Kapil Sibal Reveals How Electoral Bonds Were A Scheme To Fund the BJP Big Time
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ก.พ. 2024
- In a hard-hitting interview, former law minister and senior advocate, Kapil Sibal, has accused the BJP of exploiting the electoral bonds scheme for their own gain. According to Sibal, the changes in company law and amendments to the Income Tax Act, as well as the Representation of the People Act, were all aimed at enabling the corporate sector to fund the BJP. #ElectoralBonds #BJP #KapilSibal #IndianPolitics #Transparency #CorruptionScandal #rajasthan #newstoaday
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va2A...
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
Why is the BJP reluctant and apprehensive about it? The Honourable court judgement must be binding to all.
Coz 90% of the bonds paid are already to BJP. If that comes out the opposition will use that.
Who is reluctant...did BJP said anything...it was for all political parties...
Otherwise cash finding used to happen
@@raul9403 BJP is against it after they have freeze the accounts of opposition parties dude. Good morning, I think you woke up just now.
@@Dimuk1984first of all it's not opposition parties account getting freeze...it was congress account ...which is having his cases running in IT tribunal from 2021 ...for not paying taxes.....u don't want people to pay taxes ? ..if they would have paid taxes this issue won't have come...there are more than 20 opposition parties...none of their accounts have been freeze...only non tax payer account was freeze
iT tribunal has given them partial access to accounts and the next hearing is on March..
Also let proper news come out....
@@ajinjoyacdc electoral bonds are not even 10 % of total amount spend in election....
Huge amounts in cash are drawn by congress...
Electoral bonds were there for the accountability for money...and it was for all parties...not for a single party..only SBI was allowed to release bonds....
The solution by Kapil Sibal makes so much sense .... Let the EC of India collect funds from the corporates and distribute it among all the political parties in proportion to the number of seats they hold in LS ! .... What electoral bonds are doing at the moment is simply felicitating crony capitalism to take roots in our country ! .... I welcome the supreme court judgment on this .... This will greatly reduce the influence of the corporates in govt. decision making process also ! .... 🙏 .... 🇮🇳 ....
Corporations will not like to fund Communists, Maoists and other anti Indian parties who want to destroy their industry, they will fund the parties they like through other channels, like cash.
Electoral bonds were designed to be anonymous just like anonymous voting.
If congress comes they bring this under another name...this is good business for every political parties
Again leftist robinhood mentality
The idea is not sensible, it is stupid and laughable. People donate money to political parties of their choice. They don’t don’t donate money for politics at large.
SC must act now to ban EVM as per voters demand. Voters do not trust EVM. EC is number one fraud under fraud regime. SC has an obligation for its constituents to restore trust in free fair and transparent election. Ban EVM . Paper ballot is must now.
Lawyer Sibal is absolutely right and his solution is 100 % correct
If mr. Sibbal's solution is imposed, then the opposition will always be far behind.
Like suppose there is total donations of ₹543 crores, then BJP will get 303 crores and congress only 52 crores . This way the opposition will not be able to bounce back. Now 303/52 seems small but multiply it by 15 times. Now the calculations comes out to be BJP 4545 CRORES congress only 780 Crores.
Solution..??Remedy he suggets is far worse than malady😮
Appreciate Sibbal Sir, and congratulations on fighting for fundamental rights of Citizen of India and exposing Fallacy of Electoral Bonds . Jai Bharat.
Playing DJ on main road with a band is also fundamental right?
If mr. Sibbal's solution is imposed, then the opposition will always be far behind.
Like suppose there is total donations of ₹543 crores, then BJP will get 303 crores and congress only 52 crores . This way the opposition will not be able to bounce back. Now 303/52 seems small but multiply it by 15 times. Now the calculations comes out to be BJP 4545 CRORES congress only 780 Crores.
What fundamental right..???
The so called educated intelligentia never vote.Let them vote first..exercise their right..
Nobody stopped from playing dj,bands and dhol Tasha with standing rules and regulations (DJ is an electrical amplification consider the sound barrier of human ears & patients around, old age homes, senior citizens )There is human sound barrier,
With SC , EC and a political Jt committee must form to address this issue of political fund distribution amicably, no doubt a ruling party must get a maximum proportion of it, b'cos they have to support local infra as per agenda and that must be transparent.
Hats off to you all for relentless efforts. Supreme court mentioned electoral bonds are unconstitutional... there was no transparency at all...
