A Dual 2011-3 Server for your Homelab?? - HP DL80 Gen9 Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ค. 2021
- Thanks to EVGA for sponsoring today's video. Check out the EVGA Z15 Keyboard with hot-swappable switches here: amzn.to/36wasYD
Wanting to expand your homelab, but the thought of another aging Westmere or Sandy Bridge server got you worried? Welcome to the modern era of servers, courtesy of the HP DL80 Gen9... a Dual 2011-3 socket system, featuring DDR4 and PCIe 3.0. But should you add it to your server rack?
But first... What am I drinking???
From Anchorage Brewing, it's the What Mask DDH IPA (8.4%). Tropical juice explosion in a Hazy IPA. Definitely recommended.
Links to items below may be affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Check out the HP DL80 Gen9 (Barebones) from eSISO: ebay.to/3ebduG4
Visit the eSISO Store for any parts or accessories: ebay.to/3rkcN2N
HP Gen8 - Gen10 3.5" Drive Trays: amzn.to/3egChsf
Xeon E5-2660v3 - ebay.to/3i8JmMG
Xeon E5-2678v3 - ebay.to/3eh1yTb
Previous servers I've reviewed from eSISO
Hyve Zeus Dual 2011-0 1U: • Dual 2011 Server with ...
Chenbro NR-12000 12-Bay 1U: • A 12-Bay, 1U Storage S...
Find the parts I recommend on my Amazon store: www.amazon.com/shop/craftcomp...
Follow me on Twitter @CraftComputing
Support me on Patreon or Floatplane and get access to my exclusive Discord server. Chat with myself and the other hosts on Talking Heads all week long.
/ craftcomputing
www.floatplane.com/channel/Cr...
Shades of Spring by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.filmmusic.io/song...
License: filmmusic.io/standard-license - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
"Honey, come to bed!"
"Not now, Jeff has a new server!"
God... it's like you are here in my study!!
Cringe
Every Craft Computing video has me closer and closer to installing an actual server rack.
Or better still.. a lack rack 😂🙄
Just do it!!! 🤣
I don't have money to build a PC and I am looking forwards to the day I have server rack humming in my home
Perfect time for a homelab video! Builing my very first rack and filling it up with components.
Thanks Jeff!
Jeff: "If you're from the non Imperial sections of this planet."
My mind: "Which means pretty much everywhere else in the world"
Myanmar and America then?
@@Romnipotent not even then. Imperial is about extinct. US on the other hand, is not.
I did the exact same as the OP
Thanks Jeff for this video! I had been looking at this server for a while now and recently bumped into this video. I took the jump and now have it up and running with TrueNAS Scale.
Now, for posterity in case anybody ends up on this video (seeing that the internet content on this DL80 is limited) then here's what I did...
I didn't want to use 2 disk slots for the TrueNAS boot system and had read that this server cannot boot from NVMEs - what I did is purchased the following:
- 2 x M.2 SATA SSDs
- 2 x M.2 PCIe adapters
I then connected the M.2 PCIe adapters with an SATA cable to the 2 SATA slots that are on the motherboard and used them to install the TrueNAS mirrored boot-pool onto.
Been watching these on ebay
So happy you did a video
I love watching your vids. Keep up the good work.
I love getting new boxes in the mail Jeff, it's just a shame mine contain servers like the ML330 G7! Informative as usual Jeff, something for me to aspire to!
That's a beautiful pour!
Thank you for covering the detail about how the backplane is actually technically three separate backplanes, each controlling four drives a piece, which does screw with how you might want to deploy a server like this, IF you intend on putting a GPU in there.
This serves as a good intro to HP servers. I'm picking up a DL380p Gen8 tomorrow (2x e5-2697v2, with the rails :D). It will be the first server going into my rack.
I use to be a Data Center Engineer for HP. I loved working on those DL servers. Mostly the DL360 and 380's. So much easier to work on and configure versus Dell.
5:15 Not a problem. Torx head screws are fairly common and are less likely to cam-out/strip than phillips.
