Just Witnessed DANNY CAREY - PNEUMA BY TOOL (Reaction!!) First Time Hearing
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ย. 2022
- 🎯 Road to 300,000 Subscribers
Support the Channel Here ⤵️
🎬 NEW PATREON | / poloreacts
/ poloreacts
➡️ BUY ME COFFEE www.buymeacoffee.com/poloreacts
➡️ cash.app/$polomars
➡️ Cash App $PoloMars
If you want to send me books, memorabilia, LPs, or any other gifts you can do that at the address below. Thank you!
Polo Mars
PO Box 927
Perrysburg, OH 43552 🎯 Road to 300,000 Subscribers
Support the Channel Here ⤵️
🎬 NEW PATREON |
/ poloreacts
➡️ BUY ME COFFEE www.buymeacoffee.com/poloreacts
➡️ cash.app/$polomars
➡️ Cash App $PoloMars
If you want to send me books, memorabilia, LPs, or any other gifts you can do that at the address below. Thank you!
Polo Mars
PO Box 927
Perrysburg, OH 43552 - บันเทิง
Just want to say thanks for watching my crazy reactions! If you enjoy what I do on this channel consider supporting me. 70% of my videos are not monetized. Between setting up the studio daily, filming, editing, thumbnails, and research which all take away from my family, you guys motivate me to put out content daily. Consider buying me a coffee here www.buymeacoffee.com/poloreacts or my Patreon www.patreon.com/poloreacts PEACE!!
Subscribed my brother.
I was rockin with Tool since middle school. Back when black folks would get bullied for listening to it. Fortunately I wasn't one to be bullied so I didn't miss out. Glad you see it now.
Love your channel Bro. I'm loving the fact that you're exploring heavier music and are truly appreciating the musicianship of the artists. Danny Carey was known as "The Octopus" because it always sounded like more than one person was playing the drums. He was just so fast and still played clean with perfect coordination. BTW he was 59 when this video was shot. The man was a beast. Keep on exploring new music. Rock and metal have such a deep well of talented bands and players. Your journey has just begun my friend. Keep doing what you're doing, I know I'm gonna be here to watch you as you discover all the Amazing bands I grew up listening to. May I make a suggestion? Since you enjoyed Chris Cornell, check out Soundgarden and Audioslave. He was the front man for both of those bands. He did some solo stuff too. All were Incredible! All the best my friend. I'll be watching and listening.
New sub here. I've been listening to Tool since I was in high school, 90's. But I will say I have a HUGE music variety, with people from every part of the earth playing in it. We are all one people, varied by genetic happenstance as we moved across the planet. Music and food, the 2 greatest joiners of humanity!
God bless you, I'll be watching from now on!
Dude, he’s one of the greatest of all time, enjoy.
“I wonder if he arranges this himself” lol 😅😅😅😅 what he plays is some of the hardest ryrhums to play, with odd timing polyrhythms and polymeter, he’s just making it look easy.
With the passing of Neal Peart, Danny now holds the title of greatest living drummer
100%
I definitely agree 100%, Danny is amazing and Tool is awesome as well. However, with that being said if you enjoyed this you should really react the Neil Peart (the drummer from the band Rush). Neil's solo "Neil Peart Live in Frankfurt" is a master piece. You should also react to some Rush songs as well.
Was really cool that he got to play with Alex and Geddy at that Taylor Hawkins Tribute in LA. Wonder if that was a bucket list moment for him.
Agreed
Neil was always my favorite but Danny was already better
Four limbs. Four tempos. Four rhythm. So clean. Seemingly effortless. Enormously complex. Simply AMAZING!!!
Its not 4 tempo, but hell yeah brother! 👍👍
Hell I can play 4 tempos without even trying ;-)
He could also play 5 rythms at once, but he would have to take of his trousers for that, and people don't want that...
@@maxowar go to a meet and greet and watch the females around danny.
The Octopus
No one ever seems to notice that casual hi-hat keeping perfect time the entire song. He is playing 4 rhythms at once. And changing dynamics even on the little rimshots during the quiet parts. This guy is a machine. No better drummer living or dead. I'm sure someone will come along eventually to take the crown, but he holds it for now.
