She has pulled off a B4 with similar possibly even better quality in I’ll never love again. She’s definitely gotten lax/stylistic but her technique is not that far off from what it was tbh.
Luna saved the group tbh 'cause aside from Luna, the other members couldn't really sing. Love Krystal but her acting talent is far better than singing. As a group, f(x) had good chemistry on stage tho.
I wonder when will we get proficient or higher vocalist in this generation, especially in big3+hybe or popular group with a good songs, those previous gen are really crazy in terms of vocal.. 😮
@@praveenw.4393 could argue the same for other companies, lmao. given some of their “music” quality, recycled demos from older groups, etc. at least i can trust hybe idols to have an interest in producing their own music.
@@tunamaki1209 producing ≠ vocal Learn to differentiate it properly. Why you need to be good at composing/producing while having disgusting/irritating/bad vocal? The song needs to be meaningful and the singer should be able to express the song to make it more soulful. And why you need to be a singer if you are only good at composing/producing while be bad at singing.... Big L
1-YG’s big mama. Younghyun. mid-high A. 2-SM’s the grace. Lina. mid A. (i would say lina=yuonghyun) 3-SM’s F(x). luna. mid-high A- 4-SM’s gg/snsd. teayeon. mid B+. 5-SM’s red velvet. wendy. mid B+ 6-JYP’s 15&. jamie&yerin. low-mid AA-P. and high AA-P 7-JYP’s nmixx lily. B-/B 8-JYP’s wonder girls. sunye. B-/B. (same as lily) 9-JYP’s nmixx. haewon. mid B- 10-SM’s aespaJYP’s wonder girls. ning2/yeeun. mid C+ 11-JYP’s twice. jihyo. high C 12-YG’s blackpink. rosé. high D+. (not even low average) YG and SM ent are the only ones with A tier vocalist, but it’s impossible for YG now JYP mostly has A and AA vocalists. lily&haewon. jamie&yerin. sunye jihyo&jeongyeon. sullyoon…….. etc
In my opinion, Lily should just be Mid-AA instead of High AA. Yes, she has decent upper belts. However, her head voice still sounds floaty most of the time, even in D5-E5 and "oo" vowel (most esp. her G5), which is not enough to boost her up the tier. K-pop idols only have a typical pop head voice, but relatively, Jamie's and Wendy's, for example, have better quality and could help them be placed higher. Just saying this, because I'm seeing a lot of people overrate Lily's head voice, saying she's high AA because of her upper belts + hv, and even could be AA-P since she's starting to get consistent with Eb5 and have a few E5. Edit: Additionally, I also believe that, consistency-wise, Wendy can deliver better outputs than Taeyeon these days. However, when Taeyeon really tries, her best can drown out Wendy's best outputs, but this doesn't come around frequently now especially if we based it on her concert performances. So idk, if I personally should put one above the other or consider them as equals. What do you think?
I haven't heard much about her hv, but I kinda agree with the comment above, her mid belts and lower register are not that great (not bat tho, just not her strength). She has some really good high belts and most of her fans only focus on that, shame cuz she is a good singer but she's mostly recognized by her high notes, I think she could develop a stronger hv if she focuses on that. For Tayeon and Wendy I think they're kinda exchangeable, in terms of ranking, so I would put them as equal
I agree with you. Even though I'm a moomoo, I accept the fact that Big Mama has a better vocal line than Mamamoo...I mean, even the weakest vocalist in Big Mama is still better than(or maybe equal to i dont know) Solar herself
@@laldinpuia3333I think the worst vocalist in Big Mama (i don't remember her name 😭) used to be better than Solar in her prime but i don't think her current ability is better than Solar. Maybe Solar is a bit better? I think so. The other three, in all honesty devour most female idols in the music scene especially Lee Younghyun. She's like the Jennifer Hudson of k-pop tbh 😭
The c5s she has supported up till now is not of good quality to be considered as a consistent note in her support range, plus she never supported head voice before, I don't know where did u get that f5 head voice support.
@ She’s supported Head voice before, even in 2018 she has supported C#5’s and D5’s in head voice, and in one of her new songs from Rosie she has a supported F5 adlib. Also this is her “best” support range her consistent support range would be Bb3/B3-Bb4-B4-D5 (E5)
Yg in first place was shocking 😂😂. But to me Wendy and Lili are better vocalists than Tayeon even in her prime. But I am not a professional, that’s just my opinion
Bada should be here for sure, maybe between Jamie and Luna Park Bom will be at the last sadly For Babymonster, Rami and Rora will be between Rose and Jihyo probably I dont know much about Miss A And if you include the non-Main vocalists as well...Big Mama members will take up majority of the top half😂
@@chewieqtpie doesnt lacks consistency to be honest. All the other kTubers give her A4/Bb4 while you still give A4 (Bb4) when she kept supporting Bb4s.
