@@celiahans-pu3sh That's G.E. Smith. He played in the SNL band for a long time (80s, 90s) and was one of the guitarists Hall and Oates used when they were big. He's quite the player,, but takes a backseat in this one to enjoy the show.
@@indiecomicsjones Knew G.E. back in his Scratch Band days in New England, went on to SNL (short time married to Gilda), toured with Dylan and got to see him again touring a tour that came through Santa Barbara...miss those "Glory Days" of my youth.
@@celiahans-pu3sh Read that he was the musical director for this. You also have Booker T and the MG's and Jim Keltner. The sum of all the parts on this one is incredible.
I watch this and it makes me want to cry. No more George or Tom, and hearing this song almost 60 years after it was released -- the memories, the losses, we've all gotten so old. Bob's lyrics -- brilliant as always.
Nonsense, it's just that young aspiring artists today, for the time I've been alive (47 years now) focus on IMAGE and not on WRITING. Goofy, dorky guys of all varieties, with their thick glasses and receding hairlines, used to WRITE music. That's why certain classics are just so ultimately classic. It's because PEOPLE wrote music instead of IMAGES writing music. For my 47 years, you're not "allowed" to write music without a certain image and here in Canada those image requirements are violently enforced by the fucking police. If Bob Dylan were Canadian and born in my time he would work in a machine shop for a few years and commit suicide. If Elvis were born in Canada he would be the Prime Minister or commit suicide. If Kurt Cobain were Canadian he would be a police officer and then commit suicide. The legendary genius Mark Knopfler?! If he were born in my time in Canada the police would have tortured him and he would have killed himself after owning a car. That would have been his ENTIRE LIFE. He would have had a CAR.
@@devilsoffspring5519 You sound like you're fun at parties. Way to ruin the positive vibes of this amazing performance with an absolute trash comment. Crawl back into your hole.
I miss Harrison and Petty! I’m 74 years now and bye grace for the love of music just keep going. Thank you for the post, Thank you Dylan for the amazing music treasure ❤☮️✌️
This performance is a masterpiece. I turn 70 in November and grew up with the best music ever. McGuinn, Harrison and Petty are the reasons I bought a Rickenbacker electric 12-string some years ago. My favorite instrument. My favorite musicians. This is REAL music that has meaning.
I’m right there with ya. I’m 68. We’re losing all the great ones who were the sound tracks of our youth. Hopefully when our generation is gone, the music will live on.
you took the words right out of my mouth Ron, for i too am a Ron, i am 61 and i thank God for all these gr8 artists who shared their gift with us, we are so fortunate to have grown up in such times.
I know that every generation thinks that their music is better than the present, but just really, when was it ever better than this? All those legends on one stage playing one of the best songs ever written. I saw this comment here once: "It's worth being old now to have been young then."
The older "kids" (as I refer in my mind) like born before the Baby BOOMers - like roughly 1949 down to about early 1920''s were best & most amazing - inspired by favorites ❤ed my parents & grandparents even- more than just top thousands of them - thar my mom in particular loved and all music like Beatles, Led Zeppelin - but she had countless LP's she sang - & not just Sing Along w Miitch (Miller) - Dule Ellington - Glenn Miller - Tommy - Jimmy Dorset - Ellla Fitzgerald - Rosemary Clooney - The Andrew Sisters - Dave Brubeck- Benny Goodman - Billie Holiday - Louie Prima - ETC -- Frank Zappa, 😮also seldom brought up - RE-MARK-ABLE - Born 1940 - Died in the 90's - 'bout age 51 - was an Italian/Greek American born in the USA - Baltimore, Maryland - Zappa was actually his family name - was a Master- with all respect to Classic- Enhanced it - with /for orchestral - etc guitar - etc -fusion of all kinds - even junk sound - in every aspect - Zappa morals / unimpressed with drama- distractions - drugs etc - self taught - self disciplined genius-with uncanny unwavering rare simplitic honesty to lying elite who are unskilled,, boring hypocrites - a few fools - even now deny free thought, art, speech, etc (edit it??) was revered & honored in most countries leaders - 4 kids - Moom - "Valley Girls"--- Dweezil - Ahmet & Diva - wife Gail... ("SUZY" ...SUZY CREAMCHEESE? UH, THIS IS THE VOICE OF YOUR CONSCIENCE...😂❤😊)...
I count myself very lucky indeed to be born in '48 and bear witness to the greatest music of my life. Let's not forget the great music began in '56 with Presley, Berry, Holly etc. I agree with Keith Richards: before 'Elvis' nothing! I remember the 'yellow rose of Texas'' 'How much is that doggy in the window' and others before Elvis.
Amen...those were very hard times, 1960 - 1975, we were all put to the test. We rose to the challenge. Stood our grounds and held our mud. We were fortunate to have survived. Looking back at those paths that led us here and for all those who did not make it... I, consider it an Honor and a Privilige to have crossed the finish line...
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve watched this vid. It’s got to one of the greatest line ups ever. I grew old with these guys, all heroes and reminds me of how life used to be. Fantastic !! P.S. that’s why Dylan is simply amazing. What a song !
As I approach 75 yrs, listening to these superstars, I do feel younger than that now. I am happy that I experienced this music during my teens and watching and listening to it now makes my heart young again.
If I didn't have to work I would be more than happy to be sitting on a canal boat with my weed, listening to this song 24/7 oh I suppose I better mention the wife 😂😂😂😂😂
Saw him perform twice this month. He opens every show with this song and that 12 string bell-ringin' Ric slung over his shoulder. And this performance was of his arrangement. Great is an understatement.
