Metternich's reactions to the French Revolution led him to the remark, "When I saw what people did in the name of fraternity, I resolved if I had a brother to call him cousin."
@theinevitable storm82 Thanks. I was wondering the same. In all likelihood he just did not want to continue with his content, considering all the nonsense on TH-cam. Many such cases.
@theinevitable storm82 Yes, it would be nice if he comes back. But so far it doesn't seem likely. People like American Krogan that keep going on alternative platforms are a rarity after all.
“The French revolution therefore was the essentially chaotic and often violent process by which political power passed into the hands of those who already possessed economic power.” - Frederic V. Grunfeld “The revolution was the culmination of a long social and economic development which… made the bourgeoisie the masters of the world.” - Georges Lefebvre
Yeah I have noticed that even with the American Revolution it was a bunch of Rich White men who hated paying taxes. The only reason they tolerated Catholics is because the Catholics are the ones who helped the Revolutionaries. Most of these revolutions are lies. King Louis XV (a terrible King) asked King George III to treat the Indians and the Québécoise as his own Subjects which resulted in the Quebec Act, ( en.wikisource.org/wiki/Quebec_Act ) which permitted the Native French their language, Religion and Laws which meant a huge Cultural disconnect with the English surroundings (they did not revolt when the Americans did as a result) and autonomy, as well as The Royal Proclamation of 1763 ( www.ushistory.org/us/9a.asp ), which pissed off the American settlers because of something to do with land and wanting to steal it. Strange how the King decided to protect them.
@@johnnotrealname8168 Very true. These revolutions where about removing the "limitations" on money and power, ie. the laws and mediations regarding morals and economics that the church and the crown granted to society. The goal was to establish a oligarchy veiled by lies of "freedom" and "enlightenment". Sad to think how many still fall for the myth that any of this was about their "rights" & "liberties". It was always about the power and material interests of a select few.
"Shortly after the proclamation of a republic on September 15, 1792, Philip of Orleans presented himself to the new communal government of Paris with a request to be renamed Egalite, and to have the garden of the Palais called the "garden of equality." He paid tribute to his experience as a Freemason for providing him with a "sort of image of equality," but gave thanks that he had now "left behind the phantom for the reality" ...The linkage was deeply appropriate. For the original revolution of 1789 that had been led by Lafayette can in a sense be said to have begun in the Parisian pleasure dome of Louis Philippe's father, Philip of Orleans : the Palais-Royal. There in the shadow of the Tuileries Palace, Philip had decided to accept the revolution and rename himself Egalite rather than remain loyal to his cousin, King Louis XVI"-James H Billington 13th Librarian of Congress
Basically yes.The middle class seized power from the decaying aristocracy and clergy.It was never about freedom and equality,just conflicting interests.
@@johnnotrealname8168 That wasn't exactly true of the American Revolution. The American Revolution was very much something done by middle-class farmers and artisans. Initially, there was a rise of rich, mercantile Federalists, but they were soon displaced in 1800 by Jeffersonians, who had their base among rural yeoman farmers and small artisans. The 'rich' who supported both the American Revolution and the Jeffersonians actually weren't the bourgeoisie, but rather the planters, who functioned similarly to the local nobles who supported the Vendee revolt. The Jeffersonians, despite their support of the French Revolution overseas, practically had a near-opposite platform from the Jacobins in a lot of ways. They were against centralization, promoted free speech, fought against Federalist censorship and brutality against yeoman farmer revolts like Shay's Rebellion and the Whiskey Rebellion. America essentially had politics that was the inverse of Europe, where the democratic Republicans were agrarian decentralizers while the more autocratic Federalists were urbane merchants. This can be traced back to the influence of the Country Party's ideology on the American Enlightenment, the Country Party having influence ironically from dissident Tories. It also helped that America was way less urbanized and didn't have a real nobility. There also was a longer tradition of democratic self-government that arose more from the grassroots local level instead of a centralized Jacobin parliament dominating the rest of the country. Jeffersonian toleration, and often full on embracement, of Catholics came from their secularism. In America, Catholicism was not the religion that threatened religious freedom, but rather it was the Protestant state religions of the New English states. Nativism against the Catholics was the big threat to religious freedom in the eyes of Jeffersonians and later Jacksonians. American secularism was also more based on religious freedom since most colonies did not have state religions. The notion that a republic must follow the French Revolutionary model isn't exactly accurate either. The United Belgian States rose up in their own revolution AGAINST absolute monarchy, not because of the Enlightenment but against it. They wanted to preserve local rule against Enlightened Despot monarchs who sought to overturn their local traditions. Sadly, the decentralized republican model was crushed by both monarchical absolutism and Jacobin centralism. There were ironically less republics AFTER the French Revolution than before it, as the French destroyed a lot of the remaining small republics throughout Europe.
