought a collection of piano and violin sonatas by Mozart, and theres a near perfect match of the more complicated piano lines from the Twinkle Twinkle variations scene in Sonata No.23 in D major KV306. Im not sure if those lines are actually in the Mozart Variations or if it was an addition by Kousei, but it was a really cool thing to hear! I love YLIA ❤️
Edit: listened to both back to back, different key and different lines overall, but very similar shapes. Guess Mozart was stealing from the best; himself
Has he viewed Forest of Piano?
Glad he’s finally checking this out
This Anime should’ve been done in 60fps, it would’ve made especially the piano playing look super realistic, but sadly it wasn’t, but thankfully, you can just upscale it, playing it back on a modern TV with upscaling technology, or upscale it with AI upscaling software.
You wouldn't regret watching this one. Really good story and it's not very long either. The music is AMAZING!
One of my absolute favourite animes.
@@SCHTRAM Extremely melodramatic and relatively forced but not a regretful watch whatsoever
@@TheUnderscore_ never watched but I agree lol, I'm sure the story is great tho
I recently RE-watched this one and while the “internal monologues” of the main character can sometimes seem like “I’m trying to write poetry into my character’s thought process” in a somewhat forced way, the overall story, animation, music, and EMOTION of it make it totally worth watching.
You will cry C
You definitely should!
The finger animation is actually rotoscoped. Meaning that there is a real life piano reference they used to make it look so accurate. If you want to see another well done musical rotoscope scene, check out the "God Knows" music scene from "The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya".
Well, more like motion capture and a 3d toon shader, similar to how most dance scenes in all the recent idol anime shows are done.
With that, it's probably EASIER to do it right than to come up with your own animation of playing it
@@TheBaldrickk In theory sure, but you have to remember this is a frame by frame process. The Haruhi Suzumiya scene I referenced took several months to complete and that one was with static camera angles. You should note that all the camera shots with realistic and accurate hand motions in the Haruhi Suzumiya scene are completely still. I'm not in the animation industry, so I can't even wager to take a guess how they achieved the same rotoscoping effect with the camera in motion and that close to the players hands in Your Lie in April.
BONUS TRIVIAL KNOWLEDGE:
Rotoscoping can also be done in reverse to insert an animated effect into live action. If you have seen the original Star Wars trilogy, you have seen this effect in action as this is how Industrial Light and Magic created the light saber visual effects.
@@Syncr0w I thought for the light sabers, they went frame by frame scratching out the wooden stick props the actors were holding, and then re-captured the footage from the frames with the now transparent sabre blades lit from behind?
Not necessarily rotoscoped, but they definitely recorded the actual person playing in video and audio, and either rotoscoped that or just referenced it in excruciating detail. Only reason I say that is because the animation is definitely stylized a bit, so they didn't follow the real world motion exactly.
The anime is really good. I think the MC has some trauma‐induced pitch deafness. When he's relaxed, he can play extremely complex arrangements with ease and naturality, but when there are some of his triggers involved, or in particularly stressing situations, he stops hearing the notes. The animators did a brilliant move on the visualization of his symptoms: when it starts, the piano gets submerged, and suddenly, he's playing underwater, with muffled, dampened notes and bubbles rising from between keys. I remember crying a lot when I watched it.
You are right about that he did have a trauma a big one
I cried so hard watching this anime... a really beautiful story. The fact that the animation was accurate here just helped keep me immersed. I find when music performance imagery is off I suddenly realize "oh, I'm watching a cartoon" so I think the extra effort was worth it... for sure
Title?
@@AllanBenzon Your Lie in April
@@AllanBenzon Your Lie in April
As I remember the animation uses a technique called Rotoscoping where real piano and player is used then animated over , if its done well you cant tell which are which. The Pianist is Yuta Matsumura.
So you are already familiar with Yoko Kanno would be good to see more of her catalogue to react to, however another favorite is Kenji Kawai
FINALLY. Been waiting for this one for YEARS. This series helped me cope with the death of my college piano professor (who passed away suddenly at the age of 54 from a massive heart attack while doing yoga, of all things). He lived an extremely healthy lifestyle so it was completely unexpected. We became so close that I began to view him as the father that I never had. I didn’t touch the piano for four years after he passed away. This series taught me that I’m not alone.
