My own list is similar to yours, in order from weakest (none are worse) to strongest: 5, 1,3.4.2, and 6. I enjoyed 6 the best because of Shatner's Kirk, learning from his prejudices, humbling himself, and growing as a person.
I make it my point that when other people give their opinion, I am not ever going to be critical because in the end you’re just telling us how you feel! I think in general you nailed the order, especially six, five and four. The only place were the top three and I would’ve gone two, six, and four but like you said, they literally could be interchangeable because they are so good and I totally agree with you. I am also glad that you shared your thoughts on the scores because I think the music to Star Trek is one of its shining lights! Thank you for sharing, I totally enjoyed watching your video.♥️
6:18 YES!! Totally agree. Shatner gets a lot of grief, sometimes deserved for his acting, but the way he played the death of Kirk’s son was so powerful. I love it! Anytime I’m watching this film of people are talking I immediately start yelling at them to SHUT UP! So I can catch this amazing performance. I feel every word of it. In regards to your ranking I was more surprised that the motion picture wasn’t your 6th place film. Beautiful effects, beautiful enterprise but you hit it on the nose with the lack of Chemistry, the missing fun banter between the core three, Spock’s performance, the 70’s-esque uniforms-remember when bearded McCoy was beamed onto the ship for the first time, oof that didn’t age well. I did like the Kirk and Spock’s uniforms it’s those tan ones that bothered me a bit. Also the film was so slow paced. Might have been good for a Tv show but I wanted some action in my movies lol. I would have ranked number 5 as 5 number 6 as four then 3 then 4 then 2 as number 1, though I agree the difficulty of 4 and 2. In the end I really enjoyed the action of Wrath of Kahn and come on-KHAN HIMSELF! Ricardo Montoban. And when Kirk brings down the reliants shields man love that film. Amazing film. Anyway fun video.
My number one Star Trek film is Khan, Bennett, and Meyer helped it back from Robert Wise' TMP. The torpedo bay was just redressed from the Klingon bridge, in TMP. One interesting thing about the film, is that Nimoy didn't like how his quarters was decorated, and in The Undiscovered Country, he made sure to correct that. Speaking of The Undiscovered Country, it is second, for myself, there was intrigue, and just another great dynamic with the cast. The Search For Spock, is third on my list, mainly because of the introduction of the Oberth class, and Excelsior class, which was modified for Generations, as Enterprise B, but a new studio model was built for the 'anniversary' episode of Voyager, since they didn't want to risk damiging the original model, by trying to remove the additions. The Voyage Home is fourth, it was a great film, and obviously, did the best in revenue, and if you look at the display table at Starfleet Headquarters, it becomes the engineering table in the Enterprise D. The Final Frontier would see the new bridge, mainly because the original got water damage, so Herman Zimmerman came up with the new configuration, and I think it looks better than the previous bridge. I also liked the new elements in this feature, the shuttlebay, the observation lounge, and the turbolift shaft, there is a funny clip where the crew had fun with it, where they had one of those carnival mallet, and ring games, and they hit the ring, and then showed the clip where they are flying up the shaft. They also re-used the shuttlecraft, in Generations' ending, and just added tinted windows at the front side. The Motion Picture, for myself, was the most boring out off the six, loved the new Enterprise, but not the uniforms, which reminds me of the uniforms in Space:1999, and the story. Now waiting for your next, and great video. Take care, and all the best.
Thank you for the kind words and for your ranking. It's a great list! That is so amazing that yo mentioned Space 1999. Last week, I stumbled upon an episode of Space 1999 on Amazon Prime, and I remembered it from my childhood. I was also shocked how similar the uniforms were. Robert Wise and the design team must have been inspired by Space 1999.
I have them 5, 1, 3, 4, 2, 6. With VI only being my favorite because it was the only one where I was old enough to see it when it came out. To me the top 3 can really be in any order.