Wow... this is the most amazing work of musical art.... known to man... what's that guy's name who's directing operations... WOW. ...he made it work... call me..... BRILLIANT xx
Well, it's early morning in Durban South Africa, Saturday 28th December 2024. I'm drinking down this masterpiece, the very best of this Anniversary Gig, comfortably crammed into one glorious moment, which I could have wished would last much longer. But then, isn't that what every great moment deserves. Some of the very best in the biz, playing their hearts out in harmony, no ego, just homage to the master of sublime verse & everyone seamlessly delivering their very best to an audience drinking down every drop of nectar. My mind goes back to 1967, when I bought the Byrds album, Younger than Yesterday & My Back Pages, became another exotic bloom in my overflowing bouquet of Dylan masterpieces & here I sit, almost 60 years later, weeping with joy, listening to this celebration of joy in understanding that 'I was so much older than, I'm younger than that Now'. Why does wisdom come so late in life ? Because it takes so long to understand true wisdom. 😊😂❤🎉
@paulhewitt5198 I wish for you & your loved ones & all who come in Peace, Love & Light, all the joy your hearts can hold, until they overflow in sharing with those in need until this earth, restored & all who live upon it, shines once more.
So, OMG. I think you are my soul mate. But I am old and take no shit, but you are chill and have to be the one to hold me when I die. You will let my soul fly to the unknown and come back to you?
I'm 70 and miss the classic rock. I especially miss CSN, Pink Floyd, Who, Cream, Led Zeppelin and of course Harrison, Petty. RIP you two. ❤❤❤❤ love emmmm all.❤😂😢😅❤❤❤
This caliber of writers and musicians on this stage you will never see again gathered together to bring you a once in a life time event. How nice to have witness this happen in person would surely be a gift from God. God bless them who are still with us,and God bless them who are not. Peace to all of you who love this music.
And recent tours, he performs Hendrix's arrangement of All Along the Watchtower. It's awesome when great, successful song writers don't let their egos get in the way.
@@matthewstearns289 When it covers up poor music, it is horrible. With good music...I remember a girlfriend that danced nearly naked to Jeff Beck's "Because We've Ended as Lovers" still to this day with a rather glazed look on my face. But so much of modern trash music is shown with big boobs and wide bottoms trashing about.
You have no idea what kind of pleasure it is for a newly born Bob Dylan fan, to find his favourite song performed by those giants of rock, simply amazing!
It simply doesn't ever get any better than this. No ego's, fantastic melody and the stage filled with amazing souls. This has got to be one of my absolute favourite versions of an incredible song.
There is no way on earth these guys will ever be replaced by the crap music we are having to put up with these days. Every one of them a total hero to music.
Even today, no matter what anybody say, this is the best and can’t get any better than this. Long live Bob, Neil, Eric and Roger. Did I leave anyone? RIP George and Tom!
I don't know how to find the right words for this. I am 64 and I grew up idolizing the Beatles, The Byrds, Bod Dylan, Clapton, Neil Young...you get the picture. I have lost people I have loved dearly in this life.
Trust me any1 thinking about skipping dont please i beg you the whole 4 mins plus is something ive never experienced i just wish i see this live im only 40 years old but wow
The group of musicians were so so together. It was so nice to see them all together. Unbelievable. Amazing loved each one of them. It was gracious of Bob to let George sing last. Very nice. Love the song and listen to it everyday. He is Iconic.love that guy so . Way to go Bob.Love ya.♥️
Have seen this dozens of times and it never fails to amaze. Among other things, the sheer joy on Neil Young’s face always makes me smile. One of the best music videos and concerts ever.
I have no idea how many times I have watched this video. Once a day some days and several times a day some days. Never ceases to amaze me how good it sounds and ALWAYS makes me feel better each and every time. Can't decide who sounds the best. They all sound perfect every time. They are the best of the best. Could listen to them all day and night. Best thing of all is they are ALL enjoying themselves. Kudos Gentlemen !!❤😊🎉❤😊
Neil Young I mean everyone in this lineup, so freakin awesome. The emotion that Neil sings with is heart wrenching, almost brought tears to a 64 year old man's eyes.
Neil is a special kind of guy who can love ya if you are a true friend there’s nothing he wouldn’t do for ya if you had the same love for him and that’s who Neil is
Neil called the concert "Bobfest." I have the concert on DVD, and Neil's rendition of "All Along the Watchtower," is less a performance than a voodoo ritual trying to resurrect Jimi Hendrix; and comes damn close to it.
WRITTEN BY: BOB DYLAN Crimson flames tied through my ears Rollin’ high and mighty traps Pounced with fire on flaming roads Using ideas as my maps “We’ll meet on edges, soon,” said I Proud ’neath heated brow Ah, but I was so much older then I’m younger than that now Half-wracked prejudice leaped forth “Rip down all hate,” I screamed Lies that life is black and white Spoke from my skull. I dreamed Romantic facts of musketeers Foundationed deep, somehow Ah, but I was so much older then I’m younger than that now Girls’ faces formed the forward path From phony jealousy To memorizing politics Of ancient history Flung down by corpse evangelists Unthought of, though, somehow Ah, but I was so much older then I’m younger than that now A self-ordained professor’s tongue Too serious to fool Spouted out that liberty Is just equality in school “Equality,” I spoke the word As if a wedding vow Ah, but I was so much older then I’m younger than that now In a soldier’s stance, I aimed my hand At the mongrel dogs who teach Fearing not that I’d become my enemy In the instant that I preach My pathway led by confusion boats Mutiny from stern to bow Ah, but I was so much older then I’m younger than that now Yes, my guard stood hard when abstract threats Too noble to neglect Deceived me into thinking I had something to protect Good and bad, I define these terms Quite clear, no doubt, somehow Ah, but I was so much older then I’m younger than that now.
