Actually, that is not unusual. Other countries where the military is in charge includes Egypt, Myanmar and several African countries recently, Twenty or thirty years ago, there were several dozen, to include Argentina, whose Junta failed after the disasterous Falklands War. Taiwan, Chile, and Bangladesh was under rmilitary control until about 1990, give or take. Indonesia was run by a junta until the late 90's. And if you go to the Dark Ages, that ws the norm. The various kings and their vassals wer essentially military men with a military body under their direct command. They often lead their men at arms into battle themselves.
WOW. How she described India as a country led by Hindu Nationalist, instead of saying largest democracy. She also forgot to mention how USA, UK and west countries are also involved in making of Pakistan what it is today.
DW leaving Jammu, Kashmir, Ladakh, and Arunachal Pradesh out of India's map; the Indian media should leave East Germany, Bavaria, and Austria out of Germany's map. Yes, Austria is already not shown as part of Germany but Germany and Austria are supposed to be one; the way that India and Nepal are supposed to be one, the way that China and Taiwan are supposed to be one, the way that North Korea and South Korea are supposed to be one. Long Live India, China, Korea, and Germany.
As a Pakistani I am sure that Pakistan is not becoming a failed state Pakistan is already a failed state(Not only economically,But Socially,as a society,as a nation)
@@mjking699 I don't see it in any other way. Tbh Pakistanis don't have an identity, they did everything that was forbidden by the creator of Pakistan. I fathom if Mr Jinnah was alive today, what he could have said about Pakistan
If your population is skyrocketing, you don't need an army and win a war. You go to the continent that doesn't guard its borders, and it's population doesn't make children, and you conquer them.
@@vinsin328 The 1947 war stopped immediately with Indian intervention. The Maharaja of Kashmir lost not India How convenient of you to forget 1971 You won the Afghan war in 2020? Weren't you supposed to be a US ally? How come the talibans want to invade you now? You are laughing stock
@vinsin328 1947 war of Kashmir was fought on kashmir that wasn't indian land at that time so how did the pakistanis won that war India still controls 3/4 of jammu kashmir and all the river water
I am from Afghanistan 🇦🇫. I heard that in 1971 some 93 thousands pak army trousers were removed in East pakistan ( Bangladesh) those trousers are kept in Indian war museum. Is that true? Any Indian brother or sister have any clue?😂
Curiously no mention of the many, many billions China has loaned the Pakistani military. They have provided everything from subs, to ships, to radar systems, warplanes, ect. It's huge! The silence on this issue is deafening!!
Pakistan is paying a price for the greed of those at top. They even supported martial law. So patriotic. Now got poverty for it. No schemes for them. Their education. But elite has bought huge property in London,Dubai,Canada,Australia
DW, CBS, new york times, brain-washington post and all the other liberal pseudo secular news channels JUST NEVER LEARN .. and when someone counters them with facts n logic ...they are hindu national or RSS....lmao
What democracy, not even 1 prime minister has completed its tenure, Pakistan had the option to buy cheap discount fuel from Russia,just like the EU brought indirectly from other countries 😅
They have been cozying up with azerbaijan who is laundering Russian oil to Europe, but looks like they need to do more than kissing a dictator’s a$$ to get cheap gas.
If EU was minting money like India by buying by buying discounted Russian fuel from third parties (like India), then why there is a rampant inflation in West and EU in particular.? These things don't fix economy. Even filip to India didn't last.
I live in Geneva, Switzerland. If you look at maps of India or China on Google Maps right here, Arunachal is shown as disputed territory with a dotted line all around it; this isn't a quirk specific to Deutsche Welle and is standard across most of the world. China is just far more influential than us on the global stage.
You won't believe but these leeches are funded by common people in Germany. We pay a radio fee to fund such poor and sorry journalism. Everyone is a presstitute nowadays.
Indian perspective presented here is so incorrect. Immensely. No Modi fan, but he has tried hard to reconcile with Pak. DW should invest in research before making fool of themselves.
Why do we need to reconcile? Nothing common in us. Until pakistan is hurt, it will not understand the importance of peace. Religion is the killer of pakistan.
As an Indian citizen, I can say we don't wanna start a war with Pakistan. However, they need to stop their cross border terrorism in India. If they do something like Mumbai attacks again then I would support our government declaring war against them and bringing the Pakistan Army to its knees.
@@protagonist9716you know the reason?... pakistanis are eating grass and sleeping with empty stomach while pakistani army is busy buying weapons....as it's army which is ruling pakistan.. while in india.. people are given priority, in housing, education, health care etc while army have to wait long for getting weapons.... but once indians come out of poverty totally, with education for all.... india is going to spend heavily on arms also an indegenious defence industry is building up in india, so as to reduce dependence on other nations and have along year long war with china pakistan axis in future
The western media might be giving free and fair news on their internal politics but when it come to showing news on other countries they are just carrying out information warefare.... notice how the show the map of india and point out hindu nationalist government and call pakistan a fragile democracy even when it is run by military
@@RubiaStormmodi was the reason pakistan got into fatf grey list for sponsoring terrorism and it was modi diaspora and lobby that made imran khan go away
Modi - Gets humiliated by a country that's on the brink of collapse during the Bhalokhot incident and loses 2,000 sq km of land to China and then bans the Media from reporting on it!!
Sponsored terrorism is still Pakistans state policy. Until its rooted out there is no scope for improvement in any of these factors. India doesn't require Pak. Its the other way.
@@DSan-kl2ycPakistanis are cowards against their military since independence. In india when our PM Indira Gandhi declared emergency for her political ambitions whole india fought against her government and she was one of the most powerful and brutal PM of india . Indian army never tried to coup Indian government even when our Indian governments were unstable and weak in the past .
Their opposition is always in jail and then killed. Terrorists rule there, openly showing guns, selling drugs. Rich on drug trade. International community should Crack down on drug trade. Heavy punishment to people smuggling drugs
what you people are ignoring that Pakistanis are themselves either terrorists or terrorist sympathizers. the problem is in their people. Pakistan is only country where no one bat an eye on military coup. in Myanmar also the military has a strong hold but whenever their military does a coup, they face huge protest.
Cmnn...!! I know we Indians have suffered this terrorism thing the most from Pakistan. But the other good people can't even affording foods are not supposed to cost this thing.They are our neighbours and we love them❣️
😂😂😂I feel Same. most Europeans share same value for democracy and human rights and religion rights with paxistan. Paxistan and Europe is same in all this.
DW, A German govt owned news outlet, is very wrong when it talks about India in relation to Pakistan. It doesn't mention Pakistan's support of Islamic terrorism against India. It also doesn't want to mention that J&K is legally and historically India's land.
Inside news for those who don't know : The reason why the West wants Pakistan to survive is not because they are sympathetic to it, but because a functional Pakistan provides a lever to achieve two objectives: 1. The Pakistani military elite can siphon off the loot to Europe and the US and invest in their overpriced, useless housing there. Or maybe something else as well. 2. Pakistan provides a lever to achieve the same with India and to a lesser extent, with Afghanistan, by creating mischief at both its borders. It can thus force the Indian elite too, to work for the Western corporation, instead of focusing internally.
Exactly....There is a saying in Tamil' if getting paid some people drink phenyl also.....!!!! These news media like BBC, Jazeera, new ones like DW etc etc will fall in this category
A country created based on a lie, the chickens have some home to roost. Now the military is entrenched permanently and profiting by turning this so-called country into a vassal state for China. Only solution is ban the color Green in this country and try to integrate with mother country India, other will be a sodomized nation for Xi and over time China will wipe out Islam from Pakistan as they did by genocide of Uighurs in China.
Modi is the only Indian PM who understood Pakistan well maybe this is because he is the first Indian PM born after independence in 1947. He carries no baggage and not get emotionally fooled like all the previous prime ministers before him.
@@SPDRM Pakistanis are begging India for visa. What makes you think Kashmiris want to join Pakistan? In few years Pakistanis will ask India for reunification.
DW, CBS, new york times, brain-washington post and all the other liberal pseudo secular news channels JUST NEVER LEARN .. and when someone counters them with facts n logic ...they are hindu national or RSS....lmao
Was this produced in the belief that senior Pakistani politicians, statemen and military are watching DW, in the hope they learn how to fix their country?
They know. They are happy with a lavish lifestyle of Dubai sheikhs. All generals are billionnaires. Nation is poor,not rulers. They holiday in London paris
The future of Pakistan appears to be deeply challenged by ongoing corruption and governance issues. This isn't solely the fault of political and military leaders; the problem seems to be systemic. There is a significant lack of education and understanding among the populace about how a government should function. The country is in a difficult situation that may be hard to reverse.
First step is to separate religion and state. Too many resources go into the religion and religion has an oversized impact on society and economy, and mostly in a negative way.
