I mean there are only a handful of Megadeth songs in their entire catalog that can be fairly represented with one riff ex: symphony of destruction, she-wolf, a tour le monde. but especially in those early albums there would be like 5 or 6 killer riffs a song lol
Personally I'm glad Dave got kicked because I got 2 amazing bands instead of 1! Dave is a jerk and so is Lars but luckily I don't live with either of them. Just enjoy the music people, it's been 40 years for God's sake 🤟
Metallica is like choosing to be a warrior in skyrim it's heavy downpicking, chugging and barbaric But megadeth is like choosing to be a mage so technical and magical in its own way
Good way of looking at it never thought of it that way. I'm a big fan of both bands. I hate how megadeth fanboys talk about their speed and complexity and number of solos etc as "proof" they're better than metallica lol. It's not better it's just different that is why I love em both and always have. I never understood the one sided people who deprive themselves of the other bands material why pick sides? We can like both the always have lol.
@@jeinfimate2079 You'll find metallica fans dont mention Megadeth nearly as much as Megadeth fans will mention Metallica. I love both bands but prefer Metallica for the variety and stronger songwriting and prefer Megadeth for its guitar playing.
@@Squall6575 here comes an uninvited dirty nose.Read again.It's not about who is whose bigger fan.His comment on Megadeth fanboys is correct.But then,what about Metallica fanboys that claim simpler and slower,the better? That was my question.
@@jeinfimate2079 your problem is with a small segment of metallica fans, considering a lot of them also listen to Megadeth and other metal bands. Youre just resorting to what-about-isms because you felt called out by the comment you replied to. Its ok to like both bands regardless of fanbases
1986 - I was in 8th grade and the music that year (also Slayer - Reign in Blood) would make me a metal head for life! Best single year of metal music (IMO). \m/
Megadeth is still relevant, I remember I kind of lose interest on them once as I was into another type of music, then I heard United Abominations immediately they got my attention back then they released Endgame which was insanely good, 13 was kind of meh but still good then Supercollider which made Chris quit but Dystopia was aired and they grabbed my attention again, Mustaine listens to his albums a lot and is very critical towards them, that's why even if comes with a bad album like Supercollider or Risk he fixes course, same if he is going onto a kind of boring album like with 13 or Hidden treasures he starts re thinking about how to make something with attitude, identity and able to be put against the current year best albums.
Peace Sells is a top tier thrash metal album but Master is so much more than “just” an excellent thrash album, it’s a masterpiece that transcends genre.
Yeah Puppets was the best album of 86 IMO. First album I ever really listened to that got me into music, honestly. Peace Sells is great, but Mustaine was still trying to find his sound at that point. The cover song is funny, but it kind of kills the vibe that the rest of the album has. Rust In Peace was Megadeth's Puppets. That album was lightning in a bottle at that time. Unfortunately, the remaster sucks & is ruined with the re-recorded vocals on songs like Take No Prisoners & Five Magics.
Agreed, Master of Puppets is a juggernaut. Simple test: Ask anyone who knows the album well: "what's the worst song on MOP?" You'll be waiting a long time for an answer. The trifecta RTL, MOP, and AJFA albums were just absolutely great epic albums.
0:03 Metallica - Battery 0:29 Megadeth - Wake Up Dead 0:55 Metallica - Master Of Puppets 1:17 Megadeth - The Conjuring 1:39 Metallica - The Thing That Should Not Be 2:03 Megadeth - Peace Sells 2:28 Metallica - Welcome Home (Sanitarium) 2:51 Megadeth - Devil's Island 3:10 Metallica - Disposable Heroes 3:31 Megadeth - Good Mourning Black Friday 3:53 Metallica - Leper Messiah 4:22 Megadeth - Bad Omen 4:45 Metallica - Orion 5:08 Megadeth - I Ain't Superstitious 5:35 Metallica - Damage, Inc. 5:56 Megadeth - My Last Words
First off your playing is amazing. I wish Mustain got more credit for his skill. I love both bands but the intricacy of his riffs take some of Megadeth's music to another level.
I love both of these albums. In fact, these two are my favorite albums. But I give the winner to Master Of Puppets. It's not just my favorite Metallica album, it's my favorite album of all time.
Both are great albums but to me "Black Friday" rips more than another other song on either album. Over all I might agree that Puppets is a better record but songs like Wake Up Dead, The Conjuring and Black Friday tip the scale for me as they are more aggressive and better riffs all over. Its a tough call.
Peace Sells has inferior production because Dave spent half the budget on drugs. And he also threw in a cover song lol Master Of Puppets is better all the way man... No doubt about that.
