That rainbow rose is GORGEOUS!! 🌹🌈 I like the Sharpies better because the hard nib of the Posca is always chewing up my paper, and it often floods on me. I was able to achieve a brush effect with the soft foam of the bullet nib! 🤗😍
I knew there was a new sharpie but I forgot what it was. But everytime I see a Sharpie display I've been checking for something new. It's paint markers. Now I know what I'm looking for 😅 Maybe they're not in Canada yet? 🇨🇦
I just learned something new. I did not know I could watercolor with these acrylic markers. Liked! Subscribed! Your flower turned out great. I think I like how the Sharpie blended more.
I just recently got the Sharpies and I'm in love. The brush pens are my fave because I can get the finer details. Your cats are so cute! Anakit always has to help me crafting too. Tory used to steal my stuff and hide it under the area rug. She'd pick up the edge with her paw and slide stuff under there. Your rainbow rose is beautiful.
You can bake glassware decorated with paint pens in the oven. It makes it permanent. I don't put my mouth on the design but I did a T-rex "Hold on to your butts!" mug 2 years ago. It's black Posca outline on a white mug. It's still looking 95% the way I drew it after daily use. I don't recall time/temps but a quick search will fill you in.
I love my new Sharpie paint pens/markers. I got them the moment I saw them in the store and they need more colors. 8:25 I still have my owl painting I did from your tutorial on my wall ❤️ 14:32 the Sharpies have a bolder color than Posca. I like both for their uses. I use Pintar paint markers for cost vs Posca. Sharpie paint pens has my heart right now. I used Sharpie to paint on bells, then sealed them with a waterproof mod podge.
Have you posted any art you've made with them?! I really hope they expand the collection with more colors! A pastel set would be amazing 🤩 I think you showed me the owl painting before!! 😊
the sharpies look amazing, but i do wonder if the poscas would do better after being shaken up a lot? if the sharpies were brand new and the poscas were sitting for a while, maybe that could make a difference? I feel like my poscas need shaking to get full opacity if i haven't shaken them in a while. which could be a downside all in itself, but it would be an interesting comparison
This is super interesting. Thank you for the analysis. I’ve spent a couple years trying to show people that Posca isn’t going to stay the industry standard if their quality keeps dropping. I didn’t think it would be Sharpie of all brands to throw its hat into the ring.
I got some poscas recently and the quality is definitely different. I even tested them against my older ones and old ones with used nibs performed better than the brand new ones.
7:05 Your Posca pens look like they sat for a while without being used and need to be shaken well. When the paint is properly mixed they will be just as vibrant on black paper.
Yes exactly, this vid tbh I feel is kinda not fair because I don’t think they used the right paper for posca, also I feel they don’t shake it well enough
I'm using both Sharpie and Posca pens on rocks. I started with Sharpie markers and then found out they faded quickly, so went to paint pens (Posca and other brands). Later I was delighted to find the new Sharpie range of paint pens, and love how they are easy and quick to use (no shaking and priming). I am interested to know which out of Sharpie and Posca lasts longer on the stones?
I totally was expecting a match stick painting. The flower is very pretty though. They need more colours to be fully competitive. I wonder if they will add more.
The rainbow rose is beautiful! I've never seen anyone use a paint pen with a water brush like that. I want to try it! Oh and congrats on the sponsorship! YAY!
YOUR CAT IS CALLED MUSE. I LOVE IT. I also just recently purchased these pens (had to go on eBay because apparently the 12 pack of brush tips aren't available on UK Amazon???) so this video was super helpful, thanks!
Hullo Sarah, I have been looking for a better paint pen than Posca! It is just not good on papers and I have had real troubles with brick! I believe the brush nib on the Sharpie is just more difficult if you are used to a real brush in your painting practice. I really like that you tried the Sharpie's on so many surfaces! I did guess the top popcicle stick too! I have been trying out the Karin brush markers the DECO and BrushPro versions. The tips are quite soft and they are the best so far, for paper! Your rose is lovely and you should try a background or fill it in with some greenery. See ya real soon!
