ULTIMATE Tire Shine Test - We buy and test ALL OF THEM (Part 2 of 2: High end) Lots of surprises!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- (Sorry about the Audio syncing issues in the last 5 minutes - I wasn't able to fix it the way I recorded it!)
Support the channel here:
Patreon.com/ScottHD
Google Docs link for MS Excel Spreadsheet:
docs.google.co...
Video of building the rig/engineering behind it:
• 50+ Product Tire Shine...
Video of PART 1 of 2 of the Test:
• ULTIMATE Tire Shine Te...
Shortcut to product times in video + where to get them:
4:33 - McKees 37 Si02 Tire Shine: amzn.to/36YOEoz
5:59 - 303 High Gloss Tire Shine: amzn.to/3nJJK5z
6:54 - 303 Tire Coating Foam: amzn.to/36TiESJ
8:05 - Ammo NYC Mud: www.ammonyc.com/
9:10 - CarFidant - Ultimate Tire Shine: amzn.to/36TswM9
10:19 - Poorboys - Bold'N'Bright: amzn.to/2UIY0z4
11:17 - Milwaukee Muscle - Black Pearl: amzn.to/3kOYDSb
12:05 - NanoCoatex - Car Clean Rubber Dressing: www.nanocoatex...
12:59 - IGL Tyre (100%): amzn.to/36Wnxdz
13:55 - IGL Tyre (50%): amzn.to/36Wnxdz
14:34 - Preproduction Sample #1 - Tire Shine:
15:39 - Preproduction Sample #2 - VLR:
16:34 - Duplicolor - Tire Paint: amzn.to/35NCwYa
17:38 - Chemical Guys - Silk Shine TVD109: amzn.to/3pL2a7M
18:28 - GTechniq T2 Tyre Dressing: amzn.to/38XL1Sq
19:12 - GTechniq T1 Tyre & Trim: amzn.to/3926ZUh
20:13 - Sonax Tire Gloss Gel: amzn.to/3nJuR31
21:17 - Adams VRT: amzn.to/3lUIXy7
22:14 - Adams Tire Shine: amzn.to/35NLPaw
23:06 - Carbon Collective - Sateen: detail-divisio...
24:21 - Angelwax Elixir: angelwax.com/e...
25:20 - Angelwax Enigma Elixir: angelwax.com/e...
26:20 - Gyeon Tire Q2: amzn.to/2KuHSiL
27:29 - Chemical Guys VRP TVD107: amzn.to/36Zpc22
28:29 - Optimum - Opti-bond Tire Gel: amzn.to/38XLmoa
29:20 - Optimum - Tire Shine: amzn.to/3fm7NUY
30:17 - Gloss It - Signature Tire Gloss: amzn.to/3lUIWtW
31:19 - The Last Coat - Ceratrim: amzn.to/3fk3Tfl
32:46 - TAC Systems - Tire Coat: (does not appear to be available in USA Market - I bought mine from Canada at CarZilla, but here is another UK link: www.amazon.co.... )
33:51 - Fireball - Tire SiO2: (could not find it in the USA, purchased from Canada) carzilla.ca/pr...
34:53 - Lone Star Tire Coating: lonestarcoatin...
36:27 - Dura Coating - Dura Dressing: amzn.to/36Wo9jn
38:28 - CarPro Perl (100%): amzn.to/3lMdKgu
39:40 - Sprayed on Ceramic Coating (Carpro Gliss): amzn.to/2KsEaGq
41:03 - .....and the winner is: - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Can't believe the best car detailing scientist in the world was banned on the auto detailing subreddit. I'll share your video on there.
Thanks! Yup. I literally shared 3-4 videos over a few months. Got warned not to do it again. Did it a little while later and got the banhammer. I can view just not post.
@@ScottHDThey're probably being paid under the table by Top Coat, haha.
Wow, that’s not good. The videos you do should be fundamental viewing for all detailers.
This has happened to countless mechanic channels under very similar circumstances. It seems to be an affront to moderators' egos that you made a useful video instead of a 20 paragraph reddit post with jumbled pictures at the top, worse UX than a vbulletin board DIY post from 20 years ago, where they have control over the life/death of your uncompensated efforts with a couple clicks. In their eyes you're not posting original research - you're trying to make a handful of bucks off the ad revenue. They really overestimate their importance and reach.
It doesn't help that most of the products on their shelves are not the winners of these tests - they chose to become emotionally invested in them to be 'the best', without investing in any primary research and testing themselves. They've probably recommended inferior products before, or have relationships with the vendors of those products, and banning dissenters is a backwards way to save face.
Instablaster.
I can not believe that I just watch tires being dressed and spun for almost a hour............................and enjoyed every minute of it.
Yessss!
I watch paint dry - for YOU guys!
Many millions of dollars are spent by car enthusiasts on tire shine products, and you've helped those many, many people spend their money wisely. Thank you, Scott!
