My favorite version. Watched a million times still gives me chills. Bono’s voice is so strong and add in Larry killing it around 4:40 just before the extra shine like stars verse... perfection..U2 forever
The absolute best live performance of this song of all time, I've seen them live and NEVER was close to how amazing this is, better than the album version. Timeless classic. Those who got to see this live in 1987 are indeed very lucky.
I played this song when my dad was unwell with cancer, he's still here thank God but he got me into me U2 and this is his and my favourite song 🇮🇪☘️ God bless you 🙏
this song was played at my brother's funeral and there's nothing better to listen to when. I'm sad and it reminds me of all good times we had and no matter what happens I will never let him go from my heart he loved this song he used to sing it bless him RIP CHRISSY 💕💜💭😢
I lost one of my brothers January 13Th of this year 2018. He was only 2 years older than me at the age of 59. He got me hooked on U2 and now every time I hear this song it makes me think of him. I miss him every day. Rest in peace my brother.
It didn’t really last, now it annoys me on the newer songs. Nothing beats This album and earlier. When we got the free downloads that album was crap and the songs sound much better instrumental.
@@annunakiarzu5733 For many years, the growl has been gone from Bono's voice. I believe he began to decline vocally around the time of PopMart. You listen to this era, the versatility was amazing, and much of that was due to Bono's ability to low into something more primal -- almost guttural -- vocally. I suppose the succinct version is: Bono used to have a deep voice. He doesn't any longer. I also think that this partially dictated U2's tone as a whole. The songs now seem far too sacharine compared to the work they did in the 80s and 90s. I really miss this Bono and the U2 of War through POP.
I get shivers every time when listening to this live version. Mullen and Clayton's superb back up to the utter magnificence of Edge and his electric guitar.
Anytime i hear this song and its not this version i get annoyed. This is the perfect rendition of this song. Perfect mixing, perfect drumming, even the guitar distortion is perfect. Bono's timing, and even the adlibbed "thank you" before the song reaches its creshendo is epic. The mixing is amazingly balanced and it feels like every instrument is singing.
Check out the Rattle and Hum movie. You can see a lot of their live performances. Also try Under a Blood Red Sky Concert video. U2 had some great live performances that they recorded and sold on VHS and now DVD.
If I had to live on a desert island, I would definitely bring this great song in my suitcase. everything in this song is great : the atmosphere, the chord progression, the guitar solo at 4´15, the battery. Ideal to stop and dream during 5 mn !
By far the best live version of this song, over the years the tempo has been really slowed down to more of a soft ballad, however the faster more hard hitting tempo along with Bono's strong vocals plays really nice with this song. The highlight for me is 04:41 where the Edge solo leads into the Larry Mullen climax and into the shine like stars snippet from Bono... truly a masterpiece.
I dunno, heard it a thousand times, seen them live numerous times, everytime I hear this song it sends a shiver down my spine and a tear to my eye... U2 are a phenomena... Thank you!
What hurts the most is when you find someone who changes your whole life without even looking...only to be driven away because others can't accept our love...we both lost our self-respect and I don't know if anyone can ever understand our love but God. She's everything I ever hoped for. She's everything I desire. I might do prison time because I loved and cared for someone who needed saving, just like me. I know Gods timing will unite us together someday. I cry and pray every day for her. I hope no one ever goes thru this, and if you do/are, have faith and trust God's planning. I love you so much, janell. From the sweetness of your touch, from the pureness of your heart. You're all I desire
Adam Clayton had the best time of his life on this. 4 notes for the whole thing and still sounded like he was a real bass player. Living the dream Adam
Theirs just something about this song and this period that cannot be replicated!! This song and this Band u2 awakened me to the power of love and music !! Truly timeless 👌
@A.C. why are they better than dylan? you realize dylan is up there with shakespeare, edgar allen poe dont you? saying the stones are better song writers is like saying the screenplay of the movie top gun is better than shakespeares romeo and juliet. sure some people even think bieber is better than dylan but critics worth their salt and history will show dylan as the greatest song writer and the father of modern rock n roll. you can like the stones more than dylan but that is just your taste. even the stones will tell you that they must carry his amp to his show not the other way around. the stones themselves will bow their knee to dylans genius, so why cant you?
thesongtowoody Bob Dylan is an excellent lyricists. one of the best. but in my opinion Bono can sing much much better. especially now that Dylan’s voice is so raspy.
