‘I fought the Portuguese by starting a radio station’ | I remember how Goa was freed |BBC News India
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 มิ.ย. 2024
- Goa, a popular tourist spot on India's western coast, was freed from Portuguese rule on 19 December 1961, more than four centuries after it was colonised. The fight for Goa's freedom began in the 1940s and picked momentum after India got its independence in 1947.
Ms Libia Lobo Sardesai and Vaman Sardesai (who she later married) were two of the many freedom fighters who were a key part of this movement. Mr Uday Bhembhre's father, Laxmikant Bhembhre, was arrested and deported to Portugal after he offered 'satyagraha'.
In this short documentary, Ms Sardesai and Mr Bhembhre talk about their memories of those years.
Produced and edited by Nikita Mandhani
Filmed by Bimal Thankachan
#goa #goafreedom #portuguesecolony #freedomfightersgoa #goaindependence #goaindia
Click here to subscribe to our channel 👉🏽 bbc.in/3whmDp3
-----------------------------------
This is the official BBC News India channel. If you want to understand and follow the India story, we hope this will be your home. Here, you’ll find stories that move your heart and explainers, interviews and documentaries on issues that you care about.
Don’t expect a 24/7 stream of news, we are not that channel. But you can look forward to top-quality BBC journalism that will help you make sense of what’s happening around you.
Do comment on our videos and posts because we will be reading them and taking them on board, and if you like what we do, you can also find us here
BBC Website 👉🏽bbc.in/3XjgjcP
Instagram 👉🏽 bbc.in/3GNTSVW
Facebook 👉🏽 bbc.in/3XgMc5M
Twitter 👉🏽 bbc.in/3XlbAXZ
Thanks for following us!
#BBCNewsIndia #India
![[Live] : ONE 167 วันนี้!! "ตะวันฉาย vs โจ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D9_dvfIa6Ao/mqdefault.jpg)
As a goan, the worst thing that could have happened to my beautiful state, the Indian government marching in marked the death of Goa, the Portuguese knew what it was to run a country now it’s a state run by a headless chicken
Only when we know how we got freedom can we all understand its true value. Millions of indians have given there life and blood to secure us this freedom which we today enjoy. Lets take a pledge to never forget those bravehearts who fought so we could live a life of dignity and freedom. Never again will we be so weak to be colonised and trampled by upon by foreign invaders coming through land or sea. India will be free until the existence of humanity, never again will we be a colony. Jai hind, jai bharat.
Don't exaggerate
India isn't 'free', it's burdened by backwards religiosity and superstition! Oh, and the caste system.
@charananekibalijaun8837 thats is the truth, not exaggeration
@@navneetyadav5275 so please elaborate, how millions of indians died for their freedom
@@charananekibalijaun8837 around 4 million soldiers served in WW1 and WW2, both times because the British promised to free India after the war if they helped Britain. Apart from that? The 1942-43 Bengal famine saw 4+ million deaths (yes, most of those people were normal people and not freedom fighters, but had India been independent, the chances of those many deaths were slim), the bloodshed during partition, thousands of freedom fighters in the INA and independent groups that were killed by British, etc, it really could be over 1 million.
AMAZING! As a British Indian, I rely on TH-cam for my history lessons. They never teach the real history in the classroom. Jai Ho! I never knew the Portuguese only left in 1961. I am proud of you Indian warriors!
Thanks for watching and commenting :) Please subscribe to our channel and share this video with friends and family.
Hello sir
As a Goan I don't care. Portuguese were much better.
Coz they filled your coffers with the loot money simply because you converted to their faith. European colonizers have exploited India much much more than they gave it back. So plz..slurrp your sorpotel and stop crying coz Dadda ain't coming back for you.@@linzcoutinho6541
Yes, but please do not rely on BBC for lessons on Indian history. 😂🙏🏻
BBC = christian supremacists.
As goan the process of Portuguese occupation is presented with either black and white...
Where as in reality history lies somewhere in between..
Portuguese were most brutal during there intial years with there religiousity..
Most torturous of them was inquisition ...
But later part of 19 th century they were as able administrators in goa as rest of india
Many people fail to give credit where its due ..
They left goa with far more able administration then British did.
Common civil code , keeping of land records are finest examples
Plus the Portuguese gave citizenship to all Goans. No other colony got that honour.