Honestly though Sibal is right here I feel the very same way about bonds. If people are donating to a party it should be public information so we can see what the quid quo pro is.
This opinion is anti-national 🤣
If mr. Sibbal's solution is imposed, then the opposition will always be far behind.
Like suppose there is total donations of ₹543 crores, then BJP will get 303 crores and congress only 52 crores . This way the opposition will not be able to bounce back. Now 303/52 seems small but multiply it by 15 times. Now the calculations comes out to be BJP 4545 CRORES congress only 780 Crores.
Citizens should be transparent about their income, pay gst, vat, income tax but politicians don't want to follow it. They are not citizens for our country. Hypocrites.
No funding in future. Let us elect as per the qualification.
That would mean BJP rule for next 30 years. Qualification and Rahul Baba in one statement, not happening 😂😂😂
I can't imagine how much pressure our CJI would've gone through 😢
Just shocking that these politicians say the maximum amounts a candidate can spend is X but the reality, which everyone knows is that they spends a lot lot more than that maximum spend amount.
Stop this.nonsrnse
🎉electopn bond is nothing but prostitution business
The goes to thecwhotw covers his fsce
The lady received siesta not pay income tax. Co itbis a business
Kapil sir one of a siddar from india he is look all in india I am pray to him
Now it's time for PM CARES FUND to be scraped and all related documents need to be published.
इलेक्टोरल बांड्स ही थे जिसके चलते भाजपाई अय्याशियां करते रहे, भाजपा के सैंकड़ों पँचतारांकित कार्यालय बनाते रहे, विधायकों को प्याज आलू की तरह खरीदते रहे।
Rajdeep the ruling party is the only one who knows who is giving money to the opposition while the opposition did not know what the ruling party was getting or from whom?
Its a gift when the Bond is not turned in , cashed in.
++++++
Is 300 crores a year ... big time ???? Really ?
Its not even 2 percent of what is spent on elections in India every year...
in political campaigns.
But how does it make any difference to anyone if you ou know or not because who ever is donating it's up to them
@@oostmail Assuming this is a serious comment ....
1. You need some transparency ...you dont want foreign funding to mess up your elections
2. You need some transparency and limits on Corporate
funding to elections... corporations are not people.
Corporations putting pressure on employees to send money to preferred parties is also not a good thing..
Ditto for Churches and Islamic Religious Institutions. putting pressure on parishioners.
3. Putting limits on Individual contributions .. will lead to " benami"
donors and funding from PACs ( Political Action Committees ) and Shell institutions. This cant be stopped easily. Transparency can lead to a better informed voter. Thus I lean towards Transparency.
++++++++++++
But nothing will help Democracy if the voter is thinking Caste
and is " Sampradayak " and is chasing " Rewdi " .. ... we need a voter who is
putting Bharat Pratham. and is voting for the best candidate in the field.. .. That is not happening.
@@oostmailNo, this is how money laundering happens
@@ganeshdoretrue...the amount is not even 10% amount spect
Kapil Sibal Sir , you are 200℅ Right God bless your career and long live to save Indian Demovracy❤
It is "ELECTORAL BRIBE", beneficiaries must be punished.
Kapil is 100% right and it's basic common sense, not even complicated. Why is BJP is against it if it is not trying to hide something. Why don't they want to tell the citizens of India as to who has funded any party and why!!
Thank you sir to,approach supremecourt judgement in Kapil sivil sir God bless you and to band E V M also sir
Hats off to you all for relentless efforts. As Sibal Sir rightly said, parties in power may use this to target the corporates who has given funds to opposition parties.
Dear Sir Rajdeep,Please Don't Interupt Kapil Sibal Ji.
Allow Sibal To Speak.
Thanks.
He is a bull dog of BJP
At least I hope people will use their brain , about how bjp purchases mla, MPs,
Great Kapil sibal ji
All income and expenses of a political party must be scrutinized by an independent empowered body not under government with a jury from people. Every month declaration should be given on the website. Any party violating should be debarred for 10 years. Corruption is getting legalized in this wonderful democracy.
As per Returns filed by political parties, ECI released data and ADR report for FY 2021-2022, richest parties in India 1st BJP; 2nd TMC; 3rd Congress.
Biggest scam in India so far..
Mr. Sardesai it's not kapil sibal it's the Supreme Court verdict
Rajdeep i don't think you know what the main issue is.
