The Birth of the European Government
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 มี.ค. 2017
- How did the EU go from a trade agreement to a multinational European government?
Patreon: / averything
Social Media
Discord: / discord
Reddit: / historyscope
Twitter: / scopehistory
Instagram: / officialhistoryscope
Facebook: / averythingchannel
My music playlist while animating: • My Music Playlist
**Ode to Joy Intensifies**
Est Europa nunc unita, et unita maneat..
Una in diversitate, pacem mundi augeat...
I fucking love living in Europe. For me it doesn't mean harmful homogenization. It means an absolutely beautiful diversity that's easily discoverable.
I was raised in France, learnt French, but with American parents. Learnt Spanish in school. Now getting a masters degree in Italy, learnt Italian. Love it here. Probably going to Germany next year as part of my program. Probably going to learn German and probably going to love Germany too.
Why would anyone think Europe is harming individual nation's cultures? It makes me appreciate my French culture and history even more, just as much as it makes me appreciate Europe for having such a diversity of historical and beautiful countries.
Well written. I agree
The EU is a true ideal for the world forwards. We need however, ways to combat misinformation campaigns launched by vested interests and dispel any authoritarian risings.
"Greenland became independent in 1985." False. Greenland is an autonomous country within the Kingdom of Denmark. They have home rule, but are not independent.
Yeah I thought this when I was watching it. I learned it from Borgen :-P
@@mantwerp4304 False. Iceland became independent in 1944, 17th of June to be precise. I'm Icelandic.
Another great video here. Just a small mistake at 1:41 where instead of 'dictatorship' the label 'democracies' were used. Aside from that, great video.
For accuracy, The UK did NOT hold a referendum on whether to join the Community, until 2 years AFTER it had already joined.
what has Harry Potter go to do with the EU?
everything!!!! :D
@@lamichka nothing...
same with cdprojekt and skype both created before their respective country joined the EU...
Skype wasn't a hit because of the EU but because of microsoft, cd project released witcher 3 years after they joined the EU but I somehow think that the EU got pretty much nothing to do with it.
Spains GDP isn't the same as russia between them are 200 Billion €.
Honestly this is just a europhile video the EU has many advantages but this video is just crap...my opinion.
@@Slithermotion Call it what you want, its still kinda informative, at least for students.
@@Slithermotion just saw when this was posted, my bad, ignore my comment(s)
I don't know much about cd projekt or who created skype, but with the context and the Harry Potter example, I'm guessing they were founded or had a major notable boost by someone who either lived/was from one of those poorer economic zones that recieved aid, making a better circumstance for them to thrive and create what they did. Or they were poor themselves and received that aid before being successful with their programing. I know Rowling often talks about how poor she was before getting the first book published and receiving financial aid at points, so I'm guessing the others had similar stories. Not having to worry so much about starving lead to innovation that birthed massive economic bonuses for their country.
Here in cyprus we honestly got saved by the eu, i dont give a fuck about what people say, our lives improved since we joined. We recovered from our crisis in 2013 and we are still transforming with a steady growth, surprisingly romania is the second fastest growing country in europe and im happy for them since they arent really well off.
How do you feel about northern Cyprus?
5:40 France apparently conquered Sardinia.
Your video really helped me thanks
Talk about the Tulsa Massacre.
Your comparison with the USA and Mexico is absurd. The US and Mexico are not in a political union. A more apt comparison would be between US states, which have had "open borders" for 200+ years. Your comparison to Mexico would be more akin to the EU's relationship with Morocco or Syria. You don't have open borders with them.
these videos are great thank you !
You're welcome! :) next one, about how the EU works, will be up today! (If my internet allows it)
Hey man, i've got this test on European Institutional Law this friday and there's this one thing i don't get.. At the end of the video you talk about the freedom of goods and that this was enabled by the Single European Act (1987). You say that it gave equal standards for goods in all of the EU by harmonising laws of the Member States. The thing i don't get however is that how is this competable with the Cassis de Dijon-ruling (1979), which stated that whenever a good is produced in a Member State according to the rules of that Member State, it shall have free access in the rest of the Union?? Didn't "Cassis de Dijon" already solve the problem of differences in standards for goods??
Hope someone can help me out, as i'm a bit confused at the moment lol
Kelvin Te Brake how did it Go???
