Don't criticize India until you watch THIS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 พ.ค. 2024
- Meet Kiran Bhat. He is an Indian American writer who speaks 12 languages, been to 151 countries, and has now been living in Mumbai, India, for 3 years. Kiran shared with me why foreigners don’t understand India, the major differences in mentality between North and South Indians, and why he no longer wants to live in America. Enjoy!
TO START AND GROW TH-cam:
🎬 Online workshop "TH-cam Fast-Track to Views & Passive Income". Book your spot: event.webinarjam.com/register...
🏆 12-month full-scale personally coached program ‘Side Hustle TH-cam Mastery.’ Join us: max-chernov.mykajabi.com/shym...
LET'S BOOST OUR RELATIONSHIP:
📷 My Instagram: / chernov_networking
💰 Sponsorship-related requests: maxchernovYT@gmail.com
👥 If you have a guest suggestion for an interview, please reach out at maxchernovYT@gmail.com
WATCH NEXT:
► What happened to this American in 7 years in Indian family: • What happened to this ...
► Is India the Perfect Country for Foreigners?: • Is India the Perfect C...
► A Westerner Reveals The Truth About 9 Years in India: • Australian reveals the...
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 INTRO
00:32 Misconceptions about India
04:53 Generalisations are the worst
07:26 Indian or American?
09:01 How to learn languages
10:19 How to understand a new country?
13:47 Annoying things to accept
16:15 The biggest mistakes of tourists in India
19:09 The view on America
23:06 How to make the world better
TODAY'S GUEST:
➢ on Instagram: / originalsin_0421
➢ Kiran's new book: www.amazon.com/Speaking-Tongu...
➢ Kiran's project: www.girar.world/
➢ Kiran's website: kiranbhatweldgeist.com/
Hey! This channel bridges the gap between locals and foreigners in Singapore, Malaysia, and India. Join Max as he interviews expats, unraveling their unique stories and providing valuable insights into their lives in the vibrant cities of Asia. Through engaging conversations, Max fosters understanding and appreciation between locals and the global community, focusing on cultural exchange.
If you're a company seeking sponsorship opportunities to engage our upscale audience, contact us at maxchernovYT@gmail.com. With over 50% Singaporean viewers and a substantial number of foreign professionals (US, EU, Australia), our mature audience (35-54 years) boasts strong purchasing power and interests in an above-average lifestyle, travel, investment, and personal finance.
#ExpatLife #MaxChernov #India
If you have never traveled to another country, you have no right to criticize that country.
And even if people travel to other countries, they still don't have the right to criticize them. Because to be there just to visit is one thing. But, to live there is a whole other reality. People visit and leave, and their criticism doesn't make any difference in locals daily lives at all.
Travelled & lived for a few years. *
My opinion was formed when indians came to my country not nice
Wtf 😂
ive been in india. altho as a transit to UK, but the fact that you cant even keep your airport clean, the gates to your country, is embarrassing
India is about it's lovely people more than anything else. You can't find such kind and warm people anywhere in the world.
That's kind of narcissism
@@user-rr1mz8qi9o Only if he is Indian, not otherwise.
I have met a few in my country on the contrary
Actually I found it here in Myanmar and the Indian community lowest to highest embraced me
Now, that is what everybody says...
Thank you for this wonderful video. It dropped at the right time. I was embraced by the Indian community here in Myanmar. I was intivted by the Deputy Chief Commissioner to meet with him at the Indian Embassy. The nicest man who opened all the doors for me. Because I embrace my life in Myanmar and the people are so incredibly kind. I love Kiran's attitude! I'm learning so much about Indian culture by living in Myanmar and I'm making nice videos to capture all that. I hope to continue learning more. Kiran gave me more insights. I would love to visit India when the time is right. But I love living in Myanmar. If only we knew our true nature, who we really are - Atman is Brahman. Advaita Vedanta and Swami of NYC has WONDERFUL lectures on this. So now I really GET IT
M. seems to be in a heavy crisis, a junta regime reigns. What is ur life there, work, under such circumstances?
True; Atman is Bramha..
Lady living under Junta regime, war torn country which has militia fighting against each other on Chinese money talking about India.. surprising….