Rajdeep makes the bjp sound soo innocent. 😂😂😂
👍 kapil Sibal
Great job Supreme Court of India .Next please ban EVM .Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Well said sibal sir. Thank u
Ask Mr Sibbal why is he standing in support of Mamata Banerjee in spite of being a Congress leader. Mamta has unleashed a reign of terror in WB and Congress party workers in WB are suffering , their homes are looted and destroyed by TMC goons . And these Congress leaders, Sibbal and Manu Singvi are continuously supporting Mamata. Stop this double standard politics. Shame on you people. Even Rahul Gandhi in WB was not allowed to go through his route by Mamata's police. Are these people really Congress men or are they sabotaging the party ? It's for these people that the whole Congress party is losing elections in Bengal. Shame shame Mr Sibbal and Manu Singvi
Rajdeep Sardesai has also been converted into a Godi Media anchor.
Rajdeep should ask these questions to CJI
Will Rajdeep and India Today now grill BJP and criticise them? The nation wants to know!!!
Judgement include all parties
If it is not a scam why not disclosed by the beggars who are using this electrol bond
FUNDS SHOULD BE DONATED TO ELECTION FUND MAINTAINED BY ELECTION COMMISSION AT STATE LEVEL AND CENTRAL LEVEL, AT CENTRAL LEVEL THE FUND SHOULD BE DISTRIBUTED TO THE PARTIES ACCORDING TO THE PERCENTAGE OF VOTE SHARE THEY GOT IN THAT PARTICULAR ELECTION, AND AT STATE LEVEL THE PERCENTAGE OF VOTES OF THE PARTIES THEY GOT IN STATE ELECTIONS
We don't need corporate funding we need state funding of political parties.
State funding concept would create havoc.
Don't you know what the politician do when it comes to their salaries/pensions/expenses/etc etc.
Same things would happen if funding is done by state.
The parties will immensely increase the budget for this and they will eat up whole money(your and mine taxes).
And every party including the opposition will stay together to get that money.
Just IMAGINE.😮
@@trident56 State funding concept would create havoc.
Don't you know what these politicians do when it comes to their salaries/pensions/expenses/etc etc.
Same things would happen if funding is done by state.
The parties will immensely increase the budget for this and they will eat up whole money(your and mine taxes).
And every party including the opposition will stay together to get that money.
Just IMAGINE.😮
A person who appeared for Severing Kashmir from India talking about democracy 😂😂😂
Rajdeep sardesai was a journalist once before 2014 & now he is a Entertainer 🎉
When solution suggested by Sibal is so simple then why it was not implemented till 2014 by Congress.
Listen bhakt.
Electoral bond was started after 2014, it was BJP who introduced it in India.
Have some logic when asking silly questions.
Typical Bhakt, why not Congress without knowing what, who, why ?
@@irfanmujawar3032 typical andh namazi before 2014 it was cash which was much more difficult to track typical black money, in a way if congress wanted they could have introduced the so called solution of sibbal. Learn about thing properly not what ur maulvi or madrasa said.
Because they, Congress were the biggest collectors from political funding from 2008 to 2013. Today, their box dried up. They can lecture anyone. Electoral bonds need to be transparent or they need to be banned.
Always a solution to a problem is evolutionary in nature,why it can't be done then and now is ridiculous.
Mr.Rajdeep...ask a question why Congress accepted EB from corporates in last 6 years....which is again in thousands of crores....ask that question...
It is impossible for Kapil Sibil, a seasoned lawyer to hold such a debate and even now a lawyer who defends political corruption accused in corrupted politicians cases, to give a neutral opinion in national level!
A lawyer will do anything to win a case , sometimes he will even tell,the truth.
Just ask him his party bonds percentage also increased .
Can some one ask sibbal what about his party when is on power can we apply his own explanation then I highly doubt
His bullshit views on Kashmir are enough for majority of the country to hate him.
Absolutely correct...something like Modi defending Adani and pushing Ambani to a corner....LOL
@@krishservices2011 that's the whole point of their argument in the supreme court.the scheme was introduced in 2017 via an amendment and the ruling parties income has increased astronomically like more than 100 times... especially in the the centre but also in the states even where Congress and other parties are in power...so the argument is that the scheme is made to increase the corporate anonymous funding eventually for political favours....the only problem is anonymity.
