The #1 Selling Air Impact vs Modern M18 & Matco Rivals: 2235TiMAX Tested
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- Our lifetime of TOOL RANKINGS torquetestchan...
If you have a good air system, definitely give this one a look: amzn.to/3sfnFON . High Vis 2235: shrsl.com/2zrxb The Ingersoll-Rand 2235TiMAX is no stranger to the impact wrench game. Near a decade and a half in, she's not the youngest in the range but still advertises some healthy specs. Does the Ti still deserve a spot near the top in 2021? We test it vs the Milwaukee 2767-20 high Torque, Matco MT2779 and Aircat 1250-K to find out.
~We earn from qualifying purchases when using the affiliate links here~
150PSI static test is more of the reallife test. I've never seen a shop where the pressure is at the factory recommended amount.
Was the 165psi a static or dynamic pressure?
That was our thoughts on the outset of this channel. All of these tests we've seen on YT with professional equipment... and 90psi? How do you know which one will actually be more powerful in the shop? As we see here, almost no gap between 1250K and IR at 90psi, then the IR takes it to gapplebees at higher line pressure. If we kill an impact with this higher pressure (Harbor Freight stubby) then oh well, that's great info for you guys to know as well!
The 165psi test was static, not sure what's in the gun when its running at that pressure in the line.
I was just about to say this. My job runs our air at 150 psi, and honestly I think they’d crank it up higher if they could lol. I knew I bought my IR gun for a good reason. Hasn’t let me down yet in IL with good ol rust.
That's been my experience as well. Air pressure cranked to 120+ and water drained from the tank every summer when the blow guns turn into pressure washers.
I have the same ir gun and have had it for the last 10 years. Run the shop pressure between 150 and 160 psi. It's hands down the best
@@frankiewilliamson The fact that the two air impacts ranked higher on this list include 1 that's not out on the market yet and another that's super recent and has what we'd call a faulty trigger - and this thing is like 15 years old? Kudos to the 2235TiMAX
I've had my 2235 operating on 175psi for about 4 years constantly. Oil it everyday and had 0 issues
Mine has been 150-175, and gets oiled less than it should. No issues.
I did rebuild my 3/8" once, the 1/2" still going
A little late, but what do you lube your guns with?
Had mine for over 10 years, put a new anvil a couple years ago, just cause it was chipped. But it’s been through hell. Very harsh conditions, sometimes not oiled for a week or two. Still can knock off lug nuts on a semi, and so much lighter and less expensive then the snap off!
Someone tell me how to fix it please lol. Mine gets VERY HOT in the front. Barepy power
@@justinrosebush2079 my guess is that it needs greased. I found a guide from IR on how to do this on their impacts th-cam.com/video/CXmKkJg3XAI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=8Ls4P_HGYeO1ZlO_
I brought (and still have) an IR 2135ti back when I was working at a diesel garage. We ran 175 psi of shop air and that thing would pull semi lugs off. I didn't do it often because we had a 3/4" shop gun with big line but if someone was using it I'd use my gun. That thing is a little beast and still runs just great!
The other thing I did with all my guns (a tip an old timer gave me) is run a short piece of air line maybe (12" to 18") to get the fitting away from the base of the handle because the fittings can crack over time from all the vibration and spit the air line out, plus it gives you just a little bit more flexibility by not having the coupler right there.
I’m really impressed with the Milwaukees power. Having a tiny air compressor it really gives me an option for serious power.
Back when i was doing suspension and drivetrain work alot I learned the ol' more psi = more power lesson. Another key thing i learned was to use 1/2" air hose with large ID couplers straight from the air compressor tank. Make sure all your fittings have large ID right from the tank to your gun and it will really break some stuff real good!
The work shop I work in we use 3/4 air line and semi trailer air coupling fittings and 140psi, all this so when we service our trailers we don't need adaptors air anything to hook air up to the trailer, so biggest air lines and fittings needed. My PT850 snap-on gun is rubbish, hate that I bought it but my IR gave up the ghost. But when using the 3/4inch IR guns, they will straight up snap semi's wheel studs if you aren't careful lol.
Who knew watching torque wrenches being test (against each other) would be so entertaining and informative. I'm just wondering why the big TV execs at the MSM never thought of it, too.