Interesting Fact:- British Looted around 45Trillion USD from India. You can check studies.
Australia nd US were built on India 's looted money.
"Fun" only if you are British. For Indians, it is just a fact.
Don't forget how much the BJP has looted thus far! Our own screwing us over.
It shows
Utsa Patnaik's 2018 claims were debunked years ago.
60% no long live with under a dollar a day, that's data from 2000.
Yeah.
He is leftist. He will never give proper data and only thing leftist are good at is communication skill and after spreading virus of lgbt in US he has come to India
its not 60% its about 20 percent
Yeah. I was wondering the same.
Don't speak when you don't know!
This person is totally stranger to me, But i can listen to him whole day. His etiquette and soft speaking skill is awesome 😍😍
Exactly, you could be born in GAZA,UKRAINE, and all such places, I continuously thank the almighty for being born here in INDIA.
When he spoke Kannada he won our heart ……
Exactly
ತುಂಬಾ ಇಷ್ಟ ಆಯ್ತು😊
Pretty fluent too in kannada❤
And he bring free water to you
Back in 1991, GDP of India (265 Billion USD) was less than the GDP of Paris (266 Billion USD). By 2027 we will be the 3rd largest economy in the world. We have come so far.
It is an interesting point about politeness that he made. A lot of people who migrate within India sometimes do not realise that tone and body language can also be unintentionally rude. Instead of complaining that your host city is unwelcoming perhaps put some effort to clue into the local culture and figure out if there are some things you do that come across as hostile to the locals.
It could also be the reverse. A lot of people come to Mumbai and get offended because local colleagues may use the familiar Tu with them instead of the more polite Tum or the formal Aap. It takes some paying attention to realise that they are not being rude. It is common in Marathi (the local language) to talk to your contemporaries in a familiar manner. This shows friendliness or familiarity (a kind of "you are like me") rather than rudeness. It takes some getting used to for people who stick to the formal register in their native languages. But, once you get it, you will not spare any more thought to it.
I thought it was the opposite, lol. I had some ppl in my Uni in Chandigarh who came here all the way from Mumbai and they would always use "Aap" even when we were the same age (it's not differentiated by formality, but age I thought), so I thought "Man, these ppl are exhaustingly polite down in Mumbai....would be annoying to live among them", but u're saying it's the opposite: Interesting.
@@_UNISTAR_ Mumbaikars are told by the northerners that they are rude and many make the effort to be polite !
@@katyarkhukri7003 Interesting.
Certainly not the ones from my area. Maybe Himachalis, etc think that, but I don't think Haryanvis, or Punjabis would.
I'm really impressed by his honesty, and how soft spoken he is. It's sad he was bullied growing up.
Before 1997 I lived in Delhi and Punjab. I imagined that all South Indians were like Juhi Chawla's father in the film Hum Hain Rahi Payar Ke (1993).
Then I met many Singaporean Tamils who were hard core non vegetarians. In Chennai many CSI protestants and Kerala Syrian Christians were my friends. I even lived as a Hindu in a Shia majority neighborhood in Bangalore. My perspectived about South India changed completely.
Nowadays, people in North India have better awareness about South India because many have gone to Hyderabad and Bangalore for education and work. Also cinema from South India has exploded like movies like Ustad Hotel, Super Deluxe or Charlie 777.
Many people in North India know about Fahad Faasil and Yash while South Indians know about Badshah.
I learn so much from your comments.
❤ from Kerala
Come to North Karnataka. We are overwhelmingly Vegetarian here
@@jaibholenath6900 my favorite sweet from North Karnataka is Karadant from Gokak.
@@webabhi Dharwadi Pedha
This guy is more Indian then American. Just by staying in America for a few years becoming a citizen you can't wipe out the Indian culture.
I was born in Africa and grew up in UK and then settled in USA.. I still call myself Indian! I am a 3rd gen nri and we follow the Indian culture, food-I'm a devout Hindu and am vegetarian. I have been a citizen of each of the countries I have lived in. I still feel like I am more Indian, although India does not give me citizenship and I am called a foreigner and experience discrimination when I visit India.. 😔
sorry dude for discrimination but love you brother from another mother.