Even though Both sound great I think after you have learned MOP songs they could get quite repetitive. While songs like Black Friday, Bad Omen, and The conjuring have some of the most destructive riffs created in Metal. The Conjuring part in this video is literally the devils riff. Super Fucking Heavy. Black Friday sounds like chainsaws, and Bad Omen is just ripping you apart of how fast Dave plays it live. BUT MOP riffs are all consistently heavy and lay foundations for what future heavy metal albums should sound like. While Peace sells, KIMB, So Far, and Rust in Peace can never be recreated. That just shows how unique of a Riff master Dave is. I do not think any fan boy can deny that both bands sound great here.
As a Kid I first got to listened to Metallica, I was introduced by my uncle during my teens to Megadeth,since then I'm hooked to their music and I'm more of a Megadeth fan
Awesome video. Would love to see more like this album vs album caparison. Its a total tie for me. Would love to see maybe Slayer vs. Pantera or really Slayer vs anyone else. 🙂 Your videos are amazing. Thank you!
Slayer vs Dark Angel Annihilator vs Overkill Death Angel vs Sacred Reich Sepultura vs Sodom Kreator vs Destruction Anthrax vs Exodus Testament vs Forbidden Flotsam and Jetsam vs Heathen Helstar vs Laaz Rockit Sacrifice vs Vio-Lence Defiance vs Atrophy Sanctuary vs Vicious Rumors Nuclear Assault vs Evildead Wratchild America vs Powermad Helloween vs Blind Guardian
@@vikinglife6316 This is thrash/speed metal band with 'clean' vocals...Death in different league like Morbid Angel, Obituary, Napalm Death, Cannibal Corpse etc....
1986 was the greatest year in metal history. Master Of Puppets is my favorite of these two but seriously they are both amazing albums. Great work, Suffocater!
Heavy metal vs glam metal please. Heavy metal band : Judas priest Black sabbath Iron maiden Saxon Motorhead Deep purple Ozzy osbourne Dio band Glam metal band : Ratt Motley crue Twisted sister Def leppard Poison Cinderella White lion
Master of Puppets is the better album, it's Metallica's best and one of the very best metal albums of all time. Megadeth's best album is Rust in Peace, that would have been a much, much closer affair for me. Peace Sells is still great, though.
Peace sells is better. MoP is a great album, but very overrated. Every single song in Peace sells have a crazy variety of riffs and different approaches of composition. MoP have great songs, but it gets a bit monotone because it doesn't have too much variety, every song is in a way or another similar to each other (except for Orion)
Никогда не скажу - Это хорошее, а то плохое ! Если я люблю эти группы , то разумеется я буду их слушать. Все эти композиции нам дарили адреналин и настроение, и не престанут надоедать внося в это творчество огромный вклад !
More complex riffs on the side of Megadeth which show their tru skill and awesome sound, but also the simplicity from Metallica which shows how heavy it can be.
@@222MovieMan yea this is true but technicality doesn't always equal better. You can have super simple awesome songs that are heavy as hell just ask tony iommi lol. James Hatfield did this in metallica as well. Metallica have some fast songs too but it don't necessarily have to be fast to be badass and heavy. Metallica proves that like sabbath does.
Peace sells is a much better album, I know popularity always wins but the amount of creativity Dave and Chris and the rest of band showed in that album was mind blowing, the album was really way ahead of its time. Especially songs like my last words, Black Friday, bad omen and the conjuring, songs that are so complicated and with so much taste. Dave is such a brilliant songwriter and this video doesn’t really fully show the songs in all of its best but still appreciate it.
@@daroblackheart383 I prefer Master of Puppets, raw vocal talent of James, in which you can clearly hear every word, and you have Cliff's masterpice Orion, with thee twin guitar solos at the end. It's the greatest Metal experience for the ear.
I'll never understand people that "can't get past Dave's vocals." Thrash metal is supposed to have crazy vocals, ie, Exodus, Overkill, Nuclear Assault. Do you not like those vocals either?
@@hoofhearted6900 If you like Dave's vocals that's cool man. I don't. Many other people don't either so there must be something to his tone and delivery that's not enjoyable to some people. Its almost like when he's singing he sounds like someone who's making fun of the way someone sings, like purposely sounding a little ridiculous and odd. Not sure how you can compare his singing to any of the bands you mentioned because he has a unique delivery that's all his own.
@@SonnyJ26 I get where you're coming from. It's probably why I like the first two Megadeth albums the most... even compared to Rust in Peace, on which I thought Mustaine was trying to hard to sing. I liked his guttural approach on songs like Wake up Dead, and just thought it really captured their mood and tone.