If I practiced for a really long time, I think I could do the high hat part…
oh no. We notice.
And he’s in his 60s
@@cfhfan2000😂
Listen 10 times and you'll know 10%
everything Danny does, is exactly as it was planned to be. Tool is one of the rare bands where you WANT to hear the studio version of their songs live, because the songs are insanely intricate. And they rarely fail to deliver live.
Tool is by far one of the most progressive bands of any genre in the last 50 years.
The Mars Volta
Absolutely. I love a lot of bands for a lot of reasons, but there is no band that can compete with Tool in what they do. I really don't understand it.
It's wild how these incredibly complex rhythm schemes and musical compositions, which all sort of SOUND like they're improvised, are tightly controlled and sound exactly the same as they do on the albums. True artists.
Long time tool fan, but that might be the best description ive ever seen. Facts!,
It's what happens when you just so happen to have some of the most talented people to ever handle an instrument in every single spot
Danny is on his own level. Thanks for the reaction!
Side note: Danny was close to 60 years old when this was filmed. I can only hope to be in his shape.
I came here to post the same thing, it's actually insane when you see how amazing Danny is at 60 years old. Not to mention it's not like this was a song he had been playing for 20 years. This was the Fear Inoculum tour, the first tour they had played any song off of this album and he had perfected it already.
you know whats crazy that this video kind of hides. Danny is 6 foot 5 inches tall.
@@skurdibbles7913 dude's a Unit!
Carter is 64. Still 2 of the BEST. One and Only's.
@@strwbrryswisher420 it was so sick hearing fear inoculum live...
60 years old and still killing it. Danny's a beast!
I'm his age and feel like I'm 40-something. Not comparing myself to him beyond that. I'm just a dirt poor white piece of crap from middle America.
60 years young
Nobody plays drums like Danny...he's by far the greatest alive! Unlike any other.
@@ronaldhills6857 Mike Portnoy was pretty damned impressive a couple decades ago
He is a practitioner of Tabla & is the most proficient polyrhythmic, odd time signature, & multiple time signature drummer on the planet. It's insane to watch.
I've been playing drums for over 20 years and Danny Carey blows my mind with how talented he is. He is goated in the drumming community.
He's a big basketball fan and wears the jersey of whatever city they're playing in. Also, he has studied African drumming and incorporates it into his playing. Great reaction!
He had a basketball scholarship to go to college, but he chose music instead. He's a huge basketball fan and supporter of his local Kansas Jayhawks.
@@boddaboom77 that's right. Thanks!
@@MikeLeonard yep. I will share Danny's story to all who will hear it. The guy is really a special musician and I'm glad Ive had the chance to share the same timeline as him and enjoy his mastery live.
Advice for anyone new to Tool...if you have the chance to see it live, do NOT miss it. It is worth whatever price is charged.
Exactly what I was about to add. Well said
i wonder if he has a Winnipeg Cyclone jersey..... :^V
The polyrhythms Carey creates are just damn masterful. Every appendage doing something different making that powerful complete package. I never tire of listening to it
If Danny had another four limbs, he would use them too.
The octopus!
the subtley and polyrhythms make him the greatest of all time in my book.
I love how you said you forgot about the Singer. That’s the beauty of Tool. There are no frontmen in this band. All 4 members have unique roles that create one unified sound. Unlike most groups of any genre where the singer steals the spotlight, Maynard is almost filler
And he stands to the side of Danny’s kit. No one fronts the band. It is all about the music for them.
I remember Maynard in Green Jelly ... lolol Little pig little pig let me in...Its on here somewhere. 🤘
Exactly, Maynard has said it himself that he doesn't consider himself a "frontman". He says that he considers the singing as just another instrument in the band, and that it's no more important than any of the other instruments. It combines with all the members of the band to complete the sound they produce.
The fact that Danny Carey didn’t name this as the hardest song for him to play in concerts speaks a lot because to my mildly trained eye, this looks like an insane double marathon of technique mixed with endurance!
What’s really crazy is he’s like 60 years old. Dude is a beast. Greatest living drummer imo.
Love the reactions! FYI, Danny has a TON of NBA jerseys, and he usually wears the corresponding one for whatever city they’re playing in.
