ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Why Bollywood Makes Bad Films | Mayank Shekhar | TEDxIITKharagpur
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 ส.ค. 2015
- This video is a part of the talks given at TEDxIITKharagpur 2015, produced independently of the TED conferences. What makes a great film? What makes a bad film? As it turns out, of all the films that are produced, the most memorable ones are those that lie of the either ends of the spectrum. In this talk, Mayank Shekhar provides a sneak peek into the world of films. Movies are nothing but an outlet of the expectations of what a movie watcher wants to see. With songs and dance scenes dominating Indian cinema over scripts and acting, Mr. Shekhar discusses how our films can be improved in quality while maintaining their mass appeal.
Having hosted NDTV Prime Filmy, Mayank Shekhar, cultural editor at Hindustan Times, has always been accredited for his film reviews. Through his blog, The W14, he brings a unique perspective on movies, transcending the boundaries of entertainment journalism while striking just the right chord with the viewers.
This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at ted.com/tedx
Content of cinema is directly proportional to brain of audience
I think film content are should be powerful that change mind of the audience.
You just summed up the entire situation.
Indian movies:
Singing
Dancing
Fighting with no gravity
The actors are too talkative
@Terry Malloy what i do not like about indian movie are the fights..It's too hilarious..no offense
@Gerd Wiesler they don't have the brain capacity to do that
@@makchot3263 exactly
@T M true not all movies, just those made in india
@@daleksupreme2913 lol have you watched south indian movies which bring original content
Whenever I watch movies like the inception, the lunch box, the Shawshank redemption, etc. my family and friends always complain about having no song, dance , or masala in the films. In fact someone said me that inception was dumb, crazy and a boring film. So u guys get that why Bollywood produce these weird movies. What I think is that people should develop their minds for watching more artistic and clever films rather than watching movies like Gunda.
Even at this date my friends and family think that I watch weird n boring films whereas I think that they do.
Hollywood is far more superior than us. Be it movie or sitcoms. Most of the Indians movies and serials sucks and the public also buy those shits.
Saikat Sengupta our TV serials are shit as hell!
Its a torture when people in my house watch that.lol
Yash Kataria whatever says is totally true
Only thing works is commercially hit films
* commercially hit films in india
SGD017 Exactly bro!
lol
I hate Bollywood since few years back bcoz of only love story movies are continued making
Roshan Sarkar i dropped bollywood altogether
General Indian public don't watch a movie for it's aesthetic qualities, script or cinematography etc. They don't perceive it as a form of art.
Bollywood is so bad, it's not even entertainingly bad (Like the room) it's just embarrassing!
No Western video publishing company would ever license a Bollywood movie, it's that embarrassing.
Is that why Hollywood actors are begging to make a movie with the guy who has the biggest fan base on the planet. SRK
@@abdull1574 What deatbeats are those?
@@abdull1574 who or what is SRK?
@@abdull1574 they're not begging brother. Lmao SRK is a good actor but his movies most of them are average
In my view, most Bollywood actors either come from industry parents, uncles/aunts or the modelling industry. Once in a while an actor rises from the streets. Those are the guys that can actually act and get work outside India/Bollywood too!
I am the only one in my family who watches movies like interstellar and Goosebumps while majority of members and relatives get bored...that's why Bollywood makes shit movies...because they don't target me they target my family...because they have numbers to earn money...
Same here. Everyone in my family's want " down to earth films" but when I show them that kind of Hollywood films they say it's boring because there's no songs or dancing or action or whatever.
Dude there are way worse bollywood movies out there than Gunda. A lot of them have even won awards!
magnetdance😂😂
hahahahah
You saying....Gunda is a bad movie?
@jayesh pawar krish has 100 percent rating and dark knight 94 percent rating, do you really think krishh is greater than dark knight?
@@rahul17023 yes
yep...Bollywood suck
First of all closed tv shows like spiltvilla, love school, big boss bring back ted talks
In a country of 1.2 billion people there are many person with exceptional talent in film direction, acting, singing and many more. But todays generation(including me) always opt engineering not because they want to but due to peer pressure who think people in Bollywood are spoiled Brats not because of the films because how they show them(they always show that an actress is allowed to act in a movie if she sleeps with the director or the producer) and also there are star families who think that teir kids can act.
I also wanted to be a Director, writer but dreams crushed................
Sai Nagendra there is still hope for your dreams...carry out your passion for writing and filmmaking side by side!!