Yeah. That is a very tough call. Both albums have their merits. The only low point is I ain't superstitious, but the amount of quality riffs on the rest of the album make up for it. Master of puppets is such a triumphant, well balanced tour de force, yet Peace Sells is like a rabid dog trying to break lose from it's chains! I love it all!
I love both albums, but the Puppets album just seems less "gimmicky" to me. I'm not saying that Mustaine was coming off that way, but to my ears the body of work with MOP was 100% solid front to back. I wore that cassette tape out, bought another one before I bought a CD.
@Mega Faggot I know. What do you think about covers? It's not my thing to be honest. I saw Metallica and GNR before the pandemic and nearly a quarter of their sets was covers. I want to hear their stuff. They have so many great songs that they don't play.
I ain't superstitious solos, that's what makes it awesome, this is the reason why these comparisons do not go over the solos and it is because Megadeth has a lot of players and they are on another league.
Wow. These albums instantly transport me back to 8th grade! It was 1991 and I had just discovered metal. Bought these tapes with my allowance and had to hide them from my parents because they said metal was a tool of the devil!
Kill'em All beats Killing is my Business, Peace Sells beats Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets beats So Far So Good, Rust in Peace beats And Justice for All, Black Album beats...wait....it's Countdown to Extinction...um....that's a tie.... Youthanasia beats Load, Cryptic Writings beats ReLoad, S&M Live beats Risk, World Needs a Hero beats St. Anger, then I kind of stopped listening to both bands TBH....I guess Dystopia and Handwired are both pretty good although I haven't listened to either nearly enough..... :D
It was the best thing that could have ever happened to everyone involved including the fans. It's kind of stupid how some like to pick one or the other and dog the other I don't understand that mindset there is so much to love from both bands.
Peace Sells is just unwinnable, the riffage, jazzy style, Samuelson's drums and Poland's solos just make the album. There's so many different layers in songs like Bad Omen, Black Friday / Good Mourning and The Conjuring: slow and haunting intros and so many different riffs and tempo switches.
I would say this is not the best from Metallica! Early stuff was better. I would say this was Megadeth better. And getting better! You could see the dynamics shift this year. But! Who ruled 1986? Fucking Slayer!
This only proofs why Metallica is THE No1 On the left every riff is legendary On the right mix of random decent riffs. Could as well be from three different bands. Don't get me wrong I respect Dave. He could have drunk him self to death after being sacked. He's a great guy. But Megadeth will never be no.1 He knows it and that's why always had so much bitterness towards Lars. He knows he was kicked out from the best metal band in the world. Imagine his anger in mid 80s .
both albums created a fork in the road, they were both thrash but one was more brutal and influenced heavier genres whereas the other was catchy and more rock leaning, influencing more melodic and technical based genres.
Peace sells isn't that good to me, I'd rather take Dystopia, United Abominations, Rust In Piece and others than it (i know, pretty unpopular opinion) Master is a masterpiece from beggining to end
Both such important albums in my life! Puppets wins by a hair cause it's perfect all the way through, Peace Sells has I ain't superstitious and that song doesn't fit the album But I noticed listening to those riffs on Peace Sells how similar the vibe is to Cowboys from Hell , Pantera obviously took influence from Dave's riffs
MOP still better than Peace Sells, but both are such awesome albums! MOP is my second favourite Metallica album Peace Sells is my favourite Megadeth album
Never found the songs in Master Of Puppets memorable other than Disposeable Heroes and the title track, always thought Kill 'Em All was peak Metallica. Funny enough I also think Killing Is My Business was peak Megadeth. Both bands had very unique debut albums that I hold dear and none of their later albums had the same impact or uniqueness, going more and more in favor of technical shenanigans. But in this particular case I'll stick with Peace Sells.
@@Qthetar holy wars ain't even on this album so idk why were talking about it. You are the exact person he was referring to "unless you're a megadeth fan" lol
Master of puppets is the top 3 heavy metal albums of all time. Peace sells is not even top 10 And that’s not just my opinion majority of musician will say some thing. Chris Poland says Mustaine was so jealous of master of puppets album.
started loving metallica as a kid, listened to all the albums and thought they were amazing, i still think theyre amazing, i grew up with metallica, but then i found megadeth and was more blown away than id ever been in my life, the composition and complexity of the music and pace they carry while having the sound they do is unlike anything else ive heard before, dave mustaine has cemented himself as the thrash metal GOAT! no matter who youre a fan of, there is no denying the huge contribution that mustaine made to metallica either!