My 2235 took a while to break in. It was so weak when I first got it I took it in to be looked at. The shop near me said they see it allot. Some are made to tight from the factory. After using it for a while it got noticeably stronger. The tool shop put it on their test rig again and said it was actually making more power. Now, it's a beast.
They also said, give it at least 140 PSI
There is always a break in time.
I have the quiet version of this IR gun, was amazed just from the sound of it, and to know it’s one of the best guns that just makes me feel like a made a good purchase.
Back when the IR Titanium line was newish (2006) I bought one and worked in a shop with 160-180 psi air. It was almost scary. At some point i broke the end off of it so it no longer has a retaining ring but it still works, and it's probably seen 5 drops of oil total in all the years i used it. I still have it, it still works, but its a pointless backup since i now own a 2235 which will also never break. The reliability track record is what brought me back more than anything else. You can't do better than perfect..
If the retaining ring is missing, you're puting yourself at risk and other ppl around you. I'm a student in diesel mechanic technician.
@@hugolortie5411 You're not wrong. Would it alarm you to know i actually TEACH automotive in a community college? But i don't subject my students to my personal tools, or even my personal safety choices really. Around here it's nearly impossible to get people to wear their safety glasses. They just haven't caught enough stuff in the eyeballs yet. But it won't be a socket flying off my 15 yo IR impact, so there's that!
New IR 2236qtimax. Better than perfect. Just came out
I bought the version of the IR in December 2006. It may not have the most power, but it has lasted all these years with no issues. I do oil the vanes a couple times a week. And every couple of years I clean out the grease in the hammer assembly and refill it. But it has been a bad-ass gun. IR air ratchets have been just as good too
I have both the 2235 and the Milwaukee and love them both. At the HD truck shop I work at the air pressure may or may not be at 150 psi and the 2235 is a beast. I was using it to semi-regularly take off tractor/trailer lug nuts. I used it hard one day, Suspension Z-spring and brake anchor pins and when I went to put the wheel on it I found out the air motor drive end had sheered off. Tough guns but it only lasted 2 years at 150 psi...
I've been running my 2135 and 2235 at up to 200 psi and the trigger valve broke (just hissed at me when I pulled the trigger) because my assistant let sand in the quick connect. I do oil then daily and grease them every 2 to 3 weeks. I sent the 2235 for repair and the guy said he can tweak those for an extra 80$ to a rebuild and I went for it. I was not disappointed.
Had multiple anvils break on Mine but we keep replacements handy. It’s the king of the hill in 1/2” impacts
Never ran my guns on anything but 110-120psi. Maybe it's time to crank it up more.
Depends on the gun!
I got a 2235timax I bought back 2015. Anyways bought it used. Broke finally this past week 2023. Ingersoll makes a great gun!!! My nanvil snapped. I used it on semis. Forever the best gun out there
2235QTIMAX is the best air impact wrench that I have ever own. I work at a very busy shop mostly light duty work. But when some one can't get a bolt off. My 2235 has 80% of the time done the job. Been using it for the past 4 year. Still going strong.
That interesting. With my old shop truck. Had the air compressor set to run 175pis. Always thought it might have damage my Ingersoll Rand titanium but she never let me down. Thanks for sharing.
Awesome video! Your commentary kills it! I have an 850 Snap-on, now I’m going to pull the trigger on the TI MAX... keep doing what you do, thank you 🙏.
significantly poorer than the IR have both
I'm on my second 2235. Very solid tool.
Still got my 12 year old 2135
I worked in a few very large machine shops where air pressure was limited to 90 PSI for safety / liability insurance reasons. Some air tools gave us fits. Those factory recommended of 90 PSI are just crazy.
Bought one of these about 10 years ago. Still doing well. I like the weight, the muffler (QTi), and the power. In our shop environment my Milwaukee hits harder and it's convenient to not have an airline, but I still reach for the IR now and then when I need a lower profile impact.
I love my IR 2135 because of the trigger control. Everyone else in the shop seems to have one of each of the competing brands, and frankly at 175psi static they all get the job done just fine in an automotive shop. To me it feels like the IR is the only one that has any kind of real trigger modulation. I can reliably tighten small bolts with my IR, yet most of the other impacts I use feel like nothing but on/off with the trigger.
I've been using the Ingersoll Rand 35QMAX for 2 months 5 days a week and love it.
I use it at a automotive service shop mostly for wheel removal and initial assembly before torquing to spec only had a few instances needing a breaker bar to loosen lug nuts.