Star Trek 2 and 6 are considered the best, Star Trek 4 was kinda entertaining but doesn’t really feel like a Star Trek movie as it plays on 20th century earth most of the time
My wife recently saw 4, having never seen it before. She loved it! She and her dad used to spend their evenings watching TOS when she was a kid, and she loved the premise, and the fun the crew has
Okay. I can see IV being number one for someone in the rebirth era, having a similar experience. It was new for me at the time and I also watched my copy of a rental I personally made at 14 endlessly. That's the beauty of the series. It's personal. The "lesser" ones on the list require more attention while the top 3 float the viewer along. Speaking of back to back watches, the theater where I went to college premiered Generations the morning of opening day after playing all six originals in a marathon. It was a very insightful adventure. The theater reeked of BO halfway through VI and we forged ahead to the abomination of Generations. The same bird of prey shot happens for the third time, then the plot flops around on the floor like an escaped fish. At the end, Paramount permanently solves their Shatner salary problem onscreen. Then I cried like a baby in the car. I had just seen the hero squashed and unconsciously knew it was all downhill from here for the movie franchise. Yeah, in the next film we get Cochrane weeing in the woods, Picard becoming Rambo, Data get a moderate temporary skin graft, and hear Steppenwolf. The peak TNG film...yippity-doodle-effing-doo. Good video,btw. Real voice?
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast I'm only saying since you asked. I hate giving a critique of someone's speech since I don't create content myself. I do have a masters degree in communications with an undergrad focus in speech/theater, btw. Your delivery is properly enthusiastic in this. It's a little too even in tone, which gives it that AI feel some people accuse you of when you actually use it. I tried making a podcast once and listened to myself use a similar "announcer voice" that had the same issues. I didn't have your bravery to put it out there though. I fell into it because I was covering my dull midwest accent. I think you may have similar issues. That and/or you have a barely detectable lisp you've almost won the fight against. The slow, steady speed is good. The timbre and pitch are good. It's a fine voice and I wouldn't worry about trying to overcompensate for self-perceived flaws. That sounds like where your trouble, like mine, may lie. It's just youtube, not a forensics competition. :) I like that you're upbeat and positive, but try inserting some color in the form of sarcasm, comically assertive opinion, etc. You don't have to be totally negative, but "rascally" might be good to sprinkle in a little. I can tell people like your content, but most get turned off by AI voices in general. More and more, real voices are like home cooked meals...increasingly rare and increasingly appreciated. Don't sweat it if people dunk on a real voice, the can get. Those kinds will always be waiting to pile-on. Please add channel social media/email to the about. Here is where I will say I am either happy to help or apologize.
Nothing controversial with me about these. I totally agree on IV (aka "The Whale Movie") and II, the Wrath of Khan. They were the best, and the "Whale Movie" has a charm and relatable quality like none other - I mean, it stars us in contemporary society. I could watch it all day.
I remember seeing it in theaters when it came out- i was a kid, and nearly fell asleep- and a kid who went to his first convention in San Francisco at age 10, with his grandma-made Spock uniform! As an adult, i cannot tell you how many times ive fought to stay awake watching this. It’s become an ASMR sleep aid for me.
I feel ST TMP definitely stands on its own as a brilliant solo film. I enjoy it more today than I did in the past. Its so different than every other Star Trek movie, the Original Series, and the other Star Trek series.
Mine, from last to first: 5 (The Final Frontier), 3 (Search for Spock), 6 (Undiscovered Country), 4 (Voyage Home), 2 (Wrath fo Khan), & my top spot, 1 (The Motion Picture).
I got no problem with your rankings. I agree the battle is between 2 and 4. I give 4 over 2 for one reason and one reason only. Chekov never met Khan!!!! HE was not in space seed. Yes, book reconned it but still. For me that is the only mark against 2. I liked 4 because it was just so much fun to watch
I was a sheltered child. Back when I was 10 years old, seeing Kirk, with lapels open, bearing a t-shirt saying 'Go climb a rock!' was the most irreverent, anti-authority thing I'd ever seen. He might as well have been Johnny Rotten! I loved it and still do!
To me the best is "Search for Spock." Second would be "The Voyage Home." Third would be "The Motion Picture." Fourth is "The Final Frontier." Fifth is "The Wrath of Khan." Last is "The Undiscovered Country."
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast My brother and I were fans of the Original Series, we used to watch it in reruns all the time. We were so excited for The Motion Picture but to 11 & 8 year olds that movie was boring; especially 2 years after seeing Star Wars. The Wrath Of Khan reignited my love for the franchise even though I was crying by the end of it. To this day I can remember exactly how I felt after walking out of the theater; so upset in fact my Mom who picked us up after seeing it could tell I was distraught. I was 11 and that movie hit me like a ton of bricks. I have all 6 movies in 4K and watch them often. The Wrath Of Khan copy I have is the director's edition which is even better.