I have never been a big fan of Master Of Puppets. It's a good album but kinda overrated to me. I like Kill'em All and Ride The Lightning better. So, Peace Sells is a winner! My favorite Megadeth album. Great riffs.
Good Mourning/Black Friday cannot be fairly represented by just one riff.
Same with Orion
Neither can Wake Up Dead. He purposely short-changed Megadeth here.
I mean there are only a handful of Megadeth songs in their entire catalog that can be fairly represented with one riff ex: symphony of destruction, she-wolf, a tour le monde. but especially in those early albums there would be like 5 or 6 killer riffs a song lol
I kind of feel thats with most Megadeth songs off the early albums.
The best sonf of megadeth
Love them both` !!
Well said!
Personally I'm glad Dave got kicked because I got 2 amazing bands instead of 1! Dave is a jerk and so is Lars but luckily I don't live with either of them. Just enjoy the music people, it's been 40 years for God's sake 🤟
Metallica is like choosing to be a warrior in skyrim it's heavy downpicking, chugging and barbaric
But megadeth is like choosing to be a mage so technical and magical in its own way
Good way of looking at it never thought of it that way. I'm a big fan of both bands. I hate how megadeth fanboys talk about their speed and complexity and number of solos etc as "proof" they're better than metallica lol. It's not better it's just different that is why I love em both and always have. I never understood the one sided people who deprive themselves of the other bands material why pick sides? We can like both the always have lol.
@@midnight347bruh what about tallica fanboys who think the slower and simpler,the better?
@@jeinfimate2079 You'll find metallica fans dont mention Megadeth nearly as much as Megadeth fans will mention Metallica. I love both bands but prefer Metallica for the variety and stronger songwriting and prefer Megadeth for its guitar playing.
@@Squall6575 here comes an uninvited dirty nose.Read again.It's not about who is whose bigger fan.His comment on Megadeth fanboys is correct.But then,what about Metallica fanboys that claim simpler and slower,the better? That was my question.
@@jeinfimate2079 your problem is with a small segment of metallica fans, considering a lot of them also listen to Megadeth and other metal bands. Youre just resorting to what-about-isms because you felt called out by the comment you replied to. Its ok to like both bands regardless of fanbases
What a ridiculous year '86 was for metal. So many albums that were pushing boundaries, from both huge bands and bands that aren't well known.
Because it was the birth. Thank god I was there for it all....metal was life.....52 mow, and still love it
Wasnt MOP from 1985?
@@jedrusnowak3317 March 3rd, 1986
slayer reign in blood is the best imho.
Awaken the Guardian was released in 86', another metal masterpiece
Literally some of the best riffs on metal history right here.
Simply true
Those Megadeth riffs are wizardry levels
Whenever I hear that damage Inc riff I just can't help but choose master of puppets
But have you heard the second part of wake up dead?
@@Unknown-zn8cg it's pretty cool but not as heavy and nasty
1986 - I was in 8th grade and the music that year (also Slayer - Reign in Blood) would make me a metal head for life! Best single year of metal music (IMO). \m/
It`s defenetely the most influential single year in Metal music since double headed debut of Black Sabbath in 1970
This battle was killer! I'd like to see Slayer's REIGN IN BLOOD head to head against Dark Angel's DARKNESS DESCENDS, Next!
that will be balanced fight
That’d be awesome, but Dark Angel for me
Or Dark angel Darkness Descends and Morbid Saint Spectrum of Death
Agree dude
THIS
Though I heard Metallica first but as a kid growing up in the 80s , Megadeth just resonated more with me and still today .
Same.
Same here
@snwrist3 some of the best lyrics in any metal song
@snwrist3 best melodic intro, best shredded emotional solo, powerful riffs, mind blowing Poland's solo & best lyrics
Same.
Both albums are masterpieces. Literally can't choose. Holy hell Amazing job man
Master of Puppet anyday. Dave’s voice is a big turn off
@@DharynSimmerX But Daves riffs is a turn on
@@222MovieMan for a granny yeah
@@MrEJD 😹😹😹😹😹
@@MrEJD grannies can't listen to metal? Boo my dude
even Las Ulrich has said that he felt overwhelmed by megadeth at the time Peace Sells came out
Megadeth is still relevant, I remember I kind of lose interest on them once as I was into another type of music, then I heard United Abominations immediately they got my attention back then they released Endgame which was insanely good, 13 was kind of meh but still good then Supercollider which made Chris quit but Dystopia was aired and they grabbed my attention again, Mustaine listens to his albums a lot and is very critical towards them, that's why even if comes with a bad album like Supercollider or Risk he fixes course, same if he is going onto a kind of boring album like with 13 or Hidden treasures he starts re thinking about how to make something with attitude, identity and able to be put against the current year best albums.
