I don't think Liam and Noah know how to cooperate in such type of challenges... You don't just delete everything others made just because you don't like it. Try to make the most out of other devs' ideas, it's not only YOUR project.
Considering they’ve kicked out pry close to 100 games at this point that they’ve thrown on steam, after only a week of development, they seem to be very “quantity over quality” types. Aside from their “x number of devs worked on one game” videos I honestly find the channel to be a bit of a joke….
4 games in 1 day is insane! I got stressed just watching the video heh The 3D platformer came out quite nice, the gorgeous sprites in a 3D world makes for an interesting look.
This is such a fun idea! It could be fun to put a 'Christmas twist' on it and make each game specifically for another person in the group (this person would be skipped in the cycle). Then have that person react to his / her game at the end
Having a game cycle management and each will have a content update made by a different person in a different theme? For a ‘Christmas twist,’ that’s how I interpreted it.
idk the only way I know how collab on unity is plastic SCM and you should just be able to go through the version history, seems like he just wanted to restart.
Noa says “I had to leave for a few hours” partway through so he can move himself to be the last person in the cycle for three of the games… and then “accidentally deleted the entire level” (his words) at the end for the most fun one
Great video as always! Just one thing to mention: it would be exciting to see all of you playing these games at the end of the video and sharing your thoughts :D
Great video - suggestion if you do more of these. It would be fun to see the reaction of all developers playing eachother's games. Maybe all in a call where you recap and discuss what was changed & what each person's mindset was going into the projects. Looking forward to more videos from you guys
I think this shows that the games can be much better when the devs have more of their hours in a single session instead of spread across multiple sessions.
Oups yes you do look like an old granny in the drawing. I asked Liam whether it was a bit too much, but then he saw his character and said: I look like a fat rice ball so let’s keep sam the gran.
i am getting tired of seeing blackthornprod ruin games by putting his own spin on them. I get that it is your channel but seriously you do not have to be apart..
Fun video, but I would have expected some discussion about how the games turned out, or the reactions of the people who started it to what it turned into
Finally is here!! Wow, I wait for the video a lot!! i saw the live stream of Samyam and i think is a great and interesting way to collaborate! Nice games i love the style of the 3d climber!
Everyone did fine, Sam kinda just fucked everything up, and people are on noa & liam about it despite her throwing shit lines of code that didn’t even work, at other people. How were they supposed to know tbh
I feel like Liam's game could have been turned into some local multi-player game where you try to beat the other person by getting the most points or something.
Blackthornproductions slogan should just be "Don't Improve, Just remove" considering every challenge they just remove what the last person did and add their own crap in
I love this series / concept so much but it’s so frustrating sometimes to see some of the hard work put in completely bulldozed by blackthorn prod 🙃 I like it best when they let EVERYONE shine, and build something together, don’t just scrap stuff because it’s not their exact taste
I assume ur talking about sam? She literally destroyed mad projects + contrary to that her first hour submission was broken code that looked impossible to dechyper.
Goodness me you're all so talented 😂 45 mins per game! And I thought a 2 Day Game Jam was short! Really nice work with this, it seems like a lot of fun!
Still love the idea, but there are a lot of tower defence type of games, which is a bit tiring. I wonder what will be next in this series? Baybe the same idea not in short but in long? For example one project a few devs and a few days & cycles?
I wouldn’t mind if these vids were longer I know you edited a lot out lol or I would also like it if you made it longer like working on the games for a longer period of time. Either way I really enjoy this content.
I am also a Game Dev, but currently I have no time at all. But I would love to be part of some of those challenges at the beginning of next year. Because on the weekend spending some time on something like this would be really fun and I could finally have some content again for my TH-cam Channel which got not so much love in recent years. Because I studied Game Development and now work in a Games Company, after working in normal IT as a Programmer for a year.
Man, you guys are so good at this. I'm practicing toon shaded 3D game art on my channel and hoping I can make a game with it sometimes in the future! 😁
Cool! As an idea for a similar video I can propose something like "4 Devs try to Mess Up each other's game", adding some plot twists, changing the genre completely, turning a peaceful clicker into a survival horror or something like that:D
Game D was the one that turned out best because: -Game A started without a clear mechanic. -Game B had no graphics, which made it difficult for others to grasp the core concepts. -Game C had graphics and a mechanic, but they had trouble going in the same direction -The label that says "Climb the spire" made Game D clear for the next person. -Game D was the most straight forward idea, and even though it wasn't unique at its base, they created a unique atmosphere together.
