Why the UN Flag is a Bit Bad
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 มี.ค. 2021
- A look at the shortcomings and strengths of the United Nations Flag.
This video was made possible thanks to the generous support of my Patreon members. If you wanna join them in helping to keep my channel going, or simply to get free e-mail updates for all new uploads, Patreon's the place.
/ tapakapa
You can also contribute to the channel with a simple money transfer.
No sign-in, no recurring payments.
donate.stripe.com/00gbJ13A8dw...
MERCH
teespring.com/stores/tapakapa...
SUBREDDIT
/ tapakapa
Sources and Further Reading:
Based on "Branding the United Nations" and "World Flag Encyclopedia"
research.un.org/en/maps/flags
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of...
www.washingtonpost.com/local/...
www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/1...
ubdata.univie.ac.at/AC04791774
commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Fr...
www.fotw.info/flags/uno_honr....
www.fotw.info/flags/so.html
web.archive.org/web/200810101...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk%3A...
www.pantone.com/color-finder/...
#UN #UnitedNations #Flag #HonorFlag
I would never have associated my flag version with either crosswalks or prison bars. Quite a revelation.
See, this is exactly why films have test screenings.
5:35 Only the olive brances shoud do
This is why I like you, you listen to your community and don't just ignore it.
Cool topic! Weird question: Do you know what the march in the outro is called? It slaps, but I don’t recognize it.
I don't like it because it looks like the bars are getting bigger and smaller
*idea put a bar over and connecting the four pillars representing human rights in total, or maybe a pentagram like a roman building. idk.
The problem with your new design is it now looks like jail bars.
If that was the main problem you could just rotate the lines.
@@aktuellyattee8265 Now it looks like a horizontal jail.
@@MrAgLi I don't think horizontal bars work very well at deterring escape; they sorta create a ladder.
Kinda like what being a member of the organization is
Ironic
"The UN flag has a bland design"
*Puts 4 rectangulars on a light blue background*
I like the original
@@Casual2020Enjoyer same Eugene
@@Casual2020Enjoyer me too
@@Casual2020Enjoyer I think he has the right idea but got it wrong.
@@Casual2020Enjoyer Same
I disagree completely, the UN flag is easily reconicable for anyone whom knows what it looks like from a distance. And pretty unique in color in addition.
If anything, just remove the land from the globe and make it be a globe grid earth.
It's not Whom knows, it's Who knows.
whom isn’t really part of the English language anymore
from what globe ? are you denying the fact THE EARTH IS FLAT - even the world leaders can see this
People, whom is very much still a part of the English language, and is completely correct here
I feel the issue with putting the color on the background rather than the pillars is that it creates this illusion of the 4 pillars of freedom being drained of color and then locked behind blue prison bars.
even the UN is getting oversimplified
lol
@@BlaudracheLP Wrong oversimplified, James Pigeon was reffering to oversimplified logos(logos that are oversimplified such as the new fire fox logo)
Honestly is a good one. *(NOT THE FIRE FOX ONE)*
@@teoborges3949 in my opinion the original one is better tbh
So is collapsing
I see your point, but consider this: the current UN emblem looks friendlier than the 4 pillars thing because it's pleasant and round while the pillars are are very angular and almost intimidating looking. Also, the symbolism is way too obscure and abstract for the general population cuz like everyvone knows about the continents, but the 4 basic freedoms is straight up nerd shit lol
The symbolism being easily understood is the most important part. For the talk about the UN flag being unrecognisable at a distance, four pillars is unrecognisable whatsoever if you don't already know what it represents. But a flag with a world and a peace symbol? You don't even have to have heard what the UN even is, you'd still guess what it's about.
The redesigned flag kind of looks like prison bars to me. Probably not the ideal symbolism the UN is looking for. Now that said I am an American so of course it reminds me of prison bars.