@@Shaikhyahya1102it doesent really matter about what other creators give the majority of her bb4 are unsopprtrd and it’s not about how much you support it’s also about quality
Ahyeon may be able to hit notes, but she is much more strained compared to almost all the vocalists on here (I feel like she probably as a better range then Rose)
Maybe they're not main vocalists?? But I agree with you, they are hella stronggg~ One more thing, they're not around Younghyun(she's a force to reckon with lol) They're like around B/B+, still great though...Imagine a group where even the weakest vocalist is a B tier😭
Lina made me levitate
Lily's Time For the Moon Night Eb5 and Haewon's Day6 C5 are such joy to my ears
Lily tiene buen soporte y estabilidad hasta un E5 segun yo jeje
@@davidmoreira1310 y q tiene q ver
The fact that Luna auditioned as a dancer and was trained to be a singer is crazy. I miss f(x)
Jamie hasn't pulled off a note like that in the last 4 years, she is just Wendy without comfort above C#5...
Yeh id put taeyeon above
She has pulled off a B4 with similar possibly even better quality in I’ll never love again. She’s definitely gotten lax/stylistic but her technique is not that far off from what it was tbh.
Haewon and Lily are literally my favourite gg vocalists in 4th gen
Haewon's C5 is resonance quality
i think it was resonance quality
What is that c5 E5 all means
@Prasethamuruganantham it’s the keys(🎹 )that they’re singing in
It's just full note, resonance quality no exits
@@fugugjfddd thank you very much
Jyp and SM vocal queens
Only SM, jyp is just nmixx
@@lioipaz2010Twice and wonder girls
@@lioipaz2010 And twice?????
@@lioipaz2010 15& was also JYP, they are amazing vocals
@@멜론빵07 lmao twice??😭😭🙏
f(x)’s luna is such a vocal gem. and to think she initially auditioned for the main dancer position is crazy. shame how sm handled f(x)
Jihyo also
Luna saved the group tbh 'cause aside from Luna, the other members couldn't really sing. Love Krystal but her acting talent is far better than singing. As a group, f(x) had good chemistry on stage tho.
I wonder when will we get proficient or higher vocalist in this generation, especially in big3+hybe or popular group with a good songs, those previous gen are really crazy in terms of vocal.. 😮
Hybe cares only about visuals, popularity, and money.
@@praveenw.4393 could argue the same for other companies, lmao. given some of their “music” quality, recycled demos from older groups, etc. at least i can trust hybe idols to have an interest in producing their own music.
@@tunamaki1209 producing ≠ vocal
Learn to differentiate it properly. Why you need to be good at composing/producing while having disgusting/irritating/bad vocal? The song needs to be meaningful and the singer should be able to express the song to make it more soulful. And why you need to be a singer if you are only good at composing/producing while be bad at singing.... Big L
@@praveenw.4393That's quite literally almost all idol companies lol
1-YG’s big mama. Younghyun. mid-high A.
2-SM’s the grace. Lina. mid A. (i would say lina=yuonghyun)
3-SM’s F(x). luna. mid-high A-
4-SM’s gg/snsd. teayeon. mid B+.
5-SM’s red velvet. wendy. mid B+
6-JYP’s 15&. jamie&yerin. low-mid AA-P. and high AA-P
7-JYP’s nmixx lily. B-/B
8-JYP’s wonder girls. sunye. B-/B. (same as lily)
9-JYP’s nmixx. haewon. mid B-
10-SM’s aespaJYP’s wonder girls. ning2/yeeun. mid C+
11-JYP’s twice. jihyo. high C
12-YG’s blackpink. rosé. high D+. (not even low average)
YG and SM ent are the only ones with A tier vocalist, but it’s impossible for YG now
JYP mostly has A and AA vocalists. lily&haewon. jamie&yerin. sunye
jihyo&jeongyeon. sullyoon…….. etc
also i will add bada between luna and teayeon
wendy being P is biggest joke ive seen. she is closer of AA than P
@queen. ur DVA is the best.
but girl. that was 4 months ago. i never thought wendy was actually AA-P.
Sunye and Yeeun, Yeeun was also a Main Vocalist and they were Wonder Girls' Main Vocalist duo
@@osamafaisal3716big mama isn't kpop group
Taeyeon's and Jamie's C5's as well as Lina's D5 are everything which is okay in this world🤧
You're everywhere too pookie
@@RYUs_addractive_gal ofc queen
JYP vocalists took me to the sky
In my opinion, Lily should just be Mid-AA instead of High AA. Yes, she has decent upper belts. However, her head voice still sounds floaty most of the time, even in D5-E5 and "oo" vowel (most esp. her G5), which is not enough to boost her up the tier. K-pop idols only have a typical pop head voice, but relatively, Jamie's and Wendy's, for example, have better quality and could help them be placed higher.