Sai Nagendra try being an indie film director. Times have changed. Now days anyone can just pick up a camera or a phone with good quality and make a film. So don't worry that much.
I might suggest a TH-cam channel called DariousBritt of D4Britt. He helps in such things and his videos can be educational but also inspirational.
Director requires people managment most important
Don't worry dear work hard u will be successful I wish u all the best .
there's a movie called drishyam in malayalam (which was remade in hindi with ajay devgon) try to watch it. that movie itself says the level of malayalam movies.!
Its a good movie but its not great as you make it out to be.
Its a watered down copy of a Japanese film
No need to look anywhere. Please watch Malayalam movies you will be amazed by the thought process, creativity, originality, acting what not.
Prem Kumar i agree
Say some good Malayalam movie to start with!!!
siddharth rajan drishyam,take off,mumbai police.
sadiya zubair thank you
Ever watched bengali movies
I simply don't watch box office hits. Then I remove movies with songs in it. Then I can see some decent Bollywood movie. The crapy mass market is the main reason why we have horrible hit movies.
Indian movies are not art.... it's a business.....
So true
@@hadesproteus8191 Bollywood movies are not art ....... it's a business FTFY
Not indian, hindi movies! Better learn not to generalize!
@@akshaypendyala yeah
bollywood is all bout copy.....................
I wish one day Bollywood will make "movies."..and which means script ...story acting that's all...no song and dance .... there's is a total different genre for that it called musical. In Bolly every movie is musical
Yea, there is no creativity/brilliance. It's SAME DAMN THING OVER AND OVER AGAIN!
I also wish that......
@@8270361507 You know....there is no lack of good writers, actors etc in India but the thing is they don't get opportunity
i thought gunda was a parody
Aren’t all Indian movies kind of a parody? 😂
The problem is that majority of indian audience don't really know what is a Movie!!!
Sneha S achchhi film to flop kra dete h. Tanhaji dekh 3d me fir kahna Hollywood se ham beat kr skte h.
Education problem
@@raja-jl9os true 😊☺️
Bollywood produces Such a garbage nevertheless people love actors like an angel.
Bollywood means copywood / Garbagewood
That's why I don't watch bollywood movies.
Even Tollywood is much better than Bollywood.
Bollywood will not be changed until unless Indian people want something new and creative.
there are some great movies but they aren't mainstream. mainstream hollywood movies aren't that good either
But tollywood needs to change its action scenes
@@sanghamitrabiswal6048 Lol, better watch the movies a bit closer and then talk, the action scenes in tollywood movies have become better, if you cannot see it just get lost you b****!
at least Manoj Bajpai deserves clapping after that small scene . That would be a small yet significant token of respect for such a rare great actor.
Bollywood aisa hi hai aur bohut nepotism people enjoying zero talented actors.
Time to evolve India through our culture
Bollywood films are as mind stimulating as watching paint dry
Govinda made 40 films within 8 years of his film career
and he's not attractive at all
Bollywood refuses to make versatile and original films, I don't find any of the movies they produce to be considered entertaining now.
DONOT watch all these crap Bollywood movies,only watch selected .
Indians should learn something from Korean movies and Japanese anime
そ です ね
and other japanese movies too
Our Content is very mediocre. Because the audience is mediocre
One got to understand the pshychee of Indian cinema goers. Most have a very drab and boring personal life. No excitement same old routines to go through and hence need some no brainier entertainment, where they are not required to focus on things like continuty, laws of physics, great method acting etc. So what do we get? You are right movies that makes no sense to real life.
Victorino Ferrao Movies can be crazy and unrealistic but also be very well written. Look at Star Wars (I refuse to call it A New Hope), look at Superman 78, look at any good superhero movie ever. Look at the first Kingsman movie. Its not like everyone living in America has a crazy, over the top, super exciting life.
this video should have million views.
bros watch Malayalam movies and Tamil movies and see the level of maturity the movies have and the willingness to experiment. Bollywood has starts Tamil and Malayam movies have actors and directors.
I think Mayank Shekhar should be given an opportunity to make a film. I think he'll do wonders.
He is very intellectual.
Good critics don't necessarily make good films. That's what Anupama Chopra told me a couple days ago in a panel in the India Film Project.
now a days, bollywood is nothing but Punjabi movies.
Watch Marathi movie
The side effect of subbing t series
This video aged well.