That’s correct. When Tool performed in San Antonio earlier this year, he was wearing a Spurs jersey(#21).
And when they last played in KC, Danny wore a Kansas Jayhawks jersey…his alma mater and close to where he was born!
I also heard he trolled the Boston crowd by coming out in a Lakers jersey (either initially or after the break?). Great stuff!
@@mattscoggins It was for the encore. Funny guy.
@@mattscoggins I was at that show! Can't remember if it was the entire show or after the break but the crowd expressed their displeasure! A Lakers jersey at the garden... BLASPHEMER!!!
Your comment at 17:25 is honestly the Tool listening experience. It's amazing how much time and respect their musicians give to each other. Everyone gets their moment, and I've heard it's even common for their lead singer to walk off stage mid-song for a bit (or stand in the back of their arrangement) and let the rest of the band get the attention they deserve. It's funny how we all have gone from "a 10+ minute song?!" to "I need more" when listening to them. It's like time just disappears when listening to them.
You know what I love... How humble they all are.
Nobody is smelling their own farts, or each others here like you see with so many bands, thinking they're the absolute shit.
TOOL is a single organism made up of symbiotic beings.
Been to 3 of their shows. At one show Maynard stood stage rear the entire show, with just a dim spot and the show and the band were the highlight. They are AMAZING.
I've seen Tool 14 times and at almost every show Maynard is in the background or off to the side. He was asked why he did that and he said "I want everybody to focus on the band, my part is easy compared to them", not verbatim but that was the jist of it. I've never been disappointed going to a Tool show
To me the most amazing thing about his playing at section starting at 12:40 is the fact that every limb is playing a different rhythm....and keeping them all perfectly in sync. I've never personally seen any drummer be able to maintain polyrhythms like Danny can. Love this performance. When I first saw it, after I picked up my jaw off the floor, I had it on repeat for like a week.
This moment... and what follows, with a constant rythm, but variations on the theme on the drums, constant and changing and gaining power so slowly. And staying relax.
It's one or two minutes or pure mastery
Tool's genre is Tool. No other band like them. I guess if you wanted to find a box to put them in, it would be progressive metal.
They aren't metal they are closer to grunge than metal. They are progressive alt rock if anything.
I've always considered them Euphoric Rock.
@@VampyreVladimira euphoric? I'd say lysergic acid rock. 😂
This is the truest statement I've ever heard about TOOL. I feel the same way. NO ONE sounds like them or ever will. These 4 guys play their parts so very well. It's hard to put into words what their music means to the fans... just another level than everyone else!
There is no grunge or so. Thats the selling names of That era. Ist’s simple rock
Their live performances are just as clean and the same as the album. Very technical
@@kevorev idk I just listened to the vinyl after reading this comment and the mix sounds impeccable to me🤷🏽♂️ to my ears Danny is the center piece of the album the entire way through
Compared to the original upload on YT, I've always felt the drums are mixed higher in this version. The roto-tom? korg? tabla? section (9:49) in particular, I didn't even know it existed until I watched the drum cam. Now it's my favorite part and I don't know how to explain it. The snare hits, the triplets, the lil blast beat-like fill before seamlessly going back to triplets. It's just... sec I need a tissue.
@@narcostarko Fear Innoculum is one of the best-mixed albums I've heard in a long time, the production is really good. That said, they are similar to Rush in that their live sound and arrangements are as close to the album as possible, and their live sound engineers really know their business.
@@RCAvhstape the engineers should truly be getting asuch recognition for Fear Inoculum as the artists. I have only heard a few albums so far in my life that sounds THAT level of clean. They sure made something magical with that one.
Yeah, they are hands down the best band I’ve seen live. And I’ve seen a bunch.
You can literally put yourself into a trance listening to this on repeat. No illicit materials needed!
From what I heard, Danny joined them because he felt bad that no one wanted to be their drummer. What a wonderful decision that was!
I HIGHLY recommend the song Parabol+Parabola. It's two songs in one. The calm, then the storm.
Rick Beato just put out a long interview with Danny on his channel maybe a week ago and Danny told the story.
Danny basically lived and practiced in this small rented space that would eventually become Tool’s rehearsal space and home studio. Maynard (and I think Adam and maybe Paul too) lived next door and Danny told them they could practice in his space. Apparently after a few weeks or months of their drummers flaking out on them, Danny was like, “Hey, I’d be happy to jam with you guys”. And the rest is history.
