Music Teacher Reacts to Danny Carey (Tool Drum Cam) "Pneuma" | Music Shed EP 30
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2020
- Check out David’s reaction to Danny Carey (Tool Drum Cam) "Pneuma"
If you enjoy the content, please LIKE the video, and don't forget to subscribe for more Music Shed reactions!
Check out the original Danny Carey (Tool Drum Cam) "Pneuma" video • Danny Carey | "Pneuma"...
For more information about David and the Music Shed visit www.musicshedct.com/
Produced by Very Nice Industries veryniceindustries.com
Additional footage courtesy of pexels.com
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.” - เพลง
Sooo.. honestly, is anyone else watching other people react to pneuma drum cam multiple times a week like every week? Haha
Yes...lost in Vegas is at least one of them
I’ve watched 4 of them tonight so far!😆
Yes, why wouldn't me. Watching people getting their minds blown is fun.
I’ve seen most of them!
Ya got me
What time signature is he in?
Danny: Which limb?
😂
Lmao no joke
Father Time sheds a single, proud tear at his baby boy Danny
A: All of them...
What time signature is he in?
Me: Yes
Dr: you only have 10 minutes to live.
Patient: i want to see danny carrey play pneuma.
Dr: but thats over 11 minutes long.
God: ill allow it.
Damn straight!
RIP Mr. Patient.. spent his last moments strapped down, feet cold and eyes red. Could only muster the strength before releasing his light to shit the bed 😭 🤘
best cheating death argument
best comment!
Pure poetry brother, though I would also add one last desperate fuck with the love of my life, while listening to it (and preferably watching this video as well.) A pretty damned good way to go out, which we all shall sooner or later, when we come to the end of the journey from womb to tomb. ;-)
The time signature is whatever the f*ck Danny wants it to be
5/8,14/8,4/4
To any of the Newbies out there, welcome to Prog Rock. ;)
Danny is just your everyday 7 foot tall, jazz drumming, 180 iq having, sacred geometry loving, psychedelic doing, midwestern, fun loving, humorous guy. You know? Those guys.
He’s 7ft? For real?
@@MusicShed Lol, idk. I know he's like 6'7". He's 7 feet for my joke.
@@MusicShed 6'5"
@@MusicShed he's 6'5" which is still stupidly tall lol
@@bsfanmsounds right. When I met him my dad was a little taller (6’ 8) and I was a little shorter (6’ 3)
“ who’s that guy walking back there?”
Just a time signatures trying to find a place to sit down
LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
Bwhahahha
This dude is really bumming me! He’s gonna join? Really?
Made me snort.
The guy walking back there is MJK isn't it?
Legend has it that Danny made a deal with the devil. No one knows what Danny got out of the deal, but the devil got a drum lesson.
underrated comment
Could have wtote the song. Went to Maynard with "THIS THING" That was all she wrote
Literal the same comment posted on every single Pneuma reaction video
So true!! This f.n..guy did sell his soul!! There is NO F.N..WAY TO BE THAT GOOD!!!!!!!..🤦♂️
As a fan of Tool for 27 years my advice would be to not try to figure out the time signitures of Danny Carey, just enjoy and spiral out.
Keep going!
My first thought.
Sarah H spiral out. I see what you’ve done there. ;)
I remember seeing somewhere that Adam said pneuma was in 33/16
...because fuck it, that’s why. 🙂
@@thefourshowflip of course they went there I mean this is Tool after all..😂
Mr. Carey likes to play four different timings at once. He can do five, but not with his pants on.
Lol
🤣
This is literally the best comment I’ve ever read in my life!
Throw the same comment at every pnuma reaction and see which one sticks 😆
"Over thinking, over analyzing, separates the body from the mind." -Tool (Lateralus)
A message for life. But most importantly, when listening to Tool.
Amen
The guy is a power drummer, and the fact that he plays this song during every concert for the fear inoculum album and does it the exact same way every night speaks volumes about how incredible he is as a drummer.
Tool would never be the same band with a different drummer, singer basis and guitar player we struck gold when these people found each other and created this band !!!!
FACTS 🙌
“ what time signature are they in?”
Tool: what’s a time signature?
or "In which universe?"
“Who’s that guy walking back there”: probably Maynard
It is
it is maynard, as we all know his favorite spot is in the dark behind everyone else...at 3:57 of the video, he's right there behind the right-back crash and china lurking and crouching like a tiger ready to pounce.
