I haven't smelled every fragrance in the world, but I can definitely say Carlisle is the very best I've ever smelled. Coincidentally, Layton and Herod are close second and third. All PDM fragrances.
I talked to a fragrance salesperson the other day and told me PDM has been doing well since TH-cam and Tiktok. He feels people are so easily influenced. LOL! He is right. I wonder how much Ashton gets paid to hype certain fragrances.
@@rippedup4546 this is true. Have a sample of Layton and debating whether to buy it. Asked my wife to smell it and all she said was ‘generic’. I came to my senses when I realised that yes it is a generic smell.
several years late to the party here but Carlisle is incredible. this year was the year where I went from deigner to high end designer and then to niche. PDM is my brand of choice. Current favs 1 Haltane 2 Layton 3 Carlisle 4 Kalan (honestly, grew on me in a short period of time)
Kalan grew on me rapidly also , I have kalan layton Carlisle and oajan I'm having trouble buying Haltane. I was like you I moved from high end designer onto niche I would never go back now
Carlisle is the top PDM in my opinion. The complement factor is higher with Layton, but I don't care. Carlisle is rich, deep, not-too-sweet perfection.
Carlisle is my favourite PdM scent, it’s delicious imo. Herod goes really sour on my skin so I’m not a fan despite tobacco being my favourite fragrance note. I also really enjoy Pegasus and Oajan in the winter. Great review! 👍
The drydown for fragrance is amazing however I don't love the opening at all .. it reminds me of prunes for some reason . I'm glad it changes so drastically
I ordered (samples) Percival, Pegasus, Habdan, Herod, Oajan, Delina, Layton, Layton exclusif, Carlisle... All these frangrances are OVERHYPED. Don't believe the hype. I have a big family and many friends, I had them smell these fragrances... None of these fragrances induced the reaction I had with dolce & gabbana The One or YSL la nuit de l'homme. These fragrances (parfum de marly) are way too gourmand and feminine. If u like to walk around smelling like a tiramisu or an applepie full of cinamon, these fragrances may be for u... Also, Herod smells exactly like rochas men but 6 times more expensive... Layton exclusif smells like the room of an old woman, full of incense. I even bought Delina cause Demi Rawling sold me a dream (fragrance for women), this fragrance can't compare to the Chanel N°5, J'adore de Dior, ... The only positive point I have to concede is that the performance is REALLY on point. Even after taking a shower, u can still smell the motherf******. If affiliate marketing didn't exist, I doubt these would have had that much hype... I'm disappointed but happy ath the same time cause not gonna have to spend my money on a +200 euros fragrances. Don't invest your money in that sh*t...Don't be a fragrance snob, there is absolutely no difference between designer and niche except the performance but it's not worth 5-6 times the price...
The only PDM fragrance I have is Herod, and I love it. It's like the best of YSL Tuxedo plus a bonus depth that says masculine but sweet. When James Bond sat down to play poker in Casino Royale, I bet he was wearing Herod.
I went to a PDM event at Osme Perfumery last February coming away liking Carlisle, Herod & Layton. Afterwards I purchased decants of both Herod and Carlisle. On cooler days I seem to reach for Carlisle the most which will probably be my bottle purchase. They both are so closely alike that I wouldn't by bottles of both. As for Layton, I recently purchased the Alexandria's inspired expression called Royal Equestrian. This is so close to Layton that I won't ever be purchasing a bottle. Carlisle is 🔥
I have only smelled Layton, and that was after I bought it. I blind bought the fragrance after watching so many reviews. It is my favorite fragrance in y Small (but growing ) collection. I really appreciate the reviews and insight into these fragrances. It helps take a lot of the guess work out of my purchases.
Carlisle is probably my favorite of the house. The more I wear it the more I love it. Layton is obviously easier to wear in all seasons, but the depth of Carlisle wins for me.
I just bought it. I’m not impressed. With all the hype I was expecting to be blown away. I was expecting something like Royal Oud from Creed. To me it’s green apple Jolly Rancher candy, vanilla, smoke, and patchouli. On the dry down I’m mostly getting smoke and patchouli. Ébène Fumé by Tom Ford is a much better smoky-resin fragrance.