I want played for my Funeral. I get goose bumps and tears of joy listening to this. Time went so fast and here we are. Closer to death than life. Love it
I was reading old book of apocrypha, the Wisdom of Solomon this morning before work. I think Mr Dylan must’ve been in it. Or something like it.. It basically has the refrain - as you get older, you’re really actually getting younger. Whacked ! Peace n love :)
I am very please to be a part of that movement and to have hung out and performed with many of them. I'm going to be 73 on June 22nd. I am now so much older, I'm younger than that now.
Absolutely! Jim Keltner is the Traveling WIlburys' drummer and many, many others. One of the most under-appreciated superb musicians ever, probably because Keltner just hangs in the background providing great rhythm support.
Jim is considered to be the unofficial 6th Traveling Wilbury. He has performed on a number of records with many famous artists and bands as a session drummer, since the early 1970s. and has toured with Pink Floyd and others. He has recorded with even more. He is the guy that influenced Jeff Porcaro as a young man, which in turn made him famous for his drumming. The man is a drumming legend and still going strong at 79.
One can see in this vid the embodiment of George's classic saying: "I never wanted to be famous, I wanted to be successful". RIP Tom and George, grateful I had the chance to see Tom live in 1987.
Truly “my generation “ George was so underrated and we are smaller without him John, Jack Bruce, Ginger Baker Tom and all the wonderful wonderful musicians 😢😢😢😢 this video should be shown to all these terrible contrived so called talent shows
Yea me too Claptons was technically better but Neil's fit the song better to me. And the award for best vocal performance goes to ----------------- Neil Young
Harrison later said he and Eric looked at each other and said what the fuck is that? And not in nice way. George said he hated that one string solo shit Neil did... interesting how we all hear things differently
One of Dylan's best songs...what a cast of performers to be on stage doing it together! Great to see George Harrison singing the last verse,,,so sad that he is no longer with us.
@@cherylcampbell9369 I don't know. I only remember the main names like George Harrison, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Roger Mcguinn, Eric Clapton. I remember watching it all those years ago but I'm sorry i can't help you with the bassists and drummers.
There's wisdom in that for all of us. And if in that time he could earn a fair Euro, he may one day be better off. The latter secondary though, as governments and central banks are about to destroy money. Enjoy life
I cannot stop watching this video. These guys are my generation, and some of the greatest rock musicians who ever lived. Besides, does Dylan look totally unflappable or what?
In my humble opinion, Dylan is probably the best poet / songwriter of the modern era. There are better singers, yes, but he writes such great stories and they are just poetic.
To me, nothing says 1960s more than this song and this performance by this group of performers. It will always be at the top of my list. What a wonderful decade to have lived through.
I was 51 in 1992 when this video was made. I couldn’t have appreciated its greatness then. I can today. Because I was so much older then I’m younger than that now.
Eric Clapton's solo is so laid back so elegant, so masterful. In this wonderful song and amazing cast of musicians it is this piece of brilliance that brings me back again and again.
Eric’s guitar playing and singing stick out like a sore thumb…it’s a California folk song . This song is so beautiful and everyone captures the spirit of Bob’s composition (in the Byrds song structure) except for Eric….
bruh ahahahah. Neil Young is one of the probably top 10 guitarist of all time. If you think that solo is easy just try, I do play guitar and I can assure you the "easy" one is the Clapton one with some practice. @@goftheday489
I’m 71 and I love everyone of these artists for their work they have given us so many amazingsongs like this one will they will never be forgotten or repeated RIP Mr petty, Mr. Harrison you other artist rock on boys 🎶🎶🎼🎼🎼🎵🎵🙏🙏
A Byrd, a Beatle, a Buffalo, a Heartbreaker, a Yardbird, and a Tambourine man. Now that’s what I call a line up.
This makes me cry, isn't that the truth!
Who the guy in the green suit?
@@celiahans-pu3sh That's G.E. Smith. He played in the SNL band for a long time (80s, 90s) and was one of the guitarists Hall and Oates used when they were big. He's quite the player,, but takes a backseat in this one to enjoy the show.
@@indiecomicsjones Knew G.E. back in his Scratch Band days in New England, went on to SNL (short time married to Gilda), toured with Dylan and got to see him again touring a tour that came through Santa Barbara...miss those "Glory Days" of my youth.
@@celiahans-pu3sh Read that he was the musical director for this. You also have Booker T and the MG's and Jim Keltner. The sum of all the parts on this one is incredible.
I watch this and it makes me want to cry. No more George or Tom, and hearing this song almost 60 years after it was released -- the memories, the losses, we've all gotten so old. Bob's lyrics -- brilliant as always.
God bless Neil, Bob and Eric ❤
❤ ❤ I'm 69 and crying. Brilliant
Хочется плакать и радоваться ,что они были среди нас ,очень жаль так рано ушли,Дилону здоровья
AMAZING!!
indeed !! i feel the same
A constellation of muscians never to be repeated.
Ubiera sido lindo que esté JOHN LENON Y ORBISON
Nonsense, it's just that young aspiring artists today, for the time I've been alive (47 years now) focus on IMAGE and not on WRITING.
Goofy, dorky guys of all varieties, with their thick glasses and receding hairlines, used to WRITE music. That's why certain classics are just so ultimately classic. It's because PEOPLE wrote music instead of IMAGES writing music.
For my 47 years, you're not "allowed" to write music without a certain image and here in Canada those image requirements are violently enforced by the fucking police.
If Bob Dylan were Canadian and born in my time he would work in a machine shop for a few years and commit suicide.
If Elvis were born in Canada he would be the Prime Minister or commit suicide.
If Kurt Cobain were Canadian he would be a police officer and then commit suicide.
The legendary genius Mark Knopfler?! If he were born in my time in Canada the police would have tortured him and he would have killed himself after owning a car. That would have been his ENTIRE LIFE. He would have had a CAR.