Goa was not considered a colony but rather an overseas ("Ultramarino") province of Portugal, officially designated Estado Português da Índia i.e. Portugal's Indian state. Consequently, Goans had, and still have, by descent, a full right to citizenship@@user-vg6wt3un9r
👍
Salute to the Freedom Fighters and Activists ❤
Wow .. just wow... her enthusiasm still stands loud and clear... 😊
Or is it just a matter of changing sides post facto to gain acceptance in the new reality? An obvious catholic/Christian lady, possibly influenced all her life by the Portuguese, saying she sided with the Indian authorities and army. I will call that out. It sounds a lot like Muslims of India who claim that they rejected the idea of Pakistan and chose not to go there.
The voice of freedom. So necessary .
Thanks for watching, Leila.
The Portuguese massacred tens of thousands of Hindus and tortured Hindus who refused to convert to Christianity. Barbarians
Moguls finished 8cr of our people and took our mahilas like rundi during their 600yrs rule in India
So very well narrated in a short film. The build up to the excitement of liberation as a Goan it gave me the chills. Kudos to Mr. Bhembre and Mrs Lobo Sardessai the true voices of freedom.
So glad you enjoyed watching it. Please share it forward and subscribe to our channel :)
@@AF-uo8ur No body asked for your opinion.
All those years of British occupation and administration, Goa wasn't snatched from Portuguese is beyond me.
The Portuguese are the oldest allies of the British. This is recorded history.
Even now Goa has to have independent. It can be done by opinion poll. We can have our own country. India makes another colony without choice. Portuguese has given a chance to be part of European union.
Superb!!!! Am so happy for your achievement!!!! 👏
This shows, freedom is an illusion.😢😢😢😢no man is truly free..
Bhembre, Sardesai you are the pioneers of freedom in Goa along with the Satyagrahis. And without the Indian Army Goa would not have become free from Portuguese Military Occupation! Jai Hind!! This video is a revelation about our past which is seldom known! 🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏.
Vande Mataram. 20-12-2023
You won't know about Francisco Luis Gomes, T.B.Cunha, Menezes Braganza, Evargisto George and the Pinto's revolt because they were Catholics
@@user-vg6wt3un9r All those people you mentioned should be celebrated, if they contributed to liberation and integration of goa but don't cry discrimination. Catholicism was imposed on goa by the Portuguese.
"Afonso de Albuquerque wrote to King Manuel that the Portuguese needed not only to build stone houses but to raise sons and daughters-with Indian wives-who would have a vested interest in Portuguese rule."
What good does political decolonization do if we are governed by the same colonial ideas, let the native beliefs prevail.
@@kaliketu But Goa is now ruled by Delhi babus
@@user-vg6wt3un9r it is not ruled by people of other states rather served by them likewise many goans serve other parts of the country, if you can't draw a distinction between colonialists and fellow countrymen thats your problem
@@kaliketu Just like the Aryans from Central Asia and colonized the aboriginal Indians who are now called adivasis.
Have been to Goa once but was always curious to know about how it got freedom. Thank You for this!
Thanks so much for your comment. Please subscribe to our channel for more such videos. And share it forward :)
Sir Uday Bembre is one true Goan gentlemen
Bhembro fked Goans on Konkani language
Portuguese the first to enter India and the last to leave. The irony is people running after Portuguese passport. An important question why?
Because of economy, europe is still considered by people for best quality of life, India is still far behind and indian politicians has made the country worst. earlier foreign powers looted india now politicians are looting india.
@@jeevanrego460 exactly. Politicians should be ashamed of insulting the blood sacrificed for 500 years
Why are Indians running to Europe, Canada, Gulf, Australia and the US
@@jeevanrego460these is the best thing u said. Thousands of years invasions, clonilization, partision has destroyed India completely and now after freedom in the name of democracy some malechaas are sitting in throne and dividing humans for their votebank ,looting our taxes. But the problem is like u an me are very less educated Indians. If it will go continue like that the country will become more worse. We need population control bill, law for stoping illigal immigrants, and so on but they are not doing anything. Delhi is one of the worst place today full of crimes, population, pollution, human trafficking but still no one do anything 😅
Religion.
There are many Portuguese stories my grandma used to tell me growing up.
I am in Goa now for vacation. Glad they are free...these videos help a lot.
problem I have with this doc. It only talks through the exp of 2 people. I wish they had more people who lived through that time.
Just returned from goa. Stayed in Candolim for 3 days. I realise how blessed the place is. Back to the grind in Mumbai.
Not just the "grind" but the appalling pollution levels too! So much for India not meeting its net zero targets by 2070, eh? Do you think Modi will have to issue gas masks to every citizen of every major Indian city?? 😊
wow, amazing how Hindus and Christians United under nationalism to liberate a self sustained state.