Henri de la Rochejaquelein- "Mes amis, si j'avance, suivez-moi! Si je recule, tuez-moi! Si je meurs, vengez-moi!" (ltranslation: "Friends, if I advance, follow me! If I retreat, kill me! If I die, avenge me!").
@@danielbruceagra9022 God bless you brother, keep the faith. I will pray for you so that you may be favoured greatly by our Lord, and may rest in the arms of the blessed virgin.
Even with todays audiences I doubt that they could depict the pure insanity of the Revolution in a movie. Most people could not stomach it. Just read the chapters about the French Revolution in Kuehnelt-Leddihn's book "Leftism". Than you know what I mean.
The average village abbe served his flock(s) dutifully and was hardly dripping in gold. The revolutionaries were awful in their treatment of the peasant faithful as any corrupted bishop or marquis ever was. The cruelty knew no bounds once it was unleashed. Priests brought to the port of Nantes, shackled to a barge and slowly drowned to death.
Not entirely sure what to think about all this, but one thing is certain. Eternal glory to those, who fight for God! Long live the Catholic France! Don't cry, supporters of Vendée! Many gallant warriors of God died, many crusaders of faith perished, many knights of the kingdom lost their lives in a horrible way, martyrs suffered for what's right. It's true. But I'm sure that now they are in heaven, among the angels of the Lord
I know what you mean, but it should be emphasized that the majority of the common people opposed the republicans. Enclaves of industrial poverty produces broken people who can be wicked.
It kinda did for a little while under Napoleon. He restored the Catholic Church and was himself a Catholic. People say that he was a freemason but the thing is the Freemasons did everything in their power to dethrone him, Napoleon was against the bankers and they were the ones who backed The Coalitions. At the end of his life he recognize that Jesus-Christ was King.
@@basedkaiser5352 yeah I've read about that, not only he had a very repressive policy towards "foreign high finance" (idk how's it in English) He also did everything in his power to nullify the Rothschilds' Geopolitical Power, it's also true that he became a convinced Catholic in the end, on st. Helena A similar case is found with Italian unification and the House of Savoy: Even during 1860, the Savoyards were very opposed to Republicanism and other forms of Jacobinism, they also protected the "Dark Aristocracy" (Aristocrazia Nera) from Garibaldi and Mazzini's madness at some point, it was the part of aristocrats who never betrayed the legacy of Papal Rule. Even King Humbert I himself had alot of enemies since he waged war against Socialism, Anarchism and Liberal hypocrisy.
I recommend to read about the White Terror in 1815-1816. Most revolutionary leaders and bonapartists that survived to that day were killed or repressed. I think it's fair to say that Vendee and other royalists had their revenge. Not to mention that the kingdom got restored in 1814... Also, please remember that before the French Revolution situation in France was awful, it was already then not-so-very Christian country
Metternich's reactions to the French Revolution led him to the remark, "When I saw what people did in the name of fraternity, I resolved if I had a brother to call him cousin." “The French revolution therefore was the essentially chaotic and often violent process by which political power passed into the hands of those who already possessed economic power.” - Frederic V. Grunfeld “The revolution was the culmination of a long social and economic development which… made the bourgeoisie the masters of the world.” - Georges Lefebvre Beauty and harmony, under one eternal law: all that begins must end. Dieu vous bénisse
les prêtres fidèles seront défendu nous ne donnerons pas nos fils pour votre stupide guerre que ne nous ne voulons pas,VIVE LA VENDEE, VIVE DIEU? VIVE LE ROI
Just like in Russia, the revolution was supposedly for the "benefit" of the peasants, yet when said peasants overwhelmingly supported the monarchy and God the revolutionaries made it clear how much they *hated* the peasantry, and then murdered them in huge numbers, by the millions, in terms of Russia!