Just saying this, because I'm seeing a lot of people overrate Lily's head voice, saying she's high AA because of her upper belts + hv, and even could be AA-P since she's starting to get consistent with Eb5 and have a few E5.
Edit: Additionally, I also believe that, consistency-wise, Wendy can deliver better outputs than Taeyeon these days. However, when Taeyeon really tries, her best can drown out Wendy's best outputs, but this doesn't come around frequently now especially if we based it on her concert performances. So idk, if I personally should put one above the other or consider them as equals. What do you think?
Lily's hv is really really good, it's just that her mid belts and low register is meh
I haven't heard much about her hv, but I kinda agree with the comment above, her mid belts and lower register are not that great (not bat tho, just not her strength). She has some really good high belts and most of her fans only focus on that, shame cuz she is a good singer but she's mostly recognized by her high notes, I think she could develop a stronger hv if she focuses on that. For Tayeon and Wendy I think they're kinda exchangeable, in terms of ranking, so I would put them as equal
Wendy is definitely more consistent than Taeyeon now. Wendy's consistency is almost as good as Eunji's imo
@@mohamadfirdausbinmat2577Wendy, Taeyeon, Eunji, and Luna are examples of above average Kpop idol and Korean singer. They're too good for idol title.
Thank you for including Lina 😢 CSJH are really underrated despite have such a beautiful vocals
luna is so underrated..
Jamie, luna, lina and younghyun have god given talent.
can you do this with male idols?
What's Luna resonance range?
That E5 was her limit
Omg I finally get those on yt shorts
LINA MENTIONED🎉🎉🎉
Ningning vocal 😮❤
The fact that 2 of the vocalists are nmixx members 😻 stan nmixx!
Big mama is so insane no one can beat this group (my opinion)
I agree with you. Even though I'm a moomoo, I accept the fact that Big Mama has a better vocal line than Mamamoo...I mean, even the weakest vocalist in Big Mama is still better than(or maybe equal to i dont know) Solar herself
@@laldinpuia3333I think the worst vocalist in Big Mama (i don't remember her name 😭) used to be better than Solar in her prime but i don't think her current ability is better than Solar. Maybe Solar is a bit better? I think so. The other three, in all honesty devour most female idols in the music scene especially Lee Younghyun. She's like the Jennifer Hudson of k-pop tbh 😭
@@mohamadfirdausbinmat2577why are you comparing a singing group with kpop group.
Rosé is now a C-/C tier vocalist. She has a support range of A3/Bb3-B4/C5 (C#5)-F5
The c5s she has supported up till now is not of good quality to be considered as a consistent note in her support range, plus she never supported head voice before, I don't know where did u get that f5 head voice support.
@ She’s supported Head voice before, even in 2018 she has supported C#5’s and D5’s in head voice, and in one of her new songs from Rosie she has a supported F5 adlib. Also this is her “best” support range her consistent support range would be Bb3/B3-Bb4-B4-D5 (E5)
@tenznor2758 she can connect her head voice upto F5, not support it.
What was Luna tier at her prime ?
A- still but she had consistency to E5
Taeyeon's C5 sounds the best here for me personally
That Yuju is not here is a crime.
She is not from the big 3
im not suprised, if Nmixx were here, the one I'm suprised was Jamie because she was underrated ❤
I prefer haewon's vocal tone soo much. She has such a sweet voice
Lily B/B+ bro because her Eb5 nice resonance, Wendy B+/A-
Luna's resonant E5 was so effortless while doing hard choreo she's untouchable
WENDY ON FIRE!!
Yg in first place was shocking 😂😂. But to me Wendy and Lili are better vocalists than Tayeon even in her prime. But I am not a professional, that’s just my opinion
I would've thought Bada from SES would be first. Her vocals are no joke
i wonder if ailee is still an A, i love her voice and haewon from nmixx
Jihyo-
Where is Jessica and Yeeun? They were both Main Vocalist in SNSD and Wonder Girls
Just imagine if big mama was in a company that actually promoted them, I get they weren’t really a kpop group but they could’ve been so much bigger
Big respect on Big Mama
Winter is also a main vocalist
No she is lead
Winter is also main vocalist.
It wasn't like that a year ago
please listen to billlie, the lead vocalists are amazing.
Rosé is a C now and i think all have improved a lot now u showed a clip of rosé in her debut eras
What about Julie from kiss of life
Bigmama A+
This one got me *goosebumps* seeing Taeyeon at 5th and seeing how all the upper ranks like 😲
와 이영현은 반칙이지 ㅋㅋㅋ
Rose isnt even better than Seulgi
True 😬
Jihyo and Rose can't beat Winter and Irene
@@lioipaz2010 you mean visuals? Ok. But in vocals and dance both are better than Irene and winter.
Bro , seulgi is a lead vocalist while Rose is a main vocalist. Can you guys read the title carefully?
