Personal Ranking - Chang'e (34 voices)

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 13

  • @hefraindisnerd
    @hefraindisnerd 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Thank u for putting Daiana aka my version in 1rst Great Ranking! :D

  • @natasharomanov7565
    @natasharomanov7565 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Such a great ranking once more!!! I was expecting Daiana to be so high and rightfully, though it was a big surprise to see her first! She is a worthy winner!! I agree with every single word you wrote about Marfa, she is stunning!! Thank you so so so so much about Erasmia, my girl shines in every Chang'e's song! ❤️❤️❤️
    Your top 15 includes the majority of my favorite voices of the character, even though I haven't make my mind yet!!

    • @strubel946
      @strubel946  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Thank you very much and you're welcome about Erasmia, really great surprise from Greece after some repetitive casts (Alexandra, Sia, Vassia...) ahah :D

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Nice 1st, but I have to tell you that Daiana is from Argentina. Hehe :)

  • @rishabhrox1
    @rishabhrox1 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    "so glad India didn't cast Sunayana again" - funnily enough, Sunayana was the dubbing director for this film (and you can hear her in the backing vocals of Ultraluminary too LMAO) so maybe you should thank HER only, for Suzanne's casting and dubbing lol. Glad Suzanne finally got a lead character though, prior to this she only sang for one of the muses in Hercules, the Let It Go pop version in Ralph 2 and some backing vocals. I guess Sunidhi coming back to back in 2019 was already enough for you XDD But honestly its not a lot, cuz Elsa & Nala are the only two "rankable" roles she ever did (cuz in HSM and Camp Rock, she's the only one who dubbed, nearly everyone else saw those movies with English songs XDD)
    For the ranking, I'm yet to hear more songs in Cantonese but at least in ultraluminary I am completely in love with her. I also like Imba quite a lot actually. But Katja and Rosalie, not so much. And Vania's vibrato kind of annoys me. Jeanne surprised me too, finally we're entering the era of French voices who can SING it out as much as they portray the character as well. Her & Ana Ka are my current obsessions.

    • @strubel946
      @strubel946  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Ahah I was SURE you would react about that sentence, more than the fact that I'm maybe the only one who put Suzanne in a top 10 lol. Ok Sunayana was the dubbing director and she did a great cast but for example in Brazilian Cidalia Castro was also the dubbing director and she casted herself as Chang'e whereas it was a wrong choice IMO, so being the dubbing character doesn't prevent to be casted as an important character. Instead of casting her as Chang'e and Lara Suleiman as Fei Fei's mother, the opposite would have been more convincing and relatable. And I'm not enough familiar with Sunayana to recognize her in the backing vocals ahah. About Sunidhi I just think she's not enough special and amazing to dub two big characters or more, but well as I said you should be more focused on the positive points (like the fact that it's maybe the 1st ranking where you see Suzanne that high) instead of futilities like that lol.
      I get what you mean about recent French voices (like in Encanto for example) since it's the fact that there's a new generation of musical directors who are doing a great succession of Claude Lombard & Georges Costa : Magali Bonfils & Quentin Bachelet. But well I think that this subject (voices who can SING it out as much as they portray the character as well) is more a matter of personal taste about the voice itself and the approach of the character.
      Thanks for your comment :)

    • @rishabhrox1
      @rishabhrox1 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@strubel946
      Haha okay man, I notice everything! Like, if a ranking is interesting, I notice everything. Nothing is a futility, I take all the vibes you give me haha. I did notice Suzanne being #9, but i didnt mention it because....I honestly dont care. I dont watch rankings to get impressed by seeing my version's rank, I watch them to see how people's opinions are, and how they express them. Also, like....let me have some agency as your audience too sksks....They say that 'how your audience perceives your art, is up to them, you cannot dictate it fully'. You've created the art, your ranking, now lemme see it how i want to skks.
      Being dubbing director doesn't prevent getting casted as an important character - agreed. I asked you to thank Sunayana (in a humorous way skks) because she chose to NOT become an important character hahaha. Thank her for not pulling off a Cidalia Castro, cuz she very well could 🤣
      Its okay about Sunidhi, I don't mind what you said. But well, I personally feel you did overstate her frequency of getting casted. Like, sure...Elsa is a big role, Nala..kinda, but two roles is normal to have I think no matter how big they are. Plus there was considerable time between her casting (2015 for Elsa, and 2019 for Nala), so i guess the statement kinda didn't land for me because she never felt overused for real.
      Absolutely agree with your next statement as well, it is indeed my personal taste, which the new french voices are really in sync with, that i felt i should appreciate, they're all doing really great now and i am finally happy my queen China Moses has more French divas in line with her. 💖
      You're welcome. It was a pleasure to see your video as usual.

  • @s.a8714
    @s.a8714 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thank you for 24th place TBH I agree

  • @denkleinriderii8872
    @denkleinriderii8872 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Your editing is excellent, congrats ! I knew how much Erasmia would be high ^^

    • @strubel946
      @strubel946  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Thank you so much :D

  • @PopRock-gl5ey
    @PopRock-gl5ey 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    8:19Well,Techincally This was role for Sunidhi being a Bollywood Diva hehe

  • @ElsannaPL
    @ElsannaPL 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thanks for the 26th place :) Congrats to the winner too :D I didn't expect her that high tho as most people don't seem to love her as much XD

  • @meliae.
    @meliae. 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Ah, kinda sad to see Romanian this low, Ana's been one of my favorites since the beginning. Nevertheless, nice to see some of my favorites in the TOP 10 ^-^