I watched this during the ipl . A huge compliment you wouldn’t understand 😂.
haha I get it!
You must be a RCB fan.😂😂
Still in comment section some people pointing out problems of India like we don't know our problems. WOW👍
It seems that there is a lack of willingness to bring about change in our society. Many of us are aware of the issues we face, but only a few of us are willing to take action to make things better. Instead, some people tend to escape to foreign countries, which is perfectly understandable, but it's not helpful to bad-mouth our own country without doing anything to improve it. If we continue to deny our responsibility for the problems, we can't expect things to get better.
It's high time that we prioritize the development of our youth in civic sense, education, and technology. If we take a closer look, we'll see that we have made significant progress in solving some major problems in the past decade or two, such as reducing tobacco use and decreasing illiteracy rates. Unemployment rates will also decrease for those who are willing to work. The internet has opened up a global market, but there are some concerning issues with our younger generation, such as the hook-up culture, drug use, underage drinking, and detachment from our values like family orientation and respect for others.
If we truly want to make a change, we need to take action. It's not impossible to achieve a better future if we work together and prioritize the right things.
Ignore those so-called "intellectuals".
In real life, they don't know ABCD, but they come to educate us on important issues on social media.
i was smiling when he spoke in kannada......all kannadigas mark your attendence here.
❤
I am Bihari living in Delhi but I mark my attendance
One here
❤kannada❤
ಬಂದಿದ್ದೀನಿ ಮೇಡಂ
Because of my experiences as a woman of color and the past year and a half of some major exposure to Indian culture, specifically, this is really hitting HOME with me. Everything he said is SPOT ON. Love being yourself! Can’t wait to come visit you in Mumbai, my friend. Love you! Great coverage, Kiran!!!❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉
Thanks max for making videos of foreign people who lived in India for longer time.If these people make comment on India based on their experiences so that can be a better answer in response to western media like bbc,new york times,wall street journal etc who show biased stories about India. I have seen many of your video,love and appreciation from my side
Well said. That is why I watch Max from time to time, but this one was so fantastic on so many levels for me
Guys increase this channel reach
I was so impressed with this video. He is doing good work with the right attitude. If you can be anything, be kind.
Amazing Channel one of a kind ❤
09:05 kannada ❤❤
Loved that you added Hindi subtitles! Just love Devnagri script so much.
I appreciate Mr. Kiran's factual portrayal of India and Mr. Max's nuanced representation of the country, which is unlike the portrayal of other Western media outlets.
Only 15% of Indians live under $1 a day. You are quoting statistics which are 15 years old.
If you consider inflation this still hold true.
@joycehost-kh8vx lol whats the connection between what op said n what u said. They r talking economy n u r talking whatever
@@urmila5552gives Joyce a chance to pontificate, that’s the connection
Less than 4% , gets your facts right
awesome and beautiful video. you are doing a good job. Keep it up. I am an Indian now living in America and I know how American people react.
Wow, that was a beautiful conversation. Very well spoke Kiran.
This channel is a gem. Every single video is entertaining and informative.
He literally said how Indians think and all, man you deserve this medal.
Definitely need more conversation on this topic on podcast etc.
thank you for bringing him
Just so you people know, I totally disagree with world's happiness index. I'm about as happy as I can be living here. We have more freedom than the world media depicts on their outlet and I've never been oppressed by anyone here. Yeah, I know that India has its own fair share of flaws but there's no country out there without flaws.
Sometimes, I look at what he is talking about (in my own life from my own view) and just go numb….and then I go within and remember that we are infinite beings in a falsely structured 3D world. He is spot on
There r 2 ways to be on top .1 is ur potentiality nd other is by downgrading nd humiliating ur counter part.west following the 2nd way as it is well-known about the potentiality of india since the colonial rule.
Burma says hi. Well said.
Your channel is great.i like kirans attitude.
Nowadays an avarage indian monetary prosperity is almost 60 percent of an average European,s prosperity in early 1980s .and realise that by 1980 Europe was already developed and rich.of course there are poor people in India ,in single digit percentage but. India is no more a poor country.