I don’t think listening to the studio version will be any better than this. This is how Tool’s music must be experienced. 🔥
I actually prefer the studio version over this one. Really can't go wrong either way =)
@@Mazzini11 agree
@@Mazzini11 Yeah, the studio version is PERFECTION!
The only problem with the drum cam video is that it makes you focus on Danny's performance. Listening to studio version lets you appreciate the greatness of the song in general.
Hey makes many mistakes here and Maynard phones in the vocals live.
Tool can't easily be pigeon holed. Their bassist Justin Chancellor says he thinks Tool is more of a heavy psychedelic band. Carey is supernatural. Thanks for posting.
I'm old enough to have watched the Beatles on TV as a little kid and I have no way to categorize Tool. They're just.....Tool.
@@jr-xs9tf What subgenre of rock? Depends, what album, what song, what portion of what song? Tool doesn't seem to give a shit about staying in one box for sake of labelling them a certain something. Metal is a generic term anyways, applies to just about anything with guitar, bass, drums that is "heavier" or "harder" than "hard rock". Tool sounds like... Tool. No one else sounds like Tool. At least to me.
Math psychedelic
Algebra 1 Core
All of their videos are made by one of the band members. The guitarist. He worked on Jurassic Park..With James Cameron. He does all of the creating and filming...Hes an amazingly talented visual artist.
Bro, no embellishments.... Note perfect to the record version. He does it all. What sounds like a multilayered percussion session is all him playing live. This is a masterclass in drumming. Welcome aboard the Danny Carey journey.
Tool is the definition of the word band. Each is the master of their own domain yet none seeks to be center stage. The singer sees himself as just another instrument. They are all next level talented.
Well said they are bonkers live
@@tylerdurdan5783 just saw them last month. Maynard spent the whole time in the shadows while letting the other band member shine under spotlights.
@@mistameanor1he always does that. I've only seen them a couple times, but Maynard never takes center stage.
Danny has quadruple limb independence. Different time signature with each limb at the same time. Its brilliant.
Not only that but different volumes for each limb, even changing the volume at certain parts between his limbs, on top of the polyrhythms without missing a beat. And his sound pads with the mandala on them each of them makes a different sound at different volumes depending on where on the pad they are hit. Which means he has to be even more precise with everything.
You just heard the studio version, it was just recorded live. These guys are that amazing.
Exactly. Only I would say this live version is better. The studio version doesn't have the hi hat with the bass right before the guitar climax, and also doesn't have the hi hat double tap in the middle of that climax. It's just an amazing ensemble. I discovered this song a month ago and can't stop listening to it.
Danny Carey is the best drummer alive!! he is another level.... WOW!
I'm really excited that i found this channel when i did. Now that you're diving into Tool, it helps me to try to experience "hearing Tool for the first time" again. Thats probably the biggest thing that the Tool army will agree on...we all wish we could hear tool for the first time again. Keep up the good work brother.
He’s from my hometown!! Lawrence, Kansas. My ex boyfriends brother got to do a drum clinic with him. He comes back and does a lot for the community, it’s awesome. He’s amazing. There’s a reason they call him the Octopus lol Can you believe he’s 61? I know it and it still blows my mind 😂🖤🖤
The genre doesn't matter, it's a joy to watch a master at work.
Danny is one of my all-time favorite drummers. My brain cannot comprehend how he can do what he does. **NEW SUB, BY THE WAY**
I love that you notice when he refrains from taking the focus of the song and "let it breathe." The entire band has that approach, and it's a large reason why Maynard's vocals are sometimes faded and why he is often off center and in the back of the set in their concerts now. His vocals and lyrics are meant to just be another instrument. So much respect for the art and lack of ego from every member of this band.
Maynard stays hidden his choice
Danny Carey is one of the best people to ever sit behind a drum kit, and if you watch a video of each individual in the band you would feel the same about each. Obviously Maynard is gifted and has several bands
As a drummer, I couldn't even Dream about doing this... Danny Carey is The Master 🔥🥁💪
There are very few things I see anymore at almost 50 that capture my attention, capture my respect, remind me of the potential of humanity. Then little things like this make me feel something I can only describe as... Alive.