@@edzeljereza8234 kkkk love it
@ryth vlogs it’s Maynard, 😂
ryth vlogs I hate this dude! He’s gonna join in later? Really?
AND HE WAS 58 WHEN HE DID THIS!
And can we talk about the polyrhythms?
That other sound is the guitar, yes sir.
The guy in back is Maynard, making it about the music, not him. A shocking thing for a lead singer. He was getting out of the way for the wall of sound that the band ushered in for feeding.
The absolute master of polymetric, unique time signatures. It never gets old watching drummers try to figure out his time signatures and giving up. The complete heir to Neil Peart and it's easy to see his influence. This song is a complete showcase for him, and deservedly so. What might be more amazing is the fact that Danny is 58 yrs. old when this was recorded. Tool is simply an experience. Danny is simply one of the best drummers alive today.
And Adrien Belew, Dennis Chambers, Jon Bonham, to name 3 more...
I mean, they're easy to figure out, it just takes actual time and attention to hear them. This song has its verses in 33/16. The chorus is in 4/4. The bridge section is a 3 over 4 polyrhythm between Danny and the rest of the band.
@KingOfLegends23 Danny is highly influenced by those drummers...maybe be even just as much as Neil Peart. Not irrelevant at all.
@KingOfLegends23 The poster mentioned Neil Peart as a drummer who Danny is influenced by. I merely mentioned a few more. I guess it has to be spelled out for you...
@KingOfLegends23 How is mentioning other drummers who influenced him _in addition_ to the one mentioned not adding something to the discussion? It quite literally is.
26TH WTF. He is top 10 easy.
Yup. Steve Gadd is 24, Grohl is 27, and Travis Barker is 99! Something seems off with this list...www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/100-greatest-drummers-of-all-time-77933/earl-hudson-33973/
I’m not a fan of polls. DC is a fantastic musician. He plays the drums like he has an orchestra in front of him and he can also rock as hard as any.
They had RINGO ranked above him..... RINGO! Don’t get me wrong I love the Beatles and Ringo, but he can’t even hold a candle to DC in terms of skill. DC is easily top 5 of all time imo, right up there with Bonham, Peart and Buddy Rich
@@MusicShed Well, that magazine left freaking Joe Satriani OUT of the 100 greatest guitarrist of all time, so... You can't expect much from those guys.
It's an opinion list dude hahahah. It's hard to standardized a rating system to measure any construct. Danny is VERY good, we will leave it at that to be conservative.
Shed: “Who’s that guy in the background? Who’s that?!”
TOOL fans: “A wild Maynard appears! :D”
How many calories did Danny burn? I dont know but knowing TOOL I bet it's a number in the Fibonacci Sequence.
46 and 2 calories
With the efficacy of his movements, probably not as many as you'd think.
A comment somewhere said he drank like two cases of water during a concert and never took a piss. He's probably eating 8 to 10k calories on a concert day. The Rock eats 10k a day to maintain his physique, so drummers are probably in that range during tours.
its 25 calories at the low end of the curve to 150 Cal. seeing how hes a pretty big dude, i would consider the higher end....
What time was he in??..Danny Carey Time!
What time signature are they in?
Danny/Tool: Yes! ^^
According to experts...It would be in 33/8...Jeez!!!
5/7 I thinks 😏
Came in the comments to type the exact same thing
They exist outside of time
I thought it was Forty Six & 2?
seeing Tool live is the closest thing to a religious experience I've had, excluding taking psychedelics. they are even better live than on record, and Danny absolutely nails it every time I've seen them.
It IS a religious experience. That's how I've always explained their shows to people who don't know.
TOOL live and in person is a serious experience. Brilliant musicians bringing you on a journey. Sounds corny but it is what it is.
Everything said here is 100% truth. 🙏
Left my first tool show feeling like I just went through an hour long acid trip
Saw them at Sovereign Bank Arena in Trenton about a million years ago. Smoked a little before going in, but that's it. They played my fave, H, and during the crescendo I started tripping my face off, full on out of body experience when he screamed "I DON'T MIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIND!"
“Who’s that guy walking back there” that my friend is Sir Maynard James Keenan probably going to backstage for some wine
actually he was crossing to his other platform. On their recent tour he had two platforms, one on each side of Danny, and he would go back and forth at different points during the show. So you'd see him on one then disappear and reappear on the other side of the stage. It was a cool setup.
Man if more music teachers were like this guy the world would be a much better sounding place. Instead they make everyone play the damn recorder for a year.