Apparently you didn’t read his full comment...you know...about being an entertainer and singer. Why don’t you say Hank Williams is greater than Elvis Presley why you’re at it. 🙄
1987 was the best year for u2.. the Joshua tree was what made them .. outstanding memories of such a fantastic band ..so many incredible memories xx love u guys xx
First time I heard this was in friends. Yes I know not the most magical place to hear it. But i remember it vividly, I was in the living room, with my dad and stepmum, they watched me tear up as Ross sat sad that he’d lost Rachel, it thought it was over, all over, and I’ll always remember that night because it was the first time I saw my dad say “I love you” to anyone, instead of “love ya” and I miss it. I miss when my dad liked my company, now I’m here, in my room alone, haven’t talked to my dad since new years and it’s literally his birthday soon… I just wish I could have our bond back, I miss my dad 🙁 signed - an 18 year old who just wants to be enough for his dad
A distanza di anni ,decenni , questa OPERA D' ARTE è la mia preferita, i suoni la voce la chitarra i bassi e le bastonate di Larry su quei tamburi che ti rimbombano in testa . Io sono grato a Larry che mise In bacheca nella sua scuola la voglia di formare una band e dare inizio agl U2 .riempiendo così anche la nostra vita e gioventù . Grazie .
Please don't associate a crappy sitcom featuring clueless guys and ditzy broads with this masterpiece of music. I can't stand picturing those clueless guys with their blank faces and those ditzy chicks with their hands on their hips, mouth open and that "Oh my gosh!" expression.
ascoltate il finale del brano e chiudete gli occhi, provate a pensare a qualcuno che amate in profondità e sentirete la grandezza degli U2 e quanto sia bella la musica.
I've seen U2 twice in Vancouver, BC....first concert in 1988 and then in the early 90's...the Zoo tour...both shows were just electric, U2 rocks, a gorgeous blend of voice and guitar licks. I've seen over 200 bands over 25 yrs. U2 is among the very best bands I've seen live!
The way he sings is so sexy he seems to eat the microphone, this is a song I will play repeatedly without feeling out of date and 1987 is really a legendary year. Even I was not born in that time, but I feel I was living in that time.
It was a great time indeed... Even then I knew it would be a classic. The energy and tension of the music and his voice is awesome throughout. These were the days before rap when singers had to sing and every idiot wasn't holding up a cellphone blocking your view.
I am working in a middle East country for construction work. my family is in my home country without me. after work, my body is exhausted under hot sun. I am missing my wife and memories with her. I am middle of 40s. sing this song with little tear when I sing 'one heart, one hope, one love'.
![U2 - One ( live 1997 )[ lyrics ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1VuuSnzO_t0/mqdefault.jpg)
![U2 - One ( live 1997 )[ lyrics ]](/img/tr.png)
![U2 - With Or Without You (30th Anniversary Edit)[zhd/extended/remix]](/img/n.gif)
This is one of the greatest songs in the history of music...💔
Oh yes 😍
I agree...
I know when you first here it you say magic.🎹🎶🎼🎵🎙️🎤
U2 is the best in the world! This song is a very beautiful! Amazing! I’m apologise for my English 🤥
@@rostovonthedon3324 No apology needed! Peace to you and your nation from an American of peace and good will!
U2 in their prime. This is the best live version of 'With or Without You'. A masterpiece.
Agree!!
I triple agree!
god damn, that was beautiful!!,
It truly is. Unforgettable and unrepeatable
This is also the best version I have heard.
もう何100回見たのだろう、何でかな
見るたびに切なくて涙が出て来るのは
BONOの唯一無二の歌声とEDGEの透き通ったギター、Larryの力強いドラム、Adamの淡々としたベース。そこにこの
あなたと一緒でもあなた無しでも生きられない、、と言う胸が締め付けられる程
切ない歌詞、、U2の曲で1番好きです。
ライブバージョンにしかない最後の方
の歌詞もいい。世界一のバンドです🌟
👏👏👏👏👏
My favorite version. Watched a million times still gives me chills. Bono’s voice is so strong and add in Larry killing it around 4:40 just before the extra shine like stars verse... perfection..U2 forever
Totally agree...everything is in sync 👍
I totally agree, it’s my favourite section👏🏿
WE SHINE LIKE STARS IN THE SUMMER NIGHT.....