Have you ever tried patting your head and rubbing your stomach at the same time? Now imagine stomping with your right foot and sliding with your left foot at the same time on top of that, the limb independence Danny Carey showcases in this song I don’t think many people in the history of the world are capable of
Been on this journey many times but it's still fun watching newbies react. Yeah, this sounds almost identical to the studio version. "Stinkfist" is another song you're gonna wanna hear in your car. 💯%. Also....I think he wears a different jersey depending on the city he's playing in.
What never ceases to amaze me seeing the top level drummers like Danny is the way they are able to control each limb independently. Most of the song each of Danny's limbs was working a different beat or doing a different task. It's almost like he's got an independent brain for each limb - kinda like an octopus! 😄
That's why they call him "the octopus". He is incredible.
Danny is the Master of Polyrhythms
"What the hell is that?" That is "The Octopus" is his full glory. He is a master of his craft. Look up what a drum paradiddle is, Danny does those exercises with his FEET! THE BEST alive today!
One could confidently make the argument that Danny is the best there ever was. The complexity, the meter changes that even fascinates mathematicians, the longevity, the unprecedented skill and the EASE in which he delivers it all… astounding.
Fun video, Polo. Thanks for taking me on the ride with you. Tool is my longtime fav and it’s awesome to watch someone marvel at it for the first time.
Ps: I also watched your react to Sober. You talked about Maynards rage and intensity. If you want to WATCH that in action… check out his live performance of Sober. A rare look at Maynard actually visible during a performance (he’s often behind a curtain or way back next to Danny… almost never taking center stage and dominating as a “front man”… it’s ALWAYS about the band as a whole). Some people can’t get over the “strangeness” of his posture or whatever but… it’s like he’s on an island. The thousand yard stare, the anguish and connection he feels to his own raw Art. AMAZING video that shows his incredible level of skill and heart.
Thanks again for the great video. You go ahead and pause it as much as you want… haha. But I do love how you then rewind it so you don’t miss anything or interrupt the flow. Excellent. 😊
Rock on!
Your kinetic sculpture really fits in the split screen fade with the beat. That’s TOOL finding the perfect balance
As a drummer myself, I've listened, watched and idolized Danny throughout his career. There's none better. You should definitely check out "Chocolate Chip Trip" and "Ticks and Leeches". Thanks for the reaction. I love Tool reactions. I've seen reactors moved to tears by "Lateralus" . Keep em coming
Wings for Marie 1 and 2 still gets me every time.
@@GravyTraining Same for me. Reminds me of my own mother.
i still believe Lateralus may be the greatest song ever written... that said, few things have the melancholy beauty of Wings for Marie
I like how he's not "playing drums". He's playing the song.
What makes this even crazier is that unlike in a lot of rock bands where the drummer basically just keeps the beat, usually in sync with the bassist, in Tool, Danny Carrey is playing rhythms that rarely sync with what the rest of the band is playing.
Well. They are though. It's extraordinarily well thought out. But at the same time, you know they had a vision, a structure, a time signature progression they wanted to work with. Then, they are all such masterful musicians, that I have to believe that some of this is related to the flow state. Anyways. Danny, Justin, and Adam create the music to be stand-alone. Then Maynard writes and sings the vocals on top. In most bands, the instrumentals "support" the lead singer. With TOOL, each instrument (I consider Maynard's voice the fourth) has it's spectacular story. You can focus totally on one of them throughout an entire song and follow that journey - which is a complete masterpiece in itself. When you do that, the rest of the band is supporting THAT musician. It's wild. The pinnacle of innovation, expertise, collaboration, symbolism, and connection to the human condition and the divine. No one sounds like TOOL, because no one is capable of even remotely replicating the intelligence, instrumental mastery, and emphasis on each artist being a "soloist" in each song, at all times. Fucking brilliant.
The guy is huge….I think he’s like 6’6”. Amazing talent. It’s fascinating to watch. Another great reaction bro!
BRO! This is what they do live.
I'm telling you "Lateralus" 3,5,8,beat. Fibonacci sequence. The lyrics are just as deep as the music.