I think India still is poor country if we see on the ground. By GDP it's not. Was Europe rich by 1980s itself? Wow. Seems like unemployed youth must be getting proper help till they get their job, pregnant women and people must be getting proper medical support and almost every family must have had at least one car in their family.
It is the public spaces that reflect poverty which needs to be fixed.
Indian people are super friendly, hospitable, and kind. Especially the ones who live in India (and not abroad).
This will hit Million+ soon!
Guest is amazing to hv mastered so many languages nd culture ....truly follows 'vasudhaiv kutumbukam ' !
Bhaiya means brother respectfully and not bro. Bhai means brother and still not a bro equivalent. People will usually not use either if they are being rude. That was a misunderstanding.
Today India has better facilities than western world in areas that do matter a lot.
Let us take medical facilities. I have friends in the usa who say getting a doctor appointment might take days. Here in India you have a very good government and private hospitals where you can walk in and get an appointment. The treatment is far cheaper and good.
You have the option for allopathy, ayurveda, homeopathy, unani etc.
The insurance and pharma mafia has not taken over the medical system like the USA and hence you can get treatment at more than one tenth the cost.
My friend who is around 72 years old, an American recently came and did both her knee replacement surgery in India for Around 5000 $. She said in the USA it's not possible for a person who is of that age to get a knee replacement and even if it's possible it would have cost more than 20000$.
The ease of digital payment in India has surpassed all western world.
The cultural richness of India is something which is absent in the USA.
Family relationships are far better than the western society.
The purchasing power of the middle class Indian is greater than the western world when we compare the costs of living.
Considering all these I think India is a better place to live😊
First part is so true. I am an Indian and I think the same way. Whenever one of my relatives is pregnant, I am always praying that the baby is physicallyborn normal. That's all I care for.
Maksim , check out the easter part of Indian this time too ! Specially Kolkata. One of the most welcoming and hospitable cities
Well said and well explained 👍
Some mistakes he dont know current data
Wow he talk kannada I just surprised lovely,ondu nimisha,ondu nimisha
Hope he updates his knowledge most people atleast earn more than a 5/10 USD daily leaving a few exceptions if they do any work at all
Super guru, ನಿಮ್ಮ ಕನ್ನಡ ಪ್ರೇಮಕ್ಕೆ ನಮಸ್ಕಾರ
He is an actualised human.❤
I am not sure whether you have already interviewed her.....
But I would love to see you interact with Ivana Perkovic (who had settled in Bengaluru till recently but now happily married to an Indian and I presume she is now somewhere in North India)
She is now living in Mumbai, and is pregnant !! I would also love to watch an interview of her in this channel 😊
It's really impressive vlogs lots of inspirations ,I really like it 🎉
What a beautiful video. I loved his explanation of gratitude.
Very interesting video.👍🏻
Young man needs to check his facts
My dear friend the tables Are turning at this point of time😊
Great video ❤❤❤❤
Why is it such a big deal for Westerners if you speak more than one language even our babies speaks at least 2
Same for Europeans. I think it's more the ppl from white skin nations who think it is a miracle if they speak anything other than English. Also just egoistic bragging like the type of person who brags on how many countries they ticked off a check list. Foolishness.
I am also South Indian , why it was annoying , i dont understand
We also Say Anna (bhaiya) while addressing , Is it not stereotyping North Indian , ofcourse No South Indian will say Excuse me Sir , pls help me 😂😂😂😂
What an awesome human he's.
Wow. Now you speak Kannada very nicely.❤❤❤
How did Max put the cork back in?
For India their systems work for the Indians. They have lived there for many centuries and understand how it works. For people traveling there, just enjoy the fabulous delicious foods and cultures. Respect others ways of living.
Him: i wont use the word gratitude in the cliched western sense
Proceeds to do just that*
Kiran is a sweetheart ❤
Hijra
After living in HIND - BHARAT for 3 years as per this video & he is Still Not Aware of the Actual Population of the Country...
You will not find that because it's increasing in leaps and bounds
Although population of India is increasing, growth rate has declined...
I felt heartwarming (just a normal instinct, no trolling please) when Kiran started speaking suddenly in Kannada
Please don't put hindi Subtitles because they don't match with your conversation and they became irritating.
