Abu Dhar (r.a) said, "I was with the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) one day and I heard him saying: "There is something I fear for my Ummah than the Dajjal." It was then that I became afraid, so I said: "Oh Rasool Allah! Which thing is that?" He صَلّى اللهُ عليهِ وسلّم said; "Misguided and astray scholars." May Allah subhana wa'tala guide Sheikh Yasir
@Bin Yamin Cassim you do not assume that people have mullahs just because you don't agree with them. You might not know, this certain person is way better than you in the eyes of Allah azzawajal. She may be a beloved of Allah. And when a person insults or pains a beloved of Allah azzawajal, Allah azzawajal takes revenge on His beloved's behalf
@@fractaldelight1976 no, it is not true. Perhaps the reference is to a certain hadith that mentions such a thing, but it was not striking out of rage but out of playfulness or love, as we learn from the context of the hadith. Narrated Anas: I served the Prophet (ﷺ) for ten years, and he never said to me, "Uf" (a minor harsh word denoting impatience) and never blamed me by saying, "Why did you do so or why didn't you do so?" He never did any of this to his servants, so how come he can do it to his wives? He never beat any of his wives, ever. The Qur'anic verse about the punishment on wife's rebellion or the likes: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/An-Nisa,_34#to_beat_them_(i%E1%B8%8Drib%C5%ABhunna)
@@datuputi2549 Thanks for your answer.I accidentally went to a channel and they showed me the hadiths where the prophet beat Aisha on the chest and she said it 's hard and painful.Can you talk to them there and explain it , the channel is called Infinity apologetics 2 , Christian Prince livechat 24 /7.You will be shocked at what he showed in the videos
@@fractaldelight1976 oh, I know them. I was commenting on their videos back in the days but I just got tired because whatever you do, they're really determined to tarnish the name and reputation of al-Islam. So I wouldn't even bother anymore. The way that the Prophet struck Aisha was not in an angered way. But maybe the Prophet (PBUH) just overdid it that's why Aisha was hurt. But Aisha never took that as an offense. It was actually a very precious moment for her because the Prophet was protecting him from the devil's works. But the Kafirun and the enemies of Allah twisted the meaning of the words of our mother Aisha and made it look like the Prophet hurt her INTENTIONALLY
*1 samuel 15:3* *Now go and attack Amalek, and completely destroy everything they have. Don’t spare them, but kill men and women, children and babies* *I'M AN EX-CHRISTIAN ☣️*
Yasir Qadhi is following the position of Ibn Taymiyya rahimahullah on this, and has abandoned the incorrect, misguided analysis of Abdulwahhab, the mass murdering tyrant who his own brother called out and said he was a complete deviant. Actions are but by intentions. Both for the good and bad deeds. If intention is deleted from the equation, the sin i.e. drinking alcohol, is still a sin but by taking the intention to account (i.e. a person who accidentally drinks a soft drink thinking its innocent then realises the alcohol is in the ingredients) will be automatically forgiven and treated lightly (as per Hadith that the Ummah is forgiven for sins they do out of sincere error judgement) vs someone who drinks the same drink knowingly and with the intention of becoming intoxicated, would be sinful and punished accordingly, (unless they repent of course. Similarly if you see a man doing Sujood to a tree that is normally worshipped by pagans, he is not automatically guilty of committing Shirk, as when you ask him why he did that, his answer could be "I had no clue and I was just praying Asar and used this tree as my Sutra" That would not be an issue at all, yet by taking the hadith out of context "Dua is Ibadah" and not cross referencing that with other known Hadith "Actions are according to their intentions" will lead you astray and continue your slippery slope down the khwariji pathway and mindset. He has spoken the Truth on this matter and the falsehood of Abdulwahhab's cult is now plain and clear for all who are not tainted with Kibr to see.
@@treasuresofmedina6882 you are blind follower of this deviant dr. ... Just provide evidence instead of labelling any thing against mujadid abdul wahab... He dr. is educated illiterate person May be he is funded by jews or christians to defame salafism. He is not even following Sheikhul Islaam Ibni Tayima , he is only using his name to make followers.
You know, I don't really listen to yasir qadhi much but I do remember he once said a few years ago that mainstream islam is the right path so I'm gonna take his advice and and not his new opinions on islam.
mainstream islam is not islam that has the more media coverage because backed american and british satellites and by petro dollars...... nadjdis (neo salafis) are a tiny bunch of people that does too much sound......... mainstream islam, is islam of the four madhabs, they are everywhere, but they are quiet, wise people, their objective is to learn and teach, not as the nadjdis to destroy and refute everyone..... so no, he is making another point that ibn abdelwahab was completely false...... now if they can elaborate an answer, well that's okay, he did an ijtihad, that wasnt even his, its the opinion of other scholars as he says, he says its the opinion of classical scholars before the wahabis, and todayit is the opinion at least of Hatim Bin Arif Al-Awni which is a great scholar.... now if he is wrong , then he did ijtihad and was wrong, but prove it.... that's the question
@@abdelhakyac7285 Al-Awni accompanies people that curse the sahabah! Al-Awni is not a scholar! As for proof that yasir is wrong that they are many from the Qur'an and sunnah. But this hadeeth should be sufficient for a Muslim: An-Nu’man ibn Bashir (رضي الله عنه) narrated that the Prophet (sallallahu 'alaihi wa sallam) said: “Dua is worship." Collected by Abu Dawud [1479], At-Tirmithi [3372] An-Nisa’I in Al-Kubara [11464], Ibn Majah [3828]. Imam An-Nawawi graded this Hadith as being Sahih.
@mimomimi it's joke to demonstrate the absurdity of yasir qadhis statements about shirk. He said that it is not shirk to invoke dead people as long as you don't believe this dead person is God. Obviously an catastrophic statement from yasir qadhi, nobody should listen to him.
Would you like your good deeds to carry on increasing even after your death? The Prophet (saw) said "When a man dies, his good deeds come to an end except three; ongoing charity, beneficial knowledge, and righteous offspring who will pray for him." (Muslim 1631) Please support and share my channel with your contacts, and inshaAllah if they benefit and teach others this will count as beneficial knowledge and your good deeds will continue to increase even after your death inshaAllah. JazakhAllah khairan.
The amount of deranged individuals I’m seeing in these comments defending YQ like he pays their bills and feeds their children 🤡 instead of defending the attributes of Allah which YQ continues to question, here y’all are defending the creation and embarrassing yourselves. Yikes.
whoever he is and how knowledgeable he is doesn't matter. When there is a Sahih hadith from many many chains. الدعاء هو العبادة. .Invoking is Worshipping. So invoking is Shirk since you can only Worship Allah and Allah alone.
What is the definition of Dua that is worship? The definition is: Asking who you believe is God. Therefore, if I said to a person: Feed me, I did not worship him, and if I said to God: Feed me, then I worshiped Him. Why did the second act become an act of worship for the one from whom it was requested? Because I asked who I believe is God.
@ahmadasdfhb No, it's totally different, If you invoke anyone who is not "present" حاضر or able to hear you. It's a tribute that can only be assigned to Allah. He is the only one who is "present" (by means of His knowledge) and listening all the time to everyone. No one else could claim or has this ability. That is why invoking someone who is absent غائب except Allah is not permitted and considered Shirk. We know that there are angels everywhere, and they have been assigned duties to perform like moving wind, sending down rain, providing food, protecting us, and even sending salutation to Prophet Muhammad PBUH. But have anyone ever invoked any of the angels knowing that they have the duties mentioned above? The answer is no! So, the same way we can not invoke any human being alive of dead who is absent, let alone if he/she is able to help us or has any authority. And that's what Qadhi trying to legitimize that calling dead or alive ansent saints and prophets is ok as long as you do not believe them as god. But he forgot that is the definition of Shirk in the Quran and Hadith and violation of اياك نعبد و اياك نستعين. Even the Arabic language itself negates the concept of invoking any غائب (unseen/absent) there is no فعل الأمر (the verb of order/request) for anyone absent. In Arabic language, you can only order or request who is present (حاضر). انا، نحن، انت، انتِ، انتم، انتما، انتن
Let's just all make duas to Allah to GUIDE ALL of us and to forgive ALL of us... Let the scholars battle it out in private... Let us ALWAYS be respectful and beautiful in our behaviour, including when we disagree or argue...let's do it with love.
assalualaikum, it would be an offer to find my comment and like it, so that the channel can see my comment, no person should be confused because of this.
Yasir qadhi is hitting the cardinal point of Islam hence it can't be compromised, no matter how much good things he told other than that. So its better not to hear him any more until he completely changes his view about shirk activities.
If dividing from another group of Muslims means that I'm going to be on the Sunnah... Then I divide! May Allah guide the Muslims, we only unite upon the sunnah. And if we divide, we divide for the sunnah. Now if yasir qadhi has made these enormous blunders then i divide from him and those that support him! Because supporting him is like supporting these blunders that he is now known for. And if he returns to the sunnah then we would accept his apology.
Rasullah saw told us there will come a time when holding on to the deen will be like holding on to hot coales. Allah swt has perfected this deen and the central part of the deen is the Quran. Indeed, it is We who brought down the 'Zhikr' (Reminder/Quran) and We will surely preserve it. 15:9
I had listened to some of his lectures and it was beneficial. Brother make mistakes like everyone. I believe there is a way for others lecturers to correct his mistakes. The job they doing everyone is bound to make mistakes,no easy talking for hrs on TV. I feel sad, we are the ummah of our beloved Rasoul (saw).I believe Yasir Qadir will not misguide us but everyone will make mistakes. United we stand! Islam is beautiful. Prophet Muhammad ( saw) said support your brother if he is right or wrong. The Sabahas asked him, how do we support our brother when he is wrong. He "said stop him from doing wrong". May Allah guide us all to the straight path. Ameen thumma Ameen.
yes unity is good. But you should refer back to the ayah 103 of Surah Ali Imran. Allah has commanded us to hold his rope. As Muslims we are only united by holding on to the Rope of Allah, we are not united by holding hands. The scholars have said that the Rope of Allah refers to the Qur'an. Now yasir qadhi has opposed the quran in what he has said about shirk (see ayah 3 of surah az-zumar, verses 84-89 of al-muminoon, see surah az-zukhruf). The matter is clear but so many people are confused. Thus it is mandatory for the people who possess knowledge about yasir's mistake that they make things clear to the people. You must understand that they are minor mistakes and major mistakes. Read about the early imams and how they dealt with major mistakes. Imam Ahmand bin Hanbal boycotted Imam Yahya bin Ma'een (may Allah have mercy on them both) due to a major mistake he did. Now people are talking against yasir's mistake and people are calling this inappropriate?! Brother, read the quran, study the sunnah. Read the works of Ibn Uthaymeen, Albani, and their likes.
@@zakariab9591 . May Allah guide you. Abu Hanifa, Malik, Ash-Shafi'i, Ahmad bin Hanbal, and so many others don't believe what yasir qadhi said! Tawus, Sufyan ath-thawri, Ata bin Abi Rabah (these are the students of the sahabah) also don't believe what yasir qadhi said! Whatever "scholar" is against these scholars that I mentioned has made a mistake! (and is in reality probably not a scholar!)
@@penguinman38 with all due respect brother, but stop saying "Yasir Qadhi". You should say the vast majority of scholars of over a thousand years. Yasir Qadhi isn't unique, but just a single person with the opinion among the many thousands of scholars. Even the brother of Muhammed ibn AbdelWahhab, Sulayman ibn AbdelWahhab, called the opinion of his own brother problematic and was very very harsh on him on this subject. He even said that Muhammed ibn AbdelWahhab himself was dividing the Ummah. May Allah guide us all, bottom line, yes it's bid3a and haram. And if they worship the grave, it is shirk. But if they don't consider it worship, it can't even be shirk since they themselves don't intend to worship.
@@zakariab9591 don't you to invoke is worship,if you asked the quffar of maca of the time ,that who brings down water,who is the greator ,etc they will straight away tell you that it's the most high all mighty Allah,but what's the sin they're committing,it's because they invoke there idols and the dead.So stop invoking the dead,it's worship,face your load and ask him of what ever you May desire.that's most beloved to Allah.
INNA LILLAHI WA INNA ILAYHI RAJI’UN MEANING The translation of this phrase inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji’un is “Indeed, to Allah we belong and to Allah we shall return.”
He is a very dangerous guy! If somebody has no knowledge, he will confuse them and miss guide them and create a doubt in their heart. Do not listen to him!!!
*1 samuel 15:3* *Now go and attack Amalek, and completely destroy everything they have. Don’t spare them, but kill men and women, children and babies* *I'M AN EX-CHRISTIAN ☣️*
@@richlisola1 site the proof? Go watch his videos. May be you don’t understand? He said inderecrly quran is an old ancient book and it needed to be updated and has to matches with the modern siceity. He also said islam itself needed to be modified because sharia law doesn’t match with the modern society. Who the hell he think he is ? God? He also said grave worshiping is sin but not major shirk…
@@richlisola1 Here are some of his dangerous mistakes: 1. in a video published by EPIC (in Plano, Texas), he said that Yajooj and Majooj are "fairy tales". We can not say that, when it is mentioned in both the Quran (Al-Kahf) and the hadith of Prophet Mohamed (Sallu Allahu alaihi wa sallam). 2. for the same video above (in point 1), he said something to the meaning of "from an Engineering perspective, how can a dam hold people so powerful like Yajooj and Majooj for thousands of years"!!! So, basically, he is saying that everything Allah (Subhanahu wa t'aalaa) does MUST pass our limited human mind, and engineering standards????? 3. in another video, he said that the "science of Tawheed" is a recent science. This is 100% wrong statement, as Prophet Mohamed (Sallu Allahu alaihi wa sallam) used to say to the messengers he is sending to the tribes in the Arabian peninsula "teach them Tawheed .. when they believe, then teach them Salat .. and when they do it (the salat), then teach them the Zakat". 4. He seems to be OK with grave worshipping and going to Saints, which is a SHIRK matters that Prophet Mohamed (Sallu Allahu alaihi wa sallam) warned us NOT to do. If you think i am making this up, then watch the following videos and judge for yourself. th-cam.com/video/YXGH7vCeiBQ/w-d-xo.html
Asalaam Aleykum warahma tullahi wabarakatuhu. Brother either all of us have hearing issues or one person does, in this case that person would be you. I've watched and listened to what he said. He said it clearly "it's not shirk in and of itself" and that it's just something that will open the doors to shirk. He is absolutely wrong in this matter. If you pick up any book regarding this matter it is clear. Our beloved prophet Muhammad ﷺ said that invocation is worship. So now you decide who to follow. The prophet Muhammad ﷺ or Yasir Qadhi who keeps changing his opinions. Good luck in your choice. I choose to go with the prophet pbuh.