So it is absolutely the nexus between corporates and the political parties particularly to the rulings political parties. Why should the corporates loves to political parties representatives to the legislative Assemblies. It means it is an open encouragement of corruption by the lagislature or the govt to payback to the corporates compromising peoples interst?
All MLA and MP having salary and pension, then why need such kind of funding to party?
I think rajdeep have correct person to interview he given him the correct answers ❤
Which ever party it could be. As a citizen we should be having equal rights in upcoming days to ask the details of spending and utilizing of part funds. Because party funds are mostly by public charity. Parties cannot claim any privacy on that demand. Need RTI
Rajdesaiji, kamaal ki baaten karte hain aap. Finally you managed to sell your soul. 🎉
Why would a corporate donate money to a ruling party in power, obviously to gain favours for the corporate in many ways. Evade taxes, get contracts and many more illegal favours.
Ranga-Billa's days are ending and so is Hum Do Humarey Do Sarkar
Let the lawyer say, who said corruption is a world wide phenomenon, non but late PM Indira Priyadarshini
All donations by corporate bodies including sister concerns be disclosed party vise and they should reflect in balance sheet and be published in detail .
Why corporate gives donation for .......what they may get in return.....why they are not give for education, jobs,literacy, schools,
Procedure for Selection of high court and supreme courts judges is itself quid pro quo ,it’s foolishness to expect sane judgements from judges who have been appointed through quid pro quo’s
Good point ..and there is no transparency on corruption by judiciary too
and what makes you think that, after this judgement?
😂😂keep crying, your master's corruption is out now
@@mohitjesani2797 no one is saying it wrong ...full support to this judgement ..... but judges judge people on corruption, they must be clean too🙂
@@thanosssnap330 atleast better than legislative i guess?
सीजेआई केवल कठोर टिप्पणियाँ करते हैं, अपराध (उदहारण के तौर पे बाबरी विध्वंस, चंडीगढ़ मेयर के चुनाव और चुनावी बांड्स)स्वीकार करते हैं लेकिन कोई सज़ा नहीं दे पाते क्योंकि जस्टिस लोया याद दिलाये जाते हैं।
Let's go back to 100 percent cash and Alcohol. It's Seems Sisodia is a Visionary : He Knows How Indias Judges will Rule. Cheers.
Political funding is happening not just now in what ever manner its schemed out now, but this is happening over 70 years right from the first public election took place after 1947 independence. All these days why Sibal not approached the Court and argued in the court about corporate funding and illegality in it??? When this Electoral Bond scheme was passed in the parliament, he was very much there as the member of parliament and why he failed to put up all these points and struck down there itself? Importantly, why SC was keeping quite all these years when such schemes were passed without validating it and after 6 years why?
Very good judgement
Not really. the court should have asked the money received be given to Election Commission to use in election process
Can courts take suvomoto action when only opposition is targeted by E D?😢
Rjdeeps single point propaganda to give reward to his wife’s Rajya Sabha seat 😂
Rajdeep is happy something has come against BJP. But he will be disappointed nobody can Stop Modi
The problem is that Rajdeep has no argument he's a duffer. By the way his channel is a beneficiary in terms of advertisement received.
If mr. Sibbal's solution is imposed, then the opposition will always be far behind.
Like suppose there is total donations of ₹543 crores, then BJP will get 303 crores and congress only 52 crores . This way the opposition will not be able to bounce back. Now 303/52 seems small but multiply it by 15 times. Now the calculations comes out to be BJP 4545 CRORES congress only 780 Crores.
Then how BJP is buying other party MLA & MP ???
is that also nothing to do with elections
Why does a company in loss donate to a polical party
Rajdeep you will not get fund from bjp now what you can do 😂😂😂😂
If the corporate sectors are paying to the parties, is it being reflected in the income tax return? If so then the payment is ok
Correct this is Quid Pro Quo for fund raisers. Banning must apply to all the Political Parties.
India Today stands exposed with its subtle defense of indefensible please stand with the people and democracy and not with the corporates
Legalisation of corruption Yojna.
Wonderful better than surprise😢😢😢!!!
Still they claim that Modi most honest person and BJP cleanest party.
The News Anchor is acting so INNOCENT 😇😇😇 Look at his facial expression 😂 Really 😇😇😇
Oscar without any doubt
Let the truth be revealed to the public. SC has done the right thing.