Oh my, I am so sorry for your loss, I can't believe nobody else has taken notice to this comment. I'm happy to hear that Your Lie In April helped
Oooooof that's hard. Have you managed to return to the keyboard?
With this anime it definitely matters that it is correct! There's so much emotional importance to the piano playing and the fact you can clearly see him play immerses you into the story so much you won't stop crying. One of the best anime series in my opinion.
I 100% agree that it matters. Perhaps to the casual viewer it matters less but seeing correctness just adds a layer that everyone can appreciate. And when you get to see your own instrument animated so accurately to match the anime plot which focuses SO much on Kousei being this perfect robot performer with perfect accuracy.. It needs to be done and I wish more shows about music would put an emphasis on accuracy. To the musicians watching it really elevates everything about it.
@@scopie49 Yes! Also we didn't talk about the nuances in his play, when Kousei struggles with the tempo etc.
The fact you can hear that in the performances they recorded is so amazing.
I will rewatch it soon. I get goosebumps only thinking about that anime. It's crazy. :D
@@MaxxMcGeePrivate I'd love to give it a re-watch but I don't think I could handle the emotional roller coaster and knowing how it ends. A second time going through that is like being a glutton for punishment.
This story is a true ambassador for how Anime can touch the human soul deeper than any live action could..
Absolutely!@@hvanmegen
It's PHENOMENAL how accurate this, this is so accurate, and even the rebounds like WHAT, you can literally not see that, such a small attention to details, IT'S PERFECT! ❤
This show is immaculate in almost every way. It has a lot of that anime drama, sure, but in context of the plot it really draws you into the pain the kids need to go through to become this good at playing
Not only that.. the pain of lost love, be it that of a parent fighting for their lives, aching to leave with the tools to survive or that of losing a dear friend or soulmate.. it hits you right in the feels like no other medium can.. also, the beautiful banter and friendships wrapped in Japanese culture is just soothing and pleasant to watch..
I love when this anime get’s some recognition. The story was interesting and the ending emotional. But the way it brought light to some amazing classical pieces was a joy. I would never have known of Chopin’s Ballad in G minor which is one of my favourite piano pieces to date. And as a terrible self-taught piano player, it’s so hard to learn and play!
I've never watched this show, but I see occasional references to it such as here. The movie 'The Pianist' and Horowitz brought me to that piece.
well YLIA it's one of the most well loved and recognized anime, so I wouldn't say it needs recognition
but yea, It ignited a love for classical music in me that it's on to this day 8 years after it's aired
This is one of the reasons why i love this anime. The animation, the story, the voice acting, everything about it is so wonderful. Glad you shared your take on this, Charles. 🥰
trying.. not.. to cry!... Thank you for reviewing the music in this one! it's a stunning anime that really had an impact on me. Without giving too much away, the blonde girl (Kaori Miyazono) helps black-haired boy (Kousei Arima) through emotional trauma that made him stop playing piano.
it's a deep and emotional story that is beautiful and sad. Captivating and devastating. For me, it's a masterpiece that made me love music even more.
Honestly, this show got me into classical music 7-8 years ago, this was my 2nd ever anime. I didn't really have a piano or violin back then, so i self taught myself the guitar. Classical pieces are hard to play, but they are so worth it the moment you learn to play them correctly, then later play them in your style!
For me YLIA is one of the best animes to exist. Thank you for reviewing the musical accuracy of this masterpiece, hope you watch it!
Fun fact: The people who played for piano and violin are actually professionals and have competed before. All violin are played by Yuna Shinohara and most of piano pieces are played by Tomoki Sakata and other pianists are Eriko Kawachi and Taiji Koga.
Obviously they have to be professional. No amature can play this stuff
Your lie in april is such a great story and only 24 episodes, no spoilers but it makes you feel so much, i still tear up when i hear the opening theme, words aren't enough, 10/10 would recommend
I love this anime so much. The story goes really deep and gets a dark turn. But yes it exaggerates everything including some silly moments that are weird for non anime fans :p but you'll get used to it and it'll suck you in, as if you can almost feel the emotion the pianist is going through ♡
Your lie in april is one of the animes I recommend to anyone that hasn't watched anime. Its incredible even to non musicians, but even better if youre in the scene, and have experience with performing!