Nice and all, but then I need to ask what about Napoleon and Napoleon III both were good friends of the church (Napoleon I can be argued on this) , both were effectively pro authority and both had great impacts on France (for better or worse by some)
When you see Macron saying to defend French secularism in the face of islamic fundamentalism, you should know that French secularism is what led to this mess in the first place.
secularism! hah! well, can't you tell him that freedom includes freedom of belief as well? and just leave these people with different belief and religion, alone and in peace?
@@kinsou3865 Didn't know by simply by telling the truth I'll be the doom of some country I'm not even part of🤣but thank you, not even I gave myself that much credit🤣🤣🤣
I guess secularism is a much lesser evil when compared to islamic fundamentalism. If France thwarts the crescent and prevents islamism from spreading, they have my support
Metternich's reactions to the French Revolution led him to the remark, "When I saw what people did in the name of fraternity, I resolved if I had a brother to call him cousin."
I can confirm that.
S W E E T H O M E A L A B A M A
Metternich himself ended his career humiliated and hated. God punishment
Standing against evil, no matter the odds.
King
(￣^￣)ゞ
th-cam.com/video/T6zOT3IZ90U/w-d-xo.html
Manowar 🤘
@theinevitable storm82 Thanks. I was wondering the same. In all likelihood he just did not want to continue with his content, considering all the nonsense on TH-cam.
Many such cases.
@theinevitable storm82 Yes, it would be nice if he comes back. But so far it doesn't seem likely. People like American Krogan that keep going on alternative platforms are a rarity after all.
“The French revolution therefore was the essentially chaotic and often violent process by which political power passed into the hands of those who already possessed economic power.”
- Frederic V. Grunfeld
“The revolution was the culmination of a long social and economic development which… made the bourgeoisie the masters of the world.” - Georges Lefebvre
Yeah I have noticed that even with the American Revolution it was a bunch of Rich White men who hated paying taxes. The only reason they tolerated Catholics is because the Catholics are the ones who helped the Revolutionaries. Most of these revolutions are lies. King Louis XV (a terrible King) asked King George III to treat the Indians and the Québécoise as his own Subjects which resulted in the Quebec Act,
( en.wikisource.org/wiki/Quebec_Act ) which permitted the Native French their language, Religion and Laws which meant a huge Cultural disconnect with the English surroundings (they did not revolt when the Americans did as a result) and autonomy, as well as The Royal Proclamation of 1763 ( www.ushistory.org/us/9a.asp ), which pissed off the American settlers because of something to do with land and wanting to steal it. Strange how the King decided to protect them.
@@johnnotrealname8168 Very true. These revolutions where about removing the "limitations" on money and power, ie. the laws and mediations regarding morals and economics that the church and the crown granted to society. The goal was to establish a oligarchy veiled by lies of "freedom" and "enlightenment".
Sad to think how many still fall for the myth that any of this was about their "rights" & "liberties". It was always about the power and material interests of a select few.
"Shortly after the proclamation of a republic on September 15, 1792, Philip of Orleans presented himself to the new communal government of Paris with a request to be renamed Egalite, and to have the garden of the Palais called the "garden of equality." He paid tribute to his experience as a Freemason for providing him with a "sort of image of equality," but gave thanks that he had now "left behind the phantom for the reality"
...The linkage was deeply appropriate. For the original revolution of 1789 that had been led by Lafayette can in a sense be said to have begun in the Parisian pleasure dome of Louis Philippe's father, Philip of Orleans : the Palais-Royal. There in the shadow of the Tuileries Palace, Philip had decided to accept the revolution and rename himself Egalite rather than remain loyal to his cousin, King Louis XVI"-James H Billington 13th Librarian of Congress
Basically yes.The middle class seized power from the decaying aristocracy and clergy.It was never about freedom and equality,just conflicting interests.