I understand his point but in my opinion, I think the UN flag is one of the best especially for what UN wants to represent. And it's more universal than 4 pillars flag, Earth map and peace end.
@@weakspirit_ maybe it's because I'm from Europe but I would rather live somewhere with these 4 basic freedoms than somewhere where they are missing.
And even in European countries sometimes these 4 freedoms are not held 100% which makes me sad..
Thou speaketh truth!
HOLY MOLY A EDUCATIONAL TH-camR WHO SITES THIER SOURCES. Good on ya.
*"UN: Involved in Peace"*
imagine that line but without a colon
The honor flag with the blue and white looks like a corporate logo.
Would be accurate then tho
@@salutic.7544 how?
@@cheekybum1513 bunch of morons who thinks they have the moral high ground.
🗿
I like both designs.
I disagree. Yes, the emblem is kind of difficult to deduce from a distance. But the stark contrast of the coloration (blue and white), which is only shared by one other nation, is more than enough to denote the flag of the United Nations. Also, you oversimplify the flag by removing the world map and replacing it with abstract bars. A flag is to be simple, yes, but it should also be meaningful and indicative of the entity it represents. A world map clearly identifies to anyone, regardless of language, that this flag represents a global organization. Four bars are much more abstract, and meaning is much harder to deduce. I insist that the simplicity of colors makes up for the complexity of the world map, rounding out into what is arguably one of the most easily identified flags in the entire world.
Like the United Kingdom flag, it represents England, Scotland and Northern Ireland combining their flags together but also to signify their unity as they share these isles together.
Or the American Flag with the stars representing the 50-49 States.
Simplicity doesn’t always mean good but it can be used if that simplicity represents something more complex.
dont care didnt ask+ratio+cope+L
Let be honest no one is expecting to be invaded Samalia
@@aaronking2020 dont care didnt ask + ratio+L+cope
@@rageraptor7127 except for Africa, maybe. They kinda do that stuff often.
>Man claims the UN flag is obvious and bland
>Proceeds to change the harmonious-looking icon with a bunch of bars
This is feeling like a cgp gray fever dream
I think you could improve the flag a lot by replacing the map projection with a stylized globe like this 🌐
Cool, no countries, no bias!
That’s too boring
internet flag
But then some countries would be on the other side.
Edit: my comment makes no sense and I don't know how sleep deprived I was when I wrote it. So you can stop responding
That sorta looks like the commonwealth flag aswell.
The UN flag breaks some rules of flag design, but abides by the most important one: if it works, screw the rules. And it works!
The flag of The Most Serene Republic of Venice is one of the most complicated flags out there, but look at it! It's fucking badass and it looks great
Lots of flag people want to make flags an oversimplified corporate logo
@@bobpobcf9723 thats why I hate so called "vexilloigists" they care way too much about weird stuff like the aspect ratio than what it actually looks like
No, he's right that it's kind of indistinct and bland. The symbols are definitely too complex and obvious. "We're representing the world, so let's put a world map on our flag!" "That's a great idea! Say, Chile should do the same thing, but for its map!"
@@bobpobcf9723 simplification isn't always a bad thing
some of the most iconic logos in history are extremely simply. captain america's logo is legitimately just a red white and blue circle with a star in the middle. spider-man's logo is so simple that white triangles over a red circle makes you think of the webslinger, despite it missing the more curved designs and black line patterns
Yeah if you had a vote on these flags and had people choose which one they wanted i guarantee you'd have 90%+ for the current one
Another rule of flag design: People have to actually like how it looks
Does anybody know the name of the tune at the end of the video?
I’d leave the circle with the meridians and parallels and just get rid of the the geographical shapes. It’s the same concept just without the geographical distortion.
this is way better
So a big internet (browser) sign?
@@weakspirit_ then it's a "Geography Teachers Society" (or something). For some reason this shape just associates with maps and geography
Wouldn't it look like a crosshair then?