The problem is not that "too many resources go into the religion," rather the problem is elite capture of Pakistan's resources. The elite in Pakistan are the politicians, the military, the landlords and big businesses. Not until their grip is loosened will Pakistan come out of the never ending crises. The religious groups do not have much influence on the public in Pakistan as they have never done well in elections. Their influence is due to the military support that that they have received since General Zia-ul-Haq's time (military dictator in the 1980s), The military uses them for their own purposes. In the past the "jihad" in Indian occupied Kashmir, and now to put pressure on political parties when they start challenging the military. An example of this is the use of Tehreek-e-Labaik Pakistan (TLP), a fringe "religious" party used by the military to pressurize politicial parties from time to time.
@@gowherulislam5480 What was the main reason for the separation of India into India, Pakistan and Bangladesh? Secondly, I didnt say that the government is spending too much money on religion - it is society itself. Thirdly, many aspects of religion have an outsized influence on society such as the blasphemy law.
Waiting for the ISPR trolls in the comments section trying to tell that that how Pakistan is the world's most advanced and power country and all the problems in Pakistan is started by India.
Any country under military rule will struggle for decades. Argentina is the best example of military rule going wrong.. Argentina used to be an economic super power before Ww2. Democracy works in strange ways..
@@shikharsharma1523Israel is a example of hard time creates hard men after ww2 now it's more like good time creates weak people 😅😂, I'm talking about political parties and protests nothing against Israel
@@AliChaudhary420 they are not begging they are working there ... and gulf country is develop because of oil and dictatorship they control & check iislamb. The day democracy come to this country iislamb will gonna destroy that countries too.. and by the way change kkuffar last name...
@@AliChaudhary420Because Arab countries had one thing which the world sought out for a century. Oil. That is soon to change once the world switches to renewable energy sources
Start using correct map of INDIA,you don’t want to antagonise the second largest English speaking populace given your channel deals in English primarily. Think!
"So why can't these two sides get over their rivalry?". Perhaps they need to ask that question to themselves, as to why NATO can't get over its rivalry with Russia, even though Russia doesn't send terrorists to do attacks in western countries.
@@maigepresents5840 Israel obsession and Kashmir obsession are mental illnesses. Concentrate on your own countries and stop looking at other people's territories with greedy eyes.
So why did ur grandmother leave his ancestral land his village evrything that his ancestors built over thousands of years why what wrong did he do to anyone
It's not a misunderstanding. Moderate religious people can't or won't stop the extremists so we'd be better off with no religion. We could actually have peace. I'm not just talking about Islam. All these stone age religions are causing more problems than any good they claim to do. And all of it is over myths that nobody has ever proven.@skInspired7
The problem us pakistan has nukes, otherwise world wouldn't care less. It will be like another drama like central Africa. But nukes in the hands of taliban, AL Qaida type of organization is scary thought.
First things first economic revival includes and necessitates involving everyone including India and Afghanistan in opportunities... Also not only foreign investment but foreign investment with partnership with local businesses or state owned enterprises to ensure the money circulation and money not leaving the country when country needs it most
Why a German channel is interested in internal affairs of Pakistan and giving free unsolicited advise. Why don't you advise and discuss about the high inflation and racism in Germany. First set your Country in order before poking nose
@@vinsin328 bro you have to know that these channels like DW, BBC AND France 24 etc look like private companies, but they are public funded ( government) broadcasters. Now you know why they are coming to Developing countries.. It is a kind of Colonization, they want to create problems in the country. *_Beware_*
Compared to a country almost same its size in population, land, and resources China is close to 20 trillion dollar and india is just at 3 trillion making average Indian poorer than average pakistani. Hindu extremists and kashmir obsession is also cause of india's failure. And you pajeets keep crying how you have larger economy than a 7 times smaller nation🤦♂🤦♂🤣🤣
Give India back Kashmir and hope for improved trade relations between the two nations. Treaty can be made in such a way that Pakistan gives India, Pakistan occupied Kashmir, which till date remains a safe heaven for terrorist organisations, and India should agree to not disrupt Indus river water supplies to Pakistan. Although this might not seem a fair proposal from the Pakistani prospective yet it should be noted that in this scenario India has nothing to loose whereas Pakistan has lot, a good trade with India, which is a bright spot in this Global recession period will definitely help Pakistan, and perhaps may bring them out of this grave.
want to know can taslima nasrin can do workshop in kolkata? সালমানরা যখন সংখ্যালঘুতে থাকে তারা পশ্চিমবঙ্গের মতো বাঙালি বাঙালি ভাই ভাই দেখায় কিন্তু মুসলমানরা সংখ্যাগরিষ্ঠ হলে তারা সেখানে প্রকৃত রং দেখায় যেমন বাংলাদেশ কোরআন তেলাওয়াত করে বাঙালি মুসলমান বাঙালি বাঙালি হিন্দুদের বিরুদ্ধে গণহত্যা করেছিল মহান কলকাতা গণহত্যা। নোয়াখালী দাঙ্গা 1950 পূর্ব পাকিস্তানের দাঙ্গা 1962 রাজশাহী গণহত্যা 1964 সালের পূর্ব পাকিস্তানে দাঙ্গা (কাশ্মীরের মসজিদ থেকে কিছু ধ্বংসাবশেষ নিখোঁজ হওয়ায় বাঙালী মুসলমানরা হিন্দুদের হত্যা করতে শুরু করে) এটি আপনার বাঙালি ভ্রাতৃত্ব। বাংলাদেশ গণহত্যা (ভুক্তভোগীদের 90% হিন্দু) 1971 যোগেন্দ্র নাথ মন্ডল দলিত বিশ্বাসঘাতকের পদত্যাগপত্র (পাক প্রধানমন্ত্রীকে লেখা চিঠিতে তিনি সেখানে বাঙালি ভাইদের দ্বারা হিন্দু গণহত্যার কথা উল্লেখ করেছেন) আপনি কি আমাকে বলতে পারেন যে বাঙালি মুসলমানদের বিরুদ্ধে বাঙালি হিন্দুদের নেতৃত্বে কোন দাঙ্গা হয়েছে, হ্যাঁ বাংলাদেশে হিন্দু জনসংখ্যা 30% থেকে কমে 7% হয়েছে? এই গণহত্যার ফলে বাঙালি হিন্দুরা পশ্চিমবঙ্গে চলে যায়, গর্গ চ্যাটার্জির মতো এই নিঃস্ব বাঙালি হিন্দুরা কমিউনিজম, ধর্মনিরপেক্ষতাকে সমর্থন করেছিল এবং পশ্চিমবঙ্গ থেকে মুসলমানদের তাড়িয়ে দেওয়ার পরিবর্তে পশ্চিমবঙ্গকে ধ্বংস করেছিল।, ঢাকা বিশ্ববিদ্যালয়ের অধ্যাপক আবুল বারকাতের একটি মৌলিক বই, বঞ্চনা। 2000 সালে প্রকাশিত অর্পিত সম্পত্তি আইন এবং ফলাফলের ফলাফলের মাধ্যমে বাংলাদেশে হিন্দু সংখ্যালঘুরা। এই বৈষম্যমূলক আইনের ফলে হিন্দু পরিবারের মোট জমি হারিয়েছে 1.64 মিলিয়ন একর (6,640 কিমি 2), যা মোট জমির 53 শতাংশের সমান। হিন্দু সম্প্রদায়ের মালিকানাধীন জমি এবং মোট জমির 5.3 শতাংশ। বাংলাদেশের ভূমি এলাকা এক ধরনের পরিবর্তিত স্টকহোম সিনড্রোম। আমরা বাঙালি হিন্দুরা 1930 সাল থেকে মার্কসবাদী মতাদর্শ এবং গান্ধীবিদ্বেষের অবিরাম বোমাবর্ষণের শিকার হয়েছি। উভয়েই আমাদের ডিএনএ-তে একটি স্বতঃসিদ্ধ স্থাপন করেছেন যে 'একজন মুসলমান কোনো অন্যায় করতে পারে না'। এ কারণেই, যদিও 1946 সাল থেকে প্রায় 1.3 কোটি হিন্দুকে পূর্ববঙ্গ/পূর্ব পাকিস্তান/বাংলাদেশ থেকে বহিষ্কার করা হয়েছিল, বিশ্ব এই দেশত্যাগ সম্পর্কে জানে না এবং মনে করে যে এটি শুধুমাত্র পাঞ্জাবে হয়েছিল!, গান্ধীই পশ্চিমের মধ্যে জনসংখ্যার স্থানান্তর বন্ধ করেছিলেন। বাংলা ও বাংলাদেশ এবং তার পর নেহরু লিয়াকত চুক্তির নামে বাঙালি হিন্দুরা ক্ষতিগ্রস্ত হয়েছে যদি গান্ধী টাইপের ভাইরাস বাংলায় না আসত, বাঙালি হিন্দুদের এত কষ্ট হত না, এমনকি নোয়াখালীতেও সে অসভ্য বাঙালি মুসলমানদের আটকাতে পারেনি। হাজার হাজার বাঙালি হিন্দু মুক্তিযোদ্ধা আছে একজন বাঙালি মুসলমান মুক্তিযোদ্ধার নাম বলতে পারেন??
bruh, stop saying this. You know Pakistanis will never accept this. They'll let go of anything but Kashmir. Let's not discuss this now. We shouldn't talk about it as if we're dying to take that part of J&K. Don't let them feel attacked, let them feel ashamed by developing our part of Kashmir while their side gets increasingly destabilized thanks to their own mismanagement of their beloved country. And maybe then we'll think about a solution for Kashmir.
