Hat off for the organist, the builder of this instrument, and last but not least composer J.S.Bach for this sublime piece of music, Willem; you are the only one of this trio still alive who can accept my sincere thanks for this performance!
@@twillertorganprojects It's a pleasure Willem; I'm sure Bach and all other composers who has left us can continue their extra-ordinary talents in heaven! Meanwhile, keep up your good work by playing their inherited works on that heavenly instrument: the pipe-organ you're playing so well!
Beste Willem , Fabuleus gespeeld. Past goed op het Albertus Hinz orgel. Ik heb dit stuk ook gespeeld door Jeanne Demessieux. Je swingt de kerk uit ! Goede registratie en goed rekening houdend met de akoestiek van de Bovenkerk. Ook is het geen officieel stuk voor orgel maar blijft toch een van mijn favorieten. Nogmaals mijn 🙏 dank voor deze interpretatie ! Dit maakt mijn zondag goed . Blijft in mijn hoofd hangen. Ook opgemerkt op het kanaal op TH-cam geen dag zonder Bach.
BRAVO SIR! How Excellent is your interpretation of this Marvelous Bach Favorite!. The tempo you have chosen was excellent for the acoustics of your church at Kampen, and we can easily hear all of the melodies and counter-melodies. Thank you for not 'rushing' through this musical 'Gem'
Yes you are right, but I love playing organ and not all famous composers have composed for organ. So.... I advocate transcriptions in a moderate way. I mean do not make a program with only transcriptions then you are on the wrong side of the organ literature because the organ literature is rich, very rich.
Nogmaals in dit geweldige opus van Bach dat op viool de cantate en in piano-versie is bewerkt (Bach hergebruikte veel van zijn mooie werken terecht) heeft Willem zich weer getoond als een oprecht musicus en vakman op zijn instrument.
It's been 9 years since my first comment. I cannot stop listening to BWV 29. In this performance the tempo is so perfectly matched with the acoustics of the church....it just gives the listener a silent song from the heart. I also like James Howard Young's interpretation using nothing but recorders, and of course the Netherlands Bach Society doing the entire cantata....I have to believe that JSB was not only the greatest composer of all time, but even the greatest who will ever live, short of God himself. Thank you again, Willem.
I’ve never heard this at this slower tempo. I can hear all the nuances. Most other versions are much faster, I like your interpretation best. Thank you so much
I am a 'bear of very slow brain' (to misquote A.A.Milne) and my head needs time to process all that is happening in this piece. While I also appreciate other versions (eg. D.Bish) I am grateful for the opportunity to absorb all the notes. I do not think I have ever heard this beautiful piece played quite so slowly.
Definitely a "Like". The pace suits both building and the piece itself. How nice to hear the inner lines, not just a blur of notes rampaging through the building. Well done. Again it must have been difficult to reach the 4th manual and not have difficulty in pedaling - Well done.
I have no musical critique to make, except to say that I listen to this regularly and it at times makes me want to weep. I love your work and your channel. When I feel despair and loneliness, I listen to your music; and I am reminded--and I feel--that the Lord is always walking with me. (From one of your fans in North America)
Wilhelm, Bach truly set the standard of musical composition and still had influence in music of this day and age. The best composer of all time. When I write hymns, I do draw inspiration from Bach, occasionally using some of his short pieces of chorale compositions. Not just big works, mainly improvised from themes but the small short chorales is just as great. I wonder if he composed hymn tunes?
Wonderlike rendisie van Bach se Sinfonia Cantate nommer 29! Ek is van vooraf verlief op hierdie musiekstuk. Baie dankie vir u groot inspirasie. Bravo mijn heer, Bravo!
He escuchado más de 20 interpretaciones y siempre uno cree que ha sido la mejor , pero ésta lejos es la mejor con todos los tonos y notas bien diferenciadas sin apurar ni saltar notas , muchos se enredan casi al final , el sonido es precioso y espiritual todo es bellísimo y perfecto , gracias 🌹🌹💚🌹🌹
I'm positive 90% or more of the Bach we hear these days is played too fast. Back then times were slower. Much, much slower. His music also speaks for itself - like you said.