Truly Indian!!
I also remember how the Orthodox Christians resisted the Portuguese during the "Coonan Cross Covenant"
India is truly a miracle.
"Miracle" is an odd term for a country that has the most polluted cities on the planet!
@@SenorSol you should go and read the meaning of the word "miracle' in the Merium-Webster or the Oxford Dictionary, there's no correlation between a miracle and pollution there.
@@abc_cba You're right, there's no correlation at all, which is why I'd never use the term 'miracle' in conjunction with India's development, mainly because it's too slow, too haphazard, too beset by corruption, delays, and inefficiency, and of course any 'progress' that is made always comes with a cost, ie more pollution!
Goa was annexed by the use of military force
@@user-vg6wt3un9r Thank god for that, eh?
Goa is such a beautiful, peaceful place now run over by tourists, who have not much idea about history.
We left Goa over 400 hundred years ago...
That was soon after the Portuguese assault.
Having come from the north (Kashmir) many generations before.
We moved south along the western coast. Settled elsewhere.
Konkani remains the mother tongue for most. Our stories and thoughts still point north,
towards Goa.
GSBs are Kashmiris not Goans
@@user-vg6wt3un9r God shall add...
@@user-vg6wt3un9r we all originate from africa, whats your point? they are native indians and thats all that matters, people have moved across india since ages, you have a christian(European) name how are you goan(since you are questioning GSBs)
@@kaliketu Are GSBs Goans?
@@user-vg6wt3un9r they are indian that's it, every indian must be commited to protect the customs/languages of the region he/she is living in
Dhruv Rathee video is very different from this. He hasn't mentioned the Portuguese brutality at all.
That is what you get for watching a m@r@n. My family had to run away from Goa to Kerala to escape Portuguese persecution. There are lakhs of Konkanis like us who had to run away leaving close family and everything to Karnataka and Kerala
@@prabhukod1 And yet you're still crying about a past you can't change nor were you born into! No wonder everything takes so much time in India and progress is slow, you keep worrying about the past instead of concentrating on the future, which is a very good reason why China is so far ahead of India at this stage, they're simply not bothered about the past!
@@SenorSol
Hey, how are you doing? 😂
Back again in the comment section, distributing your third-grade wisdom. 😂
@@parjanyashukla176 I'm always good, unlike India's pollution levels! 😎
@@prabhukod1 Didn't they invade with the help of Hindu Brahmin for their greed by suppressing lower caste people of Goa. If you see now most of the land and temples in Goa belong to Hindu high caste Brahmins which were grabbed with the help of Portuguese laws.
Portuguese blood runs through the veins of the Goan people.
There was no integration at all. Nobody asked the Goans what they wanted.
There was a military invasion that nobody wanted.
The work of the Portuguese is visible. Today Goa is the richest state in India.
Goa in not at all the richest state in India
❤
Only voice which hit close...and best certificate from the enemy
Thanks for watching, Vibhu. Please share the film with friends and family :) And let us know how they liked it.
@@bbcnewsindia Welcome. I sure will share the film further and get back to you.
Loved it. Regards.... 🙏🏻
Thanks so much for watching :)
This video shows exactly the power that the Media has in changing history to their favour lol.
Jai Gomantak!!!
Vande Mataram!!!
Salute
Excellent...
Thanks for watching and commeting, Anju :) Please subscribe to our channel for more films like these. And share it forward.
Portuguese Rule was Golden age of Goa.
Surrender your Indian ID's and go to Portugal.
@@Rahul-hq1ddchedeycha ghatia the main comment is posted by you by fraudulently entering my TH-cam account. Ghatia have some courage to debate an don't use fake accounts in other people's names to post comments. You proved that you are a ghati an not a goan.
Golden Age for Converts-- mostly coastal fisherfolk. 😅
@@silverghost5752 😂😂😂
I agree
Goa was (and probably still is) one of the best regions in the Indian subcontinent. Indian and Latin culture beautifully blended as a result of 450 years of Portuguese rule. I'm from Kerala, but I always enjoyed being among Goans.