@@johnnotrealname8168 That wasn't exactly true of the American Revolution. The American Revolution was very much something done by middle-class farmers and artisans. Initially, there was a rise of rich, mercantile Federalists, but they were soon displaced in 1800 by Jeffersonians, who had their base among rural yeoman farmers and small artisans.
The 'rich' who supported both the American Revolution and the Jeffersonians actually weren't the bourgeoisie, but rather the planters, who functioned similarly to the local nobles who supported the Vendee revolt. The Jeffersonians, despite their support of the French Revolution overseas, practically had a near-opposite platform from the Jacobins in a lot of ways. They were against centralization, promoted free speech, fought against Federalist censorship and brutality against yeoman farmer revolts like Shay's Rebellion and the Whiskey Rebellion.
America essentially had politics that was the inverse of Europe, where the democratic Republicans were agrarian decentralizers while the more autocratic Federalists were urbane merchants. This can be traced back to the influence of the Country Party's ideology on the American Enlightenment, the Country Party having influence ironically from dissident Tories. It also helped that America was way less urbanized and didn't have a real nobility. There also was a longer tradition of democratic self-government that arose more from the grassroots local level instead of a centralized Jacobin parliament dominating the rest of the country.
Jeffersonian toleration, and often full on embracement, of Catholics came from their secularism. In America, Catholicism was not the religion that threatened religious freedom, but rather it was the Protestant state religions of the New English states. Nativism against the Catholics was the big threat to religious freedom in the eyes of Jeffersonians and later Jacksonians. American secularism was also more based on religious freedom since most colonies did not have state religions.
The notion that a republic must follow the French Revolutionary model isn't exactly accurate either. The United Belgian States rose up in their own revolution AGAINST absolute monarchy, not because of the Enlightenment but against it. They wanted to preserve local rule against Enlightened Despot monarchs who sought to overturn their local traditions. Sadly, the decentralized republican model was crushed by both monarchical absolutism and Jacobin centralism. There were ironically less republics AFTER the French Revolution than before it, as the French destroyed a lot of the remaining small republics throughout Europe.
God - Family - Fatherland
Henri de la Rochejaquelein- "Mes amis, si j'avance, suivez-moi! Si je recule, tuez-moi! Si je meurs, vengez-moi!" (ltranslation: "Friends, if I advance, follow me! If I retreat, kill me! If I die, avenge me!").
My mantra has always been faith, family, fatherland
instaBlaster...
Ориентиры здорового человека
For Christ the king!
Kyrie eleison!
God Bless the Martyrs of Vendée
DIEU ET LE ROI!
@Aquilaris Gott Mit Uns,
Deus, Pátria e Rei, e Deus te abençoe amigo
Gloria a patria et filius et spiritui sanctam!
@@Lord_Machiavelli Sicut erat in princípio, et nunc et semper et in sǽcula sæculórum. Amen.
@@danielbruceagra9022 God bless you brother, keep the faith. I will pray for you so that you may be favoured greatly by our Lord, and may rest in the arms of the blessed virgin.
The "french" revolution never ended
I pray that one day France notices mistakes it has made
May God save the French. I pray that they will one day recover from their downfall.
and which French are you referring to? crazy republicans or the rest who fought against it (from all factions)
God save France! Vive le Roi!
Reminder to say a prayer for Monsieur Henri's canonization boys
Let us also pray for the canonization of Jacques Cathelineau
Gamer time
¡Que viva la Gloriosa Contrarrevolución! ¡Honor a los mártires de la Vandea!
Vive le Roi!
A bas la république!
🇫🇷⚜👑
Even with todays audiences I doubt that they could depict the pure insanity of the Revolution in a movie. Most people could not stomach it.
Just read the chapters about the French Revolution in Kuehnelt-Leddihn's book "Leftism". Than you know what I mean.
We won't be an audience nor will we be passive.