I agree with you about the first 10 minutes or so of this fragrance. It's also strange how this changes so much over time. The dry down is almost chocolatey to me, very creamy, but the opening is quite spicey.
Layton is my ATF!! I just finished trying PDM Discovery Kit + Kalan samples (2) + Sedley sample. I plan on buying full bottle of Layton and Pegasus. I already have travel size of Layton Exclusif. I am receiving a sample of Carlisle tomorrow from LS.
I was super excited to try Carlisle, but when I finally did, I was super disappointed. Just don’t get the hype. As of now, Herod is my favorite scent with Layton in 2nd place. I really want to try Oajan next.
Interestingly, Carlisle on my skin IS more of a fruity floral scent... at least in the opening. There are so many nuances to it that in my estimation, it's actually overly complex and not earthy or woody enough, and I dislike it for that reason, but I know I'm in a minority here. But it just doesn't work for me, plus my wife hates it on my skin. For me, it suffers from the problem of being all things to all people, and not picking one specific direction. Try before you buy for sure.
I really appreciate your take on this one Ashton ! I perceive Carlisle as def leaning on the masculine side with kind of a slightly sweet spicy leathery vibe off my skin. This one is great and suits me well for the cooler/colder temps. I can wear this one with a leather jacket or dressed up . . . especially around the Autumn and Winter holiday's. To date, my favorite from PDM is Layton Exclusif. If I were a newbie in fragrance however, I might give the nod to the original Layton. Again, Happy Holiday's to you and yours !
Please do a review on Kenzo Homme. It’s one of the most unique and fresh scents out there. I haven’t seen any reviewer in the community talk about it. This one deserves some attention.
Dude, I blind bought this based on your review. Just watched your video again after I received my bottle just now. I do agree the first ten minutes really made me almost to hate the fragrance, but love it after like 30 minutes. Would you also please do a Amouage Interlude Man full review
Carlise is my favorite PDM fragrance. Totally beast mode... I'm down to my last 10 ml of my bottle and can't find another without paying almost $400 usd for a 100ml
@@Cainebourne yeah I posted this back when basically Carlisle was out of stock everywhere and you had to pay basically $400 to get it . I got 2 bottles now and probably didn't pay 400 combined
If you’re into designers I’d say go for Layton over Carlisle. This is very niche imo whereas Layton is more of a gateway fragrance for those moving into niche style frags. I bought a 10ml of this a few years ago and I’ve only used half of it. Definitely not a teenager fragrance, very masculine
Nice review Ash. I've never smelled a PdM fragrance. Samples of layton, Carlisle, oajan, percival and delina arrive later today! Cant wait...most excited to smell Oajan and Carlisle.
My only issue with Carlisle is I go noseblind to it within an hour and as far as the wearer is concerned you have to lowkey smell your shirt to get it after a while, however, other people can smell you for a pretty long time.
In terms of just enjoying how they smell my favorite PDMs are Layton and Kalan. Layton's got a nice combo of fruitiness and freshness and Kalan almost smells like some sort of delicious citrus curry dish. Sorry to hear you didn't like Kalan; it's one of my favorites!
The opening is terrible of Carlisle and I also do not like the rose in it, but after an hour it becomes a great scent. I do not like the smokiness of Layton, Kalan is a great disappointment for me, so my favourite is Herod!
Yeah just tried this one after buying Layton. Not sure what you guys were smelling. But it made everyone at the store nauseous. Everytime someone smelled it they felt sick.
Hey Ashton! I have a doubt regarding the cap of carlisle? I have got a carlisle where the presentation and batch code looks all right. But two issues : Cap of my Carlisle is different from that of my Herod and Oajan bottle. In the case of my Herod and Oajan, I need to put some effort to remove the cap from the bottle , this is not the case with my Carlisle bottle. Second issue: Smell doesn't change much and projection is very poor after 30mins. Remains as a faint skin scent for another 6 hours! Could you please tell me about the cap of your carlisle bottle!
I get a kinda oud smell of my skin. A bit like tom ford oud wood but sweeter. I like herod more. Carlisle is not word the money in my opinion. €280 for a bottle😂.