Short question, is the programming language used here c+? Because I wanted to start programming as a hobby and I’m confused which languages I’m supposed to use to code, draw etc. thanks in advance! :)
You are the best person to explain in a legendary way. I hope you will work hard on a whole series to learn how to make an online game and play with my friend's. I love you :O ❤️💔
imo, too many projects, too little time, too short of a video, and all the games are pretty basic. I rather prefer the idea of working on only one project and give enough time to add more exciting features
This title made me remember of a quote: "Project Manager is somebody who thinks that 9 pregnant woman can deliver a baby in 1 month"
That is a pretty good quote, will try and place it in a conversation some day! ;D
I don't think Liam and Noah know how to cooperate in such type of challenges... You don't just delete everything others made just because you don't like it. Try to make the most out of other devs' ideas, it's not only YOUR project.
It’s funny cause they’re the ones who came up with the idea so they should know how it works the best
Considering they’ve kicked out pry close to 100 games at this point that they’ve thrown on steam, after only a week of development, they seem to be very “quantity over quality” types. Aside from their “x number of devs worked on one game” videos I honestly find the channel to be a bit of a joke….
They do this every episode, he enforces his ugly art on every project
Fr, they always ruin great games and make them all look the same with a very specific art style.
4 games in 1 day is insane! I got stressed just watching the video heh
The 3D platformer came out quite nice, the gorgeous sprites in a 3D world makes for an interesting look.
Thanks Hugo! It was a tricky challenge!
Sam *does something
Liam and Noa: and i took that personally
😭
💀
She’s not that good tbh
@@HS7x3 She seems about on par with everyone else, it's incredibly difficult to make anything in 45 minutes
I think starting with code instead of some visuals to convey your direction was a mistake, no one ever does that in these challenges for a reason
this turned out sick! but the best part is definitely our beautiful portraits
I'm curious what you did when you accidentally worked on the wrong project
Thanks bro! 🔥🤣
I like to think I'm quick, but holy cow! You folks have really been working out those game jam muscles. 💪
Thanks man! Yeah we had to be real speedy here. Cool channel by the way, hope to see you hustling on LD 52 😁
@@Blackthornprod Thanks!
Fingers crossed I get time for LD 52! Would love to join that one.🤞
Two people Im subbed to in the same comment chain! Great video man!
Your playlist is misspelled. Says “poject” instead of project. @HelperWesley
@@pricelessmakoa4482 Oh wow, that's been there a looong time, I never noticed. 😅
Thanks for mentioning it. 👍
This is such a fun idea! It could be fun to put a 'Christmas twist' on it and make each game specifically for another person in the group (this person would be skipped in the cycle). Then have that person react to his / her game at the end
That is a really cool idea :D
@@Blackthornprod Hi
Having a game cycle management and each will have a content update made by a different person in a different theme?
For a ‘Christmas twist,’ that’s how I interpreted it.
Haha, that's amazing. A bit confused how the whole level got accidentally deleted, wouldn't it still be in the files sent from the previous person?
he probably just wanted to restart lol
idk the only way I know how collab on unity is plastic SCM and you should just be able to go through the version history, seems like he just wanted to restart.
@@unknowndarkthing yea that level looked pretty messy
@@domedin9894 pppp
@@domedin9894 p
Only a few minutes in, I'm assuming Noa is gonna ruin each game with bosses
shut it, bosses are a good addition
Noa says “I had to leave for a few hours” partway through so he can move himself to be the last person in the cycle for three of the games… and then “accidentally deleted the entire level” (his words) at the end for the most fun one
@NulliosG yeah had a feeling he would pull something like that
I really like the idea of a 2D character in a 3D world. Props to Polymars
Great video as always! Just one thing to mention: it would be exciting to see all of you playing these games at the end of the video and sharing your thoughts :D
Great video - suggestion if you do more of these. It would be fun to see the reaction of all developers playing eachother's games. Maybe all in a call where you recap and discuss what was changed & what each person's mindset was going into the projects. Looking forward to more videos from you guys
I think this shows that the games can be much better when the devs have more of their hours in a single session instead of spread across multiple sessions.