@@Adrian-rb4qp no one in Europe cares what you think, because there in charge, and this country must do as its told
Ben Gunn what?
@@Adrian-rb4qp What don't you under stand is it the fact that the EU use people like your self to run there indoctrination campaigns
It codified ECJ rulings and made them more concrete and detailed. They also have more standing in the form of “law” (though it may be called directives).
Should be changed to the Earth Union and to let any country to join and follow the same principals like fund to raise up poorer members and single military. Which after all countries have joined would theoretically no longer be needed once all countries have become members.
Where can we find the text of this video? @historyscope
Liked and suscribed ! European Union was the best thing that happent to us since WW2 ! I wish to see some day that European Union becomes USE, United States of Europe just like USA !
There are no states in the EU lol, it consists of different countries so it deffo wouldn't be called USE......, probably something else
Yeah you don't want to be like U.S.A. I love my country, but we are about to tear ourselves apart at the seams right now. We are probably heading toward civil war.
Yeah me too. Federalization of the EU is far and unlikely, but we can dream.
@@user-xv4xl7rs4q no one in Europe cares what you think, because there in charge and these country's must do as there told
I too hope that Europe unites one day, but it'll have to be a federation with lots of autonomy to certain countries...
Greenland aint independent, and I thought Skype was Swedish
Nops, Skype is from Estonia and Greenland is independent.
@@DJRoksor Oh yeah I mixed up Skype with spotify, also no, Greenland is not independent. Its an autonomous region.
@@pontan8084 Independent and autonomous are synonyms. Here is a definition from the dictionary for independent: "not subject to another's authority or jurisdiction; autonomous; free."
Greenland is an autonomous country of the Kingdom of Denmark with Denmark having no influence on it's authority and jurisdiction, hence it's an independent country.
@@DJRoksor Its foreign policy and security is controlled by Denmark. And as its not listed as a sovereign nation by the UN, it should not be considered as such.
so, I probably would not be butchering monsters and bandits if it weren't for this European Government
GREENLAND IS STILL APART OF DENMARK
Isnt this art done by someone from Extra History or smth
The UK has been a net contributor every single year hasn't it, since it joined in 1973? So the UK paid more than it got, every year. You video at 2:40 is misleading at best on that, if not completely dishonest. I like the fact that we now need to thank the EU for Harry Potter though :) Also, correct me if I am wrong, but aren't some of the longest border walls those of Spain's walls in Africa? Yes, the same Spain that is part of the EU. Lastly, the EU is not Europe. Europe is a continent, and the EU is a political organisation which came into existence in 1992 with the Treaty of Maastricht.
Agree except 4 border checks which r SO imp't 4 animals. Puppies r abusively shipped (they use drugs 2 get pups 2 sleep if abusers r worried about noise) but search dogs go CRAZY if pups r inside a car etc. More checks = less animal abuse.
what
"1967 Merger Treaty was signed". This is wrong, it was signed in 1965 (and came into force in 1967)
why is the French guy sitting on the Deutsche Mark bag, while the German guy is sitting on the Franc bag? 2.41
In hindsight with Brexit, De Gaulle was probably right not to want the UK in.
EU was the best thing that ever happened Greece :D
I'm from Croatia and EU fucked us over too fuck EU
F.
A surprise, but a welcome one
I’m going to miss being an EU citizen
Daniel Ethell this shit comes and goes in waves my friend, it’s not the end of the world by any means. Honestly, you may end up being lucky once the EU garners enough power where there is not enough sovereignty left among the nations to push back in case of tyranny. The consolidation of power is never a good thing, whether it be in individual nations or in a super-national organization.
de Gaulle was right. God damn right.
Too bad people didn't listen to him.
2:20 That might have been true in 1973, it is not now, as you showed later the UK is the second biggest economy in Europe, 5th GLOBALLY, so now it is just wasting money not on the UK.
Things change, shock, it is not 1950 now.
noise
The problem is the British are Anglophiles . They rarely travel or work in Europe nor do they speak European languages .British people tend to live and travel to English speaking countries such as in the commonwealth and the USA Also having open border’s into the UK is just not going to work because Britain is a small island and also a popular world destination immigration would just be too much
The British people were never going to ruled by laws from a centralised European Commission. The Eu to the British smacks of dictatorship. You can’t vote out rules,regulations and diktats. In Britain the people have the power of the vote . It’s not like in Europe where the state has all the power. In Britain the government has no powers. It only governs by the consent of the people and can easily be removed .You cant remove the European Commission . That’s the difference . The Eu was never going to work in the Uk.
