Fund schools properly instead of poorly like they do all over the country, maybe we could have more schools like this, which would lead to more students who want to go to school, and maybe countering the trend of anti-education and anti-intellectual people that our country is bursting with right now.
we would need to change the way schools are funded. right now, they are supported mostly by local property taxes, which means that wealthy places get wealthy schools, which perpetuates the wealth cycle. we would need to shift funding more onto the federal budget. this would also create justification for a more uniform standard across the country.
@@sebcw1204 Exactly! There should be universal, equitable funding for all public K-12 schools, with budget tweaks based on local costs for building, equipment, and supplies. What most of the naysayers here don't seem to comprehend is that not only do wealthy areas have more property taxes for schools, they also do much better when fundraising for additional income. Even if we iron out the former, they will still have the latter, so they won't suffer, ffs.
This school has 5.5k kids. They spend $9k per kid as opposed to Baltimore schools that have 2k kids and spend $21k per child to educate them. They don't spend more on these kids. they just have 2x the number of other public schools.
As a student at a rival Indiana High School, we all are extremely jealous of Carmel and their massive school. It’s not just their building that benefits from the massive funding, but all of their programs as well.
Graduated from CHS in 2016. School had more students and was nicer than my college, not to mention was more difficult. I took the auto shop class for two years, and after getting a 4 year business degree I decided to become a mechanic anyway. Great school with great opportunities for success. Everyone should be so fortunate.
I spent two years at a school that was half condemned. Just past my class were fire doors chained shut. Lead paint held the rest together. Next year they condemned it all and set-up a makeshift school in closed-down factory. Eventually they gave-up and shipped us all to the next county and combined three or four schools in an existing one. We didn't even have a library till the last one. In the factory (school) the girls used the staff bathroom because there was just the one for workers and one where the offices were.
Blacks don't value each other's lives. They kill each other in the streets everyday, drive-by shootings that stray bullets kill little children and then later they brag about it. No surprise they don't value education either.
@@EpsteinDidntKillHimself187 that's not how school funding works. your children are not invested in by individual participation, they are funded by taxes gathered from property value. this school exists in a high wealth bubble. the constitution places the burden of education on the government, not the parents.
@@sebcw1204 The school district's tax base is a reflection of the values and work ethic of its residents. Carmel used to be tiny little nothing. In a few decades, the people congregating there have turned it into a small city that most applaud yet others can only leer at with jealous contempt.
Besides the school only spending 10k per kid, there’s 5,000 students that go to that school. Instead of hating on the school maybe find out how they allocate their funds and find out how the city of Carmel was able to build such a school. Then take that information back to your city and see what can be done to make your schools better. Geez the envy!!
Spot on. This same school could have been built in any US inner-city by grant, and the community would have destroyed it. This is a culture and a mindset. And people are salty because they want to keep behaving a certain way, but they want the benefits that come with different choices. In such situations, we reap what we sow. They aren't sowing to reap such a school.
carmel seems like a forward thinking place, from what i can tell they implemented roundabouts to improve traffic flow, you don't see that much anywhere else in american cities or towns
I read that others think since Carmel is such an affluent area, the schools gets all the funds from the city. Wrong. Carmel High School is way more underfunded than the inner city schools by far. It has to do with the parents demanding quality schools, teachers and administration. Along with law enforcement. Clay township schools meets these demands put on by the parents in the city. Alot of parents also volunteer their own time to assist in making this school as good as it is by demanding their kids perform in school.
Just going through the neighborhoods near that HS I can tell you that Carmel HS is in a really rich area with nice houses and such which explains why they have such a nice high school. Wish I had a HS with all those things mentioned in the video.
They look a lot smaller than most houses in affluent suburbs, actually. The school is most likely a product of COVID money paired with cheap costs. The neighborhood is wealthier than the average neighborhood, at a median income of $109k but the houses seem normal sized. The school just looks nicer.
This school only funds $9k a year per student. This is a cultural issue. The community CHOSE (by how they vote) to appropriately allocate funds, then they raise kids who have self respect and respect for property. So they take care of their school. If this same exact school was built in any inner-city by donated funds, the community would ruin it within a few years. Want a better life? Create better families and then move to where others do the same. We did - there was no way I was going to raise my family in Detroit. I moved and raise my children around people with the same VALUES. We live in a "white" community.
@@katiejon17 Katie, wow! Racist much?! I pray that God softens your heart, so that you can give up your racists ways. And if God won't soften your heart, I pray that God stops it, so you can go to heaven and no longer spread your racists thoughts.
nope. Carmel is larger than you’d expect and is extremely wealthy. The west side of the city is covered in huge gated estates. A “small” affordable house in Carmel is about 3000 sq ft and $500-600k. The average price for a home in Carmel is like $450k.
@@chasef89Answer: NO But also: if you are “fiscally conservative” - and against “socialism” - then: you want schools to become Private schools only? And watch as our nation continues to circle the drain ⭕️ 💦 - Trickle Down Economics doesn’t work and never did and never will. Why? Because Greed disguises itself in slogans of “I don’t want my tax money helping Anyone else. Seems unfair.” N I T W I T S
I was astonished to read that they spend $9k per student and some inner city district spend more like 15 to even 30k per student. Where do they spend all that money on where the school with the planetarium and cathedral hallways spends less? It's not the money afterall. This school is not well funded. It's well run.
It’s crazy, all students should get the opportunity to go to schools like this. Lots of high schools in Fishers and Carmel Indiana look like this and it’s a great privilege.
Its because those students care about their education. This indiana school costs much less than your typical NYC public school. The latter is disgusting and trashy, yet has greater expenses... curious what the difference could be....
@@alleghanyonce NYC schools receive about 30,000 dollars per student, while for Carmel its about 10,000 dollars. With this knowledge one could only assume NYC has similar if not more expansive educational facilities for k-12, yet that is not the case. T
I went to Carmel. Grew up here. This city has changed soooooo much since I went to CHS. I've never seen some of the stuff they've added since I went there. Crazy overpopulated school. You can't even walk around in that school or find a place to sit and eat lunch sometimes (there's around 5,000 students). My graduating class had roughly 1,100. I never graduated myself though, huge missed opportunity.
I was curious. How is the racial diversity there? Because, just from watching this video, it seemed pretty Caucasian. I was actually watching to see if they had at least one person who wasn't white promoting the school, and they had only one.
@@ousarlxsfjsbvbg8588 It was pretty much what I was expecting. I went to school in a small town in Missouri and my school was pretty diverse, but we had many budget cuts and removed classes and after school clubs because of it. So, seeing a school like this is just such a shock to me.
@@henrytawnn8694 Hello. What do you mean by shock after watching this video? I think we should be happy because the students get the best facilities that school can offer. I hope the school across your country has the similar facilities like CHS but I don't think we should not be happy for the students who studying in CHS. About the diversity, what if in that neighborhood the majority is caucasian? I think there's also a high school in the US that the students are Black majority and as foreigners I don't see any problem with that.