I agree with your assessment of ST3 completely. I don't think that film gets the praise it deserves. It's not perfect, but it's far from bad. I might be in the minority, but I think ST6 is my favorite movie, just barely eclipsing ST2 as my 2nd favorite of the original films. I preferred ST2 when I was younger, but as I age I have a growing appreciation for ST6.
I agree! It is such a fabtastic movie but somehow unfairly got associated with the "even numbered are good and odd numbered are bad" rule. I absolutely love Star Trek 3.
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast i think the reason i put 6 higher is exactly what you stated; this subject matter is what TOS was all about. And this is why i placed it above 4. Wrath of Kahn gets the top spot because, though its a simple plot, and doesn’t have much in the way of surprises, the fact it takes an original series story, and makes it both new as well as nostalgic- well, that does it for me, as a Trekkie since i was a little kid in the 70’s, watching on my tiny black and white tv in my bedroom….
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast When i saw number 4 as a kid, the idea of the villain being the stupidity of humanity itself, made me love it, because that was the essence of Star trek!
My only criticism of Star Trek 4 being first. Is that the Enterprise is as much of a character as the rest of the crew. She was pretty absent for most of the film.
You have a good point. But that's what I live about ST4 is the payoff at the end when we get the Enterprise back. That moment gave me chills when I saw it the theater in 1986. 😀 Thank you for your comment!
While I was watching the ranking, I thought it was Star Trek 4 and 6 going head to head for 2nd place. Not Star Trek 2 and 6 going head to head. I would have started with 5, 1, and 3 also.
More or less in agreement with you. 5 sucks donkey balls and is last, obviously. 1 was worthy but tedious, so 5th. I'd put 6 behind 3, as 3 broke a lot of taboos - stealing and totalling the Enterprise, swearing? Hallo? As for 4 and 2, it's pretty much a toss-up. 4 is a feel-good flick with a moral message, 2 is a Greek tragedy in classic Star Trek style. I'd go for 2 at the moment, not least for the music, but it depends on my mood.
The Motion Picture should actually be ranked at least Number 2; it’s a masterpiece. Remove the sentimentality of Trek VI being the last Classic Trek film and it comes off as a rushed, cheap, and very simple story.
I like this controversy. But yeah… no.😂. Best: 2, then 6, 3, 4, 5, 1. All good. I was never a fan of 4, but it’s grown on me (at the time I thought a little preachy; by today’s standards not at all). I enjoy it now. But to each their own. Glad you enjoy the films.
How anybody could take STV as anything, but Shatner saying "F-U" to the fans, I don't know. It was as much a farce as anything Jar Jar Abrams made. When reminded of this film, I remember why I didn't like to see Captain Kirk for a long time.
Voyage Home was entertaining...I just dont think it aged as well as 6 and especially 2. But all of them were great. 3 belongs in the middle, Motion Picture dragged far too much, and everyone hated 5!
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast I intend to! I did a "Star Trek" themed episode when I did those GM Dustbuster minivans. All I thought about when they were new, was how much they reminded me of a shuttle craft LOL. th-cam.com/video/qp8cjJ75gMI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=3O_AbJ8KjhThVI2M
Any list that says TMP is second worst of the franchise is not a list worth finishing. "None of the banter between Spock and McCoy..." just as you show a clip of banter between Spock and McCoy. Right.
Good list .. but my list is 2,3 (it introduced new ship designs that was used throughout the rest of the series) ,1 (at least until they reach the cloud but it has the best special effects) 6, 4 (I wanted to see starships not whales) & lastly 5 it made the crew seem old and senile + the god awful special effects 👎🏾
Yeah I to put 5 and 1 at the bottom, in 1 the uniforms sucked but the rebuilt ship design was great, but I still cant choose between the TOS ship and the movie Enterprise. ST 5 would've been better if not searching after God with spaceship, it was to far anti bible for me, but that movie did have some good lines in, like what Kirk said about Spock not having a brother and Scotty know the ship like the back of his hand. The movie just need a better story line...... I still give ST-II and ST-VI on same score, I still cant make up my mind which one I like better, they both have excellent story lines. I really like Christopher Plumer in VI... I had no interests in NG ST mostly because of terrible ship design. I now have no interest in any ST after the first ST movie series, JJ Abrams has turned me off from all new ST movies.....
Pretty predictable rankings. For me 2 4 and 6 are interchangeably excellent but wrath of khan gets the edge as the objectively best film. Then i might put tmp directors cut at 4th, or search for spock, they are close together, and 5 is just unwatchable. Cant agree that its in the "good" tier
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast I'm torn... Kahn is the best but I do like the VEGR story and Spock's discovery that cold logic is not enough (for him either). It's a tie for me.