@@naseemkad Asalaam Aleykum warahma tullahi wabarakatuhu. You have made a few fallacious claims on your behalf. Let me address them. Firstly, I've seen the whole talk. Secondly, I'm very familiar with the English language. Thirdly, your first sentence alone tells me it is actually you who appears to not understand my response written in English. Maybe the Hadith went past you. Aqeedah is crystal clear in Islam. This is something the youth or younger generation of today seem to have no idea about. If i held a view that is backed by evidence from Qur'an + Sunnah + Early Predecessors then i changed my view later on in life to the contrary of the insurmountable evidence. Therefore, this suggests that either i was right before and wrong now or i was wrong before and thus right now. This is how logic works. Nobody is infallible in terms of knowledge. When a person is wrong, they're wrong. Especially in terms of Aqeedah which would lead a person into the hellfire. Narrated Ibn Abbas that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ addressed the people on the farewell Hajj and said: "O People! I am leaving among you such a thing that if you strongly adhere to it you will never go astray, the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Prophet." The prophet Muhammad ﷺ came to do away with all forms of Shirk. If you read the Qur'an you can see this. If anyone reads the Seerah they can see this. What he is saying goes against what the prophet Muhammad ﷺ taught. If the prophet taught something we need evidence of such a thing. This religion my dear sister isn't based upon whims, desires and having an opinion that suits your narrative. We aren't Christians or Jews. This Deen is based upon reason and hard evidences taken from the Qur'an and Sunnah. No man is above the words of Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ and the prophet Muhammad ﷺ. If anyone tells you something about Islam you have to do your research and enquire about it. Ask people that are knowledgeable. Read their books and see what they say on this particular matter. Ask for the source material to substantiate the claims that someone makes. If they just make an opinionated claim without giving you a reference. Then question marks should start to form in your head immediately. Moreover, you made spurious and fallacious claims where you claimed i mocked, hurt and you mentioned the word slandered. So now i want you to substantiate your claim as you have now accused me falsely. Which is a sin in Islam if you didn't know. He has been refuted now by various scholar's in the field regarding this topic and other topics. Don't be beguiled by anyone who says anything that opposes the Qur'an and Sunnah even if it's your own father. If i told you that chewing pork and consuming it is no sin "in and of itself" so long as you vomit afterwards, would you then teach this to your children and other's publicly? What more is the case of Shirk? Shirk is the unforgivable sin in Islam if you didn't know. Even Christian children know this basic Aqeedah point. ANYTHING that even leads to Shirk we must stay far away from. As was mentioned earlier and in the books of the scholars. Shirk is Shirk. Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ addresses the Quraysh Pagan Arabs as Mushriks. Do you know what this word means and do you know what it entails? Do you know the beliefs of the Pagan Arabs at the time? وَإِذَا سَأَلَكَ عِبَاد۪ي عَنّ۪ي فَإِنّ۪ي قَر۪يبٌۘ أُج۪يبُ دَعْوَةَ الدَّاعِ إِذَا دَعَانِۙ فَلْيَسْتَج۪يبُوا ل۪ي وَلْيُؤْمِنُوا ب۪ي لَعَلَّهُمْ يَرْشُدُونَ And when My servants ask you, [O Muhammad], concerning Me - indeed I am near. I respond to the invocation of the supplicant when he calls upon Me. So let them respond to Me [by obedience] and believe in Me that they may be [rightly] guided. Surah Al-Baqarah [2:186] One of the names of Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ is Mujīb مجيب. Al-Mujeeb is the Answerer of prayers. According to al-Ghazali, this means that it is HE who RESPONDS to the REQUESTS of THOSE WHO ASK by assisting them, to the call of those who call upon HIM (ALONE) by answering them, and responds to the plight of the poor with all they need. اِيَّاكَ نَعۡبُدُ وَاِيَّاكَ نَسۡتَعِيۡنُؕ It is YOU we worship and YOU WE ASK FOR HELP. Surah Al-Fatihah [1:5] Lastly, you said "it's clearly NOT true that he says worship other than Allah". I want you now to go back to my earlier response and quote me verbatim where i have said such a statement. I feel quite clear at this point that it's your lack of grasp of the English language and the topic at hand which proves to me this has gone above your head. So now you have to substantiate a lot of things you have said otherwise it is you who is slandering and an evident liar.
@@abdulmunim318 First of all I have a question if you don't mind are you saying for the past 1400 years and the majority of the Muslim world who follows a school of thought deviant? For 1400 years people have been following a school of thought and even today the majority of the world follows a school of thought. Just to clarify are you saying the majority of the Muslims in the world and for the past 1400 years people were just misguided? I know it may not be relevant to this conversation and I didn't make any claims about you. I'm just asking if you don't mind and if you do you don't need to reply or you can just tell me you don't wanna answer this question.
@@naseemkad I don't think you understand the intricacies of this discussion. You see if you don't believe the saint in the grave has any power or is a deity then the opinion is its haram but not shirk . For example if you go to the grave of a saint and ask him to make dua to Allah SWT for you without believing the Saint is a deity nor has any powers that are reserved only for Allah SWT then it wrong and haram but not shirk. Because you are not supplicating to him but asking him to supplicate to Allah SWT for you. You could ask a living Muslim to supplicate for you right? Same thing. However as it he cannot hear you because he has passed away from this world it is haram .
@@lilyiqra dead have no power Living can ask but dead cannot and that's shirk Believing they can do something is shirk Shirk is far more dangerous than normal haram
You can be a free thinker as Allah gave us free will but still don’t change what Allah says don’t do and make it not shirk. It just a common sense to know that invoking is worship, and invoking anyone besides Allah is worse. You can tell that the brother has his own personal issues, unfortunately what is saying can take people who don’t know away from Islam. A doorbell 😂
Just watch the 3 hour video by YQ with an open mind where he summarizes why he believes the Najdi theology is wrong and why his view regarding isthigatha, which is the majority view, is correct. He addressed the same thing what you have just said right now and gives explanation regarding his view.
Sheikh Yasir Qadhi Masha-Allah is the greatest scholar of our generation. I see so many people constantly attacking him recently. Well you can jump up and down all you want, but you can't drag him down from his position. You can't take away what Allah has blessed him with. He has immense knowledge and a great analytical mind. I even saw some say he is not a "real" scholar. Like I can't even.... I do not agree with his conclusion regarding the shirk issue myself. Though I understand where he is coming from. But it doesn't make him a bad scholar. You will always find even among the ancient scholars we unanimously revere now greatly differed in their view of many important topics. We just love to romanticize the ancient scholars and think they were all above flaw. Just dive a little deeper and maybe do some math on the side to clear your head, so that you can think. Scholars may come to different opinion on different matters. Because they are human. So stop attacking them. If you agree with one great. If you don't agree with one, move on. Try to focus more on your self than to refute different scholars opinions. That would certainly be most beneficial.
This is all very interesting being born and raised in the US. Its a mirror image of what has happened to Christianity over the past few decades here. A majority of conservative christian churches have been compromised and/or infiltrated over time to where the average christian here now accepts homosexuality, sex before marriage, etc as being totally normal. And "you are a bigot and going against Jesus' (pbuh) teachings" if you reject what has happened, or you are told "there's nothing you can do about it, don't worry, don't call it out, God will handle it". Meanwhile they are teaching children under 7 years old about sexual deviance of all kinds and you aren't allowed to disagree. Don't fall for it, especially the argument that it's wrong to refute people. Our enemies are very clever, attempting to keep us silent with fake religious arguments. Stay steadfast.
Yasir qadhi gave his proves and opinions why don't these ashyaakh just give their proves and tell their opinions and stop bashing and say bad things about the poor guy. Give your proves and do not bash the person as if like he is an enemy of Islam? This is not a scholarship wallahi this is horrible.
May be you didn’t under what Yasir Qadhi said, and Sheikh Assim Al-Hakeem and the brother with the doorbell example explained it. Aren’t these enough for you?
@@minahtempeh6860 Please no. I have my God. He has a son. He is different from your God who has no son: sourate 112 v 3. So no. I don't want your Allah to guide me. That's a highway to hell.
It’s not open for him as long as he’s being in this road. Why are we talking about forgiveness to someone who is lying about Allah. This has nothing to do with forgiveness. Allah don’t like lyers. So let’s deal with Yasir Qadhi skies before we talk about forgiveness. You obviously don’t know what forgiveness is about. Allah don’t like people who lie about him. Let’s not put the horse before the cart. Let’s deal with his lies. Then when he corrects himself let’s talk about forgive ness. Duh 🙄
They're definitely emotional but they're also rather incompetent and unsophisticated on most matters as well which compounds things greatly and leaves most people in awe of how silly they are.
I use to listen to Yasir Qadhi a lot. I lost my way and recently i been slowly coming to the path once again. I remember a week ago i somehow ended up on this video and right away got offended people attacking Yasir Qadhi, how can they say such things about Yasir Qadhi he's so knowledgeable, but it got me searching up on all his misguided clips to casting doubts on preservatinon of Quran, to saying graveworshiping is not shirk but a sin, to yajuj and majuj are apparently zombies because to believe a tribe stuck between two mountains is far fetched and illogical! I couldn't believe i'm hearing all this from him. Alhumdulilah i saw this video and decided to do my research. All i know is you have to question even sheikhs that you place your trust in.
Abu layth mk ll. May Creator guide them away from subjective over emotional bidah. I instinctively ignored this mans (y.qardhi) channel without prior knowledge of him way before seeing these videos. And I am a layman revert to Islam that grew up amongst deceptive individuals so I am not being emotional but recognise those that have an agenda. Y.qardhi should not speak on things above his pay grade. Reformation of Quran and Sunnah to appease modernity isn't on. Don't let their ignorance be our evidence. Excellent.
Our Prophet salaallahi waalayhi wasalaam said in hadith told in Al Bukhari that when the affairs regarding knowledge is entrust to those who don't deserve then await for the hour . This is one the sign of the days judgement. I think we all are have better things to do than refuting each other in public and proving than we are better than the others . Please brothers stop this ... islam is peace , there is better way to solve this matter ...😓
@@hamida9346 thank you, i thought you misunderstood my comment brother, I think that they just overwhelmed with too much knowledge and forget that Prohet Muhammad ( PBUH) was so kind when addressed people even they where wrong , i am not justifing the fact but i am concern about the way they treat sheikh YQ in public suppose to be done with respect.
Looks like the pro-najdis have stooped down to the level of the islamophobes like Jay Smith and co. to refute and insult YQ. That alone is a strong reason to believe and trust YQ. He's such a humble and respectful person, unlike these.
U r losing sight of the core issue this time : is calling to the dead a major sin, a stepping stone to shirk (YQ stance) or is it shirk (majority stance which he wrongly says was not majority stance)! We’ve got worshippers and self-whippers now rooting for YQ in the US whereas most of them do call out to the deceased for ‘help”!
I learned a lot from Yasir Qadhi about the Seerah of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wassallam , please address the wrong not attack the person , we should all take the good from someone and leave the bad . May Allaah swt guide us and keep us guided always .Aameen
I think you lack a basic understanding of Islaam. This is not the Islamic principle. If someone is a clear devient as qadhi is he should be refuted and exposed so the masses are not misguided by his innovation.
@@Khabib_N A misguided innovator was severely reprimanded when such fitna began. The 3 generations would not sit or be seen with ahlee bidat. In fact fadyl inn ayaad said I would rather sit with a Jew or Christian than a innovator. Such people are changing the religion from which the masses need to be protected. Learn your dean from clear and authentic sources.
I personally disagree with yasir qadhi on a lot of stuff. But i honestly disgree with Abu mussab he didnt invent it its the majority position of the ummah. I dont think we should let our dislike for him blind us.
Sidenote: the clip of Adnan Rashid is totally misused. I don't know if it was intentionally or not, but Adnan was talking about a total different subject.
What? And the guy sitting in the US can confuse and misguide as many as he wants because of his own weaknesses, personal doubts and desires?? If no one will clarify these critical things, then what’s the end result: disaster. While we sit on TH-cam and pass comments on how things should be handled!
Imran Qureshi you are as much misguided as the bafoon YQ. You are like one of those people who go to dargah and pray to the tomb. Auzubillah...may Allah SWT protect us from such iblis.
@@misterlogik8163 Welp, I’m pretty sure Yasir Qadhi dosen’t have time to respond to questions in the comments, but let’s here this “hole” this guy has found.
To the speakers on the video.. Why don't they contact him directly and talk to him in a respectful manner? Because these kind of "Exposed" videos and confrontation will NOT solve any problem instead it create more hate and division. And its not just about him, anyone who you think made a mistake it's more constructive if you do in a private and respectful way. Calling names and degrading never solve any problem. Just my opinion.
This has been discussed and agreed upon 10,00 times!. With Yasir, people have been in touch with him since 2015! He started showing his cancerous ideas back then in public. He has refused the suggestions amd consultations of numerous senior scholars including his teachers at a madinah! The principle is simple: misguide amd confuse people in public domain, the. Public domain correction/exposure/refutation is needed.
@@mustafahussain7371 u wish! He is a confused south Asian origin man whose parents left their country of origin and used Saudi Arabia as a stepping stone to emigrate to America. And he got his foundation knowledge in deen in Saudi Arabia and he became arrogant when in the USA and forgot it was Saudi Arabia that was the vehicle for so much good for his family and himself.
@@Quantum-1157 oh boy, so what you are saying is that the majority of the Muslim ummah(asian) is wrong. And Saudis and wahabis are the authority and saviours of Islam and aqeedah.
Yasir Qadhi is following the position of Ibn Taymiyya rahimahullah on this, and has abandoned the incorrect, misguided analysis of Abdulwahhab, the mass murdering tyrant who his own brother called out and said he was a complete deviant. Actions are but by intentions. Both for the good and bad deeds. If intention is deleted from the equation, the sin i.e. drinking alcohol, is still a sin but by taking the intention to account (i.e. a person who accidentally drinks a soft drink thinking its innocent then realises the alcohol is in the ingredients) will be automatically forgiven and treated lightly (as per Hadith that the Ummah is forgiven for sins they do out of sincere error judgement) vs someone who drinks the same drink knowingly and with the intention of becoming intoxicated, would be sinful and punished accordingly, (unless they repent of course. Similarly if you see a man doing Sujood to a tree that is normally worshipped by pagans, he is not automatically guilty of committing Shirk, as when you ask him why he did that, his answer could be "I had no clue and I was just praying Asar and used this tree as my Sutra" That would not be an issue at all, yet by taking the hadith out of context "Dua is Ibadah" and not cross referencing that with other known Hadith "Actions are according to their intentions" will lead you astray and continue your slippery slope down the khwariji pathway and mindset. He has spoken the Truth on this matter and the falsehood of Abdulwahhab's cult is now plain and clear for all who are not tainted with Kibr to see.