While I get that the RTX Voice was needed to make this thing tolerable for a video, I'm sure a lot of your newer viewers are probably scrubbing through the video listening for a sample of what it sounds like while running. Unless of course they don't know what an actually server sounds like to sit next to. I myself have been trying to decide on something that's house friendly. Maybe that's something you could add to your homelab series, how loud the budget options are against each other. I'm sure the original 3 you made would be the quietest given that they're consumer grade fans/PSU, but I very well could be wrong. Still, I appreciate you loading up your rack to showcase this stuff for us enthusiasts 😬 Thanks!
Lovely video as usual! Thanks again. Watch the weight buddy ❤️
Good content as always
True 😉
Heat up an exacto knife and you can cut the back of the pci-e slot and then put a graphics card in with minimal performance loss and still have the use of the upper pci-e slot (by putting the graphics card in the lower slot). Also, you could use a pci-e bifurcation cable to 2 x16 pci-e with the x16 pci-e riser you ordered. Lastly, you could get 2 more additional pci-e risers for the other 2 expansion slots that are available.
These servers are great. G9 and onwards also has that dumb RMRR fix in a BIOS update so they can be used for QEMU/KVM virtualization with PCIe passthrough, unlike the G8 and previous (there is a fix for the older cards but it's **very** tedious)
I managed to pickup an HP ML350 Gen9 tower server for $100 bucks off of goodwills auction site. It WAS a pickup-only auction, but I managed to get a 3rd party shipper to ship it to me. Came with 128GB DDR4 ECC memory, dual e5-2620v3 CPUs(I've since upgraded to dual e5-2650v3 CPUs. The server CAN take V4 CPUs which I eventually plan on putting in, but due to the current power constraints of my home, I'm kind of limited on what I can do to this thing. Currently running unraid with a couple VMs, but I plan on migrating my plex server over to it very soon! :D This is the nicest piece of enterprise equipment I've owned & I'm super excited for its potential (I have it sitting in my bedroom with the fans at their lowest settings & I can sleep comfortably & work from home with no issues)
I've always heard that HP's are very finicky servers. Can't wait to watch this one!
G5-Gen8 can be a little fiddly. Gen9, HPE caught their stride again.
@@CraftComputing The Pita with HP being of course they deny you access to firmware updates unless you have a machine on support with them. Oracle being even worse with Sun firmware.
That was exactly the deal breaker for me. I try to never use HP servers for that reason, Dell let's you download whatever you need for as long as you want and I really think they're better servers all around
@@andrewnoonan4044 Thats not strictly true. You don't get the big service packs but if you dig through their support website you can piecemeal the updates.
@@judman13 Believe me, I have been through that process. Lol. It really depends on the update. If it is a critical fix they do generally let you access. Bios updates are the most restricted and they don't always give you access to the latest of those without support. Which is a pain as generally the upgrades that allow greater memory support than the specs tell you are in the later updates. But yeah card firmware updates you can generally find a way to get. I keep a Server 2012 install specifically to do firmware upgrades on HP cards.
I just got into a dl380p with dual e5-2660 v2 cpu's that idles about 100 watts. Has 128gb of ram and I added a 10gb sfp+ card. Only mistake I felt I made was to get a SFF chassis vs LFF so i only have 2.5" drive support instead of 3.5" which is what I had already. So I bought a couple of cheap ssd's to throw in it. With the low power and the drives I chose it is actually very quiet and I am pleased with my purchase.
If you plug both PSU's in you will get a lower power draw. When the system sees there should be two available it ramps up usage on the one to cover the difference above what even a single PSU will draw. This will also spin the fans on the server down a bit.
I bought a DL80p G8 with X2 2620v2, 32gb ram, x2 PSU for $150 after shipping. It's the best $150 I've spent in a while, I've had hours of fun tinkering around. Highly recommend checking out ebay for an older server if you have been thinking about it, it's cheaper than you think.
Installing the Latest iLO4 Firmware will give you the option to use the HTML5 Console instead of .NET or Java.