Best interpretation I could ever find. Try Diane Bish version if you want to hear a disaster from hell 🤣 Not sure why it is allowed the composer might resurrect to stop it. Hehe
Fabelachtig mooie uitvoering: mooi gekozen registers, ritmes en vertragingen perfect, spannende opbouw, zeer transparant. En zo’n mooie akoestiek. Ben helemaal gegrepen. Dank je wel Willem
That's a nice comment. Thanks for being an amazing fan! I'm grateful you've enjoyed my music and content. Your support inspires me. Thank you also for your appreciation for Willem Stroman his work for video.
Thank you for your compliments. I have translated your comments into English. You wrote: Beautiful piece, poetry in music. The organist to whom I commend is very good; the piece is pretty lively!!
How about, "God". He is a genius to play like this, bringing Bach to us, like THIS !!! Only the rit.at the end felt wrong. But everyone post 19th cent does that, unfortunately.
Superb registration of stops combined with a nice tempo and good articulation, a perfect match for the acoustics of the building. You made this music come alive with your performance bringing out so much of its subtleties, especially in the pedal notes, that are all too often lost and muddled by playing too fast and by poor choice of stops. I am learning to play a transcription of this myself on the organ at the moment, you really inspired me. I really enjoyed your playing.
cet interpretation me plais beaucoup , certainement une des meilleure que j ai entendue. ce n et pas seulement du a la perfection de cet orgue. le tempo et parfait , les registres bien choisis , mais la beaute ne s annalise pas : elle et la . merci mr willem van twillert ! pierre-xavier
VERTALING Pierre-Xavier Chassot: ik vind deze interpretatie erg fijn, zeker een van de beste die ik heb gehoord. Dit komt niet alleen door de perfectie van dit orgel. het tempo en perfect, de goed gekozen registers, maar de schoonheid laat zich niet analyseren bedankt mr willem van twillert!
jammer jammer jammer dat ik deze man nooit kan horen in Middelburg tijdens de zomerconcerten want ik denk dat hij zijn strepen wel verdiend heeft met zijn geweldige uitvoeringen van zeer breed repertoire. Altijd betrouwbaar en interessant. een echte organist, Geen showman maar een oprechte
Very grand! The tempo gives you space to do some very subtle and inspired interpretation! I have a question: why do you sit so far back? Given that you do not have overly long arms, I would think that having the seat closer to the keyboards would be helpful. But I notice that the pedals do not go very far under the keyboard, so I assume that may be the reason? Thanks so much for sharing this glorious music!
Hello again! Watching your video also helped me with a question I've always had about this and similar instruments: specifically the very large grid of stops that would be quite unmanageable for the organist. But, watching your registrant, I realized that the stop knobs were specifically designed to be easily accessible for one or two registrants. Thus, this style of console had, in effect, the first "fully programmable preset system--a human being!" Again, bravo!
YEAH!!! You rock, sir!! The whole time, I was thinking, "Man, that looks so uncomfortable the way he has to lean over like that!" Thank you for enduring such discomfort for the benefit of your audience. ;-)
Dear Sir, This one of the Best Organ Pieces I've ever heard in my Life. Wonderfully, performed. Your timing and phasing is Awesome. I come from a family of Pipe Organist,however i do not play myself: I wished I could.--Bob.
Leizig? why leipzig? The is hardly something left of Bach in Leipzig . Even his grave is fake in fact. The historic organs are gone and the inside of the Thomas Church is totally altered.
@Andrew Ernyes True, but in the western part of Romania beautiful churches of the Hungarian reformed church still are in good shape. For instance the reformed church in Koloszvar/ Klausenburg / Cluj has got a wonderful organ and amazing acoustic ( 2 seconds after clapping your hands) www.360cities.net/image/cluj-napoca-church-rermatus-farkas-kogalniceanu-organ-y2015w50
Mooie interpretatie. En het tempo staat mee ook wel aan. Ben momenteel zelf bezig met dit stuk, maar kom tot de ontdekking dat ik als uitgangstempo Guillou in mn hoofd had. Maar eens rap aan gaan passen naar dit aangename tempo ;-)
Misschien is Willem van Twillert een leraar op TH-cam. Hij beheerst alle steilen, en durft het te plaatsen. Het doet me denken aan de stadsorganist van Rotterdam
This is beyond an incredible talent. Thank you Willem
Commenting again after 4 years. Remains the best version of this piece at this pace on this magical instrument
Glad you that you are back with a special comment, thank you again
I'm grateful you've enjoyed my music and content. Your support inspires me.
perfect tempo!