This is a perfect example of why so many get really into anime, and even more into certain studios or directors etc. etc. for the shear dedication to the fine minute details
Not piano-centric, but 'Sound Euphonium' has some of the most accurate depictions of a brass band playing, and it's a great anime too.
That one has as close to 100% accurate depictions of concert band instrument fingerings of any anime I've ever seen. Plus, it's my favorite all-time anime, and I'm a tubist and euphonist. I love that the least recognized brass voice in a concert band has the spotlight on it in this title.
@@Mahomie_15 It's one of my all-time favourites, too. I'm no musician, but the characters and their struggles ring true.
There's a great video about it, called 'How warm it sounds' by Under the Scope. Do you know the Kyoto Tachibana SHS Band? As the anime is by KyoAni, it might have been an inspiration. There are great video of the SHS Band on YT.
@@bastiangugu4083 I do know about Kyoto Tachibana SHS, along with other high school marching bands from Japan, mostly from the Rose Bowl parades in which the parade committee almost always includes one marching band from Japan in their lineup. Also, watching them on TH-cam from time to time. Their marching style is even more active than even HBCU bands, and that blows my mind as a veteran Sousaphone player during marching season in a "PWI" or Corps-style band in high school and college.
Been meaning to watch that for like 10 years.
@@kaitlyn__L Just do it. 🙂 Seriously, it's great. A very nice video about the series by 'under the scope' named How warm it sounds can be found here on YT.
One of my all time favourites. I loved this series. Its touching, inspiring and detailed. It actually got me back into playing the piano after a long break that I took because of my grieving process.
This is the ONLY anime that my hubby has ever been able to get me to watch lol. I actually loved it.
So glad you covered this. The animation is just as good as the music
It is impresive. I mean, even in movies they just tell the actor to press keys randomly and they put the music over it. To take the time (and in animation it is TIME) to accurately show the right notes is amazing.
Tomoki Sakata did the recordings for this piece, along with Yuna Shinohara on violin. Sakata got to the finals of the Queen Elizabeth competition in 2021!
What I find most amazing about this anime is how the OST recordings differ from the ones used in the anime. For instance, there are moments when the main character is shown to be rushing (due to his inability to hear his own notes) and that's reflected in the music itself, it literally speeds up and is more clunky. The direction on these recordings were very attentive to detail as well, not just the animation!
Charles doing his best not to laugh out loud at the melodrama of this show (and anime) LOL, this show definitely is thick on the drama but i enjoy it. All good, definitely out of context it's really silly (and in context it can be funny how serious it is) lololol
And those falsetto English voice dubs are grating on the ears. It’s much better to use subtitles and the Japanese audio.
@@ronhutcherson9845 That’s all subjective though. I prefer dubs in most contexts and don’t find them grating at all. It’s fine if you prefer the Japanese audio, but it’s bold if you to make sweeping pronouncements about what is an enjoyable experience for others.
This anime is one of the main reasons why I love classical so much, they always had great peices that went well with the plot and it really immersed me into the anime and music.
This isnt an anime I have watched recently but it is my number one favorite show and i have watched it countless times.
There are not many things I suggest watching but this is something I'll suggest until watched.
Getting pushed to watch this show in high school literally pushed me into getting into pianos with how great it does to show the emotion that goes into playing instruments. Still my favourite musical animes.
Loved this anime before but you have made really appreciate it on a whole other level. Thank you and thank you to everyone involved in making this anime
I love how this is as much a review of the animation as it is the music!
“Anticipation” is one of the principles of animation. Those keys moving before the fingers hit them will help keep things from feeling more rigid especially at the frames per second that animation uses. If you were going to film this you would probably go 60fps or more and then manipulate the motion blur for a similar effect.
What’s really crazy is that everything is drawn by hand, that - along with the direction - just gives you another perspective on the talent and effort it takes to make such a masterpiece.
This is exactly why I love sports anime. And while this isn't sports, it has the same accuracy and beautiful animations.
How light their hands are while playing, the bounce of the keys, it's all so beautiful 😭😭😭
Hey! is good to see that you are reviewing my favorite Anime, literally this Anime made me find out that I wanted to dedicate my life to music. The music of this Anime is incredible, and I'm not talking only about the classical music, I'm also talking about its original score, which pushed me to wanting to become a composer. I would really like if you could review it as well.