Top 4? Lol doesnt sound like a strong vote of confidence. I only like carlisle and herod. Carlisle more because herod is weak. Scent wise herod is great.
carlisle is basically layton +herod+habdan mixed together as such you can be of two schools of thought A carlisle id awesome and if you have it you dont need the other three, actually there is no situation wherein one would rather wear any of those 3 instead of carlisle or B the exact opposite , i am on B team IMO carlisle is a derivative, uninspiring and redundant release , i prefer to have layton, herod and habdan and wear those separately instead of carlisle , as each of them is 1 more versitle/wearable and 2 more coherant as an idea with a distinct and unique character that said carlisle is much more cost-effective considering its 3 PDMs in one bottle,and it performs better than either of those 3 , at least on me , but it compromises on versatility, again from my perspective, its exclusively, or predominantly a winter and cold weather nights out , and formal occasion scent , its too strong and cloying for the fall, its not office-friendly , its too dark and resinous for casual use , for date its 50/50 if its too much or not i have to admit i love carlisle as a scent it does smell awesome but its not bottle/ buy worthy for me , i am much happier owning layton , herod and habdan instead of carlisle , and i really see no point or use for owning those 3 an carlisle together , but thats just me
This cologne is missing orange 🍊 peel In it. Other then that this cologne is eh. If they put orange 🍊 peel in it the. It will be better. And probably put some iris with the orange 🍊 peel. Then Wala.😉
I wasn't a fan of the opening it wasn't bad but I was underwhelmed due to the hype but in the dry down is where this shines. I got a leather Amber from the opening but it settled down very nice to a vanilla and nice spice.
My favorite PFDM hands down is Layton with Carlisle a very close second. Layton is my favorite scent second only to Dior Sauvage ODT. Thanks for your reviews. I thoroughly enjoy your channel.👍
Maybe I haven't given it enough time to evolve but it smells reminiscent of Tom Ford black orchid. To me black orchid smells better. It has that mysterious pop in it that Carlisle lacks.
I’ve smelled the entire line many times. Carlisle is the best to me, but older bottles of Herod compete. Layton Exclusif if you don’t mind the harshness is also quite nice. Gives me a headache tho
Carlilse became my number 1 and signature scent when it first became available to the masses. I literally forgot about Layton and haven't worn it since. Glad to see this being talked about finally at Layton frequency lol
fragrantica and forums of any topic are for 90's babies.. it's in the past counting myself in it. I'm updating and realizing the true power of youtubers on media....
I bought a sample of Carlisle the other day and i didn't really like it at first but, man, it's really growing on me. I think I'll order a bottle now. Great review thank you!
How long should a bottle of this last before going bad? I know some may get better over time. Pdm says three years. I was gonna buy a used bottle from someone that is 1.5 yr since first spray.
I admittedly am new in my frag journy but i find the opening challenging. After a breif period the magic starts to happen. Edit: What is the deal with companies insisting that their are only two styles of fragrance, for women and unisex? I am a dude that has no reservations in being a dude. I am not apologetic about it nor do i see it as a problem. In fact just the opposite. I told myself i would not purchase a frags from brands that are ashamed if manhood but quickly realized i would limit myself to next to nothing. Love me some brands such as Rogue that understand the point of being a gentleman.
I just recently acquired Carlisle. It is everything it is hyped up to be and is therefore one of, if not THE flagship scent from PdM. It is absolutely one of my top!
This is my favorite fragrance I own. I wear this to work twice a week... because I work remote, so it's just me and the dog. Seriously, on my skin the projection is 3 ft.+, and it lasts 12 hours on my skin, and 3+ days on whatever shirt collar I spray it on. The opening is too smoky for me, but that's gone in a minute or two. After 10 minutes it's simply fantastic, and the longer it's there, the better it gets. 6 hours in, it's hard to keep from sniffing my arm like a lunatic. I do smell the rose, but it's completely underpinned by the patchouli-tonka-vanilla combination that smells... expensive.
All sents are unisex truly and honestly but we have developed a traditional way of use, I have only smell go dolphin I dont even know what it is but I think I love it!!
Got my PdM Layton from Fragrancenet and I am not smelling the same I smelled at the Nordstrom store. After two hours I can't smell it. Will be returning it. I've ordered Herod from FragranceX will see if it smell the same as the sample I got from Nordstrom.
![ผัวเถื่อน - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P08ORRVDGl8/mqdefault.jpg)
Honestly bro, I watch other reviewers but really I value your reviews the most!!!