2:156. who, when afflicted with calamity, say: "Truly! To ALLAH we belong and truly, to Him we shall return." 2:157. They are those on whom are the Salawat (i.e. blessings, etc.) (i.e. who are blessed and will be forgiven) from their Lord, and (they are those who) receive His Mercy, and it is they who are the guided-ones. 2:155. And certainly, We shall test you with something of fear, hunger, loss of wealth, lives and fruits, but give glad tidings to As-Sabirin (the patient ones, etc.).
@@mahmudibnabidin Proof # 9 (Help O Slaves of Allah) "إن لله ملائكة في الأرض سوى الحفظة يكتبون ما يسقط من ورق الشجر، فإذا أصاب أحدكم عرجة بأرض فلاة فليناد: أعينوا عباد الله". رواه البزار ورجاله ثقات. Translation: Allah has angels on the earth - other than the [two] record-keepers - who keep a record [even] of the leaves that fall on the ground. Therefore, if one of you is crippled in a deserted land where no-one is in sight, let him cry out: " HELP O ALLAH'S SERVANTS" Imam al Haythami (rah) said after this hadith: It is narrated by Al-Bazzar and all its narrators are reliable (thiqa) [Reference: Majma uz Zawaid, Volume 10, Hadith No. 17104] This hadith is not only authentic but rather it has been “ACTED UPON” by great scholars إِذَا أَضَلَّ أَحَدُكُمْ شَيْئًا أَوْ أَرَادَ أَحَدُكُمْ عَوْنًا وَهُوَ بِأَرْضٍ لَيْسَ بِهَا أَنِيسٌ، فَلْيَقُلْ:"يَا عِبَادَ اللَّهِ أَغِيثُونِي، يَا عِبَادَ اللَّهِ أَغِيثُونِي، فَإِنَّ لِلَّهِ عِبَادًا لا نَرَاهُمْ"، وَقَدْ جَرَّبَ ذَلِكَ After Imam At-Tabarani transmitted the hadith of calling out : O Servants of Allah, Help me! In his Mu'jam al Kabir (17/117) he said “this has been acted upon (وَقَدْ جَرَّبَ ذَلِكَ)” Plus the narration in Mu'jam al Kabeer does not talk about Angels. The amal of great Imam of Salaf, Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal (rah). عبد الله بن أحمد بن حنبل قال سمعت أبي يقول حججت خمس حجج اثنتين راكب وثلاث ماشي أو ثلاث راكب واثنتين ماشي فضللت الطريق في حجة وكنت ماشيا فجعلت أقول يا عباد الله دلوني على الطريق قال فلم أزل أقول ذلك حتى وقفت على الطريق أو كما قال أبي Translation: Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Hanbal (rah) said that he heard his father (Imam Ahmed) who said: I performed Hajj 5 times, thrice on foot and twice on ride or he said thrice on ride and twice on foot, once when I was on foot I lost my way hence I started to exclaim this: O Allah’s servants show me the way (يا عباد الله دلوني على الطريق), I kept on repeating this until I came back on track. [Imam Baihaqi in Shu’ab ul Iman, Volume 6, Page No 128,Narration No. 7697] So Alhamdulillah the great Hadith specialists themselves acted upon it and approved it, had there been a hint of shirk in this then they would have mentioned it! Imam Mullah Ali Qari (rah) in Sharh of Hisn-ul-Hiseen writes that our Prophet (Peace be upon him) said that: اذا انفلتت دابة احد كم بارض فلاة فليناد يا عباد الله احبسوا Translation: If the animal of someone runs loose in jungle, then he should say: O Allah’s servants stop it (for full hadith see:Musnad Abu Ya'la # 5269. It also does not include wording Angels) He writes under “Ibaad Allah” المراد بهم الملىكة او المسلمون من الجن او رجال الغيب المستمون بابدال Translation: It means the angels, Muslims, jinn or men of unseen i.e. Abdaal Then he writes: هذا حديث حسن يحتاج اليه المسافرون وانه مجرب Translation: This hadith is Hasan (good) and the travelers are in urgent need of it and this has been acted upon [Sharh Hisn al Hiseen, Al-Hirz al-Thamin, page 378]
So how does this help people who want to be Muslims? Why is this not done in private? I think there are people of different opinions about what you are doing here especially the bashing language. Please Please handle this differently! May Allah GUIDE us all! Ameen.
"Because a lot of people say something that doesn't make it right? This is against our usool". Several hundred years where Ash'arism was the majority view among the ummah...
@@RoyFlush716 right. I get it, that's a really good point. I'm non-Muslim and sometimes curious how the diffent madhabs etc. interact. What people believe, and how they differ.
Even Adnan rashid used to defend Qadhi when Dawah man exposed him, now Adnan also knows some reality about Yasur qadhi. Yasir hasnt understood aqeeda tawheed and aqeeda hifz al Quran.
@@mohammedusmanmufti5311 no he is not aggressive. Yes he made some errors but he is slso going around helping celebrities like Adam Saleh. That is good work to give dawah to people who are vulnerable to major calamities. And this derrogatory term Wahabi shouldnt be used. If you want to link him with M bin abdul Wahab then call him abdul wahabi.
@@osamamanan2723 I guess dawah man isn't that bad after all. It's only sometimes he kinda acts aggressive not all the time. I do like some of his talks though
assalualaikum, it would be an offer to find my comment and like it, so that the channel can see my comment, no person should be confused because of this.
If they would to follow the position of sheikh Yasir Qadhi, they actually would follow the opinion of the vast majority of all our scholars for at least a thousand years.
May allah guide him. And he is saying it will open door to shirk no no this is definitely shirk no doubt subhanallah. We have the quran and the sunnah of the prophet peace and blessings be upon him.
If you disagree with him so much, isn't it better to call and talk to him first, rather than bash him in the open without attempting to understand where he is coming from? What does that achieve?
Narrated Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman: The people used to ask Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) about good, but I used to ask him about evil for fear that it might overtake me. Once I said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! We were in ignorance and in evil and Allah has bestowed upon us the present good; will there by any evil after this good?" He said, "Yes." I asked, "Will there be good after that evil?" He said, "Yes, but it would be tained with Dakhan (i.e. Little evil)." I asked, "What will its Dakhan be?" He said, "There will be some people who will lead (people) according to principles other than my tradition. You will see their actions and disapprove of them." I said, "Will there by any evil after that good?" He said, "Yes, there will be some people who will invite others to the doors of Hell, and whoever accepts their invitation to it will be thrown in it (by them)." I said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! Describe those people to us." He said, "They will belong to us and speak our language" I asked, "What do you order me to do if such a thing should take place in my life?" He said, "Adhere to the group of Muslims and their Chief." I asked, "If there is neither a group (of Muslims) nor a chief (what shall I do)?" He said, "Keep away from all those different sects, even if you had to bite (i.e. eat) the root of a tree, till you meet Allah while you are still in that state."
How can Allah judge anyone when he never talks to anyone? Has any muslim ever seen any manifestation of Allah? any response to a prayer? any healing? NOPE!!!! That Allah must be dead.
@@nikzahui3477 Who feeds you. Who gives you health when you are sick. Who brings you back to life when you are dead. He is the One who guides you when you are lost. He communicates through His signs. There are signs within you and Outside. Look at them. If you talk and see God where is the question of believing. When you see a building you know that there is a builder who has constructed it. If you ask Him He responds. If walk one step towards Him He takes steps towards you. Read and understand Quran , it is the Word of God. Dont ruin your present life and hereafter. WAKE UP BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE
@@indianrational6887 BS. You Allah never feeds anyone. He is dead. that's why you have to defend him. Our God Jesus is alive. And he can defend himself. We don't have to. He heals people every day, no matter their religion, because he is a God of Love. Watch this: th-cam.com/video/LWlxnWV2klc/w-d-xo.html
I joined this channel to learn how to teach Ahsanul Qawaid. Now I'm getting suggestions for videos with extremely shallow, immature salafee social media personalities.
Ahaha you don't know the peak of their ideology leads a person to this: 'I'm a Salafi, and you're not Salafi, and they're not Salafi...' These people hate their brains so much it's hilarious.
I don't know why everyone pinpoint Yasir qadi lectures why they don't talk directly with him Shem to all of you part-time Muslim If you are real Muslim please don't rebuke another Muslim Gave another lacthure on that topic
ASSALAMOUALAIKUM DR YASSIR QHADI JUST IGNORE THEM TAKE NO NOTICE OF ANY OF THE RUBBISH I HAVE LEARNT A LOT FROM YOU JUST PURE JEALOUSY BE STRONG MAY ALLAH SWT GUIDE ALL OF US ALL YEARS ROUND THESE PEOPLE ENJOY PICKING ON SCHOLARS FAULT MY DUAS WITH AND YOUR FAMILY AND ALL YOUR SUPPORTERS
It seems as though for YQ the adulation and respect of the masses is more important to him than the truth itself. He always came across to me as this sort of person even when he was on the correct knowledge in the past. I always kept myself silent on this but it saddens me to see that I was totally right. May Allah guard us from his misguidance.
Only this? What about yajuj and majuj are tales and might be zombies? What about the quran being preserved? What about our Islamic punishments needing updating? What about our scriptures saying some problematic and bizarre things?
@@mdrasid007 yes of course Akhi but you can see one thing leads to another and qadhi has changed since yale around 10 years or so. I used to love him very
@@iimiboy ya I love him too, I think he tries to get larger audiences to watch his videos or he may be interested in American politics to get power, so he's getting Liberal day by day to please all sunni, Shia, Jews Christians, Hindus to get their votes
@@mdrasid007 yes exactly which isn't Islam, we are completely different from everyone else, he has belittled even the great sahaba umar radiallahu anhu by saying he will fail the aqeedha test. Sorry but he's getting worse by the year and according to his definition even the Hindus aren't really committing shirk
Salaam. HealMyTajweed will help you improve your relationship with the Quraan, and that includes all the sciences, but I myself as the main person am only qualified to deal with Tajweed at this point in time as I continue my studies. I PERSONALLY will not take questions re Aqeedah or Fiqh or other controversies until I am given the permission if I continue to study those sciences, or deal with them directly. This does not mean that the channel will not tackle these issues at all, like in the form of this compilation above, which has full link references to the original videos. We may also bring qualified people on to discuss these issues in the future. We may also test variations of content related to the Quran and/or Islam generally in the near future, and if you feel this is not for you then you may leave Insha Allah no problem. I am not on TH-cam to please the public above having to answer to my Creator, and I will do what I need to do if I feel a topic is important enough to cover, like in this case. If you are under the impression that I am here to please you as an individual person, or even the general TH-cam viewer, I am sorry to say this is not the intention nor the objective, and there are plenty of channels which are far superior to this one where you can seek whatever you are looking for. I will continue to create Tajweed related content Insha Allah, especially coming up for Ramadhan, and still being a one man show without having help even from the regular people visiting the channel, except for a few individuals who have helped in the past either with their time or by donating, (May Allah reward them) I can only do what I am physically able to with limited resources without jeopardising my main source of income work from my Tech work. Wassalaam!
Putting these small clips together to refute someone by name and to dishonour him because you do not understand and haven't seem whole videos and talks is a massive problem, and it can easily make you hate someone you haven't even heard off..Fear Allah swt and stop this, because you will answer for this..
Mohammed Hijab has been quite unwise lately with this interview---and with the interview with that guy the dressed like a woman----something wrong----May Allah guide him
Humm this popped up on my screen. Well, I don't all the tension, accusations... here. Mr. QADHI said something, that is right and it is his opinion and understanding. Period. You may agree or disagree that's also your right, opinion and understanding. But i find the response, attitude to that a little over the line. Even the companions of the prophet (pbuh), had differences in opinions over some issues but they didn't point fingers at each other, treat one another of being misguided or having an " agenda" etc. Knowledge without wisdom is vain. All you ( the critics) have to do in this instance is to do your own videos, teachings to explain your view on the matter and why you think the other(s) is/are wrong on the matter. In the end only Allah ALONE knows the truth and only He can judge between you. I follow videos, teachings, of so and so that doesn't mean i believe in every single of theirs. Come on we are not dummies who just follow blindly. Bring your arguments/ counter-arguments then people will chose their own path. In the end it is Allah who guides, not you nor mr. Qadhi etc.. No matter his " diviance", " secret agenda" or whatever, the truth of the matter is that man had been teaching lot of things and many people have benefinited from it. If you wanna shut him up, be productive, do better than him, bring the good teachings to people in an effective way.
What utter nonsense People have benefited because he said don’t smoke But it ok for him to insult (Umar ra) the wee holes in the Quran, gog Magog is a science fiction And on and on Have you watched the video/s
Shirk is not a matter of opinion. He has directly opposed the fundamental teachings of Allah and our Prophet pbuh. If you choose to follow him from this point then you will have no excuse in front of Allah.
I felt suspicious of Yasir Qadi from another topic but this one on shirk overwhelmed me and distrust him from anything he says. I am Pakistani and Alhamdulilla I was raised with right aqeeda. I find Yasir as hypocrite who is being used using our race face and etc. He looks like my ex-husband who lied about being Muslim, he turned out to be a Sihk religion who live among us in Punjab deceiving Muslims, they dress like us, they talk like us, they learn our religion to misconstrue and play with innocent people. Shut this guy out please!!
So far no one say anything to disprove him especially " holes" he is speaking about like ubay ibn kab having doubts , all i can see is attack and restless scholars what is wrong??? these scholars have no evidence for their claims against YQ, only here bashing him!!!!!!!!;Is he saying some truth ??? 🙄 May Allah guide all of us
something that helped me stay humble is this ayah. "And whatever of blessings and good things you have, it is from Allâh. Then, when harm touches you, unto Him you cry aloud for help." [16:53] And that no matter how much knowledge I have, I've gotten it from Allah and then through his righteous servants. For the credit belongs all to them. As for me, I'm simply a follower or forwarder of their works.
This is not the scholarly way of defaming a sincere scholar of Islam like Yasir Qadi, without the context of his talks, Just picking and cutting without context of talk. May Allah guide all the scholars shouting on Yasir Qadi
Here is what YQ should do. First of all, define shirk. He did his MA in tawheed, for God's sake, so he should be able to do that. And then provide proof for his opinion. And let people more knowledgeable than him break it down and tell him if it's valid or not.