@@Gilang-Ramadhan There are tens of thousands of schools that don't have anywhere near the facilities and expenses of CHS. The shock is that there should be more schools like this, all over the country, in every community, not just the predominantly white and wealthy ones. Many schools have to make budget cuts, cut classes, or don't have the funding for after school club activities, like mine did. I don't have an issue with that school getting an amazing working environment, which should help with learning. The issue is that tens of thousands of schools aren't. Not even close. And you don't even need to take a wild guess at which communities tend to have less educational budgets. We both already know that answer.
Carmel spends less per student than Indianapolis yet all of those schools are failing. It's the household culture of the families not a cast system. 71% of Carmel students are above average, they earned that school.
@Kruimeltje What if your values don't align with that of the Republican Party? Wait...here comes the "Then vote third party" response. Yes, that will work.
If public schools were paid throgh state income taxes or sales tax there would not be so much inequality of High Schools when most of their funding comes from Property taxes.
Or an even property tax across the board pulled into a state fund and divided on a per capita basis. I'm priced out of the neighborhoods with good schools. All a rated schools in ohio are not open enrollment either.
In many cases the districts mismanage their funds. Especially in school districts that have crazy bureaucracy not to mention that property tax is more consistent than sales or income tax. Property tax is easier across the board.
There is no way Carmel Clay does not benefit from substantial spending from PTAs and individuals which aren't counted in their per pupil spending. It's easy to not spend a lot when others buy you stuff. Carmel Clay, Indiana median household income: $105,720. Baltimore, MD median household income: $54,124.
A highschool in Indianapolis I went to, called Franklin central was JUST like this. Had the TV, and radio stations. They played the radio until 2 minutes before the bell rang between classes, and the TV was how we got our announcements. They also had 2 cafeterias, and a basement with the pool,, along with 2 other stories. They also had a market in the cafeterias. It was AWESOME! Went there part of my freshman year in 2009. Loved it. I didn't live in a nice, rich area either, but that was the school I had to go to.
I went to this high school - but before many of these things existed. The school has had 3 major expansions, 1978, 1991, and 1994 plus other expansions for the sports facilities. Nice that these students can show off these amenities and a few of them actually get that this is atypical.
Yearly cost per student...under $10,000 which is FAR less than many schools. Also keep in mind that there are almost 6,000 students which explains why they have more than one gym and so many specialty rooms. Most of all, the "customers" (parents) are mostly republicans so they don't put up with waste, fraud and abuse by administrators.
FYI, Carmel is one of the schools we faced for sports in our school’s division. You want to talk about some of the most snobby, entitled kids I’ve ever met? Carmel is the kind of town that looks you up and down before they would ever say hello. And I think this video shows all of us from surrounding high schools just how much privilege and special treatment they get for having lived in a area with just a couple more wealthy people. It’s sickening. Especially when my school has had professional sports players and Olympic athletes as alum, it doesn’t make any sense to me why our school doesn’t have enough funding for like half of this.
@@doncarlo4576 and i can definitely get behind that idea. Anything possible to help adolescents into adulthood and enter society easier. But our school had to create a whole program just to bus students to another high school so they could have a chance at classes like shop or vocational trainings or even certain science courses. And some schools around here aren’t even given that chance.
There is no way Carmel Clay does not benefit from substantial spending from PTAs and individuals which aren't counted in their per pupil spending. It's easy to not spend a lot when others buy you stuff.
@@dannyfa7x if a school benefits from the generosity of of the community that too bad. I bought my kids class ipads. Other classes, other schools didn't get them. How's that my problem?
@@brunonaccarato6219 it’s not a bad thing. But when lots of donations and help are coming in and it’s not reported it makes it seem like Carmel is doing more with less per student. I’ve already seen this thread full of people saying well this inner city school spends more per kid than Carmel and look at all the problems. If it were shared info it would give a more realistic spending per student than what’s reported to slow down the dummies. It’s obviously a lot deeper than just funding for what makes a school good or bad. I’m glad you could afford that. Not a lot of teachers I know and knew could do such things.
@@dannyfa7x I'm not a teacher. I'm a parent doing whats best for his daughters. I'm aware my viewpoint isn't fair. However, 2 schools A & B get $6k per student in government funding, thats fair, thats equality. If school B gets $5k per student in donations to bad for A. It can't be equalized. Taking anything from B to offset the difference is theft. I deliberately work towards giving my kids advantages. I'm not unique. I'm troubled when race is introduced. I bought ipads. Were all the students recieving them white? The other class didn't get new ipads. Were all those students black? Frankly I don't know and I don't care. Is that racist? Government allocation should be equal and likewise colorblind, anything else is racist.
This is what happens when educational funding is based on the surrounding property value. So do yourselves a favor and make sure you have a few million in your back pocket so your kid can go to fully funded school
@@sillybilly121212 lol enjoy that boot. I love working class people they worship the rich and act like the system isn’t completely one sided. Lol these clowns are hilarious
@Lèmon Lēe lol you googled how much is spend on a child in Baltimore and ripped that figure from the super reputable Daytona247now and reporting from Fox News who in court has stated they are not news and they shouldn’t be believed but you do you.
My daughters started school here in the suburbs. And it's absolutely disgusting how badly funded they were in the city compared to their new school. There are only 40 students in their new school, and the school looks like what's in this vide. It's wild.
@@Dwight_ my daughters go to a public school. It's in a very good neighborhood though. We live on 150 acre farm and most our neighbors are affluent. It's no wonder folks in the suburbs are more likely to succeed... Wealthy folks are clueless to how everyone else is doing, the financial divide makes it almost unfair, to be born without money...
Went to a school similar by accident when I was put in a Group home from out of the Urban City...It was amazing. I miss the people there and how it was 🙏
@@sillybilly121212if only people understood that… It’s a culture problem. No matter how much money you give to trash, very little of it will turn out will. Some of it might, but the rest will be the same pipeline
I went to two high schools one in nyc which was Queens vocational high school it had no gym and no cafeteria gym was outside and in the auditorium if it rained we called it the cafetorium 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️ and I went to Reading senior high in Reading pa that looked just like this plus there were pools it was valued at 60million when I went like 20 years ago🤦🏽♀️ I wish all schools were like that
Reading high definitely has some of these amenities but the school is like 100 years old in parts! My mom told me the pool was closed when she went in the 60s, because it was so old it needed to be renovated. I agree RHS is atypical, but only cause it was built when education was well funded
dont be whining and trying to make the school worse because they actually spend the money they get properly. they make proper use of their money and spend less than most of the other schools with only around 9k per student.
@@ryanadams0922 Blue states (CA, MA, NJ) do the best in education, yet plenty of red states are the exemptions that disprove the rule. Indiana being one of them. Meanwhile, red states (LA, AL, MS) have the worst education systems in the country, yet there are the Blue states that disprove the rule. New Mexico is one of them. Almost as if politics has little correlation with educational success.
