Unexpected Results: Charcoal Soap Experiment

Today I'm testing the results of using three different activated charcoals in my soap recipe. I'm using Coconut Husk Ash, Bamboo Ash, and Wood Ash charcoals to test today. The soap gelled fast using CPOP and I did get a bit of silicone rash due to the heat. I suspect this heated up so much from the fragrance.
I certainly get some unexpected results. I suspect this is due to a few factors such as usage rates and where the charcoals are sourced from. Let me know if you've tested yours. Are they different from my results?
I used exactly 1 TSP of each charcoal splitting my batter in 3 with about 300 grams overage for the pink layer. Approx. 666.6g for each layer of batter. My recipe used 2300G of oils.
Full recipe below.
***Test batching: I recommend doing a test batch if you're using a new recipe, fragrance oil, or special additives. You don't want to ruin a large batch if things don't go as planned! This is my test batch size. You can adjust yours to suit your needs.
Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more creative soap-making videos!
Visit my shop on Etsy: hudsonvalleyso...
****__________________________________________________________
Recipe:
Lard 25%
Palm Oil 20%
Coconut Oil 20%
Olive Oil 25%
Sweet Almond Oil 5%
Castor Oil 5%
SF: 5%
I soaped this batch at 95 degrees F with a 1.5:1 Water Discount
I did not use sodium lactate or any additives in this recipe.
*****IMPORTANT: Please run this recipe through a soap calculator for your batch size. This will give you your water/lye ratio once you input your desired ratio and batch size. You can also adjust your hard to soft oil ratio to meet your preferences. ***
Fragrance: Fresh Bamboo - Nature's Garden
Colors: Activated charcoal and....
***** Hey....I'm now an affiliate for Mad Micas. By using my link below, I will earn a small commission. This will go towards ingredients to make more soap!!
Mad Micas: Sakura bit.ly/4cROxeL

[@dianehedricks7860]

What a FANTASTIC demo on all 3!!! Thank you SO MUCH for trying this❣️❣️❣️

[@Hudsonvalleysoapery]

@@dianehedricks7860 it wasn’t what I expected but interesting all the same ❤️

[@nonnielight]

Excellent and very informative video! Thank you for sharing your research. Sakura from Mad Micas is my most favorite shade of pink. Question: where did you get your gloves and they look to be reusable? Are they?

[@Hudsonvalleysoapery]

I’m glad it was informative for you. My gloves are reusable and quite thick. Here’s the link on Amazon where I bought them. I love all Mad Micas and I’ve gone through so much Sakura already too 😊 a.co/d/8wwkMe7

[@nonnielight]

@Hudsonvalleysoapery thank for the glove info. They look like they are a nice fit. Much better than the pair I bought from Wally World. I really like all the Mad Micas offerings too!