A thing to understand about Tool is the musicians Wright the music first, then Maynard listen to it and then Wrights the lyrics. Their progression over the years is insane. Danny carey is my favorite drummer. "Evgeny Novikov" is my second. Love your exploration Polo.
So happy that you are getting to experience Tool as a new listener. They are one of my favorite bands of all time! Each member is an exemplary artist in their own right, and the manner in which they record new music is so intense, each member molding their own part as a unique work of art. Danny is incredible and definitely deserves to be in the argument for greatest drummer of all time.
I like that you noticed how he's not trying to outshine the band. You'll learn as you listen more that they ALL are that way. Maynard usually stands BEHIND the drummer because he doesn't want to be "the front man". They all respect each other so much and treat each other as fully equal and crucial parts to the band.
Pneuma is just a phenomenally well constructed piece of music. Danny definitely kicks ass with those fills, but every part works together to make this song so satisfying to listen to. You can just see it in the reaction from Lost in Vegas, it killed those guys.
This is definitely still metal, you can hear it in the style of drumming, the distortion on the guitars, and just the complex structure of the song. I think those are the kinds of things that define metal more than just being heavy and aggressive.
One of the best drummers ever! Tool is a phenomenal band because of every piece. This concentrates on just one and it is so beautiful.
In reference to your comment about Danny letting the song breathe, and coming in when it was his time to shine....I've noticed that groups like Tool that have such a wealth of amazing musicians tend to shift the focus around from one instrument to another, showcasing all of the incredible talent they have on tap. Bands like Tool, Rush, and Yes do this so seamlessly that you don't even see the transition as each one takes the spotlight. I think this is why a lot of their songs tend to be long, as they need that extra time to give everyone some space to spread their wings. One thing about Tool especially that I like is that where most groups always have the vocalist front and center almost constantly, Maynard moves in and out of the song just like the others. You can see it reflected by the way he positions and moves himself on stage in live performances, and in studio recordings, if you listen, you'll notice his voice isn't always at the front of the mix.
And yes..Danny Carey is the truth. I've seen both him and Pert live. Best 2 drummers... ever..
Since you asked, this live performance is pretty faithful to the original studio track. But I would still encourage you to give the studio version a listen because the sound/production quality is just impeccable. Incredible song.
On top of the amazing playing (which is a given with Danny) it is his posture, his completely relaxed state, how much fun he is having and the fact that he is still innovating and growing at 60 years old. He just really enjoys what he does and stays humble. Also, in damn good shape!
His biggest skill is his obvious ability to use both his left and right hemispheres of his brain both simultaneously and independently. Thats a skill that you only really see in the top levels of professional athletes. His hand eye coordination is off the charts
What's crazy is the dude is 61 and still in peak form. His ability to play polyrhythms so effortlessly is fascinating to watch.
As someone who used to try and learn drumming, this is a masterclass in technique. It's amazing how little movement his arms make. It's all in the wrists. This was a mistake I made all the time. Drummers like Carey, Peart, etc are inspiring to hear and watch.
I’ve heard Plant and Page say that Bonham’s power was in his wrists as well…but watching him….I can’t see it. As someone who studied drumming, was Bonzo’s power in his wrists too?
That's what makes drummer like Peart and Carey stand out from 99.9% of drummers out there. Plus the fact Danny is 60+ and still plays like he does is inspiring as well.
@@strwbrryswisher420 he just gets better and better with age.
Danny Carey is 61 years old and still rockin it!!
I've been a Tool and Rush fan for forever and seen them both live many times. All for the drummers....Neil was a drumming GOD and Danny is an alien from another planet lol. The two best to ever sit behind a set
Man, at the end of this song he put those drum sticks down on the drum like he was at his alter of worship.
I promise you, Tool fans are dedicated and always wanting to see more. If you keep pumping out Tool reactions, they will keep showing up to watch it.
Also, I don't think I'd call Tool a metal band. They're more like a kind of alternative industrial rock. I can't think of anyone with a similar sound or style to them. Unlike say, Slipknot, which there are many bands with a similar feel or sound. Honestly they're kind of in a genre of their own, in my mind.
Check out the self titled album by Lucid Planet from 2015. Definitely not as amazing as Tool, but it’s like they got sick of waiting so long for a new album and tried to just make their own.