Agreed. TMP is neck and neck with Wrath of Kahn for top spot for me, but the first ages out the second because it has the best visual, biggest concept, most mature character arcs, and gets at the true core of what Trek is.
Voyage Home is the worst of the TOS movies. Silly concept. First, do they have money or not in Kirk's time? Hello, canon anyone? Also, they can use physics to travel back in time, but can't use a computer to simulate a whale call?? A FVCKING whale call??? That is what this movie is about? A whale call???? Obviously, if the invader was coming to Earth to find a dang whale, they for sure did not originate from Earth. Get it together. And it is such an infinitesimal subject. It's pretty much a fake catastrophe like what Lefties have been trying to stir up now. What's next...Star Trek The Mission to end Global Warming?????? Get your heads out of your asses. That ain't real either.
![[MV] A leap of faith...ความเชื่อใจครั้งสุดท้าย (From "Petrichor the series")](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/U1piZH2CNXA/mqdefault.jpg)
Completely agree with your listing, nice job !
Thank you! It's always nice to meet a fellow 4>2. 😀
They have NEVER improved upon those GREAT monster maroon uniforms. Chefs kiss.
Those uniforms were so good! I agree. The absolute best in the series by far.
I actually groaned when you announced number 2
Haha! 🤣 I think I heard your groan all the way over here!
My own list is similar to yours, in order from weakest (none are worse) to strongest: 5, 1,3.4.2, and 6. I enjoyed 6 the best because of Shatner's Kirk, learning from his prejudices, humbling himself, and growing as a person.
I like your ranking! 🙂
Great video. For me it's 5, 1, 3, 4, 6, and 2 takes the top spot.
Excellent ranking! Thank you for your comment!
My same!!!😎
Same for me as well!
I make it my point that when other people give their opinion, I am not ever going to be critical because in the end you’re just telling us how you feel! I think in general you nailed the order, especially six, five and four. The only place were the top three and I would’ve gone two, six, and four but like you said, they literally could be interchangeable because they are so good and I totally agree with you. I am also glad that you shared your thoughts on the scores because I think the music to Star Trek is one of its shining lights! Thank you for sharing, I totally enjoyed watching your video.♥️
Thank you for thr kond words! They are totally appreciated. 🙂
6:18 YES!! Totally agree. Shatner gets a lot of grief, sometimes deserved for his acting, but the way he played the death of Kirk’s son was so powerful. I love it! Anytime I’m watching this film of people are talking I immediately start yelling at them to SHUT UP! So I can catch this amazing performance. I feel every word of it. In regards to your ranking I was more surprised that the motion picture wasn’t your 6th place film. Beautiful effects, beautiful enterprise but you hit it on the nose with the lack of Chemistry, the missing fun banter between the core three, Spock’s performance, the 70’s-esque uniforms-remember when bearded McCoy was beamed onto the ship for the first time, oof that didn’t age well. I did like the Kirk and Spock’s uniforms it’s those tan ones that bothered me a bit. Also the film was so slow paced. Might have been good for a Tv show but I wanted some action in my movies lol. I would have ranked number 5 as 5 number 6 as four then 3 then 4 then 2 as number 1, though I agree the difficulty of 4 and 2. In the end I really enjoyed the action of Wrath of Kahn and come on-KHAN HIMSELF! Ricardo Montoban. And when Kirk brings down the reliants shields man love that film. Amazing film. Anyway fun video.
People cant deny that Star Trek V is a lot of fun.
My number one Star Trek film is Khan, Bennett, and Meyer helped it back from Robert Wise' TMP. The torpedo bay was just redressed from the Klingon bridge, in TMP. One interesting thing about the film, is that Nimoy didn't like how his quarters was decorated, and in The Undiscovered Country, he made sure to correct that.
Speaking of The Undiscovered Country, it is second, for myself, there was intrigue, and just another great dynamic with the cast.
The Search For Spock, is third on my list, mainly because of the introduction of the Oberth class, and Excelsior class, which was modified for Generations, as Enterprise B, but a new studio model was built for the 'anniversary' episode of Voyager, since they didn't want to risk damiging the original model, by trying to remove the additions.