@@devilsoffspring5519 nonsense
@@devilsoffspring5519 You sound like you're fun at parties. Way to ruin the positive vibes of this amazing performance with an absolute trash comment. Crawl back into your hole.
I miss Harrison and Petty!
I’m 74 years now and bye grace for the love of music
just keep going.
Thank you for the post, Thank you Dylan for the amazing music treasure ❤☮️✌️
We had the best time... Now we get older and older... I feel young, when I hear songs like this! (71 years old )😉
I miss them so much, and what gets me the most is slow hands solo. I tear up every time
Absolutely....😢
I'm 41 and this song gives me goosebumps woooow amazing artists EVERY1 of the them
@@deanhawkins8629 yes!!!!
This performance is a masterpiece. I turn 70 in November and grew up with the best music ever. McGuinn, Harrison and Petty are the reasons I bought a Rickenbacker electric 12-string some years ago. My favorite instrument. My favorite musicians. This is REAL music that has meaning.
Right there with you. So lucky to have lived during this time. Concert tkts were $5 to see the best music ever. Great clip.
@@selewachm In 1973 while a student at Syracuse University I saw The Beach Boys for one buck. Couldn’t believe then, can’t believe it today.
I too will be 70 in November and listening to this incredible piece and wonder why it doesn't go on forever.
Turned 79 last month and listening to this masterpiece
I’m right there with ya. I’m 68. We’re losing all the great ones who were the sound tracks of our youth. Hopefully when our generation is gone, the music will live on.
I’m 71 now and I’m so glad and grateful that this music and these musicians was an integral part of my youth!
Só am I!!!
you took the words right out of my mouth Ron, for i too am a Ron, i am 61 and i thank God for all these gr8 artists who shared their gift with us, we are so fortunate to have grown up in such times.
Same here, and I’m 66. Esp Bob Dylan & Neil Young ❤️
beautifully put....me too
We grew up in the best of all times, bro.
All of us 70 plus year old who grew up listening to these guys separately together beautiful music God’s plan together beautiful music
Yup-i agree.
Totally agree ✌️❤️🌼
Hell yes
Yes sireee
Oh yes, those were/are the days!!
Roger mcguine what can you say a true legend
and overshadowed by everyone one stage
@@ucctggdon’t think so.
I know that every generation thinks that their music is better than the present, but just really, when was it ever better than this? All those legends on one stage playing one of the best songs ever written. I saw this comment here once: "It's worth being old now to have been young then."
Из другой страны и мне 56 ,но мы любим всех ДЖ ХАРИССОНА,ТОМА ПИТТА🙏❤❤❤Бобу Дилону здоровья ❤❤❤❤
I don't. I'm the next generation, while Ok except for disco. This ear is the best.
The older "kids" (as I refer in my mind) like born before the Baby BOOMers - like roughly 1949 down to about early 1920''s were best & most amazing - inspired by favorites ❤ed my parents & grandparents even- more than just top thousands of them - thar my mom in particular loved and all music like Beatles, Led Zeppelin - but she had countless LP's she sang - & not just Sing Along w Miitch (Miller) - Dule Ellington - Glenn Miller - Tommy - Jimmy Dorset - Ellla Fitzgerald - Rosemary Clooney - The Andrew Sisters - Dave Brubeck- Benny Goodman - Billie Holiday - Louie Prima - ETC -- Frank Zappa, 😮also seldom brought up - RE-MARK-ABLE - Born 1940 - Died in the 90's - 'bout age 51 - was an Italian/Greek American born in the USA - Baltimore, Maryland - Zappa was actually his family name - was a Master- with all respect to Classic- Enhanced it - with /for orchestral - etc guitar - etc -fusion of all kinds - even junk sound - in every aspect - Zappa morals / unimpressed with drama- distractions - drugs etc - self taught - self disciplined genius-with uncanny unwavering rare simplitic honesty to lying elite who are unskilled,, boring hypocrites - a few fools - even now deny free thought, art, speech, etc (edit it??) was revered & honored in most countries leaders - 4 kids - Moom - "Valley Girls"--- Dweezil - Ahmet & Diva - wife Gail... ("SUZY" ...SUZY CREAMCHEESE? UH, THIS IS THE VOICE OF YOUR CONSCIENCE...😂❤😊)...
It was never better than this
"Don't be sad that has ended, be happy that happened"
Thank You God for letting me grow up when I did, such talent that just isn't around anymore...
So sorry for the infringe on your privacy. Beautiful song How are you?
I count myself very lucky indeed to be born in '48 and bear witness to the greatest music of my life. Let's not forget the great music began in '56 with Presley, Berry, Holly etc. I agree with Keith Richards: before 'Elvis' nothing! I remember the 'yellow rose of Texas'' 'How much is that doggy in the window' and others before Elvis.
Amen...those were very hard times, 1960 - 1975, we were all put to the test.
We rose to the challenge. Stood our grounds and held our mud. We were fortunate to have survived.
Looking back at those paths that led us here and for all those who did not make it...
I, consider it an Honor and a Privilige to have crossed the finish line...
They’re like buddies we went through war with.
INDEED!!!!+
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve watched this vid. It’s got to one of the greatest line ups ever. I grew old with these guys, all heroes and reminds me of how life used to be. Fantastic !! P.S. that’s why Dylan is simply amazing. What a song !
Yup
Me too
The same experience here!
That's it in a nutshell...cudn't have said it better. I too have watched it countless times. Bob doesn't try to take the Limelight, he's so humble!
Inspiring message … nice
I'm a musician and this is so good! Bob
We'll never again see so much amazing talent on one stage playing together on such an iconic song.
1:40 great group of musicians the BEST.❤love Mr Dylan
Neil Young and Eric Clapton wailing on their guitars. Not much better
❤
Your so right.