I’m in the middle of reading my book and all of a sudden I thought about you haha. Last time I watched a video of yours was maybe 10 years ago?! I really thought you stopped posting haha. This brings back so many good memories🥰
The Sharpie paint pens are the first paint pens I've used! And I'm liking it! The black is SO black, you can see the difference on a black cardstock! I wish that the makers at Sharpie would include more colors into the paint pens, because I doubt you can mix them for different shades and colors. It also helps that not ONLY did they come in two different nibs (Bullet and brush), but the price is affordable as well! Again, my only wish is that the Sharpie paint pens had more colors in future separate sets, because it worked with the Sharpie markers.
How long does it take for the sharpie painted rocks to dry? I teach senior citizen craft classes and I’ll be doing rock painting. I was going to use regular acrylic paints, but this may be easier for their hands. If you need to add a layer of a different color, like in your strawberry with the white dots on the red, how long did it take for the red to dry? This was so interesting ❤❤
Also, sharpies been made paint markers before they had to brush tip and bullet tip. They had the press down markers, shake, and press down markers like Pasca they still sell them.
I have the bullet nib ones and my biggest complaint is that I wish they were skinnier for tinier areas. Kind of glad I didn't get the brush tip ones if the paint isn't as pigmented. I also don't care for Posca pens that much. I'm not a huge fan of how matte the paint is, and on certain surfaces like resin, the black just looks more like a charcoal color, plus it can scrape off easily.
I was wondering about how the Sharpies smelled. I remember using Sharpies for work to do redactions and always had a hard time with the strong chemical fumes.
Oh wow! I feel validated. I know everyone loves Posca but I personally find them bleeding a lot and destroying my paper. Could totally be user error but I think the sharpies might just solve all my problems.
Cool. Thank you for doing this video. 😃👍🏼 Based on this video only (because I don't have either of them to try for myself)... I think I prefer the Sharpies. *LOL!* Phoenix and Muse are super adorable. 🥰😺🐱 Oh wow! your rose is beautiful 🌈
You didn’t discuss cost. Can the Sharpie marker be refilled? If not you’re throwing away a lot of plastic. They may still be worth it but that is a decision for each person to make.
@@BunnyDoesArtThingsYes they can. Google it. They aren’t designed to, but they can easily be refilled. Posca Doesn’t sell any official refillable ink, but you can use any water-based paint and they work amazing. The brand Montana makes a good refillable Ink. And there are a lot of refillable paint markers on the market. It’s nice because it gives you the ability to use colors you may not be able to find elsewhere.
Sharpie is much more affordable! Especially when it comes to the brush version. I don't have any Posca brush markers at the moment, but they are between $6-10 individually or nearly $50 for a set of 10. Both types of Sharpie Creative Markers are around $20 for a pack of 12. I should have included that info in the video. However, this way the viewer can form an opinion before looking up the prices.
The paint is different in these paint pens. Posca are acrylics and Sharpie are oil based paint, I think that is a big reason they react and perform differently which makes it hard to truly compare.
Pretty sure they have had em for a while. I know ive seen em sold individually for a few years in Michaels at my store. Looking it up theyve been out since 2006. Not very new
That rainbow rose is GORGEOUS!! 🌹🌈 I like the Sharpies better because the hard nib of the Posca is always chewing up my paper, and it often floods on me. I was able to achieve a brush effect with the soft foam of the bullet nib! 🤗😍
Thank you!! 😊 Oh the Posca ink explosion! haha I've experienced many of those.
@@SoCraftastic You're so welcome!! 🤗😍 I'm sure you have!! 🥰 They can be a creation making changing experience!! 🤣
Ahhh I saw these the other day and wondered if they were any good!! Your rose is gorgeous 😍
Omg hiiiiiii
I was pleasantly surprised with them!! And, thank you 😊
I knew there was a new sharpie but I forgot what it was. But everytime I see a Sharpie display I've been checking for something new. It's paint markers. Now I know what I'm looking for 😅 Maybe they're not in Canada yet? 🇨🇦
Love how you tried them on so many different items! Most reviews I’ve seen just choose one or two types of paper and call it good.
I just learned something new. I did not know I could watercolor with these acrylic markers. Liked! Subscribed! Your flower turned out great. I think I like how the Sharpie blended more.