There never was a land in history known as pakistan. The people are punjabi, sindhi, baloch or pathans forcefully brought together by partion from Bharat to serve the interests of then english rulers. The ruling elite and army enjoyed themselves at the cost of the masses and have amassed huge wealth abroad. Even today the ruling army gets its instructions from US who has used them as pawns. The only solution is to break up pakistan and once the mess has been cleaned up, join back into Bharat in the long term. Till then the pain and cycle has to be borne by the population and the world.
1) Peace with India with current position of armed forces. 2) Cut defence spending to 10%. 3) Increase educational spending three fold and send people abroad who will send remittances and bring back expertise. 4) Help foreign investment especially in service sector. 5) Invest in tourism industry.
As an Indian. I am very proud of our so called "Hindu Nationalist government". And guess what DW you can whine all you want to, but there is nothing you can do about it😂
Half of this video is about india and its supposed Hindu nationalism. Its as if the desperation to bring that concoction up was way to great for DW that they couldn’t Handel it. And the question is…before this supposed Hindu nationalist government, were the relationship between india pak lovey-dovey?
Pakistan lived by the sword. In Afghanistan & in India. And backed by some Middle East powers. Now the chickens are coming home to roost. Unfortunately the military supported such ill advised forays.
They have to start trading with nearby countries and stop the tension with India. Remove corruption, counter and stamp out terrorism and stop continuously resorting to IMF bailouts.
Really interesting report and a really good overview. I have very mixed feelings about Pakistan- one of the few countries I’ve visited that I genuinely disliked & found it hard to find much good in. The corruption is terrible and far to much of the population combine lack of education ( which can be fixed) but also deeply held ignorance , xenophobia & misogyny ( religious intolerance much harder to address). They are so dumb they keep voting against their own interests, which make no sense to me? Putting hope in making deals with China has to be the worst “two-ended sword” choice.... I hope it can be turned around into a better country.😢
and i cant understand that when any western country describe indias ruling party they use hindu nationalist party ......are u mad if its like that than majority of western vountries are ruled by christanist nationalist party................if they use these words they cant get close to any developing nation
One can’t view Pakistan-India and Pakistan-China relationships in isolation. They have to be viewed along with the India-China relationship. Saying Pakistan is under threat because they fought 4 wars with India is wrong. Pakistan started all the 4 wars. The fear of India is perpetuated just to assign a large share of the budget to the military. The expert saying “Pakistan should stop viewing itself as a warrior country “ is right. They should start behaving like a normal country putting the interests of the common citizen first. Unfortunately, it is easier said than done.
Disappointing to see @DW News show Kashmir and Arunachal Pradesh in the map as a disputed territory. Is DW News taking inputs from China on this? Should Russia start showing Berlin as part of Russian territory?
The concept of marshal race (warriors) is both a strength as well as a weakness and when particularly when the marshal race is a majority, it's catastrophic. In the modern warfare consisting of flying weapons, unmanned delivery systems, electronic guidance, outter space occupation, etc. the so called marshal race is a big burden. Whether it's the Balkans or the South of Caucus or the Central Asia regions, all these places unfortunately were in the middle of various political/ religious /ethnic blocks and always were /are in perpetual conflicts. Pakistan as a nation should stop being proud of their warrior population. They are fit for fighting and nothing else If a nation is full of warriors - education, trade, technology, society etc. would be the casualties in that nation. The only trading community in Pakistan were the Sindhi(s) (Hindus) - Pakistan successfully got rid of them in the name of religion. Sooner they understand their fundamental problem, they have the chance of revival of the economy, else it will become another Afghanistan, always in perpetual wars - both internal and external...
Ironically, people who have essentially submitted to a foreign religion call themselves marshal and view those who endured hardships for centuries without giving up their original traditions as weak.
What a completely useless waste of a video. Wasted my 21 minutes. I think DW stands for "Don't Watch". What "Indian - American military ties"?! You mean when America sold F-16s to India? No wait, you mean when US sent an Aircraft Carrier to fight agsinst Pakistan in it's war vs India
@@changthunderwang7543 Assuming that Pakistan wants to have a solution. Pakistan has had numerous chances to save itself, it has frittered each one away. Even now, all it has to do is do away with its India enmity: basically reverse course. It won't. You can't save a drowning person when they're _trying_ to drown themselves; they'll take you also down with them.
@@changthunderwang7543 they call pakistan unstable democracy ,when democracy is non existent in Pakistan. But they call Modi autocratic and what not.
@@changthunderwang7543Their pro-Pakistan stance is apparent in this video. Literally every "expert" interviewed here, including that clown "Gigolo-man" is pro- Pakistan.
There is no solution to Pakistan's woes... Everyone loves to blame the politicians but nobody is willing to bell the Cat! A politician in Pakistan knows that he will come to power and remain in power only if he keeps the military establishment (ME) in good humour! Naturally he will be accountable to ME rather than to the people. The Military Establishment in Pakistan controls majority of the resources (share of budget, land & property, businesses, etc) and on top of that it controls the Politicians, Bureaucrats and Judiciary by proxy. The current system which benefits them at the cost of all others - will not be allowed to change - no matter what! And in order to maintain the hegemony of the ME…. Pakistan cannot afford to improve its ties with India! It must continue this animosity with India on communal lines - which helped it create a separate country in the name of religion from British India... Otherwise it cannot justify its existence as a separate country to its own brain-washed people. There is no escape for Pakistanis!!
Manufacturing defects can not be removed from the final product unless the product is converted back to the raw material and made completely a new product ....
There is no way India and Pakistan can be at loggerheads forever. Normal relations would benefit Pakistan more than India. Most Indians don’t care but it is not good to have an unstable Pakistan as our neighbour….
ur a perfect example of a librandu who lives in it's own la la land ... paapistan is like a golum character in lord of the rings, u cannot change the golum ( paapistan) character .
Between a sinking Pakistan and a strong Pakistan, we 🇮🇳 the people of Bharat🇮🇳, choose a sinking Pakistan... We thank Jinnha for creating Pakistan... and saving we Kaafirs of Bharat🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳....
Pakistan is living majorly on aid of US,EU,Saudi Arabia and UAE and international organisations . China does give them the money but china have already lost 68 billion USD by investing in CPEC that is not going according to plan and have threats from terrorists ,so china may leave them on their own too because china have their own money problem due to which they can't spend money like water like they used to do before. So yeah without stable western aid pakistan will collapse from economic challenges or the whole country resources will be sale .
there are nearly 20 crore paapistani living in iindia too ....the failure of iindia is not doing population ttransfer after 47' partition. that was a huge mistake by iindia it is going to haunt india .
Whenever I feel like the world is getting better , I just switch to dw and they never dissapoint . DW is the channel that maintains hypocrisy as standard. Never failed to entertain.
Thanks. Insightful. I have always thought the Pakistan government has spoken and acted with a forked tongue; playing a double game. Like in Myanmar, the military will not give up meddling. They are destined to remain a sick, stunted nation.
Bharat never attacks first on Pakistan. It has to stop terror. And everything depends upon how thinks people and how it act for the country. In realm Pakistan thinks over that their country possesses fertile land and they have cattle farm. If they are serious for agriculture and Pasupalan. and technological education. They are vert stern to perform their religion and may they. But they must attentive towards vocational guidance and activities and they are acutely lacking this. Their menace is only to fight with Bharat and that makes them weakest.
My idea for these Pakistani problems , Please , think this way , If Pakistan become a state of America , every body will be happy , like, Americans , Indian & Pakistan ( Pakistan is for sale ) Ha,Ha
The issue is that Pakistan is conducting a colonial occupation of several regions that are not legitimate parts of Pakistan. Balochistan is a totally separate country, Gilgit Baltistan belongs to India and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa belongs to Afghanistan. Pakistan has supported ISIS types to maintain these occupations but that costs money and is backfiring. The answer is to let these areas go and become a normal country.