Me to. Most honest, most precise, most valuable.
You guys are still apprentice
@@iTZ_xalechikx5137 ?
@@TheXone7 You don't trust your own nose or opinion?
@@rippedup4546 some of our noses aren’t rich so we come here to watch content to get insight of the fragrance
Carlisle, Herod, Layton in that order. PDM kills it with these heavy cold weather-ish scents...Percival is my favorite freshy from the house.
i just wish herod had better performance
@@Mike-hy8csfacts bought Carlisle over Herod just for this reason . Might get oajan next
I haven't smelled every fragrance in the world, but I can definitely say Carlisle is the very best I've ever smelled. Coincidentally, Layton and Herod are close second and third. All PDM fragrances.
Me too, well it’s
1. Carlisle
2. Layton(Original)
3. Habdan
Demi Rawling would agree with your opinion.
I talked to a fragrance salesperson the other day and told me PDM has been doing well since TH-cam and Tiktok. He feels people are so easily influenced. LOL! He is right. I wonder how much Ashton gets paid to hype certain fragrances.
@@rippedup4546 this is true. Have a sample of Layton and debating whether to buy it. Asked my wife to smell it and all she said was ‘generic’. I came to my senses when I realised that yes it is a generic smell.
@@BourbonInhibitions You don't have to lie to kick it. LOL
several years late to the party here but Carlisle is incredible. this year was the year where I went from deigner to high end designer and then to niche. PDM is my brand of choice.
Current favs
1 Haltane
2 Layton
3 Carlisle
4 Kalan (honestly, grew on me in a short period of time)
Does Layton and Carlisle last long?
@@bsmoove2357 they do
Today I went crazy and applied Haltane and Carlisle at the same time.
It was great!
I just got Sedley and in love with it. I want more PDM
Kalan grew on me rapidly also , I have kalan layton Carlisle and oajan I'm having trouble buying Haltane. I was like you I moved from high end designer onto niche I would never go back now
Carlisle is the top PDM in my opinion. The complement factor is higher with Layton, but I don't care. Carlisle is rich, deep, not-too-sweet perfection.
Terry Hollifield agreed Sir,Carlisle is on another level!!!!
Spot a fake reviewer when they hype layton and harod.
@@huzlfinance I like both of those as well, they just fall short of Carlisle IMO.
And last 15 hours.
Carlisle is lovely, yes. But Herod just gets the edge for me as the top PDM. Layton...I just don't get the hype.
I took a break at work immediately when I saw you uploaded a video 😁 best TH-cam frag channel 💯💪🏻
Carlisle is my favourite PdM scent, it’s delicious imo. Herod goes really sour on my skin so I’m not a fan despite tobacco being my favourite fragrance note. I also really enjoy Pegasus and Oajan in the winter. Great review! 👍
I just received my bottle of Carlisle 🤔. I mean, its has a unique interesting smell. Personally Layton smell waaay better.
Am I the only person that thinks this smells like Red Tobacco?
It does, Carlisle does smell sweeter and projects more when I compare them off my skin
The drydown for fragrance is amazing however I don't love the opening at all .. it reminds me of prunes for some reason . I'm glad it changes so drastically
Blind Bought Carlisle, I wish I could say I love it like everyone else. But I get a bunch of floral. Its uber disappointing for me...
@MAGACOP I decanted 12 ml out of the bottle, it's also a tester so no full presentation.
I ordered (samples) Percival, Pegasus, Habdan, Herod, Oajan, Delina, Layton, Layton exclusif, Carlisle... All these frangrances are OVERHYPED. Don't believe the hype.
I have a big family and many friends, I had them smell these fragrances... None of these fragrances induced the reaction I had with dolce & gabbana The One or YSL la nuit de l'homme.
These fragrances (parfum de marly) are way too gourmand and feminine. If u like to walk around smelling like a tiramisu or an applepie full of cinamon, these fragrances may be for u... Also, Herod smells exactly like rochas men but 6 times more expensive... Layton exclusif smells like the room of an old woman, full of incense. I even bought Delina cause Demi Rawling sold me a dream (fragrance for women), this fragrance can't compare to the Chanel N°5, J'adore de Dior, ... The only positive point I have to concede is that the performance is REALLY on point. Even after taking a shower, u can still smell the motherf******. If affiliate marketing didn't exist, I doubt these would have had that much hype...