What an exciting video to work on and holy cow the end products look good! Also why do I look like that in the hand drawn figure lmao😂
Oups yes you do look like an old granny in the drawing. I asked Liam whether it was a bit too much, but then he saw his character and said: I look like a fat rice ball so let’s keep sam the gran.
😑
hopefully you aren't in the next one lol
@@HM-bq7muLMAO
@@HM-bq7mu damn bro chill
i am getting tired of seeing blackthornprod ruin games by putting his own spin on them. I get that it is your channel but seriously you do not have to be apart..
Fun video, but I would have expected some discussion about how the games turned out, or the reactions of the people who started it to what it turned into
out of the only 2 videos I've watched on this channel they both ended with noa deleting everyone else's work just for his own
exactly it’s super annoying when someone makes a good game and he just removes it because he doesn’t want that game and just wants a shooter or smth
Yeah then he adds a new rule and make sure he goes first so everything goes his way
Nice work you all - looks like a ton of fun 😊
Despite some speed bumps on game B I think that one turned out super cool!
Thanks man! 🔥
These challenges are so exciting and unique
Finally is here!! Wow, I wait for the video a lot!! i saw the live stream of Samyam and i think is a great and interesting way to collaborate! Nice games i love the style of the 3d climber!
❤
Glad you liked it!
i honestly don’t blame noah and liam this video, the other devs didn’t do much at all to help the projects
Everyone did fine, Sam kinda just fucked everything up, and people are on noa & liam about it despite her throwing shit lines of code that didn’t even work, at other people. How were they supposed to know tbh
Would be nice to see u guys play them together/talk about the finished games to each other at the end!
I feel like Liam's game could have been turned into some local multi-player game where you try to beat the other person by getting the most points or something.
Great video!! It was sad seeing how most of Sam's ideas had to be removed lol.
i overengineered it 😭
@@samyam True!! Can you explain what game you tried to make?
@@cybeartron Similar to Toontown Minnie’s Matching game where you have to press a sequence of buttons in order to win
@@samyam ohhhh
That was such a blast to watch! You all did great!!! And also fredoka is one of my fav fonts as well :)
Blackthornproductions slogan should just be "Don't Improve, Just remove" considering every challenge they just remove what the last person did and add their own crap in
to be fair sam didn’t actually make anything so i forgive liam for starting something new
literally one round sam just made the platforms rotate weirdly which makes the game look bad and makes no sense
epic video as always, you've done so much stuff alot to this year, and i love it! :D
No bruh her unity setup kills me 1:37
I love this series / concept so much but it’s so frustrating sometimes to see some of the hard work put in completely bulldozed by blackthorn prod 🙃 I like it best when they let EVERYONE shine, and build something together, don’t just scrap stuff because it’s not their exact taste
I assume ur talking about sam? She literally destroyed mad projects + contrary to that her first hour submission was broken code that looked impossible to dechyper.
I witnessed @polymars attempt to sabotage this collab live.
He was up to some nasty tricks The Poly.
Samyam adds random stuff for no reason lmao
Goodness me you're all so talented 😂 45 mins per game! And I thought a 2 Day Game Jam was short!
Really nice work with this, it seems like a lot of fun!
Excellent work my lads!! Fabulous work and great collaboration 👍
Game B might be my favorite, i like the growing and shrinking adding a puzzle feel to it
why is Liam or Noah always remove features others add? what is the point of this challenge then
Still love the idea, but there are a lot of tower defence type of games, which is a bit tiring. I wonder what will be next in this series? Baybe the same idea not in short but in long? For example one project a few devs and a few days & cycles?
I wouldn’t mind if these vids were longer I know you edited a lot out lol or I would also like it if you made it longer like working on the games for a longer period of time. Either way I really enjoy this content.
i love these types of videos! plz keep doing more!! maybe another one with Hugo! 😎
Grateful for your channel's inspiration in dark times. My game is set for Steam after two years of learning!