Nah that's just making a target of the UN flag
„The honor flag is simple and iconic“
Is it bad that I never knew it existed?
I thought it was a German military rank at first lol
@@abdisaniini why german?
@@anopirsten7565 Just thought of Germany first
No, almost no one knows about it lmao
No its the worst flag i could think of other than putting Doritos, mt. Dew, and the cool s on a flag
Funfact, the English used at the UN is British-ish English.
So "programme", "centre" and, most relevant for your video, "honour".
Gotta love the UN’s bright blue colors being used as a “shoot here” icon on peacekeepers’s helmets, completely negating camouflage and providing no protection for UN troops
@A Mothman with a phone the same way you’re not really supposed to shoot people normally, that doesn’t give the UN an excuse to give troops equipment with barely any protection that could and has gotten a lot of peacekeepers killed. The really should’ve just stuck with an armband
I mean, a good flag IS visible and distinguishable. It’s easy to find on a uniform so that you can easily see who that soldier serves. That’s the point. Civilians can easily find the UN troops, that’s a good thing. People fighting against UN troops likewise ought to know, they’re fighting against UN troops. If the enemy is close enough to use the icon as a crosshair, then they probably don’t even need said crosshair
@@Omnominus my issue here is combat troops being thrust into battle with plastic all-blue bucket helmets (like the ones given to Irish soldiers in Jadotville, which I’m pretty sure they decided to not even bother wearing them). For identification, that’s simple solution, out of combat, you’ve got the bright blue arm bands, and in battle, an arm band is easy and not betraying camouflage nearly as much as 20% of the uniform being this useless bright blue piece of plastic easily giving away your position to the enemy.
@@ATFprdepartment They're not going into battle. Most of the time the best way to keep UN soldiers safe is by letting everyone know they're UN soldiers because there are consequences to targeting peacekeepers and most groups aren't going to risk it.. They're not even really soldiers- they're peacekeepers, bodyguards, and guards for refugee camps. Saying they need better camouflage is like saying police officers need better camouflage.
Current design isn't perfect but your alternative is worse
True
Amen.
Maybe we should remove the world map and make the olive branches bigger
Not even sure why theres a problem with the UN flag. Just because it rests on a certain continet doesnt even mean most people would notice that. O sure didint notice it at first
@@juniorcrusher2245
The only thing you can't properly recognise is Australia and that's mostly because of the stretching affect. Maybe put the Atlantic ocean at the bottom but apart from that it's absolutely okay.
I disagree with the olive branches being too detailed, they're super simple. I'd keep the flag as-is but change the map to a simple symbol representing the earth.
And what would that symbol be?
@@underscoredfrisk Have you never seen a simplified world map?
@@soarel325 Some countries are gonna be left out and they're not gonna be happy
What about the astrological symbol for earth? It's a circle with a plus inside. (you'll be familiar with venus ♀and mars ♂symbols).
Much preferable to the prison-bars design! 🤣
@@ReubsWalsh I like it a lot, especially since I love old mystical symbolism
3:51 Instructions unclear I now have to pay child support for F
The problem with your new design is that it looks like a barcode you would scan at the supermarket.
Not to be too mean... But the moment I saw the old flag I thought of a jail
I thought of a zebra crossing
kentucky fried chicken.
6:35 North korea: Dont add it, i might have to leave if you do!
A good way to kinda get rid of confusion just make a shield and a non specific globe in the shield it makes sense for both the present and a possible future
I’d have to disagree, I think that the flags simplicity works because it has to represent everyone so the symbolism has to be broad and include everyone. The blue represents the sky which is the same for everyone and is the opposite of red which is often associated blood and war, the map shows the earth with no borders so nations with territorial disputes won’t get offended, and the olive branch’s while cliché are widely recognized as symbols of peace. If you put any more symbolism you risk alienating or offending a nation. On the other hand I think your redesign goes too far in the other direction were you simplified it to the point where it has lost all meaning, and in a worst case scenario could be misinterpreted in a negative way.