Next step bigger tool would be nice for the stubborn nuts or incase I need to work on a dually.
I have this exact IR air impact and I love it.
Cornwell has some impacts made by IR. I have the Cornwell/2235Ti gun but my Matco has more power and I've had/have most of the top guns out there air or electric but I don't have the newest 1/2" Milwaukee. I'm waiting for a little while so I can watch for issues if any. I've always used higher air psi with high flow couplings for best results but working in a shop that works on everything from Mini Coopers to F800's or GMC KODIAKS with Cat diesels you'll have to get the bigger 3/4" or 1" gun eventually. The best gun I ever used was a Snap On MG31/325. That thing is a beast for a 3/8"! I have two incase one breaks. Unless there's something new out there(or a prototype) my choice is my 2779 but maybe the 2235Ti has more than my Cornwell version of it. Great video keep em coming!
I would be curious about the torque loss (if any) there is with the quiet version of this tool and compare the sound levels as well.
Funny enough the quiet version feels really dampened but in reality it still torques like a beast on the highest setting
Agreed, I have the Cornwell-badged version of the tool (IRC9000Q). I’m curious
Do you think the extended anvil has some torque compared to the short one?
@@braydinjones6301 no extensions and adapters will always be a torque loss. How much would require testing
I’ve had my IR for years, going through the worst conditions, salt, oil, grease, diesel, gasoline, varsol, water, you name it this thing dealt with it. Bad air systems, lack of oil and grease. Replaced anvil and hammers cause the kit that was available off the truck, and anvil was chipped and couldn’t get the snap ring on any more. Bought a snap off 3/8 gun. It got oiled religiously every work day. Quit after a year, got it repaired under warranty which took 2 months to get dealt with. After another year it quit yet again. This time just after warranty was done. Bought an IR 3/8 titanium and ran it for years being abused, had to replace its anvil cause it busted the end clean off. Cheap and easy to repair, took 10 min and I was back running again. So much lighter and a lot easier on the wrists then the snap off. And so much more power. My wife is scared of the twins, neighbor loves them. My dad runs IR and has since he started being a mechanic 3 years after, yes that’s right after, I was already in the trade. These things love pressure and volume. I’ll be buried with these things or my kids will run with these. Can’t kill them. Loud as hell
The cordless Milwaukee and the like will beat out all air guns on a little home gamer compressor at 90psi, so for that scenario I totally recommend the cordless stuff. However if you're working in a shop, chances are there's 160ish psi and a monster compressor backing it up with volume. In that scenario a 2235 will kick the pants off anything. They're designed to work in a shop. They have to put the lawyer approved 90psi on the box, but the IR engineers know exactly how they're gonna be used and design them accordingly. I had a mac gun that had almost the power of a 2235 when it was new but after 2 years it lost alot. It still works fine now even 7 years later but it has about the power of a 2135q now.
That old gun is very impressive. I see them come up for sale on the used market, it would make for a great backup gun or home gun that will likely last forever. Thanks for this amazing test guys. Can't wait to see more electric high torques on the list soon!
Many people told me that electric impact are better than air.
But thats only true if you run air at 90 psi. I got both and i guarantee you that my IR has more torque, we run at 140psi (still fine since 12 year). Thank for this video showing those result.
Being a tool truck guy for a lot of tools I still run a 2235 at home and it does everything my matco does. The Milwaukee high torque is massive but the high torque and mid torque make a great pair
I own pretty much all IR tools for my power tools in my box. I bought them out of tech school in 2010. As a heavy truck tech I've never had a single issue with them and my 3/4" back in 2010 had more power than Snap Ons 1" at the time had. Now my dad's worn out Matco 1/2" from 1986 does hold it's own against my 1/2" 2235 still. Guess I'm old school and not one to spend hundreds on a battery powered tool that I probably won't be able to get a battery for in 10 years especially when I always have access to a air line.
Would love to see how Ingersoll’s 20v iq series W5133 3/8, W7152 1/2, and W7172 3/4 compare to what you’ve already tested.
I have the 2235QTi max and it is a very reliable gun. Ive used it for about 4 years now and its fantastic. Worth getting the Qti version as it really saves your ears when not using hearing protection
Please test the quiet versions of the 2135 both the titanium and the original.