This anime is just perfection the plot itself is heartbreaking and they give every character some development also the animation is correct as someone who plays both the violin and piano they animated every single part correctly
I feel like they hired a real pianist as a reference for the animation, I really appreciate the amount of effort they put into this and I really mind if instruments plays the right note in anime as someone who knows musical instruments too.
And also great review! Thanks for putting up a video like this ^_^
This stpry is so rich and beautiful. Made me fall in love with orchestral music.
Also, not really Piano related, but Oshi no Ko has a phenomenal opening and ending song.
I started watching this after seeing this video. You would enjoy the hell out of it being a musician. For me, it feels like home
I've watched this anime already, but after seeing how much work has been put in to make everything accurate, I'm going to binge watch it again!
This some is definitely one of my favorites, and the accuracy of the instruments is probably a big reason why.
To answer your question, the pianists for the show are Tomoki Sakata and Eriko Kawachi. I don't know anything beyond their names and I'm not sure if there are any recordings of them playing for the OST, but since I know you talked about Kids on the Slope as well, there's definitely footage of the pianist and drummers recording for the show floating around somewhere online. I used to have the blu-ray for the show and it came with a behind-the-scenes video of the recording and rotoscoping process so maybe someone's uploaded it.
The series is definitely worth a watch, one of my favourite series
I’m just here to comment on how excited Charles is getting over one of my favorite anime (Your Lie In April)
And to hear him describe music the exact same way I do (“itching that part of your brain”)
In todays episode, Charles discovers the powers of motion capture animation
Maybe I’m an old man, but how is it possible to do motion capture on 2D animation ?? 😅
Looks to me like the piano is 3d rendered. The hands might be as well (with a hand drawn rendering style), or possibly they're hand drawn but traced over the 3d rendering.
@@LaurieCheers I mean it's still a lot of work to do.
@@dunerat42 that would be rotoscoping, which is where animators draw over filmed footage and use that as a base to drive their actual poses/frames. This is most certainly the technique used in YLiA as well as having all the reference footage of players actually playing the pieces to guide the animation. None of that means any of what's seen is any less impressive or any less insanely time and effort consuming to do
@@thebesposeidon Piano's animation is a mix of 3D and 2D
Merci to the musicians and the graphic artists for this masterpiece.
This was one of the first few anime that I ever watched over a decade ago, and I really need to rewatch it now that I've seen many more anime and have a deeper understanding of the music that it showcased.
I loved watching your reaction to these scenes!! This anime is really something special and it’s more of an experience than anything.
I just finished Trigun Stampede and there’s a couple scenes I’d love to see your reaction to when it comes to the piano! A beautiful piece is played in that show a couple times and I think you’d really enjoy it!
I'm watching this right now, and it's a phenomenal anime. Glad he's looking into it.
Carole and Tuesday has very beautiful soundtracks with piano def worth a check!
Even just watching these few clips from the show the tears started to well up… damn this show!
I'm so glad your checking out this gem!
The love and attention that went into this show is what elevated.
And I agree I watched more for the beautiful piano section than the actual story.
Though dont get me wrong the story its self though simple is fantastically told. Heartbreaking.
Lastly such a shame you only teased us with the Twinkle Twinkle little star part. One of my favorite pieces to listen to.
so awesome to see you check this out, amazing amazing animation
One of the best single season shows of all time!
YESSSSSSS IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR 2 YEARS
I highly recommended the whole anime !!
The context here is emotional.
Everyone there has something to overcame, and something that they wanna show to others.
A feeling that they wanna share with the world. The overreactions feel surprisingly immerisive while you're actually watching the whole show
I love the curiosity and amazement you portray in every video, you’re definitely an inspiring learner/teacher 🎶💯
Hot damn that rebound on the piano keys is amazing!!!
1:15 - wrong. YOU did notice, and now there's more than 200'000 people who appreciate the effort the animators put into it :).
As an animator, my assumptions is that they had a 3D model of the piano that would play the song (with the little piano keys bouncing included). Then they recorded someone actually playing the song at different camera angles to the music, matched the camera angles to the 3D model, and then they drew each hand frame on top of that (also known as rotoscoping).