Agreed, and you didn't even mention that the 4 pillars design was based on a US presidential speech.
I did like the shift to gold olive branches though, perhaps to represent peace and prosperity rather than solely peace
Ehhhh you had me until you showed the alternative. Nah I'd rather have the current flag than 4 bars. I agree with the others here. Just make the globe a white circle. Done.
The thing is by doing that you are giving the impression you see the planet as a uniform blob. Would certainly fuel the paranoia that the UN and globalization is destroying national borders and identites and homogenizing everything into... a white circle.
@@icecold1805 Okay, then make it a black stickman holding hands with a white stickman.
@@sanjaymatsuda4504 barrage of accusations of racism, of discrimination against those who feel not identified in this flag (what about latinos, asians, arabs, etc). Of making world politics into just an issue of race, of disregarding political individuality among white or black populations and so on and on and on.
@@sanjaymatsuda4504 yellow stickman????? Your design would cause alot of problems
@@juniorcrusher2245 In real life nobody is white as paper or black as crude petrol, all people are inbetween. So if two stickmen at opposite ends of the color spectrum can hold hands, it's easy to understand that it's okay for a brown/"yellow"/whatever person to hold hands with a slightly lighter person.
I really liked this video. It is kind of similar to the style of one Sam O’Nella, but different in a good way. It has a close enough format, visual style, and feel to Sam’s videos that it’s within an easy comfort zone to watch, but also very different so you’re not just some guy doing what he did. It’s pretty great, and it’d be ironic if you didn’t even know who Sam is.
Anyway, you just earned a new subscription.
I think you could probably "unwrap" a globe, without stretching it, to make an accurate flat map. (the seams would be the pacific plate boundary, shifted slightly eastwards to accommodate Japan/Australasia and a straight line going up in the Bering strait)
To be quite honest, I think the redesign is plain horrible lmao
well so is the current and tbh organization that can't even take care of it's own shouldn't have that much power
@@kasper4079 Something blurry > Jail bars
Yep
The UN: stop developing nuclear weapons
Me: How bout I do, _anyway_
funny seeing you here Mr supreme leader
supreme leader of best korea, You don't see supreme leader of the other korea commenting on a Tapakapa video.
thought you hated japan lol
Grrr metal gear
Funny thing is it was actually the americans who violated the original non-proliferation treaties with north korea
5:12 - LOL, i had the experience of spending 20 minutes on just drawing the US flag in a school project )))
The UN Flag should actually just be a pentagram
Makes sense to make the UN flag into a zebra crossing.
Everyone just walk over them anyway!
Exactly what I thought
Bar one or two times
Keep talking smack like that and you might just receive a strongly worded letter!
@@FriedTurkey You'd have to give the punishment to yourself. Because the UN represents your interests.
You see how it works now?
Tapakapa: We are better off letting maps be maps and flags be flags.
Cyprus: How dare you?
Kosovo: *I'm with Cyprus*
Bangladesh: I'm in-- Nah nvm
@@risannd what does bangladesh even have to do with it?
@@trollinape2697 Bangladesh flag originally had yellow map of hers inside the red circle. It was later removed upon independence.
@@risannd never knew, thx for tellin me
Ah yes, nothing says “universal freedom” like prison bars
Very good video but you created the 4th hyperstate for 1984
I prefer the old one... I'm sorry. I go against the emoji/simplistic design flags, I think they become to simple and lose something.
Noo UN don't turn me into an oversimplified logo!
It's the Firefox nightmare all over again.
I'm with this!
If you oversimplify something so much it loses it's uniqueness and recognizability, like the firefox or edge logo.
Isn't 70% of europe flags like 3 lines or a cross
You almost turned the UN flag into a loss meme and that is hilarious to me
honestly a large circle with "UN" in it, similar to their goofy helmets, would be a banger flag for the organization
Text on flags never go well.