I'm disappointed but happy ath the same time cause not gonna have to spend my money on a +200 euros fragrances.
Don't invest your money in that sh*t...Don't be a fragrance snob, there is absolutely no difference between designer and niche except the performance but it's not worth 5-6 times the price...
@MAGACOP Stop acting like a COP.
Agreed, way too feminine for me.
@@Makiaveliiste you are fake
My favourite from PDM, interested to learn what you think of it 🙏
The only PDM fragrance I have is Herod, and I love it. It's like the best of YSL Tuxedo plus a bonus depth that says masculine but sweet. When James Bond sat down to play poker in Casino Royale, I bet he was wearing Herod.
It's interesting how in our community the PDM favorite seems to be shifting from Layton to Carlisle. I love both and most of their line.
For me its Carlisle, Pegasus and Kalan. Admittedly, I still have to smell a lot of their fragrances though.
@Surround Scent Maybe true. I also think some reviewers are highly influenced by the other.
Out of Carlisle, Herod, and Layton, Carlisle is the winner for me.
I went to a PDM event at Osme Perfumery last February coming away liking Carlisle, Herod & Layton. Afterwards I purchased decants of both Herod and Carlisle. On cooler days I seem to reach for Carlisle the most which will probably be my bottle purchase. They both are so closely alike that I wouldn't by bottles of both. As for Layton, I recently purchased the Alexandria's inspired expression called Royal Equestrian. This is so close to Layton that I won't ever be purchasing a bottle. Carlisle is 🔥
I have only smelled Layton, and that was after I bought it. I blind bought the fragrance after watching so many reviews. It is my favorite fragrance in y Small (but growing ) collection. I really appreciate the reviews and insight into these fragrances. It helps take a lot of the guess work out of my purchases.
It smells like a middle eastern version of TF black orchid
My favorite from his house so far has got to be Layton. Smells absolutely amazing. I’ll have to check this other scent out though.
Carlisle is probably my favorite of the house. The more I wear it the more I love it. Layton is obviously easier to wear in all seasons, but the depth of Carlisle wins for me.
Demi Rawling and all the other fragrance reviewers would agree with you as well! LOL!
I have it but don't get the hype. It's decent but I wouldn't buy it again. Herod is my champ. Followed by the criminally underrated Percival.
I just bought it. I’m not impressed. With all the hype I was expecting to be blown away. I was expecting something like Royal Oud from Creed. To me it’s green apple Jolly Rancher candy, vanilla, smoke, and patchouli. On the dry down I’m mostly getting smoke and patchouli. Ébène Fumé by Tom Ford is a much better smoky-resin fragrance.
Haven’t smelled Carlisle, but it is rapidly becoming one I want to try. My favorite PDM is Herod. It’s totally gorgeous.
Carlisle 1st smell to me is very floral and feminine.
I spray Herod behind my ears and on my wrists and then Tuscan Leather on my collarbones and behind my neck. The sweetest bookshop vibes :)
I agree with you about the first 10 minutes or so of this fragrance. It's also strange how this changes so much over time. The dry down is almost chocolatey to me, very creamy, but the opening is quite spicey.
Carlisle is incredible and one of my favorites from any house.
I like how Justin Copeland came out with a video and said this fragrance is overhyped.
Layton is my ATF!! I just finished trying PDM Discovery Kit + Kalan samples (2) + Sedley sample. I plan on buying full bottle of Layton and Pegasus. I already have travel size of Layton Exclusif. I am receiving a sample of Carlisle tomorrow from LS.
Carlisle did not work for me at all. I am going to wait for the new Pegasus release later in the year and buy Layton now.
@@Austin_2015 Which one did you prefer: Pegasus or Pegasus exclusif?
I was super excited to try Carlisle, but when I finally did, I was super disappointed. Just don’t get the hype. As of now, Herod is my favorite scent with Layton in 2nd place. I really want to try Oajan next.
100% agree
Agree.
I haven’t tried Carlisle, but I suppose that is about to change. Out of the ones I own, it’s Herod, Oajan, Layton, Percival, then Pegasus. Thanks!