The truth is that, with traditional hand-drawn 2D animation, a piano and the innerworkings of the piano are incredibly difficult to draw let alone animate. It's simply too complicated and would require a lot of people and/or time to animate it frame-by-frame. Perhaps it may be possible with a high-budget movie, but the camerawork of this TV series is so complex with such a detailed piano that it looks to be 3D-animated to me, and I'm pretty sure the hands are rotoscoped.
You'll notice in things like the Tom and Jerry piano cartoon (which is all hand-drawn) that they use angles that can reuse animations of the piano keys falling down (or sometimes they don't show the piano keys at all). They don't have the camera move dynamically on purpose because that would be so difficult to animate by hand.
As for the frames looking strange, that's likely the result of video interpolation, which was probably by the person who uploaded the video onto TH-cam or TH-cam itself. Usually the frames of an animation runs at 24 frames per second (and this depends on region and country, of course), but when the video codec is at 30 fps or 60 fps, it can cause wonky stuff to happen.
Also, the video itself may be running at 24 fps while the animation is running at 12 fps, or on twos. What's likely is that they had both the background (piano) and the foreground (hand) run at 12 fps but on different frames, so when the background moves on Frame 1, for example, it will pause for two frames until Frame 3. Then they would have the foreground moving on Frame 2 and pause until Frame 4. This gives an illusion of running at 24 fps while simultaneously taking half the work to draw or half the time to render.
With the complexity of the 24 fps running on opposing frames, interpolating the footage in any way would cause it to be very wonky.
That being said, this scene has a lot of attention to detail to have a 3D model of a piano simulated to play the exact notes played by the musician. Pretty cool stuff!
So glad that you finally checked this out. This anime brought me back to piano, along with *many* friends =)
You should also break down the instrument fingering animations in Hibike! Euphonium. They are ALL spot-on, every instrument, every time. It's insane, and it's my favorite anime of all time, being a band geek.
Oh there's definitely context for why it's all so dramatic and emotional lol. You should watch the series, it's all one season so easy to binge, and you will feel all the emotions 😅
great vid as always!
Quick note about the "frames blending into each other". That's not how it looks like in the original uncrompressed video of the animation 😄 to me that looks like a very common video framerate conversion error from the original 23.976fps to probably something like 30fps ✨ oh and frame blending is rarely an intentional choice in 2D animation. If at all, it's mainly due either the animator wants to make things more smooth with the easiest and worst looking method or it's used as an intentional dramatic effect like slomotion and simulation of a high shutter speed of real cameras.
I have a habit of looking at the fingers of pianists in movies, animations, etc. to see if they are playing to see if they are playing the correct notes. Super impressed at the level of accuracy and detail of the pianists in this anime.
2:45 okay I can't be the only one that was dying laughing from the Shrek edit
I noticed and i cared its just that as a piano player its nice to see accurate depiction
I also strongly recommend "the Forrest of Piano" -- it has really interesting and unique piano animations and the story is incredible
I'm not Violonist but Animator and I can tell that this animation of the violon is absolutely stunning, even more impressive than the Piano ! It's incredibly hard to animate and those guys just gave us a lesson.
Didn’t realize the animation was accurate but that’s amazing! Gives me even more appreciation for the show
Seeing this man be so happy about one of my favorite animes made my day!
Also the show is good, and I definitely reccomend it if you're willing to cry from an anime
That shot of the internals of the Steinway looks like a top-down shot of an actual performance of the piece (at least that section) but warped and stylized in a way that you can merge it into a scene and its not too jarring but you retain the accuracy of the visuals.
Also I wonder what their arrangement was with Steinway to have so much product placement lol
Glad to see that you're checking out the animation on this show!
other than the music, and visuals; the story itself is pretty nice! just watch out for spoilers if you plan on watching it; it's a decent 8/10 Anime (some even give it a 9/10 or 10/10)
I hope you consider watching the entire anime... it's one of my favorites of all time. It has some campy comedy... but it's probably one of the best dramas ever animated... and I'm weeping as I type this because of the emotional impact it had on me as a musician and artist.