See this is why we need to make sure the EU survives once you take in to account what the EU does you see why it's highly unlikely to fail
As if the EU fails Europe fails
It's one of the reasons Germany did what it did in Greece they needed to stabilize the euro so that Europe doesn't have a recession
I understand the complaints against the EU but dismantling the EU is basically economic suicide for the European economies
Greece was handed money to pay off loans during the Greek financial crisis so that its fall wouldn't hurt Greece and especially the European market
Overall the EU is better but we must safeguard what it stands for and prevent it from failing at its own goals
We must safeguard the EU against authoritarians and skeptics looking to disassemble the EU like how in Germany threatening democracy if a criminal offense which is wise considering the history of how dictators rise
Great video
And to the random reader have a nice day
Love from Florida, U.S.A.
no one in Europe cares what you think, because there in charge and these country's must do as there told
@@bengunn7443 years later and i have to tell you that i care about what he thinks
"The UK created the Harry Potter series"??? WTF???? I think you'll find that J.K.Rowling created the Harry Potter series, and did so while scraping a life on the dole.
Wrong she created nothing she just the front face deceiving the sleepwalking zombies guess who owns Harry Potter as it's to groom your children to accept black magic.
What a Naive view of the EU
What a naive comment
(look how little value a statement has when you provide no explanation of why that's the case)
This video some how forgets to mention the U.K. had areas of massive poverty because literally every penny the U.K. had was spent freeing our European neighbours. Germany offered a truce several times which the U.K. at which time the U.K. could easily have walked away.
no one in Europe cares what you think, because there in charge and this country must do as its told
No one in Europe cares what you think, because the three unelected person's in charge don't care. And these EU country's all must do as there told by these three little Hitlers
Great pro EU video.
You are confusing western Europe with the Western bloc from the Cold War. Greece is not in western Europe, they were part of the American-led western bloc which was at war with the USSR-led eastern bloc. This is not western europe or eastern europe, it's western bloc, which includes western ,northern and southern Europe. Big difference.
Uncomfortable voice on this episode.
bias af
LOL I love this video but the guy thinks he’s making a better case for the EU than he is. “It’s because if this (the EDF) that Britain could create the Harry Potter series” like shut UP, an individual person’s ideas and stories and character creations are not because Britain’s poorer regions got funds from richer EU religions. That’s such an overreach lol
Poor people are far far far less likely to publish a book than rich people. Hence: making people richer means more books get published. Hence a large number of books from the UK are published because people became richer because of EU funding.
I've got the degrees in economics. I know what I'm talking about.
@@HistoryScope You made a good video but I'd keep an eye on the Dunning-Kruger effect. Rowling was incredibly poor when she conceived and penned the concept for the entire series.
Quote:
"We're talking suicidal thoughts here, we're not talking 'I'm a little bit miserable,'" Rowling said. "Mid-twenties life circumstances were poor and I really plummeted."
Comically biased and misleading.
Hephaestus specific??
Yup
anti-british bias showing hard here.
yeah ok, nice wall of bullshit but we both know he is pushing the narrative of the UK to take loads of money from the EU at the beginning and leaves out the fact we were always net contributors... so really it's only our own money coming back.
I'm not gonna write an argument to convince you of anything. You have clearly already made up your mind and will probably be too stubborn to change it. Also, I'm not that clever(I only went to primary school) and you seem smart so I would probably make myself look dumb. I just don't think it was right to leave out that fact just because it's in another video. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it. :)
No anti-british biased was intended nor any narratives. These videos are meant to educate, not to push an agenda. The European development funds were a hotly debated topic during the Brexit referendum. It was therefore important to show the connection between how it was created and how it affects the world today.
Don't worry , search the TH-cam/ 99 % is Anti European British propaganga :)). You'll find something to like for sure lmao.
@@xxDeath99Starxx buthurt much?
British Hypocrisy
Watched up to the points were they say Estonia made skype. So many inaccurate or half way measure things in this video. Don't bother people.
3/5 creators were Estonian, most of the development team, and 44% of all the division's employees are still situated in Tallinn and Tartu, Estonia... what are you talking about?