@@annlaplante4425 Neal Young es el de cuadros verdad?
As I approach 75 yrs, listening to these superstars, I do feel younger than that now. I am happy that I experienced this music during my teens and watching and listening to it now makes my heart young again.
Join the clan it doesn't get much better than the real music years of the '60s & '70s
I'm with you Brother, I just turned 75 and still love this music! We got to experience the best music ever in our lifetime!
Couldn't agree more
like me 74 on thanksgiving day 😏😏😏
Testify Bro testify.
If I didn't have to work I would be more than happy to be sitting on a canal boat with my weed, listening to this song 24/7 oh I suppose I better mention the wife 😂😂😂😂😂
I'd forgotten how great McGuinn was.
Saw him perform twice this month. He opens every show with this song and that 12 string bell-ringin' Ric slung over his shoulder. And this performance was of his arrangement. Great is an understatement.
This makes me cry from nostalgia. They are from my generation... and still some of the greatest music of all time. What a lineup!
Mine too x
Wow... this is the most amazing work of musical art.... known to man... what's that guy's name who's directing operations... WOW. ...he made it work... call me..... BRILLIANT xx
Yep..... I agree blondy.., Brilliant...xx
Perfect Christine 😀
E.G. Smith directing.
Every time I watch this, I am younger than that now. I was there in '92. Best guitarists ever.
There in 1992? LUCKY YOU!
Absolutely the best of all time!
I was there in 1964 when this song was released on the album "Another Side of Bob Dylan". Where were you?
I love how George Harrison just stands off to the side and comes in at the end.....just like him
This is the best ever and Dylan looks so proud to have these legends around him singing his song.
@@evelyngallagher5893 Jim Keltner on the drums????
Hello Evelyn Gallagher and I almost pocket called you
apparently George hated what Neil Young was doing on this one, lol.
@@opartyep. His guitar playing on this song.
I wouldn't give up my memories for all the tea in San Francisco 💜
Well, it's early morning in Durban South Africa, Saturday 28th December 2024. I'm drinking down this masterpiece, the very best of this Anniversary Gig, comfortably crammed into one glorious moment, which I could have wished would last much longer. But then, isn't that what every great moment deserves. Some of the very best in the biz, playing their hearts out in harmony, no ego, just homage to the master of sublime verse & everyone seamlessly delivering their very best to an audience drinking down every drop of nectar. My mind goes back to 1967, when I bought the Byrds album, Younger than Yesterday & My Back Pages, became another exotic bloom in my overflowing bouquet of Dylan masterpieces & here I sit, almost 60 years later, weeping with joy, listening to this celebration of joy in understanding that 'I was so much older than, I'm younger than that Now'. Why does wisdom come so late in life ? Because it takes so long to understand true wisdom. 😊😂❤🎉
Awesome!!! What a gathering!! Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year from Norwich UK.
@paulhewitt5198 I wish for you & your loved ones & all who come in Peace, Love & Light, all the joy your hearts can hold, until they overflow in sharing with those in need until this earth, restored & all who live upon it, shines once more.
❤ Great music is forever !❤️
So, OMG. I think you are my soul mate. But I am old and take no shit, but you are chill and have to be the one to hold me when I die. You will let my soul fly to the unknown and come back to you?
I'm 70 and miss the classic rock. I especially miss CSN, Pink Floyd, Who, Cream, Led Zeppelin and of course Harrison, Petty. RIP you two. ❤❤❤❤ love emmmm all.❤😂😢😅❤❤❤
George is so quietly amazing he doesn’t try to upstage anyone he just stands back then takes his turn singing with the presence of a god
Presence of
GOD
Yes a god
George Harrison is sorely missed. Hope there's a Heaven.
He was truly wonderful.
Born in 1947, my Heritage! Eve of Destruction, my Senior Trip! Vietnam Veteran! This brings tears to my eyes!
In hundred years this performance will still be around and listened to. My god. It's so beautiful and so brilliant.
I believe that 🎼🎶
❣👍👏🔺️💙🤝❗
Love from Hamburg, Germany!
Cheers to that
To me Bob Dylan will always be the Greatest Poet Ever.
I thank the good Lord for this beautiful tune ☺😇
Does this song bring tears to anyone else's eyes?
Contrary to tradition, I have grown more liberal as I have aged! I think that is what this song means to me.
Yes
No
These guys will forever be brothers. In this world and in heaven where they will be greeted by many more
This caliber of writers and musicians on this stage you will never see again gathered together to bring you a once in a life time event. How nice to have witness this happen in person would surely be a gift from God. God bless them who are still with us,and God bless them who are not. Peace to all of you who love this music.
Who is the guy in the green suit?
Thank you. I know I am a better man for having listened to Dylan's music.
I could not agree more.
Unbelievable to witness this.
Thanouren you Kevin. May peace follow you.
The guy in the green suit is G.E. Smith. He was the leader of the Saturday Night Live band a few years back
Lest we overlook it, but this is McGuinn's brilliant arrangement of this great Dylan song. He totally transformed it.
The Byrds certainly gave new life to Dylan songs, I love their jangly sound !
Absolutely! xo
And recent tours, he performs Hendrix's arrangement of All Along the Watchtower. It's awesome when great, successful song writers don't let their egos get in the way.
Hes always done that.
I think, for myself, that McGuinn made it better than Dylan himself.
No nearly naked dancers, no auto tune, just writing, playing and teamwork
What's wrong with naked dancer's.😆
@@matthewstearns289 When it covers up poor music, it is horrible.
With good music...I remember a girlfriend that danced nearly naked to Jeff Beck's "Because We've Ended as Lovers" still to this day with a rather glazed look on my face.
But so much of modern trash music is shown with big boobs and wide bottoms trashing about.