Total agreement. It’s not about faultless. It’s about that’s moment that time they were another fin level.
Heard this on an old scratchy audio tape in 1990. Thank you Ytube for allowing me to hear this again over 30 years later.
This song was on the radio when I got in the car on my first date with my son's father who passed in 2016. I'll never forget.
I hope u get better, and be happier. :)
❤ God bless 🙏
May the Lord gives you the peace ,that overpass understanding ,and the love that never dies.
Bless you
I love that for you.
this video deserves 1 Billion views, gosh the most beautiful song ever...
The absolute best live performance of this song of all time, I've seen them live and NEVER was close to how amazing this is, better than the album version. Timeless classic. Those who got to see this live in 1987 are indeed very lucky.
I saw them live in san diego in 1987
I saw this w my own two eyes. 12/1987
Reminds me of my brother who would of been 58 Feb,19 this year U2 are very much missed, bless you,happy birthday!🙋🙏✌️🧑🎓
I saw them in 1987 live in Rotterdam , the Netherlands ❤
I was one of them. And yes I was very lucky
The song was played at my mother's funeral, and every time I have tears in my eyes
🤍
I played this song when my dad was unwell with cancer, he's still here thank God but he got me into me U2 and this is his and my favourite song 🇮🇪☘️ God bless you 🙏
I want this played too at my funeral....also The Cure ...Just like heaven
See how Bono walks up to the mic? LIKE A BOSS!
This is the best live version of this song I’ve ever heard, and I’ve heard them all. This song is timeless, a true masterpiece!!
The bloody last 60 sec are unmatchable
U2 at one of their greatest peaks. Bono's vocals are unmatched....
this song was played at my brother's funeral and there's nothing better to listen to when. I'm sad and it reminds me of all good times we had and no matter what happens I will never let him go from my heart he loved this song he used to sing it bless him RIP CHRISSY 💕💜💭😢
Abby Swales ❤
Esta é uma das músicas da minha vida. E garantidamente, gostava que no meu funeral também a tocassem. Que linda homenagem ao seu irmão. ❤️👊🏻
Lucky Soul
🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
I lost one of my brothers January 13Th of this year 2018. He was only 2 years older than me at the age of 59. He got me hooked on U2 and now every time I hear this song it makes me think of him. I miss him every day. Rest in peace my brother.
Bono's vocals were simply amazing and unmatched at that time.
It didn’t really last, now it annoys me on the newer songs. Nothing beats This album and earlier. When we got the free downloads that album was crap and the songs sound much better instrumental.
@@annunakiarzu5733 For many years, the growl has been gone from Bono's voice. I believe he began to decline vocally around the time of PopMart.
You listen to this era, the versatility was amazing, and much of that was due to Bono's ability to low into something more primal -- almost guttural -- vocally.
I suppose the succinct version is: Bono used to have a deep voice. He doesn't any longer.
I also think that this partially dictated U2's tone as a whole. The songs now seem far too sacharine compared to the work they did in the 80s and 90s.
I really miss this Bono and the U2 of War through POP.
@@mortenpotzdidler1998 agree totally, not sure how well Bono could sing Bad or Red Hill Mining Town w the loss of power
I get shivers every time when listening to this live version. Mullen and Clayton's superb back up to the utter magnificence of Edge and his electric guitar.
2025 ? still one of the best Live performance 😌
Indeed❤
Anytime i hear this song and its not this version i get annoyed. This is the perfect rendition of this song. Perfect mixing, perfect drumming, even the guitar distortion is perfect. Bono's timing, and even the adlibbed "thank you" before the song reaches its creshendo is epic. The mixing is amazingly balanced and it feels like every instrument is singing.
♥️
Perfect
Absolutely! I feel the same
😂
The guy on the drums is EVERYTHING!!!. He's LITERALLY playing all my emotions❤❤❤
larry mullen jr
The one and only James Dean....