Okay, that was stressful - great work guys!
Keep the game dev challenges coming plz. My new fav genre of TH-cam vid
Really like the look of Project A, the mind protection one, great stuff!
Love this concept! Amazing video! New subscriber for sure 🙌
Love your videos noa and liam😁
These videos are exciting and inspirationa, Keep them coming!! 🙌🏾🙌🏾
I am also a Game Dev, but currently I have no time at all. But I would love to be part of some of those challenges at the beginning of next year. Because on the weekend spending some time on something like this would be really fun and I could finally have some content again for my TH-cam Channel which got not so much love in recent years. Because I studied Game Development and now work in a Games Company, after working in normal IT as a Programmer for a year.
Liam's troops at the beginning looked like candles
Nice video as always, cheers
Hands down some of the BEST dev style videos and I wish more devs would do this! So awesome!
Amazing format, love it👌
I miss the classic poly mars look w/ the split hair lmaoo
Man, you guys are so good at this. I'm practicing toon shaded 3D game art on my channel and hoping I can make a game with it sometimes in the future! 😁
Cool! As an idea for a similar video I can propose something like "4 Devs try to Mess Up each other's game", adding some plot twists, changing the genre completely, turning a peaceful clicker into a survival horror or something like that:D
Thought u were gonna show off the games at the end?
Nice work guys
"no communication" yet Noah uses text in 2 games to explain to the next dev what his plan was with the game.
Would love to see the reaction of the developers when the game is finished!
Game D was the one that turned out best because:
-Game A started without a clear mechanic.
-Game B had no graphics, which made it difficult for others to grasp the core concepts.
-Game C had graphics and a mechanic, but they had trouble going in the same direction
-The label that says "Climb the spire" made Game D clear for the next person.
-Game D was the most straight forward idea, and even though it wasn't unique at its base, they created a unique atmosphere together.
Very nice. Gave me tons of ideas.
Amazing video, very entertaining
You should be scared every time polymars says that he will make his own sound effects
Short question, is the programming language used here c+? Because I wanted to start programming as a hobby and I’m confused which languages I’m supposed to use to code, draw etc. thanks in advance! :)
It's Unity so it's C#
What are the odds of training someone completely new to this. Then be able to make a game
i would really like to see you continue the piece by piece remake
we need longer videos to see more of the reactions and process of each person
also, why can't i play the games from this video? lol
Always supaaa motivating watching your vidssss🙃🙃
No reactions to the games?
The developer art tho
New Gartic phone mode looks very impressive!
Love the idea 💡
seriously how do you come up with these challenges lmaooo
It is frustrating when the devs try and do something with a game, and Liam and Noah immediately delete it.
Wouldnt the dev who worked on it last still have all the imtact files? Why remake the levels?
Im just starting the vid. But i have a feeling im gonna watch Noa completely ignore what everyone else has done because he thinks his ideas are better
Definitely think deleting the level of game D was no accident 😂, it definitely needed to be restarted for better level design
Are the games available to download?
4 Producers 1 Sample vibes
Could you do like a Korean War game or something
You are the best person to explain in a legendary way. I hope you will work hard on a whole series to learn how to make an online game and play with my friend's. I love you :O ❤️💔
Samyam out here trying to make a Hideo Kojima like video game I'm not smart enough to understand LUL
This Chanel inspired me to make games
Samyam needs more practice
just keep playing persona
@@addisonknox5052 ?
sponcered by stream! *Uses discord*
this idea is insane
4 games must create 4 devs in 1 day
Does Noa have to put his over used art style on literally everything?
Love these vids
We need to watch you guys play it and react to what happened with them
Poly vibing is honestly the best part of the video. (10:14)
More tower defense... Yay... 😮💨
yo can i download those games?
imo, too many projects, too little time, too short of a video, and all the games are pretty basic. I rather prefer the idea of working on only one project and give enough time to add more exciting features
PLS LET US PLAY THE GAMES
Time to vibdeo gameses😁
more of this!
What do you mean, you had to go do something for a few hours?
Hey, you should check out flax engine, also would love to see Dani Collab with you
4 devs one game next?
Accidentally deleted