Sarah Lynn your videos always make me feel better, you have such a positive energy and light. Thank you ❤
Obsessed with that rainbow rose drawing - definitely need that as a sticker! 💜🌹
I loved that you tested then in so many different surfaces!!! ❤
I love my sharpie oil based paint markers. I used them a lot for my wedding
I just recently got the Sharpies and I'm in love. The brush pens are my fave because I can get the finer details. Your cats are so cute! Anakit always has to help me crafting too. Tory used to steal my stuff and hide it under the area rug. She'd pick up the edge with her paw and slide stuff under there. Your rainbow rose is beautiful.
Oooooo!! Thanks for this! I would have never thought Posca could be dethroned. Especially by sharpie!! Gonna throw both sharpie sets in my cart now!!!
I'm glad you enjoyed! Can't wait to see what you create with them!
@@SoCraftasticHow do you see what people “create with them” on TH-cam?
You can bake glassware decorated with paint pens in the oven. It makes it permanent. I don't put my mouth on the design but I did a T-rex "Hold on to your butts!" mug 2 years ago. It's black Posca outline on a white mug. It's still looking 95% the way I drew it after daily use. I don't recall time/temps but a quick search will fill you in.
Throwback to the polymer clay owl!! Omg you just unlocked a memory, I started doing polymer clay because of you!! My favorite one was the fox🥰
Lovely to see you’re properly back on here!! You’re doing great ❤❤
These Sharpie paint markers are very good. They just need more colors. I hope they come soon. Very good work. Very good video.
I love my new Sharpie paint pens/markers. I got them the moment I saw them in the store and they need more colors. 8:25 I still have my owl painting I did from your tutorial on my wall ❤️ 14:32 the Sharpies have a bolder color than Posca. I like both for their uses. I use Pintar paint markers for cost vs Posca. Sharpie paint pens has my heart right now. I used Sharpie to paint on bells, then sealed them with a waterproof mod podge.
Have you posted any art you've made with them?! I really hope they expand the collection with more colors! A pastel set would be amazing 🤩 I think you showed me the owl painting before!! 😊
@@SoCraftastic I’ll have to now. ❤️
the sharpies look amazing, but i do wonder if the poscas would do better after being shaken up a lot? if the sharpies were brand new and the poscas were sitting for a while, maybe that could make a difference? I feel like my poscas need shaking to get full opacity if i haven't shaken them in a while. which could be a downside all in itself, but it would be an interesting comparison
Awesome! I appreciate you taking the time to review and compare. I had never seen the water marker/brush so that’s definitely a new game changer
I loved that you tested them in so many different surfaces!!! ❤
This is super interesting. Thank you for the analysis. I’ve spent a couple years trying to show people that Posca isn’t going to stay the industry standard if their quality keeps dropping. I didn’t think it would be Sharpie of all brands to throw its hat into the ring.
I got some poscas recently and the quality is definitely different. I even tested them against my older ones and old ones with used nibs performed better than the brand new ones.
Wow always so blown away with your colorful roses ! Your cats are so funny and cute
Thank you so much! They brighten all my days
Wow I'm surprised at how well the Sharpie did on the wooden popsicle stick!
I love you cabinet behind you in the intro, it looks so appealing and organized! Love your videos!!
Thank you! It's a DreamBox. I'm glad you enjoy my videos!!
7:05 Your Posca pens look like they sat for a while without being used and need to be shaken well. When the paint is properly mixed they will be just as vibrant on black paper.
Yes exactly, this vid tbh I feel is kinda not fair because I don’t think they used the right paper for posca, also I feel they don’t shake it well enough
I'm using both Sharpie and Posca pens on rocks. I started with Sharpie markers and then found out they faded quickly, so went to paint pens (Posca and other brands). Later I was delighted to find the new Sharpie range of paint pens, and love how they are easy and quick to use (no shaking and priming). I am interested to know which out of Sharpie and Posca lasts longer on the stones?
I totally was expecting a match stick painting. The flower is very pretty though. They need more colours to be fully competitive. I wonder if they will add more.
The rainbow rose is beautiful! I've never seen anyone use a paint pen with a water brush like that. I want to try it!
Oh and congrats on the sponsorship! YAY!
I'm glad a huge Sharpie fan and will always support them. I was at one point gonna buy Posca, glad I didnt buy the Posca. 😊
Posca is better
@@alemma_studios That’s what Inwas wondering. Would you mind giving your opinion? I bought Poscas, but they are still in the wrapper.
