Well couldn’t agree more with your number 1. I have always been fascinated with her performance. I mean like, her voice may be as not as strong as the others but I feel really calm and relaxed when listening to it especially on my way home after a tiring day. She still remains as my favourite Anna though! Thanks for number 4! It looks like her name is one of the longest here XD
I’m so happy you like the French version 🥰 I didn’t expect this kind of rich, deep voice from my country, that’s typically more a singer I’d see in a Canadian version but I’m so proud of having her as my Chang’e :D and I also love that you put Greek so high too, she’s a real gem :)
I actually prefer Indonesian more than Malay XD (I love Imba sari’s voice so much) Cantonese, Japanese, Greek, Thai, Turkish, and Hungarian were my favourites💓
O my God! I wasn't expecting Erasmia so high, I thought you had forgotten her!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ I knew Pia would be first, actually I was guessing that it would be Pia or Marfa. Magnificent ranking!!
Egyptian Arabic is also one of my favs. 💛 It's strange that I don't like MSA version at all despite the same singer. Noha did an amazing job in Arabic (Egypt)!
What can I say? Amazing ranking, but most of all congratulations for managing to rank Chang'e's voices. I had such a haaaard time ranking them. Anyway, I can't say our opinion are the best match, but I mostly agree with your placements. Especially your favourites have high spots in my ranking, too. Your top 15 is full of gems. Excellent job and thanks for the 11th spot😉
Egyptian Noha: Big Yes. MSA Noha: Big No. Not a big fan of Suzanne but she does has a nice voice. Oh I love Gisela and I think she would sound great on Chang'e (with her being Elsa and all) but at the same time I would have been disappointed if it would have been Gisela again (or any other voice we already know) so therefore I am happy we got a bunch of new voices for Chang'e.
Can see why someone would not like Suzanne, honestly, can't blame you for her place in the ranking at all. Gisela would have been awesome, but at the same time she has dubbed quite a few characters already so hearing someone new was great. Not that I would have minded hearing her again, she's my favourite Castilian voice after all haha Hearing other Elsa's on Chang'e was a nice surprise, though. I'm really digging how they sound in these songs.
I have been really dying for a rank of this character!! I agree one Arabic is a lot worse than the other. Exact same feeling on Castilian...she's so neutral for me. LOL don't even make me THINK of Meshi on Chang-e. That would be such a bad choice. Agreed on Imba, hope she's back someday. I like your country's version quite a bit. Because not many ranks exist of this character yet, I couldn't tell you if your tops are unusual. I am a big Pia fan too of course, it seems she might be one of the most popular voices for her.
Me too I wanted more rankings of her and then I was well, let's just do it myself. I know Meshi would be bad on Chang'e but she dubbed many roles already where I was like: Seriously Non/Disney Israel?! Pia is thebomb.com
Great ranking! I hope to see more rankings of Chang’e soon :D I must say I’m glad you decided to separate the Arabic versions, for I’m sure the MSA version would always drag the Egyptian one down x) It’s interesting how Noha is equally good in LSN and YF, but is worse in Hey Boy and especially Ultraluminary in the MSA version. Nonetheless, I think this is by far her best role as well, very different from how she usually sounds! So many amazing voices this time around, so I bet people’s top 10s won’t be very similar haha. I wasn’t really into Phillipa when the movie was out, but I’m totally under her charm now! I’m not sure if I love Pia that much this time, but that was a stellar top 10 regardless of that! :D
Yeah I know it's weird how bad her Ultraluminary sounds in the MSA version compared to her Egyptian one. Noha does sound way more fierce as Chang'e a side I didn't know she had. True so many good voices that Top 10's look very different!
I put Katya, Suzanne, Maya, Diamond, Imba, Daiana, Radics, Erasemía higher I put Chitchanok, Lourdes, Vendula, Céng Sī-Yú, Noha, Rosalie, Vanda, Jeanne, Katarzyna lower
0:50 YES! I was soo mad when I found Sylvia didn’t sing her songs, she voiced a DISNEY PRINCESS why they didn’t choose her to do Chang’e too (no hate to Cidalia of course, I like her but not as Chang’e))
This was the first song where I was very impressed with Pia! I knew she was great but I have always thought Rapunzel and Anna were wrong type of characters for her. I had heard so many amazing versions of this character and was super excited to see who was singing in the Finnish version... aaand I was super disappointed to see Katja's name there :| She's one of the most common voice actresses in Finnish dubs and while she's very good voice actress, I was hoping to hear something more special for this character. It's very much like when they cast Katja Sirkiä for Elsa, these two do very similar roles in many shows and commercials. I like the fact that they give bigger roles for common voice actors too but also wish they would use special talents when the role kinda requires it. Chang's speaking voice was different actress and I thought she was much more suited, I was surprised they didn't give the singing parts for her since she has also done lot of musical roles etc. And she is pretty common voice actress once again too.
Great that you love Pia as well. Was afraid you might be disappointed to see the Finnish version so low. I am happy that a Fin thinks that she isn't that great either. I think even Saara Aalto would have been a better choice for a singing voice for Chang'e...