Dude, this show was INCREDIBLE. I’m in the 4th row, center, here. 🤘
Danny is the centerpiece of the group. I closed my eyes during the concert and it sounded like there were 2-3 drummers. Amazing keeping all those tempos
Since you're enjoying them so much, you might want to think about doing their whole discography from the beginning. It's really interesting to see their progression from each album. They only have 5 whole albums and an ep. And some of the tracks aren't really traditional songs but are interesting to listen to.
Never have to ask if Tool fans want to see a reaction to a tool song. The answer will always be yes. Do the studio versions of every song.
And add Salival version of Pushit and No Quarter.
I agree with Pushit
Yes and yes! He needs to listen to Led Zeppelin’s version of No Quarter first to compare. I truly believe Tool’s version is better.
Someday you'll listen to "Chocolate Chip Trip" and when you do you'll hear just what a genius Danny Carey is. The whole thing was just on a whim while they were recording Fear Inoculum and they decided to keep it on the album.
Danny Carey and Neil Peart from Rush my all-time two favorite drummers
Do the studio version for sure! He’s a huge basketball fan and usually wears the jersey of the city he’s playing in.
You picked up on the African beats. Good on you :)
PS, he's also a great Jazz drummer.
African? Noooooooo
His left hand alone is one of the best drummers in history
Let's see a single African do the meter changes
Those 'African beats' sections are paradiddle runs. Right left right right, left right left left, split over the drums.
Tool is like perfectly tuned machine with finest parts.
On the jerseys.. he's a huge sports fan, beginning with his beloved Kansas. He asks (politely) for uniforms of the basket ball arenas he plays in, and that's the start of an amazing tradition.
If "the pot" gets you pumped you should check out "vicarious" it's another song that you can't help but bash the steering wheel while driving.
Another drummer who is very good, and also doesn’t over play and leaves space for the song to breath and grow, is Gavin Harrison. His play through of White Mist is worth a listen.
He did the same as the rest of us. He didn't hear the music. He just felt it and went with it.
Poly meter/rhythm GOD. ON THE SOLO AT 6:30 forward he plays 4 separate beats simultaneously!!! And it works perfect.. wow, just wow man.. Mad love from Oklahoma!!
Just want you to know... This channel is about to blow up. Keep on the tool train, massive base, great music.... But just wait until you get into Gojira, Deftones, system of a down.... more metallica and megadeth... eventually understanding and getting a taste for lorna shore etc.... Vids are going to hit 1 mill... Your reactions are great and the music isnt lost on you. Keep up the great work.
Also... More tool recs.... Ticks and leeches. Lateraulus. Vicarious. Aenima. 46 and 2
Can't wait to see if he catches on to whats really happening in Lateralus.
I like how you give a thoughtful reaction that’s not dramatized. I think you’d enjoy Tool’s 10,000 Days (song is an emotional, beautiful and powerful tribute to his mom after she passed). Also Tool’s Right in Two has a very powerful message with amazing music/drums. Both would make great reaction videos.
For your own enjoyment, you should definitely consider watching Metallica’s S&M videos (1 & 2). They play with a symphony. The power of Metallica combined with the beauty/power of a symphony is a must watch/listen experience!
GREATEST DRUMMER OF ALL TIME
Witnessed this gem in concert... I've been a drummer for 25 yrs... in the fuck sane
I think it's cool you reacted to this so early in, what I hope to be, your Tool journey. You'll appreciate the other songs much more now. And don't worry about the pauses in the reactions, just keep keeping them genuine.
There are a lot of great drummers out there. Some of them are even faster. But there is no polyrhythmic drummer as good as Danny Carrie out there. He is just the best and he makes it sound the best which is one thing I love about it he’s not just trying to go super sonic. He actually makes it sound good and goes really well with what the other band members are doing. Any tool reaction you do will bring me to your channel.
i cant speak for the band but Pneuma is a song about the unity of life and i like to think the african beats section is an ode to our origins, being that africa is regarded as the cradle of life. thats just my interpretation and one of the reasons i believe TOOL's music is a true artform. they dont set out to push any agenda, their music is made to be used however the listener can connect with it. they simply provide the tools.