That's a brilliant book. You can get it for free (though I recommend buying it): mises.org/library/leftism-de-sade-and-marx-hitler-and-marcuse
@Based Eagle what’s worse is they cut pregnant women open to kill unborn children ,women are routinely raped and killed infants are bayoneted
Where did you learn this? Not that I doubt it but… That’s all kinds of messed up. So much for Liberté, égalité, fraternité.
Now it is time to redeem Maximiliano and the Second Mexican Empire.
Catholic History is so rich and beautiful. Thank you for making these types of videos.
He's back! 👌
The average village abbe served his flock(s) dutifully and was hardly dripping in gold. The revolutionaries were awful in their treatment of the peasant faithful as any corrupted bishop or marquis ever was. The cruelty knew no bounds once it was unleashed. Priests brought to the port of Nantes, shackled to a barge and slowly drowned to death.
Dieu le Roi! ❤︎
De la Rochejaquelein was a chad
Thanks you for tell this about Henri de la rochejaquelin
Thumb up for my ancestors
Well done, a highly underrated topic. Royalists unite?
Henri de La Rochejaquelin , great french heroe !
Not entirely sure what to think about all this, but one thing is certain. Eternal glory to those, who fight for God! Long live the Catholic France!
Don't cry, supporters of Vendée! Many gallant warriors of God died, many crusaders of faith perished, many knights of the kingdom lost their lives in a horrible way, martyrs suffered for what's right. It's true. But I'm sure that now they are in heaven, among the angels of the Lord
Tyranny of the Third Estate
Indeed
a while ago, a friend told me that common people are far more tyrannical than their government can ever be like
I know what you mean, but it should be emphasized that the majority of the common people opposed the republicans. Enclaves of industrial poverty produces broken people who can be wicked.
Of certain radicals. And then, so ironically, so many Third Estate members rose to fight for monarchy
France never recovered from 1789.
It will only ever do so when it finds back to Christ!
Dieu le roi!
It kinda did for a little while under Napoleon. He restored the Catholic Church and was himself a Catholic. People say that he was a freemason but the thing is the Freemasons did everything in their power to dethrone him, Napoleon was against the bankers and they were the ones who backed The Coalitions. At the end of his life he recognize that Jesus-Christ was King.
@@basedkaiser5352 yeah I've read about that, not only he had a very repressive policy towards "foreign high finance" (idk how's it in English)
He also did everything in his power to nullify the Rothschilds' Geopolitical Power, it's also true that he became a convinced Catholic in the end, on st. Helena
A similar case is found with Italian unification and the House of Savoy:
Even during 1860, the Savoyards were very opposed to Republicanism and other forms of Jacobinism, they also protected the "Dark Aristocracy" (Aristocrazia Nera) from Garibaldi and Mazzini's madness at some point, it was the part of aristocrats who never betrayed the legacy of Papal Rule.
Even King Humbert I himself had alot of enemies since he waged war against Socialism, Anarchism and Liberal hypocrisy.
@@basedkaiser5352 Napoleon is the action ancestor of Stalin, Hitler, Castro and other horrible tyrants in 20th century
@@basedkaiser5352 Napoleon was Jewish, he regarded Judaism highly and was descended from Jewish converts from Corsica.
I recommend to read about the White Terror in 1815-1816. Most revolutionary leaders and bonapartists that survived to that day were killed or repressed. I think it's fair to say that Vendee and other royalists had their revenge. Not to mention that the kingdom got restored in 1814...
Also, please remember that before the French Revolution situation in France was awful, it was already then not-so-very Christian country
Vive le Roi. Monarchie où es-tu? 🤴👑⚜🦉
Metternich's reactions to the French Revolution led him to the remark, "When I saw what people did in the name of fraternity, I resolved if I had a brother to call him cousin."
“The French revolution therefore was the essentially chaotic and often violent process by which political power passed into the hands of those who already possessed economic power.”
- Frederic V. Grunfeld
“The revolution was the culmination of a long social and economic development which… made the bourgeoisie the masters of the world.” - Georges Lefebvre
Beauty and harmony, under one eternal law: all that begins must end. Dieu vous bénisse
Vive le Christ Roi !