I mostly just wish the UN flag could be centered on any point on earth, or at least rotated however you feel. But I'm a sucker for any flag you can edit.
I very strongly disagree with most points you made in this video. I actually really like the UN flag and the way it represents earth. The Lay-out of the world‘s continents is pretty much the most basic (and only) thing that all countries can agree and put similar value on as it simply displays their „home“. The Northpole projection is ingenious as it removes a lot of the biases towards a specific region since it is simply a fact that there are more people and, even more importantly, more landmass on the northern hemisphere. Leaving Antarctica out is a very acceptable down side to this and the compromise on focusing on the GMT Line makes sense as it puts the pacific towards the back which is the least inhabited part of the globe. Communication is still functioning as the white and blue Colour scheme is Sufficient to distinctly spot the UN flag from a distance and being able to “draw” a flag really shouldn’t be a criteria for flag design in our day and age anymore.
Also those “fundamental values” you described are actually much more euro centric (or American) than the simple display of the geographic features of the earth. Freedom of speech and freedom of worship are definitely NOT the most common shared values across the entire globe. And even if they were I can’t imagine China or anyone else for that matter being happy with a quote of a wartime US-president being the foundation of what essentially is the world’s emblem. Therefore I find the 4 stripes pattern (not even mentioning its obvious visual shortcomings which others here have already described sufficiently) decidedly inferior compared to the current design (which I do think is in fact the best compromise there is).
woah this is long, i just thought the og UN flag looked nice
Exactly, idk what went through this guys head.
yea, like i dont believe anyone would be offended by the way they rotated the map. for example kids learning in australia dont have their maps upside-down to show australia at "the top of the world"
this is just how the world agreed to present the map of the earth
Also, new flag looks like jail
@@wojtekpolska1013 also that, everyone accepted it
Something I like: The UN today is most focused with maintaining peace. Changing the flag would symbolically change the focus to more human rights rather than just anti-war
actually your wrong, because china is in the UN and they despise human rights lol.
@@ortherner that's the point, everyone says the UN is useless at stopping atrocities (it is) but that's by design as its only goal is to stop global war from happening again, not protecting minority/appressed groups sadly.
@@ortherner Most nations are in UN. Their presence doesn't say anything.
I hate the UN
*I HATE THE ANTICHRIST*
@@kennedytheretard975 ayyy I saw that meme
personally I'd just make the olive branches simpler, and then make the globe into a solid circle. Maybe even invert the colors so that the planet is blue.
6:19 mustache man and friends bruuuh
Bruhhhh the “have we been invaded by Somalia” joke had me DEAD
As a Catalan I absolutely agree with implementing the original Honour flag, we should just turn it 90° and paint the background yellow. There, perfect!
isn't that just the catalan flag?
@@kasper4079 Shhh, dont let them into the secret
lel xF
😂😂😂👍
💪🏽💪🏽💪🏽
"is that Somalia"
Somali pirates: *yes, hand over the goods*
I would argue that if you removed the globe and scaled up the size of the wreath, that would make for a beautiful flag.
“This is a bad flag” he says to one of the most iconic flags in the entire world
Iconic doesn’t mean good
@@Ara-gp4yj It is good
@@Ara-gp4yj so u mean great right?
@@theratking6168 it’s not
@@Ara-gp4yj it’s good for recognizing.
Another great vido from Takap... Tapek... Tepek... The flag guy.
would the brazilian flag be bad cuz of the stars in the blue circle representating the 26(+federal district) states of brazil and the "order and progres" thing writed or no cuz its ez to detect it?
I like the blue. But I think the emblem should actually be UN with the olive branches
My proposition: Delete the branch and the map, but leave the globe lines (only delete the map) because either you agree or not, not everyone has the same ideals as those 4 pillars representing.