Hat off for the organist, the builder of this instrument, and last but not least composer J.S.Bach for this sublime piece of music, Willem; you are the only one of this trio still alive who can accept my sincere thanks for this performance!
This is a nice comment you wrote Jan Visser. Thank you for that. Perhaps the composer and the organbuilder can hear your comment in heaven.
@@twillertorganprojects It's a pleasure Willem; I'm sure Bach and all other composers who has left us can continue their extra-ordinary talents in heaven! Meanwhile, keep up your good work by playing their inherited works on that heavenly instrument: the pipe-organ you're playing so well!
@@janvisser5850 Yes Thank you
You are a master sir! Absolutely brilliant!
I'm grateful you've enjoyed my music and content. Your support inspires me.
Beste Willem ,
Fabuleus gespeeld.
Past goed op het Albertus Hinz orgel.
Ik heb dit stuk ook gespeeld door Jeanne Demessieux.
Je swingt de kerk uit !
Goede registratie en goed rekening houdend met de akoestiek van de Bovenkerk.
Ook is het geen officieel stuk voor orgel maar blijft toch een van mijn favorieten.
Nogmaals mijn 🙏 dank voor deze interpretatie ! Dit maakt mijn zondag goed .
Blijft in mijn hoofd hangen.
Ook opgemerkt op het kanaal op TH-cam geen dag zonder Bach.
BRAVO SIR! How Excellent is your interpretation of this Marvelous Bach Favorite!. The tempo you have chosen was excellent for the acoustics of your church at Kampen, and we can easily hear all of the melodies and counter-melodies. Thank you for not 'rushing' through this musical 'Gem'
Bach, no doubt the best composer who has ever lived. He still has the influence on music today.
Such a nice instrument.
Perfect interpretation!
Schitterend. Die manuaal wisselingen met de diverse registraties geven extra cache aan dit arrangement. Heel mooi!
Bravo. I like the tempo and the light registration. Many interpretations are too bombastic.
Thanks for your comment
What an inner joy in the sound of this instrument. The Bovenwerk sounds fantastic.
Yes, you are right. Thank you
Danke, Herr van Twillert! Wunderschön - ein wirklich "orcherstraler" Klang! Wunderschöne Kirche, herrliche Orgel, schöne Aufnahme und hervorragendes Spiel! Vergelt*s Gott!
+DietrichBrauer1 Danke
Hello willem, it is one of the best versions I have heard ! thank you, this is an enchantment !
+Gilles Seyler Thank you for your compliment.
Angelic soul music.
BRAVO, bravo, bravo.
DIVINE * MUSIC.
Sincerely, Svyatoslav Bach - S.R.Bach (Germany - Russia)
***
Ангельская музыка души.
Браво, браво, браво.
Божественная музыка *.
С уважением, Святослав Бах - S.R.Bach (Германия - Россия)
Very nice! One of my favorite pieces by Bach, and good acoustics in that Church. Thank you!
+ShimiChic Thank you for your comment'.
Nice job It is good to see a Dutch organist playing a transcription. You guys can be such purists!
Yes you are right, but I love playing organ and not all famous composers have composed for organ. So.... I advocate transcriptions in a moderate way. I mean do not make a program with only transcriptions then you are on the wrong side of the organ literature because the organ literature is rich, very rich.
Nogmaals in dit geweldige opus van Bach dat op viool de cantate en in piano-versie is bewerkt (Bach hergebruikte veel van zijn mooie werken terecht) heeft Willem zich weer getoond als een oprecht musicus en vakman op zijn instrument.
Dit is daadwerkelijk het goede tempo voor mij. Wow. Proficiat.
GENIAL!!! - der Komponist, der Arrangeur und der Spieler!!! 🙏 Vielen Dank für die wunderbare Musik. 👋👋👋
Danke sehr
Thank you for playing this work at the pace intended. Best interpretation. Well done.