Clinging onto the religion of their forefathers even though they were misguided. And evil scholars who want to demolish the foundation of Islam for the dunya.
I lost courage to listen to Yasir Qadhi the day he belied and belittled Imam Anwar Rahimahullah... Whoever wage war against the friends of Allah, Allah will humiliate them in this world and the hereafter.
So he speaks the truth and that’s a problem? Don’t Muslims call upon and ask for Muhammad to pray for them, he’s dead. Wouldn’t that be shirk? Genuine question.
Depends on which opinion you favour. If you look to the fundamental teachings of Sunni Islam, then yes it is shirk to call upon anyone, even Muhammed S.A.W.
The CONDITIONAL Opinion (syllogism) of Yasir Qadhi CANNOT BE ABSORBED by those who are relying ONLY on CATEGORICAL (absolute) Syllogism. For as long as Yasir Qadhi is UPHOLDING or ADHERING to the CONDITION that he ESSENTIALLY attached to his OPINION, Yasir Qadhi has NOT COMMITTED SHIRK.. A condition is a requirement and remained as it is.
Don't forget that literally none of these speakers you've compiled, are even close to experts in aqeedah, nor are they even close to Shaykh Yasir in terms of pure knowledge based on credentials and experience. If you're not going to do research yourself, at least quote ulema who are actually learned in these matters.
Lol you literally included Daniel Haqiqatjou basically lying about what Shaykh Yasir said. Shaykh Yasir was speaking about going against the majority, yet Daniel starts arguing as if Shaykh Yasir was talking about going against ijma3. You and I both know that Shaykh Yasir was not talking about going against ijma3 because 1) the majority of ulema are literally in AGREEMENT with Shaykh Yasir's opinion on this matter of shirk and 2) Shaykh Yasir himself said MAJORITY. Not ALL. Honestly, fear Allah when you do this type of backbiting. This kind of video is extremely unIslamic.
@Cheese Cake No point in talking to you in my opinion since you made claims that Yasir Qahdi is his Prophet astaghfurallah and in my opinion he doesn't have difficulty in English comprehension and he doesn't suffer form confusion of the highest order. I honestly believe that to you do have these issues.
@Cheese Cake these kinds of comments just validate my opinions of people like you guys. Entirely ignorant and illogical. Instead of addressing my comments, you chose to write about how you think 'Yasir Qadhi is [my] prophet' wal iyaadu billah. And then you continue with comments about 'difficulty in english comprehension'. lol you didn't even address a single comment I made. Have some ikhlaas and be just. Muslims like you, embarrass the rest of us.
Wow it’s embarrassing to see our “daii and scholars” being emotional in their response against YQ like this. Right or wrong the response should be ethical. If a scholar refutes with anger towards another the followers may be at war with each other.
@@saadhasan2300 I'm not barelvi, but musrik can be forgiven by toubah, What about abdul wahab who killed thousands of Muslims in makkah to spread wahabism Killer will never be forgiven , so all we wahabi following a murderers belief, I left wahabi after listening his history, who was just like IsIs killer
I sincerely believe the people of knowledge Should find a way to interact with each other. TH-cam is not the right tool. If People of Knowledge start fighting among each other what will happen to the Ummah. Masha Allah we have learned to take the good and leave the bad.
OMG wallahi that's what bothered be about him in like 2005 and I later found a lot of other things and tried to listen to the good from him, I couldn't understand why he went to study under Tony Blair while the Crusader was waging a declared Crusade in Iraq and Afghanistan. I still just took the good from him for the beneficial knowledge.
First of all, these matters aren't for the average muslim because it's not wajib knowledge; they should just know that it's forbidden and major sin to envoke the dead, that's it. Secondly, a lot of responses but unfortunately, all are emotional responses, we need a thorough explanation. And it would be fine if it were as it seems to imply, that this position (envoking pious is shirk, not just haram and therfore you are kafir) is the majority view of the ummah currently and historically: turns out it is to the contrary; majority ummah currently and historically are aligned with yasir qadi's view; he has only gone and aligned himself with majority scholars of the ummah of muhammad pbuh. Yasir qadhi has explained it thoroughly in his video: najdi dawah; listen to it and make a critical approach, not emotional. Learn about the history of abdul wahhab and the consequence of holding unorthodox, splinter views and positions.
Most people, even the TH-cam refuters, have not even heard the full video of what YQ has said. It is evident as their responses don't even adequately touch upon what YQ spoke about.
I saw the whole 3.5 hour video follow up which shows he was still wrong. I have the time stamp notes to prove it, and this is from a person who first listened to Yasir over 10 years ago & did a portions of research with many imams! Many ppl watch the part that is where is his opinion, its clearly incorrect!
how is meat halal? We sacrifice it to Allah alone. Prayer & sacrifice is from acts of worship assigned by Allah & worship for Allah alone is Tawhid Ulluhiyah or Allah's Oneness as God. to expect a response in du'a or blessings of meat from other then Allah is additional shirk in Allah's Rububiyah or Lordship! Quran 6 : 162 - *Say (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم): "Verily, my Salat (prayer), my sacrifice, my living, and my dying are for Allah, the Lord of the 'Alamin.* (all that exists). - It is shirk regardless of intention, Allah may excuse a person due to their ignorance (Qur'an 2 :22) but the act is still shirk! Yasir doesn't know Tawhid, even the pagans accepted Allah as Lord like in surah Fil and at time of hardship they called upon Allah alone, but at other times they called to other then Allah! Qur'an 31 : 25 - *And if you ask them: "Who has created the heavens and the earth," they will certainly say: "Allah.* " Say: "All the praises and thanks be to Allah!" But most of them know not. 30. - *Allah, He is the Truth, and that which they invoke besides Him is Al-Batil* 32. - And when a wave covers them like shades they invoke Allah, *making their invocations for Him only. But when He brings them safe to land, there are among them those that stop* in between (Belief & disbelief). Summary, Tawhid has 3 Categories: 1) Lord = Actions of the Creator *2) God = One served, or acts by creation assigned by & done for the Creator!* 3) (Names & Attributes, not being mentioned here, but letting you know) Qur'an 6 : 163 - "He has no partner. *And of this I have been commanded,* and I am the first of the Muslims." The Main Tawhid called to by the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him was Tawhid of Worship! ~~~ Also the Grave life is from the ghaib & can't hear except textual acts like Salams : Quran 35 :22 - Verily, Allah makes whom He wills to hear, but you cannot make hear those who are in graves. - Quran 6 : 50 - Say (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم): "I don't tell you that with me are the treasures of Allah, nor (that) I know the Unseen; nor I tell you that I am an angel. *I but follow what is revealed to me."* Abu Hurayrah narrated that the Messenger of Allah Peace & blessings on him said: “There is no one who sends Salaam upon me, but Allaah will restore to me my soul so that I may return his Salaam.” (Abi Dawood Sahih) Jundub Ibn ‛Abdullāh (radiyallāhu ‘anhumā) who said: I heard the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) five days before his death saying: “I free myself before Allāh from taking any of you as a special close friend (khaleel) for indeed Allāh has taken me as a khaleel just as he took Ibrāheem as a khaleel. And if I was to take anyone from my Ummah as a khaleel, then surely I would’ve taken Abu Bakr as a khaleel. Indeed those who came before you would take the graves of their Prophets as places of worship (as mosques). Do not take graves as places of worship, for indeed I forbid you from that.” [Reported by Muslim]
Yasir's teacher Muhammad bin Hadi Madkhali also warned against Yasir before he left Medina... May Allah guide us & him, this isn't the first time he has been dishonest! here's his teacher in Medina : **"Yasir Qadhi Has A PhD In Calling To The Gates of The Hell Fire! "**
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 "Warned against" wow! Are you for real!? Why blind follow an opinion of a man who doesn't even live in the west and who hasn't sat with YQ to discuss matters face to face? Can such a "warning" be valid? Who from the kibar ulema or the ulema from the lajna have warned against YQ? Forget Rabi or Hadi Madkhali, give me from the kibar ulema. These Madkhali scholars have a tiny following in Saudi. I know cus I live here. No one ever refers to the Madkhali scholars in Saudi as we have the kibar and the lajna ulema that we refer to. Only brothers from the west who are cultish in their Salafiya quote the Madkhali scholars over the kibar and lajna scholars.
Dr. Yasir Qadhi do not listen to these accusations . Your follower knows better. You are extremely knowledgeable scholar and you always explain Deen in the best possible way that it can be use for today’s life. May Allah(swt) Grant you Jannah .Ameen
:) Unfortunately this is how world works. Words are interpreted and understood in different levels. I'm not at all a fan of Dr. Yasir but his level of communication is not for the internet I feel.
Because he is a master of misdirection and setting up agenda in his speeches. You need to have some experience in understanding such kind of speech, otherwise it is all rosy.
He is encouraging people as ignorant is him to think outside the box. Thinking outside the box means explore ideas that are creative and unusual and that are not limited or controlled by rules or tradition. This is innovation, he doesn't know innovation is not permissible?
Abu Dhar (r.a) said, "I was with the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) one day and I heard him saying: "There is something I fear for my Ummah than the Dajjal." It was then that I became afraid, so I said: "Oh Rasool Allah! Which thing is that?" He صَلّى اللهُ عليهِ وسلّم
said; "Misguided and astray scholars."
May Allah subhana wa'tala guide Sheikh Yasir
@Bin Yamin Cassim you do not assume that people have mullahs just because you don't agree with them. You might not know, this certain person is way better than you in the eyes of Allah azzawajal. She may be a beloved of Allah. And when a person insults or pains a beloved of Allah azzawajal, Allah azzawajal takes revenge on His beloved's behalf
@@datuputi2549 Helloo , is it true the prophet beat his wife Aisha on the chest hard and it 's also allowed to beat women in quran ?
@@fractaldelight1976 no, it is not true. Perhaps the reference is to a certain hadith that mentions such a thing, but it was not striking out of rage but out of playfulness or love, as we learn from the context of the hadith.
Narrated Anas:
I served the Prophet (ﷺ) for ten years, and he never said to me, "Uf" (a minor harsh word denoting impatience) and never blamed me by saying, "Why did you do so or why didn't you do so?"
He never did any of this to his servants, so how come he can do it to his wives?
He never beat any of his wives, ever.
The Qur'anic verse about the punishment on wife's rebellion or the likes: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/An-Nisa,_34#to_beat_them_(i%E1%B8%8Drib%C5%ABhunna)
@@datuputi2549 Thanks for your answer.I accidentally went to a channel and they showed me the hadiths where the prophet beat Aisha on the chest and she said it 's hard and painful.Can you talk to them there and explain it , the channel is called Infinity apologetics 2 , Christian Prince livechat 24 /7.You will be shocked at what he showed in the videos
@@fractaldelight1976 oh, I know them. I was commenting on their videos back in the days but I just got tired because whatever you do, they're really determined to tarnish the name and reputation of al-Islam. So I wouldn't even bother anymore.
The way that the Prophet struck Aisha was not in an angered way. But maybe the Prophet (PBUH) just overdid it that's why Aisha was hurt. But Aisha never took that as an offense. It was actually a very precious moment for her because the Prophet was protecting him from the devil's works. But the Kafirun and the enemies of Allah twisted the meaning of the words of our mother Aisha and made it look like the Prophet hurt her INTENTIONALLY
Great we have ppl in our ummah who stand up against which is wrong! Alhamdulillah...
THATS WHY OUR RASOUL ALAIHAI SALAM TOLD US TO HOLD TIGHT INTO QURAN SUNNAH
Yasir Qadi has good knowledge before after his PHD in yale University Western ideology, he changed his aqeetha. May Allah guide Yasir.
*1 samuel 15:3*
*Now go and attack Amalek, and completely destroy everything they have. Don’t spare them, but kill men and women, children and babies*
*I'M AN EX-CHRISTIAN ☣️*
Yasir Qadhi is following the position of Ibn Taymiyya rahimahullah on this, and has abandoned the incorrect, misguided analysis of Abdulwahhab, the mass murdering tyrant who his own brother called out and said he was a complete deviant.
Actions are but by intentions. Both for the good and bad deeds.
If intention is deleted from the equation, the sin i.e. drinking alcohol, is still a sin but by taking the intention to account (i.e. a person who accidentally drinks a soft drink thinking its innocent then realises the alcohol is in the ingredients) will be automatically forgiven and treated lightly (as per Hadith that the Ummah is forgiven for sins they do out of sincere error judgement) vs someone who drinks the same drink knowingly and with the intention of becoming intoxicated, would be sinful and punished accordingly, (unless they repent of course.
Similarly if you see a man doing Sujood to a tree that is normally worshipped by pagans, he is not automatically guilty of committing Shirk, as when you ask him why he did that, his answer could be "I had no clue and I was just praying Asar and used this tree as my Sutra" That would not be an issue at all, yet by taking the hadith out of context "Dua is Ibadah" and not cross referencing that with other known Hadith "Actions are according to their intentions" will lead you astray and continue your slippery slope down the khwariji pathway and mindset.
He has spoken the Truth on this matter and the falsehood of Abdulwahhab's cult is now plain and clear for all who are not tainted with Kibr to see.
@@mysteriousx3258 what's your religion, if , you're okay you can tell
@@treasuresofmedina6882 you are blind follower of this deviant dr. ... Just provide evidence instead of labelling any thing against mujadid abdul wahab... He dr. is educated illiterate person May be he is funded by jews or christians to defame salafism. He is not even following Sheikhul Islaam Ibni Tayima , he is only using his name to make followers.
Yale Institute teaches Islam better than anywheee j the Easter m
You know, I don't really listen to yasir qadhi much but I do remember he once said a few years ago that mainstream islam is the right path so I'm gonna take his advice and and not his new opinions on islam.
mainstream islam is not islam that has the more media coverage because backed american and british satellites and by petro dollars...... nadjdis (neo salafis) are a tiny bunch of people that does too much sound......... mainstream islam, is islam of the four madhabs, they are everywhere, but they are quiet, wise people, their objective is to learn and teach, not as the nadjdis to destroy and refute everyone..... so no, he is making another point that ibn abdelwahab was completely false...... now if they can elaborate an answer, well that's okay, he did an ijtihad, that wasnt even his, its the opinion of other scholars as he says, he says its the opinion of classical scholars before the wahabis, and todayit is the opinion at least of Hatim Bin Arif Al-Awni which is a great scholar.... now if he is wrong , then he did ijtihad and was wrong, but prove it.... that's the question
@@abdelhakyac7285 Al-Awni accompanies people that curse the sahabah!