The Portuguese inquisition was brutal for the Hindus of Goa. Beauty through oppression.
its been ruined by randians bro
@@kc4276Caste system and sati were worse. Still prevailing. Do something about it
@@thegreatest36516/9 Community ( Katuwa's ) All Interfering Now In Indian Matter
go Find Your New Daddy On China "! 🐖💨💨
@@user-vg6wt3un9r Lol In Western World Womans Were Burnt Alive In The Name Of " Witch Hunting "
And Balck And White Discrimination Is Still High ( I Can't Breath ) ! 😂 🐕💨💨
Goa was much better during Portuguese governance. Clean and laws were good. No corruption. Still we are governed by Portuguese civil code. Freedom fighters are right in their context however there is other side of the story also. It will be a big debate. Finally I ask is Goa free? Only Goans can answer it others will hardly know.
Goa had an exodus of people leaving once india occupied, why did so many of the catholics seek asylum in Portugal, UK etc.? why did indian supreme court on two occasions decide it was an invasion?
Goa has become a colony of Delhi
@@thegreatest3651That's because Catholics are not given jobs and are treated like second class citizens
@@thegreatest3651Converts lorded it over the Hindus and humiliated them during the time of Portugese occupation. Now its their turn. Called Karma.
Still it’s the best
This gave me goose bumps....it deserves to be turned into movie.
Thanks for watching :) So glad you enjoyed it.
There was peace but no justice!! it is possible!
Easiest conquest on record...
❤
My dad was on INS Vikrant. Indian navy ships were involved in clearing the islands occupied by portuguese troops and keeping western navies like britain out of our territorial waters.
Brit navy wanted to rescue handful of its citizens.
Once in they would have never left.
Your dad wasn't on the INS Vikrant, he was a local chai wallah. At least be honest. I used to buy chai from him!
Besides, the Vikrant was a hand-me-down from the Brits, you got their sloppy seconds!! 🤣🤣🤣
@@SenorSolsounds like someone is salty 😂 Cry more CRY HARDER 😂😂 🤡🤡
@@BasedTruthSeeker Salty about what exactly?? INS Vikrant was a British hand-me-down, the Brits literally taught India how to 'navy'!
@@SenorSol And where is their navy now? And the Indians actually showed the Europeans how to ‘Navy’ concidering even they bought ships from India that lasted 20 years vs 12 years for any European ship. At least get your facts straight 🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@SenorSol And which hand me down? INS Vikrant is a brand new carrier made within India completely. Also the same British that fled hand over foot after Daddy Russia threatened them in 1971? We used your old equipment and still you couldn’t do nothing about it with Daddy America by your side 🤡
Now stories remains the same after liberation goa still migrating with portuguese passport, that means portuguese is better off
Bye bye
there was an exodus because, its kinda known globally india is a failed state, sorry to say it.
Running this video about Portuguese colonial past should have been so awkward for BBC😂
Why?
Why?
@Libia Lobo Sardessai - You are so out of depth. 63 years on - Does Goa have any jobs ? Thanks to the Portuguese - Goans including Hindus have availed that and moved to Europe. STOP being a Hypocrite. We are worse in Goa with India - Look at the coastal belt and the rapes and drugs - Stop being Dramatic
exactly, goa is overrun and taken off the catholics, it was clean and fresh before.
In 🇮🇳 lNDIA Country GOA State this old History of golden age Facts and real History of Portugal 🇵🇹 young generations must preserves this History 📖 Hats 👑⛑👒🎩 off for this old Madam Sir gentleman and tanky 👍U GOD bless 🙏
Portuguese has give 30% of their gdp to goa every year
Today all those people who has Portuguese passports seen with high respect and the goans are proud of all things Portuguese 🇵🇹..most people are want Portuguese citizenship
Most of them only want it as it wd be easier to apply for British citizenship and with brexit it's only worse .
Portugal is a poor country.. fuck that land of Robbers
@@NoOne-tg9tk Says someone who has never been to Portugal! Their infrastructure, and cleanliness, is infinitely better than India!
They only take purtugese passports to drop them in 5 years latter they either take british or back indian nattionality and come back to india
Not all Goans. Not even the majority. Mostly those who claim Portuguese descent.
You fought to make Goa a colony of Delhi. No jobs and land for original Goans. Goa was annexed by the use of military force. A pacifist and non-violent India had to use its vast military force to annex tiny Goa. Goans are made homeless in Goa. Shame on you.
😮
Thank the Portuguese, Goa is a unique place in all India, with a fascinating culture. Not even the British left that legacy.
British legacy is the Parliament, the Indian Railways, secular legal system, equality before law! Let's not compare little Goa ruled by the Portugese to the rest of India!
At what cost?
Forced conversion and brutuality
True,but I believe the uniform civil code implemented by them in Goa was the most important legacy.
1961???!!!!
Really?!!!!!!