This is a dumb comment but could you test the milwaukee 1" d handle? I've always been so curious maaaam
I have those IR's and Milwaukee's and I absolutely love them both.
I rarely use the air these days, but when I do I use Milton V series fittings and a large 2 stage compressor with a kick on set at 150 and peak static pressure 175-180.
Loved my IR when I got it back in 2014 on clearance at Sears for $175. Kicked the crap out of my lead techs Snap On 1/2” and didn’t break on me like his. People where always borrowing it if they couldn’t get stuff off with their guns. They just seem to hit harder, and back then it was rated 650lbs of breakaway torque.
I wonder what ever happened to real tool reviews. Used to love that guys channel and still go back to it sometimes for info
He was on Instagram, can’t remember whose post he commented on, but he said he’ll be back soon.
Good thing our shop runs at 150psi😀😀, I knew my 2235 was a beast
I've had the quiet version of the IR for about 6 years now and I really like it. It's well-balanced, not too heavy, not too loud (former lube tech got the regular one and, Christ, that thing was loud). I'm not sure what our shop air is set at. I think it's ~120ish. I oil it... occasionally. Hasn't missed a beat. Just a solid impact all around.
You just cannot beat the sound that these ir make especially with the ir thunder ⚡, it let customers know you mean business 😂
Bought my IR for 75 bucks used had almost no power. After a 25$ rebuild kit. It's taking off head bolts from cummins isx engine. Not to mention still had some scoring on the inside. Best gun ever tbh
The 3/8 air hose is too small when I would use that gun I would hook 2 3/8 hoses together and run a 1/2 hose because at 90 psi it recommends to run 1/2 inch air hose. It needs the volume that a half inch hose can supply.
Guys at work didn’t believe me either till they couldn’t get some hub bolts loose and I pulled air from 2 smaller hoses and ran a half inch hose. It broke all the bolts loose. Making their day a lot easier. I’ve had that gun for 10 years and have gone through 3 of them. Love it and would suggest that impact over any of them for an air impact with a lot of power.
We have a "fleet" of them so to speak at work for our tire shop. They always perform awesome, but what I really like about them is the way they feel in your hands with the grip as well as the forward/reverse switch location. It's a comfortable gun to use in a capacity where you use it all day. Much more comfortable than Snap On guns and even a tad better than my Matco. I would even say more comfortable than an Aircat too.
Test the ingersoll Rand w7152 against the Milwaukee
Okay, we have a bunch of High torques coming up, so we'll add this to the tail end. It's some coin, but should be worth it!
@@TorqueTestChannel we all appreciate it. With 1500ftlbs advertised breakaway I’m hoping it’ll do well
I love my 2235. I bought it from my automotive instructor for $250 and it's been a beast
Love this channel so much! Excited to see what you test next!
I have the original 2135ti gun. Still working and plenty of power.
That 2235ti is slightly more powerful but extremely and obnoxiously loud for everyday use. Can't stand it in the shop.
Out of 14 techs in my shop we have 9 IR guns (one old matco) they're absurdly loud.
Still break out the ol 2135QTi with a few drops of oil when the going gets tough, use an Aircat 1056-XL as my go to 1/2" most of the time these days as it's light, quiet, and compact. Have an IR 2190Ti I got for a song as a backup to that with 1/2" line for bigger stuff, but usually just grab a 3/4" breaker bar at that point if it can be done without impact.
I've had the IR impact for right at 20 years now so it's been out way longer than 12 years and yes it is the exact same gun, it's been a great old gun and has held up to the 190psi line pressure in my shop (actually proffesionall auto repair shop/bussiness I own) and years of use and abuse, I think it puts out more power than this test shows personally but air run guns is a thing of the past now that the technology has advanced so far with the electric rechargables, my IR and all my other air guns never get touched since I got my collection of Millwaukee and Snapon electrics,,having air hose all over the place is crap for the birds. my most used gun is my little Millwaukee M12 fuel stubby 3/8th drive,,it's got enough power to break loose 90% of any nut or bolt on 95% of any car or light truck you'll ever work on and even heavy truck as well, and has way more than needed to overtighten nearly all of those same nuts and bolts when putting them back together, so why use a heavier harder to use gun??
Was waiting for this test. I guess their's a reason one sees so many IR composite impacts as daily use guns in a shop.
I use this ir impact at work. It's been alright for daily use when a full size impact is needed.