It's been 9 years since my first comment. I cannot stop listening to BWV 29. In this performance the tempo is so perfectly matched with the acoustics of the church....it just gives the listener a silent song from the heart. I also like James Howard Young's interpretation using nothing but recorders, and of course the Netherlands Bach Society doing the entire cantata....I have to believe that JSB was not only the greatest composer of all time, but even the greatest who will ever live, short of God himself. Thank you again, Willem.
What a fine comment, Thank you
I’ve never heard this at this slower tempo. I can hear all the nuances.
Most other versions are much faster, I like your interpretation best.
Thank you so much
I am glad you like it in this a little slower tempo, thank you for your compliments
I agree with you. 👌
ich auch!!! 👍👋
Schitterend . schitterend !
Beautifully done !! No rushing here, perfect tempo and precision !
Tony Simulinas Thank you for your compliment.
Such a beautiful, inspirational piece, and so perfectly performed. Thank you!
+Bonnie Jean Thank you for your compliments.
I am a 'bear of very slow brain' (to misquote A.A.Milne) and my head needs time to process all that is happening in this piece. While I also appreciate other versions (eg. D.Bish) I am grateful for the opportunity to absorb all the notes. I do not think I have ever heard this beautiful piece played quite so slowly.
Gracias
Definitely a "Like". The pace suits both building and the piece itself. How nice to hear the inner lines, not just a blur of notes rampaging through the building. Well done. Again it must have been difficult to reach the 4th manual and not have difficulty in pedaling - Well done.
Thank you for your nice comment
Love the smile on his chops at the end. Quite right. The performance is👌
That's a nice comment, thank you
Best performance. Perfecto tempo. Thank you.
Thanks for listening
Superbe, merevilleux et grand joeur, ouvre et orgue!!
When I hear this I could almost, slightly believe.
I have no musical critique to make, except to say that I listen to this regularly and it at times makes me want to weep. I love your work and your channel. When I feel despair and loneliness, I listen to your music; and I am reminded--and I feel--that the Lord is always walking with me. (From one of your fans in North America)
Thank you for your impressive statement
BRAVO Mr. van Twillert! Beautiful piece, magnificent organ and great player.
A skillful interpretation both of reverence and exuberance.
I'm grateful you've enjoyed my music and content. Your support inspires me.
Beautifully played-a fine recording.
Gorgeous. I love it how you put the accents in the right places.
Cada día me sorprende más la belleza de la música de J.S. Bach , y del extraordinario sonido que brindan éstas hermosas máquinas instrumento. Gracias.
Thanks for being an amazing fan. I'm grateful you've enjoyed my music and content. Your support inspires me.
Wunderbar.Ich nehme diese Cantate.
Wilhelm, Bach truly set the standard of musical composition and still had influence in music of this day and age.
The best composer of all time. When I write hymns, I do draw inspiration from Bach, occasionally using some of his short pieces of chorale compositions.
Not just big works, mainly improvised from themes but the small short chorales is just as great.
I wonder if he composed hymn tunes?
Yes Bach did, there is one which I have uploaded Johanneskerk amersfoort
Magnifique 🎶
Thank you.
Willem,je bent the "number one"..een superuitstekende interpretatie!
***** oui cher Patrice,est solennel et majestueux!
Il est d'une beauté absolue!
One of the greatest German composers.
Yes Bach is, perhaps the greatest?
Wonderlike rendisie van Bach se Sinfonia Cantate nommer 29! Ek is van vooraf verlief op hierdie musiekstuk. Baie dankie vir u groot inspirasie. Bravo mijn heer, Bravo!
Marvellously beautiful.
Imagine having something this beautiful in your head, and to be able to write it as sheet music for the world to adore :))))))
Zeer indrukwekkend,dit is genieten,wat een organist.dankjewel Willem.
Nice mix of stops! Beautifully done!
Thank you for your compliment Daryl
What a gorgeous lyrical sounding organ. Love this performance. 👍👍👍
Thanks for being an amazing fan. I'm grateful you've enjoyed my music and content. Your support inspires me.
Willem, dit vind ik echt fenomenaal gespeeld, chapeau.
Ik buig mijn hoofd voor de Heerlijke vertolking van dit werk !
Precioso , bellísimo , muchas gracias.