OMG
No Goan fought for independence.... especially the Portuguese bloodline.....
जय जय श्री राम 🙏🙏🚩🚩
Gen. Sagat Singh Rathore Jindabaad 🙏🙏🚩
The worst thing that happened in Goa was India invading Goa and colonising and destroying it to this day
Thats absurd Indians cant colonize Indians
@vishveshkhanzode9342 Considering the people of Goa overwhelmingly voted to remain seperate from India, and India took it over anyway, I would call that colonisation.
Ur portugese?
My earlier point was, wasn't Goa a part of Portuguese empire and the citizens of Goa citizens of Portugal? This is unlike British empire where the Indians were not British citizens.
In that regard, wasn't the attack on Goa and subsequent surrender an invasion by a new state according to international law? Just asking
Just who all ruled Goa before the Portugese came along in the 16th century? Go read some history before you BS on international law.😅
Why don't you ask Vatican to move against India on this matter?😉
@@silverghost5752 I read about it. But why do you think it matters?
Before portuguese, adil shah dynasty ruled it. You mean it would have been better to return it to descendants of that dynasty? Or to the descandants of kannada or Marathi empires who were fighting between themselves for that part? These empires were different countries at that time, dont forget.
Now among all these empires another empire comes to trade but get attacked and retaliates and wins. Winner not only keep the land but make it part of their empire and the people its citizens.
So you tell me why not??
Also why do you think vatican has anything to do what portugal is doing..lol.
@@albertjoseph9684 Look Indo-Luso, I understand your frustration. Your kind feels left out in contemporary India because you eat here stake your loyalties elsewhere. You vent your frustrations out on Indian government and Hindus and hold them responsible for your loss of prestige and position which you enjoyed under Portugese rule because you converted danced to the tune of the whites. You also felt a false sense of superiority over the majority. Now history has left you in the limbo. Come to terms, bro or get left out!
@@silverghost5752 All Indians "danced to the tune of the whites" which is precisely why Indians are so colour obsessed!!! India is the world's largest market for skin-lightening products, the demand by Indian aunties for girls to be 'fair' so that they'll get married is all-consuming. At least be honest.
Survival of the fittest.
Salute to Charles Darwin.
Portugal 🇵🇹 government is very good job in our GOA , 🎉🎉🎉
What stupid. They killed thousands of us. Because they wanted to spread Christianity. Your own ancestors were probably a Hindu who was forced to convert.
Sir Ji the Britisher did not leave peacefully
Of course they did.
See how Goans defending Portuguese in comments
Christian goans
@@skywalker8940you are a ghati from maharashtra who entered goa during Portuguese rule an that too illegally an if you think Portuguese rule was so bad then why your ancestors entered goa during Portuguese rule?
@@Myworldisgoa Portugese illegaly destroying the local culture doesn't count for people like you ?
Read about Goa Inquisition by Portuguese. How Hindus were persecuted and temples destroyed & churches built on it.
freedom fighters who fought for goa's liberation thought that they will have better days after liberation, they never imagined that goa would be how it is today an they are really sorry for what is going on in goa today, an most of the freedom fighters children have migrated to the western countries with Portuguese passport specialy from the majority community of goa.
Most of the so called freedom fighters were gold smugglers and petty thieves
@@user-vg6wt3un9r "Gold smugglers and petty thieves", sounds like a large percentage of the Indian population!
😂😂😂 You mean to say slavery of Portuguese was way better than freedom.
Anyways you accepted Goa is liberated from Portuguese, which is enough to prove Goa was under Portuguese Dictatorship and Portuguese were invaders in the name or in the cover of your scripted gift deeds🤣
@@Rahul-hq1dd chedeycha ghatia, coward an a fraud person belonging to the rss IT cell an one who is known to post comments using fake ID'S an also fraudulently posting comments on other people's ID'S, you first reveal your real ID by posting comments using your own name an also let me know you are a native of which village of goa.
@@Rahul-hq1ddare ghatia chedeycha you people entered goa illegally during Portuguese rule and now calling yourself goans. If you are goan then show me atleast one document which states you are native goan.
Because of Portugese Goa is a International tourist centre otherwise it will be a begger states like North India.
People will not recognise the contribution of Nehru in leading this master surgical strike. Some will say Nehru is to be blamed for this success. Shame on them
Sadly woke nationalists have nothing left except to disgrace our indian leaders who don't match their hateful ideology
Tbh it was very easy to overtake Goa because of the sheer size of Indian army compared to Portuguese troops, and they were surrounded. This isn't to discredit our army, its just that it was an easy battle.