Al-Awni is not a scholar!
As for proof that yasir is wrong that they are many from the Qur'an and sunnah.
But this hadeeth should be sufficient for a Muslim:
An-Nu’man ibn Bashir (رضي الله عنه) narrated that the Prophet (sallallahu 'alaihi wa sallam) said: “Dua is worship."
Collected by Abu Dawud [1479], At-Tirmithi [3372] An-Nisa’I in Al-Kubara [11464], Ibn Majah [3828]. Imam An-Nawawi graded this Hadith as being Sahih.
"it's okay to eat pork as long as you imagine it's beef" yasir qadi
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Where did he say that
@mimomimi it's joke to demonstrate the absurdity of yasir qadhis statements about shirk.
He said that it is not shirk to invoke dead people as long as you don't believe this dead person is God.
Obviously an catastrophic statement from yasir qadhi, nobody should listen to him.
"In his humble opinion"
Alhamdulillah we still have ulamas, and don't hesitate to correct any of this kind
Would you like your good deeds to carry on increasing even after your death?
The Prophet (saw) said "When a man dies, his good deeds come to an end except three; ongoing charity, beneficial knowledge, and righteous offspring who will pray for him." (Muslim 1631)
Please support and share my channel with your contacts, and inshaAllah if they benefit and teach others this will count as beneficial knowledge and your good deeds will continue to increase even after your death inshaAllah.
JazakhAllah khairan.
The amount of deranged individuals I’m seeing in these comments defending YQ like he pays their bills and feeds their children 🤡 instead of defending the attributes of Allah which YQ continues to question, here y’all are defending the creation and embarrassing yourselves. Yikes.
Shut up wahabi extremist. Atleast YQ abandoned the so called salafi community and is more open minded
Spot on
Shhh wahabbi
whoever he is and how knowledgeable he is doesn't matter. When there is a Sahih hadith from many many chains.
الدعاء هو العبادة.
.Invoking is Worshipping. So invoking is Shirk since you can only Worship Allah and Allah alone.
What is the definition of Dua that is worship? The definition is: Asking who you believe is God. Therefore, if I said to a person: Feed me, I did not worship him, and if I said to God: Feed me, then I worshiped Him. Why did the second act become an act of worship for the one from whom it was requested? Because I asked who I believe is God.
@ahmadasdfhb No, it's totally different, If you invoke anyone who is not "present" حاضر or able to hear you. It's a tribute that can only be assigned to Allah. He is the only one who is "present" (by means of His knowledge) and listening all the time to everyone. No one else could claim or has this ability. That is why invoking someone who is absent غائب
except Allah is not permitted and considered Shirk. We know that there are angels everywhere, and they have been assigned duties to perform like moving wind, sending down rain, providing food, protecting us, and even sending salutation to Prophet Muhammad PBUH. But have anyone ever invoked any of the angels knowing that they have the duties mentioned above? The answer is no! So, the same way we can not invoke any human being alive of dead who is absent, let alone if he/she is able to help us or has any authority. And that's what Qadhi trying to legitimize that calling dead or alive ansent saints and prophets is ok as long as you do not believe them as god. But he forgot that is the definition of Shirk in the Quran and Hadith and violation of اياك نعبد و اياك نستعين. Even the Arabic language itself negates the concept of invoking any غائب (unseen/absent) there is no فعل الأمر (the verb of order/request) for anyone absent. In Arabic language, you can only order or request who is present (حاضر).
انا، نحن، انت، انتِ، انتم، انتما، انتن
Let's just all make duas to Allah to GUIDE ALL of us and to forgive ALL of us... Let the scholars battle it out in private... Let us ALWAYS be respectful and beautiful in our behaviour, including when we disagree or argue...let's do it with love.
very true
Ameen..
assalualaikum, it would be an offer to find my comment and like it, so that the channel can see my comment, no person should be confused because of this.
@Des safry Ricky keep in mind that allah knows what his intentions are. We can't say someone is wrong because of a mistake.
@Des safry Ricky I understand, but we should not promote conflict, because conflict is never good
Yasir qadhi is hitting the cardinal point of Islam hence it can't be compromised, no matter how much good things he told other than that. So its better not to hear him any more until he completely changes his view about shirk activities.
No compromise in Islam shirk is shirk. only Allah SWT you invoke and ask for help
It’s scary how many people he has misled!
MUSLIMS DO NOT DIVIDED THANKS
We can only unite upon the Truth. Such wickedness must be exposed.
If dividing from another group of Muslims means that I'm going to be on the Sunnah...
Then I divide!
May Allah guide the Muslims, we only unite upon the sunnah. And if we divide, we divide for the sunnah.
Now if yasir qadhi has made these enormous blunders then i divide from him and those that support him! Because supporting him is like supporting these blunders that he is now known for.
And if he returns to the sunnah then we would accept his apology.
@@penguinman38 well said akhi karim
do not divide upon the truth, disassociate yourself from deviants and misguiders habibi
Rasullah saw told us there will come a time when holding on to the deen will be like holding on to hot coales. Allah swt has perfected this deen and the central part of the deen is the Quran. Indeed, it is We who brought down the 'Zhikr' (Reminder/Quran) and We will surely preserve it. 15:9
I had listened to some of his lectures and it was beneficial. Brother make mistakes like everyone. I believe there is a way for others lecturers to correct his mistakes. The job they doing everyone is bound to make mistakes,no easy talking for hrs on TV. I feel sad, we are the ummah of our beloved Rasoul (saw).I believe Yasir Qadir will not misguide us but everyone will make mistakes. United we stand! Islam is beautiful. Prophet Muhammad ( saw) said support your brother if he is right or wrong. The Sabahas asked him, how do we support our brother when he is wrong. He "said stop him from doing wrong". May Allah guide us all to the straight path. Ameen thumma Ameen.
yes unity is good. But you should refer back to the ayah 103 of Surah Ali Imran.
Allah has commanded us to hold his rope. As Muslims we are only united by holding on to the Rope of Allah, we are not united by holding hands.
The scholars have said that the Rope of Allah refers to the Qur'an. Now yasir qadhi has opposed the quran in what he has said about shirk (see ayah 3 of surah az-zumar, verses 84-89 of al-muminoon, see surah az-zukhruf). The matter is clear but so many people are confused. Thus it is mandatory for the people who possess knowledge about yasir's mistake that they make things clear to the people.
You must understand that they are minor mistakes and major mistakes. Read about the early imams and how they dealt with major mistakes. Imam Ahmand bin Hanbal boycotted Imam Yahya bin Ma'een (may Allah have mercy on them both) due to a major mistake he did.
Now people are talking against yasir's mistake and people are calling this inappropriate?!
Brother, read the quran, study the sunnah. Read the works of Ibn Uthaymeen, Albani, and their likes.
Brother Yasir Qadi you are twisting things that are very clear to understand.
Masha Allah. Subhanullah. May Allah (swt) protect our Iman.
The end time is nearer
What are you talking about? The majority of scholars held the same opinion as Yasir Qadhi (not shirk) for at least a thousand years?
@@zakariab9591 . May Allah guide you.
Abu Hanifa, Malik, Ash-Shafi'i, Ahmad bin Hanbal, and so many others don't believe what yasir qadhi said!
Tawus, Sufyan ath-thawri, Ata bin Abi Rabah (these are the students of the sahabah) also don't believe what yasir qadhi said!
Whatever "scholar" is against these scholars that I mentioned has made a mistake! (and is in reality probably not a scholar!)
@@penguinman38 with all due respect brother, but stop saying "Yasir Qadhi". You should say the vast majority of scholars of over a thousand years. Yasir Qadhi isn't unique, but just a single person with the opinion among the many thousands of scholars. Even the brother of Muhammed ibn AbdelWahhab, Sulayman ibn AbdelWahhab, called the opinion of his own brother problematic and was very very harsh on him on this subject. He even said that Muhammed ibn AbdelWahhab himself was dividing the Ummah. May Allah guide us all, bottom line, yes it's bid3a and haram. And if they worship the grave, it is shirk. But if they don't consider it worship, it can't even be shirk since they themselves don't intend to worship.
You all go indoor and clear yourself. Most of you dictating . Please we don't want to see more than 72 groups.
@@zakariab9591 don't you to invoke is worship,if you asked the quffar of maca of the time ,that who brings down water,who is the greator ,etc they will straight away tell you that it's the most high all mighty Allah,but what's the sin they're committing,it's because they invoke there idols and the dead.So stop invoking the dead,it's worship,face your load and ask him of what ever you May desire.that's most beloved to Allah.
May Allah save us from those who teach reverse islam...
Ya Rabb protect us Aameen أمين
INNA LILLAHI WA INNA ILAYHI RAJI’UN MEANING
The translation of this phrase inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji’un is “Indeed, to Allah we belong and to Allah we shall return.”
He is a very dangerous guy! If somebody has no knowledge, he will confuse them and miss guide them and create a doubt in their heart. Do not listen to him!!!
*1 samuel 15:3*
*Now go and attack Amalek, and completely destroy everything they have. Don’t spare them, but kill men and women, children and babies*
*I'M AN EX-CHRISTIAN ☣️*
How is Yasir Qahdi wrong? Cite the proof
@@richlisola1 site the proof? Go watch his videos. May be you don’t understand? He said inderecrly quran is an old ancient book and it needed to be updated and has to matches with the modern siceity. He also said islam itself needed to be modified because sharia law doesn’t match with the modern society. Who the hell he think he is ? God? He also said grave worshiping is sin but not major shirk…
@@richlisola1
Here are some of his dangerous mistakes:
1. in a video published by EPIC (in Plano, Texas), he said that Yajooj and Majooj are "fairy tales". We can not say that, when it is mentioned in both the Quran (Al-Kahf) and the hadith of Prophet Mohamed (Sallu Allahu alaihi wa sallam).
2. for the same video above (in point 1), he said something to the meaning of "from an Engineering perspective, how can a dam hold people so powerful like Yajooj and Majooj for thousands of years"!!!
So, basically, he is saying that everything Allah (Subhanahu wa t'aalaa) does MUST pass our limited human mind, and engineering standards?????
3. in another video, he said that the "science of Tawheed" is a recent science. This is 100% wrong statement, as Prophet Mohamed (Sallu Allahu alaihi wa sallam) used to say to the messengers he is sending to the tribes in the Arabian peninsula "teach them Tawheed .. when they believe, then teach them Salat .. and when they do it (the salat), then teach them the Zakat".
4. He seems to be OK with grave worshipping and going to Saints, which is a SHIRK matters that Prophet Mohamed (Sallu Allahu alaihi wa sallam) warned us NOT to do.
If you think i am making this up, then watch the following videos and judge for yourself.
th-cam.com/video/YXGH7vCeiBQ/w-d-xo.html
Yasir Qadhi says it's haram so I am not sure what the big deal is , he isn't exactly propagating it.
Asalaam Aleykum warahma tullahi wabarakatuhu. Brother either all of us have hearing issues or one person does, in this case that person would be you. I've watched and listened to what he said. He said it clearly "it's not shirk in and of itself" and that it's just something that will open the doors to shirk. He is absolutely wrong in this matter. If you pick up any book regarding this matter it is clear. Our beloved prophet Muhammad ﷺ said that invocation is worship. So now you decide who to follow. The prophet Muhammad ﷺ or Yasir Qadhi who keeps changing his opinions. Good luck in your choice. I choose to go with the prophet pbuh.
@@naseemkad Asalaam Aleykum warahma tullahi wabarakatuhu. You have made a few fallacious claims on your behalf. Let me address them. Firstly, I've seen the whole talk. Secondly, I'm very familiar with the English language. Thirdly, your first sentence alone tells me it is actually you who appears to not understand my response written in English. Maybe the Hadith went past you. Aqeedah is crystal clear in Islam. This is something the youth or younger generation of today seem to have no idea about. If i held a view that is backed by evidence from Qur'an + Sunnah + Early Predecessors then i changed my view later on in life to the contrary of the insurmountable evidence. Therefore, this suggests that either i was right before and wrong now or i was wrong before and thus right now. This is how logic works. Nobody is infallible in terms of knowledge. When a person is wrong, they're wrong. Especially in terms of Aqeedah which would lead a person into the hellfire.
Narrated Ibn Abbas that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ addressed the people on the farewell Hajj and said: "O People! I am leaving among you such a thing that if you strongly adhere to it you will never go astray, the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Prophet."
The prophet Muhammad ﷺ came to do away with all forms of Shirk. If you read the Qur'an you can see this. If anyone reads the Seerah they can see this. What he is saying goes against what the prophet Muhammad ﷺ taught. If the prophet taught something we need evidence of such a thing. This religion my dear sister isn't based upon whims, desires and having an opinion that suits your narrative. We aren't Christians or Jews. This Deen is based upon reason and hard evidences taken from the Qur'an and Sunnah. No man is above the words of Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ and the prophet Muhammad ﷺ. If anyone tells you something about Islam you have to do your research and enquire about it. Ask people that are knowledgeable. Read their books and see what they say on this particular matter. Ask for the source material to substantiate the claims that someone makes. If they just make an opinionated claim without giving you a reference. Then question marks should start to form in your head immediately. Moreover, you made spurious and fallacious claims where you claimed i mocked, hurt and you mentioned the word slandered. So now i want you to substantiate your claim as you have now accused me falsely. Which is a sin in Islam if you didn't know.
He has been refuted now by various scholar's in the field regarding this topic and other topics. Don't be beguiled by anyone who says anything that opposes the Qur'an and Sunnah even if it's your own father.
If i told you that chewing pork and consuming it is no sin "in and of itself" so long as you vomit afterwards, would you then teach this to your children and other's publicly?
What more is the case of Shirk?
Shirk is the unforgivable sin in Islam if you didn't know. Even Christian children know this basic Aqeedah point.
ANYTHING that even leads to Shirk we must stay far away from. As was mentioned earlier and in the books of the scholars. Shirk is Shirk. Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ addresses the Quraysh Pagan Arabs as Mushriks. Do you know what this word means and do you know what it entails? Do you know the beliefs of the Pagan Arabs at the time?
وَإِذَا سَأَلَكَ عِبَاد۪ي عَنّ۪ي فَإِنّ۪ي قَر۪يبٌۘ أُج۪يبُ دَعْوَةَ الدَّاعِ إِذَا دَعَانِۙ فَلْيَسْتَج۪يبُوا ل۪ي وَلْيُؤْمِنُوا ب۪ي لَعَلَّهُمْ يَرْشُدُونَ
And when My servants ask you, [O Muhammad], concerning Me - indeed I am near. I respond to the invocation of the supplicant when he calls upon Me. So let them respond to Me [by obedience] and believe in Me that they may be [rightly] guided.