Pakistan for its political gains did go too deep in Wests pocket and same is happening with their relationship with China. Unlike India or Bangladesh, they failed to reform a country for the interests of its citizens (education/health/land reforms etc). On top of that, after independence, their Rich and Elite leader class left the had been enjoying the western countries and never returned to give it back to the Pakistan.
The largest ever experiment happened in 1947 with 400 million participants. Control was India and test was Pakistan. Same people but the only difference between them was Islam. 76 years down the line one country is 5th largest economy and soon to be third largest. the country which separated from 8ndia based on Islam is now a basket case. No marks for guessing what this experiment proved?
Pakistan especially West Pakistan which got the best resources of the Indian subcontinent has the best agricultural land, 50% of coal, the best cities (Lahore and Karachi), 40% of railways, 25%+ land for 16% of the population (West Pakistan - 20%+ land for 6% of the population), $100 Billion Aid from the USA alone, refused to pay the debt they own to India ($30 Billion at least by now) etc.
What crisis? When does a country's defence budget, army personnels' networth, nuclear stockpile increase? When it's economy grows. Hence, paxtan is growing.
Every nation has a army. But in Pakistan's case, its the army that has a nation!
Actually, that is not unusual. Other countries where the military is in charge includes Egypt, Myanmar and several African countries recently, Twenty or thirty years ago, there were several dozen, to include Argentina, whose Junta failed after the disasterous Falklands War. Taiwan, Chile, and Bangladesh was under rmilitary control until about 1990, give or take. Indonesia was run by a junta until the late 90's.
And if you go to the Dark Ages, that ws the norm. The various kings and their vassals wer essentially military men with a military body under their direct command. They often lead their men at arms into battle themselves.
@@ycplum7062 which country amongst the ones in your list would you prefer to live?
But they think Hindus are their enemy.. and their Govt made sure tehyacre fed that via their 75 years of brainwashed educated system.
One of the best Quotes by Mr.Tharoor, other then "Even the god din't trust English in the dark".....
We're happy with our army. You should worry about Hindutva taking over India.
WOW. How she described India as a country led by Hindu Nationalist, instead of saying largest democracy. She also forgot to mention how USA, UK and west countries are also involved in making of Pakistan what it is today.
DW leaving Jammu, Kashmir, Ladakh, and Arunachal Pradesh out of India's map; the Indian media should leave East Germany, Bavaria, and Austria out of Germany's map. Yes, Austria is already not shown as part of Germany but Germany and Austria are supposed to be one; the way that India and Nepal are supposed to be one, the way that China and Taiwan are supposed to be one, the way that North Korea and South Korea are supposed to be one. Long Live India, China, Korea, and Germany.
What should she have said? "India the worlds largest democracy, which is beeing led by Hindu Nationalists?
Regular thing for European media, nothing to fret about.
India is led by Hindu Nationalist. What is the lie?
India is led by hindu Nationalist! nothing wrong with that
As a Pakistani
I am sure that Pakistan is not becoming a failed state
Pakistan is already a failed state(Not only economically,But Socially,as a society,as a nation)
you muswt be sitting abroad.
@@zoraizalibaig5377 nah man im not
That's what happens when you mix religion with governance
@@blastergoon4185 No man Mixing religion with governance is not the cause
@@mjking699 I don't see it in any other way. Tbh Pakistanis don't have an identity, they did everything that was forbidden by the creator of Pakistan. I fathom if Mr Jinnah was alive today, what he could have said about Pakistan
They don't want to change, they want to escape their problems .
That's what happens when you create a country in the name of a religion.
Israel is also created in the name of religion
@@Ron-pm3qk but for different reasons.
That is the difference between Judaism and islam. islam is about sh##.@@Ron-pm3qk
@@Ron-pm3qkIsrael is not only religion but using brains at the optimum level.
@@toledotoll7171 wish if you could use your brains at optimum level too and suss out the relevance of your comment
An Army that never won a war,
An army that never lost an election.
Slava Pakistan!
If your population is skyrocketing, you don't need an army and win a war. You go to the continent that doesn't guard its borders, and it's population doesn't make children, and you conquer them.
Fascist rss indian terrorists from slums always obsessed with pakistan
@@vinsin328
The 1947 war stopped immediately with Indian intervention. The Maharaja of Kashmir lost not India
How convenient of you to forget 1971
You won the Afghan war in 2020? Weren't you supposed to be a US ally? How come the talibans want to invade you now?
You are laughing stock
@vinsin328 1947 war of Kashmir was fought on kashmir that wasn't indian land at that time so how did the pakistanis won that war India still controls 3/4 of jammu kashmir and all the river water
Right, India successfully took over Azad Kashmir in 48, 65, and then again 71😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Oops that was just a wet dream
I am from Afghanistan 🇦🇫. I heard that in 1971 some 93 thousands pak army trousers were removed in East pakistan ( Bangladesh) those trousers are kept in Indian war museum. Is that true? Any Indian brother or sister have any clue?😂
Bro we smashed them 😂
@@harshhiwal4915 love ❤ to great India 🇮🇳 from Afghanistan 🇦🇫
@@untouchboy We also love you brother 🇮🇳🤝🏻🇦🇫
You heard right 😂✅
@@untouchboy😂
Curiously no mention of the many, many billions China has loaned the Pakistani military. They have provided everything from subs, to ships, to radar systems, warplanes, ect. It's huge! The silence on this issue is deafening!!
Unless you’re a Baloch. They’re howling. The CCP is about to take their fishing port.
Pakistan is paying a price for the greed of those at top. They even supported martial law. So patriotic. Now got poverty for it. No schemes for them. Their education. But elite has bought huge property in London,Dubai,Canada,Australia
CCP has two handy rogue states for global mess north Korea and Pakistan under its belly
But didn't forget to mention the "Hindu nationalist government" and drawing parallels with the imagery they provided with the Taliban. Typical DW.
Karma ! As a Bangladeshi, Seeing the fall of pakistan give me a diabolical joy ! May the God prolong the situation.
😂😂😂
You are a balck@ss indian. Banglis hate India more than pakistan
Even this pain won't change them. That is a guarantee.
@@meesamnajef6435 its hard to do that when ICC was created in 2002. It took 10 years to convict its 1st criminal.
DW, CBS, new york times, brain-washington post and all the other liberal pseudo secular news channels JUST NEVER LEARN .. and when someone counters them with facts n logic ...they are hindu national or RSS....lmao
Bottom line is the Pakistani army is the core of all the issues that Pakistan is facing
yes brother... and 2nd is extremist jihadi mullah ...
That’s true
Wrong, Pakistan Army is the reason why Pakistan is still surviving but I wouldn't expect an Afghani to understand this.
@@A7XKoRnRocks1He's right. As a Pakistani you should accept this. Otherwise, you are blind. Also Afghans know firsthand just as much as Pakistanis do.
@@A7XKoRnRocks1 lol, no
“What Pakistan needs to do is fortify its border … to stop militants coming across the border…?” Hilarious 😂
Haven't watched the video yet, but hopefully, just hopefully, she meant the Afghan border. For the sake of her own reputation
People want to run away from this failed state. Nobody is dying to go there 😂
hahahahah uz hahahahah ul ahahhahaha ur hahahahahah ud hahahhahaha al hahahhahaha
He is talking about the Afghan border.
@@orangeneratorthey sent twrrorists in afghanistan.
What democracy, not even 1 prime minister has completed its tenure, Pakistan had the option to buy cheap discount fuel from Russia,just like the EU brought indirectly from other countries 😅
They have been cozying up with azerbaijan who is laundering Russian oil to Europe, but looks like they need to do more than kissing a dictator’s a$$ to get cheap gas.
If EU was minting money like India by buying by buying discounted Russian fuel from third parties (like India), then why there is a rampant inflation in West and EU in particular.?
These things don't fix economy. Even filip to India didn't last.
@thezoldics7648 Bengali "Hindus" to be precise and those who lived the way of life as Bengali
I am really amazed by the fact that DW showed arunachal as disputed teritory.
Its shows from where funding is coming
I live in Geneva, Switzerland. If you look at maps of India or China on Google Maps right here, Arunachal is shown as disputed territory with a dotted line all around it; this isn't a quirk specific to Deutsche Welle and is standard across most of the world. China is just far more influential than us on the global stage.
You won't believe but these leeches are funded by common people in Germany. We pay a radio fee to fund such poor and sorry journalism. Everyone is a presstitute nowadays.
Brother of BBC. I started feeling like all western media has only 1 agenda "Always speak something negative about India"
We should also start showing some of territory as disputed in our maps these Hypocritic western countries 😑🤷🏻♂️
Not only arunachal also sikkim are captured states. Captured in early 70s.