Nehru however was too non violent and peace loving to be a good wartime leader, and that showed in the 1962 Sino-Indian war. Shastri, even while being non violent was a better wartime leader.
Nehru had promised special status for Goa. Never gave it. Today Goa has become a colony of Delhi
What's the use so many Hindu SC/ST/OBC and Saraswat Brahmins got converted to Christianity and they never came back to their roots.
Liberation of Goa brought curse on Goans
Feel free to migrate to beloved Portugal. No one's stopping you.😅
@@silverghost5752 who want stay in the cursed land anyway...
@eltonpereira875 Converts only shout most, u can apply for Portuguese passport n move out, see how european Portuguese treat a convert living in delusion of the colonizers.
@@eltonpereira875 Go and wash Portugese underwears in Lisbon. 😁
only converts feel that way and than they take portuguse passport but stay in UK not in their beloved portugal ,, hypocrisy ,, the day UK wil stop European union passports no one will take portuguese passports
Im from porvorim goa, Daman and dui my family prior to indian occupation of goa so called freedom fighers speaking english Portugese and kit n kin passport?
The funny thing now is that many Goanese are trying to get Portuguese 🇵🇹 passports to get into Europe lol 😂 how the wheel turns ! If it stayed as a Portuguese enclave , it would have autonomous rule like other Portuguese provinces like Madeira and the Azores , be part of the EU and not be dominated by New Delhi? How the wheel turns lol 😂 if only Goa could turn back time to 1961??
I don't think the majoraty wanted. They never made a referendum 🤷♂️
See what is Goa today. Has Portuguese people left Goa in this condition? ???What have you done to protect Goa??????
Forced conversion u see?
Not goa only daman and diu also
Goa is still liberal and educated compared to main land India , even youth first think about visiting and enjoying Goa during their college days ,it’s because of the European culture that still exists , love Goa and Kerala , ❤they have different ethos
European culture ?? Yeah just forget about the massacre and killings they did ?
European culture 😅😅...Portugese were the most bigoted and obscurantist of Europeans. They carried out Inquisition on Hindus in Goa until the 19th century. Get a grip on history and facts bro!😅
People visit Goa for the beaches and cheap liquor. Also for the ‘parties’ (if you know what I mean).
Sure Goa is a great place and most of us love to visit it, but not because it was brutally ruled by Portuguese, because of its beaches which always existed. Care to define different ethos you are referring to? Even the education couldn't save them from becoming Islamic sympathizer (ISIS) and communist state. Even, Al Bagdadi and Bin Laden were highly qualified. Don't spread your hatred and divisiveness hate monger!
@@blandingscastle3729 are you a goan? An from where you got this Information that inquisition was for hindus?
They have fought the Portuguese, now they all want portuguese passports
The majority of Goans never fought the Portuguese 🙄
Neharu is only responsible for goans suffering.
Who is "Neharu"??? Sounds like a Japanese fisherman!
@mihirojha4475
you wrote that millions gave their blood for independence. Firstly: 74187 Indian dollars died during World war 1, roughly 87000 Indian soldiers died during World war 2. Ironically, you decided to refer to the Bengal famine. While none of the victims died in a struggle for Indian independence, you also decided to exaggerate the death toll but what's even worse: the Bengal famine was a direct result of the regional autonomous Bengal government's failure to adhere to the Famine codes procedures. You will probably blame British for the famine while the exact opposite is the case, it's a blatant failure from the Bengal provincial government, which was run exclusively by Bengalis themselves. A shortage caused by hoarding of grains, which could only be ended, when the British sent in the army to break open the warehouses. It was self inflicted and directly proved to the British, that indians weren't capable of governing themselves responsibly. Please abstain from posting any further skewed Indian 'history' and educate yourself outside of Indian nationalist propaganda
Free from what, Portugal rightfully had sovereignty over Goa.
Portuguese rule was brutal. Goa inquisition is proof of that. Brazil in s.america , Mozambique in Africa & Goa in India for Asia. Well done to all who fought them. When Britain got kicked out of India it began the breakup of the European colonial era .
Goa Inquisition is almost a myth created by right wing Hindus that they were persecuted. This is being done for political mileage.
Inquisition involved questioning Catholics of heresy. It could not be done on non-catholics. This is what an educated hindu must understand.
Those hindus who converted to Catholicism just show to portuguese, ran away to other places when inquisition of catholics started. Those run-away konkanis today cry foul. smh.