I think you put in more work than all the other TH-cam detailers combined
Thank you!
Yep, I'll watch some of these commercials on account of that.
Two years after you uploaded this video, I send you my appreciation for such an intensive work and dedication. I went with Adams for the convenience of shipping and delivery.
Glad it was helpful! Thank you!
Wow..just wow. The amount of work in this test is insane. Apply, clean, re-apply, water test, dust test, sling test, record video, edit video, spreadsheet...this is godsend for detailers. At this moment no other TH-camr test like this with 50+ brands..which is a ton of work. Thank you for your great effort and because of this you help a lot of current/future detailers and car enthusiast. Cheers from Malaysia.
I feel like I should have paid for this video. Man, thank you so much for your content and keeping it real with us. This is truly the ultimate test haha.
He has a Patreon account for when you get that feeling.
Hey Scott. I just wanted to say, thank you thank, you thank you, for all your hard work to bring us this priceless information. You're awesome!!
Literally everything is perfect in this video! You deserve way more recognition.
The number of products,
The rigs,
The tests,
The fact you even did tyre dressings; no one usually tests this,
The editing,
The time stamps
Everything.
Bravo
Thanks for staying honest and unbiased in your videos. That makes all the difference in the world to me as a detailer watching these as research
You're welcome
Just bought some lonestar tire coating based on your video! Thanks for the time, effort and money you put into your videos. Very helpful!
Great job, lots of work but we’re worth it. Thanks
You are delivering great testing and evaluation of these products. A truly valuable resource for the detailing community. Thanks for all the time and effort spent to conduct these tests and video them. The video quality and the lighting was very good and it was easy to see the difference in the appearance of the tire dressings.
So, as a regular dude, I'm now torn between Adams VRT (and now there's a graphene version!) and Griot's Satin finish.
Thank you for all you've done for us, Scott! I hope things are good in your world and I hope you return to TH-cam soon!
This is super impressive. I appreciate all that went into this.
Incredible test. Making this video mustve been laborious and I thank you for taking the time!
Oh absolutely!! And there's two parts to it! Almost a month and a half total.
Your commitment is amazing..I appreciate your hard work
Watched MANY of your videos to figure out what products to buy, and great to see the office with z32 in the background !
Unbelievable! The time, the work, the ingenuity, ect....this channel is a jem! So helpful.
I hope you get lots of views and new subscribers for your efforts! Some interesting observations. Cheers
50 minutes? Woof, guess that explains the fewer videos the past few weeks! Can't wait to watch, thanks for all you do Scott!
Yes. This video consumed me! Haha.
Not only that I was fighting with the audio syncing issues which I'm sure you'll see when the camera is on me talking. Still couldn't figure it out 100%
@@ScottHD Great test. I'm surprised by some of the results (I had high hopes for 303 and AMMO) and I might have to try the Lone Star coating (especially since it lasts months, according to the website... Tire shine is something I miss during my own washes, if I get lazy, lol). Thanks again for your hard work!
@@peteyification Ammo seemed to do "ok" but there were others that faired better.
Thank you so, so much for your time and immense dedication. I’m astounded by the shear amount of products you methodically tested. This is the benchmark for all others to go by. Well done Scott H!
Very impressive work. I don't even know what to say, but thanks. You are the most dedicated that I have seen.
Here's a helpful tip that youtube doesn't communicate anywhere I've seen yet.
To add your timeline to your red video timebar, put "0:00 Intro" at the top, followed by the rest of your time stamps. The video will automatically adjust it's timebar and add whatever text you have after the X:XX time.
This
^Second this
Best tire dressing review so much brand and so relevant to know ! Keep your good work!
How is this self promoting?!
Wow! What a colossal undertaking! Thank you for this. I wish the best performers were economical for pro use. It seems they're only pkgd for retail sales. The best performer I've found in all categories that's pkgd for commercial use is Beyond Black by Surf City Garage but they just discontinued it.
Retest the Duplicolor Tire Paint with a foam / microfiber application method - it's MUCH better that way! Very uniform.
Getting shine is simple, making it last isn’t. Longevity is the most important factor.
Very well done Scott. I just placed an order for Lone Star Hi Gloss.
What did you pay?
Just be sure you prep the tires very well. That seems to be the key for them working well. (Basically follow the instructions and you'll be good!)
Great video. Thank you for taking the time to do all of that.
If anyone wants the winner of them all, he tells you at 41:20
Your level of effort is amazing! Never stop!!
Motorkote tire shine is one that a local guy said is best, and he’s tried them all he said recently.
I’ll try it and this guys favorites too.
Great video.
Super video! I applauded for $5.00 👏👏
I'd never heard of Lone Star before. I'll definitely be getting some.
wow that videos is a pearl*
I'm always looking for a good tire shine . Good video.