In Dutch you wrote: Mooi, mooi, heel erg bedankt, ik raad het afspelen van snelheid aan.
Such a great interpretation. I never thought I would hear Dupré’s arrangement on this baroque organ, but it really works here
Heel mooi! Bedankt!
Superb... I don't know what else to say...
Belíssima execução da Sinfonia Cantata 29 de Bach! Parabéns Willem!
He escuchado más de 20 interpretaciones y siempre uno cree que ha sido la mejor , pero ésta lejos es la mejor con todos los tonos y notas bien diferenciadas sin apurar ni saltar notas , muchos se enredan casi al final , el sonido es precioso y espiritual todo es bellísimo y perfecto , gracias 🌹🌹💚🌹🌹
That's a nice comment thank you
sehr gut...ist für mich perfekt ...Bach pur ..Barock
Like the tempo. So often its played like a bat out of hell. Lets the musical logic work.
Couldn't agree more! This sings!
I'm positive 90% or more of the Bach we hear these days is played too fast. Back then times were slower. Much, much slower. His music also speaks for itself - like you said.
I agree with the bat out of hell, but I think it could use just a few extra bpm
Best interpretation I could ever find. Try Diane Bish version if you want to hear a disaster from hell 🤣 Not sure why it is allowed the composer might resurrect to stop it. Hehe
@@fvlok, 👍
music or acrobatics!
its a wonderful dream to listen your music
Fantastic!
Fabelachtig mooie uitvoering: mooi gekozen registers, ritmes en vertragingen perfect, spannende opbouw, zeer transparant. En zo’n mooie akoestiek. Ben helemaal gegrepen. Dank je wel Willem
Ik word er bijna verlegen van. Dank
Bravo Willem! You always get the tempo of whatever you play spot-on! And a respectful tip of the cap to Wim Stroman for his part in the production.
That's a nice comment. Thanks for being an amazing fan! I'm grateful you've enjoyed my music and content. Your support inspires me. Thank you also for your appreciation for Willem Stroman his work for video.
Complimenti MAGNIFICO!!!
My Most favorite work by Bach and from Nederlands even Better Heel Mooie MagicalPipes
Thank you
🇮🇹👏👍🌟 • Bellissimo pezzo, poesia in musica. Bravissimo l'organista al quale vanno i miei complimenti; il pezzo è piuttosto movimentato!!
Thank you for your compliments.
I have translated your comments into English. You wrote: Beautiful piece, poetry in music. The organist to whom I commend is very good; the piece is pretty lively!!
Grazie, semplicemente meraviglioso.
The best version i have seen / heard. and the tempo is just right. Well done Buddy.
Thank you for your comment
How about, "God". He is a genius to play like this, bringing Bach to us, like THIS !!! Only the rit.at the end felt wrong. But everyone post 19th cent does that, unfortunately.
Excellent !!
Perfect! Nice clear interpretation ! Not too fast like most here. Bach would love it this way :-))
Beautifully played. A delight to listen to. Thank you for sharing.
Superb registration of stops combined with a nice tempo and good articulation, a perfect match for the acoustics of the building. You made this music come alive with your performance bringing out so much of its subtleties, especially in the pedal notes, that are all too often lost and muddled by playing too fast and by poor choice of stops. I am learning to play a transcription of this myself on the organ at the moment, you really inspired me. I really enjoyed your playing.
Glad you like it and you gave me nice compliments, thank you!
De mooiste uitvoering van dit stuk die ik ooit hoorde...
Dat is fijn te lezen. Dank voor je commentaar.
👍👍👍
Thank you!!
Taką, tak wykonywaną muzykę, trzeba teraz grać we wszystkich kościołach podczas nabożeństw, może wówczas wiara nie zagaśnie...
eccellente! !!
cet interpretation me plais beaucoup , certainement une des meilleure que j ai entendue. ce n et pas seulement du a la perfection de cet orgue. le tempo et parfait , les registres bien choisis , mais la beaute ne s annalise pas : elle et la . merci mr willem van twillert ! pierre-xavier
VERTALING Pierre-Xavier Chassot: ik vind deze interpretatie erg fijn, zeker een van de beste die ik heb gehoord. Dit komt niet alleen door de perfectie van dit orgel. het tempo en perfect, de goed gekozen registers, maar de schoonheid laat zich niet analyseren bedankt mr willem van twillert!
jammer jammer jammer dat ik deze man nooit kan horen in Middelburg tijdens de zomerconcerten want ik denk dat hij zijn strepen wel verdiend heeft met zijn geweldige uitvoeringen van zeer breed repertoire. Altijd betrouwbaar en interessant.
een echte organist, Geen showman maar een oprechte
In 2018 speelde ik nog in Brouwershaven Michael.