@@AmberBasti Now that you mention her, I'm kinda surprised they didn't go with Saara for this character! She would have been kinda obvious choice, she loves to sing this kind of songs and has even studied Chinese language
If Celia still sounds like her Megara days, yeah that would be a good choice. But they also could have gone with Gisela for example. So yeah I am different it's a new voice and not someone we already knew.
@@dasnet6846 Oh yeah she is great as Giselle & Elsa, still would have been disappointed if she would have also been Chang'e. I lose interest in voices when they voice more than like three roles (so I also hope Pia Allgaier won't be picked for a while)
@@AmberBasti Seriously, the know this community? Because ALWAYS overuse the voice that we love. And I don't like Meshi's Performances, so imagine, for that, the are a lot CGI characters that I don't like in Hebrew because of that
@@dasnet6846 Oh believe I know... I adored Meshi as Rapunzel (and still do actually) but everything after that is just not as great and would have been tons better, if someone else voiced the character... Same as the voices in my country I love Joke de Kruijf and Laura Vlasblom because they are childhood but I wish there would have been more different voices...
I think that would have been a great choice. I'm still waiting for Bella Santiago to be the singing voice of an animated character in Romanian and I think she would have been perfect for Chang'e...
![F.HERO Ft. JSPKK x ลำไย ไหทองคำ x M-PEE - ไม่สนิทบิดหมด (Thai Riders Anthem) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kPJZ0UihBfk/mqdefault.jpg)
Joehoe! Chang'e voices are amazing! So rather look at the comments than the placement! I already really like my Top 20 ranking this was very hard!
Well couldn’t agree more with your number 1. I have always been fascinated with her performance. I mean like, her voice may be as not as strong as the others but I feel really calm and relaxed when listening to it especially on my way home after a tiring day. She still remains as my favourite Anna though!
Thanks for number 4! It looks like her name is one of the longest here XD
THX FOR HUNGARIAN!! Gigi has such a amazing voice…I fell in love with it at my first listen!! Thx for the high ranking for her!!
Thanks for German!! I thought you forgot her at first haha I love Pia but she sounds so much like Anna/Rapunzel to me, I can’t help it 😂
Ha to me she doesn't, she sounds way more fierce than she does in the 'kinder' roles.
Thanks for 11🇮🇹🇮🇹
Agree whit; Malay,Croatian,Greek and german
I’m so happy you like the French version 🥰 I didn’t expect this kind of rich, deep voice from my country, that’s typically more a singer I’d see in a Canadian version but I’m so proud of having her as my Chang’e :D and I also love that you put Greek so high too, she’s a real gem :)
French did a great job (like normally) but they did surprised me with their choice, a real special one she is!
I actually prefer Indonesian more than Malay XD (I love Imba sari’s voice so much) Cantonese, Japanese, Greek, Thai, Turkish, and Hungarian were my favourites💓
O my God! I wasn't expecting Erasmia so high, I thought you had forgotten her!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I knew Pia would be first, actually I was guessing that it would be Pia or Marfa. Magnificent ranking!!
Nope, I don't forget a pearl like Erasmia
Thanks for 3rd place!
Thanks so much for the 4h place :D Yeah, Kasia is an amazing dubber
Egyptian Arabic is also one of my favs. 💛 It's strange that I don't like MSA version at all despite the same singer. Noha did an amazing job in Arabic (Egypt)!
What can I say? Amazing ranking, but most of all congratulations for managing to rank Chang'e's voices. I had such a haaaard time ranking them. Anyway, I can't say our opinion are the best match, but I mostly agree with your placements. Especially your favourites have high spots in my ranking, too. Your top 15 is full of gems. Excellent job and thanks for the 11th spot😉
It was hard ranking her, many great voices! You're very welcome Erica slays.
I thought you forgot Katarzyna for a sec, thanks a lot! x) Iconic number one, obviously!
I would never forget Katarzyna :)
Thanks for the 5th place
I'm so happy to see we share quite a few favourites, #1 included, she's incredible
Egyptian Noha: Big Yes. MSA Noha: Big No. Not a big fan of Suzanne but she does has a nice voice. Oh I love Gisela and I think she would sound great on Chang'e (with her being Elsa and all) but at the same time I would have been disappointed if it would have been Gisela again (or any other voice we already know) so therefore I am happy we got a bunch of new voices for Chang'e.
Can see why someone would not like Suzanne, honestly, can't blame you for her place in the ranking at all.
Gisela would have been awesome, but at the same time she has dubbed quite a few characters already so hearing someone new was great. Not that I would have minded hearing her again, she's my favourite Castilian voice after all haha
Hearing other Elsa's on Chang'e was a nice surprise, though. I'm really digging how they sound in these songs.