The Voyage Home is fourth, it was a great film, and obviously, did the best in revenue, and if you look at the display table at Starfleet Headquarters, it becomes the engineering table in the Enterprise D.
The Final Frontier would see the new bridge, mainly because the original got water damage, so Herman Zimmerman came up with the new configuration, and I think it looks better than the previous bridge. I also liked the new elements in this feature, the shuttlebay, the observation lounge, and the turbolift shaft, there is a funny clip where the crew had fun with it, where they had one of those carnival mallet, and ring games, and they hit the ring, and then showed the clip where they are flying up the shaft. They also re-used the shuttlecraft, in Generations' ending, and just added tinted windows at the front side.
The Motion Picture, for myself, was the most boring out off the six, loved the new Enterprise, but not the uniforms, which reminds me of the uniforms in Space:1999, and the story.
Now waiting for your next, and great video.
Take care, and all the best.
Thank you for the kind words and for your ranking. It's a great list! That is so amazing that yo mentioned Space 1999. Last week, I stumbled upon an episode of Space 1999 on Amazon Prime, and I remembered it from my childhood. I was also shocked how similar the uniforms were. Robert Wise and the design team must have been inspired by Space 1999.
I have them 5, 1, 3, 4, 2, 6. With VI only being my favorite because it was the only one where I was old enough to see it when it came out. To me the top 3 can really be in any order.
I like your rankings! 😀
Star Trek 2 and 6 are considered the best, Star Trek 4 was kinda entertaining but doesn’t really feel like a Star Trek movie as it plays on 20th century earth most of the time
I think most people will agree with you. 😁
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast Why ? They explore the strangest planet ever.
My wife recently saw 4, having never seen it before. She loved it! She and her dad used to spend their evenings watching TOS when she was a kid, and she loved the premise, and the fun the crew has
Okay. I can see IV being number one for someone in the rebirth era, having a similar experience. It was new for me at the time and I also watched my copy of a rental I personally made at 14 endlessly.
That's the beauty of the series. It's personal. The "lesser" ones on the list require more attention while the top 3 float the viewer along.
Speaking of back to back watches, the theater where I went to college premiered Generations the morning of opening day after playing all six originals in a marathon.
It was a very insightful adventure. The theater reeked of BO halfway through VI and we forged ahead to the abomination of Generations.
The same bird of prey shot happens for the third time, then the plot flops around on the floor like an escaped fish.
At the end, Paramount permanently solves their Shatner salary problem onscreen. Then I cried like a baby in the car.
I had just seen the hero squashed and unconsciously knew it was all downhill from here for the movie franchise.
Yeah, in the next film we get Cochrane weeing in the woods, Picard becoming Rambo, Data get a moderate temporary skin graft, and hear Steppenwolf.
The peak TNG film...yippity-doodle-effing-doo.
Good video,btw. Real voice?
Yes. This is me i all my glory! 🙂 How is it?
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast I'm only saying since you asked. I hate giving a critique of someone's speech since I don't create content myself. I do have a masters degree in communications with an undergrad focus in speech/theater, btw.
Your delivery is properly enthusiastic in this. It's a little too even in tone, which gives it that AI feel some people accuse you of when you actually use it. I tried making a podcast once and listened to myself use a similar "announcer voice" that had the same issues. I didn't have your bravery to put it out there though.
I fell into it because I was covering my dull midwest accent. I think you may have similar issues. That and/or you have a barely detectable lisp you've almost won the fight against.
The slow, steady speed is good. The timbre and pitch are good. It's a fine voice and I wouldn't worry about trying to overcompensate for self-perceived flaws. That sounds like where your trouble, like mine, may lie. It's just youtube, not a forensics competition. :)
I like that you're upbeat and positive, but try inserting some color in the form of sarcasm, comically assertive opinion, etc. You don't have to be totally negative, but "rascally" might be good to sprinkle in a little.
I can tell people like your content, but most get turned off by AI voices in general. More and more, real voices are like home cooked meals...increasingly rare and increasingly appreciated.
Don't sweat it if people dunk on a real voice, the can get. Those kinds will always be waiting to pile-on.
Please add channel social media/email to the about.
Here is where I will say I am either happy to help or apologize.
Nothing controversial with me about these. I totally agree on IV (aka "The Whale Movie") and II, the Wrath of Khan. They were the best, and the "Whale Movie" has a charm and relatable quality like none other - I mean, it stars us in contemporary society. I could watch it all day.
