He says that steel is heavier, the others claim that they are of equal weight… but I would argue the feathers are of far greater weight. In their pursuit to become like the steel, they become heavier than the steel
@@oru 89 is the number of Hachikuji Mayoi (a major character in monogatari), because 8 is spelled hachi in japanese, and 9 is kyuu. In kanji, her name is written as 八(hachi) 九(kyuu) 寺(ji). The last kanji can also mean temple, and there are a couple of jokes throughout the series that reference this little detail, it's pretty fun :D
I remember someone saying the feathers are heavier because you have to bear the weight of the now flightless birds and even more so if the feathers are from an endangered species.
@@marselo1316 okay if the random quora person is right you’d need to pluck thirteen and a half chickens for a kilogram of feathers, steel is way heavier unless you take the feathers after killing some very little birds lol
Reasoning.... Yozuru : you just need a single ball of stell to get one kilogram and could pierce your heart If It was a Bullet. Oshino : Both shows the equivalent of a Kilogram and the scale is perfectly balanced. Kaikii : A feather weighing a Kilogram would feel heavier than the ball of steel and could pierce a person`s heart with ease without the help of a gun.....
@@lefroste6370 the original video is very weird to watch. it's definitely not written to feel like an actual reaction. something about it is off. the atmosphere contributes to the humor. this edit changes the atmosphere drastically.
@@lefroste6370”surreal” isn’t really the right word to describe the original tone of this Limmy sketch, edit:[although it definitely IS surreal or bizarre.] It definitely does have an uncomfortable and morbid angle to the joke, especially in the context of the original show the sketch is from. Hard to explain, but Limmy somehow makes the classic “steel vs feathers” joke puzzle have a psychological horror element to it that is much in line with the other psychological horror that makes up a great deal of Limmy’s Show. Lot of the sketches in his show feature some element of cognitive/mental decay and the fear that accompanies the recognition that something bad or wrong is happening to you, but you have lost the ability to understand what that is. Alienation from reality, existential dread, cognitive dysfunction, emotional suffering; these are staples of Limmy’s show and why people like it so much The whole sketch doesn’t even really make sense if you don’t watch it in the context of the episode because even this sketch is split up into three segments across the length of the whole episode
I like how the paper at 0:07 shows that a kilogram of steel would be heavier than a kilogram of Feathers assuming they are both spherical or something like that where the feathers would fit the same shape as the steel, just larger. Because on average the feathers would be slightly further from Earth making the gravitaional pull on them slightly smaller making them weigh ever so slightly less like 0.0001% less. It does assume that you initially took both objects spread them equally thin when you weighed them, then gathered them into their respective shapes.
I like how nobody mentioned that the setup they show has the _bag_ of feathers balancing out the steel weight. If there were both a kilo of steel and a kilo of feathers, the additional weight of the bag itself should have cause the balance to tip toward the feathers.
For me, this is the single funniest video posted on the internet. If it ever for some reason got taken down, then rest assured. Because it's lives rent free in my head at all times.
I fucking hate how much I love monogatari, i want to tell people around me about this great show but then I remember how fucking weird it is. 10/10 show would not recommend👍
As far as making something that feels like it came out of Bakemonogatari, this was pretty good! The slides with random facts and measurements (like at 0:06) were pretty good touches, and felt in style!
I feel sorry for him man, imagine you are discussing what's heavier 10 liters of water or 10 liters of mercury and someone corrects you saying "they're both 10 liters" confusing you on your understanding of weight and volume.
I honestly love the monogatari style. I don't care what subject matter it is, monogatari style of editing with a monogatari soundtrack makes it 100x more interesting.
I understand that Suteki Meppou is the meme song, it's hella iconic, _and_ it's also one of my favorites, too, but: IMO this could have been a lot better with Owarimonogatari OST instead, like "Shichigatsu Juugonichi" or "444-goushitsu" Or even just something like a touch of "Hyouri" or "Ika, Kaisou" from Bake could have worked
Add in more shots of eyes blinking, one of someone running around or looking extremely durpy, maybe an ass/boob shot for good measure. Heck, let's even have some fun and throw in a fish eye shot and a birdy eye and bottom view shot.
