CHRISTMAS SPECIAL! Vocal Coaches react to PENTATONIX - 'Mary Did You Know'

[@TheFairyVoiceMother]

Always special to film with Holly!💜Also, I HAVE NEW MERCH! 🧚You can check it out at www.thefairyvoicemother.com/shop
If you want to support the channel, you can "Buy Me A Coffee" ☕ www.buymeacoffee.com/TFVM
You can also join our community on Patreon: www.patreon.com/TFVM
Thank you SO MUCH for the incredible support! ✨

[@gesco2275]

New subscriber here. Absolutely enjoyed this reaction. You two together are really entertaining. I would highly suggest that you two react to The Prayer video by this group. Mitch really really shines through in this song. I promise you will not be disappointed at all. I feel that it is their best cover to date. Other songs to react to are Shallow and The Sound of Silence.

[@mjbartholomew5317]

LOL, You need to do many more reactions together. You're a hoot together.

[@weebee5jpf1]

Can't disagree with that in the least! These ladies charmed me to death...witty, talented in their trade, intelligent, spirited and hilarious with amazing sense of humor. What's not to like? And you're both beautiful....inner and outer. I went to get educated a bit about Holly after watching this, and MJ hit it on the head with the suggestion of "more!" PLEASE!! (And two gingers is almost more than I can bear! A personal life-long "thing."

[@brotherdust]

I love the impromptu harmony you had with your friend. You were both like, “OMG it’s so shiny! Let’s try it!”. Then you just locked in. Impressive.

[@michelle32855]

PTX just owns Christmas. This one and their rendition of Silent Night are...well I can't decide which one I like better. Thanks for this reaction!

[@rudewalrus5636]

Their version of Oh Come All Ye Faithful absolutely transforms the song. I defy anyone to listen to it without smiling.

[@jameshays7907]

Welcome Holly! The two of you are outrageously funny together. I would love to see more reactions with the two of you!

[@gripanimal]

Its not about the singer, its about the song. PTX demonstrates this so well with their use of dynamics. They each get their turn in the light, but they work together flawlessly to elevate the song, not themselves. And your reaction is, as always, genuine, instructive, and fun. Having Holly on was a blast! Did she find that word yet? Merry Christmas to you and Holly and Paul!!

[@MichaelB769]

It’s also the singer

[@magi144]

Music teaches us such beautiful lessons.

[@weebee5jpf1]

"Bells and whistles" was what Holly was after....she found it near the end with Lolli's help (I believe).

[@HolyCodzta]

Gimmick was the word she was looking for I reckon!

[@striderdavid]

@@HolyCodzta Came to the comments to say the same thing!

[@ghytredstillghytred7617]

Jeez! When you two sang the line 'Did you know that your baby boy has come to make you new'....that was one of the best, most beautiful, harmonies I have ever heard.

[@kourtneywildman8468]

If she couldn't get over Mitch and his voice in this song, you should have her react to The Prayer! And then add Amazing Grace to that as everyone has a singing part in it!

[@chrishubbard8033]

Check out their version of Little Drummer Boy. Kirsten does a lot of belting in that one as well.

[@keithcollins1318]

You also have to hear Pentatonix do The Prayer and Sound Of Silence and Shollow !!

[@the22ndday]

Mitch, Scott and Kirstin have been friends since high school. You can really tell they know exactly what each other are doing and where they're going with/ in a song. It's unmistakable when you listen to all their music. Even the ones when they are very young.

[@tss9886]

Kristy, Scott and Mitch sung together since high school. Avi and Kevin joined them for the Sing Off an acapella contest, they were only 19 and 20 years old. They won and went on to change acapella forever.

[@andrewmccormack4295]

Kirsty is such a beautiful woman with a voice to match, Loved your reaction to this song, out of all the reactions to MDYK yours is by far the best (IMO). Loved your explanation of where the name Pentatonix came from, I always wondered about that. Keep up the great work Ladies,you two are amazing.

[@rexb2918]

Merry Christmas Lolli and Holly. The two of you are wonderful together. Thanks for the early morning Xmas gift

[@richdiddens4059]

And they've got the whistle part of bells and whistles covered, too. Mitch can hit the "whistle register." I'm not sure if he can sing there but he can hit it. Check out the video on his vocal range.

[@boballen818]

I think a big reason they 'share" the spotlight so well is because the 3 of them (Scott, Kirstie, and Mitch) have sung together since their school days. They grew up together in Texas.