I've been there it's pretty cool and the volunteers students we got for our competition awesome. Keep up the good work, teachers and staff. And schoolboard
I was supposed to go to this school until I moved away right before the year started (literally chose my courses and everything). 2 years later, one of my new friends found this video and told me he felt really bad for me cause I didn't end up going...
These kids deserve to be proud of their school, as should all kids. But, we should acknowledge that it's not an accident that the most resources, attention, and amenities are given to a high school in one of the most snow white communities in Indiana, a segregation very much due to housing discrimination and public racism, not purchaser choice. "...this is a city that also has never elected someone who is not white to serve either as mayor or on city council. Likewise, every department head is white." "In the Carmel Clay School District only 10 out of the more than 1,000 teachers, or less than 1%, are Black. All of the 65 administrators are white. That means young Black people in the community rarely see adults who look like them." "Those factors, as well, as some troubling decisions from the past, have fueled the perception - deserved or not - that Black people are less welcome here. Of the handful of Black Carmel residents IndyStar talked to, most were reluctant to generalize a whole city, but also acknowledged the city's lack of diversity is a problem and that many people they encounter in the city have outdated views of minorities." "They recounted tales of inappropriate jokes in church, the use of racial slurs in schools and experiences of being racially profiled." - The Indianapolis Star, July 12th, 2020
Wow. I grew up in Orange County, CA. Not exactly a slummy area by any means. But this makes my HS look like it’s in the ghetto of a downtown high volume city when it’s actually a suburban, high value home area. Despite having one of the best performing arts programs in the state- we had to bus 30 min to a different school in our district to use their auditorium. Our “home” games for football & swim were at neighboring schools due to not having a stadium or pool. Our SAT scores & overall gpa’s were also top in district of 12 schools. But I never even knew how crappy our school was until I visited other states as an adult.
IF you pay for schools with property taxes, it helps to not cap the property tax rate at a set amount each year like California did with Prop 13. You still have to budget smartly and not throw money at pork projects and board member's friends being developers/builders but the cash comes in easier.
I think we need to be more upset that this isn't the standard...not that it's so much nicer. Why is this not the standard Highschool in America? We're a wealthy enough nation that it should be.
@@Loquacious_Jackson The description of the video talks about this being a case of inequity, and many of the comments claim this school district is being treated more favorably than urban areas. I'm simply proving evidence to the contrary.
@@Loquacious_Jackson ...I actually looked up these numbers...he's entirely correct. Let me give you a hint...just because you don't want it to be true doesn't mean it isn't. Grow up...
Indiana has the 4th most equitable school funding in the country. Carmel gets 40% less funding per student than the inner city schools in Indianapolis. Their parents and their culture are why they are successful.
That’s past mall and approaching town status! That much stuff should be able to pay for itself, if you want to incorporate in some business management.
To be able to solve the schooling problem (and healthcare, social welfare etc.) you need to stop your phobia of high taxes. In order for that to become true, you must get rid of corruption (i. e. non tax funding, including political campaigns). That's difficult in a country like the US, where so few people have experience of a non-corrupt system, with publicly funded political campaigns. Companies shouldn't be allowed to fund stuff at all with un-taxed money. They should pay higher taxes instead. Without trust in the spending of public money, things will never be better. And throw away your ridiculously outdated constitution... Start looking at other countries that have done things better than the US for ages
@@markbenjamin1703 the $10k figure is on average across the entire district and this school is the crown jewel getting the majority of the funding. Another explanation is if a lot of those facilities were donated by wealthy alumni and don't count in their $10k figure. There is no way Carmel Clay does not benefit from substantial spending from PTAs and individuals which aren't counted in their per pupil spending. It's easy to not spend a lot when others buy you stuff. Carmel Clay, Indiana median household income: $105,720. Baltimore, MD median household income: $54,124.
Info to a school in a rural area with only 1,100. They recently started adding on a 2nd gym to our schoo, which I though was a lot, but after seeing this school, I’m blown by how amazing the facilities are.
If you want better for your kids then do something about it. I live in a fairly poor rural area, yet we have a fabulous school system. Why? Because the people and businesses in this area take pride in the school system and support the kids. People step up and help out where needed and offer financial what they can. Not everything is about race. Sometimes it’s priorities that are lacking.
...completely agree. People are complaining about race...about it being "rich"...ect. If anyone cares to look into this Carmel HS spends roughly 10K a year per student. Compare that to city schools like Baltimore or Boston...where they spend roughly $25K per student per year. To me this schools speaks volumes about what can be if the community, faculty and students care about school.
What is astonishing is that they spend $9,000 per student per year. Chicago schools have spent in the area of $29,000 per student. Where does it all go?
It starts with two-parent homes, parent involvement, self-respect, and respect for others. School Pride and dignity before the first brick is laid. This school has 5K+ students. A school with 500 students could have the same thing but the investment begins with the character of faculty, staff, parents, students, school board, and community.
as someone who lives in central indiana, carmel has gained a large reputation for being an interesting and rich area. ask ANYONE who lives/lived in indiana and theyll tell you stories/experiences from there haha
I graduated out of class of only 12 people from a school so small theres only two hallways. One for elementary students and the other for middle and high school students and the school's football team is a 6-man. These kids are lucky, i wish i had as many educational options as them
Your educational opportunities fall squarely on your parents and on you. Even homeschooling parents are giving their children amazing educations with very little. If you didn't do well from learning to read and learning basic math... then you just don't make the cut.
@@laborincana4490 poor people are poor in the US because they choose to be, yes. I was “poor” until 30, when I finally became a nurse. I worked my butt off and supported myself to EARN a better life. Am I rich? Not even close. I earn a very modest living, but I spend significantly less money on “non-essentials” than people who earn even less than I do. It’s basic math.... with is taught in basic schools, not just fancy ones.
@@katiejon17 it always amazes me to come across people with your ignorant beliefs, no understanding of how different people have different life experiences, and yet you are a NURSE. I feel for anyone under your care that you may see as beneath you!!! You clearly have a dislike for certain people different than yourself and I worry how many patients have lost life at your hands?!? Believe it or not, if people had a choice no one would CHOOSE TO BE POOR. White Americans have a far better advantage in many areas wether you choose to believe it or not. The eyes will never see what the mind chooses to remain blind to.
Wonderful a school looks like is, tragic all schools don’t, but it’s certainly unfair that schools I see on a daily basis are run down while this is better than many colleges.
This is what funding from property taxes gets you. Or you could live by a giant refinery that has a permanent tax easement and be lucky to get used books. Great system 😒
Shouldn't all these taxes throughout the whole state just get equally distributed amongst the districts based on population. I feel like that'd be a lot more fair. Smaller cities don't need as much funding because they don't have as many students or teachers but the inner city schools have large populations of students and teachers so they need the most money.
Inequality in public schools exists because funding for public schools is one of the first things cut from budgets by politicians and predictably the poorest areas suffer the most and some random wealthy schools sneak through without losing funds because wealthy parents either pay to make up the difference or pay to keep their funding in place.