IR 2235 is pretty weak with the rated 6.3bar. Using it @ 10bar makes it whole different animal. Also incredible rugged. We used them at work @10 bar and the conditions were dirty. Lot’s of abuse, never serviced and still they held long time.
i have a 2135ti max 175 psi for 13 years, oiled daily, on first rebuild now
I actually have both the Ingersoll 2235QTIMAX and the Milwaukees High Torque and I have put them through the motions in real life situations in a high volume professional shop .....The Ingersoll does do very well but there has been quite a few situations that I could not remove something from it being over torque but my Milwaukee will remove anything that the IR can not but the Cordless is not my first primary go too ...Pneumatic is so to give the Ingersoll a fare shake it is a well decent gun I don't believe there is no gun out there that cannot fail depending upon how tight a fastener is over torqued just my opinion from using these tools in a professional setting day in day out ...Air restrictions could also enable one to get the full maximum performance out of there gun just as well with having wrong fitting
I managed to pick up the 12v 3/8 DeWalt impact kit, with charger, carrying bag, and two 2ah batteries, for $21.20 at Lowes. I'm so hyped. The first impact I've been able to add to my tool collection.
21.20$ for the impact wrench? How'd you pull that off?
@@omarm6678 They had a promotion for a free $80 5ah battery with the purchase of the $99 kit. Well, they were sold out and not going to restock any time soon. First Lowes I went to said they couldn't do anything. Second Lowes took the price of the battery off the price of the kit.
Impact wrench, charger, two 2ah batteries, and a bag.
I understand testing at the manufacturer recommended pressure but I have never been in a shop that wasn’t running at least 150 psi. We run about 175 psi. I couldn’t imagine using air tools in a shop environment at 90 psi. It just makes everything feel so weak.
Damn I never knew it woke up that much above 90 psi. I worked at a Conrad's for a few years and bough one of these guns on sale for 250 and got a box of Grey Pneumatic sockets for free with it. Loved the gun and the sockets. Unfortunately it got stolen out of my box after I put in my two week notice and I never saw it again.
Other factors I considered prior to purchasing this gun is aftermarket support, reviews, quality. Some of the no name guns break often and can't get parts.
I love my 2235 timax. My home compressor runs 135psi and every shop ive ever worked at is 125 and they warn you to bring your own regulator if you need to step down.
I’d really like to see the Cornwell 1/2” thrown in the mix. It’s the most powerful impact I have used; boasts 1,450 breakaway. I’d like to see how it matches up against Matco.
Cornell is a quiet company. They manufacture some nice American forged hard line tools.
Ken Roesner , I think the Cornwell CAT4280 vs Proto J150WP is the fight to book here.
Please do a test on a 1/2 DeWalt XR electric impact. Really want to see how it performs compared to the Milwaukee m18 fuel and if it’s worth sticking with DeWalt or switching.
Dude bite the bullet and get a turbo charger and two batteries of all three platforms. Then you can say fuck you to the whole team bullshit and just buy the best tool you can. That's what I'm doing. Sure it kinda sucks at first but remember you can only run a single tool at a time
I would like to see you guys branch out to other tool brands like snap-on and cornwell
epends on application.. when your running in 200 rubber bars for a railroad sweeper you have to compact the pretty solid rubber down about 1/2-3/4 of an inch. That can do alot of strain on an electric motor while if you lube your air impact every here and their it wont show wear after the 2 hours of impacting your impacting each bar about 30-45 seconds straight
I worked at a full suspension shop which required high air pressure to run the emerson air jacks, with 190psi of air pressure, the anvil on my IR 2235 got rounded off and pitted, this was after most of it's life, I then bought the Snap-on PT850 and the veins wore out withen 4 months, I'm looking for another 1/2" drive air impact in 2024 and I'm thinking Matco or IR
The ir is half the size of the cordless tools. The cordless is good for wheel nuts only as they are massive.
I run the M18 high torque & the 2235 IR up against each other everyday. In mine duty work the only reason I use the M18 is so I dont have inconvenience of the hose . Both awesome guns much better than snap on ( air or Batt.) Great vid thx
I greatly enjoy your channel. I appreciate the methodology, honesty, unbiased test results.
Hey guy's you need to test this brand called Air Boss our of Taiwan.
One of the parts stores here in Australia, Bursons had them for sale for a while when I bought mine they had 250 in stock so must've got a pallet or two in.