[@sandyleewhite]

I have often been lost for words, when trying to describe Pentatonix's unique vocals & sound, & I still cannot express, or even come to terms, with what my ears are hearing, most times, but one thing I do know, is that, when I hear their voices, it always takes me to a place, that touches my heart, & can make me feel things, I didn't even know existed!!! To me, that is their gift, & what makes them, not only an amazing group, but incredible artists 💝 **THEY TRULY ARE A RARE GIFT** 💝

[@talyn5304]

Wow!
I really loved this reaction/analysis. The two of you were creating your own bit of contrast and dynamics and it was really a joy to behold! More, please!! =)

[@carolgillies5699]

Now I need to see Holly react to Hallelujah for a full-on Mitch Slap

[@donkrom3599]

I am addicted to PTX and reactions too them. I was stopped in my tracks by the naturalness you both share. Please do more. Start a PTX series. Next should be Halleluiah. It was fun having the guy pop in with his off screen comments. Nothing scripted. Truly refreshing. Thank you

[@CJ_536]

She did Hallelujah by PTX already.

[@hawkthorn33]

What a gift, fitting for the day.
These lovely people know how to get out of each other's way. Allow each to shine and not have to be the center of it all.
The fact this song (for them) is now years old, and the ability to see the improvement in a recent release it stunning as well. (The Prayer, or Amazing grace for reference)

[@keithcollins1318]

Pretty Lady you still have to hear My Heart With You !! It's amazing !!

[@greattheillusion]

A version of this song I think you will adore. Voctave featuring the original writer of the song Mark Lowry. I love the pentatonix version but there is something very special about the original writer singing it. And for being 62 or so during the recording he holds a note for an insane amount of time, while sitting. You don't need to react to it but please do listen to it on your own time. Take care.

[@jackpearson1110]

an opportunity lost. Not that there's anything wrong with this version.

[@greattheillusion]

@@jackpearson1110 I would definitely agree that there is nothing wrong with this one. I do truly feel the voctave version is the Supreme version. And I've told a lot of people about it. Take care

[@LonesomeTwin]

The definitive Voctave version seems to be almost universally ignored in favour of PTX. Would love to know why that is exactly. Anyone who's heard knows that FVM would be utterly blown away by it, as we've all been.

[@greattheillusion]

@Lonesome Twin it may just be a case of Pentatonix being more well known. They were in a TV show, and Voctave wasn't kind of a thing. I do feel sorry for people who haven't heard the voctave version yet, and I hope that they do some day. It just makes it really special having Mark Lowry there and that note he holds is so impressive.

[@CarlD70]

That was a boat load of fun ladies.... You need to do more of these together for sure. Love PTX and love your videos as well. Merry Christmas and have a great New Year.

[@edreppert3091]

I just a few minutes ago commented on another of your reactions that I would like to hear your reaction to this and here it is! Thank you!

[@annicajakobsson]

Would love to hear you analyze Avi Kaplan’s Change on the rise, it’s so layered at the same time as it’s very minimalistic and it’s just wonderful!

[@jasonzvonkin5464]

Grebenchen on th vocal

[@brandonlongmire3020]

I've always loved this group. Their ability to just literally bring the music alive is unbelievable... you've probably heard about this already but if you haven't seen how Pentatonix got their big break/start, check out an old American television show called "The Sing Off." They were on season 3 and unfortunately that was the last season but its incredible seeing all of the acapella groups perform and compete. I highly recommend checking the show out!

[@elizabethsantersero9597]

Wow, yes, I second the suggestion that you two go through the Sing Off performances. You have great synergy together ❤ and you will find some interesting lessons to comment on about doing covers, how to work as a group, and how to grow and learn as a performer/singer/arranger. The judges on the series were the best set I've seen on a competition show, and I still see PTX applying the lessons learned there in their music today. Plus you are a hoot together, lol.

[@ellesadil5372]

Carol of The Bells and The Prayer by PTX are both very good as well and i love them.

[@alfredh3071]

Happy Holly-Lolli-days!
You two lovely people work together brilliantly!
This song has been one of my favorites for a long time, so I’m very picky about how it’s interpreted. PTX has taken this song even beyond any version ever recorded imo. The depth, the layered harmonies, my goodness! Just glorious

[@richardrobertson1886]

My favorite Christmas song and the only version I listen to.

[@guillermomunoz4287]

"They could do so much more... there is no ego". How true that they all make their own singular performance subservient to the group and the song, and in this way, they serve themselves best. They put their individuality in service to the group, and in doing so they become some of the most respected/honored individuals in the music business. Selflessness does pay off.