Thank you I enjoyed that video.
Great machine. Have one running a dealership.. 36 inch is what mine are
HP makes a RAID expander card that is designed to carry more Drives. If your server had been configured for 2.5" it would have had 16 max slots
New server day for you is a great day for all.
That spider now resides in Sto-vo-kor!
It's fun when he drifts from his "I'm doing a TV weather forecast" voice into his "I'm having something appraised at the Antiques Roadshow" voice during that mezzanine tangent.
Opening a new server box with a D'k tahg, Glory to you, and your House
Plus I killed a spider. Victory was had on this day.
The T-10 Torx screws are a remnant from Compaq if I'm not mistaken.
All this talk of mezzanines and balconies... Does that make the SAS bays, foyer bays? :D
As others have said, if you update your iLO 4 firmware, you’ll get the HTML5 virtual console option with it.
i can confirm this , i know this is like a year old though lmao
Yes more server content
I really like the form factor of the server. Pretty shallow, and I find that for most people I converse with in small apartments or houses the shallow server chassis are the only option until you get some larger space.
My lab is right next to my desk, and also same room where we sleep so quiet operation is like paramount, unless I want to get divorced lol.
This one definitely isn't quiet by default, but I hear there is a modified firmware for the iLO that allows for lower fan speeds.
@@CraftComputing Yeah that seems like a good option. Worth it. I noticed, in the video you used RTX on the mic, due to noise. Didn’t you make a video on that before?
@@CraftComputing Was that with the original config? The 43% fan reading suggests it is boosting the fan due to one of your unrecognized non-HP cards. With no cards I would expect closer to 20% if all the temperature sensors are reading cool.
If my memory serves me correctly, that love of Torx screws is a legacy of the Compaq era.
You are correct 😄
I think you mean DEC 🤣
Wow. nice server. Perfect for homelab or small business server
I really enjoyed the video. Do you have a way to quiet down the fans? It is SO MUCH LOUDER than my Dell Power Edge units. Can you recommend an aftermarket fan that is quieter than the stock fans?
I can see a new rack system in Jeff's future. ;)
That PSU...SO CUTE!
I got 2 of the exact same boxes from eBay today dual NR12000s :)
I'm actually about to build an X99 2011-3 system. Just a single CPU for me, and I went with the 2670 v3 12C/24T and 32GB 2133MHz ECC DDR4.
Can you tell me what the minimum size of the rails is and what the actual depth of the server is?? My rack is configured with the posts spaced 21" deep and it's fully enclosed. With the doors shut and adapters I can get about 26" in there. Hoping this 2u server can be squeezed into my rack.
Thanks!
Not sure it has been mentioned, but these servers don’t make much noise at all, the catch is that you need to use hp pcie certified devices. I was using a 10g sfp card that I had laying around and it was very noisy. When I installed a hp sfp card the noise decreased a lot.
I wonder Jeff, if you could do the upgrade to the V4 Broadwell CPU's, like some of HP workstations, (like the Z840)
A pair of E5-2699 V4's at 22 core's each would make this puppy fly!
I approve the use of the D'k tahg - Qapla’
I haven't used iLO since whatever version I was using with a DL385 G5 with two mighty (lmao) Opterons in it that has long since been resigned to extra table top space next to my studio room pc desk...oh boy has it changed haha, looking great for a free option! It's *much, MUCH* more comprehensive than even the 'proper' version I had to use as I don't think there was a free option when that came out, and prettier!
I've been a Dell sucker mostly since as far as bought and not built servers
Any chance you can make an update video of what’s running on this server .
Great vid, no youtube adverts though?
you can go 4 sata to 1 SAS connector for the expansion.
This reminds me, i so need to upgrade my 180g6 and x1600.
Hello I have a gaming cloud server question.
1. How many people can run game on rtx 2080ti
2. If a user crackup the setting to high does other pcs gets slower?
3.if number 2 was yes.. is there anyway to prevent from doing this? Like making a person if even using high settings doesn't lower other users performance instead lower his.