Interestingly, Carlisle on my skin IS more of a fruity floral scent... at least in the opening. There are so many nuances to it that in my estimation, it's actually overly complex and not earthy or woody enough, and I dislike it for that reason, but I know I'm in a minority here. But it just doesn't work for me, plus my wife hates it on my skin. For me, it suffers from the problem of being all things to all people, and not picking one specific direction. Try before you buy for sure.
I really appreciate your take on this one Ashton !
I perceive Carlisle as def leaning on the masculine side with kind of a slightly sweet spicy leathery vibe off my skin. This one is great and suits me well for the cooler/colder temps. I can wear this one with a leather jacket or dressed up . . . especially around the Autumn and Winter holiday's.
To date, my favorite from PDM is Layton Exclusif. If I were a newbie in fragrance however, I might give the nod to the original Layton.
Again, Happy Holiday's to you and yours !
Yes, I definitely get a sweet spicy leathery vibe
Please do a review on Kenzo Homme. It’s one of the most unique and fresh scents out there. I haven’t seen any reviewer in the community talk about it. This one deserves some attention.
This is one of the best PDM. It has an absolutely beautiful creamy drydown.
My favorite PDM is definitely Carlisle, 2nd is Layton exclusif 3rd is Oajan, and 4th Layton
Carlisle is overhyped
Dude, I blind bought this based on your review. Just watched your video again after I received my bottle just now. I do agree the first ten minutes really made me almost to hate the fragrance, but love it after like 30 minutes. Would you also please do a Amouage Interlude Man full review
just got it and sprayed it on my skin
@@Channysupreme you like it?
You completely agree with Ashton? He truly is an influencer! LOL!
Carlise is my favorite PDM fragrance. Totally beast mode... I'm down to my last 10 ml of my bottle and can't find another without paying almost $400 usd for a 100ml
Did u buy a big bottle
@@AccentBwoy Since then I actually have a two 125ml bottles now I got for really solid prices
@@Rell40 I add one in my cart for 215 dollars and when i finally went to pull the trigger it was gonna was so mad
I can get any pdm fragrance new bottle for 150-170 4.2 oz
@@Cainebourne yeah I posted this back when basically Carlisle was out of stock everywhere and you had to pay basically $400 to get it . I got 2 bottles now and probably didn't pay 400 combined
Costs a right arm but unique✔️
I tried it once and it reminded me of Mancera Red Tobacco; which I don’t like at all. Herod is still my favorite PDM followed by Layton.
Herod is so so solid
If you’re into designers I’d say go for Layton over Carlisle. This is very niche imo whereas Layton is more of a gateway fragrance for those moving into niche style frags. I bought a 10ml of this a few years ago and I’ve only used half of it. Definitely not a teenager fragrance, very masculine
Herod, Layton, Carlisle, Percival
Nice review Ash. I've never smelled a PdM fragrance. Samples of layton, Carlisle, oajan, percival and delina arrive later today! Cant wait...most excited to smell Oajan and Carlisle.
How do you like them? Is Carlisle worth a purchase?
Update?
This last only 4-6 hrs on my skin -_- I’m hoping I got the right one LoL
Herod, all the way , fantastic dry down.
Could not agree more! Herod is fire 🔥
Not my favorite price point
Yes... any clones?
My only issue with Carlisle is I go noseblind to it within an hour and as far as the wearer is concerned you have to lowkey smell your shirt to get it after a while, however, other people can smell you for a pretty long time.
That's really unfortunate, maybe you should spray it on your Adam's apple. It radiates off me all day (15-18h) with just one spray.
@@marcelo1458 when did you buy your bottle of Carlisle
Very nice breakdown. I think Carlisle is a 10. Pegasus Exclusive Herod and Layton are 10s in my book.
Carlisle is definitely a top 5 of all time for me.
$195 2 years ago.. now $330... I was a little late :(
Dude...I just wanna say I appreciate your content .
In terms of just enjoying how they smell my favorite PDMs are Layton and Kalan. Layton's got a nice combo of fruitiness and freshness and Kalan almost smells like some sort of delicious citrus curry dish. Sorry to hear you didn't like Kalan; it's one of my favorites!
bro enjoys smelling like curry
Do some more Amouage reviews .
Really want to hear your opinion on some of the newer realises !