1 kg of はがね (steel) is clearly heavier than 1 kg of はね (feathers). Except if the extra が weighed nothing, which is frankly impossible since the dakuten marks are so heavy they make my vocal cords vibrate. Ok this isn‘t even funny, sorry! Scroll further down friend
Socrates: "But isn't steel heavier than feathers?" Lemios: "The steel IS heavier, and this can be proven both empirically through experimental induction and rationally through deduction. If you removed the bag, which is not feathers, the feather side wouldn't be as heavy and the scale would tip toward the steel, which would empirically verify that the kilogram of steel is heavier than the kilogram of feathers. Alternately, you can correctly deduce that the steel is heavier because steel is heavier than feathers." -From Plato's _Lemios_
1 kg of feather in this set up is actually has more mass because the atmosphere exerts a larger force of bouyancy on the pile of feather so you has to put a little bit more feather for the scale to balance.
He doesn't know everything. He just knows what he knows
One of my favorite quotes. Wise too
Nandemo wa shiranai wa yo, shiteru koto dake
I don't know anything, you are
-Oshino Ougi
he knows nothing, his friend is the one that knows everything
There's nothing i don't know, I know everything - Gaen Izuko
He says that steel is heavier, the others claim that they are of equal weight… but I would argue the feathers are of far greater weight. In their pursuit to become like the steel, they become heavier than the steel
In the fake's efforts to become real, it becomes more original than the original.
What is this, some fucking fate reference?
@@Cunny_Lord nisemonogatari reference
@@PedroTorres-ky2yx (Ik)
@@Cunny_Lord To be fair to you they say that exact same line in Fate
This is a genius move. Monogatari 100% would have a scene where a scale with a bag of feathers appears mid-conversation.
more like 89%
Can't forget to show all the featherless birds sacrificed for the test too after the appearing of the feathers in the studio
@@nurusds3 You mean all those men.
@@n0denzphilosophy nerd spotted
I am 89% certain that this was loosely a real conversation that took place within the "first season" time frame of Monogatari.
why 89
Yeah I feel like this was actually in monogatari… it’s the kind of topic nisio isin would write about
Maybe some dumb conversation between Araragi and Hachikuji
@@oruit's part of the joke. I won't explain it tho
@@oru 89 is the number of Hachikuji Mayoi (a major character in monogatari), because 8 is spelled hachi in japanese, and 9 is kyuu. In kanji, her name is written as 八(hachi) 九(kyuu) 寺(ji). The last kanji can also mean temple, and there are a couple of jokes throughout the series that reference this little detail, it's pretty fun :D
the giant feather with "HUGE" in all caps makes me laugh every time
Best monogatari edit ive seen
Yeah a lot of them just repeat character dialogue in the slides, this really captures the spirit of the show
@@stivaoblonskystan im sorry bro i was in a rush and i had to edit on my phone :(
Indeed
ikr it's so accurate
Only thing missing is a random pantyshot from a 10yo girl 💀
I remember someone saying the feathers are heavier because you have to bear the weight of the now flightless birds and even more so if the feathers are from an endangered species.
That's..... awesome
steel could arguably be heavier since you know theres a decent chance it was mined by some poor fellow making 50 cents a day
@@marselo1316 tbh you probably have to kill a lot of birds to get a kilogram of feathers lol
@@marselo1316 okay if the random quora person is right you’d need to pluck thirteen and a half chickens for a kilogram of feathers, steel is way heavier unless you take the feathers after killing some very little birds lol
@@aramikami is that a monogatari pfp
Yozuru: Steel is heavier than feathers
Oshino: They're equal
Kaiki: Actually the feathers weigh more
Reasoning....
Yozuru : you just need a single ball of stell to get one kilogram and could pierce your heart If It was a Bullet.
Oshino : Both shows the equivalent of a Kilogram and the scale is perfectly balanced.
Kaikii : A feather weighing a Kilogram would feel heavier than the ball of steel and could pierce a person`s heart with ease without the help of a gun.....
I like how Tadatsuru was not join the debate. Lol
Tadatsuru: There aren’t feathers or steel. There’s just you.
I like how this changes the feeling of the video from surrealist and confusing humor to much more lighthearted
how is this "surrealist"
@@lefroste6370 the original video is very weird to watch. it's definitely not written to feel like an actual reaction. something about it is off. the atmosphere contributes to the humor.
this edit changes the atmosphere drastically.
@@lefroste6370”surreal” isn’t really the right word to describe the original tone of this Limmy sketch, edit:[although it definitely IS surreal or bizarre.] It definitely does have an uncomfortable and morbid angle to the joke, especially in the context of the original show the sketch is from. Hard to explain, but Limmy somehow makes the classic “steel vs feathers” joke puzzle have a psychological horror element to it that is much in line with the other psychological horror that makes up a great deal of Limmy’s Show.