Btw Love your videos ❤❤
Must be useful to those who don't understand English. I can see your point as well as many of those people wouldn't even click on these kinds of videos. I ignored the subtitle and listened to what's being told.
All your podcasts are great but this one is truly amazing!
Agree!
Glad you enjoy it!
Whatever you say about India is correct😔
Doesn't matter if someone criticizes India or not... it's their choice. We don't care about others'opinions.
To understand India, you need to understand different castes(and how it's related to kind of jobs people do), understand different linguistic regions, different geographic regions, economic and demographic disparity in different parts of India and this is just the bare minimum.
The famous Kannada expression “ swalpa adjust Maadi “ ( please accommodate a bit )
When he says chappal instead of flip flops or slippers, then you know he has made the transition
Great video
Bhartiya people are not materialistic,,,they are full of contentment,,
I think if you want to learn more about India you need to understand Hinduism, Hindu philosophy, Ethics, local culture (Food, Dressing, Festivals, Customs), Local Language, History before colonial times and colonial times, changes that this land has gone through during these times etc.
So I don't think as a tourist one get opportunity to read or learn this land in the brief time they spend here. Unless one is passionate and able to give time for all this it is possible to understand India.
I think that is very insightful comment. It is funny. Life brought me to Myanmar. I started making little videos. I was embraced by the Indian community. At the same time life had also brought me to the wonderful talks of the Swamy of the NYC Advaita Vedanta Society. So even though I am very ignorant of Indian culture (I lived 7 years in Mainland China and understand very well), at some level I think this already helped me to understand a lot. I love my life in Myanmar and want to thank the Indian community for welcoming in this funny Aunty with the funny colored hair!
@@MissLizaYangonMyanmar Don't think it is difficult to understand China or Mayanmar or any other country because more or less they are uniform. China is communist rule for a long time. Their native cultures are all hijacked by communist and standardised in their own way. But there will be some suttle differences be it in food and customs.
Coming to Mayanmar that is a buddist country. so understanding Buddism, bit of their political struggle is enough.
but India is more diverse. Between states dressing, language, customs, architecture, food everything changes. Mostly that unites all is our religion i.e Sanatan Dharma. Some call the same as Hinduism. So it is not easy unless someone tries to understand India from religion, cultural and historical standpoint.
You are nt correct that 60% live with one dollar a day.
The pollution got me this trip arrived in Delhi 26/2 got severe bronchitis spent 3 weeks of my 4 in a hotel getting well enough to travel home. I come every year for a month and never had this problem before, so yes agree with him about getting use to weather or food etc so if the pollution is high wear a mask outside for westerners other your holiday could be ruined like mine was this year 🙏
What is your proof or anything saying half of Indian living below 1$ a Day!!!
those people who have not good stomach to digest food blame the food ... ogh its indian food its spicy it's this its that. learn about india some basic things, talk to some indian before you go to india , so you have rough idea .... india is vast country with all the weather available in the world in one country so its important to do some learning
Understanding India is the most easiest task in the world, only the perspective of looking at the world should be right, the people of India takes selfies with every foreigner without considering his religion, color or appearance.
2:30 According to World Bank, in 2021, 12.9% people in India lived under $2.15 a day. And 38% live under $6.85 a day. And according to most sources, half of the population lives below $13/day, a number which is $35 in China. So India is not that poor what you think. Indians have high saving rate.
Don't forget to mention the cost of living as well. 2$ per day is certainly bad but if you're you're making even 15$ per day then that's pretty decent and could get you a decent life.
😂 pro just accept India is the best
@@blackman7186 Yeah its true. But I think most of us are still poor, not as he said like dollar a day.. But even PPP wise our income per capita is quite less than other countries. Good thing is, we are growing quite fast.
@vedants.vispute77 That's incorrect. India is ranked third in GDP per PPP. Indians do have a lot of purchasing power parity. Also, GDP per capita is not worth comparing between different countries as you also need to consider the Cost of living, inflation, and purchasing power with per capita income, only then it's relevant. India is a poor country is a myth, India is not poor, a percentage of Indians are poor, and these poor are rapidly getting out of poverty.