I think it was advertised at 900ish ftlbs, it's a steel cased gun and the catalogue said it had a full steel motor.
I tested it on a truck wheel and it was pulling 41mm hex nuts off on Mitsubishi trucks. We tested it against the 1/2 version of the brushless 3/4 gun from Snap-on and it out did it and that's on 100psi static I think my work runs around 80 dynamic line size plays a role there.
I can only imagine what what the little beast would do on 100 dynamic. Also the thing is tiny for a full size gun plus they're like $180 to $170usd well I paid $240aud so probably even cheaper in USD tbh.
www.twairboss.com/
That's the brand mine is a light blue all steel gun.
i have a 2767 milwaukee and a 2355ti. when the milwaukee doesn't move it, i get the IR and it comes out. every time.
To my knowledge and I may be wrong. But I believe the 2235 is fairly new. May be within the past 4 years. I have the older 2135ti, 2135qti, and the 2135timax. All of them are about 10-13 years old. All of them I’ve run at 140psi+ every day. Hardly ever oil them. Use them for hammers and they have never skipped a beat. I’ve used various snap on gun and have been disappointed. Ir for the win. Keep up the great videos.
2235TiMAX came out around 2008 based on the press release, but they came out with new 2135 version after that as well
@@TorqueTestChannel2135 came out in 2003, 2235 in 2014. Look for the new 2236 which just released (2024). I know, I invented them.
Tonight I had to remove a 55m yoke nut from a RV and my air IR 1/2” titanium was the only tool I had that did the job. Battery m18 couldn’t get it off
I worked at a used tire shop back in the 80's that did a high volume of tire changing. We always used Ingersoll Rand 1/2-in impacts. I can tell you we would have never considered running that tool at only 90 PSI. I don't remember what we used but it was way over a hundred pounds. I don't have any memory of any Ingersoll Rand impact gun failing because of it. I did oil it everyday but other than that it got ran hard and dropped on the ground not treated gently at all. I would not want to buy an impact wrench that is designed to not increase the torque when you increase the air pressure
Very impressed at the high pressure results. The price has gone up a bit, I bought mine on amazon 3 years ago for $250. Imo the current 20 dollar increase is well worth it, it's a great gun. I have put coworkers $500+ dollar impacts to shame with my ir. I oil it sometimes and it works as good as the day I got it
The IR impacts love the high air pressures but you should be putting oil in every day. It only takes a couple seconds and really makes them last.
@@actionjksn You're right. I really should oil it more, but ever since I got my m18 high torque my ir has just been sitting in my box. The location of the air hose relative to my bays is super annoying so the electric impact has made it easier to move around. We're in the process of moving into a new building so maybe I'll go back to using my ir daily if the air hose situation is better.
I did buy the ir grease though! I did that a while ago, can't remember what the service interval is for greasing the gun but if I recall it's not that often
I love watching these videos! I feel my next purchase will be well informed
That ingersol impact makes the most power in reverse with the dial turned all the way to the left. It appeared to be turned to the right in the 10 second test, couldn’t tell which way it was on the max test.
I really liked your anecdote that higher pressures create magic with the 2235TiMax. After some frustration over a Honda crank bolt last week, I came here with torque envy. All I had to do was to crank up the volume. For a tool not often used, it's not an ideal fit for battery powered tools, unless you use those batteries for something else in between. What's the story behind the mystery tool, is it an experimental Astro?
Those hondacrank bolts are tedious man.... They sell a weighted socket specifically for the job because some impacts just wont cut it. I think this will knock it right out tho !!! But you need a good compessor to maintain that air presurre 👍👍👍
I don’t know if i got one of these exact models, but i have an IR Ti model in gray that i only break out when i have some stuff that is REAL stuck. Best $40 i ever spent.
Heat + lube+ hammer + air gun usually gets it done.
Lol. That’s our truck shop secret. 1/2 lines and 145 psi shop pressure with the power knob turned to low in reverse.
Always have a spare anvil handy. My ingersoll ate 3 of them already
What are you doing to the anvil? I work on dump trucks and heavy equipment. Bought my TnT gun in 2006, been running it on 175- 200 psi whole life and never replaced the anvil
@@Matt-ou1bg 2235 has a lot more grunt than a tnt.