You have no idea what kind of pleasure it is for a newly born Bob Dylan fan, to find his favourite song performed by those giants of rock, simply amazing!
Life was so much better when George was alive.
😍😍
I miss George and Tom and I'm sure Roy and John would've there somehow. And where was Joni and Gordon?
And Tom too
Amen.
Very true Phil
Those from WWII are from the “greatest generation”….but these guys are from the greatest generation of rockers. Never to be seen again.
I also love music from the war years. Old war tunes, Motown, and rock are the best. Musicians today have almost no talent.
It simply doesn't ever get any better than this. No ego's, fantastic melody and the stage filled with amazing souls. This has got to be one of my absolute favourite versions of an incredible song.
Oy! You are my twin!!!!
You're exactly right, it will never get better than this!
Bang on wonderful stuff. Superb Dylan song one of his best.
Absolutely love this
Yes, I didn't think much of this when I started it years ago and it blew me away instantly - best ever version.
Tom Petty and Neil Young sharing a microphone. Warms my heart so much.
✨🎸♥️🎸✨
Ol'Black and the distortion pedal should go to the Smithsonian Institute once Mr. Young passes.
Me too : )
Just incredible Petty and Young sharing mic
The gods of the late 1960's and 1970's it don't get any better than this folks for us who lived through it ❤👍👍👏👏👏
The smile on Neils face
after his solo ,is pure joy!!!!!!!!
Doesn't get better. Dylan's early songs never fade in their glory and depth.
His early songs fit the times of that era. His later songs are brilliant too, but there are no talented people to cover them.
He made music that others could cover, too. How about this one! th-cam.com/video/EsIaVWXNLVo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=kPlwGLV9oWwdFrsS
We are so blessed to be living in Bob’s time. There are many great legends but none surpass Bob
There is no way on earth these guys will ever be replaced by the crap music we are having to put up with these days. Every one of them a total hero to music.
Very well spoken!☮️
Agreed!
Even today, no matter what anybody say, this is the best and can’t get any better than this. Long live Bob, Neil, Eric and Roger. Did I leave anyone? RIP George and Tom!
George and Tom may not be here physically, but through their music they will live forever, as will the other greats from the years of our youth.
@@NVRick1 answering your comment now in November 2022...totally agree, how lucky to have grown old with the music from the sixties and on
I don't know how to find the right words for this. I am 64 and I grew up idolizing the Beatles, The Byrds, Bod Dylan, Clapton, Neil Young...you get the picture. I have lost people I have loved dearly in this life.
Don’t forget Duane, brother.
I lost them before I was born.....I'm 17 now.....feel like I'm in the wrong generation.
Sorry for your loss.
Nice comment. Thanks
Trust me any1 thinking about skipping dont please i beg you the whole 4 mins plus is something ive never experienced i just wish i see this live im only 40 years old but wow
That smile on Neil Young’s face after that crazy solo says it all!
Yes he was an exuberantly happy man that day which is not how we think of him!
Yeah, he delivered and he knew it. It wouldn't surprise me if he was nervous the whole time.
@@evelynbaron2004 Yes he was! Check out his song "Comes a Time" farm aid 1986. He's the happiest I've ever seen him there!😊
He's joyous on that stage! Because of that, he stole the show for me!
Comes a time, i have that album on vinyl@@jaya.0069
I’ve watched this a hundred times and every time I get goose bumps. So much talent on one stage, amazing.
Beautiful music 🎶
I do too
I feel the same way!
Yes!! Me too❤
i feel sorry for the young of today never having heard fantastic music from an incredible lineup like this !
they here it but didnt grow up with it
ive used my daughters car and there is classic rock stations like Q1`07 on her Tuner
Huh? This generation can hear it anytime on demand right here.
@@VideoAmericanStylejust not the same as live and at the time of the release I guess
The group of musicians were so so together. It was so nice to see them all together. Unbelievable. Amazing loved each one of them. It was gracious of Bob to let George sing last. Very nice. Love the song and listen to it everyday. He is Iconic.love that guy so . Way to go Bob.Love ya.♥️
Have seen this dozens of times and it never fails to amaze. Among other things, the sheer joy on Neil Young’s face always makes me smile. One of the best music videos and concerts ever.
a felicidade dele é nítida. imagina a festa, que é para esses caras de alto nível, tocarem com seus iguais.
😅
I have no idea how many times I have watched this video. Once a day some days and several times a day some days. Never ceases to amaze me how good it sounds and ALWAYS makes me feel better each and every time. Can't decide who sounds the best. They all sound perfect every time. They are the best of the best. Could listen to them all day and night. Best thing of all is they are ALL enjoying themselves. Kudos Gentlemen !!❤😊🎉❤😊
Thank you guys for the greatest music of our time and awesome very talented musicians of our time. RIP
Neil Young I mean everyone in this lineup, so freakin awesome. The emotion that Neil sings with is heart wrenching, almost brought tears to a 64 year old man's eyes.
your younger then that now!
Neil is a special kind of guy who can love ya if you are a true friend there’s nothing he wouldn’t do for ya if you had the same love for him and that’s who Neil is
He sure is a special guy and, a brilliant guitarist.
I agree! Mr Youngs joy and presence is fantastic!
Neil called the concert "Bobfest." I have the concert on DVD, and Neil's rendition of "All Along the Watchtower," is less a performance than a voodoo ritual trying to resurrect Jimi Hendrix; and comes damn close to it.
The greatest of the great
Missing Jeff Lynne.
I’m 13 and my favorite musicians are up on THIS STAGE. 💜💜💜George and Tom and Bob💜💜💜
And Neil!!!!! 🙏
Your a lucky young man. Your parents have done you well.
Icons 🙏
Don't forget Roger!
you have great taste in music for such a young person! do you sing or play an instrument?