Lot of the sketches in his show feature some element of cognitive/mental decay and the fear that accompanies the recognition that something bad or wrong is happening to you, but you have lost the ability to understand what that is.
Alienation from reality, existential dread, cognitive dysfunction, emotional suffering; these are staples of Limmy’s show and why people like it so much
The whole sketch doesn’t even really make sense if you don’t watch it in the context of the episode because even this sketch is split up into three segments across the length of the whole episode
@@rondobrondoI haven't heard of this show before, but after hearing you describe it, it must be ridiculously surreal
@@rondobrondoI don’t know, the description you’ve given of the show makes it sound pretty surreal to me. I guess I’ll go watch it for myself
Oh my sweet lord. A monogatari/limmy mashup. There has NEVER been and never will be something so obscure yet perfectly targeted at me.
This is beautiful. I never expected to see Limmy’s Show Monogatari videos but I absolutely love this.
This is how I feel halfway through professor Layton games.
*_"But Steel is heavier than feathers..."_* I can feel the confusion in his words even though it's a skit lmao
Ah yes, my favourite arc, Limmy steel
Good but one thing is always missing from these edits. A zoom in one of the character's eyes and camera shutter sound as they blink
A kilogram of feathers is heavier than a kilogram of steel, because a kilogram of feathers carries the sin of killing all those birds.
The little dude reading behind the word true, just after the text said wrong destroys me everytime.
this is my 2nd favorite video on this website, immaculate editing in the show's style
what's your most favorite then
@@NotAvailablexd yer asking questions too hard to answer
this is the loudest and hardest i have silently laughed in ever
that looks surprisingly natural for the scene
Scottish Monogatari is a big need
I felt like this video reallllly captured the soul of what monogatari truly is!
I like how the paper at 0:07 shows that a kilogram of steel would be heavier than a kilogram of Feathers assuming they are both spherical or something like that where the feathers would fit the same shape as the steel, just larger. Because on average the feathers would be slightly further from Earth making the gravitaional pull on them slightly smaller making them weigh ever so slightly less like 0.0001% less.
It does assume that you initially took both objects spread them equally thin when you weighed them, then gathered them into their respective shapes.
that's weight, not mass.
@@lefroste6370Yes it is weight, the question is which is heavier, referring to weight.
Huh. KG is a measure of mass, not weight. Meaning yeah. I hadn't a clue. You have enlightened me!
I like how nobody mentioned that the setup they show has the _bag_ of feathers balancing out the steel weight. If there were both a kilo of steel and a kilo of feathers, the additional weight of the bag itself should have cause the balance to tip toward the feathers.
@@Utrilus OP has a mental disability, dont worry about it
For me, this is the single funniest video posted on the internet.
If it ever for some reason got taken down, then rest assured. Because it's lives rent free in my head at all times.
If they explained to him that steel was denser, this wouldn't be an issue
Crab weight God be like "prank time"
He's right if he said a steel is heavier than a feather. But this is plural in a kilogram form... . He has a point, steel.
Good god am I happy I was recommended this. I forgot Monogatari existed!
Captured the style so well
As a Limmy fan and monogatari enjoyer, this mashup makes me want to brush my sister's teeth
"Steel is heavier than feathers" is his constant, it won't change.
Every one of his reflexions are based on this statement.
I come back to this video monthly and laugh really hard all over again
I fucking hate how much I love monogatari, i want to tell people around me about this great show but then I remember how fucking weird it is. 10/10 show would not recommend👍
Same
The Limmy's Show!
This is the best made one I've seen so far
As far as making something that feels like it came out of Bakemonogatari, this was pretty good! The slides with random facts and measurements (like at 0:06) were pretty good touches, and felt in style!
Thank you for editing like it's an actual monogatari scene and not just copying and pasting what characters say as text.
Classic density vs weight misunderstanding.
Genius edit, lovin these monogatari memes
i love this
this one is a masterpiece
This feels like an allegory to a view on society
God I love the way monogatari was directed and this edit was on point
This is missing the random dramatic closeup shots and camera angles but otherwise... Quite accurate XD
The word he was looking for was density
i love monogatai way of flashing important info for 100ms and expecting any living human to read it 😭
Density and volume are the ideas you need to know, my friend.