You cannot change truth and history no matter how much Goebbels you do.
Are you a goan? Can you tell me something about goa inquisition an what was the purpose of it.
Addin again...
Goa Inquisition is almost a myth created by right wing Hindus that they were persecuted. This is being done for political mileage.
Inquisition involved questioning Catholics of heresy. It could not be done on non-catholics. This is what an educated hindu must understand.
Those hindus who converted to Catholicism just show to portuguese, ran away to other places when inquisition of catholics started. Those run-away konkanis today cry foul. smh.
You cannot change truth and history no matter how much Goebbels you do.
Also provide some solid proof of what happened to hindus during inquisition
La peor conolizacion que existió fue la británica,la portuguesa y la española fue mucho mejor en todos los sentidos,saludos desde Colombia
Goa completely different of India, Goa still not free.
Why did it take India Nehru so many 15 years or more to take over lil goa Nehru was scared of Portuguese
India has never gone to wat with anyone in earth, unless it's as little as Goa.
The jokers who played the songs of freedom of Goa from India are all enjoying their lives in some or the other western country shamelessly indeed, and proud too.
अब पुर्तगाली पहले जैसे नहीं है, सुधर गए हैं, नागरिकता दे रहे हैं
Now 1000s of Portuguese women comes every year to goa to satisfy goa men 😂😂😂
Goan free? Since when? Goa was annexed by India. And you lying.. My respect to Goan people. Goa must be free and independent.
Already goa is free.
Show me the records for ur thought
You are not goan man.
Absolute rubbish !! It was the greed of Jawarhal Nehru to conquer and annexe Goa and it's union territories Daman and Diu to rest of India, as these were very westernised and civilized countries compared to the rest of India. ON PAPER, GOA, DAMAN & DIU STILL BELONG TO PORTUGAL AND THIS IS SOMETHING I WILL FIGHT FOR AGAINST INDIA IN THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURTS TO LIBERATE GOA AND ITS UNION TERRITORIES, SO THAT THEY ARE ONCE AGAIN FREE FROM INDIAN RULE
🤣🤣🤣🤣😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😜😜😜😜🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣
But our goa is sold to outsider n finished everything s n even BJP party sold our motherland n mother river to outsider . Russian enter n many other countries people enter in Goa because of this BJP party . Useless
Outsides. Portuguese were born in Bharat?
People like you are a disgrace. Bastov.
Now 1000s of Portuguese women comes every year to goa to satisfy goa men 😂😂😂
So why do goans vote for bjp , anyways ?
@@user-hn7zs9yr4ean there are many European men who comes to India to take pleasure from Indian woman, if I am wrong then check the news papers of goa.
you can erase history 😅
आपको काफी देशों की किताबों से उनका इतिहास गायब मिलेगा😊
Now 1000s of Portuguese women comes every year to goa to satisfy goa men 😂😂😂
Apart from covering the roads with tarmac and invasion of Goa by non Christians, Indira Ghandi did nothing for Goa and now it is the dirtiest place in India.
Are you a real Saraswat or a deluded Christian ?
Invasion of Goa by non Christians? Goa was Shivaji’s territory before the Portuguese. So who are the invaders here?
Non Christian invasion? The audacity!!
@@user-oq2rk7ep8fWas Shivaji born in 1510?
Trouble is Goa didn't want to be freed and over the years has lost its charm by Indian commercialisation
Only converted Christians like you did , not the Hindu people who were persecuted
@@skywalker8940 lol come on man, theres an exodus of people living india, lets call a failed state a failed state
@@thegreatest3651Exodus ?? I don't what your smoking ?
Is Goa free? it was just replaced by bigger rouges and rascals from Delhi / Gujarat.... together they have destroyed Goa.
Na Vatican rice bag
@@catsid87no ghatis like you.
I don’t care I’m Goan and I want Goan should have dual citizenship or as a Goan I’m not interested to be part of India. 🙌 it’s simple.
Migrate to Portugal, Sawant!!😅😅
@@blandingscastle3729 You would too if you had the chance! In fact, you'd sell your own sister for a visa to go and live in Europe! At least be honest!
@@blandingscastle3729 yeah it’s better than to live with uneducated idiots and heartless people.🤚😀 I’ve Portuguese citizenship already and oci but I want dual citizenship.
@@SenorSol Says the man who lives by selling his Mum, wife and sisters to ragged tourists in Goan Beach!!😁😁
@@SenorSol Pimping is your family trade. Hence you see things that way, Senor Pimpo d Souza....🤣😁
Portugal itself was the poorest of the poor country. Anachronistically speaking Portugal used Catholic church!