WRITTEN BY: BOB DYLAN
Crimson flames tied through my ears
Rollin’ high and mighty traps
Pounced with fire on flaming roads
Using ideas as my maps
“We’ll meet on edges, soon,” said I
Proud ’neath heated brow
Ah, but I was so much older then
I’m younger than that now
Half-wracked prejudice leaped forth
“Rip down all hate,” I screamed
Lies that life is black and white
Spoke from my skull. I dreamed
Romantic facts of musketeers
Foundationed deep, somehow
Ah, but I was so much older then
I’m younger than that now
Girls’ faces formed the forward path
From phony jealousy
To memorizing politics
Of ancient history
Flung down by corpse evangelists
Unthought of, though, somehow
Ah, but I was so much older then
I’m younger than that now
A self-ordained professor’s tongue
Too serious to fool
Spouted out that liberty
Is just equality in school
“Equality,” I spoke the word
As if a wedding vow
Ah, but I was so much older then
I’m younger than that now
In a soldier’s stance, I aimed my hand
At the mongrel dogs who teach
Fearing not that I’d become my enemy
In the instant that I preach
My pathway led by confusion boats
Mutiny from stern to bow
Ah, but I was so much older then
I’m younger than that now
Yes, my guard stood hard when abstract threats
Too noble to neglect
Deceived me into thinking
I had something to protect
Good and bad, I define these terms
Quite clear, no doubt, somehow
Ah, but I was so much older then
I’m younger than that now.
Neil is that Crazy Uncle that shows up at every gathering ... Bless him.
Harrison hated it.
A
I like his solo!
I like it too...make your own mind
I want played for my Funeral. I get goose bumps and tears of joy listening to this. Time went so fast and here we are. Closer to death than life. Love it
Good one to go out on....
Closer to the real life, brothers and sisters.
❤Love this version.. ♬❤ Beautifully performed.. ♬ the best lineup ever.. ♬ ❤👍
We all getting old.
But this song presented by the greatest on earth and heaven made me feel young again!
🙏♥️👊
You're younger than that now, Tom ;-)
I was reading old book of apocrypha, the Wisdom of Solomon this morning before work. I think Mr Dylan must’ve been in it. Or something like it.. It basically has the refrain - as you get older, you’re really actually getting younger. Whacked ! Peace n love :)
I'm 66 and that song is part of my soul.
Ton Kanselaar WHOHOOO!! Damn Skippy! Rock will never die...we will...but our music will live on!!! ❤️☮️❤️. Peace Out! 🤘🏻👍🏻
Tom and George, RIP in rock heaven.
rock is better there than on earth now
Si meries
If there is a rock and roll heaven they for sure got one hell of a band
@@typritchard8280 aqwqqqp0
And Duck Dunn.
Seriously im 41 years old and hand on heart i have never heard a tune like woooooow gives me goosebumps
I am very please to be a part of that movement and to have hung out and performed with many of them. I'm going to be 73 on June 22nd. I am now so much older, I'm younger than that now.
Jim Keltner has played with all the greats, yet he is rarely mentioned or given the credit he deserves.
Absolutely! Jim Keltner is the Traveling WIlburys' drummer and many, many others. One of the most under-appreciated superb musicians ever, probably because Keltner just hangs in the background providing great rhythm support.
He just makes do with the money.
Respect to Jim Keltner , first saw him with Ry Cooder, who keeps the band together 🥁👍
Jim is considered to be the unofficial 6th Traveling Wilbury. He has performed on a number of records with many famous artists and bands as a session drummer, since the early 1970s. and has toured with Pink Floyd and others. He has recorded with even more. He is the guy that influenced Jeff Porcaro as a young man, which in turn made him famous for his drumming. The man is a drumming legend and still going strong at 79.
A traveling willburry also
One can see in this vid the embodiment of George's classic saying: "I never wanted to be famous, I wanted to be successful". RIP Tom and George, grateful I had the chance to see Tom live in 1987.
I agree with you 💯the best of the best. Still Miss George and Tom but glad to have seen Bob and Tom back in the days when life was so much better ☮️
My generation. The magnitude of talent will never be seen again. I was lucky to be young during that time.
this is priceless ,legends of rock Clapton a Beatle GH Dylan Neil Young Tom Petty you wont see this ever again
Truly “my generation “ George was so underrated and we are smaller without him John, Jack Bruce, Ginger Baker Tom and all the wonderful wonderful musicians 😢😢😢😢 this video should be shown to all these terrible contrived so called talent shows
That last guitar solo by Neil Young blows me away every time.
Yea me too Claptons was technically better but Neil's fit the song better to me. And the award for best vocal performance goes to ----------------- Neil Young
Harrison later said he and Eric looked at each other and said what the fuck is that? And not in nice way. George said he hated that one string solo shit Neil did... interesting how we all hear things differently
FastgunEd Clapton is god.
Yeah both Clapton & Young's sounds are so distinctive you could close your eyes and know exactly who's playing.
Neal such a rebel. The expert of the one note guitar solo. He is a God. You can see where Rick Nielsen gets his antics.
I'm old now but I thank the universe that I lived through these great years.
One of Dylan's best songs...what a cast of performers to be on stage doing it together! Great to see George Harrison singing the last verse,,,so sad that he is no longer with us.
TP gone too soon also. :-(
Tom petty also has moved on
agreed!! possibly THE best to me..!
I don't know I came upon this but I'm sure glad I did! Wow! Just Wow!!
Basically, George sang the final verse because he was the only person in the room bigger than Dylan.
All that talent on that stage, and backstage, come out for the bard of music,so good to see George Harrison and Tom Petty,both sadly missed. 🇬🇧🇺🇸✌️
And some of us also miss the bassist, Donald "Duck" Dunn.