.I mean Larry Mullen Jr.
U2 at their prime. Joshua tree is one of the best albums ever.
Magnificient! 4:33 the guitar and drum are perfectly coordinated
What I would give to go back in time and see them in their heyday...the charisma is amazing
That's the power of Youth...
Check out the Rattle and Hum movie. You can see a lot of their live performances. Also try Under a Blood Red Sky Concert video. U2 had some great live performances that they recorded and sold on VHS and now DVD.
To me one of the most beautiful live versions of any U2 song
I will never stop loving this song!
Out of this world
Amazing song ☘️
me toooo
제일 좋아하는 live version 입니다. 기타,드럼,보컬,베이스 너무나 완벽한 하모니입니다. 12월9일은 U2 한국공연 정확히 2주년 되는 날이었습니다. 코로나 19 발생하기 바로 직전 한국에서 마지막으로 콘서트를 볼 수 있었던 것은 무척 행운이었습니다.
I love Bono’s voice. It’s so perfect in every way possible. No one else will ever have his voice. Ever.
What a memories........my 20s.........and this song on a walkman.....
Carlo Aversano and when the cassett gets jammed and searching for a handy dandy pencil to wind it back up!!! LOL
This songs remind me in my grade school
My 18
@@MH-mv6uw yeah, I still remember that
Same here
If I had to live on a desert island, I would definitely bring this great song in my suitcase. everything in this song is great : the atmosphere, the chord progression, the guitar solo at 4´15, the battery. Ideal to stop and dream during 5 mn !
Larry Mullen, Jr. has a very unique style of drumming. Can't be beat IMO.
Reagan Miller me too I am his fans ,he is the handsomeness off all. sorry for Bono fans ,Bono has strong great voice no doubt
agnes riberu Agreed!
***** I've never heard Tool so can't agree or disagree on that one. There are a lot of great drummers out there.
By far the best live version of this song, over the years the tempo has been really slowed down to more of a soft ballad, however the faster more hard hitting tempo along with Bono's strong vocals plays really nice with this song. The highlight for me is 04:41 where the Edge solo leads into the Larry Mullen climax and into the shine like stars snippet from Bono... truly a masterpiece.
Chris R yes, yes, yes!!!
Did you see how in sync Edge and Larry were at that moment? Incredibly perfect
This performance will never be beaten... Don't think by any artist, with any song, at any time...imo...
fully agreed.. this is the best version of this song. hard drumming and bono's voice was strong back then....and powerful ending
Hands down, the best version of this song EVER. Everyone was in top form that night. Love that extra short verse towards the end...
코리아에서도 U2는 레전드 그룹임에 틀립이 없고 많은 팬들이 있읍니다...^^*
totally and absolutely breathtakingly unbelievable.
Bono's voice is simply amazing. he sounds so deep and suddendly blows up. I can listen to three differentes voices.
This song is planted in my HEART
Wow Bono had some mad decent vocals. His deep notes are incredible.
May we take a minute to shout out the literal BEAST that is Larry Mullen, Jr.?
best live of with or without you
+bruno1999100 Totally agree. I've watched this vid many, many times.
Defo
for sure....Watch Larry hands on the end and the speed he gotespecially if you like the drums :)
agree
It would be wonderful!
Every time i listen to this song, i get chills up my spine.
I can’t hold my tears when I am listening this song. ❤
I dunno, heard it a thousand times, seen them live numerous times, everytime I hear this song it sends a shiver down my spine and a tear to my eye... U2 are a phenomena... Thank you!
Still bring tears to my eyes love this song
Only guys can feel the pain of this song..😏
Was there in 87. Meadowlands N.J. Best year of my life.
The best version of this song.
Great version and quality. I think this was when Bono was the best vocally and also still had that haunting stare to him.
He is gorgeous and his song with or without you love ❤❤❤😊
🖤 This could have easily been an official music video. The lighting is so beautiful.
Thank you Bonnie ,thx U2 for YOUR music !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
maybe my all time favorite song, reminds me of college and makes me feel so young again
Wonderful! Bono is gorgeous!
yup.