I have been really dying for a rank of this character!! I agree one Arabic is a lot worse than the other. Exact same feeling on Castilian...she's so neutral for me. LOL don't even make me THINK of Meshi on Chang-e. That would be such a bad choice. Agreed on Imba, hope she's back someday. I like your country's version quite a bit. Because not many ranks exist of this character yet, I couldn't tell you if your tops are unusual. I am a big Pia fan too of course, it seems she might be one of the most popular voices for her.
Me too I wanted more rankings of her and then I was well, let's just do it myself. I know Meshi would be bad on Chang'e but she dubbed many roles already where I was like: Seriously Non/Disney Israel?! Pia is thebomb.com
Thank you so much for Vanda's placement! :) I think she slayed this role ♥
She sure did!
Great ranking! I hope to see more rankings of Chang’e soon :D
I must say I’m glad you decided to separate the Arabic versions, for I’m sure the MSA version would always drag the Egyptian one down x) It’s interesting how Noha is equally good in LSN and YF, but is worse in Hey Boy and especially Ultraluminary in the MSA version. Nonetheless, I think this is by far her best role as well, very different from how she usually sounds!
So many amazing voices this time around, so I bet people’s top 10s won’t be very similar haha. I wasn’t really into Phillipa when the movie was out, but I’m totally under her charm now! I’m not sure if I love Pia that much this time, but that was a stellar top 10 regardless of that! :D
Yeah I know it's weird how bad her Ultraluminary sounds in the MSA version compared to her Egyptian one. Noha does sound way more fierce as Chang'e a side I didn't know she had. True so many good voices that Top 10's look very different!
I put Katya, Suzanne, Maya, Diamond, Imba, Daiana, Radics, Erasemía higher
I put Chitchanok, Lourdes, Vendula, Céng Sī-Yú, Noha, Rosalie, Vanda, Jeanne, Katarzyna lower
i don't like katja.
0:50 YES! I was soo mad when I found Sylvia didn’t sing her songs, she voiced a DISNEY PRINCESS why they didn’t choose her to do Chang’e too (no hate to Cidalia of course, I like her but not as Chang’e))
I am not the biggest fan of Sylvia either, but I think she was a better choice for Chang'e than Cidalia...
This was the first song where I was very impressed with Pia! I knew she was great but I have always thought Rapunzel and Anna were wrong type of characters for her.
I had heard so many amazing versions of this character and was super excited to see who was singing in the Finnish version... aaand I was super disappointed to see Katja's name there :| She's one of the most common voice actresses in Finnish dubs and while she's very good voice actress, I was hoping to hear something more special for this character. It's very much like when they cast Katja Sirkiä for Elsa, these two do very similar roles in many shows and commercials. I like the fact that they give bigger roles for common voice actors too but also wish they would use special talents when the role kinda requires it. Chang's speaking voice was different actress and I thought she was much more suited, I was surprised they didn't give the singing parts for her since she has also done lot of musical roles etc. And she is pretty common voice actress once again too.
Great that you love Pia as well. Was afraid you might be disappointed to see the Finnish version so low. I am happy that a Fin thinks that she isn't that great either. I think even Saara Aalto would have been a better choice for a singing voice for Chang'e...
@@AmberBasti Now that you mention her, I'm kinda surprised they didn't go with Saara for this character! She would have been kinda obvious choice, she loves to sing this kind of songs and has even studied Chinese language
@@yourillusionndream I know right! It would make more sense for sure!
thanks a lot for 4th place 💟
You're welcome! I stan Katarzyna in everything she does
Can you post poor unfortunate souls in talegu please
Why do you think I have that version. Because I really don't...
@@AmberBasti sorry😞
I would have preferred Celia (Castilian Megara) more than Lourdes, but glad that my country gave us finally a completely new voice
If Celia still sounds like her Megara days, yeah that would be a good choice. But they also could have gone with Gisela for example. So yeah I am different it's a new voice and not someone we already knew.
@@AmberBasti Yeah, Gisela had a "diva" voice sometimes so that would have been great, and I see that you really like Gisela, I'm right?
@@dasnet6846 Oh yeah she is great as Giselle & Elsa, still would have been disappointed if she would have also been Chang'e. I lose interest in voices when they voice more than like three roles (so I also hope Pia Allgaier won't be picked for a while)
@@AmberBasti Seriously, the know this community? Because ALWAYS overuse the voice that we love.
And I don't like Meshi's Performances, so imagine, for that, the are a lot CGI characters that I don't like in Hebrew because of that
@@dasnet6846 Oh believe I know... I adored Meshi as Rapunzel (and still do actually) but everything after that is just not as great and would have been tons better, if someone else voiced the character... Same as the voices in my country I love Joke de Kruijf and Laura Vlasblom because they are childhood but I wish there would have been more different voices...
Ty for 12th place but TBH I find Her very annoying
i would have preferred dalma over ana bianca tbh :(
I think that would have been a great choice. I'm still waiting for Bella Santiago to be the singing voice of an animated character in Romanian and I think she would have been perfect for Chang'e...
@@AmberBasti omg yes but her accent is kinda weird xd
@@meowoofie lol I don't speak Romanian so I wouldn't be able to hear xD.