Why did you remind me about this anime I don't wanna cry
Aweh, I'm too gruff for anime
Your Lie In April might be my favorite series, since it reverberates so deep in my soul.. Please allow yourself to watch this show; it is simply beautiful and a heart-wrenching story.. it won't leave you untouched.. trust us on this one
LOVE THIS😭😭😭GONNA START CRYING
the concerts were what got me to sit through the painful and sad moments of this anime. its pretty much like oh god these people are getting so heartbroken...but its ok, theres gonna be an incredible concert after this!
When looking at anime as an outsider who hasn’t really dove in and given it a chance it DEFINITELY seems OVERLY dramatic and melodramatic and well… that’s because it IS.
The strange part is that, after watching a few different shows (in Japanese dub, in particular, so you can avoid the mostly cringe English VO) you come to completely accept the drama of it and even love it. It becomes completely normal to you.
I truly think there’s an anime out there for everyone. “A Silent Voice” is probably the first one I would show any non-anime watching adult.
I’m 33 and have been watching anime since Pokémon was first airing in the US lol (for context).
Your lie in April is an animation master class. emotionally and artistically speaking it is a price of art work.
Salute to the production team
i left my 2D animation course last year for illustration, because as much as i love animation for all its intricacies i just don't have it in me mentally to do this much technical work. This is absolutely crazy especially since they're drawing HANDS 12 times a second, in strange positions and angles, and it's all so accurate. Add everything you said to that- and let's not even think about animating the piano itself in so much detail. Blows my mind lol
The hands are not drawn. These are 3d models using motion capture from real piano players.
@@brendanmetivier511 oh that makes a lot more sense! having only seen those clips i didnt even think about that haha.
Good one - as a pianist i got hooked onto this show so hard that i watched it in one sitting. Watch out for the die hards though because apparently theres another show that this one mimics and folks love to tell you how “ThAtS nOt ThE oRiGiNaL”.
as someone who doesnt really watch anime either I highly recommend your lie in april
it's short and incredibly beautiful
and a huge part of it is about passion in music and classical musicians that resonates a lot with any musician imo
4:19 It's actually a common technique in animation, to have effects happen *before* the cause, especially in simulation VFX. I don't know if there's a name for it, but I've seen it a couple times here and there.
Hey Charles, I highly recommend the choral music by Christopher Tin for his Civilization games and some of his other work. Its really great and I think you would find it really interesting. I recommend the pieces: Sogno di Volare, Baba Yetu and Waloyo Yamoni. they are all amazing and I'm sure there are other amazing pieces as well.
There's another anime named Kids on the Slope, where music also plays a major role. There's multiple scenes of musicians being accurately animated and it's incredible. I'm almost certain it's a forerunner to Your Lie in April, because you can definitely tell much of the budget went into those animations - whereas in Your Lie In April, accurate depiction of music isn't a priority, it's just an added bonus.
I think a few of the quirks here aren't necessarily intentional, but are an artifact of compositing hand-drawn frames with 3D-rendered frames.
2:25 that's probably just an interpolated frame from the original animation being compressed and uncompressed onto TH-cam. Not an actual frame of the animation
Yeah, I also suspected the video frames became interpolated by youtube. Does anyone know where to see the original animation?
since anime is generally low fps, the interpolation might actually be intentional to compensate for that
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR COVERING MY FAVORITE ANIME OF ALL TIME, CHARLES!!! ❤❤❤❤❤
Edit: Also, I watched some of the behind the scenes footage of how they were able to recreate perfect piano (and all instruments played) in the anime. Put simply, they put musicians into mocap suits and tracked their movements and fingerings as they played, and the animators did the rest. It’s beautiful!
I didn't know that, that's pretty cool!
It certainly looked like they did mo-cap or watched a lot of video of musicians playing their instruments. They did a good job making it look accurate without looking TOO perfect. If that makes sense.
gotta say, this is the first time i've heard someone describe your lie in april as "kinda hilarious"
1:13 From one artist to another, the animators go to such great lengths specifically FOR people like you! 😁❤️
Great now I can cry at the accuracy and the plot
I WAS WAITING FOR THIS
Love this anime! Given and Nodame Cantabile will give you similar quality in animation. All favorites!!!
Animation today is full of CGI. That's why it's accurate because they shoot the real person, things etc. As an in-between animator, it is what it is.