✝️ Defend Catholicism ✝️
God bless Henri de la Roche Jacquelin, a truly French hero
If you're interested in this period of our history, listens to "la ligue noire" song
"La Vandeana" is also great
Thank you for the video ! a lot of my ancestors were slaughtered by republicans but there fight shall never be vein. Dieu le Roy !
Pour Dieu et le roi!
May we all remeber the heroes of the Vendée, and their sacrifice tho maintain catholicism in such a time of parrel in France.
God bless
POUR LE ROI !!! 987-2024
Vive Dieu, vive le Roi!
Wie immer großartig und inspirierend!
Du solltest dir zu Sicherheit auch einen Telegram Kanal erstellen.
Vive la France vive le roi ⚜️⚜️⚜️
TH-cam didn’t screw with the Audio this time. Nice job as always
VIVE LE ROI
VERY BEAUTIFUL !!!😍😍😍😍❤️
Unexpected, but as usually brilliant!
les prêtres fidèles seront défendu nous ne donnerons pas nos fils pour votre stupide guerre que ne nous ne voulons pas,VIVE LA VENDEE, VIVE DIEU? VIVE LE ROI
Por Dieu et le Roi!
Insane mode. Scenario may be deleted.
What film are the clips taken from?
God bless Cathelineau
When the peasents revolt against the peasents.
You know your revolution isnt right when the people you claim to represent revolt against you.
Jacobins represented rather the poor city inhabitants, not peasants
Just like in Russia, the revolution was supposedly for the "benefit" of the peasants, yet when said peasants overwhelmingly supported the monarchy and God the revolutionaries made it clear how much they *hated* the peasantry, and then murdered them in huge numbers, by the millions, in terms of Russia!
The French "Revolution" and its consequences
Baguette xD
Oh non!
What movie did you use?
La Révolution Française (1989) and Les Vendéens (1993)
@@catosspeech134 Thanks!
Anyone know the movie used for this music video?
La Révolution Française (1989) and Les Vendéens (1993)
@@catosspeech134 Thank you!!
Gloria a los martires vandeanos.
"Spain has representated only one national idea universal: Contrarrevolution" (Carl Schmitt).
Thats is H.E.R. real nature
Vive Dieu le Roy !
What great evil, the people of God are always persecuted. The world hates God, and so they hate His people
whats the film?
What's the name of the movie?
Wie heisst das Film?
La Révolution Française (1989) and Les Vendéens (1993)
@@catosspeech134 Thank you!
Dieu, le Roi, que crève la République.
Venant d'un canard bolchevik c'est étrange comme affirmation ;)
What's the film?
The intro is from a film called "La Revolution Française," while the rest of the clips are from a documentary-movie called "Les Vendéens."
MASAKRA !
Nice and all, but then I need to ask what about Napoleon and Napoleon III both were good friends of the church (Napoleon I can be argued on this) , both were effectively pro authority and both had great impacts on France (for better or worse by some)
Lesser evils
they acted more like modern military dictators rather than actual monarchs.
Jai Shree Ram 🚩🕉️🙏
JAI SHREE RAM 🙏🕉🚩
Needs some effects
Made a version with effects. But it seemed a bit to much, so i dropped them.
First!
A medall for you
A lot of this is inaccurate like the priest and mass Vatican 2 sized host, but whatever
Mixed feelings tbh.
Very fair to think like this. French Revolution was a super complicated period
When you see Macron saying to defend French secularism in the face of islamic fundamentalism, you should know that French secularism is what led to this mess in the first place.
secularism! hah! well, can't you tell him that freedom includes freedom of belief as well? and just leave these people with different belief and religion, alone and in peace?
@@altinaykor364 you are the reason why France is doom
@@kinsou3865 Didn't know by simply by telling the truth I'll be the doom of some country I'm not even part of🤣but thank you, not even I gave myself that much credit🤣🤣🤣
I guess secularism is a much lesser evil when compared to islamic fundamentalism. If France thwarts the crescent and prevents islamism from spreading, they have my support