Bono does look Cute Here Ok
What hurts the most is when you find someone who changes your whole life without even looking...only to be driven away because others can't accept our love...we both lost our self-respect and I don't know if anyone can ever understand our love but God. She's everything I ever hoped for. She's everything I desire. I might do prison time because I loved and cared for someone who needed saving, just like me. I know Gods timing will unite us together someday. I cry and pray every day for her. I hope no one ever goes thru this, and if you do/are, have faith and trust God's planning. I love you so much, janell. From the sweetness of your touch, from the pureness of your heart. You're all I desire
Gli U2 non hanno bisogno di commenti, si commentano da soli con la loro musica 🔝😇
U2 my favourite since 1987. Love you stay blessed, healthy with long life
Masterpiece....my favorite song all the time
Love his music, such a great voice, so true to his self.JUST GREAT IN EVERY WAY, A GREAT HUMAN BEING
TOP TOP TOP... dal 4:33 al 4:50 chitarra e batteria una cosa sola...
Larry è una mitragliatrice con quelle bacchette...
Old is gold!
Makes me cry every time I hear it, wonderful memories with a wonderful, beautiful lady who I will never ever forget 🌹
The greatest song of all time.. one heart, one hope, one love with or without you.🥺🥹
Best song in my life.
This song, this specific version of the song, is so insanely good! Just wow!
Adam Clayton had the best time of his life on this. 4 notes for the whole thing and still sounded like he was a real bass player. Living the dream Adam
his voice ...i never realized how powerful and beautiful is!
Those were the days!!! No phones blocking your view.
Joe Gomez tankyou
Joe Gomez thank
@Joey Style Today yeah. Not back then.
Feel free to re-live the good ol' days by getting rid of your cell phones.
Ok boomer
We'll shine like stars in the summer night, we'll shine like stars in the winter light
Theirs just something about this song and this period that cannot be replicated!! This song and this Band u2 awakened me to the power of love and music !! Truly timeless 👌
i can Play It Over and Over...
2018 and still can't get over in this song ❤
Beautyful Men.. beautyful Songs Happy Memories happy days. Thank You Forever 💞
best rock singer/song writer /preformer ever lived
no thats bob dylan.
@A.C. why are they better than dylan? you realize dylan is up there with shakespeare, edgar allen poe dont you? saying the stones are better song writers is like saying the screenplay of the movie top gun is better than shakespeares romeo and juliet. sure some people even think bieber is better than dylan but critics worth their salt and history will show dylan as the greatest song writer and the father of modern rock n roll. you can like the stones more than dylan but that is just your taste. even the stones will tell you that they must carry his amp to his show not the other way around. the stones themselves will bow their knee to dylans genius, so why cant you?
thesongtowoody Bob Dylan is an excellent lyricists. one of the best. but in my opinion Bono can sing much much better. especially now that Dylan’s voice is so raspy.
Nobody ever said that. You’re just saying it now because of the movie and gay worship times we live in. 🙄
Apparently you didn’t read his full comment...you know...about being an entertainer and singer. Why don’t you say Hank Williams is greater than Elvis Presley why you’re at it. 🙄
14살에 밴드음악에 빠져서 처음으로 중독된 노래.
31살이 된 지금도 주기적으로 듣지만 라이브가 너무 좋다...
I'll never leave this group, this era, till someone better comes along.....I may have a long wait...
Fave 🌹❤️🦋😍😍😍😍😍
this Drummer kills me - the best drummer i have ever seen
may89 ebraheem he’s incredible; cute too!
You've never seen Neil Peart then.
Led Zeppelin had the best drummer.
@@andrewpowell1734 peart, not pearl and no hes a totally different drummer
No he's not, but god damn it, he kinda is!
Great guitar lines, great song, certainly the best version
U2 - With Or Without You ( live 1987 )[ lyrics ] *** Love this song ....Haven't heard it a long time.... ty for sharing...True love waits for you..
What an amazing song!