Where are Rami and Ahyeon? They are Main Vocalists for YG Babymonster.
what song is taeyeon singing?
Curious about the old groups like S.E.S, Miss A, 2ne1, and even BM. Are they taken into consideration on this list too?
Bada should be here for sure, maybe between Jamie and Luna
Park Bom will be at the last sadly
For Babymonster, Rami and Rora will be between Rose and Jihyo probably
I dont know much about Miss A
And if you include the non-Main vocalists as well...Big Mama members will take up majority of the top half😂
Csjh are old group, they're early 2nd gen tho
I love Nayeon and Rosie’s high notes💞
Taeyeon siempre es la mejor🪙👑
If I could, I would click millions of likes, not just one...
Number 3 strain
My haely 😭🙏🏻
I know its unrelated, but id love to see kelly clarkson on here.
She'll be around Younghyun, maybe higher
I need this including groups from small companies like Mamamoo and Dreamcatcher
Solar will be around Haewon
Hwasa and Wheein will be above Ningning
Sadly, Siyeon will not be that high
@laldinpuia3333 I'll be happy just to see them there tbh haha
@@rosivardI feel you, being a Moomoo myself...I used to search for Mamamoo in every reels😂
How abt S.E.S Bada??
Rosé's supported range :
[A3/bb3~A4/Bb4]
Bb4s are more consistent and Clean,Open now.. tier ( D+)
Agree
Lacks engagament for the mostpart
@@chewieqtpie doesnt lacks consistency to be honest. All the other kTubers give her A4/Bb4 while you still give A4 (Bb4) when she kept supporting Bb4s.
@@Shaikhyahya1102it doesent really matter about what other creators give the majority of her bb4 are unsopprtrd and it’s not about how much you support it’s also about quality
why mentioned Jamie but not Yerin?
Song in Taeyeon moment??
Holler by SNSD-TTS
YG on top 💅🏻
F(x) luna queen of vocal
Rose is the best vocalist for me
Same here.
She is my inspiration to keep learning
Same here 🔥✨
What's the song Taeyeon is singing?
Taeyeon voice is still sth very special to me.
why r u not considering their techniques?
Song name from snsd? ❤❤
Holler by SNSD-TTS
@CosmicWishes wow finally thank you so much 🫶🏼
LUNA MEMTIONED 🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥
How the heck is Ailee or Younha not in here 🌝
Mamamoo😢
Why are the vocal tiers only based on how high you can go? Isn't is based on you WHOLE vocal range? Otherwise it doesn’t make sense.
It's not based on how high you can go, rather it's based on support range
Where's Ahyeon 😢
Ahyeon may be able to hit notes, but she is much more strained compared to almost all the vocalists on here (I feel like she probably as a better range then Rose)
f(x) mentioned 🔥
Jamie😭😭😭
What song was Taeyeon singing 🤭
Holler by TTS
Bada tier apa?
Yuju?
THE JAMIE APPRECIATION
0. 2NE1s PARK BOM, THE MOTHER ❤
Where is AILEE? IU? HYOLIN?
None of mamamoo members on the list 🙄
This is a BIG3 ranking@@Paladinaxe
@MY-CTZEN oh my bad jajaj
But if they were on this list:-😂
Ailee(prime) will be above Younghyun - A+
Hyolin will be above Luna - A-
Ningning or Ariana who's better?
I guess ariana since both are in same tier
Ningriana Grande 😍
Ariana
@@chewieqtpie what's Ariana vocal tier and support range (please tell me)
@@Rexille_Creative what's her full range (low to high) and tier
Winter is also a main vocalist now
Updated on Kprofiles
She would be above Jihyo
Also if we count then Jessica will Also be there above ningning
I didnt want to clog the video
No one consider her that bro
Jeongyeon can beat her
What about yerin from 15&😭😭 her belting is comparable to Wendy and other vocalist
Suhyun akmu Where?
Rose now is C
For reallllllll
And Park Bom???
She would be last on this list since she has regressed over the years.
Rosé is C!
Akmu not here?
I don’t get it? What does this ranking mean? Like does A mean good and F mean bad 🤔 and how does one grade it? Girl I’m so confused rn
Dont put yuju is a crime 😢😢😢
This video is only for Big 3
Ailee was missing
Whats abt lee suhyun?
Rose D+
WHERE IS THE OTHER BIG MAMA MEMBERS? THEY'RE ALSO AT THE SAME LEVEL AS YOUNGHYUN
Maybe they're not main vocalists?? But I agree with you, they are hella stronggg~
One more thing, they're not around Younghyun(she's a force to reckon with lol) They're like around B/B+, still great though...Imagine a group where even the weakest vocalist is a B tier😭
@@laldinpuia3333 fr. but the creator should put them too
Rosé c+
Where is YG Rami?
Jessica?
and monday?