@@blackman7186 PPP factor is itself calculated by adjusting to cost of living. An average American earns $4000 a month, while iphone, ps5 all cost less than $1000.. This is not the case for India. India is one of the most poorest countries in the world. You just belong to the top 2% hence you might not feel it.
More to learn
As an indian..i still find india is hub of mystery
I speak 14 languages....
And the language of love as well ?😅
Whole world media criticizes india, and reason is that something is hard to digest for them
I think sometimes it is because they want India to do better. It is 2024 and they are disappointed that things haven't changed. Like Bill Gates, a Christian, gave one billion dollars of his money to improve conditions in India. How much have the Adani's and Ambanis have done with their money for India?
@@Dan-xx5jq well , it's not about hindu , Christians, muslims or other . All are equal and our Sikh brothers are feeding millions in foreign. HAF in usa are ran by Hindus . Personally I don't care about relegion. I don't wanna judge anyone because of relegion because you know who were Brits and what they did to india . You know about jamsetji Tata ? India's billionaire who donated almost 103 billion while bill gate did 79 billion according to world philanthropic list . Basically there are many reasons for India's average development. You have to take care of 1.4 billions people also with democracy. Like you can't handover Everything to private companies as it happens in west .
@@Dan-xx5jqIndians respectfully don't agree with any of your point. Bcz none of your point is valid. Your comment itself says..you consumed these information from non authentic sources or non true or biased. Moreover you don't know India and its problem. your Christian gave one billion thing is also untrue better research properly before reacting to a comment.
@@Dan-xx5jq I am 100% sure Bill Gates is not doing philanthropy as a "Christian". Stop giving religious spin to humanitarian work.
@@Dan-xx5jqlol it's exactly opposite they don't want there Anglo Saxon hegemony to ever end and India who once was the centre of this planet wrt to everything is rising again and that fears them
There is a say in Sanskrit "Loko. Bhinna Ruchihi' means all people of this universe have different tastes - All family members in a single family are different from one another in nature So is all about different countries and all depends on the belief, culture of their own of their countries and its human nature that every person is somewhere out of his place tends to compare his own beliefs to that of others
Add more questions like, about cricket, vegan life etc..
There is North South East West North East
But everything is Bharat
60% under $1.. You sure man?
He's a interesting person
Lots of demand for India and Singapore interviews 😂
Racisim is not जातिवाद i will urge you to kindly change your subtitles. Although you are doing a great job....Har Har Sambhu ❤
I like that kid drinking Sting.
That's happy.
This guy likes to complain a lot about people that complain a lot
I love India but working in India as a nurse I won't be able earn as much I earn in UK
09:04 Wow kannada ❤❤
Sir simple question how can u translate racism into jaativaad
Please be correct
Both are different. Jaativaad is casteism.
@@sudhakar7889 hmm but in their video they defined racism as jaativaad
@@DiptiDangi-zq2wv maybe because of lack of words. You tell me what word is suitable?
@@sudhakar7889 yes, I can understand lack of word situation but saying it's jaativaad is wrong and better word would be nasalvaad
@@DiptiDangi-zq2wv Yes.right
❤❤❤✨🙏!!
Bhaiya means ealder brother
This guy should meet Abhijit Iyer mitra
😂😂😂
bhaiya doesn't mean bro it means big bro... they were respecting him as big bro though they didn't knew him.. even when we say bhai its intent is purely as a brother.. until someone just calls you by "oye" ,"oh sun"...still the level of offence depends on the level of ego you're bearing which you think suits your political status/financial status...
It is funny that he calls himself part Indian and a calm person but he got offended by 'bhaiya', which actually shows that those kids spoke to him very respectfully and nowhere does it show that they wanted him to stop all his work. He should also know that there are no parallel words for 'excuse me' in Hindi, every language works differently.
Don't try to understand it just accept it.
I feel 🇬🇧 gets mentioned in almost every video on this channel. Sure, we’re usually getting a kicking, but at least you’re talking about us, right?
We need to pick up some lessons from the 🇺🇸 USA when it comes to robustness of institutions, having accountability and transparency! Efficient governance and infrastructure, swift justice system that is very much fair!