I'd be mad too if my democrat led Baltimore city spent 21k per student vs 9k per student in Carmel and this were the result. Imagine being mad at socially prudent and responsible programs 🤣
I can't begrudge them for their advantage, but I hope they are aware of it and will vote Progressive so other communities can get the same kind of advantages and head starts. Another question: is _everything_ indoors?
@@sillybilly121212 , yeah, it's called sharing. And it can be equally good, depending on your attitude. It's important to give the future generations equal opportunities for their talent, abilities to develop and find their place to contribute to a civilised world (or towards a more civilised world). And when it comes to _public_ schools, the funds and resources should be divvied out evenly through the communities. America has more than enough to do this.
@@sillybilly121212 , so Carmel paid for that whole school. No state of federal funding awarded to them? Or maybe state and federal funds were poured in elsewhere so that Carmel got to save its money and pour into a school. Oh. Which country is the richest? And by what metric? I would say that there is economic disparity, for sure. Sharing is voluntary. But voting so that everyone is taxed fairly, and those taxes get to education instead of wasted spending is taking care of the future of the country, and its democracy (as opposed to an oligarchy which is what we've become).
@@MB-jz3uu Do you trust the same people in power to facilitate “more fair” education though..? Or even the same dinosaur institutions that have been ruining things since at least the 80s?
My high school is literally two hallways, upstairs and downstairs, lockers and classrooms all the way down the halls. And this school is basically a college campus.
That entire town throws money around like it’s no thing at all. Their football stadium can seat 6,000 people. It’s a little over the top compared to my little school. It was good but we didn’t have nearly as nice stuff as this. Low population density will do that. Our teachers did well with what they had. And let’s not lie, by what they contributed from their own pockets too.
The education system is very well funded. If the local politicians and school boards weren't so corrupt and the members weren't lining their pockets there would be a lot more "good schools".
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 88 | คู่เอก "ป้อมเพชร vs อัสลามจอน"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1ZqTVVbMgbo/mqdefault.jpg)
This is better than some colleges
🤡
I was wondering if they'd taken over an old college campus, goodness
Topped all 3 universities I spent over 80k on.
I have no doubt when I look at the real estate surrounding this area it's no less than 500k per house.
@@Wordsworth11my in laws live in the area. I live very close by. It’s incredibly wealthy.
In my high school you needed to fight a raccoon to get to first class on time.
At least he hasn't been stolen by the Russians .. yet :). Take Care and Best Wishes!
Or played by the 🕎 zelensky like the sucka Ukrainians.
🤣
Sure it wasn’t rocket
I choked on air just now 🤣
Fund schools properly instead of poorly like they do all over the country, maybe we could have more schools like this, which would lead to more students who want to go to school, and maybe countering the trend of anti-education and anti-intellectual people that our country is bursting with right now.
we would need to change the way schools are funded. right now, they are supported mostly by local property taxes, which means that wealthy places get wealthy schools, which perpetuates the wealth cycle.
we would need to shift funding more onto the federal budget. this would also create justification for a more uniform standard across the country.
@@sebcw1204 I think these all sound like good ideas.
@@sebcw1204 Exactly! There should be universal, equitable funding for all public K-12 schools, with budget tweaks based on local costs for building, equipment, and supplies.
What most of the naysayers here don't seem to comprehend is that not only do wealthy areas have more property taxes for schools, they also do much better when fundraising for additional income. Even if we iron out the former, they will still have the latter, so they won't suffer, ffs.
this should be the standard for all highschools in America. It could easily be done with just a fraction of the Defense budget.
This school has 5.5k kids. They spend $9k per kid as opposed to Baltimore schools that have 2k kids and spend $21k per child to educate them. They don't spend more on these kids. they just have 2x the number of other public schools.
As a student at a rival Indiana High School, we all are extremely jealous of Carmel and their massive school. It’s not just their building that benefits from the massive funding, but all of their programs as well.
I would then ask, how much are the parents involved compared to your school?
does youre school come close too this on scale level?
have you thought of joining that school?
Our enrollment is about half of theirs, and no way lol.
@@greyson2150 what school? North central?
i mean yea, wealth and privilege can raise people of mediocre talent and limited intelligence to remarkable heights.
Graduated from CHS in 2016. School had more students and was nicer than my college, not to mention was more difficult. I took the auto shop class for two years, and after getting a 4 year business degree I decided to become a mechanic anyway. Great school with great opportunities for success. Everyone should be so fortunate.
I spent two years at a school that was half condemned. Just past my class were fire doors chained shut. Lead paint held the rest together. Next year they condemned it all and set-up a makeshift school in closed-down factory. Eventually they gave-up and shipped us all to the next county and combined three or four schools in an existing one.
We didn't even have a library till the last one. In the factory (school) the girls used the staff bathroom because there was just the one for workers and one where the offices were.
Jesus. That broke my heart
So what? I went to school in the ghetto and became an engineer. Quitchabitchin and hit the books!
Builds character
your community created it's own reality. Just like the community of Carmel High School has created their own reality.
Blacks don't value each other's lives. They kill each other in the streets everyday, drive-by shootings that stray bullets kill little children and then later they brag about it. No surprise they don't value education either.
All schools need to be like this!
Not feasible
So what you are really saying is all districts need to be like Carmel. Super rich and super white.
@@always_markb Go read a book for once, it’ll do you a favor.
@@fight8the8feeling8 i live there, shut up :)
@@always_markb You live in a book?
proof we need to stop funding schools based on property tax and distribute this wealth to other kids who are equally deserving.
Proof that the government needs to stop cutting budgets to educations so they just rely on property or sales tax
Agreed!
@@EpsteinDidntKillHimself187 that's not how school funding works. your children are not invested in by individual participation, they are funded by taxes gathered from property value. this school exists in a high wealth bubble. the constitution places the burden of education on the government, not the parents.
@@EpsteinDidntKillHimself187 rofl yup
@@sebcw1204 The school district's tax base is a reflection of the values and work ethic of its residents. Carmel used to be tiny little nothing. In a few decades, the people congregating there have turned it into a small city that most applaud yet others can only leer at with jealous contempt.
Besides the school only spending 10k per kid, there’s 5,000 students that go to that school. Instead of hating on the school maybe find out how they allocate their funds and find out how the city of Carmel was able to build such a school. Then take that information back to your city and see what can be done to make your schools better. Geez the envy!!
You are right
I agree, you are right
Spot on. This same school could have been built in any US inner-city by grant, and the community would have destroyed it. This is a culture and a mindset. And people are salty because they want to keep behaving a certain way, but they want the benefits that come with different choices. In such situations, we reap what we sow. They aren't sowing to reap such a school.
carmel seems like a forward thinking place, from what i can tell they implemented roundabouts to improve traffic flow, you don't see that much anywhere else in american cities or towns
Absolutely, nailed it
I read that others think since Carmel is such an affluent area, the schools gets all the funds from the city. Wrong. Carmel High School is way more underfunded than the inner city schools by far. It has to do with the parents demanding quality schools, teachers and administration. Along with law enforcement. Clay township schools meets these demands put on by the parents in the city. Alot of parents also volunteer their own time to assist in making this school as good as it is by demanding their kids perform in school.