Posca is better (Might be coping)
Phoenix is soooo adorable!and mews too!
YOUR CAT IS CALLED MUSE. I LOVE IT. I also just recently purchased these pens (had to go on eBay because apparently the 12 pack of brush tips aren't available on UK Amazon???) so this video was super helpful, thanks!
Hullo Sarah, I have been looking for a better paint pen than Posca! It is just not good on papers and I have had real troubles with brick! I believe the brush nib on the Sharpie is just more difficult if you are used to a real brush in your painting practice. I really like that you tried the Sharpie's on so many surfaces! I did guess the top popcicle stick too! I have been trying out the Karin brush markers the DECO and BrushPro versions. The tips are quite soft and they are the best so far, for paper! Your rose is lovely and you should try a background or fill it in with some greenery. See ya real soon!
Loved seeing the cats. 😺😺After seeing all the tests, especially on the black paper, I'd go with the Sharpies.
I’m in the middle of reading my book and all of a sudden I thought about you haha. Last time I watched a video of yours was maybe 10 years ago?! I really thought you stopped posting haha. This brings back so many good memories🥰
Hii i love your videos so much! I’m so glad you started posting again
Hi! Thank you so much!! I'm happy to be posting here again
@@SoCraftastic AHH OMG THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR REPLYING!!! I’ve been watching your videos for years now, you’re one of my favorite TH-camrs
@@God_Loves_You_13 I'm so glad you stuck around!! More videos will be coming soon
Great video! My watch intentions weren’t for anything art related, but this video caught my eye and I’m glad I watched. New subscriber alert! ♥️♥️
Interesting. I’ve never loved posca, I found that they globbed paint, and tore up paper. I’m excited to try the Sharpie.
Where did you get the art cabinets in the back❤
Excellent thorough review 👌
i've been looking for paint pens for rocks and the sharpies look amazing across the board!
I love this video
I like how you used the water brushes to paint from the marker colours. That didn’t occurs to me and I’ll give it a try.
Wow interesting!! Think I’m going to have to put these on my wish list!
The Sharpie paint pens are the first paint pens I've used! And I'm liking it! The black is SO black, you can see the difference on a black cardstock! I wish that the makers at Sharpie would include more colors into the paint pens, because I doubt you can mix them for different shades and colors.
It also helps that not ONLY did they come in two different nibs (Bullet and brush), but the price is affordable as well!
Again, my only wish is that the Sharpie paint pens had more colors in future separate sets, because it worked with the Sharpie markers.
Great comparison, silly questioon - where do I pick up that blending brush pen thingy?
10:29 Phoenix really said NOM! 😂😂😂
How long does it take for the sharpie painted rocks to dry? I teach senior citizen craft classes and I’ll be doing rock painting. I was going to use regular acrylic paints, but this may be easier for their hands. If you need to add a layer of a different color, like in your strawberry with the white dots on the red, how long did it take for the red to dry? This was so interesting ❤❤
Also, sharpies been made paint markers before they had to brush tip and bullet tip. They had the press down markers, shake, and press down markers like Pasca they still sell them.
Could you provide a summary of what worked better and worse on different produce like wood, canvas etc
What type of “marker” did you paint the rose with off the markers? Is that a water pen?
I have the bullet nib ones and my biggest complaint is that I wish they were skinnier for tinier areas. Kind of glad I didn't get the brush tip ones if the paint isn't as pigmented. I also don't care for Posca pens that much. I'm not a huge fan of how matte the paint is, and on certain surfaces like resin, the black just looks more like a charcoal color, plus it can scrape off easily.
Can we use linseed oil inside brush pen instead of water and use oil paints? Comment please
I was wondering about how the Sharpies smelled. I remember using Sharpies for work to do redactions and always had a hard time with the strong chemical fumes.
Do they work on silacine molds
Oh wow! I feel validated. I know everyone loves Posca but I personally find them bleeding a lot and destroying my paper. Could totally be user error but I think the sharpies might just solve all my problems.
Ive been watching you since you did co-op videos with lardiy and co. Good to see how well you transitioned from the teen years.
Cool. Thank you for doing this video. 😃👍🏼 Based on this video only (because I don't have either of them to try for myself)... I think I prefer the Sharpies.