It's always nice to meet a feelie 4>2. 😀
My firing order is 5,1,3,4,6,2. 3 and 4 pretty are tied. I often say the best Star Treks have fire extinguishers on the bridge.
I like you ranking!🙂
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast 🖖😸
1 is a cinematic masterpiece, no matter if it is Star Trek or not. All others are fanboy pleasers with 6 and 2 on top.
I remember seeing it in theaters when it came out- i was a kid, and nearly fell asleep- and a kid who went to his first convention in San Francisco at age 10, with his grandma-made Spock uniform! As an adult, i cannot tell you how many times ive fought to stay awake watching this. It’s become an ASMR sleep aid for me.
You're not alone in this opinion.😀
I feel ST TMP definitely stands on its own as a brilliant solo film. I enjoy it more today than I did in the past. Its so different than every other Star Trek movie, the Original Series, and the other Star Trek series.
I'm so close to being in perfect agreement with you... my rankings from best to worst: 2,4,6,3,1,5.
So close! Great ranking! 👍 I think your decision to rank 2 above 4 is probably more "correct". 😀 I am definitely in the minority here.
Mine, from last to first:
5 (The Final Frontier), 3 (Search for Spock), 6 (Undiscovered Country), 4 (Voyage Home), 2 (Wrath fo Khan), & my top spot, 1 (The Motion Picture).
Wow! That's certainly an interesting list. Star Trek The Motion Picture has been getting more deserved live these days.
I got no problem with your rankings. I agree the battle is between 2 and 4. I give 4 over 2 for one reason and one reason only. Chekov never met Khan!!!! HE was not in space seed. Yes, book reconned it but still. For me that is the only mark against 2. I liked 4 because it was just so much fun to watch
Thank you. It's always nice to meet a fellow "4 over 2" fan. 😀
I was a sheltered child. Back when I was 10 years old, seeing Kirk, with lapels open, bearing a t-shirt saying 'Go climb a rock!' was the most irreverent, anti-authority thing I'd ever seen. He might as well have been Johnny Rotten! I loved it and still do!
That's amazing! I love it!
I kinda liked the “I know the ship like the back of my hand” joke.
Haha! You know, I like it when I saw it in the theater, but it gets cringier every time I see it.
To me the best is "Search for Spock." Second would be "The Voyage Home." Third would be "The Motion Picture." Fourth is "The Final Frontier." Fifth is "The Wrath of Khan." Last is "The Undiscovered Country."
That's certainly a controversial ranking. But I like it! 😀
Your list is almost perfect. You got #1 wrong haha. My list is 2, 4, 6, 3, 1, 5.
I cant argue with that! 😀 Thank you for your ranking!
#2, #6, #4, #3, #1, #5 for me - The Wrath Of Khan came out 42 years ago but it's still a Top 5 movie of all time for me.
I like your rankings. Isn't it amazing how well it's held up over 42 years?
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast My brother and I were fans of the Original Series, we used to watch it in reruns all the time. We were so excited for The Motion Picture but to 11 & 8 year olds that movie was boring; especially 2 years after seeing Star Wars. The Wrath Of Khan reignited my love for the franchise even though I was crying by the end of it. To this day I can remember exactly how I felt after walking out of the theater; so upset in fact my Mom who picked us up after seeing it could tell I was distraught. I was 11 and that movie hit me like a ton of bricks. I have all 6 movies in 4K and watch them often. The Wrath Of Khan copy I have is the director's edition which is even better.
That's great! Actually, I'm working on a video about Star Trek The Original Series. I hope to release it on Monday or Tuesday. I hope you enjoy it.
for me episodes 2,3,4 are *one* film, with top episode 4 😊
so overall ranking would be: 4,2,3 .... then 1, then 6 and 5 as last.
I'm always happy to meet a fellow 4>2. I'm also like you in that I see 2, 3, and 4 as one film, or at leatlsr as the greatest trilogy of all time!
I agree with your assessment of ST3 completely. I don't think that film gets the praise it deserves. It's not perfect, but it's far from bad. I might be in the minority, but I think ST6 is my favorite movie, just barely eclipsing ST2 as my 2nd favorite of the original films. I preferred ST2 when I was younger, but as I age I have a growing appreciation for ST6.
I agree! It is such a fabtastic movie but somehow unfairly got associated with the "even numbered are good and odd numbered are bad" rule. I absolutely love Star Trek 3.