4. Can we limit MHz to every user to not have the issues in question 3?
...I'm somehow more interested in that fabric covered XLR cable you've got on your mic.
What would you recommend for budget homelab server (running only Proxmox ) in 2022 ? Do you think that build AMD 3900x or 3700x would beat any E5 build for this purpose ?
dumb question incoming! Do you need the RAID card in order to use any drives in the system? I bought this server and it didnt come with the card in it
thanks in advance!
Volume levels are decent. Initial startup is loud but myDL60 quiets down to a reasonable level that allow quiet conversation and media playback. I have it sitting two feet from me.
try installing any non-hp disk or controller and you will have lift-off. dl380g7 here...
I think a good video for you to consider making would be about figuring out what to look for in an UPS
Would like to see more AMD Epyc content
7742 Make you happy? Because that's coming up shortly.
@@CraftComputing The mid-range Epyc can replace every server you have and then some. We just replaced 45 Gen 8 380's with one maxed out Epyc and it just Purrs. But the data center and the racks are so empty. We have another 90 units to replace as soon as Bambi and Thumper arrive (Yeah, we name all our servers after Disney animals). We are thinking of converting the data center to a Ballroom and offering ballroom dancing classes! 😋
Not sure if those are the same rails as what I used in the past g7 vs g9, but they were an absolute pain in the ass to pull out when I was moving servers arround.
Okay, I bought the keyboard you advertised (the link did not work for some reason). If it sucks, you'll owe me a beer.
You owe me a beer
New server day? You know i’m stopping everything to watch right now.
But no 3TB drives. ;-)
Because of Jeff's experiences I specifically ordered 4TB drives for my boxes. ;-)
less gooo
Plugging in non-supported PCIe devices causes the fans to ramp to a higher minimum speed, though there is a custom iLO4 firmware which should help lowering that (and the noise). Not sure if I can post links, but look for "Silence of the Fans pt 2" on r/homelab.
Yes, that seems to be what's happening here. 43% seems to the specific fan speed on my DL380pG8 when there are two unsupported cards.
You mentioned the fan noise briefly - how bad is it under normal load?
I've got some DL380 G7 servers running FreeNAS and XCP-NG with some MSA storage. These things are rock solid and parts are CHEAP. I'm an IT engineer so using these things is like slipping on a comfy warm robe and sipping a hot cup of coffee. It might be time for some new models with better efficiency and out of band management that doesn't require IE or Java like ILO 4 does.
Does someone have the dual 8x pcie riser PCB handy? I have a very samey ancient Asus board, that looks like it has the same pinout, distances and dimensions, and I would really consider grabbing one to replace my current dodgy extension and ziptie mount.
You can remove the 2nd psu post error by popping out the 2nd psu. It’s quite happy with 1.
Does any of the server options have a lot of full size pci-e slots?
Hi, I just would like to know if shutting down a server daily can be harmful or not for it, it is a machine that is only for a development environment over 10 hour daily shift, so there is not any need to be powered on at night nor even in the weekends, I just wonder if shutting down any server daily can make a damage on it through time, I appreciate any answer back as you guys have got a lot of experience working with servers, thanks
what would I use a server for or benefits I could gain from one?
Good lord how many servers do you have now? I've got four and I want to trim that down to three.
If you really want some nice hardware for the buck, check out the X3550 M4. EnergyStar certified, not super loud, 16 2.5" bays, etc. Best part? Space for a full fat GPU AND integrated 10 gig capabilities. I would kill to see you review that thing and see what you can get up to with it!
Did you have any problems getting firmware for that server? The DL360e G8 I have was all locked behind a paywall. Kindness of others got me what I needed.
that is normal. ask on reddit for a firmware.. there are guys who have full access to everything of hpe ftp ... or find a full upgrade disk online... there is everything in
@@nebuzstar thanks, I don't often use Reddit, I'll have to make an account. The dl360e that I have is running True as for storage with my XCP-NG system in my personal lab. That said, I'm much happier owning old SuperMicro machines. I have X7 era machines at work that still function (out of production now).
