Wow! How did I just stumble upon this gem today? I call myself a fan of PT but have never heard this song or know what album it’s on. I have seen them live but this..... this performance is just RIDICULOUS! It’s just so good it makes you lose your mind! OMG...Tomorrow is my 66th birthday and I consider this video the perfect gift! Thank you guys. Your reaction was spot on appropriate in just not even knowing what to do or say. Still smiling...
@@marvsmooth unbelievable... it’s one of MY favorite albums too (can’t lie, I don’t own it) but there it was sure enough, sandwiched in between two of my favorite songs: The Rest Will Flow and Where We Would Be. I managed to download a good collection of PT songs from the old Limewire ‘file sharing’ app and I think Hatesong either just never showed up or I failed to download it. Thanks for enlightening me!
@@glenndespres5317 Lightbulb sun is one of my favourite albums as well! I love Gavin's take on "Hatesong" here, sounds so amazing live and also so different than the studio version (by Chris Maitland, I think) :D
It’s from the arriving somewhere but not here show they did in Chicago 2005. The whole concert is great! I’ve seen PT three times in Chicago. They are one of my favorite prog rock bands.
"Cheating The Polygraph" live from Tilburg. Everything about it is outstanding. The vocals, the heavy instruments, the soundscapes.. all the highs and lows... oh and of course Gavin's impeccable beat. It feels more like watching a movie than listening to a song with these guys.
Possibly the best organised chaotic sound I have ever heard. This band is so tight and on time, nothing is left to chance even when they improvise. The BEST jammers there is. All of them. You should continue your journey with them; try - Fear of a Blank Planet (live @Tilburg) or What Happens Now (also, Tilburg). Sleep Together is another mind blowing performance too (again, Tilburg). So many to choose from.
Epic Reaction!!! Porcupine Tree - Russia on Ice(90's PT is trippy as hell. In my opinion this is on of their best songs ever) Porcupine Tree - Blackest Eyes Steven wilson - Drive Home (one hell of an emotional ride) Please do all studio versions of these Love your channel guys!!!
Been a fan from almost their beginnings, they never fail to impress. I obtained this dvd that this is on when it was issued, and it is played often. The best sounding live performance ever. ❤️👏👏👏
So lucky to catch many early tours in small clubs in Seattle. FOABP at the Crocodile Cafe with a capacity of 500 was indescribable standing in front of Steven with essentially no stage. Welcome to the PT family, folks!
Omg im so glad you guys did the live version, gavin is one of the greatest drummers of all time and this song really showcases his creativity and skill
Or... Cheating the Polygraph, live from Tilburg. (The video title says Live from Anesthetize) Quite possibly the quintessential Porcupine Tree live performance.
Saw Porcupine Tree in Chicago on their “The Incident” tour. I was grinning ear to ear to see half the crowd wearing King Crimson shirts and the other wearing TooL shirts. Not sure there could be a better compliment to this band really.
I love how this song serves as a showcase for each musician. Everybody gets a little freestyle spotlight. 🤘 (Except John Wesley I suppose, but he's got the velvet pipes so he wins by default)
I don't know why danney has to be brought up every time, these two are completely different. I like having because of the attention to small detail, like the way he plays a ghost note or plays quarter notes on a ride cymbal when most people play 8th notes. All that flashy stuff is cool like a 100 hit rip through the tomms or blast beats on the kick drum all stuff gavin can do but chooses not to for the music. Danny on the other hand is great but I just see him as the best rock drummer ever and nothing more.
ONLY the greatest ROCK drummer ever? WTF is Tabla then? Why does he have another band called VOLTO! that is a jazz fusion band? You definitely don’t know what you’re talking about.
Interesting, I never knew he was in another group. At the end of the day, I find Porcupine Trees music to be better and I have a feeling these people think so too. Tool is boring to me for the most part, lateralus was good for what it was an 8/10 a little long. The last disc felt like they were trying too hard. The title track off fear inoculum builds up and nothing happens lol. Tool just feel uninspiring to me. Like they get together get all high and never finish lol.
The guitar solo and Gavin Harrison's drum performance was what made me as a teenager realize that this band was special and unlike anything Ive heard before.
Live- Octane Twisted/The Seance/Circle of Manias concept suite. It's mindblowing. Single songs live from Tilburg -Fear of a Blank Planet -Strip The Soul -Cheating The Polygraph Live from Chicago- Halo, Don't Hate Me, Open Car
Please Please do PT “Normal” Live from Tilburg!!!!! It’s one of the tracks after Anesthetize, which you guys loved, and is according to SW the hardest song to play.