Danny Carey doesn't use time signatures. He just *is* time.
Tool has 3 other members, so Danny is constantly playing between 2 and 4 time signatures to sync everybody up... He unifies the time signatures with his drums and makes the song work. Every member of the band is a genius and an equal contributor and has equal say in composition.
I think Danny is the greatest in the band, but the others are great too.
Well said which why they are great. Team work at its finest. Especially artistically speaking. No one memember is more important than the other in the band and its apparent if you see them live. Absolutely incredible
I have watched a thousand reaction videos to this video...every single one: "wtf time signature is this"
Ty for being honest and not arrogant. I remember riding my bike to get undertow. I’m 42 now. They really are badass
Are you 42 or 46&2?
I can't wait to turn 48 to annoy people.
That’s awesome!
The guy you seen walking in the back is Tools lead singer Maynard. He stays in the back in the dark and sings so the people can focus on the truth of the lyrics and not on him. One reason why this band is so F**K**G AWESOME!!!!
Seeing Danny Carey doing his thing I would call MJK a Drum Backup Vocalist. ;-)
I've watched about 20 plus different reactions to this song. That was very entertaining! A nice mix of teaching, awe, funny comments and piano too! Well done!
"What time signature is he in?"
Danny Carey: "Jazz."
33 16
Danny Carey: yes
Question: “What time signature are they in?”
Answer: “Yes.”
“What time signature are they in??” Sorry sir Thats classified.
Danny Carey: "yes"
All of them
tool is such a mind bending band. they should make a song called: "what time signature is that?" 🤯
In fact they did... but they called it "Die Eier von Satan"
It's almost as if his limbs act independently of each other. Unreal
That's why they call him the octopus.
That "guy walkin' back there" is the lead singer of Tool, Maynard James Keenan, doing his usual "I'mma do the whole concert from the back of the stage" routine.
Edit: Also, 33/16. Count 5+3+3+3+5+3+3+3+5
I get the same result but for me, it feels more natural to solve it polymetrically as 5/8 + 11/8 + 12/8 + 5/8 (it is especially the 12 - 13 transition that makes wobbly heads) for the verse. And yes - we both smile to each other at 33.
And it makes sense that we solve it differently because the different band members have a tendency to put their accents at different places. So it can end up feeling even more rhythmically deep - even before they break out into polyrhythmic on top of the poly-metrics (as in the middle theme).
The important thing is though - how smooth and groovy they play odd-number bonanza. It is there, making headbangers confused, but when we lean back and lets it wash over us it is so damned fluid and meaty. The sequences are not flashy - they feel integral to what at least I listen to.
And in this case, I feel that almost the entire song is creating tension. Only a couple of times do they release the tension. (my personal theory, this is why FI-album got mixed reviews for being introvert or navel-gazing as first listening. They are building these long phases of tension - and they give a big F in people's desire for a quick tension-release. I enjoy the way they hold and builds these statics - insisting us to be there and listen. Excellent stuff).
@@glacieractivity the fact that this is a comment on a youtube video is the best fuckin part. Thank you sir!
I saw a video that counted it like this. Made sense to me.
1-2
1-2-3-4-5-6
1-2-3-4-5-6
1-2
1-2-3-4-5-6
1-2-3-4-5-6
1-2
1-2-3 (repeat)
maybe I'm retarded but I got a 7-8, 7-4, 5-8, delay 7-4 in the begining
@@Mazzini11 and sadly its in a reply to a comment so it will get surely missed by the masses.. but yes amazing stuff @glacier activity
I just saw them Tuesday and hearing this live was an emotional experience. The entire band is awe inspiring. Been a fan since ‘96!
Got rid of Facebook so I've been addicted to watching the Danny Carey reaction videos. This one is in my top three
@3:45 "What time signature are they in?"
IIRC at the moment you're asking it's 14/8 + 14/8 + 5/8. With occasional 14/8 + 14/8 + 6/8. The chorus is 4/4. There are a couple one-off 5/4 bars throughout the song, too.
Now I get it. I thought it was 666/69
It hurts my brain
It sounds like 11/8: first bar of 11 beats is grouped 6 + 5, second bar is 5 + 6
I also wondered how much energy Danny must use during a set. When I saw them live earlier this year, Pneuma was I think fifth out of ten songs. The guy is an athlete of the highest calibre. Mentally and physically on another level.
Also a little tidbit for you. The drum pad skins were designed by Ironhead Studios. The team that design and make all the Marvel Avengers masks and outfits.