Hi Scott! Will you please do a video of the best “interior detail” so many and would like to narrow it down just like this video. Great work!
I can add it in the queue of things to test for sure!
@@ScottHD that would be great to know also... thank you, Scott.. you're the man... there are so many that claim they work great.. I have used Armor all most of my life till recently and I am finding out people are saying Armor all may be the reason my dash's crack after all these years, I almost want to sue them, if that's true... all the dashes I have ruined for using their products.. makes me almost mad over it.. I wish someone could prove whether it does ruin your Dash or not cause that would be a hell of a lawsuit, to figure that one out... lol
Outstanding video. Robust method, the results sheet is very helpful. Kudos to you, real skill in this experiment and video
Wow that a lot of tire shines
Man that is just crazy how many hours you put into all this for us Scott.. I so very much appreciate your time and I will be sending you some funds for your time man might be a few weeks till I get paid but I will be donating... But Thank you, Scott.. you're the man.. I watch you and "Pan the organizer" about the only 2 I listen to for products.. I trust you guys.. pan does get paid but he is at least honest about it.. The thing pan doesn't really do and You do.. he doesn't do longevity really.. he will do the chemical test but ya hardly ever see longevity test out of him.. as to where you do that... and to me, that's a lot more important.. the chemical thing is a maybe that will happen.. how long a product lasts is a lot more important to me, then if another chemical will kill the wax/ceramic or not.. just my opinion..
Thank you for posting this informative video and really great unbiased work. Looking at the google sheet, seems that Last Coat nailed it on all except Dust. Surprised it wasn’t one of your top choices after Lone Star!
One of the best videos I have watched to the end and what good is a tire product if it is not water resistant ; it rains everywhere .
Thanks a lot for these videos again, you're an amazing fountain of information
I thought that for the longevity test you could do half and half tire with different products and that would mean you can test 8 at a time for every car, even you could split it on 3 sections and do 12 at a time!
Looks like you put a lot of hard work and thought into this one. I’ve been looking for the best tire dressings on the market and you made that a whole lot easier on me! Thanks!
One dressing that should be included, but hard to find, is Dodo Juice Tyromania. By far one of my favorite ones to use.
Thank you for all the hard work. One of the best!
bummer i didnt make the lineup. i got alot left of the gallon Meguiar’s D170 HYPER DRESSING so it will be awhile before i buy more. always wondered about the sling if any from it. Thanks and keep up the good work.
Haven’t tried the first pick out of the bunch but I can back up Dura dressing. Great product! Will never go back to anything else.
Side note if you have tire lettering on it, it’ll help coat and preserve that as well. Keep it away from yellowing and repel from the elements.
Great to know!
Next run please consider *Renew Protect GLOZ*. I find it VERY comparable to the two winners here. GREAT work and thank you for your testing.
I use 902 uni-blue from stinger chemical. I apply it wet, let it marinate till I'm almost done with my detail and take a microfiber and wipe up the extra so there would be no sling
You put so much hard work into this video, imma subscribe!
Gonna grab some T1 and VRT because of this. Thanks Scott
Amazing video Scott! So much time and effort put into it! 👊
I was blown away about Lone Star and TAC System! Disappointed about Fireball and Optimum! 😵
Wish you had a chance to test Optimum Tire Protection & Coating and Auto Fanatic Holeshot. 😐
That poor tire though... It got hammered! 🤣
TAC puts out some great products
cheers Scott. love these real world mega comparisons! really appreciated
Thank you Scott for such an extensive video! Chiming in on the Duplicolor Tire Paint, I have bought 4 cans of it and each had a different spray pattern or mixture. One can would not spray right unless you were shaking the can while spraying, even then it was like sprayed on orange peel. The first can I had was the only one that sprayed with a fine uniform coating requiring only 1 coat, the other 3 did not. So something is up with the nozzles and/or mixture. Might check out the Lonestar one if and when the Duplicolor wears off.
Definitely! Thank you for the input. I was struggling with the tire paint and others have said similar things that the key is uniformity and it is hard to get!
Much appreciate all your time and effort
I wonder how the Lone Star Gloss coating is for dust resistance? Was getting ready to order the Griots from part one until I saw the results of the Lone Star! Wow! Even the matte finish is pretty shiny. Great videos!
This is the tire dressing master test, great job, thanks for your effort and your time dedication. Happy new year from Guadalajara, Mexico
Awesome work scott! Thank you so much for your videos
Hey Scott. Love your videos.
Re constructive criticism.
The margin of error re sling seems quite large on these tests. Paper weights varrying by .07 seems minimal. But when you are looking at products that sling between .003 and .5g. It seems too me like recording the paper weights pre and post sling would be more accurate (altho monotous pay a shop hamd.too weight paper maybe?)