The
😭😭😭
Who are the other musicians? Drummer, bassist...
I recognize G.E. Smith from (? snl?). but who are the others?
@@cherylcampbell9369 I don't know. I only remember the main names like George Harrison, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Roger Mcguinn, Eric Clapton. I remember watching it all those years ago but I'm sorry i can't help you with the bassists and drummers.
My favourite Dylan tune so fantastic great artist goose bumps every time I listen to this rendition magnificent!,,
Can’t stop listening to this wonderful embodiment of what REAL music sounds like…WTF WOULD WE HAVE DONE WITHOUT BOB DYLAN IN OUR LIVES…
You will never see this kind of Talent together again. Many have left us and they just don't make much good music anymore.
To me this is the BEST song video on the internet. ALL TIME BEST.
I was so much older before hearing this song, but I'm younger than that now!
A man is a success if he gets up in the morning and gets to bed at night, and in between he does what he wants to do.
- Bob Dylan
Eric sneaked out
Ok, Dylan. Thanks for let me playing video games all day and not feeling guilty about it. lol
There's wisdom in that for all of us. And if in that time he could earn a fair Euro, he may one day be better off. The latter secondary though, as governments and central banks are about to destroy money. Enjoy life
I'm in this video. Seat A17, dead centre, leaning on the rail, in absolute bliss. And Bob fixed on me throughout.. all true, ask people around me..
I cannot stop watching this video. These guys are my generation, and some of the greatest rock musicians who ever lived. Besides, does Dylan look totally unflappable or what?
Dylan's the ultimate "I"m my own man" man. He will never "meet expectations" of anyone. Remember the folkies?
These guys are the generation prior to mine, but they are still the greatest rockers ever.
These guys changed music FOREVER.
I think Dylan remains an enigma. What's he got a Donald Duck Voibe to this his superb creation My Back pages. Keil and Tom are having fun.
In my humble opinion, Dylan is probably the best poet / songwriter of the modern era.
There are better singers, yes, but he writes such great stories and they are just poetic.
Unfortunately we'll never see the amazing likes of these amazing musicians again
Eric what man whatca voice btw they are all absolutely amazing i get goosebumps
George Harrison by himself all the way through that guy is the quietest legend ever
The quiet Beatle...
He was so awesome
And he's a BEATLE.
@@kiloechocharlie1342 a@@@a@@aa
@@kiloechocharlie1342 But made a BIG noise with them and without them.
To me, nothing says 1960s more than this song and this performance by this group of performers. It will always be at the top of my list. What a wonderful decade to have lived through.
The best decade in music ever🎤🎹🎺🎻👌♥️
Absolutely 😃
My favourite decade, the 60’s, and I spent it in London
With ya! Incredible music decade!
Ji
What a moment. Heavy sigh.
What a line-up. The heavens smiled on this group of greats.
As a kid of the 60's I grew up listening to their music. It seemed like every week a new song was coming out. 60's and 70's... what a great time.
Soundtrack of my youth. How fortunate I was to be born when I was. 72 and still listening and enjoying the best music and memories ✨
Claptons solo is absolutely sublime!
Clapton's is great but Neil's opens the song up
George's voice soars! 🤗
Agree, but I think they all sang brilliantly. I just love this song and the line up was just breathtaking
How wonderful was this joy in 2024, to totally admire with soooooo many joyous memories of our generations very best ! 🎉❤😊😊😊😊
seen this a dozen times and I'm weeping still :-( George and Tom RIP
To see George do his 'Hard Days Night' foot shuffle, even ever so slightly, right after 3:50 made me bawl my eyes out. Life is so fleeting...
Thanks for pointing that out. So cool
Hard no to want to cry when you see Georgie in any of these live shows from the past. I miss him and Tom so much.
It's fleeting at 5 hours long but I have a Harrison & friends related surprise here. th-cam.com/video/vXIap366w3g/w-d-xo.html Still in progress.
I was thinking the same thing
I saw that too, so cool.
I was 51 in 1992 when this video was made. I couldn’t have appreciated its greatness then. I can today. Because I was so much older then I’m younger than that now.
If only one song was chosen to represent and define the past century, this would suffice. The greatest artists to ever grace a stage!
Missing the boss
Eric Clapton's solo is so laid back so elegant, so masterful. In this wonderful song and amazing cast of musicians it is this piece of brilliance that brings me back again and again.
Meh - give me Neil’s solo any day.
Eric’s guitar playing and singing stick out like a sore thumb…it’s a California folk song . This song is so beautiful and everyone captures the spirit of Bob’s composition (in the Byrds song structure) except for Eric….
Agreed also my favorite
This is the Shawshank or Good Fellas of music. Anytime I see it, I stay and watch.
Miss so many of them....miss my husband...we grew up to these song...best time of our lives...life goes fast so go enjoy!!
Neil's solo is pure magic !
How is that a pure magic? It is only a one string solo and sounds awful af.
@Coogan I know. That's what I meant to say.
you accidentally defined in the most perfect way the sheer beauty of that solo.
bruh ahahahah.
Neil Young is one of the probably top 10 guitarist of all time.
If you think that solo is easy just try, I do play guitar and I can assure you the "easy" one is the Clapton one with some practice. @@goftheday489
I love them all. Greatly
*greatly* such a kind word
Love Roger McGuinn's distinctive voice
I’m 71 and I love everyone of these artists for their work they have given us so many amazingsongs like this one will they will never be forgotten or repeated RIP Mr petty, Mr. Harrison you other artist rock on boys 🎶🎶🎼🎼🎼🎵🎵🙏🙏
Great music, I'm 68 and love this line-up...I agree with @carsonshane4102!!!!
This is real music, this is real art. A simply exceptional performance.
Here gathered are some of the greatest song writers and musicians ever......