Filmmakers make such kind of movies as indirectly support comes from major chunk of audiences who rather care about cinema only expect some cringeworth entertainment (As stress buster in their weekends to their daily frustrating routines)
Taste of Bollywood audiences maybe beyond worse as they gave movie like judwaa 2 200crores while movies like trapped and many other were ignored.
Better go for some Malayalam movies as they are high on content compared to Bollywood in India
indian movie sucks. they get into fighting scene and suddenly they switch into dancing & singing and switch again into fighting. How weird
Rather than watching Bollywood movies I'll prefer watching 💩
You are not representing mass audience
dudes needs to pause in between sentences
Better to make bahubali type films
It is great movie but even its most scens are copied man just check it
6:17 And mist of the times the songs are coped from a different source.
Dude.... Breath. Take a breath. Take a pause and let your audience gulp the information you just fed them in previous minute. Don't bombard them with info.
Plus, You introduced you topic only in one sentence "We make bad films because we like to watch bad movies". Really? that's it?
He said it like it is. That is, after all, the truth
jo bikta hai wahi dikta hai it's a fault of audience !
Never in my life did i see sharukh khan and salman khan acting great as they speak i wonder why ? Actor like nawaz are ten times much better actor than any other
Actually srk has done good movies. But most of them weren't hit. So, he switched to masala movies.
See chak de india, Swades,my name is khan,u will get ur answer
I feel pity for so called actors. "jinhe bhari jawani mein , profession ke naam ye sab backchodi sehan karni padti h"
hy...I'm from Kharagpur...😊😊😊
angel mukherjee
To 😗
Mithun acted in more than 15 movies in 1998.
Eye opening. I’ve always been so perplexed by Bollywood
Here in Nigeria a lot of people thinks kabhi kushi kabhi gam is among the top movies in the world. The first time i saw the movie all i can see in the movie is bad acting and display of wealth, a lot of Bollywood movies displays wealth, beauty and unrealistic love
Unfortunately directors like Satyajit ray was not appriciated
Bhai commercial cinema m bhi bhut mehnat lagta h vfx, concept, action
Keep it up
absolutely true
Play at 0.70× speed
I've only seen a few Indian films. A lot of the male actors in bollywood seem especially bad at acting... But when I hear Indians speak of them they say things like "His portrayal was so REAL!!" Sheesh. They can't even see awful acting when it's right in front of them.
Which actors are u talking about?
Considering the fact that this whole session is done by a critic it's obviously one sided
I dont know guys. It might just have something to do with Indians. Wild guess
Why does it matter what Hollywood or anyone makes? We like songs in movies. We make them and we watch them. Why do we say it is bad or good?
If you keep repeating it throughout every films it gets old really fast. Singing and dancing don't always work. That's why the west don't take you guys seriously.
@@godzilla0083 sad truth.
@@sosringdaothaosen3562 Don't watch bollywood
Please watch malayalam movies
Fingers crossed, India will make a film like Inception. The audience need to be all open to all entertainment including European and Asian entertainment.
First you all need to do is de promote productions like t series and zee .
True story bro..
Movies of other countries: Love, Drama, Action, Thriller and educational
Indian movies: *boy loves girl but girl doesn't want boy but boy purpose girl and girl agreed but girl's dad doesn't agree*
That is true about the music. Hindi music is great but movies not so much.
Is there something like this but in ENGLISH?
What is the definition of "bad"?
That's why they are copying south indian movies
long story short, some movie directors and editors doesn't know what they're doing
bollywood movie plots: man meets girl, love song, men want to kill girl, man saves girl, man marries girl, the end
Why bollywood filmmakers and writer not make fantasy, superhero movie
Bollywood films are so bad, that I grew more iq than the directors directing the films.
The content was nice but it was poorly delivered.
Apologies, but I heard of Satya way before I heard of Gunda. While the speaker does make a few good points, just stringing words along does not make a speech. We have to understand that songs are not dissociated from Hindi movies, and that is not a bad thing - some songs have a role to play within the narrative. And don't movies from other industries have soundtracks now? The issues are the over-hyped actors, and the degree of acceptance from the public - there are things the audience cannot handle or digest. Film-making in Bollywood is very rarely about art, but then again, that is subjective. Let's not forget the masterpieces that do come from Hindi cinema.
yes thats very few in numbers, imean really very very few
But songs are often iritative
Ajay devgn and manoj bajpayee are far better than any stablish actor in bollywood
Irfan Khan: am I a joke to you?
@@jaykrishnak3268 Irfan Khan : Am I Alive?
is this speech relevant to the topic why bollywood make bad films except 2 or 3 lines in the whole speech.