Just going through the neighborhoods near that HS I can tell you that Carmel HS is in a really rich area with nice houses and such which explains why they have such a nice high school. Wish I had a HS with all those things mentioned in the video.
They look a lot smaller than most houses in affluent suburbs, actually. The school is most likely a product of COVID money paired with cheap costs.
The neighborhood is wealthier than the average neighborhood, at a median income of $109k but the houses seem normal sized. The school just looks nicer.
This school only funds $9k a year per student. This is a cultural issue. The community CHOSE (by how they vote) to appropriately allocate funds, then they raise kids who have self respect and respect for property. So they take care of their school. If this same exact school was built in any inner-city by donated funds, the community would ruin it within a few years. Want a better life? Create better families and then move to where others do the same. We did - there was no way I was going to raise my family in Detroit. I moved and raise my children around people with the same VALUES. We live in a "white" community.
This school actually receives 6k less in funding per student than nearby black schools and still has better amenities due to better management.
@@katiejon17 Katie, wow! Racist much?!
I pray that God softens your heart, so that you can give up your racists ways. And if God won't soften your heart, I pray that God stops it, so you can go to heaven and no longer spread your racists thoughts.
nope. Carmel is larger than you’d expect and is extremely wealthy. The west side of the city is covered in huge gated estates. A “small” affordable house in Carmel is about 3000 sq ft and $500-600k. The average price for a home in Carmel is like $450k.
This is how every school should be
With 5x as much spent on athletic facilities as academic?
@@chasef89Answer: NO
But also: if you are “fiscally conservative” - and against “socialism” - then: you want schools to become Private schools only?
And watch as our nation continues to circle the drain ⭕️ 💦
- Trickle Down Economics doesn’t work and never did and never will. Why? Because Greed disguises itself in slogans of
“I don’t want my tax money helping Anyone else.
Seems unfair.”
N I T W I T S
nah this is excessive for a high school.
Nobody needs this. HS is for basic education.
@@chasef89 yea you right about that
I was astonished to read that they spend $9k per student and some inner city district spend more like 15 to even 30k per student. Where do they spend all that money on where the school with the planetarium and cathedral hallways spends less? It's not the money afterall. This school is not well funded. It's well run.
teachers
It’s crazy, all students should get the opportunity to go to schools like this. Lots of high schools in Fishers and Carmel Indiana look like this and it’s a great privilege.
Its because those students care about their education. This indiana school costs much less than your typical NYC public school. The latter is disgusting and trashy, yet has greater expenses... curious what the difference could be....
@@va1hk I really doubt that lmao, this is about as expensive as a high school could possibly be. Do you have any numbers for it
@@alleghanyonce NYC schools receive about 30,000 dollars per student, while for Carmel its about 10,000 dollars. With this knowledge one could only assume NYC has similar if not more expansive educational facilities for k-12, yet that is not the case. T
@@va1hkwhat might the difference be?
@@JMG0305 That's for you to decide, but there are prominent common variables that could help you deduct it.
This is what little corruption will get you
I went to Carmel. Grew up here. This city has changed soooooo much since I went to CHS. I've never seen some of the stuff they've added since I went there. Crazy overpopulated school. You can't even walk around in that school or find a place to sit and eat lunch sometimes (there's around 5,000 students). My graduating class had roughly 1,100. I never graduated myself though, huge missed opportunity.
I was curious. How is the racial diversity there? Because, just from watching this video, it seemed pretty Caucasian.
I was actually watching to see if they had at least one person who wasn't white promoting the school, and they had only one.
@@henrytawnn8694 it is obviously not going to be very diverse. You don’t see schools in the ghetto half as well funded as this.
@@ousarlxsfjsbvbg8588 It was pretty much what I was expecting. I went to school in a small town in Missouri and my school was pretty diverse, but we had many budget cuts and removed classes and after school clubs because of it.
So, seeing a school like this is just such a shock to me.
@@henrytawnn8694 Hello. What do you mean by shock after watching this video? I think we should be happy because the students get the best facilities that school can offer. I hope the school across your country has the similar facilities like CHS but I don't think we should not be happy for the students who studying in CHS.
About the diversity, what if in that neighborhood the majority is caucasian? I think there's also a high school in the US that the students are Black majority and as foreigners I don't see any problem with that.
@@Gilang-Ramadhan There are tens of thousands of schools that don't have anywhere near the facilities and expenses of CHS. The shock is that there should be more schools like this, all over the country, in every community, not just the predominantly white and wealthy ones.
Many schools have to make budget cuts, cut classes, or don't have the funding for after school club activities, like mine did.
I don't have an issue with that school getting an amazing working environment, which should help with learning. The issue is that tens of thousands of schools aren't. Not even close. And you don't even need to take a wild guess at which communities tend to have less educational budgets. We both already know that answer.
This should only be viral to show the cast system we've tolerated.
Carmel spends less per student than Indianapolis yet all of those schools are failing. It's the household culture of the families not a cast system. 71% of Carmel students are above average, they earned that school.
With 5,000 students I’m sure the entire cast system is represented.
@Kruimeltje What if your values don't align with that of the Republican Party? Wait...here comes the "Then vote third party" response. Yes, that will work.
@@AmandaFromWisconsinwhat are your values?
If public schools were paid throgh state income taxes or sales tax there would not be so much inequality of High Schools when most of their funding comes from Property taxes.
federal would be better. that way no state could tank their kids future in a gambit to make them more susceptible to campaign lies.
No, it would make it worst. Burden will go on poor family’s not able to spend extra for take out or goods
Or an even property tax across the board pulled into a state fund and divided on a per capita basis. I'm priced out of the neighborhoods with good schools. All a rated schools in ohio are not open enrollment either.
This school district in Indiana spends $10.3K per student. Less than half what is spent on Baltimore public schools
In many cases the districts mismanage their funds. Especially in school districts that have crazy bureaucracy not to mention that property tax is more consistent than sales or income tax. Property tax is easier across the board.
Wealthy zip code
Not really. Their median house price is only 300ish k. That’s extremely low.
9k per student Vs Baltimore's 21k per student
@@Crystalbomb321 The average income is 120k. More than half of the country lives off less than 50k.
There is no way Carmel Clay does not benefit from substantial spending from PTAs and individuals which aren't counted in their per pupil spending. It's easy to not spend a lot when others buy you stuff.
Carmel Clay, Indiana median household income: $105,720.
Baltimore, MD median household income: $54,124.
Tax money being well spent.