Not everyone has those ideals, but they should, and the UN should stand for those
@@hugomlpaixao Forcing it is like a dictator forcing his ideals
@@bomba7197 That's a paradox. If people live in a state that doesn't share those ideals, they live in a dictatorship. If freedom is forced, its like a dictatorship.
To be honest, I would support a UN campaign to democratise every country, and I believe that there should be a law to which all countries should obey
@@hugomlpaixao That would be terrible, the definition of democracy is very wide.. that would mean the UN attacking democratic nations that are accused of not democratic. Who will decide what is a democracy will have the power to attack other nations... Even if it is a council of nations they would have the power to decide what countries to be attacked by the whole world based on what they saw as non-democratic.
@@bomba7197 yeah sure, it does have its flaws.
But take North Korea. Do you think they should be allowed to exist?
Do you think Saudi Arabia has the right not to treat women and men equally?
I think the UN flag is actual a masterpiece. It presents in a clear enough way the world so that you see where everywhere is. It's centering one europe is the option that allow for the most countries near the top to not be mushed up. It doesn't show antartica because it's unimportant and a tense region.
It's colour scheme makes is recongizable. Anyone looking at it from afar will guess it's the UN (the flag of Somalia is rarely scene and the central area shaps are kind of opposites), the red and white flag you're offering actual less recognizable, red and white aren't exactly rare on flags.
The messagery is much less controversial. Instead of imposing American values (it's literrally based on a state of the union adress, not exactly neutral) that are at best centered on the West it puts a clear neutral message that few would openly object to (freedom of speach and religion are not at all seen as universal rights by UN countires let alons beligireant combatants). Being non controversial is key for a flag of peace keepers who want to be defended by the universal values they represent.
The current flag of the UN is honestly one of my favorite flags
@@marten8148 Agreed, I proudly hang a UN flag in my room (just wish Antarctica could have some representation, but I guess the Antarctic Treaty System and Antarctica Flags are pretty nice)
I just thought I mean it's kinda a dumb idea but what if you had a south pole projection on the backside of the flag so it could include antarctica
Honestly this entire video feels dumb. The UN flag is probably the second most recognizable flag in the world. Literally there's only 1 other country using that light blue and white combination.
And while it's not perfect. His new flag is so bad.
There's the symbolism that's just dumb. He's using American values in a UN flag? And then he claims using the line where the whole globe adjusts it's time is biased?
Also there's the fact everyone would be confused by it. It's redesign lacks any recognition. Like he said, the UN relies on recognition to defend itself and 4 pillars are so fucking vague nobody would recognize it.
This video just reeks of him trying to justify why the UN would use this flag. He creates this "issue" with recognizability and then does mental gymnastics trying to prove the UN's old flag was better when it was far, far worse. It adds nothing. It creates conflict and confusion. Honestly the worse video on his Chanel by far.
I agree with most of what you said but just as a small correction: he actually never proposed to change the flag to the red-white color scheme. He wanted to keep the iconic blue and white and just change the "logo".
In the clouds in a sky thing there's some text. It says "not even on[e] fallout"
Also the [e] is something that may or may not be there, it's even harder to see
New here, love the fact, that you actually suggested something! :D
One problem about using those 4 pillars as the basis for the new design, is there are countries in the UN that don't agree with them very strongly.
Fuck em.
And that right there is why the UN is toothless and pointless
@@AmariFukui The UN provided lots of military action in the past, and there are still peacekeepers deployed around the world.
@@albar428 Keyword, in the past
Darfur demonstrated their toothlessness, they couldn't even protect the citizens of a country who WANTED them there. That is the ultimate failure
@@AmariFukui That makes every single military organization toothless. Every single military on earth hasn't stepped into a conflict that they should have. However one of the greatest things about the UN is the Peace corps, they helped teach and build homes in Guinea during and after the reign of Sekou Tore, and are still there to this day helping out with Covid and such. Saying the UN is useless is a fucking idiotic statement, looking at the vrand picture. The UN stopped tens of thousands of Croats from being killed, and did amazing work in West africa during the fall of the Soviet Union and still are.