Endgame was amazing!
@@dontbothertoreply9755 Risk wasn't a bad album, it was a bad Megadeth album.
But I Like 13, I think than it was a Great album, just Hear Sudden Death!@@dontbothertoreply9755
Peace Sells is a top tier thrash metal album but Master is so much more than “just” an excellent thrash album, it’s a masterpiece that transcends genre.
Yeah Puppets was the best album of 86 IMO. First album I ever really listened to that got me into music, honestly.
Peace Sells is great, but Mustaine was still trying to find his sound at that point. The cover song is funny, but it kind of kills the vibe that the rest of the album has. Rust In Peace was Megadeth's Puppets. That album was lightning in a bottle at that time.
Unfortunately, the remaster sucks & is ruined with the re-recorded vocals on songs like Take No Prisoners & Five Magics.
Agreed, Master of Puppets is a juggernaut. Simple test: Ask anyone who knows the album well: "what's the worst song on MOP?" You'll be waiting a long time for an answer. The trifecta RTL, MOP, and AJFA albums were just absolutely great epic albums.
@@Fister_of_Muppets I disagree I find 4 songs in mop as filler.
@@Qthetar lol of course you would
@@Fister_of_Muppets you said there is no filler but to me there is like 3 or 4 filler songs.
0:03 Metallica - Battery
0:29 Megadeth - Wake Up Dead
0:55 Metallica - Master Of Puppets
1:17 Megadeth - The Conjuring
1:39 Metallica - The Thing That Should Not Be
2:03 Megadeth - Peace Sells
2:28 Metallica - Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
2:51 Megadeth - Devil's Island
3:10 Metallica - Disposable Heroes
3:31 Megadeth - Good Mourning Black Friday
3:53 Metallica - Leper Messiah
4:22 Megadeth - Bad Omen
4:45 Metallica - Orion
5:08 Megadeth - I Ain't Superstitious
5:35 Metallica - Damage, Inc.
5:56 Megadeth - My Last Words
Thanks Tim :)
@@TheSuffocater No Problem, keep up your work - I like watching your videos :)
They are very close...can t choose one. Metallica is heavier and those riff are genius,the other is clases and technical
I think MEGADETH still blows them out of the water here peace sells is the best album
🗣facts🤘💀🤘🍻😁🙋♂✌peace sells😎
Dude, Megadeth blew everybody out of the water with Peace Sells, and still do to this day!
I'm calling it a tie. I love both albums.
First off your playing is amazing. I wish Mustain got more credit for his skill. I love both bands but the intricacy of his riffs take some of Megadeth's music to another level.
these are the facts
What skills? He can't hit a note right, always out of tune
Are you retarded?
I love both of these albums. In fact, these two are my favorite albums. But I give the winner to Master Of Puppets. It's not just my favorite Metallica album, it's my favorite album of all time.
Both are great albums but to me "Black Friday" rips more than another other song on either album. Over all I might agree that Puppets is a better record but songs like Wake Up Dead, The Conjuring and Black Friday tip the scale for me as they are more aggressive and better riffs all over. Its a tough call.
Black friday is my favorite Megadeth song!!!
@@cord_6656 same! Along with My Last Words.
Black Friday is way better then anything on matters of puppets
@@ETH85 nooooo
@@jochencooper2751 yes !
Request: Seasons In The Abyss (Slayer) Vs Persistence Of Time (Anthrax)
They both kick ass. But for me master of puppets just has that feel in the songs that I cant describe. I just love that album lol but that's just me
Peace Sells has inferior production because Dave spent half the budget on drugs. And he also threw in a cover song lol Master Of Puppets is better all the way man... No doubt about that.
I prefer Peace Sells but they’re both classics!
Megadeth all day.”
Even though Both sound great I think after you have learned MOP songs they could get quite repetitive. While songs like Black Friday, Bad Omen, and The conjuring have some of the most destructive riffs created in Metal. The Conjuring part in this video is literally the devils riff. Super Fucking Heavy. Black Friday sounds like chainsaws, and Bad Omen is just ripping you apart of how fast Dave plays it live. BUT MOP riffs are all consistently heavy and lay foundations for what future heavy metal albums should sound like. While Peace sells, KIMB, So Far, and Rust in Peace can never be recreated. That just shows how unique of a Riff master Dave is. I do not think any fan boy can deny that both bands sound great here.