Surah Al-Baqarah [2:186]
One of the names of Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ is
Mujīb مجيب. Al-Mujeeb is the Answerer of prayers.
According to al-Ghazali, this means that it is HE who RESPONDS to the REQUESTS of THOSE WHO ASK by assisting them, to the call of those who call upon HIM (ALONE) by answering them, and responds to the plight of the poor with all they need.
اِيَّاكَ نَعۡبُدُ وَاِيَّاكَ نَسۡتَعِيۡنُؕ
It is YOU we worship and YOU WE ASK FOR HELP.
Surah Al-Fatihah [1:5]
Lastly, you said "it's clearly NOT true that he says worship other than Allah". I want you now to go back to my earlier response and quote me verbatim where i have said such a statement. I feel quite clear at this point that it's your lack of grasp of the English language and the topic at hand which proves to me this has gone above your head. So now you have to substantiate a lot of things you have said otherwise it is you who is slandering and an evident liar.
@@abdulmunim318 First of all I have a question if you don't mind are you saying for the past 1400 years and the majority of the Muslim world who follows a school of thought deviant? For 1400 years people have been following a school of thought and even today the majority of the world follows a school of thought. Just to clarify are you saying the majority of the Muslims in the world and for the past 1400 years people were just misguided? I know it may not be relevant to this conversation and I didn't make any claims about you. I'm just asking if you don't mind and if you do you don't need to reply or you can just tell me you don't wanna answer this question.
@@naseemkad I don't think you understand the intricacies of this discussion.
You see if you don't believe the saint in the grave has any power or is a deity then the opinion is its haram but not shirk .
For example if you go to the grave of a saint and ask him to make dua to Allah SWT for you without believing the Saint is a deity nor has any powers that are reserved only for Allah SWT then it wrong and haram but not shirk.
Because you are not supplicating to him but asking him to supplicate to Allah SWT for you.
You could ask a living Muslim to supplicate for you right?
Same thing. However as it he cannot hear you because he has passed away from this world it is haram .
@@lilyiqra dead have no power
Living can ask but dead cannot and that's shirk
Believing they can do something is shirk
Shirk is far more dangerous than normal haram
You can be a free thinker as Allah gave us free will but still don’t change what Allah says don’t do and make it not shirk. It just a common sense to know that invoking is worship, and invoking anyone besides Allah is worse. You can tell that the brother has his own personal issues, unfortunately what is saying can take people who don’t know away from Islam. A doorbell 😂
Just watch the 3 hour video by YQ with an open mind where he summarizes why he believes the Najdi theology is wrong and why his view regarding isthigatha, which is the majority view, is correct. He addressed the same thing what you have just said right now and gives explanation regarding his view.
Sheikh Yasir Qadhi Masha-Allah is the greatest scholar of our generation. I see so many people constantly attacking him recently. Well you can jump up and down all you want, but you can't drag him down from his position. You can't take away what Allah has blessed him with. He has immense knowledge and a great analytical mind.
I even saw some say he is not a "real" scholar. Like I can't even....
I do not agree with his conclusion regarding the shirk issue myself. Though I understand where he is coming from. But it doesn't make him a bad scholar. You will always find even among the ancient scholars we unanimously revere now greatly differed in their view of many important topics. We just love to romanticize the ancient scholars and think they were all above flaw. Just dive a little deeper and maybe do some math on the side to clear your head, so that you can think. Scholars may come to different opinion on different matters. Because they are human. So stop attacking them. If you agree with one great. If you don't agree with one, move on.
Try to focus more on your self than to refute different scholars opinions. That would certainly be most beneficial.
May be you want to invoke the dead that's why you blindly defended him
We should make dua to only Allah
Did he say dont make dua only to Allah?
Well. Said
This is all very interesting being born and raised in the US. Its a mirror image of what has happened to Christianity over the past few decades here. A majority of conservative christian churches have been compromised and/or infiltrated over time to where the average christian here now accepts homosexuality, sex before marriage, etc as being totally normal. And "you are a bigot and going against Jesus' (pbuh) teachings" if you reject what has happened, or you are told "there's nothing you can do about it, don't worry, don't call it out, God will handle it". Meanwhile they are teaching children under 7 years old about sexual deviance of all kinds and you aren't allowed to disagree. Don't fall for it, especially the argument that it's wrong to refute people. Our enemies are very clever, attempting to keep us silent with fake religious arguments. Stay steadfast.
It is most DEFINITELY SHIRK thereare many forms of SHIRK. What YASIR QADHI say is SHIRK invoking others , is SHIRK there are many forms of SHIRK.
This guy is dangerous for the Muslim Ummah
Excellent clips
Yasir qadhi gave his proves and opinions why don't these ashyaakh just give their proves and tell their opinions and stop bashing and say bad things about the poor guy. Give your proves and do not bash the person as if like he is an enemy of Islam? This is not a scholarship wallahi this is horrible.
what are you doing in Islam my friend? You are better human being than Muhammad.
May be you didn’t under what Yasir Qadhi said, and Sheikh Assim Al-Hakeem and the brother with the doorbell example explained it. Aren’t these enough for you?
@@sheemmee1 no. the dude is encouraging his fellow radical to kill Yaser qadhi
@@nikzahui3477 no
May Allah guide us all to Him
Are you INSANE??? 😳
May Allah guide you Solomon Santos and Dr Yasir
@@jelkajalika899 Ameen Ya Allah,May Allah guide you and us all
I'm really disappointed with Yasir Qadhi through listening to him few years back.
Correct the wrong with kindness not hatred. Allah is the most mercifully. The door of taubah is open for everyone, that includes Yasi Qadhi.
@@nikzahui3477 May Allah guide you to the truth.
@@minahtempeh6860 Please no. I have my God. He has a son. He is different from your God who has no son: sourate 112 v 3.
So no. I don't want your Allah to guide me. That's a highway to hell.
@@nikzahui3477 Does your Christian religion teaches you to insult other religion?
@@nikzahui3477 Priest and preachers are entering Islam. Example Yusuf Estes from texas and many more. Why? Google it. Peace ✌
It’s not open for him as long as he’s being in this road. Why are we talking about forgiveness to someone who is lying about Allah. This has nothing to do with forgiveness. Allah don’t like lyers. So let’s deal with Yasir Qadhi skies before we talk about forgiveness. You obviously don’t know what forgiveness is about. Allah don’t like people who lie about him. Let’s not put the horse before the cart. Let’s deal with his lies. Then when he corrects himself let’s talk about forgive ness. Duh 🙄
You can never have an intellectual and academic debate with a Salafi. They are simply too emotional for it.
They're definitely emotional but they're also rather incompetent and unsophisticated on most matters as well which compounds things greatly and leaves most people in awe of how silly they are.
I use to listen to Yasir Qadhi a lot. I lost my way and recently i been slowly coming to the path once again. I remember a week ago i somehow ended up on this video and right away got offended people attacking Yasir Qadhi, how can they say such things about Yasir Qadhi he's so knowledgeable, but it got me searching up on all his misguided clips to casting doubts on preservatinon of Quran, to saying graveworshiping is not shirk but a sin, to yajuj and majuj are apparently zombies because to believe a tribe stuck between two mountains is far fetched and illogical! I couldn't believe i'm hearing all this from him. Alhumdulilah i saw this video and decided to do my research. All i know is you have to question even sheikhs that you place your trust in.
Yasir qadhi is way ahead of his time, just like how ibn tahmiyya and many other scholars were in their time. Time will tell inshaAllah
Abu layth mk ll.
May Creator guide them away from subjective over emotional bidah.
I instinctively ignored this mans (y.qardhi) channel without prior knowledge of him way before seeing these videos.
And I am a layman revert to Islam that grew up amongst deceptive individuals so I am not being emotional but recognise those that have an agenda.
Y.qardhi should not speak on things above his pay grade.
Reformation of Quran and Sunnah to appease modernity isn't on.
Don't let their ignorance be our evidence.
Excellent.
Our Prophet salaallahi waalayhi wasalaam said in hadith told in Al Bukhari that when the affairs regarding knowledge is entrust to those who don't deserve then await for the hour . This is one the sign of the days judgement.
I think we all are have better things to do than refuting each other in public and proving than we are better than the others . Please brothers stop this ... islam is peace , there is better way to solve this matter ...😓
Watch the video Razah Bhai!
😢
@@hamida9346 are you address it to me or to those people bcs i also not agree the way they mistreated people in public
@@hamida9346 thank you, i thought you misunderstood my comment brother,
I think that they just overwhelmed with too much knowledge and forget that Prohet Muhammad ( PBUH) was so kind when addressed people even they where wrong , i am not justifing the fact but i am concern about the way they treat sheikh YQ in public suppose to be done with respect.
Looks like the pro-najdis have stooped down to the level of the islamophobes like Jay Smith and co. to refute and insult YQ. That alone is a strong reason to believe and trust YQ. He's such a humble and respectful person, unlike these.
YQ is a jahil, may Allah Guide him, stop gaining knowledge from people like YQ who says ignorance. May Allah guide us all.
Ameen..
bro I have heard that he is an orientalist. is it true?
@@Abdullah_Khan578 no not true at all.
U r losing sight of the core issue this time : is calling to the dead a major sin, a stepping stone to shirk (YQ stance) or is it shirk (majority stance which he wrongly says was not majority stance)! We’ve got worshippers and self-whippers now rooting for YQ in the US whereas most of them do call out to the deceased for ‘help”!
May ALLAH swt guides him🤲
I learned a lot from Yasir Qadhi about the Seerah of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wassallam , please address the wrong not attack the person , we should all take the good from someone and leave the bad .
May Allaah swt guide us and keep us guided always .Aameen
I think you lack a basic understanding of Islaam. This is not the Islamic principle. If someone is a clear devient as qadhi is he should be refuted and exposed so the masses are not misguided by his innovation.
@@amjadfarooq8063 you're the one who lack basic understandings of islam and common sense.
Think what our Prophet (SAW) had done in situation like this.
Please think
@@Khabib_N A misguided innovator was severely reprimanded when such fitna began. The 3 generations would not sit or be seen with ahlee bidat. In fact fadyl inn ayaad said I would rather sit with a Jew or Christian than a innovator. Such people are changing the religion from which the masses need to be protected. Learn your dean from clear and authentic sources.
@@amjadfarooq8063
Q: what are the TWO weighty matters to hold onto, as the prophet of Islam said?
I personally disagree with yasir qadhi on a lot of stuff. But i honestly disgree with Abu mussab he didnt invent it its the majority position of the ummah. I dont think we should let our dislike for him blind us.
Whoop wait a minute this not the opinion of the scholars at all all true Islamic reputable scholar agree it's shirk
Sidenote: the clip of Adnan Rashid is totally misused. I don't know if it was intentionally or not, but Adnan was talking about a total different subject.
Sad to see this bald person so called muslim is making a mockery of another muslim... good example you are setting..
What? And the guy sitting in the US can confuse and misguide as many as he wants because of his own weaknesses, personal doubts and desires?? If no one will clarify these critical things, then what’s the end result: disaster. While we sit on TH-cam and pass comments on how things should be handled!
How is baldness even a Shar'i metric?
Imran Qureshi you are as much misguided as the bafoon YQ. You are like one of those people who go to dargah and pray to the tomb. Auzubillah...may Allah SWT protect us from such iblis.
It is haram to refer to someone who hasn’t apostated from Islam, as a non Muslim.
@@misterlogik8163 Welp, I’m pretty sure Yasir Qadhi dosen’t have time to respond to questions in the comments, but let’s here this “hole” this guy has found.
To the speakers on the video..
Why don't they contact him directly and talk to him in a respectful manner? Because these kind of "Exposed" videos and confrontation will NOT solve any problem instead it create more hate and division. And its not just about him, anyone who you think made a mistake it's more constructive if you do in a private and respectful way. Calling names and degrading never solve any problem. Just my opinion.
This has been discussed and agreed upon 10,00 times!. With Yasir, people have been in touch with him since 2015! He started showing his cancerous ideas back then in public. He has refused the suggestions amd consultations of numerous senior scholars including his teachers at a madinah! The principle is simple: misguide amd confuse people in public domain, the. Public domain correction/exposure/refutation is needed.
Because none of the them have the intellect to deal with him one on one
@@mustafahussain7371 u wish! He is a confused south Asian origin man whose parents left their country of origin and used Saudi Arabia as a stepping stone to emigrate to America. And he got his foundation knowledge in deen in Saudi Arabia and he became arrogant when in the USA and forgot it was Saudi Arabia that was the vehicle for so much good for his family and himself.
@@Quantum-1157 oh boy, so what you are saying is that the majority of the Muslim ummah(asian) is wrong. And Saudis and wahabis are the authority and saviours of Islam and aqeedah.
@@Quantum-1157 YQ is an American born muslim. And any goodness he has is from Allah swt alone.
The two person becomes so miss guided and I used to listen them for years one is “ Imran Hussain and yasir qadi .
I think Yale university has something to do with his action this days
Allah knows best he was one of my favorite
btw what are your credentials?
@@TaQo007 True Credential is Muslim with TRansparent quran and Sunnah and Manhaj Salaf.
Yasir Qadhi is following the position of Ibn Taymiyya rahimahullah on this, and has abandoned the incorrect, misguided analysis of Abdulwahhab, the mass murdering tyrant who his own brother called out and said he was a complete deviant.
Actions are but by intentions. Both for the good and bad deeds.
If intention is deleted from the equation, the sin i.e. drinking alcohol, is still a sin but by taking the intention to account (i.e. a person who accidentally drinks a soft drink thinking its innocent then realises the alcohol is in the ingredients) will be automatically forgiven and treated lightly (as per Hadith that the Ummah is forgiven for sins they do out of sincere error judgement) vs someone who drinks the same drink knowingly and with the intention of becoming intoxicated, would be sinful and punished accordingly, (unless they repent of course.
Similarly if you see a man doing Sujood to a tree that is normally worshipped by pagans, he is not automatically guilty of committing Shirk, as when you ask him why he did that, his answer could be "I had no clue and I was just praying Asar and used this tree as my Sutra" That would not be an issue at all, yet by taking the hadith out of context "Dua is Ibadah" and not cross referencing that with other known Hadith "Actions are according to their intentions" will lead you astray and continue your slippery slope down the khwariji pathway and mindset.
He has spoken the Truth on this matter and the falsehood of Abdulwahhab's cult is now plain and clear for all who are not tainted with Kibr to see.
@@treasuresofmedina6882 You are extremely foolish may Allah guide you
May Allah guide us all.