A highschool in Indianapolis I went to, called Franklin central was JUST like this. Had the TV, and radio stations. They played the radio until 2 minutes before the bell rang between classes, and the TV was how we got our announcements. They also had 2 cafeterias, and a basement with the pool,, along with 2 other stories. They also had a market in the cafeterias. It was AWESOME! Went there part of my freshman year in 2009. Loved it.
I didn't live in a nice, rich area either, but that was the school I had to go to.
I went to this high school - but before many of these things existed. The school has had 3 major expansions, 1978, 1991, and 1994 plus other expansions for the sports facilities. Nice that these students can show off these amenities and a few of them actually get that this is atypical.
There are ppl on here that are actually unhappy about these kids having faciltiies like this. Hater-ade.
Yeah I totally miss Carmel
i mean yea, wealth and privilege can raise people of mediocre talent and limited intelligence to remarkable heights.
As a person who lived in Carmel, the school was and still is massive and chaotic but still really fun.
Yearly cost per student...under $10,000 which is FAR less than many schools. Also keep in mind that there are almost 6,000 students which explains why they have more than one gym and so many specialty rooms. Most of all, the "customers" (parents) are mostly republicans so they don't put up with waste, fraud and abuse by administrators.
Exactly. You could waste more money easily on people instead of facilities.
seems like theyre not wasting another 10k per student through restorative justice policies or administrators etc lol
Not one pride flag in sight
Sadly HSE and Fishers can’t say the same
FYI, Carmel is one of the schools we faced for sports in our school’s division. You want to talk about some of the most snobby, entitled kids I’ve ever met? Carmel is the kind of town that looks you up and down before they would ever say hello. And I think this video shows all of us from surrounding high schools just how much privilege and special treatment they get for having lived in a area with just a couple more wealthy people. It’s sickening. Especially when my school has had professional sports players and Olympic athletes as alum, it doesn’t make any sense to me why our school doesn’t have enough funding for like half of this.
Get over yourself 😂😂😂😂
I'll be okay with more auto shop, woodshed and electronic classes gotta learn a trade early
@@doncarlo4576 and i can definitely get behind that idea. Anything possible to help adolescents into adulthood and enter society easier. But our school had to create a whole program just to bus students to another high school so they could have a chance at classes like shop or vocational trainings or even certain science courses. And some schools around here aren’t even given that chance.
@@isailevilopez5134 Found the deep throater, get those boots out of your mouth son.
It’s the only school in that area with about 6,000 students to accommodate to, of course it’s going to have a lot of options
A nice safe 95% white area to live.
Poor kids, no gangs, no murders, low drug rates...Can they survive the inequality compared to Baltimore and Chicago schools?
Nice to live in a rich community that is mostly white. Republicans really know how to treat white kids.
I saw a couple black kids in the gym.
This school district in Indiana spends $10.3K per student. Less than half what is spent on Baltimore public schools..
@@tonys7524 He doesn't care. He wants to shake a fist a Whitey.
yeah, pretty much. Sorry white people are successful and care about their kids?
Mostly white community is generally having lesser crime rate
There is no way Carmel Clay does not benefit from substantial spending from PTAs and individuals which aren't counted in their per pupil spending. It's easy to not spend a lot when others buy you stuff.
Almost certainly do. That’s off the books though 🤫
@@dannyfa7x if a school benefits from the generosity of of the community that too bad. I bought my kids class ipads. Other classes, other schools didn't get them. How's that my problem?
@@brunonaccarato6219 it’s not a bad thing. But when lots of donations and help are coming in and it’s not reported it makes it seem like Carmel is doing more with less per student.
I’ve already seen this thread full of people saying well this inner city school spends more per kid than Carmel and look at all the problems. If it were shared info it would give a more realistic spending per student than what’s reported to slow down the dummies.
It’s obviously a lot deeper than just funding for what makes a school good or bad. I’m glad you could afford that. Not a lot of teachers I know and knew could do such things.
@@dannyfa7x I'm not a teacher. I'm a parent doing whats best for his daughters. I'm aware my viewpoint isn't fair. However, 2 schools A & B get $6k per student in government funding, thats fair, thats equality. If school B gets $5k per student in donations to bad for A. It can't be equalized. Taking anything from B to offset the difference is theft. I deliberately work towards giving my kids advantages. I'm not unique. I'm troubled when race is introduced. I bought ipads. Were all the students recieving them white? The other class didn't get new ipads. Were all those students black?
Frankly I don't know and I don't care. Is that racist?
Government allocation should be equal and likewise colorblind, anything else is racist.
@@brunonaccarato6219 colorblindness is racist you dolt.
This is what happens when educational funding is based on the surrounding property value. So do yourselves a favor and make sure you have a few million in your back pocket so your kid can go to fully funded school
This school district in Indiana spends $10.3K per student. Less than half what is spent on Baltimore public schools.
@@sillybilly121212 fr even though they don't actually deserve it
@@sillybilly121212 lol enjoy that boot. I love working class people they worship the rich and act like the system isn’t completely one sided. Lol these clowns are hilarious
@@sillybilly121212 yeah I’d love that. No reason anyone should have 100 billion while people have none. I’m glad you understand that
@Lèmon Lēe lol you googled how much is spend on a child in Baltimore and ripped that figure from the super reputable Daytona247now and reporting from Fox News who in court has stated they are not news and they shouldn’t be believed but you do you.
My daughters started school here in the suburbs. And it's absolutely disgusting how badly funded they were in the city compared to their new school. There are only 40 students in their new school, and the school looks like what's in this vide. It's wild.
are all private schools like this level? or is this like at the top of the chain.
@@Dwight_ my daughters go to a public school. It's in a very good neighborhood though. We live on 150 acre farm and most our neighbors are affluent. It's no wonder folks in the suburbs are more likely to succeed... Wealthy folks are clueless to how everyone else is doing, the financial divide makes it almost unfair, to be born without money...
@@Dwight_This is a public school in the video. The private schools are probably nicer
ha, if people got triggered by this high-school, you should check out some of the middle schools and high schools in Texas.
Went to a school similar by accident when I was put in a Group home from out of the Urban City...It was amazing. I miss the people there and how it was 🙏
Please explain by accident thanks you. Did you graduate? Or did you keep up with the people. So many questions but lets start there.
The demographics for Carmel, IN is sobering
AKA winning. Good culture breeds good values and outcomes.
@@sillybilly121212 you can breed culture. you can breed children differently as well, but there has to be some will to do so. which is the difference.
@@sillybilly121212if only people understood that…
It’s a culture problem. No matter how much money you give to trash, very little of it will turn out will.
Some of it might, but the rest will be the same pipeline
their girls swimming has won 37 straight state championships….
I went to two high schools one in nyc which was Queens vocational high school it had no gym and no cafeteria gym was outside and in the auditorium if it rained we called it the cafetorium 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️ and I went to Reading senior high in Reading pa that looked just like this plus there were pools it was valued at 60million when I went like 20 years ago🤦🏽♀️ I wish all schools were like that
Reading high definitely has some of these amenities but the school is like 100 years old in parts! My mom told me the pool was closed when she went in the 60s, because it was so old it needed to be renovated. I agree RHS is atypical, but only cause it was built when education was well funded
What equality? It is a school with over 3000 students. That is a reasonable size for so many students.