As a Kid I first got to listened to Metallica, I was introduced by my uncle during my teens to Megadeth,since then I'm hooked to their music and I'm more of a Megadeth fan
Awesome video. Would love to see more like this album vs album caparison. Its a total tie for me. Would love to see maybe Slayer vs. Pantera or really Slayer vs anyone else. 🙂 Your videos are amazing. Thank you!
Even though I'm more of a deth fan, I reckon Master of Puppets wins this one! Now rust in peace vs. Black album? No debate RIP wins the cake
I already thought about Countdown vs Black album , so it would be their best selling albums :)
Slayer vs Dark Angel
Annihilator vs Overkill
Death Angel vs Sacred Reich
Sepultura vs Sodom
Kreator vs Destruction
Anthrax vs Exodus
Testament vs Forbidden
Flotsam and Jetsam vs Heathen
Helstar vs Laaz Rockit
Sacrifice vs Vio-Lence
Defiance vs Atrophy
Sanctuary vs Vicious Rumors
Nuclear Assault vs Evildead
Wratchild America vs Powermad
Helloween vs Blind Guardian
No mention Death? How dare you.
@@vikinglife6316 This is thrash/speed metal band with 'clean' vocals...Death in different league like Morbid Angel, Obituary, Napalm Death, Cannibal Corpse etc....
1986 was the greatest year in metal history. Master Of Puppets is my favorite of these two but seriously they are both amazing albums. Great work, Suffocater!
молодец! МУЗ rock\🎸🎸🎸=
th-cam.com/video/7T12KNBIUsI/w-d-xo.html
Heavy metal vs glam metal please.
Heavy metal band :
Judas priest
Black sabbath
Iron maiden
Saxon
Motorhead
Deep purple
Ozzy osbourne
Dio band
Glam metal band :
Ratt
Motley crue
Twisted sister
Def leppard
Poison
Cinderella
White lion
I like M.O.P but peace sells is another level.Peace sells breaking down both enstrumantally,and Agressiveness
Both albums are great, and so is each closing track. My Last Words will always be my number one Megadeth track.
Can we all agree that Dave getting booted from Metallica is the greatest thing to happen to metal?
No one beats Mustaine´s riffs.
Damaged inc does circles around all peace sells songs
@@alasek how so? Are you serious?
Exept hetfield
@@alasek ...
@@alasek lmao
Master of Puppets (the song, not the album) is *OVERRATED* as fuck! Seriously, people, don’t you know any better metal song?
Master is the blaster.
Mustaine is a riff genius
Master of Puppets is the better album, it's Metallica's best and one of the very best metal albums of all time. Megadeth's best album is Rust in Peace, that would have been a much, much closer affair for me. Peace Sells is still great, though.
Peace sells is better. MoP is a great album, but very overrated. Every single song in Peace sells have a crazy variety of riffs and different approaches of composition. MoP have great songs, but it gets a bit monotone because it doesn't have too much variety, every song is in a way or another similar to each other (except for Orion)
Megadeth wins these every time
Megadeth always
Никогда не скажу - Это хорошее, а то плохое ! Если я люблю эти группы , то разумеется я буду их слушать. Все эти композиции нам дарили адреналин и настроение, и не престанут надоедать внося в это творчество огромный вклад !
Hell yeah this is badass🤘🏻🤘🏻
More complex riffs on the side of Megadeth which show their tru skill and awesome sound, but also the simplicity from Metallica which shows how heavy it can be.
Complex riffs have usually have little to do with great songs
@@philliprobinson129 True, but from a musicians perspective you appreciate the skill
@@222MovieMan yea this is true but technicality doesn't always equal better. You can have super simple awesome songs that are heavy as hell just ask tony iommi lol. James Hatfield did this in metallica as well. Metallica have some fast songs too but it don't necessarily have to be fast to be badass and heavy. Metallica proves that like sabbath does.
@@midnight347 yes it's true
The simplicity of Metallica sucks.
Peace Sells yo. I'm getting that cover engraved into my skin soon.
Peace sells is a much better album, I know popularity always wins but the amount of creativity Dave and Chris and the rest of band showed in that album was mind blowing, the album was really way ahead of its time. Especially songs like my last words, Black Friday, bad omen and the conjuring, songs that are so complicated and with so much taste. Dave is such a brilliant songwriter and this video doesn’t really fully show the songs in all of its best but still appreciate it.
You're right! Peace Sells is better.
@@daroblackheart383 I prefer Master of Puppets, raw vocal talent of James, in which you can clearly hear every word, and you have Cliff's masterpice Orion, with thee twin guitar solos at the end. It's the greatest Metal experience for the ear.