What a Lie. Portuguese Goa was/is the best Land in the whole Subcontinent.
Living in your past
😅😅😅😅What F.....Rao??😅😅
Best Land, Amazing culture and food.@@skywalker8940
You want to spray Gutkha and Leer on women that's why you want GOA ?@@blandingscastle3729
I'm not sure why we Indian Christian goans suffer from superior complex. The Portuguese weren't nice people....
But wasn't it invasion?
Yes, the Portugese invaded and took over Goa and was liberated by Indian Government under Nehru.
@@blandingscastle3729 wasnt it islamic empire that attacked portuguese ship which started the war instead of trading spices and later the islamic empire lost? This started the age of colonization in Indian subcontinent, Goa was born and everywhere else it slowly started. Portuguese and other powers discovered this can be done.
Before this islamic forces were fighting with hindu forces and before this Kannada and Maratha forces which were both hindu were fighting for the same place now called Goa.
@@albertjoseph9684 By Islamic empire, do you mean the Mughals? If so, they were not foreign in any sense, unlike Portugese who were in India for plunder and forced conversions.
@@albertjoseph9684 Yes, islamic "empires ", British, Portuguese, French, they r all colonizers, none native to India, they want our land, money, resources for themselves. Most of the Goans r still Hindus, Christians r converts, following the religion is personal choice but falling in love with the captor is delusional. Indian civilization is Hindu n it is b'cos of Dharma everyone is free to practise their religion. If Hinduism is gone, this will become n Islamic nation with muslims taking overn u will have the crusades again.
@@Ganguly0106 you need to be ashamed writing such comment, under muslim india was world's 25% economy, now under hindus its barely 0.1%
m@darch@d s@le angreej
The current peaceful and secular environment of goa is because of 450 years Portuguese rule. Now slowly communal poison has entered there by right wing.
secular environment was created by force conversion by churches and killings of hindus tribals , i am against BJP but you cannot fight communalism with different type of communalism naming it secular
The peaceful environment of Goa and rest of India is being poisoned by Jihadis and Islamists.
😂😂😂 Portuguese secular! It's like Nobel peace prize given to Osama.
Portuguese were never secular, they were settler colonisers, and I do agree that majoritarianism is on the rise all over india that dosent mean you can glorify the horrors or portugese rule. And If you so enjoy portugese colonialism you are free to move to portugal. Goa now belongs to india for eternity.😊
my comments were deleted because i mentioned forced conversion by missionary@@yajatsen2657
Goa made a big mistake by being part of India who is ruled by Greedy politicians Wilson Churchil said that Country will be Ruled by Dacoits..n that is the Fact
But greatest dacoit were British
@@ismartdaya9442you aren't serious, are you? 😂
Winston Churchill was a famous racist who has said disgusting things about Palestinians and aboriginal indigenous people of America and Australia too
@@ismartdaya9442absolutely true😂
Winston Churchill was himself one of the greatest dacoit, imperialist and murderer of 3 million indian people in 1943 bengal famine. And if you like britain go there and live, don't lecture us. We've taken enough of your lectures. We will not take lectures from a man who worships and cold blooded murderer like churchill.
Hypocrites! @bbc do better!
This is shameful.
These are traitors.
Goa was not FREED. It was annexed!
Goa was always and should always been part of Portugal!
I’m from Goa so this is first hand experience. You’ll are conveniently forgetting the great history of the Portuguese and those who fought for Portuguese Goa
colonized traitor.
Now 1000s of Portuguese women comes every year to goa to satisfy goa men 😂😂😂
Pls tell your rate 😂😂😂
The man in the video says that there was a section that wanted to remain part of Portugal. If it was annexed, so be it! It was Indian territory before the Portuguese came and it came back to India. Go home to Portugal.
@@user-oq2rk7ep8f it wasn’t an Indian territory because India didn’t exist
@@eltonmenezesHeard of something called Bharatvarsh or Vijaynagar empire ?
GOA belongs to Portugal
Goans freed Gia from Portugese but now is ruled by immigrants ( Delhi, u. P, bihar) 😂
Thats why I vote for BJP because Congress and Khangressi wants divided India based on C@ste, Religion, Region, Language, R@ce
@@CuriosityforTruth lol bjp is doing the worst dude, moving biharis and UP people to destroy indigenous peoples lives, you like biharis so much you can take them in your own house.
Such an achievement from such a lady with iron will.......