I’ve always felt ingersol is the best bang for buck
One point I'd like to make on the pricing of the Milwaukee 2767-20, I feel like you should include the cost of the batteries/charger as well. You could make the argument that "you have to buy a compressor to run the air guns" but, that really is a one-time purchase and then that compressor can run any brand of tool or air line forever, whereas buying into a battery system only lets you run those specific brands of tools, ever. Buying any other brand (or tool type in some cases, a la electric ratchets), means another financial outlay where the same compressor runs everybody, all day, forever.
Additionally, there are really only two types of people; either those that are buying the gun for the stats and therefore need to buy into the battery ecosystem (in which case the cost of battery and charger matter to getting anything other than a paperweight), or those that already have bought into the battery ecosystem and are picking the gun not for the stats, but for the compatibility (ie, stats don't matter to the latter buyers). So really, battery costs should be included in the price and price score.
Thus, the 2767-20 should actually have a minimum cost of $349 (tool + 1 battery + charger combo), which drops the fiscal score to 33.4, and puts the 2235 in third place.
Love your tests. Looking forward to see how the HF Earthquake XT electric sits on your chart.
Can you test torque sticks? See how accurate they are?
Cordless will always make that power, there's the difference. Air is at the mercy of the workshop compressor. My shop runs 1/4 adaptors and the air impacts can't keep up with an M18, there's been 4 or 5 times already where the air impacts can't budge something so they come to me and the M18 barely struggles. Same IR impact here, there's about 5 of them in the workshop.
I have had used 2235ti every day no semi trucks for 10 years at 175 psi, none of the snap-on or other guns I have can touch it at that. I get about 3 years between rebuilds and that with drilling out the restriction on the forward speed.
You guys should do a video of all the Ingersoll Rand 3/8" air impacts ( 2115TiMax, 2115QTiMAX, 2115QXPA, and maybe the 15QMAX).
wonderful work.
I bought the Xukoom impact wrench in Amazon. It looks like a carbon copy of the Kuccmo and Seesii. I'm working on my truck this weekend and we shall see if it delivers the bean.
our 2235's live on 175psi lines, they last better that anything else to boot
I like that you added the weights on the table. The green text little hard to read for me. Thanks for all the hardwork.
Could you put up like a link to the comparison chart (the one with your scores)
Would like to see a plug-in impact test, for those without air as an option.
I’ve always felt ingersol was the best
I have a soft spot for IR. The 231 with an extended anvil was my first gun and has never been apart although it's been on the back up to the backup gun for years.
@@BlindBatG34 Once I got a IR I stayed off tool trucks.
I'm curious if you guys have gotten a hold of an IR W7152 yet. I'd seen someone else offer and I hope they were able to contribute! If not, I would be willing to work something out.
Great video as always. I have never owned the 2235 in any form, but I've seen it run great in shops everywhere. Cheers!
That person never contacted us. We just purchased one
@@TorqueTestChannel Awesome! Glad to hear it. Any interest in the Astro 1834?
Patiently waiting for that video. I’ve been waiting a long time to see someone do a fair comparison between the two. Love my 2235. Love the channel, keep up the great work.
Could you some time do a video on how to rebuild a air impact wrench, and do a before and after dyno test,, to see if it's worth the$50 rebuild kit prices... thx
It's almost always worth rebuilding, assuming you've oiled it and the metal air motor parts aren't worn out.
well the price is a new gun every 2 years vs every 20, so consider that i guess
Are you going to test the IR W7152 soon?
Been holding off on purchasing a new gun specifically on your tests. This and the dewalt are on that list thanks for the great videos !
Did RTR get bullied into not making videos anymore it’s been like 2 years?
Yaaaa. Looks like i made a good purchase! Thanks for video. You're the best - for real.
Great video comparison, thanks!! IS the mystery the Capri CP35205
The IR is a great tool use them at a machine shop and a lot of their 231 models. The 231 are heavy after some weeks of heavy use. The titanium version is much lighter makes a huge difference. I however just purchased the HF eq12 the 1000lbs version. The main reason is it falls between both IR models for torque from your channel test and is the lightest of them at 3.8lbs. Longevity is another story not sure if it’s rebuildable but should last some time I hope.
For a home gamer like me, I’ll take the 1250k all day. Small 2hp compressor, can’t run much above 100psig dynamic, and at those pressures the 1250k outperforms the 2235, is smoother, and costs less.