Indian perspective presented here is so incorrect. Immensely. No Modi fan, but he has tried hard to reconcile with Pak. DW should invest in research before making fool of themselves.
Deutsche welle, run by nñ@zï k Rauts are extremely anti-indian.
Why do we need to reconcile? Nothing common in us. Until pakistan is hurt, it will not understand the importance of peace. Religion is the killer of pakistan.
You are fool bro you really don't no what is happening in pakistan which is rulled by military 🤔. Pakistan is not a democracy it's a failed country..
They are biased against India and Hindus and always will be!
Why should the largest democracy and the 5th largest economy stoop so low as to respect a terrorist state?
As an Indian citizen, I can say we don't wanna start a war with Pakistan. However, they need to stop their cross border terrorism in India. If they do something like Mumbai attacks again then I would support our government declaring war against them and bringing the Pakistan Army to its knees.
Yes last time the Pakistan did a Abhinandan to Indians 2019, NYT called it most humiliating for India
@@protagonist9716just building up massive indian troops along the border would bankrupt pakistan out of panic.
@@protagonist9716you know the reason?... pakistanis are eating grass and sleeping with empty stomach while pakistani army is busy buying weapons....as it's army which is ruling pakistan.. while in india.. people are given priority, in housing, education, health care etc while army have to wait long for getting weapons.... but once indians come out of poverty totally, with education for all.... india is going to spend heavily on arms also an indegenious defence industry is building up in india, so as to reduce dependence on other nations and have along year long war with china pakistan axis in future
@@protagonist9716western hypocrist
@@protagonist9716last time I remember India chopped Pakistan in to two countries.
Modi - I will make sure that Pakistan gets completely isolated for the wrongs it has been doing. 😎
The western media might be giving free and fair news on their internal politics but when it come to showing news on other countries they are just carrying out information warefare.... notice how the show the map of india and point out hindu nationalist government and call pakistan a fragile democracy even when it is run by military
@@RubiaStormmodi was the reason pakistan got into fatf grey list for sponsoring terrorism and it was modi diaspora and lobby that made imran khan go away
Pakistan is perfectly capable of destroying itself. Although in the mind of an average Pakistan, it's all India's doing.
1990-पाकिस्तान जिंदाबाद
2023-पाकिस्तान से जिन्दा भाग
2040-किधर गया पाकिस्तान
2050-क्या था पाकिस्तान
Modi - Gets humiliated by a country that's on the brink of collapse during the Bhalokhot incident and loses 2,000 sq km of land to China and then bans the Media from reporting on it!!
Hypocrisy of Germany media, God bless the democratic republic of India ❤️
Sponsored terrorism is still Pakistans state policy. Until its rooted out there is no scope for improvement in any of these factors. India doesn't require Pak. Its the other way.
That probably won't be rooted with a military hold on the government. Those tend to be old fashioned and conservative and slow to change.
@@DSan-kl2ycPakistanis are cowards against their military since independence. In india when our PM Indira Gandhi declared emergency for her political ambitions whole india fought against her government and she was one of the most powerful and brutal PM of india . Indian army never tried to coup Indian government even when our Indian governments were unstable and weak in the past .
Their opposition is always in jail and then killed. Terrorists rule there, openly showing guns, selling drugs. Rich on drug trade. International community should Crack down on drug trade. Heavy punishment to people smuggling drugs
what you people are ignoring that Pakistanis are themselves either terrorists or terrorist sympathizers.
the problem is in their people.
Pakistan is only country where no one bat an eye on military coup.
in Myanmar also the military has a strong hold but whenever their military does a coup, they face huge protest.
Failed terror state and a favorite child of British and Americans. In future India will reunite Pak with India.
The fact that a pakistani recognising India as a democracy and a foreign first world reporter addressing
India as hindu nationalist, says all.
This news channel is a looser
Then US is a White Nationalist Govt.
So, Aren't Modi and his supporters are not Hindu nationalists...?
India is a Hindu Nationalist Autocratic regime disguising itself as a Democracy
Just report this video and block this channel.... they have to pay price for incorrect reporting!
Look at DW's sympathies and concern for the terrorism exporter of the world
Pakistan was created by the West so that Soviet Union could not access Indian Ocean
One day the chickens will come home for dinner 😜🍻
Cmnn...!!
I know we Indians have suffered this terrorism thing the most from Pakistan.
But the other good people can't even affording foods are not supposed to cost this thing.They are our neighbours and we love them❣️
DW never blames that one religion like they do with all others. I wonder why 🌚
😂😂😂I feel Same. most Europeans share same value for democracy and human rights and religion rights with paxistan. Paxistan and Europe is same in all this.
DW, A German govt owned news outlet, is very wrong when it talks about India in relation to Pakistan. It doesn't mention Pakistan's support of Islamic terrorism against India. It also doesn't want to mention that J&K is legally and historically India's land.
Inside news for those who don't know :
The reason why the West wants Pakistan to survive is not because they are sympathetic to it, but because a functional Pakistan provides a lever to achieve two objectives:
1. The Pakistani military elite can siphon off the loot to Europe and the US and invest in their overpriced, useless housing there. Or maybe something else as well.
2. Pakistan provides a lever to achieve the same with India and to a lesser extent, with Afghanistan, by creating mischief at both its borders. It can thus force the Indian elite too, to work for the Western corporation, instead of focusing internally.
Nice conspiracy theory
DW's standard is going down. They are discussing Pakistan. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
🤣😂
😂😂
Exactly....There is a saying in Tamil' if getting paid some people drink phenyl also.....!!!! These news media like BBC, Jazeera, new ones like DW etc etc will fall in this category
Lol😂
A country created based on a lie, the chickens have some home to roost. Now the military is entrenched permanently and profiting by turning this so-called country into a vassal state for China. Only solution is ban the color Green in this country and try to integrate with mother country India, other will be a sodomized nation for Xi and over time China will wipe out Islam from Pakistan as they did by genocide of Uighurs in China.
Modi is the only Indian PM who understood Pakistan well maybe this is because he is the first Indian PM born after independence in 1947. He carries no baggage and not get emotionally fooled like all the previous prime ministers before him.
He is also extremely prgamatic and has no soft corner for Pakistan. He will teach them a lesson if they dare attack India 😂
India will make Pakistan leave POK.
@@SPDRM Pakistanis are begging India for visa. What makes you think Kashmiris want to join Pakistan? In few years Pakistanis will ask India for reunification.
@nihalpathak3407
May be you're right, after all !
@@realnapster1522
We should never ever give visas to Pakistanis. We 'll be digging our own grave.
People can play drinking games every time ill informed media say Hindu nationalist in the wrong context 😂😂
DW, CBS, new york times, brain-washington post and all the other liberal pseudo secular news channels JUST NEVER LEARN .. and when someone counters them with facts n logic ...they are hindu national or RSS....lmao
lol seriously what Hindu did that make Pakistan bankrupt? 😂😂😂
1947 was a mistake. It can be remedied by
1. Embrace Hinduism.
2. Join India.
3. Live stable and peaceful life.
Was this produced in the belief that senior Pakistani politicians, statemen and military are watching DW, in the hope they learn how to fix their country?
😁😁🙊
Ha ha, good one.
They know. They are happy with a lavish lifestyle of Dubai sheikhs. All generals are billionnaires. Nation is poor,not rulers. They holiday in London paris
1:02 now. Pakistan has always been controlled by the army
The future of Pakistan appears to be deeply challenged by ongoing corruption and governance issues. This isn't solely the fault of political and military leaders; the problem seems to be systemic. There is a significant lack of education and understanding among the populace about how a government should function. The country is in a difficult situation that may be hard to reverse.
The US could help but they don't want to listen and didn't fully side with the US when it was in Afghanistan.
_"Pakistan is deeply challenged..."_ is a DEEP understatement.
"In its death throes.." is more accurate.
Dcvful😮66
this earthy life in paapistan is nothing the real life start in jannna with 72 hhorris..
@thezoldics7648 Not to mention hid bin ladin from the US
First step is to separate religion and state. Too many resources go into the religion and religion has an oversized impact on society and economy, and mostly in a negative way.
The problem is not that "too many resources go into the religion," rather the problem is elite capture of Pakistan's resources. The elite in Pakistan are the politicians, the military, the landlords and big businesses. Not until their grip is loosened will Pakistan come out of the never ending crises. The religious groups do not have much influence on the public in Pakistan as they have never done well in elections. Their influence is due to the military support that that they have received since General Zia-ul-Haq's time (military dictator in the 1980s), The military uses them for their own purposes. In the past the "jihad" in Indian occupied Kashmir, and now to put pressure on political parties when they start challenging the military. An example of this is the use of Tehreek-e-Labaik Pakistan (TLP), a fringe "religious" party used by the military to pressurize politicial parties from time to time.