I wish this video went on forever
the man is right, steel is heavier than feathers
Finally! Someone does it right! The picture blocks don't just copy paste what they say, they'll have more information and pictures!!!
I feel sorry for him man, imagine you are discussing what's heavier 10 liters of water or 10 liters of mercury and someone corrects you saying "they're both 10 liters" confusing you on your understanding of weight and volume.
Oh no. I clicked on this video expecting Madou Monogatari...
I'm.
I think I'm lost here...
Beautiful. Love and blessings!
I honestly love the monogatari style. I don't care what subject matter it is, monogatari style of editing with a monogatari soundtrack makes it 100x more interesting.
I understand that Suteki Meppou is the meme song, it's hella iconic, _and_ it's also one of my favorites, too, but:
IMO this could have been a lot better with Owarimonogatari OST instead, like "Shichigatsu Juugonichi" or "444-goushitsu"
Or even just something like a touch of "Hyouri" or "Ika, Kaisou" from Bake could have worked
it's missing some spicy quick tempo cuts, but it is appreciated
holy fuck this is done so well
My dude discovers density
0:22 don't tell me the unit mixing happens in monogatari all the time
These are so much better than the ones on tiktok
When you mistake weight for density..
I wish this was the monogatari series sometimes.
Only sometimes
damn this is way better than mine
wtf did i just stumble upon
You should have a bit more flashes and unholy amounts of words per cutscene. That’s about it.
Also head tilts
@@Kyrmana it's been a year. I've headtilted so much my neck nearly broke thrice. I'm living the SHAFT life.
This is why you need to explain mass and not just weight.
yokermonogatari
Holyshit this is the best one I've seen yet.
HOW IS THIS SO ACCURATE?
Can someone please edit all of Limmy's Show like this?
I feel like it would fit every single sketch
I am a year late, nevertheless, the only thing this edit is missing is the random cuts to close ups of characters faces
Hoping this could be a meme someday
1 kg of steel is denser than 1 kg of feathers
And some people are denser than 1 kg of steel
Of course it’s that BGM
Okay okay I need to watch monogatari
bless this video
Well, a kilogram of feathers would be bigger so it must be heavier
THIS IS SO GOOD
Never seen the monogatari series and am SO confused now
Add in more shots of eyes blinking, one of someone running around or looking extremely durpy, maybe an ass/boob shot for good measure. Heck, let's even have some fun and throw in a fish eye shot and a birdy eye and bottom view shot.
The most Schizophrenic anime ever made meets the NPC script
Monogatari but steel's heavier than feathers.
99/100
need more head tilts
Esto es magnífico
SI ES y adoro haber encontrado alguien que es un aparente hispanohablante que también lo aprecia jajaja
@@G30R6E93 en efecto, soy hispanohablante, y gracias a tí he vuelto a ver esta joya
We need more of this 🤤🤤🤤
Beautiful
The steel is slightly heavier if you account that some of the feather weight was a plastic bag
kg of feathers is heavier. add up the weight of conscience of de feathering OR killing said birds!
I love this shit oh my lord
1 kg of はがね (steel) is clearly heavier than 1 kg of はね (feathers). Except if the extra が weighed nothing, which is frankly impossible since the dakuten marks are so heavy they make my vocal cords vibrate. Ok this isn‘t even funny, sorry! Scroll further down friend
XD
steel is heavier than feathers
Wi's heeviar? A kelograam o' Weet Crab 'r 'keelograam o' Hyt'jee?
Well actually steal is really heavier, because of buoyant force
these edits always kill me
this made me laugh to hard lol
Socrates: "But isn't steel heavier than feathers?"
Lemios: "The steel IS heavier, and this can be proven both empirically through experimental induction and rationally through deduction. If you removed the bag, which is not feathers, the feather side wouldn't be as heavy and the scale would tip toward the steel, which would empirically verify that the kilogram of steel is heavier than the kilogram of feathers. Alternately, you can correctly deduce that the steel is heavier because steel is heavier than feathers."
-From Plato's _Lemios_
1 kg of feather in this set up is actually has more mass because the atmosphere exerts a larger force of bouyancy on the pile of feather so you has to put a little bit more feather for the scale to balance.
This video goes hard as fuck
We need more monogatari edits
This was awesome
This is extremely good and, afraid of being wrong, IT HAS ACCURATE JAPANESE?! 100/100