A couple of things:
1) Fun fact. Danny is actually an octopus, and that's why he's such an amazing drummer
2) Pneuma is one of my favorite Tool songs. Fun fact. Pneuma means "the vital spirit, soul, or creative force of a person" so the lyric:
"Pneuma
Reach out and beyond
Wake up remember
We are born of one breath, one word
We are all one spark, eyes full of wonder"
becomes even more beautiful and wonderful to me.
3) Other amazing songs by Tool you should check out (my favorites), if you haven't already are:
a. Parabol/Parabola (in that order, and honestly, if these songs aren't played at my funeral, I'm not going)
b. Lateralus
c Right in Two
d. Rosetta Stoned
e. Schism
f. Prison Sex
g. Stinkfist
h. Ticks & Leeches
i. Swamp Song
j. Forty-Six & 2
k. Hooker with a Penis
l. The Grudge
m. Pushit
n. Vicarious
o. Maynard's Dick (it's a hilarious song)
p. Ænema
The greatest living drummer of our time! Next up- 46&2!!!
I like to think of tool as a storm, slowly riding in building until crashing down on your head, and then slowly begins to end and dissipates and it’s finalized.
Dudes like Danny get into a flow state when they're playing live. It's really just a switch for em. Just like with Stevie ray Vaughn on the guitar. You could've just told him to play and he'd just shit out a masterpiece
The song really starts this way, and it’s generally a decent recording.
GREAT Tool song to react to. Off the most recent album, this has worked its way into my top 5 Tool, and of those, I can’t say that one is better than any other, they’re all good. Just like the band in general and all their work. Tool is, well Tool, it doesn’t need words or explaining, it just, is, and it’s all good.
I am a drummer, and your reaction to him is similar to mine when I first heard him. He's pretty much THE drummer these days, the way Neal Peart was in his day. Great pick!
Danny Carey! There isn't anyone out there that would argue against Danny being considered one of the greatest drummers of all time. Heavy roots in jazz which is the most complex most difficult music to play. Danny is a beast! The syncopation, time signatures, progression, impossible on paper complexity, yet it works and sounds good. Music theorists quite enjoy him.
Danny Carey is an absolute monster on drums!
There are currently 91 types of metal. Tool would be in the realm of progressive metal, a broad fusion music genre melding heavy metal and progressive rock, combining the loud "aggression" and amplified guitar-driven sound of the former with the more experimental, cerebral or "pseudo-classical" compositions of the latter.
Once you've seen him do it live, you can visualise him in each studio recording
There's a reason they call him the "Octopus". He's a drumming god.
That’s how the song actually begins. They’re unreal
studio version is identical bro. he is a god drummer
Danny Carey is one of the most underrated drummers ever, his fills and his runs are almost unhuman, he can do things with one hand, that most people can't do with 2 hands.
Tool is like the highest rated band in history
It’s pure class, when you can search his name and find many posts of him poppin up at high school talent shows, or random events as a sit in drummer. He smiles and has fun no matter who he’s jammin with
I think I saw Danny hitting one of his cymbals from underneath coming up from a drum hit a couple of times. He's like a samurai in wasting as little effort as possible while being devastatingly effective. He is my favorite drummer without question. A former employer of mine commented on the drumming as "Jungle Drums" and I can definitely hear the African influence on Danny's playing. If you can hear the influence, there is nothing wrong with saying it out loud. I think it's awesome to hear that influence blended in with prog metal. On a long enough time scale, we are all of African descent.
13:48 "He's from Africa.."
Bro this just sparked a memory from my childhood! I'm 33 now, and I can't believe I just remembered this. My parents never raised my brother and I on "kids music", thank god haha! I was raised on 60s-70s classic blues rock and some old school reggae.
My dad always played this one reggae band Black Uhuru. I had totally forgotten about them, as I became a die-hard metalhead, basically only listening to metal for the past 20 years.
You saying "He's from Africa" reminded me of Black Uhuru and their song "Whole World is Africa".
I know it is an irrelevant story lmao but it is crazy how things such as one random comment brought back a ton of memories for me. So, thank you! Haha.
If you're interested in hearing that song, here is the link...
th-cam.com/video/FB4NU2A28I0/w-d-xo.html