But pakistan previous govt establishments were all secular govt , they had no religious connections
@@gowherulislam5480 What was the main reason for the separation of India into India, Pakistan and Bangladesh? Secondly, I didnt say that the government is spending too much money on religion - it is society itself. Thirdly, many aspects of religion have an outsized influence on society such as the blasphemy law.
You know nothing of Pakistan. Their problem is military spending, which is many times larger, than education and health care combined.
Not to mention the skyrocket population growth.
video calls india hindu nationalist looking every reason to fight with pakistan...this video should be reported as misinformation
Stay strong India!
India is! Since independence
We're.
@@sunilpaliwal995 Great!
1990-पाकिस्तान जिंदाबाद
2023-पाकिस्तान से जिन्दा भाग
2040-किधर गया पाकिस्तान
2050-क्या था पाकिस्तान
Bro is acting way too sarcastic 🤌
Waiting for the ISPR trolls in the comments section trying to tell that that how Pakistan is the world's most advanced and power country and all the problems in Pakistan is started by India.
India is actually doing pakistan a flavour by killing the UN designated terrorists sitting in pakistan one by one.
Any country under military rule will struggle for decades. Argentina is the best example of military rule going wrong.. Argentina used to be an economic super power before Ww2. Democracy works in strange ways..
*Any country establishd under ethnoreligious banner will struggle for centuries except if you leave Israel.
@@shikharsharma1523Israel is a example of hard time creates hard men after ww2 now it's more like good time creates weak people 😅😂, I'm talking about political parties and protests nothing against Israel
Argentina...the country that never misses an opportunity to miss an opportunity. 🙂
another country as an example, Myanmar, Cambodia, Thailand. These countries are under military rule.
@@1s1o1n1g1not Thailand...
Corruption & population , religious control no democracy, terrorism
Relegiin is the main problem, and time and again Everyone fails to identify it.
If religion is the problem y are Indian labourers begging to b in Arab Gulf countries 😂
@@AliChaudhary420 they are not begging they are working there ... and gulf country is develop because of oil and dictatorship they control & check iislamb. The day democracy come to this country iislamb will gonna destroy that countries too.. and by the way change kkuffar last name...
@@AliChaudhary420 abey 420 walae, jakae news daek 90% of beggars caught in Saudi are paki, 🐷
@GimlinPatter Around 5000 years ago, there were great cities in China, Egypt and Iraq too.......
So whats thst got to do with anything?
@@AliChaudhary420Because Arab countries had one thing which the world sought out for a century. Oil. That is soon to change once the world switches to renewable energy sources
Start using correct map of INDIA,you don’t want to antagonise the second largest English speaking populace given your channel deals in English primarily. Think!
Modiji offered Pak to freeze all issues for 10 years and fight isuues like poverty, unemployment etc.
But it fell on deaf years in Pak
No, they took it really serious. look at their poverty rate, look at their unemployment rate- they are number one!! just look at the list from down
They should have focused on their economy instead of their military
Peaceful neighbour is good neighbour
Please also cover how generations have been raised on hatred and extremism even in textbooks
In India there isn't a Hindu govt rather there is democratically elected government
"So why can't these two sides get over their rivalry?".
Perhaps they need to ask that question to themselves, as to why NATO can't get over its rivalry with Russia, even though Russia doesn't send terrorists to do attacks in western countries.
The same reason Israel will never face consequences for its apartheid regime and genocide... thank heavens for Veto powers...
@@maigepresents5840 Israel obsession and Kashmir obsession are mental illnesses. Concentrate on your own countries and stop looking at other people's territories with greedy eyes.
I'm an Indian...my grandfather came from sindh from pakistan...i feel sad for them...but there is no hope.
Why did your grandfather came from Sindh to India?
So why did ur grandmother leave his ancestral land his village evrything that his ancestors built over thousands of years why what wrong did he do to anyone
Granpa was smart. He knew how to secure the future of his children.
I feel sad for the remaining hindus in sindh. Every year thousand of our sister get kidnapped and converted in pakistan.
Appreciate your generous spirit, but why are you sad for those who stole your ancestral homelands from you?
Balkanisation of Pakistan is only left now
Only Father can fix his child harkat😂
Watching this makes me think not having a military isn't so bad. 🇨🇦
Kashmir, india ko dhe dho. All problems will be solved. 🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂
Remove religion and all problems will be solved.
It's not a misunderstanding. Moderate religious people can't or won't stop the extremists so we'd be better off with no religion. We could actually have peace. I'm not just talking about Islam. All these stone age religions are causing more problems than any good they claim to do. And all of it is over myths that nobody has ever proven.@skInspired7
@@neal.karn-jonesLike in Germany and America? Broken families, greedy women, confused children about sex. Sure did solve all the problems.
If u care so much, y not give Indian kashmir and make peace 😂
@@neal.karn-jones religion is not the only issue. Pakistanis think themselves as Arabs & Turks Iranians.😂 so its ethno religious hatred.
As someone from other side of the border, I am more than happy to witness the state of Pakistan right now
As much asi understand where you are coming from. It's never good to wish ill will on others
@@HeatherBoo916 what's not good about it? Infact I believe that it's good for entire humanity
@@mathai5456 ok you live your life in that matter of you choose
The problem us pakistan has nukes, otherwise world wouldn't care less. It will be like another drama like central Africa. But nukes in the hands of taliban, AL Qaida type of organization is scary thought.
India ka bhi time aye ga
Shaheed Arshad Sharif,s Family also need Healing Hand. I Wish that Army Chief Asim Munir Would retire on time and not ask for 3 years extention.
If Germany is going to support terror exporting country,We Indians will definitely support our friend in the Ukraine-Russia Conflict.
Simple
how, by selling curries to moscow?
@@Ron-pm3qk atleast we are not selling terrorists 😅😅😅
@@davidsarkar6108 good for you sunshine
@@Ron-pm3qkby buying 🛢️
@@Ron-pm3qk curries are better than ur taste less food ....
First things first economic revival includes and necessitates involving everyone including India and Afghanistan in opportunities... Also not only foreign investment but foreign investment with partnership with local businesses or state owned enterprises to ensure the money circulation and money not leaving the country when country needs it most
Why a German channel is interested in internal affairs of Pakistan and giving free unsolicited advise.
Why don't you advise and discuss about the high inflation and racism in Germany.
First set your Country in order before poking nose
Wow
It is an international channel not limited to Germany.
@@vinsin328 who gave them this right?
It is not geo mews ptv .😊
@@vinsin328 bro you have to know that these channels like DW, BBC AND France 24 etc look like private companies, but they are public funded ( government) broadcasters. Now you know why they are coming to Developing countries..
It is a kind of Colonization, they want to create problems in the country.
*_Beware_*
This is what happens , when you put religion before politics🤣
True 😂.. i 💯 % agree
@@Sahil-gx1pk..hindu terrorist
Islam*
Work, work and more work for country's development instead of looting the country by corruption at every stage.
14:54 Kashmir is not disputed. Kashmir is an integral part of India 🇮🇳. Also India follows a no first use policy for nuclear weapons.
Compared to a country almost same its size in population, land, and resources China is close to 20 trillion dollar and india is just at 3 trillion making average Indian poorer than average pakistani. Hindu extremists and kashmir obsession is also cause of india's failure. And you pajeets keep crying how you have larger economy than a 7 times smaller nation🤦♂🤦♂🤣🤣
Not true.
Kashmir was always disputed.
Calling it an integral part of india is just your State narrative contrary to facts.