*LOL!* Phoenix and Muse are super adorable. 🥰😺🐱
Oh wow! your rose is beautiful 🌈
Your cats are such good friends!!!
Gotta tell you something brush tips are for coloring in and fine tip is to make the outline hope I helped u
For the last drawing, I couldn't see a difference in the colors. Pretty, pretty rose
"AFTER Phoenix decides to move..."😂 🐾😹
Stoked ❤🎉
Came for the art, stayed for your ginger painting supervisor!
Very, very interesting. I didn't realize that Sharpie made a paint pen.
Can you tell me how you draw it 🎉😊
We do love the - Shaky Shake, and Pressy Press! lol
For the rose the posca side looks more glossy, while the sharpie side looks more aesthetic-y
You didn’t discuss cost. Can the Sharpie marker be refilled? If not you’re throwing away a lot of plastic. They may still be worth it but that is a decision for each person to make.
Poscas cant be refilled either. Im not sure any paint marker brand has that as an ability
@@BunnyDoesArtThingsYes they can. Google it. They aren’t designed to, but they can easily be refilled. Posca Doesn’t sell any official refillable ink, but you can use any water-based paint and they work amazing. The brand Montana makes a good refillable Ink. And there are a lot of refillable paint markers on the market. It’s nice because it gives you the ability to use colors you may not be able to find elsewhere.
@@BunnyDoesArtThings yes you can refill posca pens you unscrew the top there few videos on yet about it
I have the brush sharpies they are a but different bc they have brush on one side and a fine tip on the other
The ad before the video was for the sharpie paint pens lol
This is totally a paid promotion
I feel like that flakiness was coming off of the nib, or it was in the paint.
I can’t tell the difference between that rose. It is so pretty.
I saw these at Michael’s last week! Almost bought some but I had just gotten posts so I didn’t 😅 Now I know
Very pretty 😀
Brb about to RUN to Walmart and see if they have them. I love doodling with normal sharpies😭
That is sharpy through and through 😁 I can smell it through the screen 😝
Great way to test the markers. I think sharpie won overall. I will say I came for the art, but staying for the cats. Actually I’m staying for both!
I was watching this and I got the sharpie paint brush AD
I have a orange cat 2 but he is 10 weeks
I like sharpies better. it was so pretty.🤩
Just in time, I wanted to buy these!
I hope you enjoy them if you end up getting some of your own!
You're awesome :) love watching you
Thank you so much for watching!! ^-^
You should use the sharpie paints to create some neurographic art. It’s really relaxing.
I wonder how sharpie would look in shrink plastic
You should try out the paint pens from Trippy Draws if you haven't already❕❗
Seeing Phoenix’s toe beans, made my day. 😊 🐾
New hair highlights? If so, they look nice.
Sad that you could not find a paper to match correctly with this markers :(
Sharpie is very good for me
I think I'm team Sharpie tbh!
Sharpie on a dress!?!
@@SoCraftastic omg that'd be so much ink or paint but that could be cool! Or a collab haha
did you know posca do brush markers too?
Well the answer is really what is the price difference between the 2
Sharpie is much more affordable! Especially when it comes to the brush version. I don't have any Posca brush markers at the moment, but they are between $6-10 individually or nearly $50 for a set of 10. Both types of Sharpie Creative Markers are around $20 for a pack of 12. I should have included that info in the video. However, this way the viewer can form an opinion before looking up the prices.
Were those Amazon Poscas ?
The paint is different in these paint pens. Posca are acrylics and Sharpie are oil based paint, I think that is a big reason they react and perform differently which makes it hard to truly compare.
These are not their oil based - this product is a new acrylic Sharpie. The oil based ones have a white body.
The Sharpie is very promising. If only the colours were more vibrant.
You’re so good with combining colors. Also I want these pens 😮
Pretty sure they have had em for a while. I know ive seen em sold individually for a few years in Michaels at my store. Looking it up theyve been out since 2006. Not very new
Those are the oil based that have been around for awhile. These new ones are water based acrylic.
Sharpie on top because their purple looks more blue-ish.
what about make pot holders
For the next video
Beautiful so beautiful dear ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
The ASMR scratching gave me chills. I didn't like it.
Yeah I hate the sound too! ( ˇ෴ˇ )
No Sarah! Don't convince me to buy more markers!!