I wish the biggest problem with the UN was their flag design.
Laughs in human rights violations
*Laughs nervously at China joining the Human Rights Council*
@@pierresihite8854 as opposed to who else? american best buddies, the saudis are on there too. the us and its vessels themselves commit tons of crimes. the UN works by including everyone this means you get to criticize people but also get criticized by others.
Laughs in world government
@@shamusson "Remember that the UN itself was built on land donated by John D Rockefeller."
Him : There you go!
Me : *sees the worst flag ever*
Me again : Say Whaaaaaaaattt
that's a great new flag and all but how are you gonna adjust the proportions for other countries, like Switzerland?
I think the whole "you can't see the details from a distance" isn't necessarily an issue. As long as you can identify what the flag is at a distance, it doesn't matter how many details it has. For example, look at the Portuguese flag, it has a lot of detail in the center, but has a design that lets it stand out from other flags at a glance. I'd argue it's a better flag than for example the Dutch flag, which is really simple and straightforward, but there's so many similar looking flags (Russia, Luxemburg, Croatia, Paraguay, just to name a few) that it loses that "identifiable from a distance" property.
Or Slovakia vs Slovenia... and even more, Monaco and Indonesia (although, they are much farther apart, and don't come into contact that often)
It's not our fault so many flags look like ours, the Netherlands had it before the rest did
One thing I do like about the map in the current UN flag is that although strange-looking it's actually as fair as a world-map could conceivably be.
Areas in the north get to be in the center at the cost of being smaller, and areas in the south get to be larger at the cost of being more distorted
Your intro is basically like the PBS one
This show is brought to you by viewers by you.
Bro I always thought its a default flag in games when I was young
you kno wwhat? Just make the flag a hexagon, because we all know that hexagons are bestagons
Good idea!
Wrong channel but yeah lol, i agree
noice idea
I think the symbolism is only "meh" because it's very literal. It's a world, and the symbol for peace, aka "World Peace". I think the U.N. understands that peace isn't exactly an exciting concept, but it's literally what it's striving for.
Whats the name of the song in the end
When I saw the fellow with the UN hat I thought you were going to suggest that they should change the flag to just have the letters UN on it
I know keeping it simple is an important rule in flag design but I think this is a rare exception. The UN flag should be a little grandiose and flamboyant. It's represents a meeting of all the nations on earth working on freedom and peace for all and I think a fancy flag can reflect that important mission.
"Flags should be simple."
The US: *Are you sure about that?*
The map only has a bias if you've already decided that North is up
at 0:52 the flag on the left side ist the "bonnie blue flag" whisch was used by the confederates in their independence war (also known as the American civil war). There is also a popular song about this flag.
im pretty sure the earth in the un’s emblem thing is supposed to be centered on greenwich (or whatever idk how to spell it), because, to my knowledge its the center of the official? timezone, GMT, centered on greenwich
That’s what the dang antarcticans* get for not joining
antrarica*
@@MCCCXI. antarctica*
Apparently hearts disappear when you edit a comment TIL
@@UGMD WHAT, feel sorry for u man
They uave joined
Bro it's United NATIONS, not United Earth, Antartica is no nation, why include it tho?
Because most of it is controlled by Countries?
Unpopular opinion: Complex flags are cool. PLC and Two Sicilies are my favourites.
What if one just simplified the earth map to a circle, and made the olive branches a lot less detailed?
Me: can we get CPG grey
Mom: we have CPG grey at home
CPG grey at home:
I actually clicked on this, thinking it was a CPG video
Not disappointed tho
He pretty cool
I think you could change your name to: Flags that suck and sometimes potatoes
Way catchier ^_^
BOOO! YOU ARE MEAN
4:06 that flag is much better than the old UN flag, when it just has the olive branches
I honestly thought you were going to replace the map with the symbol of the proposed "International Flag of Planet Earth", designed by Oskar Pernefeldt.