People never talk about his precision during live performance. They are touring and playing through their songs. He makes it look thoroughly easy. So hard for people to understand the level of musicianship of these guys. Including Maynard of course.
Calories burned? None - that's Danny's resting state...
Most tool songs have Justin and Adam doing their own things and Danny tying it all together with multiple different time signatures going. One with each hand and foot at times. That's why his nickname is the octopus.
Danny is so good. He's always in the zone and he's a super nice human being.
He’s like 60, shredded, giant and phenomenal. That rolling stone tanking must’ve been way before this album. There’s no way he doesn’t jump to the top 3. I just wish they had a chancellor cam and a Jones cam. Even a Maynard cam would be wicked. Tool is to this generation what ELP or Pink Floyd was to those generations.
I’m really against music polls at my core. But the factoid sparked nice dialogue here!
3:44 "Which time signature are they in?" This is Tool, mate; which bar are you referring to?
also which limb
Tool playing in 2 different alternating time signatures with a 3rd time signatures after so many bars.
Right? There around 80 signature changes in this song.
Thank you for showing The Master at Work, full screen, and yourself in a inset window. That's how it should be!
Very few "reactors" do this (I've watched maybe dozens of reactions to this video), so mad props to you for that.
You've got your priorities right!
David - What time signature are they in?
TOOL Army - Yes.
Is that what they say?
@@MusicShed Yes.
PINK FLOYD + LED ZEPPELIN + RUSH =
🔥👽TOOL👽🔥
Also some King Crimson imo
Yup
@@jpthemusicenjoyer Definitely.
That math seems to add up. I think I will use that when someone asks what is Tool. I'll say imagine those three bands put together.
Cannot say you're wrong! 😂
Their music is a TOOL to elevate your spirit
Exactly 🙏❤
Music Teacher: “What time signature are they in?”
Tool: Yes
Lol
Student: What time signature are they in?
Music Teacher: Yes
Music Teacher: "What time signature are they in?"
Tool: All of them!
Greatest drummer of all time. 100%.
“He’s in the zone. He’s at One.” Yeah that’s the idea of this song ha!
@10:08 - 'Who's that guy walking back there?'
That's the singer, Maynard. He sings from a platform on either side of the drum kit rather than front/center stage. He will sometimes swap sides in a breakdown like this.
Great reaction!!
Strange to see this, and that's the beauty of TOOL, odd and so fucking good!!!
"What Time Signature are They In: An Unauthorized Biography of Maynard Keenan"
What time signature are y'all in?
Maynard: fuck if I know, ask Danny!
@@normancounts2924 Danny: Speaks in alien, no one has the capability to comprehend.
"What's the time signature?"
"Tool."
the guy in the back was probably Maynard, he likes to perform at the back away from the spotlight, so he was probably walking around while the others were playing
I really like the added facts about Danny like where he was born. I think it adds greatly the reaction experience. Good job 👍
Eurystheus: " Heracles, I have a thirteenth labor to complete if you wish to gain immortality: Play the drums live on this Tool song; Pneuma."
Danny Carey:
"Hold my beer."
Edit:
BTW, sub'd.
Great production, presentation.
Joining in at the end was icing on the cake.
Yeah rolling Stone magazine must be high..there is no way Danny is 26 more like #1 or 2. He's my all time favorite though. Top 5 are Danny, Neil, Keith Moon, John Bonham and Stewart Copeland.
Best drummer to ever walk the face of the earth.
@@aquawicket my thoughts exactly.
Stewaaaart! I don't see many people giving him the recognition he deserves.
you've got a good base, now groove to Billy Cobham, Vinnie Colaiuta, Lenny White, maybe some Weckl
@@ericyount3858 Billy Cobham is fantastic
Time signature is just that Tool is the greatest band and key to the Universe
If every drummer hadn’t already seen this, every drummer should see this.
Never get tired of people watching Danyy Carey and watching them realize how brilliant he is
Finally someone mentioned how he has that Neil Peart sound. Danny is amazing. Seen them play a couple times. Flawless live. Syncopated
Watching him control the volume, pitch, and speed of those taps at the beginning just made my brain melt with amazing
YOU: ‘What time signature are they in?’
Danny: ‘Most of ‘em.’
“What time signature are they in?”
Good question! Only 4 people in the world know...
You will be a TOOL fan for life now if this is your first experience!!!!! One of my most favorite bands since 1992!!!!!
Tool doesn’t make songs. They compose works of art.