Indian Occupied Kashmir is DISPUTED territory as per UN
@@Wanderer975kashmir name come from Rishi kashyap 😂😂😂😂
Give India back Kashmir and hope for improved trade relations between the two nations. Treaty can be made in such a way that Pakistan gives India, Pakistan occupied Kashmir, which till date remains a safe heaven for terrorist organisations, and India should agree to not disrupt Indus river water supplies to Pakistan. Although this might not seem a fair proposal from the Pakistani prospective yet it should be noted that in this scenario India has nothing to loose whereas Pakistan has lot, a good trade with India, which is a bright spot in this Global recession period will definitely help Pakistan, and perhaps may bring them out of this grave.
want to know can taslima nasrin can do workshop in kolkata? সালমানরা যখন সংখ্যালঘুতে থাকে তারা পশ্চিমবঙ্গের মতো বাঙালি বাঙালি ভাই ভাই দেখায় কিন্তু মুসলমানরা সংখ্যাগরিষ্ঠ হলে তারা সেখানে প্রকৃত রং দেখায় যেমন বাংলাদেশ কোরআন তেলাওয়াত করে বাঙালি মুসলমান বাঙালি বাঙালি হিন্দুদের বিরুদ্ধে গণহত্যা করেছিল মহান কলকাতা গণহত্যা।
নোয়াখালী দাঙ্গা
1950 পূর্ব পাকিস্তানের দাঙ্গা
1962 রাজশাহী গণহত্যা
1964 সালের পূর্ব পাকিস্তানে দাঙ্গা (কাশ্মীরের মসজিদ থেকে কিছু ধ্বংসাবশেষ নিখোঁজ হওয়ায় বাঙালী মুসলমানরা হিন্দুদের হত্যা করতে শুরু করে) এটি আপনার বাঙালি ভ্রাতৃত্ব।
বাংলাদেশ গণহত্যা (ভুক্তভোগীদের 90% হিন্দু) 1971
যোগেন্দ্র নাথ মন্ডল দলিত বিশ্বাসঘাতকের পদত্যাগপত্র (পাক প্রধানমন্ত্রীকে লেখা চিঠিতে তিনি সেখানে বাঙালি ভাইদের দ্বারা হিন্দু গণহত্যার কথা উল্লেখ করেছেন)
আপনি কি আমাকে বলতে পারেন যে বাঙালি মুসলমানদের বিরুদ্ধে বাঙালি হিন্দুদের নেতৃত্বে কোন দাঙ্গা হয়েছে, হ্যাঁ বাংলাদেশে হিন্দু জনসংখ্যা 30% থেকে কমে 7% হয়েছে?
এই গণহত্যার ফলে বাঙালি হিন্দুরা পশ্চিমবঙ্গে চলে যায়, গর্গ চ্যাটার্জির মতো এই নিঃস্ব বাঙালি হিন্দুরা কমিউনিজম, ধর্মনিরপেক্ষতাকে সমর্থন করেছিল এবং পশ্চিমবঙ্গ থেকে মুসলমানদের তাড়িয়ে দেওয়ার পরিবর্তে পশ্চিমবঙ্গকে ধ্বংস করেছিল।, ঢাকা বিশ্ববিদ্যালয়ের অধ্যাপক আবুল বারকাতের একটি মৌলিক বই, বঞ্চনা। 2000 সালে প্রকাশিত অর্পিত সম্পত্তি আইন এবং ফলাফলের ফলাফলের মাধ্যমে বাংলাদেশে হিন্দু সংখ্যালঘুরা। এই বৈষম্যমূলক আইনের ফলে হিন্দু পরিবারের মোট জমি হারিয়েছে 1.64 মিলিয়ন একর (6,640 কিমি 2), যা মোট জমির 53 শতাংশের সমান। হিন্দু সম্প্রদায়ের মালিকানাধীন জমি এবং মোট জমির 5.3 শতাংশ। বাংলাদেশের ভূমি এলাকা এক ধরনের পরিবর্তিত স্টকহোম সিনড্রোম। আমরা বাঙালি হিন্দুরা 1930 সাল থেকে মার্কসবাদী মতাদর্শ এবং গান্ধীবিদ্বেষের অবিরাম বোমাবর্ষণের শিকার হয়েছি। উভয়েই আমাদের ডিএনএ-তে একটি স্বতঃসিদ্ধ স্থাপন করেছেন যে 'একজন মুসলমান কোনো অন্যায় করতে পারে না'। এ কারণেই, যদিও 1946 সাল থেকে প্রায় 1.3 কোটি হিন্দুকে পূর্ববঙ্গ/পূর্ব পাকিস্তান/বাংলাদেশ থেকে বহিষ্কার করা হয়েছিল, বিশ্ব এই দেশত্যাগ সম্পর্কে জানে না এবং মনে করে যে এটি শুধুমাত্র পাঞ্জাবে হয়েছিল!, গান্ধীই পশ্চিমের মধ্যে জনসংখ্যার স্থানান্তর বন্ধ করেছিলেন। বাংলা ও বাংলাদেশ এবং তার পর নেহরু লিয়াকত চুক্তির নামে বাঙালি হিন্দুরা ক্ষতিগ্রস্ত হয়েছে যদি গান্ধী টাইপের ভাইরাস বাংলায় না আসত, বাঙালি হিন্দুদের এত কষ্ট হত না, এমনকি নোয়াখালীতেও সে অসভ্য বাঙালি মুসলমানদের আটকাতে পারেনি।
হাজার হাজার বাঙালি হিন্দু মুক্তিযোদ্ধা আছে একজন বাঙালি মুসলমান মুক্তিযোদ্ধার নাম বলতে পারেন??
That will never happen
bruh, stop saying this. You know Pakistanis will never accept this. They'll let go of anything but Kashmir. Let's not discuss this now. We shouldn't talk about it as if we're dying to take that part of J&K. Don't let them feel attacked, let them feel ashamed by developing our part of Kashmir while their side gets increasingly destabilized thanks to their own mismanagement of their beloved country. And maybe then we'll think about a solution for Kashmir.
Or maybe the better deal is to give them all 20 cr Pakistanis living in India?
1990-पाकिस्तान जिंदाबाद
2023-पाकिस्तान से जिन्दा भाग
2040-किधर गया पाकिस्तान
2050-क्या था पाकिस्तान
There never was a land in history known as pakistan. The people are punjabi, sindhi, baloch or pathans forcefully brought together by partion from Bharat to serve the interests of then english rulers. The ruling elite and army enjoyed themselves at the cost of the masses and have amassed huge wealth abroad.
Even today the ruling army gets its instructions from US who has used them as pawns.
The only solution is to break up pakistan and once the mess has been cleaned up, join back into Bharat in the long term.
Till then the pain and cycle has to be borne by the population and the world.
DW showing Arunachal Pradesh as disputed territory along with Pakistan is emboldening Chinese claims. Government should ban DW in India.
Pakistan sounds like to be in a load of mess. The rich remains rich and the poor becomes much poorer
1) Peace with India with current position of armed forces.
2) Cut defence spending to 10%.
3) Increase educational spending three fold and send people abroad who will send remittances and bring back expertise.
4) Help foreign investment especially in service sector.
5) Invest in tourism industry.
I think the point 2 won't and cannot be applied to Pakistan because they are the one who controls the country
Stop force conversion of Hindus to Islam in Pakistan. You forgot to main point which created radicalization.
None of this is going to happen
Foreign investment??
With every Friday 💣
@@nanthakumarrrSuspect Is hindu terrorist
As an Indian. I am very proud of our so called "Hindu Nationalist government".
And guess what DW you can whine all you want to, but there is nothing you can do about it😂
Half of this video is about india and its supposed Hindu nationalism. Its as if the desperation to bring that concoction up was way to great for DW that they couldn’t Handel it. And the question is…before this supposed Hindu nationalist government, were the relationship between india pak lovey-dovey?
Pakistan lived by the sword. In Afghanistan & in India. And backed by some Middle East powers. Now the chickens are coming home to roost. Unfortunately the military supported such ill advised forays.
Problems:
Lack of education
Foreign Policy
Military Rule
Religion
They have to start trading with nearby countries and stop the tension with India. Remove corruption, counter and stamp out terrorism and stop continuously resorting to IMF bailouts.
Where is Allah???
Really interesting report and a really good overview. I have very mixed feelings about Pakistan- one of the few countries I’ve visited that I genuinely disliked & found it hard to find much good in. The corruption is terrible and far to much of the population combine lack of education ( which can be fixed) but also deeply held ignorance , xenophobia & misogyny ( religious intolerance much harder to address). They are so dumb they keep voting against their own interests, which make no sense to me? Putting hope in making deals with China has to be the worst “two-ended sword” choice.... I hope it can be turned around into a better country.😢
Its short sighted. It thinks its a nuclear state so world is duty bound to help them. Their collapse is too disastrous for the world
Voting in Pak is inconsequential. Army calls the shot doesn't it?
The Solution is free and fair election
and i cant understand that when any western country describe indias ruling party they use hindu nationalist party ......are u mad if its like that than majority of western vountries are ruled by christanist nationalist party................if they use these words they cant get close to any developing nation
Gobar Bhakt show me in Western country beef and alcohol are banned! Or pork is banned? Or Curry and daal is banned?
One can’t view Pakistan-India and Pakistan-China relationships in isolation. They have to be viewed along with the India-China relationship.
Saying Pakistan is under threat because they fought 4 wars with India is wrong. Pakistan started all the 4 wars. The fear of India is perpetuated just to assign a large share of the budget to the military.
The expert saying “Pakistan should stop viewing itself as a warrior country “ is right. They should start behaving like a normal country putting the interests of the common citizen first. Unfortunately, it is easier said than done.
Pakistan 🇵🇰 === The Asian version of Nigeria 🇳🇬.