[@NotYourMomma]

Really enjoyed this, especially seeing your anticipation of her reaction, essentially, we are all doing that as we watch you react to these, now we are grinning together in anticipation. almost a visceral thrill of enjoyment as someone experiences Pentatonix for the first time. It really is a hoot!
Now you should watch them do "The Prayer" or their grammy winning "Daft Punk"!

[@tbexecutioner5392]

You both are beautiful human beings

[@DougHanson2769]

Expertly Conveyed. Love this podcast.
Please explain the Suspended Chords: Changing from the regular to suspended - * inverting the root of the chords
* diminishing or augmenting
Etc….
Prior to the ending cadence(s)
Etc.

[@davidquenneville7611]

Brilliant ladies. Lookin forward to more of your collaborations. Cheers.

[@scottdaniello9908]

I would love to see you react to The Prayer. It is by far in my opinion, one of their best!

[@keithmarshall3371]

I absolutely loved it when you sang together, you both have amazing voices , and are so knowledgeable.

[@allenjones7722]

Rewatched this and it's funny as hell when Lolli is punking Paul and Holly!

[@keithjohnson3199]

You two are great together! Please do a reaction to Pentatonix version of The Prayer! You’ll be gobsmacked!

[@elizabethtucker6026]

Seconded.

[@brentpoulsen6376]

Trippled

[@tamatirangiuaia140]

Need some more ptx reactions please with good headphones on.
Best ptx reactor yet, just need more

[@allendesalme197]

Girl, you need to move next to O Come All Ye Faithful by Pentatonix - guarantee it will be the most fun you have had all year!!! Incredible!!!

[@edwardsadler3348]

The pair of you are funny and so talented... almost forgot I was watching and listening to the fabulous Pentatonix

[@frankskye5584]

What a fantastic Holiday Gift! Thank you Lolli and Holly! What I have enjoyed the most about Pentatonix is their harmonies first, but their respect for the song/music is wonderful. They continually make the arrangements their own while showing respect for the music. I can't wait for the next duo reaction!

[@Coach_B23]

No gimmicks? 🤔 loved this reaction. And the knowledge being shared. Loved this.

[@jeancaldwell5391]

You two gave such a great reaction! I love when a knowledgeable reactor informs me about technicalities I’ve missed. That elevates your reaction above someone listening to the song even when they appreciate and enjoy it. As you may know, Avi left Pentatonix in 2017 and now has his own solo career. He has just completed a tour, and someone was kind enough to post him singing O Holy Night. It’s definitely worth checking out.

[@abeldiaz3877]

I had a bloody amazing morning waking up to this! Merry Christmas to the three of you. Paul's intromissions were absolutely hilarious 😂.

[@annboyce1090]

Delicious Xmas present…thank you. Wishing you a very merry Xmas

[@johngordon7510]

Merry Christmas, loved the double reaction. It's always great to see a newbie hear Pentatonix the first time.

[@garrywood5015]

You amaze me every time! You found another woman much like yourself to delight us with your collective chemistry and musical knowledge! I think PTX did an amazing job of this special song, certainly my favourite rendition of it, and you made it more special with your obvious enjoyment, both of Pentatonix ' performance and your introduction of Holly to the group! And of course the technical analysis from both of you. I always learn new things about music from your reactions!🤩

[@heinleinreader]

There's a group called Chapel Hart that made their big break on America's Got Talent. They did it with an original song of their own called You Can Have Him Jolene. Yes it is a follow-up to Dolly Parton's Jolene. That appearance on AGT was special, and my suggestion would be for you to react to that performance rather than the separate version without the judges there. The judges add some depth and color to the clip.

[@par500dragon7]

Hi... Merry Christmas! For a sublime experience, check out this song as done by the aca group Voctave, featuring Mark Lowry (the one who wrote the lyrics). This version, and the one done by Home Free, are just beautiful. But nobody sings this song like Mark, and Voctave as BV's take it to whole other level. It's the most 'real' and moving version I've ever heard or seen.

[@Kimmerkel-k]

Thank you ladies! You were such fun to watch! And what a great PTX song to do!

[@vickiroman189]

The way they build with such relentless drive and beauty - stunning.

[@DougHanson2769]

Yes. Stunning indeed

[@brockjansen1617]

I am unreasonably amused at your joint giggle/curse fest. Please do more.