Ameen
If you read the books of classical scholars Yasir Qadi is technically right. The classical ulama didn’t believe it to be shirk.
2:156. who, when afflicted with calamity, say: "Truly! To ALLAH we belong and truly, to Him we shall return." 2:157. They are those on whom are the Salawat (i.e. blessings, etc.) (i.e. who are blessed and will be forgiven) from their Lord, and (they are those who) receive His Mercy, and it is they who are the guided-ones. 2:155. And certainly, We shall test you with something of fear, hunger, loss of wealth, lives and fruits, but give glad tidings to As-Sabirin (the patient ones, etc.).
@@mahmudibnabidin Proof # 9 (Help O Slaves of Allah)
"إن لله ملائكة في الأرض سوى الحفظة يكتبون ما يسقط من ورق الشجر، فإذا أصاب أحدكم عرجة بأرض فلاة فليناد: أعينوا عباد الله".
رواه البزار ورجاله ثقات.
Translation: Allah has angels on the earth - other than the [two] record-keepers - who keep a record [even] of the leaves that fall on the ground. Therefore, if one of you is crippled in a deserted land where no-one is in sight, let him cry out: " HELP O ALLAH'S SERVANTS"
Imam al Haythami (rah) said after this hadith: It is narrated by Al-Bazzar and all its narrators are reliable (thiqa) [Reference: Majma uz Zawaid, Volume 10, Hadith No. 17104]
This hadith is not only authentic but rather it has been “ACTED UPON” by great scholars
إِذَا أَضَلَّ أَحَدُكُمْ شَيْئًا أَوْ أَرَادَ أَحَدُكُمْ عَوْنًا وَهُوَ بِأَرْضٍ لَيْسَ بِهَا أَنِيسٌ، فَلْيَقُلْ:"يَا عِبَادَ اللَّهِ أَغِيثُونِي، يَا عِبَادَ اللَّهِ أَغِيثُونِي، فَإِنَّ لِلَّهِ عِبَادًا لا نَرَاهُمْ"، وَقَدْ جَرَّبَ ذَلِكَ
After Imam At-Tabarani transmitted the hadith of calling out : O Servants of Allah, Help me! In his Mu'jam al Kabir (17/117) he said “this has been acted upon (وَقَدْ جَرَّبَ ذَلِكَ)” Plus the narration in Mu'jam al Kabeer does not talk about Angels.
The amal of great Imam of Salaf, Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal (rah).
عبد الله بن أحمد بن حنبل قال سمعت أبي يقول حججت خمس حجج اثنتين راكب وثلاث ماشي أو ثلاث راكب واثنتين ماشي فضللت الطريق في حجة وكنت ماشيا فجعلت أقول يا عباد الله دلوني على الطريق قال فلم أزل أقول ذلك حتى وقفت على الطريق أو كما قال أبي
Translation: Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Hanbal (rah) said that he heard his father (Imam Ahmed) who said: I performed Hajj 5 times, thrice on foot and twice on ride or he said thrice on ride and twice on foot, once when I was on foot I lost my way hence I started to exclaim this: O Allah’s servants show me the way (يا عباد الله دلوني على الطريق), I kept on repeating this until I came back on track. [Imam Baihaqi in Shu’ab ul Iman, Volume 6, Page No 128,Narration No. 7697]
So Alhamdulillah the great Hadith specialists themselves acted upon it and approved it, had there been a hint of shirk in this then they would have mentioned it!
Imam Mullah Ali Qari (rah) in Sharh of Hisn-ul-Hiseen writes that our Prophet (Peace be upon him) said that:
اذا انفلتت دابة احد كم بارض فلاة فليناد يا عباد الله احبسوا
Translation: If the animal of someone runs loose in jungle, then he should say: O Allah’s servants stop it (for full hadith see:Musnad Abu Ya'la # 5269. It also does not include wording Angels)
He writes under “Ibaad Allah”
المراد بهم الملىكة او المسلمون من الجن او رجال الغيب المستمون بابدال
Translation: It means the angels, Muslims, jinn or men of unseen i.e. Abdaal
Then he writes:
هذا حديث حسن يحتاج اليه المسافرون وانه مجرب
Translation: This hadith is Hasan (good) and the travelers are in urgent need of it and this has been acted upon [Sharh Hisn al Hiseen, Al-Hirz al-Thamin, page 378]
So how does this help people who want to be Muslims? Why is this not done in private? I think there are people of different opinions about what you are doing here especially the bashing language. Please Please handle this differently! May Allah GUIDE us all! Ameen.
Very good point
If you guys want to contradict with Yasir Qadi, criticise his views in a logical and intellectual manner, rather than attacking him or mocking him.
It's not logic that makes us Muslims, its following the commands, and following those before, the salaf
"Because a lot of people say something that doesn't make it right? This is against our usool".
Several hundred years where Ash'arism was the majority view among the ummah...
Do you disagree with Ash'arism? In what way?
@@veronicaredeemed Not necessarily but I know the brother in the video does which is what makes it an odd statement from him
@@RoyFlush716 right. I get it, that's a really good point.
I'm non-Muslim and sometimes curious how the diffent madhabs etc. interact. What people believe, and how they differ.
Even Adnan rashid used to defend Qadhi when Dawah man exposed him, now Adnan also knows some reality about Yasur qadhi. Yasir hasnt understood aqeeda tawheed and aqeeda hifz al Quran.
Dawah man is a wahabi extremist who is aggressive in his approach towards the sinners and non muslims. Dawah man isn't the guy u should follow at all
@@mohammedusmanmufti5311 no he is not aggressive. Yes he made some errors but he is slso going around helping celebrities like Adam Saleh. That is good work to give dawah to people who are vulnerable to major calamities. And this derrogatory term Wahabi shouldnt be used. If you want to link him with M bin abdul Wahab then call him abdul wahabi.
@@osamamanan2723 I guess dawah man isn't that bad after all. It's only sometimes he kinda acts aggressive not all the time. I do like some of his talks though
@Mohammed Usman Mufti so what if he speaks firmly and with passion
Atleast hes not lying about the deen like yasir qadhi al barbadhi
Yasir qadi said islam was only spread by force and swords
I’m worried about the young people to get confused Subxanallah
Salam, same thought here!
assalualaikum, it would be an offer to find my comment and like it, so that the channel can see my comment, no person should be confused because of this.
If they would to follow the position of sheikh Yasir Qadhi, they actually would follow the opinion of the vast majority of all our scholars for at least a thousand years.
wllo kawaani cidaad aragto oo somalida ah
Read Quran & Sunnah and memorize them
May allah guide him. And he is saying it will open door to shirk no no this is definitely shirk no doubt subhanallah. We have the quran and the sunnah of the prophet peace and blessings be upon him.
If you disagree with him so much, isn't it better to call and talk to him first, rather than bash him in the open without attempting to understand where he is coming from? What does that achieve?
Exactly all they do is bash and make him bad in public instead of calling or talking personal. Dont follow such people
Narrated Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman:
The people used to ask Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) about good, but I used to ask him about evil for fear that it might overtake me. Once I said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! We were in ignorance and in evil and Allah has bestowed upon us the present good; will there by any evil after this good?" He said, "Yes." I asked, "Will there be good after that evil?" He said, "Yes, but it would be tained with Dakhan (i.e. Little evil)." I asked, "What will its Dakhan be?" He said, "There will be some people who will lead (people) according to principles other than my tradition. You will see their actions and disapprove of them." I said, "Will there by any evil after that good?" He said, "Yes, there will be some people who will invite others to the doors of Hell, and whoever accepts their invitation to it will be thrown in it (by them)." I said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! Describe those people to us." He said, "They will belong to us and speak our language" I asked, "What do you order me to do if such a thing should take place in my life?" He said, "Adhere to the group of Muslims and their Chief." I asked, "If there is neither a group (of Muslims) nor a chief (what shall I do)?" He said, "Keep away from all those different sects, even if you had to bite (i.e. eat) the root of a tree, till you meet Allah while you are still in that state."
Guidance only comes from ALLAH.
Not from any of you.
LA ILAHA ILALLAH... No god but ALLAH alone.
Leave it to Allah. He knows what is in the hearts of His slaves. Why should we as humans judge other people's beliefs .
How can Allah judge anyone when he never talks to anyone? Has any muslim ever seen any manifestation of Allah? any response to a prayer? any healing? NOPE!!!! That Allah must be dead.
@@nikzahui3477 Who feeds you. Who gives you health when you are sick. Who brings you back to life when you are dead. He is the One who guides you when you are lost. He communicates through His signs. There are signs within you and Outside. Look at them. If you talk and see God where is the question of believing. When you see a building you know that there is a builder who has constructed it. If you ask Him He responds. If walk one step towards Him He takes steps towards you. Read and understand Quran , it is the Word of God. Dont ruin your present life and hereafter. WAKE UP BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE
What does allah now?
@@grantmaree3537 What is your question
@@indianrational6887 BS. You Allah never feeds anyone. He is dead. that's why you have to defend him. Our God Jesus is alive. And he can defend himself. We don't have to. He heals people every day, no matter their religion, because he is a God of Love. Watch this: th-cam.com/video/LWlxnWV2klc/w-d-xo.html
I joined this channel to learn how to teach Ahsanul Qawaid.
Now I'm getting suggestions for videos with extremely shallow, immature salafee social media personalities.
Ahaha you don't know the peak of their ideology leads a person to this: 'I'm a Salafi, and you're not Salafi, and they're not Salafi...'
These people hate their brains so much it's hilarious.
wahabis are very active in social media
@@aburnieab205 Of course, every genius that goes to the University of Madina comes out afterwards thinking they're the Mujaddid of this generation.
@Aaliyah Powell not only grave worshippers, salafees have managed to piss almost everyone off.
@Aaliyah Powell True! That's why I used the term "Salafees"
I'm really scared but, may Allah guide him from misguidance.
allah of Islam is dead...
But Jesus said unto him, Follow me; and let the dead bury their dead .
Matthew 8:22 KJV
@@ivin6415 peace
@@ivin6415 yeah your God may have died on the cross, ours hasn't.
I don't know why everyone pinpoint
Yasir qadi lectures why they don't talk directly with him Shem to all of you part-time Muslim
If you are real Muslim please don't rebuke another Muslim
Gave another lacthure on that topic
@@naseemkad Yeah and in my opinion he just lost so many people who used to watch him and like him
@@furious7754 it doesn't matter
He will be rewarded for forbidding evil
@@naseemkad refuting an evil is an obligation, 💯
@@aatif7518 According to you and him he is forbidding evil, but not everyone else.
@@aatif7518 We never said it isn't brother don't make claims and it sounds like you are.
ASSALAMOUALAIKUM
DR YASSIR QHADI JUST IGNORE THEM TAKE NO NOTICE OF ANY OF THE RUBBISH I HAVE LEARNT A LOT FROM YOU JUST PURE JEALOUSY BE STRONG
MAY ALLAH SWT GUIDE ALL OF US
ALL YEARS ROUND THESE PEOPLE ENJOY PICKING ON SCHOLARS
FAULT MY DUAS WITH AND YOUR FAMILY AND ALL YOUR SUPPORTERS
😂😂😂😂 pray that yasir has this same energy for you on the day of judgement when you’ll be asked about indulging in this misguidance.
Pla heart this
It seems as though for YQ the adulation and respect of the masses is more important to him than the truth itself. He always came across to me as this sort of person even when he was on the correct knowledge in the past. I always kept myself silent on this but it saddens me to see that I was totally right. May Allah guard us from his misguidance.
You was right. If you can correct wrong do so even if it’s as small as thinking it is wrong.
What if he is right and you are wrong. He is leading you from the misguidance
@@theoracleofthenorth2870 how can he be right?? Shirk sounds like being guided out of misguidance? 🤡 make it make sense
I'm also Sad that I was right but Allah knows best I knew he has some flaws that are strong as well as the benefits
Today I have learned how foolish the muslim ummah is. Not from Yasir Qadhi but from All the people on this list.
Ya akhi can you please explain to me how
I am strongly condemn this particular opinion of Yasir Qadhi.
Only this? What about yajuj and majuj are tales and might be zombies?
What about the quran being preserved?
What about our Islamic punishments needing updating?
What about our scriptures saying some problematic and bizarre things?
@@iimiboy all these things are not as serious as the matter shirk
@@mdrasid007 yes of course Akhi but you can see one thing leads to another and qadhi has changed since yale around 10 years or so.
I used to love him very
@@iimiboy ya I love him too, I think he tries to get larger audiences to watch his videos or he may be interested in American politics to get power, so he's getting Liberal day by day to please all sunni, Shia, Jews Christians, Hindus to get their votes
@@mdrasid007 yes exactly which isn't Islam, we are completely different from everyone else, he has belittled even the great sahaba umar radiallahu anhu by saying he will fail the aqeedha test.
Sorry but he's getting worse by the year and according to his definition even the Hindus aren't really committing shirk
He reminds of that Australian guy Who said anal .. is halal 😂
Wasnt this a tajweed channel?
Salaam.
HealMyTajweed will help you improve your relationship with the Quraan, and that includes all the sciences, but I myself as the main person am only qualified to deal with Tajweed at this point in time as I continue my studies. I PERSONALLY will not take questions re Aqeedah or Fiqh or other controversies until I am given the permission if I continue to study those sciences, or deal with them directly. This does not mean that the channel will not tackle these issues at all, like in the form of this compilation above, which has full link references to the original videos. We may also bring qualified people on to discuss these issues in the future. We may also test variations of content related to the Quran and/or Islam generally in the near future, and if you feel this is not for you then you may leave Insha Allah no problem.
I am not on TH-cam to please the public above having to answer to my Creator, and I will do what I need to do if I feel a topic is important enough to cover, like in this case. If you are under the impression that I am here to please you as an individual person, or even the general TH-cam viewer, I am sorry to say this is not the intention nor the objective, and there are plenty of channels which are far superior to this one where you can seek whatever you are looking for.
I will continue to create Tajweed related content Insha Allah, especially coming up for Ramadhan, and still being a one man show without having help even from the regular people visiting the channel, except for a few individuals who have helped in the past either with their time or by donating, (May Allah reward them) I can only do what I am physically able to with limited resources without jeopardising my main source of income work from my Tech work.
Wassalaam!
@@HealMyTajweed I just subcribed, I appreciate that you dont care about what people think of you, mashallah brother keep it up.
@@HealMyTajweed May Allah reward you
Yasir Qadhi should change his last name to Qadhiani.