Also re the dust testing. Some of the dust results really surprise me. I live in northern alberta. Being surrounded in farmland and lots of.oilfield traffic dragging mud onto the highways means dust accumulation is a big factor for me.
I feel that the dust accumulation on many of these products is much different at speeds then they are while standing still. Maybe next time spin them up? And then deploy a predetermined weight of dust near the tire too see what sticks? I think ot would take some experimentation too find the most aggressive way too deploy the dust. But i dont feel that throwing random amounts of dust at the products in a random pattern is not the most accurate representation of things/testing methodology.
CP perl for example seemed too be very attractive too dust in this test. Which does not line up with my testing up here?
Awesome video as always and i know a pile of work went into both videos. Keep up the good work. I wish i had the time too do more testing like this myself
Thanks for all your detailed information.
Thanks for the dedication and hard work.
Thanks for watching and being a subscriber!
Great info due to your hard word
Thank you!
Once again, thank you thank you thank you for your work in putting this video together.
I'm not sure if in the past you have done reviews on wheel and tire cleaners. There are so many different products out there so I was wondering if you have a personal recommendation for such a product. Could this also be a possible future video idea?
Amazing job scott! Many products ive never heard of. Gyeon tire ive got good results with but it was quite weak here.
My favorite have been Angelwax Elixr and TAC Tire Coat. Thanks for the video!!
You're welcome!
Big thank you!!!
Great video. I used adams Tire Shine and VRT alot, but have switched to Carpro Perl (1:1 generally) and have found it to outlast adams. Having a few years use with both products. Thanks for all the info.
We use Perl as well in our shop, but I use it at 100% usually, and frequently on engine bay plastics. It definitely attracts dust, however. I would imagine 1:1 it would be a little better in that regard.
Great effort man. Thanks for such an informative video.
Great job Scott! I am going, to be honest, I had a hard time sitting these tire shine videos thru ( along with the plastic dress-up videos). Probably because I don't use dress up nor tire shine products. I have my cars wrapped and slinging is a big no-no but I might give the lone star a try. I don't like the super wet look anyway.
I tried to shorten them down as much as possible but with so many in here, I can only do so much!
@@ScottHD I know.. i know. way too many products and not as easy to test as other ones.
When i used to detail cars at the Freidman Toyota in des moines,iowa back in 90/91, we had this blue tire dressing that smelled like vanilla. Ive never seen anything up and til today that could be used inside and out that lasted that long. Im interested dude, show us what ya got!👍
You got to add D3Renew Black , renew satin and Gloz
Great job Thanks for doing this.
Loved the video but the next time you do this type of video on rubber, can you let it sit over night? Normally we don’t wash our car 30 min after dressing the tires...maybe this would help the longevity of the shine..
No ETHOS Tire Shine???
After trying a dozen or more over the past few decades, that is the one I like the best and have settled on as my go-to.
Scott, Amazing work. You mentioned a google sheet, but I couldn't find the link. Can you kindly post that? Thanks!
would be better for us if you made a chart table with scores of all products so we can see based on score and price. thanks for the review
In hindsight yes, I agree. My current tests have much better spreadsheets and results. Check out my cordless polishers test, for example on TH-cam.com/ScottHD
Thx for that informative video!
Wow nice work man.
Thank you. Thanks for watching and for being a subscriber!
Thanks for your work on this!
Witch brand lasted the longest?
Excellent video, my friend, can't believe what I'm reading about you being banned from a certain subreddit.
That's correct!
Thank you for this!!!!!! 🙏
Thank you Scott
Man that tire is knackered. All of them looked like 💩 and patchy 😬
It's a pity they don't sell does two in the Netherlands.
One of the best video
Dupli color also got the same numbers as the nr1😮
Epic, thank you
love the Channel thank you for what you do! have you tried the chemical guys blue guard tire shine? looking into getting it, but not sure how it would perform!
thanks again!
I've been using Adam's VRT for years but unfortunately the product isn't shelf stable over a year or two, especially in an unconditioned garage. The product separates and it doesn't seem possible to get it well-mixed again. I also would like a look closer to what the Lone Star provides. The VRT looks great at first, but as it wears off it looks uglier than pre-coating.
The fact that I watched both these videos back to back lol. My gf asked me how I watch these long videos... My response "cuz.... It's science b***h" (Jesse pinkman reference)
The man!!!
THANK you!!!!
I don't understand how you test this many products and NOT HAVE MAGUIRE'S HYPER DRESSING D170 ??? seriously bro please explain.
Tremendous job !!
You didn't get CarPro blackout?
EZ Car Care Revolution is my favourite. Where was this in your test? 😪
Me as a GTechniqT1 guy before watching, oh fuck, there's some stiff competition. After watching....better step up my game to T2.
I really want to see armor all extreme shield
41:04 and the winner is...
Great video! I’m now subscribed. Seeing is believing. Any experience from others on the durability of lone star?