I like the current UN flag as it is :/
I think that trying to get every country to agree to a flag that references so many freedoms would be hard. There's quite a few UN members which are freedom-optional. ://
ikr freedom of speech? We don’t have that in my country (People’s Republic of China)
@@newspacia your country? you profile says you live in Uk and don't even speak chinese. you like pretending to be a PRC citizen on the internet?
@@mxn1948 he probaly just has learned english
@@mxn1948 Breaking: Local clown ignores existence of VPNs, more at 11.
@@grand-dadmiral Made more hilarious by the fact that it's pretty much impossible to be on youtube in china without a VPN.
1:53 - "The symbolism here is... weak."
Fitting, because the U.N. is also... weak.
Also, the Azimuthal Equidistant Projection of the world map used on the U.N. flag happens to be exactly the same as the Flat Earth Society's preferred depiction. Annnnddd... cue the conspiracy theory thread! 😂 🤣 😂 🤣
For replacement? Good idea but quite hard to implement though, I mean yes that 4 pillars are meaningful but only in some ways.
For military perspective? I freaking agree and love the pillars. Easier to costumize for sure. (UN-SOG/UN-SFG for spec-ops guys and many more).
(1:10) Proportions/Aspect ratio can never be "bigger" than another. 2:3 isn't bigger than 1:1, and isn't bigger than 3:5. It's all about how it's formatted.
• If you have a fixed width of the flags, then the less square flags will be bigger and longer.
• If you have a fixed length of the flags, then the more square flags will be bigger and taller.
• If you ensure all flags have the same area, then no flag is bigger than another. A 1:1 flag will be shorter but taller than a 2:3 flag
Mathematically, if a ratio is just a rational number, it is comparable to other ratios. 2:3 = 0.66…, 1:1 = 1, 3:5 = 0.6. So 3:5 < 2:3, and 2:3 < 1:1.
You identify two different things: the area of a flag and the size of its aspect ratio. I think we agree on that greater area means bigger flag, but bigger aspect ratio can mean relatively either wider or higher depending on the definition. In this case, it seems that the aspect ratio is the ratio of height to width, so relatively higher is bigger.
2937282:1928517 is my favorite aspect ratio
1:58 your Austrian German accent makes presence here.
I think that was intentional ;)
I think on the UN flag they should put the symbol for earth instead of a world map
0:15it represents the scout from tf2?
I would change the globe to a solid circle and make the olive branches somewhat straighter so they stay under the globe rather than wrap around it. Keeps the symbolism while making it more visually distinct from a distance.
Perhaps make the branches gold instead/as well like how it was shown in the video. Adds a new color with a generally well understood meaning to offset the 2 light colors as well as making it more visually distinct
@@TrueFlameslinger I actually like that Idea
I mean you could just have a blue background with a globe looking shape in the middle without any continents. Similar to the armillary sphere (gold part in the Portuguese flag)
That's a good idea broh, that seems better for me. The guy of the video idea was terrible, i mean bars wtf?? xd
an armillary sphere replacing the global projection would be much better.
The new one lowkey looks like Greece's flag
I hope Nepal's UN flag is the quadratic formula with the globe at the top the globe and the olives on the bottom
Nah i prefer the og over your proposed one
While the UN emblem is definitely overly detailed in a vexillological sense, I do like it more than just four simple pillars, which are a bit boring :’ ) Additionally, there is also a issue regarding the meaning of the pillars; Some UN-member states are not exactly the biggest fans of (some of) these freedoms and might oppose such a new design. I think a better solution might be to simplify the projection of the earth on the flag and maybe to remove the wreath.
Maybe a dark background with a bright yellow-ish stripe and a pale blue dot inside- "a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam"
When mom says we have CGPGrey at home
Both are good so i would reccomend to shut