Putting these small clips together to refute someone by name and to dishonour him because you do not understand and haven't seem whole videos and talks is a massive problem, and it can easily make you hate someone you haven't even heard off..Fear Allah swt and stop this, because you will answer for this..
Finally someone with sense in the comments.
Go tell yasir qadhi al barbadhi to stop changing the deen
Mohammed Hijab has been quite unwise lately with this interview---and with the interview with that guy the dressed like a woman----something wrong----May Allah guide him
Humm this popped up on my screen. Well, I don't all the tension, accusations... here. Mr. QADHI said something, that is right and it is his opinion and understanding. Period. You may agree or disagree that's also your right, opinion and understanding. But i find the response, attitude to that a little over the line. Even the companions of the prophet (pbuh), had differences in opinions over some issues but they didn't point fingers at each other, treat one another of being misguided or having an " agenda" etc. Knowledge without wisdom is vain. All you ( the critics) have to do in this instance is to do your own videos, teachings to explain your view on the matter and why you think the other(s) is/are wrong on the matter. In the end only Allah ALONE knows the truth and only He can judge between you.
I follow videos, teachings, of so and so that doesn't mean i believe in every single of theirs. Come on we are not dummies who just follow blindly. Bring your arguments/ counter-arguments then people will chose their own path. In the end it is Allah who guides, not you nor mr. Qadhi etc..
No matter his " diviance", " secret agenda" or whatever, the truth of the matter is that man had been teaching lot of things and many people have benefinited from it. If you wanna shut him up, be productive, do better than him, bring the good teachings to people in an effective way.
Well said
What utter nonsense
People have benefited because he said don’t smoke
But it ok for him to insult (Umar ra) the wee holes in the Quran, gog Magog is a science fiction
And on and on
Have you watched the video/s
Shirk is not a matter of opinion. He has directly opposed the fundamental teachings of Allah and our Prophet pbuh. If you choose to follow him from this point then you will have no excuse in front of Allah.
This is not the Islamic way to discredit someone without even asking them to clarify their stance
They are speaking in such a clear cut way. What do you mean he didn't clarify? He is clearly speaking of his claims and beliefs.
Make all your ibada / dua and worshipa just to Allah ! that's it ! very easy !
I felt suspicious of Yasir Qadi from another topic but this one on shirk overwhelmed me and distrust him from anything he says. I am Pakistani and Alhamdulilla I was raised with right aqeeda. I find Yasir as hypocrite who is being used using our race face and etc. He looks like my ex-husband who lied about being Muslim, he turned out to be a Sihk religion who live among us in Punjab deceiving Muslims, they dress like us, they talk like us, they learn our religion to misconstrue and play with innocent people.
Shut this guy out please!!
So far no one say anything to disprove him especially " holes" he is speaking about like ubay ibn kab having doubts , all i can see is attack and restless scholars what is wrong??? these scholars have no evidence for their claims against YQ, only here bashing him!!!!!!!!;Is he saying some truth ??? 🙄 May Allah guide all of us
Why don't these EXPERTS do something useful & listen to the Dua's coming from mothers whose child is dying every 10 minutes... 😠
something that helped me stay humble is this ayah. "And whatever of blessings and good things you have, it is from Allâh. Then, when harm touches you, unto Him you cry aloud for help." [16:53]
And that no matter how much knowledge I have, I've gotten it from Allah and then through his righteous servants. For the credit belongs all to them. As for me, I'm simply a follower or forwarder of their works.
reminds me of the saying La hawla wala kuwatta illa billah
This is not the scholarly way of defaming a sincere scholar of Islam like Yasir Qadi, without the context of his talks, Just picking and cutting without context of talk. May Allah guide all the scholars shouting on Yasir Qadi
Akhi if you continue to listen to him he will misguide you
Here is what YQ should do. First of all, define shirk. He did his MA in tawheed, for God's sake, so he should be able to do that. And then provide proof for his opinion. And let people more knowledgeable than him break it down and tell him if it's valid or not.
m.th-cam.com/video/dRtYCJ7bE5I/w-d-xo.html
@@Quantum-1157 whr is the land of tawheed?
Quantum ran.
@abu muhamed i cant do tawassul through the prophet peace and blessings be upon him?
See ayah 3 of Surah Az Zumar. That should answer your question. Why not seek nearness to Allah by asking Allah by His Beautiful Names?
Salamualaikum, what is the reason of the act of invocking if one doesn't believe in that invoking?
Clinging onto the religion of their forefathers even though they were misguided.
And evil scholars who want to demolish the foundation of Islam for the dunya.
I lost courage to listen to Yasir Qadhi the day he belied and belittled Imam Anwar Rahimahullah...
Whoever wage war against the friends of Allah, Allah will humiliate them in this world and the hereafter.
So he speaks the truth and that’s a problem? Don’t Muslims call upon and ask for Muhammad to pray for them, he’s dead. Wouldn’t that be shirk? Genuine question.
Depends on which opinion you favour. If you look to the fundamental teachings of Sunni Islam, then yes it is shirk to call upon anyone, even Muhammed S.A.W.
how can i contact you for future videos in sha allah.
Salaam. Contact details in the description, and you can also Google me easily.
The CONDITIONAL Opinion (syllogism) of Yasir Qadhi CANNOT BE ABSORBED by those who are relying ONLY on CATEGORICAL (absolute) Syllogism.
For as long as Yasir Qadhi is UPHOLDING or ADHERING to the CONDITION that he ESSENTIALLY attached to his OPINION, Yasir Qadhi has NOT COMMITTED SHIRK..
A condition is a requirement and remained as it is.
Very disappointing compilation. Good to see you made a video without actually researching or trying to understand. May Allah guide you and guide me
Don't forget that literally none of these speakers you've compiled, are even close to experts in aqeedah, nor are they even close to Shaykh Yasir in terms of pure knowledge based on credentials and experience. If you're not going to do research yourself, at least quote ulema who are actually learned in these matters.
Lol you literally included Daniel Haqiqatjou basically lying about what Shaykh Yasir said. Shaykh Yasir was speaking about going against the majority, yet Daniel starts arguing as if Shaykh Yasir was talking about going against ijma3. You and I both know that Shaykh Yasir was not talking about going against ijma3 because 1) the majority of ulema are literally in AGREEMENT with Shaykh Yasir's opinion on this matter of shirk and 2) Shaykh Yasir himself said MAJORITY. Not ALL. Honestly, fear Allah when you do this type of backbiting. This kind of video is extremely unIslamic.
@Cheese Cake No point in talking to you in my opinion since you made claims that Yasir Qahdi is his Prophet astaghfurallah and in my opinion he doesn't have difficulty in English comprehension and he doesn't suffer form confusion of the highest order. I honestly believe that to you do have these issues.
@Cheese Cake these kinds of comments just validate my opinions of people like you guys. Entirely ignorant and illogical. Instead of addressing my comments, you chose to write about how you think 'Yasir Qadhi is [my] prophet' wal iyaadu billah. And then you continue with comments about 'difficulty in english comprehension'. lol you didn't even address a single comment I made. Have some ikhlaas and be just. Muslims like you, embarrass the rest of us.
@@hassanabdaladl Shaykh Yasir?
Nice one lol
“If you don’t feel like waking up for fajr, just ask allah for forgiveness and you good bruh”
-probably yasir qadhi
this is slander btw
Wow it’s embarrassing to see our “daii and scholars” being emotional in their response against YQ like this. Right or wrong the response should be ethical. If a scholar refutes with anger towards another the followers may be at war with each other.
We are Muslim make peace not like this if there something wrong about teaching make a correction in a nice way as salamalaikum to all
JazakAllah Khair
Yes, i will listen to SHEIKH YASAR QADHI
You must be a barelwi mushrik
@@saadhasan2300 I'm not barelvi, but musrik can be forgiven by toubah,
What about abdul wahab who killed thousands of Muslims in makkah to spread wahabism
Killer will never be forgiven , so all we wahabi following a murderers belief,
I left wahabi after listening his history, who was just like IsIs killer
I sincerely believe the people of knowledge Should find a way to interact with each other. TH-cam is not the right tool. If People of Knowledge start fighting among each other what will happen to the Ummah. Masha Allah we have learned to take the good and leave the bad.
Scholars started giving fatwa without any proper knowledge.
May Allah bless sh.yasir qadhi
When in the beginning I first started watching him, he's hand gestures worried me.
Thanks for this video...
Same.
OMG wallahi that's what bothered be about him in like 2005 and I later found a lot of other things and tried to listen to the good from him, I couldn't understand why he went to study under Tony Blair while the Crusader was waging a declared Crusade in Iraq and Afghanistan. I still just took the good from him for the beneficial knowledge.
He learnt well from tony blair at yale
@@UmarIbnAlKhattab1😆
First of all, these matters aren't for the average muslim because it's not wajib knowledge; they should just know that it's forbidden and major sin to envoke the dead, that's it.
Secondly, a lot of responses but unfortunately, all are emotional responses, we need a thorough explanation. And it would be fine if it were as it seems to imply, that this position (envoking pious is shirk, not just haram and therfore you are kafir) is the majority view of the ummah currently and historically: turns out it is to the contrary; majority ummah currently and historically are aligned with yasir qadi's view; he has only gone and aligned himself with majority scholars of the ummah of muhammad pbuh. Yasir qadhi has explained it thoroughly in his video: najdi dawah; listen to it and make a critical approach, not emotional. Learn about the history of abdul wahhab and the consequence of holding unorthodox, splinter views and positions.
Most people, even the TH-cam refuters, have not even heard the full video of what YQ has said. It is evident as their responses don't even adequately touch upon what YQ spoke about.
I saw the whole 3.5 hour video follow up which shows he was still wrong.
I have the time stamp notes to prove it, and this is from a person who first listened to Yasir over 10 years ago & did a portions of research with many imams! Many ppl watch the part that is where is his opinion, its clearly incorrect!
how is meat halal? We sacrifice it to Allah alone. Prayer & sacrifice is from acts of worship assigned by Allah & worship for Allah alone is Tawhid Ulluhiyah or Allah's Oneness as God. to expect a response in du'a or blessings of meat from other then Allah is additional shirk in Allah's Rububiyah or Lordship!
Quran 6 : 162 -
*Say (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم): "Verily, my Salat (prayer), my sacrifice, my living, and my dying are for Allah, the Lord of the 'Alamin.* (all that exists). -
It is shirk regardless of intention, Allah may excuse a person due to their ignorance (Qur'an 2 :22) but the act is still shirk! Yasir doesn't know Tawhid, even the pagans accepted Allah as Lord like in surah Fil and at time of hardship they called upon Allah alone, but at other times they called to other then Allah!
Qur'an 31 : 25 - *And if you ask them: "Who has created the heavens and the earth," they will certainly say: "Allah.* " Say: "All the praises and thanks be to Allah!" But most of them know not.
30. - *Allah, He is the Truth, and that which they invoke besides Him is Al-Batil*
32. - And when a wave covers them like shades they invoke Allah, *making their invocations for Him only. But when He brings them safe to land, there are among them those that stop* in between (Belief & disbelief).
Summary, Tawhid has 3 Categories:
1) Lord = Actions of the Creator
*2) God = One served, or acts by creation assigned by & done for the Creator!*
3) (Names & Attributes, not being mentioned here, but letting you know)
Qur'an 6 : 163 - "He has no partner. *And of this I have been commanded,* and I am the first of the Muslims."
The Main Tawhid called to by the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him was Tawhid of Worship!
~~~
Also the Grave life is from the ghaib & can't hear except textual acts like Salams :
Quran 35 :22 - Verily, Allah makes whom He wills to hear, but you cannot make hear those who are in graves. -
Quran 6 : 50 - Say (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم): "I don't tell you that with me are the treasures of Allah, nor (that) I know the Unseen; nor I tell you that I am an angel. *I but follow what is revealed to me."*
Abu Hurayrah narrated that the Messenger of Allah Peace & blessings on him said: “There is no one who sends Salaam upon me, but Allaah will restore to me my soul so that I may return his Salaam.” (Abi Dawood Sahih)
Jundub Ibn ‛Abdullāh (radiyallāhu ‘anhumā) who said: I heard the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) five days before his death saying: “I free myself before Allāh from taking any of you as a special close friend (khaleel) for indeed Allāh has taken me as a khaleel just as he took Ibrāheem as a khaleel. And if I was to take anyone from my Ummah as a khaleel, then surely I would’ve taken Abu Bakr as a khaleel. Indeed those who came before you would take the graves of their Prophets as places of worship (as mosques). Do not take graves as places of worship, for indeed I forbid you from that.”
[Reported by Muslim]
Yasir's teacher Muhammad bin Hadi Madkhali also warned against Yasir before he left Medina... May Allah guide us & him, this isn't the first time he has been dishonest! here's his teacher in Medina :
**"Yasir Qadhi Has A PhD In Calling To The Gates of The Hell Fire!
"**
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
What exactly is, "clearly incorrect"?
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
"Warned against" wow! Are you for real!? Why blind follow an opinion of a man who doesn't even live in the west and who hasn't sat with YQ to discuss matters face to face? Can such a "warning" be valid? Who from the kibar ulema or the ulema from the lajna have warned against YQ? Forget Rabi or Hadi Madkhali, give me from the kibar ulema. These Madkhali scholars have a tiny following in Saudi. I know cus I live here. No one ever refers to the Madkhali scholars in Saudi as we have the kibar and the lajna ulema that we refer to. Only brothers from the west who are cultish in their Salafiya quote the Madkhali scholars over the kibar and lajna scholars.
I wonder for what benefits is yasir qadhi fighting for
$$ worldly fame. Disposable things. YQ is truelly a looser
Money and fame
Troublemakers are hitting back
Dr. Yasir Qadhi do not listen to these accusations . Your follower knows better. You are extremely knowledgeable scholar and you always explain Deen in the best possible way that it can be use for today’s life. May Allah(swt) Grant you Jannah .Ameen
Shaitan was the most knowledgeable as well. Always ask for hidaya not knowledge or ilm
If you ignore all the scholars than you have left the path of Truth
Why am I clearly understanding what Sheikh Yasir Qadhi is saying and still trying to understand he is wrong.
:) Unfortunately this is how world works. Words are interpreted and understood in different levels. I'm not at all a fan of Dr. Yasir but his level of communication is not for the internet I feel.
Because he is a master of misdirection and setting up agenda in his speeches. You need to have some experience in understanding such kind of speech, otherwise it is all rosy.
Bexause your jahil about your deen
He is encouraging people as ignorant is him to think outside the box. Thinking outside the box means explore ideas that are creative and unusual and that are not limited or controlled by rules or tradition. This is innovation, he doesn't know innovation is not permissible?