Really nice!
Herrlich - endlich mal mit schönem Tempo gespielt. Danke !!
+Alfred unbekannt Danke auch für Ihre Aufmerkzamkeit
Very grand! The tempo gives you space to do some very subtle and inspired interpretation! I have a question: why do you sit so far back? Given that you do not have overly long arms, I would think that having the seat closer to the keyboards would be helpful. But I notice that the pedals do not go very far under the keyboard, so I assume that may be the reason? Thanks so much for sharing this glorious music!
The lowest manual is almost in my stummick, and then I can't see the pedal keys.
La magnificencia de Bach la reconoces hasta las rocas. Simplemente impresionante!
Merci bien
Hello again! Watching your video also helped me with a question I've always had about this and similar instruments: specifically the very large grid of stops that would be quite unmanageable for the organist. But, watching your registrant, I realized that the stop knobs were specifically designed to be easily accessible for one or two registrants. Thus, this style of console had, in effect, the first "fully programmable preset system--a human being!" Again, bravo!
Well you put it nice, ."fully programmable preset system--a human being!" Thanks for the compliment for the designer of the organ, (Hinsz)
The dutch organs were designed for improvisation in the first place.
Heel Mooie Orgel this is one of my Personal Favorite works
esta es la composicion musical mas extraordinaria que he escuchado
GRACIAS
YEAH!!! You rock, sir!! The whole time, I was thinking, "Man, that looks so uncomfortable the way he has to lean over like that!" Thank you for enduring such discomfort for the benefit of your audience. ;-)
Thanks for your remarks Peter. I love the 4 manuals of course so, no problem at all... and the splendid music of Bach is also very inspiring
On that, I cannot agree more! :-)
great performance great vid too
+Alejandro Sosa Thank you
Beautiful and relaxing!
Glad you think so!
Another fav of mine. Registration is perfect. Concur with several others fine work!
Thanks again!
Dear Sir, This one of the Best Organ Pieces I've ever heard in my Life. Wonderfully, performed. Your timing and phasing is Awesome. I come from a family of Pipe Organist,however i do not play myself: I wished I could.--Bob.
+Bob Martin Thank you Bob. To listen to music is also an art
Mooie uitvoering en verrassende registratie. Gelukkig geen Formule 1 tempo, zoals zo dikwijls gebeurt. Proficiat
Dank voor je compliment
OK Diederik, ik heb de muziek gezien van Guilmant. Dank.
Bravo!
Beautifully played. I would love to hear you play this in Leipzig one day.
Leizig? why leipzig? The is hardly something left of Bach in Leipzig . Even his grave is fake in fact. The historic organs are gone and the inside of the Thomas Church is totally altered.
@Andrew Ernyes True, but in the western part of Romania beautiful churches of the Hungarian reformed church still are in good shape. For instance the reformed church in Koloszvar/ Klausenburg / Cluj has got a wonderful organ and amazing acoustic ( 2 seconds after clapping your hands)
www.360cities.net/image/cluj-napoca-church-rermatus-farkas-kogalniceanu-organ-y2015w50
Thanks Eneha, You are welcome.
Zeer goed tempo
Thanks
Mooie interpretatie. En het tempo staat mee ook wel aan. Ben momenteel zelf bezig met dit stuk, maar kom tot de ontdekking dat ik als uitgangstempo Guillou in mn hoofd had. Maar eens rap aan gaan passen naar dit aangename tempo ;-)
Misschien is Willem van Twillert een leraar op TH-cam. Hij beheerst alle steilen, en durft het te plaatsen. Het doet me denken aan de stadsorganist van Rotterdam
It seems to Bach's violin partita No.3