"as always I'm Jeff, and its Christmas year round!"
I have its little sister the HP DL60 four-bay. Overall, it's a good server. But it's got a bunch of quirks that make setup annoying. It has four drives bays but getting all four recognized is exceedingly difficult. It requires a special SATA drive that is hard to locate and the process of installing it into the operating system is obtuse and not well documented. I managed to get the firmware updated once, But when I tried to do a new update six months later it wouldn't mount the USB key (The same USB key I used for the first update). Since it's deprecated by HP (About a year after it was announced, which is ridiculous) I can't use their online tools to update it. I also would have to pay for a service contract of several thousand dollars. I reconfigured to use a two-drive SATA configuration that doesn't require drivers and installed Redhat Enterprise Linux. Works well but SABA configuration is difficult. For some reason, my windows 10 cannot see the server and Redhat won't let it connect. so I am using USB keys to move data around.
If you want a home(lab) friendly server with adjustable fanspeeds: Dell Rx20/Rx30/Rx40. I have a R720 with 2x E5-2680v2, 256GB RAM and more than 2TB of SSDs sitting next to me and I can barely hear it.
E5 26xx v3 can be forced to unlock maximum turbo frequency on all cores with a BIOS mod (UEFI should work too). Might be worth looking into.
Are you going to do a review of Proxmox 7 and perhaps an upgrade tutorial?
Looking at it ;-)
Drive trays my biggest struggle I have servers which I bought cheaper than the drive trays that I had to buy after separately
I have never seen an MoB where there is a mismatch with the number of dim slots.... That's generally fascinating
what was your solution to getting drivers/BIOS files for this server?
Jeff: it idles at 110 watts
me: *cries in german*
The thing I am not liking about HPE is that they are putting their firmware updates behind a support contract. The hardware is pretty solid, but I find it easier to update my Dells at home.
yeah i have that issue too. its a pain in the ass trying to find firmware updates. if someone finds an easy way to get them id love to know
Just checking...do those fans move a metric or imperial crap-ton of air?
They're using normal torx or the security variant?
ok.....where did u get the Klingon knife? I want one!
How do you do the RTX voice in post?
5:02
That laugh!!! :''')
Nice shout-out to techtechpotato
I believe there is an HTML 5 update for ILO Gen 3 and up?
Are you use hpe drives or is there a cheaper option?
Have you ever sold your Craft Computer t-shirts before?
Can you 3d print the drive tray?
where did you get the dk'tahg from
Installing a non HP expansion card (Quadro P2000 in my case) ramps up the fans on gen 8 servers. Is this also the case in a gen 9? Something to be aware of, if you plan on running a video card in your server.
The solution to that issue is to Just leave HP behind for dell or Supermicro.
@@nilswegner2881 This is my last HP server ever. This behavior is not suitable for a home lab.
@@VictorvanDijkNL it's Not even suitable for production use. My company despises HP Servers and we have pretty much Dell only apart from a few Supermicro custom servers. Also Dell offers AMD CPUs in their Most powerful Servers which is awesome for the whole Lot of virtualization that we utilize
I liked the video on the HP DL80 but I did not hear how noisy it was . I know you have the rack in the garage so noise would not be a problem. But I have my rack in my office and noise is important to me.
i want to do more servers but cant as money is going to get tight as im off work do to back
I bet all these are delivered when the wife isn't around. "Honey who was that at the door?" "Oh, nobody, they had the wrong house." Shuffles giant server box into the basement...
Is that just me or has Jeff become a little fluffier :D :D
So, what you're telling me is if I need to run some really basic stuff like duckdns, pihole, enginx, kemp, and an open VPN server i don't really benefit from haswell and could get away with some in expensive ivy bridge xeon E5-L cpus. Why thank you, that makes deciding what to do much easier.
How deep is this server? HP States 23.9 but also states 24.97? Which one is it?