Great review
The opening is terrible of Carlisle and I also do not like the rose in it, but after an hour it becomes a great scent. I do not like the smokiness of Layton, Kalan is a great disappointment for me, so my favourite is Herod!
Will this work in a tropical country? I own a decant of Herod and I loved it but it seems that people prefer Carlisle over Herod.
Yeah just tried this one after buying Layton. Not sure what you guys were smelling. But it made everyone at the store nauseous. Everytime someone smelled it they felt sick.
I bought a 4.2oz bottle blind buy and ITS MY FAVORITE. Class in a bottle I call it 5 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟's
Where did you buy it from and how much please?
@@atsusanoumegah646 EBay
I keep hearing about a tobacco smell, but its not in the notes......whats that about???
Hey Ashton! I have a doubt regarding the cap of carlisle? I have got a carlisle where the presentation and batch code looks all right. But two issues : Cap of my Carlisle is different from that of my Herod and Oajan bottle. In the case of my Herod and Oajan, I need to put some effort to remove the cap from the bottle , this is not the case with my Carlisle bottle.
Second issue: Smell doesn't change much and projection is very poor after 30mins. Remains as a faint skin scent for another 6 hours!
Could you please tell me about the cap of your carlisle bottle!
Carlisle is my personal all time favorite, not just in the pdm line.
Totally agreed! Carlisle is a fragrance perfection!
Mine as well. Got a lifetime supply of it and I'll be wearing it until I kick the bucket! 👌
I get a kinda oud smell of my skin. A bit like tom ford oud wood but sweeter. I like herod more. Carlisle is not word the money in my opinion. €280 for a bottle😂.
My Favorite PM is by far Kalan I think it's smells great I have just started my PM collection I will be getting Carlisle soon thanks for the review.
Top 4? Lol doesnt sound like a strong vote of confidence.
I only like carlisle and herod. Carlisle more because herod is weak. Scent wise herod is great.
1.Carlisle, 2.Layton Exclusif
3.Herod 4. Godolphin 5.Habdan
carlisle is basically layton +herod+habdan mixed together as such you can be of two schools of thought A carlisle id awesome and if you have it you dont need the other three, actually there is no situation wherein one would rather wear any of those 3 instead of carlisle or B the exact opposite , i am on B team
IMO carlisle is a derivative, uninspiring and redundant release , i prefer to have layton, herod and habdan and wear those separately instead of carlisle , as each of them is 1 more versitle/wearable and 2 more coherant as an idea with a distinct and unique character
that said carlisle is much more cost-effective considering its 3 PDMs in one bottle,and it performs better than either of those 3 , at least on me , but it compromises on versatility, again from my perspective, its exclusively, or predominantly a winter and cold weather nights out , and formal occasion scent , its too strong and cloying for the fall, its not office-friendly , its too dark and resinous for casual use , for date its 50/50 if its too much or not
i have to admit i love carlisle as a scent it does smell awesome but its not bottle/ buy worthy for me , i am much happier owning layton , herod and habdan instead of carlisle , and i really see no point or use for owning those 3 an carlisle together , but thats just me
This cologne is missing orange 🍊 peel In it. Other then that this cologne is eh. If they put orange 🍊 peel in it the. It will be better. And probably put some iris with the orange 🍊 peel. Then Wala.😉
I wasn't a fan of the opening it wasn't bad but I was underwhelmed due to the hype but in the dry down is where this shines. I got a leather Amber from the opening but it settled down very nice to a vanilla and nice spice.
My favorite PFDM hands down is Layton with Carlisle a very close second. Layton is my favorite scent second only to Dior Sauvage ODT. Thanks for your reviews. I thoroughly enjoy your channel.👍
Herod, percival, sedley. Both Laytons smell awesome just not my style.
i hate patchouli, but i love this fragrance
so you have 77% batch here. can you make comparison with new 81%vol ?
Definitely upper echelon PDM. My #1 unsolicited female compliment fragrance.
Our tastes our very different you like too many strong strong fragrances that are bold and less inviting. Thanks for the watches ive contributed.
Right I've noticed that with Him. I Prefer More Alluring and Inviting he Prefers more BOLD and Brash. I Enjoy his Vidz but we have diff Taste
Why don't we ever hear about Darley? Got it today and it's great
Maybe I haven't given it enough time to evolve but it smells reminiscent of Tom Ford black orchid. To me black orchid smells better. It has that mysterious pop in it that Carlisle lacks.