[@pancentricism]

You must listen to their version of The Sugar Plum Fairy.

[@tombaastad9829]

You should really react to their version of the Prayer

[@LonKat]

I would love to hear you both react to pentatonix Sound of silence.

[@user-de4il2zx4f]

This is the first time I’ve seen you two reacting to a video, this video particularly as I’ve watched many others react to the same. You both are so sweet and your reaction was and is great to watch! Looking forward to hearing more from you guys, stay safe and healthy

[@gingersnap22]

Have you two ever seen the recording of Evergreen. It's a short documentary of Pentatonix in the studio. They're amazing.

[@BrilligandtheSlithyToves]

I strongly recommend (even if you don't react to them on camera), watching their journey on The Sing Off. It's neat to see their evolution, and maturation as it happens. Love y'all.

[@hbarfarkle]

Excellent duet by you two

[@Tournesol1982]

Holly: "There's no bells and whistles!"
Holly a minute or less later: "you know those bells that they ring *imitates bells perfectly* that's what this sounds like!"
You guys are the perfect mix of fascinatingly informative and hilarious ❤️

[@joeb4142]

What a beautiful Christmas present! 🎁 Thank you Lolli and Holly and I hope you have a wonderful evening. Merry Christmas! 🎄🧑🏻‍🎄💝🥳🫶🏻👯‍♀️🌛

[@pc1chas]

Would still like to hear you react to their "carol of the bells". You will totally enjoy it!

[@danpitzel5900]

Miss Lollie I had to take the time to thank you for responding to this magical piece. I was one of those who had requested it. Thank you for bringing in your friend she has a lovely voice as well. God bless you both in 23.

[@Guy8417]

since u mentioned bells, you should hear their vrrsion of Carol of the Bells. Also, for tge most interesting and AWESOME take on Oh Come All Ye Fathfull, their version almost sounds....African Tribal. It is STUNNING and will have you on your feet dancing!

[@user-sd7hb4ub4y]

Please do another Christmas special with this year. I so enjoyed last one sooo much😅🎉😂❤

[@letitiaathanasiu1979]

Ohhh, bells.. Would love to see you reacting to Carol of the Bells or Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy! (both from Pentatonix)

[@larryross9492]

I love your giggly delight.

[@remiavard7709]

Thank you tu explain why I just love Pentatonix, I didn't know why but just appreciated. With all your comment I understand better now, Thank again.

[@davidphillips4476]

love Dr. Who LOL!!! Great tie in. That was FANTASTIC review and reaction.

[@jenniferwendt3193]

Great reaction! You should really check out their rendition of Lennon's Imagine, it's one of their best IMO.

[@ptxlvr7150]

This was so fun, you two work so good together, and Paul is adorable. Since Holly likes Mitch so much the two of you need to listen to Scott (Tall baritone), and Mitch (beautiful voice), have a side channel (they've haven't been able to maintain it recently), but the do a song from the Broadway play, Wicked, name of the song is Defying Gravity. I call the play The Wizard of Ox part 3. THe song is about Elphaba the witch learning to actually fly on a broom, the first with ever to do that. Mitch is Elphaba. They are halfway in costume. They are doing this as a comedy, but you wee how serious they are about their singing, no matter how big a joke it is, they still sing perfectly. That song and the PTX upgrade of The Prayer by Celine Dion, and Adrea Bouchilli, both really show off just what Mitch is capable of. I want to see you both do these.

[@kajlennartsson4234]

Merry Christmas the gorgeus fairy Voice Mother and the lovely and the gorgeus Holly. 🎄🎁❤🎶❤

[@igman3878]

Have always loved your reactions, thank you so much, but as someone else said wish you could find the time for more PTX. Popspring 2016 is a live concert with a number oof originals and even more. Merry Xmas!!

[@ihateallandme]

I am a HUGE Doctor Who fan. I am very familiar with that Ood scene. And I am familiar with this particular Pentatonix song. Now I will keep thinking of the Ood whenever I watch this. It is funny, but spoilt it just a bit. But I still enjoy your reactions, and I really enjoyed your explanations of the songs, the notes, the techniques, to the regular layperson. Thank you. This was fun. I hope you do more Pentatonix, maybe "Sounds of Silence", or "Bohemian Rhapsody".

[@dpluethj]

Thanks for the Christmas video! Would love to see you react to PTX Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairies. Keep up the great work!

[@stevebondy7924]

Thanks for this delightful Christmas treat! Supremely entertaining as always. And you two make a great reacting duo. Merry Christmas!