I actually don’t think st5 is that bad. The visuals let it down but generally it’s a lot of fun
I agree. It's a fun movie, and it's very rewatchable.
I’ll post mine before i see your list;
5, 1, 3, 4, 6, 2-worst to best, of course
I like your list. What do you think of mine?
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast i think the reason i put 6 higher is exactly what you stated; this subject matter is what TOS was all about. And this is why i placed it above 4. Wrath of Kahn gets the top spot because, though its a simple plot, and doesn’t have much in the way of surprises, the fact it takes an original series story, and makes it both new as well as nostalgic- well, that does it for me, as a Trekkie since i was a little kid in the 70’s, watching on my tiny black and white tv in my bedroom….
Love this list I agree ☝️
Thank you so much!
"KHAN" is the BEST movie, "VOYAGE" is my FAVORITE movie.
Looks like we agree on that.
I like how you phrased that! Genius. 😃
I can live with that 😊
Thank you. I thought people would find me and hurt me after chosing 4 over 2. 🤣
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast When i saw number 4 as a kid, the idea of the villain being the stupidity of humanity itself, made me love it, because that was the essence of Star trek!
My only criticism of Star Trek 4 being first. Is that the Enterprise is as much of a character as the rest of the crew. She was pretty absent for most of the film.
You have a good point. But that's what I live about ST4 is the payoff at the end when we get the Enterprise back. That moment gave me chills when I saw it the theater in 1986. 😀 Thank you for your comment!
I love voyage home but wrath of khan is #1, the battle, the maturing of Star trek and Starfleet
I can totally respect your opinion.
And obviously the bird of prey was supposed to be a Romulan ship.
Yes!
Did you check out my video on Star Trek 3 where I explained the whole change?
While I was watching the ranking, I thought it was Star Trek 4 and 6 going head to head for 2nd place. Not Star Trek 2 and 6 going head to head. I would have started with 5, 1, and 3 also.
Interesting! 🙂 What is your ranking?
@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast Almost like yours. 5, 1, 3, 6, 4, and finally 2.
More or less in agreement with you. 5 sucks donkey balls and is last, obviously. 1 was worthy but tedious, so 5th. I'd put 6 behind 3, as 3 broke a lot of taboos - stealing and totalling the Enterprise, swearing? Hallo? As for 4 and 2, it's pretty much a toss-up. 4 is a feel-good flick with a moral message, 2 is a Greek tragedy in classic Star Trek style. I'd go for 2 at the moment, not least for the music, but it depends on my mood.
That's a very solid ranking, very close to mine.😃
All good here, it’s hard to split the top two so tilting one way or the other is fine… actually it’s not- a double dumb-ass on you 😂😂
🤣🤣🤣 I love it! Haha.
The Undiscovered Country for me. Then Wrath of Khan. The Final Frontier is last. The rest in any order you want 😊
That's an interesting ranking. 🤣 That's what I love about these rankings. You get so much variation! Thank you for your comment!
You can't beat practice effects
Yup!
The Motion Picture should actually be ranked at least Number 2; it’s a masterpiece.
Remove the sentimentality of Trek VI being the last Classic Trek film and it comes off as a rushed, cheap, and very simple story.
Certainly a controversial opinion, but I can respect it. Thank you for your rankings!
I like this controversy. But yeah… no.😂. Best: 2, then 6, 3, 4, 5, 1.
All good. I was never a fan of 4, but it’s grown on me (at the time I thought a little preachy; by today’s standards not at all). I enjoy it now. But to each their own. Glad you enjoy the films.
Thank you! I like your rankings. 😃 Thank you for your comment!
Star Trek 2 has no rival, and revived Star Trek.
It certainly did!
Enterprise refit will always favorite ship and enterprise A is a close 2nd.
Me too! So sleek and awesome!
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast something about the the 1960's fins on the nacelles. Much improved over the orbs
How anybody could take STV as anything, but Shatner saying "F-U" to the fans, I don't know. It was as much a farce as anything Jar Jar Abrams made. When reminded of this film, I remember why I didn't like to see Captain Kirk for a long time.
🤣🤣🤣
Voyage Home was entertaining...I just dont think it aged as well as 6 and especially 2. But all of them were great. 3 belongs in the middle, Motion Picture dragged far too much, and everyone hated 5!
Great recap. 🙂 Thank you for your comment!
@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast Great channel and Subscribed..Im a You Tuber too, that is just my personal account LOL.