Only 1 lakh+ views??
You make a very good point that I agree with, but is badly explained.
Telling the truth in a wrong way
How?(wanna know your viewpoint)
On the contrary I don't like songs in a movie sometimes they feel like a distraction. Rajnikant does not sing or dance that much he became a star because of his style of acting and other gimmicks and tricks he pulls off .
I don't like the songs either.
@@jaykrishnak3268 okay
Indian audience wants entertainment entertainment entertainment......
Entertainment ke liye or bhi cheeze hai bhai
Indian music might be good but indian music videos and lyrics is mostly horrible(with some rare
good gems) Which is a huge and important part of music out of which it means that
only instrumental,vocal,musical,melodical part of music thats good in india...
So over all important key parts that should be good in indian music are actually bad....so its not
that bollywood music is good just that most of the audience prefers bad movies with bad music as well...
I think there is a arrogance in Indian industry and even Indian audience industry don't want to make good movies and audience don't want to watch good movie
In Hollywood people always keep trying and keeping changing their style of movie and audience also keep changing and keeping trying new movies
I don't think Indian movies will ever change and even Indian audience will ever change their mind is too rigid to change
The US culture is all about change as well. Not held back by a rich long culture like India, it allows Americans to constantly evolve, especially with cinema.
@@trevor3013 i totally agree
Look out Tamil movies awesome story&creativity
Watch other industry except bollywood
Bollywood aways target hindus
Kaisa? Bollywood Movie Ke Jyadatar Characters Toh Hindu Hote Hai.
why is he moving so much!!!
The speaker sure sounds like Ranbir Kapoor.
Dawood, UAE aur pakistan produced bullywood jisme...urdu words Pakistani singer aur muslim writers aur bikao media...
Jo ek planned thought process sell karte hain...
Moula mere lele meri jaan..
Allah Allah tarif teri allah allah..
Barna hai milta kahan hum kafiro ko khuda(hasi banagye)
Mardala allah (devdas)
Aaja aaja me hun pyar tera allah allah..
Allah k bande husde...
Khuda hafiz...
Kesa yeh pyar hai allah allah
Khalibali hogaya..
Yaa Alli reham alli
Sajda tera sajda..
Aur bhi lambi list hai..
Aap bhi try karlo...baki sudh Hindi gano ko majak banakar pes kiya jata hai 😡😡
Sirf Allah Nahi Ram Ke Baare Mei Bhi Gaane Hai Bollywood Mei Tumhe Bas Hate Felana Hai Aur Kujh Nahi.
Support Hollywood
Bollywood is basically a parody of entertainment
He's about as boring as a Bollywood movie.
bhai India mein koi hindi bhi bolta hai ?
anu malik North Indians
Gawaar states
vernon lewis matlab sirf gawaar log hi Hindi mai baat karte hain??
English is an international language while Hindi is not. Also, internet is for many people. Ted talks most of the times are in English ..please don’t watch it if you have a problem..watch hindi videos instead..
@@vernonlewis5671 learn to respect all languages. Im hounoured to be a gawaar if Mahadevi Verma, Harivash Ray Bachchan and Narendra Modi are gawaar. And at last I want u to answer only one thing-
Do u dream in English?
I bet u dont
No offense but the guy is not very good in communicating/talking. The content might be good but it's very troublesome if you are not fluent with the language. Lots of pauses and uhm-ahms. Slowed the flow overall
This guy doesn't know how to speak. Film critics are usually of this kind they themselves r bad at everything.
This guy hasn't watched good films🤣🤣
bad and good films are in every industry, it's audience fault they watched bad films and bollywood knew what their future projects will be like🤷♂🤷♂
India make cringe movie specially in commercial movie's
20 saal baad achanak sab GUNDA ke piche pade hain
Creating an international or even general yardstick for movies or story telling may be a futile work. It is much more than that. Story means different for different people and communities. As long as it engages and sells to viewers it is to be respected. May Not be meeting any standards but still accepted by people should be considered for further learning.
Yes, exactly.
IMDB pe isko 10 rating dene walo kgpians, janta maaf nahi karegi!!
Bro Hindi bolne me dar lgta he Kya
Abe uski marzi hai. Woh Jan much ke English nahi bol raha hai. Tere ko samaj nahi ati toh kya tere liye alag se Hindi me bole.
Intellectual kaise kahlayega
angrez ka aulad hai na
theguy who gave 6/1pto captain america civil war lo