Both of the albums are amazing and essential
Ummm no
Black friday has best and more evil riffs than all of metallica albums
Bad omen's riff is on a whole different level
Metallica is my fav band ever but Peace Sells is my fav thrash album ever. Loved both bands btw.
The winner is Metallica.
I'm one of those guys that has never been able to get past Dave's vocals. But, there's no denying how bad ass his riff writing is.
I'll never understand people that "can't get past Dave's vocals." Thrash metal is supposed to have crazy vocals, ie, Exodus, Overkill, Nuclear Assault. Do you not like those vocals either?
@@hoofhearted6900 If you like Dave's vocals that's cool man. I don't. Many other people don't either so there must be something to his tone and delivery that's not enjoyable to some people. Its almost like when he's singing he sounds like someone who's making fun of the way someone sings, like purposely sounding a little ridiculous and odd. Not sure how you can compare his singing to any of the bands you mentioned because he has a unique delivery that's all his own.
@@hoofhearted6900 Nope. There are so many good metal bands that I can't listen to because of the vocals.
I actually like Dave’s vocals
@@SonnyJ26 I get where you're coming from. It's probably why I like the first two Megadeth albums the most... even compared to Rust in Peace, on which I thought Mustaine was trying to hard to sing. I liked his guttural approach on songs like Wake up Dead, and just thought it really captured their mood and tone.
Yeah. That is a very tough call. Both albums have their merits. The only low point is I ain't superstitious, but the amount of quality riffs on the rest of the album make up for it. Master of puppets is such a triumphant, well balanced tour de force, yet Peace Sells is like a rabid dog trying to break lose from it's chains! I love it all!
I love both albums, but the Puppets album just seems less "gimmicky" to me. I'm not saying that Mustaine was coming off that way, but to my ears the body of work with MOP was 100% solid front to back. I wore that cassette tape out, bought another one before I bought a CD.
@Mega Faggot I know. What do you think about covers? It's not my thing to be honest. I saw Metallica and GNR before the pandemic and nearly a quarter of their sets was covers. I want to hear their stuff. They have so many great songs that they don't play.
I ain't superstitious solos, that's what makes it awesome, this is the reason why these comparisons do not go over the solos and it is because Megadeth has a lot of players and they are on another league.
Wow. These albums instantly transport me back to 8th grade! It was 1991 and I had just discovered metal. Bought these tapes with my allowance and had to hide them from my parents because they said metal was a tool of the devil!
How lucky I was to be 13 in 1986. What a year.
Kill'em All beats Killing is my Business, Peace Sells beats Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets beats So Far So Good, Rust in Peace beats And Justice for All, Black Album beats...wait....it's Countdown to Extinction...um....that's a tie.... Youthanasia beats Load, Cryptic Writings beats ReLoad, S&M Live beats Risk, World Needs a Hero beats St. Anger, then I kind of stopped listening to both bands TBH....I guess Dystopia and Handwired are both pretty good although I haven't listened to either nearly enough..... :D
I'm just thankful Dave got kicked out of Metallica so we have both of these albums to bang our heads to.
It was the best thing that could have ever happened to everyone involved including the fans. It's kind of stupid how some like to pick one or the other and dog the other I don't understand that mindset there is so much to love from both bands.
Peace Sells wins for me. Good job!
Master of Puppets all the way
Both are amazing, but Orion is the master piece!
Orion is great. Competes with Good Mourning/ Black Friday.
Battle of 1986 🤘🤘
both great metal bands! 🤘🔥
how do you get the peace sells tone?
Peace Sells is just unwinnable, the riffage, jazzy style, Samuelson's drums and Poland's solos just make the album. There's so many different layers in songs like Bad Omen, Black Friday / Good Mourning and The Conjuring: slow and haunting intros and so many different riffs and tempo switches.
MEGADETH ALL THE WAY. METALLICA IS JUST A BORING POP BAND
Megadeth are a pop band
There are many great solos in metal but mustaines solo in My Last Words might be the solo I love the most
I would say this is not the best from Metallica! Early stuff was better. I would say this was Megadeth better. And getting better! You could see the dynamics shift this year. But! Who ruled 1986? Fucking Slayer!
In my opinion both bands are legend but "Master of Puppets" is a full album masterpiece. "Peace Sells" have some songs for masterpiece.
Nah, both albums are masterpieces
I’ve always considered Peace Sells… But Who’s Byuing? a masterpiece, but Master Of Puppets too repetitive in a few songs.
Peace sells for me is the best
I agree every song in Master of puppets is good can't say the same thing for Peace Sells
This only proofs why Metallica is THE No1
On the left every riff is legendary
On the right mix of random decent riffs.
Could as well be from three different bands.