Mr. Desai you look like... ' fishiyari billi khanbha nonche '
This judgement is for all parties, every political party goes in trouble. Corporate sector or any individual comes forward to give political fund to political parties.
Funds should have been accepted by sbi only between days of commencement of general elections process announced byECI (whether to state assembllies or loksabha )till the date of witdrawal of electioncode conduct by ECI.
Sibbal ji's former party approves only cash payment jisme koi proof na rahe 😂
Now that’s what we called as a proper debate.!!!
Views are addressed and anchor is playing a neutral role. That’s what we are missing in todays media.!
Kapil Sunil Sir 👏🙏🫰🏻
Sometimes the supreme court verdicts reminds us that we are living in democratic country.
Rajdeep. Sometimes you just don't seem to get it. Under the Electoral Bonds Act only MODI Amit Shah and the SBI chief would know who has given how much to whom.
Rajdeep acts very innocent
What you did when you were ruling. Took cash and won.
Kapil sibal ji and rajdeepji are u aware of the second biggest beneficiary of these bonds ?
Sir, the supreme court judgment on electoral bond too late to be effective. This case was on transparency of electoral bond and prevention of black money influence on election. But since bjp hindutva and mandirs now have strong conection, so now on elections will be influenced by charity box of mandirs where anyone can donate black money in mandirs without any transparency.
Rajdeep naively begins the interview with the assumption that the Electoral Bond was to dispense cash and corruption and clean up electoral malpractices. Kapil Sibal destroyed this minconception. kudos to the supreme court.
If the parties opposing each other, learn about each other's donors, either of those parties when in power will make those donors life a living hell and deliberately fail them at every level.
Solution is rule of law not weaponising investigation agencies
Then the corporate house can go to the court and ensure equality and rule of law. Transperancy and accountablity is always better and the way forward than anonymity for ambigous reasons.
@@n______n26
You should have told
C.K. party before
2014 elections.
So are you suggesting only one ruling govt party should know the doners for rest of all parties..and then by your own logic they wont take it upon the donors of other parties? What sort of logic is that which works only one way not both ways😂😂
The donors are not giving free money they expect favours later on for business interests the fear will be there. The day opposite party will win they will get taste of their own medicine
Respect Prashant Bhushan!
😅😅😅😅 Rajdeep tries roo hard but fails again and again 😂😂😂
And this rajdeep character did not read the news of ex naval personnel released by qatar due to the ability of modi govt.
Irrelavant matter. Be sensible.
As a common citizen Inwant ro know What is the purpose of this exercise?....is it to find what Ambani and Andani donated. if it is so the entire exercise is a waste. A rule could have been passed to disclose all the funds donated from the political parties... Universally every political party was getting donations.....Did Congress and communist parties not get a donation. Can Sibil say they were very transparent when they were in power all through their period......Did the Congress use their personal.funds for election and not ask any corporates? I am surprised why the judiciary is also spending time on this ....If all the political parties agree to be transparent why court?. Please make a committee and see that there is no black money involved when collected....Can the concerned parties put an end to this high drama.
Now black money is nack with support of Supre Court. What is the use to public by knowing who contributed to TMC,DMK,ADMK,BRS,SP,RJD BJD etc who are Regional parties? Transparency in selection of Judges are not agreed to by SC and Collegium is their creation
Rajdeep just shut your mouth and ask these same question to PM Modi,have you got the guts to question PM Modi.
No money should play in politics...EC must even stop campaigning...people must vote silently in election
Opposition never made any issue out of this. Since every was getting benefitted from this.
Kapil Sibalji ❤❤❤❤
Thanks to Kapil sir, for exposing biggest scam of all time. And thanks to CJI for a fair awaited judgement. We elect a party to do services for the people of India. Not for Adani , Ambani or Vedanta.
Haha even after witnessing scams after scams by scamgress can u name the deal given to adani and Ambani in the last 10yrs and during scamgress
Sorry, i am not liable to answer any IT Cells of RSS/BJP, keep on trolling @@repanh1979
Seems like hardest interview of life which i won't be able to interview.
Not only these electoral bonds but there are different types of Reserves Funds in ruling party. Now Hon. SC to instruct/advice EC to amend some rules while candidates contesting next elections. It is need to note that candidate must be well educated (graduate/ double graduate) and there must be age limits for all posts also
to see this anchor failing miserably 😄😄😄😄