"What time signature are they in?" Danny: "All of them"
When the performance is so good you instinctly wanna start jamming along with the band.
Awesome.
Apparently nasa has its best scientists trying to decipher the time signatures
If you want the time signature, it's the rythm guitar! Danny plays lead!
The dude drumming in the yellow jacket lmfao had me rolling
Danny doesn’t need time signatures, he lives in the 4th dimension. He just pops in and out of our perceived reality when he needs to.
People are saying 33/16, but it wouldn't make sense to have a 45-50 bpm tempo. It's much simpler if you say 33/8 @ 100 bpm. I think the easiest way to count it is to think of the first bass note as a pickup note, then count 7 twice (half time), then 5 double time. So 14 + 14 + 5 = 33.
Those are 4 guys sent from an other galaxy to teach us what music can be...
This guy is a fuckin maniac. I hardly disbelief that even a few people are able to do what he is capable of. Period
He is a numerology man, you are in his time signature where time does not really exist.
The purple electronic drums are Synesthesia Mandala Drums that are capable of 128 different sounds per head... Givem a look.. He helped develop them.... Simply a Percussion God.
"Classical" pianist composer here. Absolutely into technique. Tool is a classical band. The structure and the execution is what folks typically called classical... "Classical" is a period of music but we all know what it means when it's used
Also, I have heard Maynard stays in hiding because he doesn't feel he "works" as hard and shouldn't up stage the other musicians.
Maynard said it best in a Joe Rogan interview, his lyrics and vocals are just another instrument. I think he tried his best to subvert the "front-man" image that is so common everywhere.
also something about the way sound flows and the drums affecting his vocals when he's up front..so he moved to the back and fixed it.
Loved your reaction and the way you started to join in at the end.
I’ve loved tool since the first ep and still listen to them with passion.
Love ya work!
One of the best pieces of musical advice I ever got came from a one-on-one master class with Daron Hagen back when I was in music school. He said: "Totally inspired composing and performing is the best. It's what we all want all the time. But of course it doesn't work like that; inspiration comes and goes. So our job -- the real 'job' of being a musician -- is to get SO GOOD at our craft that no one can tell the difference between inspiration and technique."
Amen
You should look at Lateralus from them live. He is multi tasking the whole song. Amazing drummer
we did that one
2 things I've read about DC that blow my mind - 1) he doesn't really think about time signatures, more he follows the "feel" of the song, and 2) he practices playing the "hand rhythms" with his feet and the "feet rhythms" with his hands, I guess minus all the fills though!
Awesome reaction man, I'm glad you enjoyed it! They have an incredible discography definitely worth diving deeper into, even if just for yourself.
"What time signature are they in?"
"Yes."
"What time signature are they in?" That's gotta be the most common question for any musician when listening to Tool.
Favorite part was when you were like "I can't just feel this music anymore, I gots to play along some!"
When a cat gotsta play, a cat gotsta play!
By for now? Eric the Actor reference!!?? Lol. Yeah man, heartfelt respect given to one of the absolute greats!! Doesn’t matter what kind of music your into, you cannot listen/watch Danny rock around this sound and not have your mind blown 🤯 the patterns and rhythms guitar, bass, drums, and even vocals are forming weaving in and out of are like no other kind of music!! Love love love the drum cam Vic Firth so thank you for sponsoring this effort. I’ve been watching reaction videos around Pneuma and Danny Carey for days and EVERYONE views it like I do!! Danny, you are the drum 🥁 👑!!!! ✊✌️
Great advice, for those that are blocked. Thanks for that.
Wow, Technique will set you free !! So true!! I love how Daney Carey uses a more conventional Rock grip with his sticks ,but I would still love to learn the Jazz technique . I would also love some of those nice double kick pedals as well 8)
David: "What time signature is that?"
Danny: "Yes"
The way he hits the One after those fills. It’s insane.
Reactor: What time signature are they in?
Tool: Yes
What time signatire are you playing here Danny?
Danny: yes....
This song in particular is basically a show case for Danny.
Amazing review video man! Love the insert you add in the video! Super informative!
That guy you saw walkin in the back was Maynard the lead vocalist. He goes back and forth from these elevated darkened platforms on either side of Carey. I got to see them last February the day before everything shut down, it was amazing.
Time signature is on his shirt. Really.
Every time I watch and listen that part 11:46 I feel I could cry.
Danny is his own time signature
Drum Kingdom...best description ever...and your duet killed it