Don't get me wrong I respect Dave.
He could have drunk him self to death after being sacked.
He's a great guy.
But Megadeth will never be no.1
He knows it and that's why always had so much bitterness towards Lars.
He knows he was kicked out from the best metal band in the world.
Imagine his anger in mid 80s .
both albums created a fork in the road, they were both thrash but one was more brutal and influenced heavier genres whereas the other was catchy and more rock leaning, influencing more melodic and technical based genres.
Peace sells isn't that good to me, I'd rather take Dystopia, United Abominations, Rust In Piece and others than it (i know, pretty unpopular opinion) Master is a masterpiece from beggining to end
Both such important albums in my life! Puppets wins by a hair cause it's perfect all the way through, Peace Sells has I ain't superstitious and that song doesn't fit the album
But I noticed listening to those riffs on Peace Sells how similar the vibe is to Cowboys from Hell , Pantera obviously took influence from Dave's riffs
MOP still better than Peace Sells, but both are such awesome albums!
MOP is my second favourite Metallica album
Peace Sells is my favourite Megadeth album
amazing!!
MoP is part of the Library of Congress and the National Recording Registry ( 1st Metal album with such honors ) so MoP wins
Never found the songs in Master Of Puppets memorable other than Disposeable Heroes and the title track, always thought Kill 'Em All was peak Metallica.
Funny enough I also think Killing Is My Business was peak Megadeth. Both bands had very unique debut albums that I hold dear and none of their later albums had the same impact or uniqueness, going more and more in favor of technical shenanigans.
But in this particular case I'll stick with Peace Sells.
I would totally agree that Killing is the best Deth album by far.
Dude your tone for both is absolutely perfect. HOWWWWWW
Yes, this tone beats the original peace sells tone
Two best album 🤘🏻 Youthanasia & Black album battle please 🤘🏻
Fucking badass, dude!
Why is Metallica playing Megadeth songs along with Megadeth? Just proved that Megadeth is more technical than Metallica
Master Of Puppets all the way! It's a beautiful thrashterpiece!
My Last Words the winner.
Master Of Puppets wins always, unless you’re a Megadeth fan…
Holy wars alone wins
@@Qthetar holy wars ain't even on this album so idk why were talking about it. You are the exact person he was referring to "unless you're a megadeth fan" lol
@@midnight347 exactly😂
@@midnight347 he's a baby fan of megadave😂
Master of puppets is the top 3 heavy metal albums of all time.
Peace sells is not even top 10
And that’s not just my opinion majority of musician will say some thing.
Chris Poland says Mustaine was so jealous of master of puppets album.
started loving metallica as a kid, listened to all the albums and thought they were amazing, i still think theyre amazing, i grew up with metallica, but then i found megadeth and was more blown away than id ever been in my life, the composition and complexity of the music and pace they carry while having the sound they do is unlike anything else ive heard before, dave mustaine has cemented himself as the thrash metal GOAT! no matter who youre a fan of, there is no denying the huge contribution that mustaine made to metallica either!
I'm a fan of both, but Megadeth is my favorite. Cmon, nothing can top rust in peace.🤘
Exactly! I feel the same, you took the words out of my mouth! Mustaine is the BEST EVER!!!!
MUSTAINE👊🔥🤘🎸
megadeth wins for instrumentals, but metallica wins for overall songs.
how general and vague.
Orion is the best instrumental
Orion is very much overrated.
Always preferred Mustaine's blues-ey swing feel over any of the other big 3 thrash rhythm guitarists.
two legendary albums \m/
Megadeth is so trash absolutely no melody whatsoever. just grating scales at crackhead speed. can’t compare these bands
Peace Sells all day!
I'm glad Dave quit/got fired from Metallica, otherwise we wouldn't be having this amazing comparison right now 👍🙌🤘
i think Hetfield's riffs are more melodic, easier to digest for most listeners.
MEGADETH all the way!!!!! Mustaine is a legend.
I have never been a big fan of Master Of Puppets. It's a good album but kinda overrated to me. I like Kill'em All and Ride The Lightning better.
So, Peace Sells is a winner! My favorite Megadeth album. Great riffs.
Feels like Megadeth got the short-straw here with the riff selections......
Man what a battle... they both Great albums but maaaaannnn Master of Puppets is a a Master piece 🔥🤘🔥 is hard to beat that one
This is like saying was the steak better than the pork chop. Both freaking great, but different.
This was awesome. Two of the best albums of 1986, and definitely two of the top ten metal albums of all time. Excellent job, my friend.
None metallica álbum is better than any megadeth álbum..
Both albums are 10/10
9/10