Thank you so much! I'm working on Star Trek TOS at the moment. I hope you enjoy it when I release the video!
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast I intend to! I did a "Star Trek" themed episode when I did those GM Dustbuster minivans. All I thought about when they were new, was how much they reminded me of a shuttle craft LOL. th-cam.com/video/qp8cjJ75gMI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=3O_AbJ8KjhThVI2M
1-IV
2-VI
3-II
4-I
5-III
6-V
Yes! Another person who thinks Star Trek 4 is the best! 😀 Thank you for your ranking!
2,4,3,6,1,5
I like your ranking! 🙂 thank you for your comment.
Star trek 4 is a better movie, than wrath of Khan.
Thank you!
Any list that says TMP is second worst of the franchise is not a list worth finishing. "None of the banter between Spock and McCoy..." just as you show a clip of banter between Spock and McCoy. Right.
Oh. Sorry you feel that way. But I respect your opinion. Thank you for your comment.
Good list .. but my list is 2,3 (it introduced new ship designs that was used throughout the rest of the series) ,1 (at least until they reach the cloud but it has the best special effects) 6, 4 (I wanted to see starships not whales) & lastly 5 it made the crew seem old and senile + the god awful special effects 👎🏾
Interesting! 🙂 I love your list! It is certainly different. Thank you for your ranking! 😀
2 is #1 4 is #2
I cant argue with that! 😀
TWOK has to be #1. I can understand your reasoning but without TWOK there is no TVH.
Great point! I cant argue with that. 😀
Yeah I to put 5 and 1 at the bottom, in 1 the uniforms sucked but the rebuilt ship design was great, but I still cant choose between the TOS ship and the movie Enterprise. ST 5 would've been better if not searching after God with spaceship, it was to far anti bible for me, but that movie did have some good lines in, like what Kirk said about Spock not having a brother and Scotty know the ship like the back of his hand. The movie just need a better story line......
I still give ST-II and ST-VI on same score, I still cant make up my mind which one I like better, they both have excellent story lines. I really like Christopher Plumer in VI...
I had no interests in NG ST mostly because of terrible ship design. I now have no interest in any ST after the first ST movie series, JJ Abrams has turned me off from all new ST movies.....
I like your list. 👍 Thank you for your comment.
My ranking would be 264351 best to worst.
That's a great ranking! 🙂
2, 6, 4, 3, 1, 5 is THE definitive ranking.
I cant argue with that! 😀
To me 5 beats 1. Row, row, row your boat. The most TOS-ish movie.
Wrath of Khan>the voyage home
Who am I to argue with that? 😀
Pretty predictable rankings. For me 2 4 and 6 are interchangeably excellent but wrath of khan gets the edge as the objectively best film. Then i might put tmp directors cut at 4th, or search for spock, they are close together, and 5 is just unwatchable. Cant agree that its in the "good" tier
I like your rankings! Thank you for your comment. 🙂
Any ranking of these movies that doesn’t put 5 last and 2 first is trash.
😔
Yep, I stopped at your choice of second place
😒
As soon as you put the first one number 5, I checked out👎🏽
Really, what would be your ranking?
@@TotallyAwesomeFilmsPodcast
I'm torn... Kahn is the best but I do like the VEGR story and Spock's discovery that cold logic is not enough (for him either). It's a tie for me.
Wow! That's certainly a controversial opinion but I can respect it! Thank you for your opinion.
Agreed. TMP is neck and neck with Wrath of Kahn for top spot for me, but the first ages out the second because it has the best visual, biggest concept, most mature character arcs, and gets at the true core of what Trek is.
@@lestatdelc 'Can't argue with that.🖖🏽
2,1 or 1,2; then who cares.
You said it! 😀
Star Trek 1 is such a booooring mess, watching it felt like being force fed in an all you can eat restaurant.
The Slow Motion Picture or the Motionless Picture. 😄
Voyage Home is the worst of the TOS movies. Silly concept. First, do they have money or not in Kirk's time? Hello, canon anyone? Also, they can use physics to travel back in time, but can't use a computer to simulate a whale call?? A FVCKING whale call??? That is what this movie is about? A whale call???? Obviously, if the invader was coming to Earth to find a dang whale, they for sure did not originate from Earth. Get it together. And it is such an infinitesimal subject. It's pretty much a fake catastrophe like what Lefties have been trying to stir up now. What's next...Star Trek The Mission to end Global Warming?????? Get your heads out of your asses. That ain't real either.
🤣