Large population + huge potentials but being messed up by politicians/security forces.
Nah Nigeria is much more developed than Pakistan
Pakistan should be compared with somalia
Dont insult nigeria like that it is a fast growing economy unlike pakistan
Disappointing to see @DW News show Kashmir and Arunachal Pradesh in the map as a disputed territory. Is DW News taking inputs from China on this? Should Russia start showing Berlin as part of Russian territory?
The concept of marshal race (warriors) is both a strength as well as a weakness and when particularly when the marshal race is a majority, it's catastrophic.
In the modern warfare consisting of flying weapons, unmanned delivery systems, electronic guidance, outter space occupation, etc. the so called marshal race is a big burden.
Whether it's the Balkans or the South of Caucus or the Central Asia regions, all these places unfortunately were in the middle of various political/ religious /ethnic blocks and always were /are in perpetual conflicts.
Pakistan as a nation should stop being proud of their warrior population. They are fit for fighting and nothing else
If a nation is full of warriors - education, trade, technology, society etc. would be the casualties in that nation. The only trading community in Pakistan were the Sindhi(s) (Hindus) - Pakistan successfully got rid of them in the name of religion.
Sooner they understand their fundamental problem, they have the chance of revival of the economy, else it will become another Afghanistan, always in perpetual wars - both internal and external...
Ironically, people who have essentially submitted to a foreign religion call themselves marshal and view those who endured hardships for centuries without giving up their original traditions as weak.
Such an interesting perspective...
They funny thing is they are not even good warriors. They have lost all the wars they have fought so far 😂
Curse of committing a genocide in 1971
What a completely useless waste of a video. Wasted my 21 minutes. I think DW stands for "Don't Watch".
What "Indian - American military ties"?! You mean when America sold F-16s to India? No wait, you mean when US sent an Aircraft Carrier to fight agsinst Pakistan in it's war vs India
Appreciate DW's penchant for enjoying its own Echo Chamber on & on & on.
Could you explain what they're getting wrong
sympathsing with the terrorist exporter@@changthunderwang7543
@@changthunderwang7543
Assuming that Pakistan wants to have a solution.
Pakistan has had numerous chances to save itself, it has frittered each one away. Even now, all it has to do is do away with its India enmity: basically reverse course.
It won't. You can't save a drowning person when they're _trying_ to drown themselves; they'll take you also down with them.
@@changthunderwang7543 they call pakistan unstable democracy ,when democracy is non existent in Pakistan. But they call Modi autocratic and what not.
@@changthunderwang7543Their pro-Pakistan stance is apparent in this video. Literally every "expert" interviewed here, including that clown "Gigolo-man" is pro- Pakistan.
There is no solution to Pakistan's woes...
Everyone loves to blame the politicians but nobody is willing to bell the Cat!
A politician in Pakistan knows that he will come to power and remain in power only if he keeps the military establishment (ME) in good humour!
Naturally he will be accountable to ME rather than to the people.
The Military Establishment in Pakistan controls majority of the resources (share of budget, land & property, businesses, etc) and on top of that it controls the Politicians, Bureaucrats and Judiciary by proxy. The current system which benefits them at the cost of all others - will not be allowed to change - no matter what!
And in order to maintain the hegemony of the ME…. Pakistan cannot afford to improve its ties with India!
It must continue this animosity with India on communal lines - which helped it create a separate country in the name of religion from British India...
Otherwise it cannot justify its existence as a separate country to its own brain-washed people.
There is no escape for Pakistanis!!
every country owns a military. military owns a country it’s called Pakistan
This place has been in crisis for the last thousand years
PKMKB 😂😂😂
Y'all think running a military and terrorists are cheap...
Manufacturing defects can not be removed from the final product unless the product is converted back to the raw material and made completely a new product ....
There is no way India and Pakistan can be at loggerheads forever. Normal relations would benefit Pakistan more than India. Most Indians don’t care but it is not good to have an unstable Pakistan as our neighbour….
I would say an unstable stable Pakistan is best for India. Someone which struggles at the same time having a stable rulers in that country.
I think a broken Pakistan always on its knees would be best for India
Pakistan should be divided because it is oppressive regime, Punjabi are ruling over others.
ur a perfect example of a librandu who lives in it's own la la land ... paapistan is like a golum character in lord of the rings, u cannot change the golum ( paapistan) character .
Between a sinking Pakistan and a strong Pakistan, we 🇮🇳 the people of Bharat🇮🇳, choose a sinking Pakistan...
We thank Jinnha for creating Pakistan... and saving we Kaafirs of Bharat🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳....
The day current pakistan got separated from india - it was bound to fail ....
Pakistan is living majorly on aid of US,EU,Saudi Arabia and UAE and international organisations . China does give them the money but china have already lost 68 billion USD by investing in CPEC that is not going according to plan and have threats from terrorists ,so china may leave them on their own too because china have their own money problem due to which they can't spend money like water like they used to do before. So yeah without stable western aid pakistan will collapse from economic challenges or the whole country resources will be sale .
there are nearly 20 crore paapistani living in iindia too ....the failure of iindia is not doing population ttransfer after 47' partition. that was a huge mistake by iindia it is going to haunt india .
Pakistan should follow the example of Bangladesh, which bolstered a fast growing economy
*Only solution is 100% Madrasa Education in Pakistan.*
Whenever I feel like the world is getting better , I just switch to dw and they never dissapoint . DW is the channel that maintains hypocrisy as standard. Never failed to entertain.
Thanks. Insightful. I have always thought the Pakistan government has spoken and acted with a forked tongue; playing a double game. Like in Myanmar, the military will not give up meddling. They are destined to remain a sick, stunted nation.
The only option for pakistan is to give-up its soverign state and divide into 4 countries, sindh, balouch, NW frontier and punjab.
Where is your nuclear bomb........pichbaade le lo unko😂😂😂
What Pak needs now is leadership that is genuinely interested in solving its problems. But no ray of hope as of now.
Bharat never attacks first on Pakistan. It has to stop terror. And everything depends upon how thinks people and how it act for the country. In realm Pakistan thinks over that their country possesses fertile land and they have cattle farm. If they are serious for agriculture and Pasupalan. and technological education. They are vert stern to perform their religion and may they. But they must attentive towards vocational guidance and activities and they are acutely lacking this. Their menace is only to fight with Bharat and that makes them weakest.
My idea for these Pakistani problems , Please , think this way , If Pakistan become a state of America , every body will be happy , like, Americans , Indian & Pakistan ( Pakistan is for sale ) Ha,Ha
The issue is that Pakistan is conducting a colonial occupation of several regions that are not legitimate parts of Pakistan. Balochistan is a totally separate country, Gilgit Baltistan belongs to India and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa belongs to Afghanistan. Pakistan has supported ISIS types to maintain these occupations but that costs money and is backfiring. The answer is to let these areas go and become a normal country.
Pakistan is a completely artificial entity. It has no historical basis. It was always part of various Indian empires.
So just punjab and sindh? That’s not going to happen. Baluchistan has too many resources and KP is a buffer against the Afghan tribes.
@@omarjaved9748 Pakistan can have good relations with Afghanistan after it returns Afghan lands.
Pakistan for its political gains did go too deep in Wests pocket and same is happening with their relationship with China. Unlike India or Bangladesh, they failed to reform a country for the interests of its citizens (education/health/land reforms etc). On top of that, after independence, their Rich and Elite leader class left the had been enjoying the western countries and never returned to give it back to the Pakistan.
This video shows Arunachal Pradesh as disputed territory. My fellow Indians, please report this video.
The largest ever experiment happened in 1947 with 400 million participants. Control was India and test was Pakistan. Same people but the only difference between them was Islam. 76 years down the line one country is 5th largest economy and soon to be third largest. the country which separated from 8ndia based on Islam is now a basket case. No marks for guessing what this experiment proved?
Pakistan especially West Pakistan which got the best resources of the Indian subcontinent has the best agricultural land, 50% of coal, the best cities (Lahore and Karachi), 40% of railways, 25%+ land for 16% of the population (West Pakistan - 20%+ land for 6% of the population), $100 Billion Aid from the USA alone, refused to pay the debt they own to India ($30 Billion at least by now) etc.
Western godi media: Pakistan secular democratic country
India hindu nationalist country 😂😂😂😂
Yes India is a Hindu nationalist
so????? we are hindu nation? any problem
@@hitanshuchaurasia3452 proctor to be hindu
Soo take yours moom away from hindu nation.....today or tomorrow we will make india hindu rastra
What crisis?
When does a country's defence budget, army personnels' networth, nuclear stockpile increase?
When it's economy grows.
Hence, paxtan is growing.
CPEC passes through the Indian territories of Gilgit and Baltistan , To normalise relations with India Pakistan would have to vacate POK.