Way more. It's edging towards 6,000.
My graduating class was 176 lol
Jesus. This high school is nicer than my university.
dont be whining and trying to make the school worse because they actually spend the money they get properly. they make proper use of their money and spend less than most of the other schools with only around 9k per student.
It boils down to culture, not money.
More like politics
@@ryanadams0922 Blue states (CA, MA, NJ) do the best in education, yet plenty of red states are the exemptions that disprove the rule. Indiana being one of them. Meanwhile, red states (LA, AL, MS) have the worst education systems in the country, yet there are the Blue states that disprove the rule. New Mexico is one of them. Almost as if politics has little correlation with educational success.
Yep, 100%
fyi this is what public schools should be.for everyone
I've been there it's pretty cool and the volunteers students we got for our competition awesome. Keep up the good work, teachers and staff. And schoolboard
I was supposed to go to this school until I moved away right before the year started (literally chose my courses and everything). 2 years later, one of my new friends found this video and told me he felt really bad for me cause I didn't end up going...
These kids deserve to be proud of their school, as should all kids.
But, we should acknowledge that it's not an accident that the most resources, attention, and amenities are given to a high school in one of the most snow white communities in Indiana, a segregation very much due to housing discrimination and public racism, not purchaser choice.
"...this is a city that also has never elected someone who is not white to serve either as mayor or on city council. Likewise, every department head is white."
"In the Carmel Clay School District only 10 out of the more than 1,000 teachers, or less than 1%, are Black. All of the 65 administrators are white. That means young Black people in the community rarely see adults who look like them."
"Those factors, as well, as some troubling decisions from the past, have fueled the perception - deserved or not - that Black people are less welcome here. Of the handful of Black Carmel residents IndyStar talked to, most were reluctant to generalize a whole city, but also acknowledged the city's lack of diversity is a problem and that many people they encounter in the city have outdated views of minorities."
"They recounted tales of inappropriate jokes in church, the use of racial slurs in schools and experiences of being racially profiled." - The Indianapolis Star, July 12th, 2020
Why is there always a laser focus on black people, as though black people are the only non-white race on Earth?
😂
I graduated from Carmel High School in the 1970’s. Only the Dale Graham Auditorium (the namesake was an excellent principal) looks familiar to me.
$9k per student Vs $21k per student in Baltimore PS. Demographics and culture play a larger role in people in the way they appreciate and treat things
Hahaha this video has horribly back fired according to the comments... everyone is right schools are under funded in most areas of country..
it started a conversation. so it was actually 100% successful.
@@always_markb Not from their perspective...
I doubt they'll dismantle all their amenities because of the comments.
Wait. How did it backfire again?
Wow. I grew up in Orange County, CA. Not exactly a slummy area by any means. But this makes my HS look like it’s in the ghetto of a downtown high volume city when it’s actually a suburban, high value home area.
Despite having one of the best performing arts programs in the state- we had to bus 30 min to a different school in our district to use their auditorium. Our “home” games for football & swim were at neighboring schools due to not having a stadium or pool. Our SAT scores & overall gpa’s were also top in district of 12 schools. But I never even knew how crappy our school was until I visited other states as an adult.
IF you pay for schools with property taxes, it helps to not cap the property tax rate at a set amount each year like California did with Prop 13. You still have to budget smartly and not throw money at pork projects and board member's friends being developers/builders but the cash comes in easier.
for those that don't know... caramel, indiana is like the wealthiest city in the WHOLE state.
Correction, one of the ten wealthiest suburbs in the NATION.
The Geist area in fishers beats Carmel. But all this makes Hamilton county one of the wealthiest counties in the country
I think we need to be more upset that this isn't the standard...not that it's so much nicer.
Why is this not the standard Highschool in America? We're a wealthy enough nation that it should be.
The problem isn't funding.
This school district in Indiana spends $10.3K per student. Less than half what is spent on Baltimore public schools.
What are you implying?
@@Loquacious_Jackson The description of the video talks about this being a case of inequity, and many of the comments claim this school district is being treated more favorably than urban areas. I'm simply proving evidence to the contrary.
@@tonys7524 reported for misinformation
@@Loquacious_Jackson ...I actually looked up these numbers...he's entirely correct. Let me give you a hint...just because you don't want it to be true doesn't mean it isn't. Grow up...
@@KingNicotine racist
Carmel is one of the richest areas in ALL of Indiana.
Indiana has the 4th most equitable school funding in the country. Carmel gets 40% less funding per student than the inner city schools in Indianapolis. Their parents and their culture are why they are successful.
And this is our one non white kid.
That’s past mall and approaching town status! That much stuff should be able to pay for itself, if you want to incorporate in some business management.
please no, we have enough tax funded business making profit off the back of the taxpayers.
Schools like these exist when funds are properly used. Ask your school where and how they use the funds.
Oh wow, that school is fantastic, very new age. Well done to all those kids that made this awesome video, you all look so proud. 🥰
To be able to solve the schooling problem (and healthcare, social welfare etc.) you need to stop your phobia of high taxes.
In order for that to become true, you must get rid of corruption (i. e. non tax funding, including political campaigns).
That's difficult in a country like the US, where so few people have experience of a non-corrupt system, with publicly funded political campaigns.
Companies shouldn't be allowed to fund stuff at all with un-taxed money. They should pay higher taxes instead.
Without trust in the spending of public money, things will never be better.
And throw away your ridiculously outdated constitution...
Start looking at other countries that have done things better than the US for ages
My highschool didn't any of those nice things.
Nor mine, but they are doing something right. Only $9k per student, so it is worth finding out if something people can replicate within reason.
WHY IS IT SO BIG! IT’S INSANE!
Average annual income in this area is 120k and its 80% white.
9k per student Vs Baltimore's 21k per student
@@markbenjamin1703 the $10k figure is on average across the entire district and this school is the crown jewel getting the majority of the funding.
Another explanation is if a lot of those facilities were donated by wealthy alumni and don't count in their $10k figure. There is no way Carmel Clay does not benefit from substantial spending from PTAs and individuals which aren't counted in their per pupil spending. It's easy to not spend a lot when others buy you stuff.
Carmel Clay, Indiana median household income: $105,720.
Baltimore, MD median household income: $54,124.
@@CassVanCat The state of Indiana is 85% White so Whites are actually underrepresented
@@markbenjamin1703 again the income tax difference is more important than that number. Also the cost of living is different.
Info to a school in a rural area with only 1,100. They recently started adding on a 2nd gym to our schoo, which I though was a lot, but after seeing this school, I’m blown by how amazing the facilities are.
All schools in America should have the facilities of this one.