1987 was the best year for u2.. the Joshua tree was what made them .. outstanding memories of such a fantastic band ..so many incredible memories xx love u guys xx
First time I heard this was in friends. Yes I know not the most magical place to hear it. But i remember it vividly, I was in the living room, with my dad and stepmum, they watched me tear up as Ross sat sad that he’d lost Rachel, it thought it was over, all over, and I’ll always remember that night because it was the first time I saw my dad say “I love you” to anyone, instead of “love ya” and I miss it. I miss when my dad liked my company, now I’m here, in my room alone, haven’t talked to my dad since new years and it’s literally his birthday soon… I just wish I could have our bond back, I miss my dad 🙁 signed - an 18 year old who just wants to be enough for his dad
i can Play It Over and Over...
Fernanda Lo Pizzo I do!! Lol
@@krystalgray5675 this is all its ok
Born in 1992 but I feel I like old songs more And old singers feel more affinity from their voice.
Classic U2,love it....
This song is an Icon!! for sure I believe that is called immortal
A distanza di anni ,decenni , questa OPERA D' ARTE è la mia preferita, i suoni la voce la chitarra i bassi e le bastonate di Larry su quei tamburi che ti rimbombano in testa . Io sono grato a Larry che mise In bacheca nella sua scuola la voglia di formare una band e dare inizio agl U2 .riempiendo così anche la nostra vita e gioventù . Grazie .
Straight Outta Friends! xD
I just watched s02ep8 for the first time, amazing serial!
Same
Please don't associate a crappy sitcom featuring clueless guys and ditzy broads with this masterpiece of music. I can't stand picturing those clueless guys with their blank faces and those ditzy chicks with their hands on their hips, mouth open and that "Oh my gosh!" expression.
@@adriankarbowniczyn2091 と
@@davidhoover4063I really hated “Friends”
I was 2 when this album came out,never would i have imagined I would get to experience this live! #joshuatreetour2017
I was 17 and waited 30 years to see them live...best album of all time for me
ascoltate il finale del brano e chiudete gli occhi, provate a pensare a qualcuno che amate in profondità e sentirete la grandezza degli U2 e quanto sia bella la musica.
Melhor banda da história do rock
excelente banda linda musica perfeita saudades dessa época 1987 eu tinha 17 anos de idade saudades
I wait for you !! With or without out
Eu também ❤
A great song.Surely,one of the best,ever.Doesn't matter which version.
Every good song has a great/best live version ever and this one is that of this song ♥️
Beautiful song and I have such a crush on Bono in this video!
Emily Pugh o Brasil cuti
Louco solitário
All the ladies used to tell me I looked like Bono, I told them id rather have his money, my wife doesn't think so. Oh well.
I'm a straight guy, but I also have a crush on Bono
MrRondonmon hahaha
pure magic. this song will be around 100 years from now.
I've seen U2 twice in Vancouver, BC....first concert in 1988 and then in the early 90's...the Zoo tour...both shows were just electric, U2 rocks, a gorgeous blend of voice and guitar licks.
I've seen over 200 bands over 25 yrs. U2 is among the very best bands I've seen live!
they always seem to have a strong flavorful bass line thank you adam
This album is masterpiece.
Best version it gives me chills
90년대 중반에 동인천 심지음악감상실에 갈 때마다 이 영상을 신청했습니다. 그때나 지금이나 최고입니다.
Grazie di 💜 U2 40 con voi solo con voi!!!
The way he sings is so sexy he seems to eat the microphone, this is a song I will play repeatedly without feeling out of date and 1987 is really a legendary year. Even I was not born in that time, but I feel I was living in that time.
Medieval Dream sameeeee ❤️
It's like he making love to you
He songs with lots of emotions.
Sometimes losing someone can change your life.
I 100% agree with u. The Joshua Tree is the best album from the 80s, this song is will never age at all, it will always be a masterpiece.
It was a great time indeed... Even then I knew it would be a classic. The energy and tension of the music and his voice is awesome throughout. These were the days before rap when singers had to sing and every idiot wasn't holding up a cellphone blocking your view.
One of my favorite band. Since high school days. 90's kids hello 🖐🖐🖐
I really enjoy the last 1.5min.. the drum, the guitar, the bass... wowwowwwww
I'm happy to have found this live version wherein the whoa climax part is sung by both Bono and Edge.
I am working in a middle East country for construction work. my family is in my home country without me. after work, my body is exhausted under hot sun. I am missing my wife and memories with her. I am middle of 40s. sing this song with little tear when I sing 'one heart, one hope, one love'.