[@ronprichard6145]

I've been waiting for your reaction to "Two country singers try singing opera'" since the day it appeared. Please do that one it'll make my year.

[@kayecastleman6353]

Your reactions are always so much fun and packed with solid information. Thanks for another wonderful breakdown of a Pentatonix classic. Merry Christmas to you and Holly from Canada.

[@tome2294]

I hope you will be reacting to PTX " The Prayer". Would really love it if you would. Thanks!

[@theaogrady4042]

When Lolli cracks up during the song, I know It's from pure delight. PTX always does that to me too! Loved your reaction, you two.

[@tamatirangiuaia140]

Please please please bring us pentaholics more pentatonix reaction.
Bohemian rhapsody is amazing too

[@gailseatonhumbert]

That was a fun reaction on both sides I think 🙂
This was an amazing group going from countertenor to an actual basso profundo.
There was another popular countertenor in the USA at the time who led the way for Mitch, Chris Colfer in the television series Glee was a major inspiration.
The primary arrangers at this time were usually Ben Bram, Scott Hoying (the baritone), Avi Kaplan (the bass) and Kevin Olusola (the beatboxer).
Avi left Pentatonix and had a spot of bad luck getting started on his own as a singer-songwriter because of the pandemic (travel was shutdown literally the day after his big launch by his new label).
He has been through a couple of phases in his solo career but he is generally folk rock.
His band harmonizes with him as well as playing instruments.
Do give him a try sometime. Most reactors start with Change On the Rise. A fun one is When I'm a Fool (try the version recorded at Sunset Sound Studios) that and All is Well ft Joy Williams should give you a good view of his range and direction.

[@richmckinney7231]

OH! MERRY CHRISTMAS !!!

[@johncspine2787]

I said this in another comment, but, I played horn professionally, I loved when a conductor would ask me to play a solo louder, I’d always, always ask “I’m sorry, what dynamic do you have for me there?” And they’d say mf or whatever and say “yes, I know, but, could you please bring it up a little?” And I’d of course always say “sure!”..and then play microscopically softer to bring everyone into what I was doing..it worked every time..lol..if you start competing and playing louder to draw ppl in, you actually repel them instead…I always thought the more intensely beautiful magic happened when many ppl onstage played so softly and beautifully together..

[@TheToscanaMan]

"Bloody Hell" well that sums it up for me too. Lovely reaction. Thank you. 🎄❤☮🙏

[@Nunyabizness_]

They really work the dynamics! That really makes a song!

[@AnthonyRodriguez-zm4rc]

You so enjoyed Nothing Else Matters by Voice Play doing a Metallica cover. You and Holly have to do a joint collaboration on this because it sounds like it should be a load of fun for you, Holly, and your subs!

[@xboxbml]

Yay!! You did it! Watching…

[@BrilligandtheSlithyToves]

Holly, your baratone is INCREDIBLE. Singing Avi's part of the two part harmony from the beginning was SOOOOO smooth and resonant, and beautifully mimicked Avi's own performance. ❤ love it!!!!

[@markmclendon8621]

Voctive sings this song with the composer.....unmatched

[@kaminator4463]

just found your channel would love to hear you react to their performance aha live in singapure you can hear the low and high notes it sounds unbelivable.

[@JoseRodriguez-uf2pt]

I'm going to need a membership roster for the Cult of Ginger Vocal Coaches. For research purposes of course lol. Love your reactions and your team ups with Julia as well

[@JustGrowingUp84]

Hmm, I *am* subscribed to several ginger vocal coaches, so for me "the club" is absolutely a real thing!

[@fred5784]

You have to listen to “O Come All Ye Faithful” by PTX.

[@oluwatobiogundele218]

Idk how I stumbled on this channel but I’m loving it and I’m here to stay 😂

[@BrilligandtheSlithyToves]

Love love love you both. Merry holidays and jovial new year.💜❤️💕❣️... And I think the word she was looking for was "gimmicks" (there were no gimmicks used in their arrangement)

[@johncspine2787]

Their control, and “gentle” way of keeping, or sustaining with zero forcing the dynamic they’re on allows them to increase or decrease at will..and the duet between Avi and Scott, wow..their voices are synergy personified..and the balances aren’t just constant, the subtle in and out of bringing things up and down goes nigh unnoticed by most..

[@paulm8908]

god bless your beautiful souls. keep this up, and continue to get the word out! JESUS is lord, and God is the great I AM!