I hope not, bc I hate Black Orchid
Perfect 10 Out of 10 for Parfums de Marly Carlisle!!!
Carlisle is my number 1
Herod is my number 2
Carlisle = Batman
Layton = Superman
Just my opinion
Fr
Hi Ashton, sorry I know this is a old video now but was wondering which PDM fragrances you would put above Carlisle please?
I’ve smelled the entire line many times. Carlisle is the best to me, but older bottles of Herod compete. Layton Exclusif if you don’t mind the harshness is also quite nice. Gives me a headache tho
Just ordered this and layton , herod and Pegasus . Thank you guys im broke now .
Carlilse became my number 1 and signature scent when it first became available to the masses. I literally forgot about Layton and haven't worn it since. Glad to see this being talked about finally at Layton frequency lol
Great review man. Received a sample and tried it. Love the dry down of this fragrance
For the summer would this be recommended for one or two sprays?
either one or two but not over three though because it fills up rooms, honestly awesome performance
herod and layton exclusif are my favs at the moment
Carlisle or oajan?
Beauty liv is got killer price to😊
Kalan is one of the best along with Green Irish Tweed...Kalan is a performer!
fragrantica and forums of any topic are for 90's babies.. it's in the past counting myself in it. I'm updating and realizing the true power of youtubers on media....
I bought a sample of Carlisle the other day and i didn't really like it at first but, man, it's really growing on me. I think I'll order a bottle now. Great review thank you!
How long should a bottle of this last before going bad? I know some may get better over time. Pdm says three years. I was gonna buy a used bottle from someone that is 1.5 yr since first spray.
I admittedly am new in my frag journy but i find the opening challenging. After a breif period the magic starts to happen.
Edit: What is the deal with companies insisting that their are only two styles of fragrance, for women and unisex? I am a dude that has no reservations in being a dude. I am not apologetic about it nor do i see it as a problem. In fact just the opposite. I told myself i would not purchase a frags from brands that are ashamed if manhood but quickly realized i would limit myself to next to nothing. Love me some brands such as Rogue that understand the point of being a gentleman.
Carlisle is pretty much Tom Ford Extreme Noir, Percival = Legend.
Could be an idea to do a vid of PDM cheaper alternatives?
I just bought this and Herod. Can’t wait to get them!
Herod is going to blow you away! To me it’s a masterpiece in my opinion
Best pdm 👍
This one is like a tequila don julio . With some musk note. But I’m not a expert in ingredients. But is very manly and strong POWER fragrance.
I just recently acquired Carlisle. It is everything it is hyped up to be and is therefore one of, if not THE flagship scent from PdM. It is absolutely one of my top!
This is my favorite fragrance I own. I wear this to work twice a week... because I work remote, so it's just me and the dog. Seriously, on my skin the projection is 3 ft.+, and it lasts 12 hours on my skin, and 3+ days on whatever shirt collar I spray it on. The opening is too smoky for me, but that's gone in a minute or two. After 10 minutes it's simply fantastic, and the longer it's there, the better it gets. 6 hours in, it's hard to keep from sniffing my arm like a lunatic. I do smell the rose, but it's completely underpinned by the patchouli-tonka-vanilla combination that smells... expensive.
Which batch u had mate?😁
I like Carlisle a lot, but I love Layton and Pegasus
Unfortunately, on the dry down this became cloyingly sweet on my skin.
Have a full size bottle of Herod and love it.
All sents are unisex truly and honestly but we have developed a traditional way of use, I have only smell go dolphin I dont even know what it is but I think I love it!!
Got my PdM Layton from Fragrancenet and I am not smelling the same I smelled at the Nordstrom store. After two hours I can't smell it. Will be returning it. I've ordered Herod from FragranceX will see if it smell the same as the sample I got from Nordstrom.
For me, i like pegasus best then herod, Carlisle, layton and Galloway have them all, love it, big fan of parfums de marly
I got the discovery set and I'm not a fan of this one. It has an apple pie with menthol type scent. Smells mature like a grandpa scent.
Where can i get vintage batch (before-reformulation)?