If you want better for your kids then do something about it. I live in a fairly poor rural area, yet we have a fabulous school system. Why? Because the people and businesses in this area take pride in the school system and support the kids. People step up and help out where needed and offer financial what they can. Not everything is about race. Sometimes it’s priorities that are lacking.
...completely agree. People are complaining about race...about it being "rich"...ect. If anyone cares to look into this Carmel HS spends roughly 10K a year per student. Compare that to city schools like Baltimore or Boston...where they spend roughly $25K per student per year. To me this schools speaks volumes about what can be if the community, faculty and students care about school.
Sounds like you're implying that people of color don't take pride in their schooling and facilities. Have to disagree with you here.
That school is the size of two or three small American towns.
What is astonishing is that they spend $9,000 per student per year. Chicago schools have spent in the area of $29,000 per student. Where does it all go?
It looks like how TV producers think high schools look
I went to a high school similar to this one except no live radio we had pools and agriculture which was really nice.
This is in fckn Indiana?
Here question how are schools across nation spending their funds?
It certainly appears that this school district does a better job of budgeting than inferior school systems that spend twice as much.
This is a HIGH SCHOOL?? I’ve seen universities that aren’t even this nice!
Good
This is phenomenal!
This is bs
It starts with two-parent homes, parent involvement, self-respect, and respect for others. School Pride and dignity before the first brick is laid. This school has 5K+ students. A school with 500 students could have the same thing but the investment begins with the character of faculty, staff, parents, students, school board, and community.
I'm not going to complain like the rest of you. School's architecture didn't matter all that much to me.
it'd be cool if they focused a little more on the education aspect of school but whatever I guess.
as someone who lives in central indiana, carmel has gained a large reputation for being an interesting and rich area. ask ANYONE who lives/lived in indiana and theyll tell you stories/experiences from there haha
Especially minorities. They have wonderful tales from Carmel/Hamilton County
I graduated out of class of only 12 people from a school so small theres only two hallways. One for elementary students and the other for middle and high school students and the school's football team is a 6-man. These kids are lucky, i wish i had as many educational options as them
Most kids here accept the fact they are lucky to have a school like this. High Schools in central Indiana are just downright massive
Your educational opportunities fall squarely on your parents and on you. Even homeschooling parents are giving their children amazing educations with very little. If you didn't do well from learning to read and learning basic math... then you just don't make the cut.
@@katiejon17 i guess you are a neoliberal that blames poor people for being poor. You're the one who needs to read more.
@@laborincana4490 poor people are poor in the US because they choose to be, yes. I was “poor” until 30, when I finally became a nurse. I worked my butt off and supported myself to EARN a better life. Am I rich? Not even close. I earn a very modest living, but I spend significantly less money on “non-essentials” than people who earn even less than I do. It’s basic math.... with is taught in basic schools, not just fancy ones.
@@katiejon17 it always amazes me to come across people with your ignorant beliefs, no understanding of how different people have different life experiences, and yet you are a NURSE. I feel for anyone under your care that you may see as beneath you!!! You clearly have a dislike for certain people different than yourself and I worry how many patients have lost life at your hands?!? Believe it or not, if people had a choice no one would CHOOSE TO BE POOR. White Americans have a far better advantage in many areas wether you choose to believe it or not. The eyes will never see what the mind chooses to remain blind to.
Wonderful a school looks like is, tragic all schools don’t, but it’s certainly unfair that schools I see on a daily basis are run down while this is better than many colleges.
4 gyms is ridiculous but if there's like 5000 kids there then it makes sense
This is what funding from property taxes gets you. Or you could live by a giant refinery that has a permanent tax easement and be lucky to get used books. Great system 😒
This comment deserves 1000 likes.
Shouldn't all these taxes throughout the whole state just get equally distributed amongst the districts based on population. I feel like that'd be a lot more fair. Smaller cities don't need as much funding because they don't have as many students or teachers but the inner city schools have large populations of students and teachers so they need the most money.
Inequality in public schools exists because funding for public schools is one of the first things cut from budgets by politicians and predictably the poorest areas suffer the most and some random wealthy schools sneak through without losing funds because wealthy parents either pay to make up the difference or pay to keep their funding in place.
I'd be mad too if my democrat led Baltimore city spent 21k per student vs 9k per student in Carmel and this were the result. Imagine being mad at socially prudent and responsible programs 🤣
Ngl I’m mad why I didn’t come here nkt once black person 😭
Imagine how long it takes to walk between classes there
Lmao they probably have a transportation service too 😂
we don’t have transports and passing period is only ten minutes but like she said the freshmen center has all the classes in one area
10 minute passing periods, which you really do need, especially because the traffic gets really bad.
I swam against Carmel swim club, even the swimmers are swanky
fight back we win
I can't begrudge them for their advantage, but I hope they are aware of it and will vote Progressive so other communities can get the same kind of advantages and head starts. Another question: is _everything_ indoors?
@@sillybilly121212 , yeah, it's called sharing. And it can be equally good, depending on your attitude. It's important to give the future generations equal opportunities for their talent, abilities to develop and find their place to contribute to a civilised world (or towards a more civilised world).
And when it comes to _public_ schools, the funds and resources should be divvied out evenly through the communities. America has more than enough to do this.
@@sillybilly121212 , so Carmel paid for that whole school. No state of federal funding awarded to them? Or maybe state and federal funds were poured in elsewhere so that Carmel got to save its money and pour into a school.
Oh. Which country is the richest? And by what metric? I would say that there is economic disparity, for sure.
Sharing is voluntary. But voting so that everyone is taxed fairly, and those taxes get to education instead of wasted spending is taking care of the future of the country, and its democracy (as opposed to an oligarchy which is what we've become).
I see why some people peak in High School now.
The unfairness of zip code inequalities.
Life ain’t fair bucko. Look at India 😂
@@krisjones4051it isn't but we can do a better job at making it more fair for kids in our country.
@@MB-jz3uu Do you trust the same people in power to facilitate “more fair” education though..? Or even the same dinosaur institutions that have been ruining things since at least the 80s?
I went to a good public high school (academically) and we didn’t have any special amenities. Our football team played on a patch of messed up grass.
Umm how come they get so much funding to build such a beautiful high school?
They really don't they just spend their money wisely
My high school is literally two hallways, upstairs and downstairs, lockers and classrooms all the way down the halls. And this school is basically a college campus.
Fantastic tour guides
That entire town throws money around like it’s no thing at all. Their football stadium can seat 6,000 people.
It’s a little over the top compared to my little school. It was good but we didn’t have nearly as nice stuff as this. Low population density will do that.
Our teachers did well with what they had. And let’s not lie, by what they contributed from their own pockets too.
WTF I love republican states now.
The education system is very well funded. If the local politicians and school boards weren't so corrupt and the members weren't lining their pockets there would be a lot more "good schools".
That isn’t a HS, that’s a University! Whoa! 😮
What a awesome school
Why is this news ???
It is like this in every country in the world.
Nice places have nice schools
Poor places have poorer schools.