Loved your reaction. One of the most incredible live performances I've ever seen. All 4 band members are frickin' virtuosos, but Gavin Harrison really shines on this one
Another brilliant reaction, you guys probably do this the best, thanks a million for reacting to this one, really showcases every member of the band. Where do you go next with PT? Easy - Dark Matter (live) or sleep together (live) , cheers guys - keep rocking.
Wonderful stuff- being a progressive rock fan since the late 1960's, I thought nothing much could motivate me as we got into the 80's, until I started listening to Steven Wilsons music in the early 90's- being an avid vinyl collector I also appreciated that he never gave up on the format and I now have most of the LP's he produced especially Porcupine Tree, Bass Communion and Blackfield plus of course his later music published using his own name. Porcupine Tree takes the biscuit though as the music was fabulous, the albums were prolific and so much of it was outstanding.
I love The Pineapple Thief. Discovered them recently and can't get enough of them. "Tear you up " is amazing too, but they have so many great songs. They deserve much more attention
Steven Wilson: Drive Home, and Luminol are both really good. both are different. Luminol is kinda Jazzy, and Drive Home is a Complete Emotional Trip. By the way, if you're doing Drive Home, do the Video. the Storytelling is insane, and makes the Music 1000% MORE Impactful. Luminol should be the Studio Version this time.
I first heard (I think heard, maybe saw) this song as the live version and this live version is certainly the quintessential version of this song, you guys are right.
I wonder how would you react to their highly underestimated album The Incident. It is their last album together from 2009. The song The Blind House is really captivating
I would say you picked the right version of this to watch, not just to see it being performed, but also because the studio version is a completely different sounding track, much more basic and without all the crazy technical musicianship. It's still good, but this is definitely the definitive version as it combines the main song with an impressive jam performance.
Porcupine Tree, are fantastic live. They are probably one of the best live bands ever. Steven Wilson is, also one of the best, producers ever. With that said, he would be the 1st to admit, he couldn't recreate, his studio production live. Everyone should marvel, at how close P.T. come to reproducing their albums. With that said, you cannot truly appreciate, one of their tracks, live. It's like viewing a George Lucas story board, or a Looney Toons still panel. You can appreciate it. But it as part, not a whole.
Now you all know, Steven is a absolute MONSTER on guitar.
Wow! How did I just stumble upon this gem today? I call myself a fan of PT but have never heard this song or know what album it’s on. I have seen them live but this..... this performance is just RIDICULOUS! It’s just so good it makes you lose your mind! OMG...Tomorrow is my 66th birthday and I consider this video the perfect gift! Thank you guys. Your reaction was spot on appropriate in just not even knowing what to do or say. Still smiling...
It’s from the incredible album Lightbulb Sun. In my top five of Porcupine Tree albums!
@@marvsmooth unbelievable... it’s one of MY favorite albums too (can’t lie, I don’t own it) but there it was sure enough, sandwiched in between two of my favorite songs: The Rest Will Flow and Where We Would Be. I managed to download a good collection of PT songs from the old Limewire ‘file sharing’ app and I think Hatesong either just never showed up or I failed to download it. Thanks for enlightening me!
Its never too late to find this rare gems 😊😊
@@glenndespres5317 Lightbulb sun is one of my favourite albums as well! I love Gavin's take on "Hatesong" here, sounds so amazing live and also so different than the studio version (by Chris Maitland, I think) :D
It’s from the arriving somewhere but not here show they did in Chicago 2005. The whole concert is great! I’ve seen PT three times in Chicago. They are one of my favorite prog rock bands.
"Cheating The Polygraph" live from Tilburg. Everything about it is outstanding. The vocals, the heavy instruments, the soundscapes.. all the highs and lows... oh and of course Gavin's impeccable beat. It feels more like watching a movie than listening to a song with these guys.
Rightly said man!
Filmed at the Park West, Chicago, USA, 11-12 Oktober 2005, incredible perfomance show omg damn!
The first time I heard this song was transformative
Possibly the best organised chaotic sound I have ever heard. This band is so tight and on time, nothing is left to chance even when they improvise. The BEST jammers there is. All of them. You should continue your journey with them; try - Fear of a Blank Planet (live @Tilburg) or What Happens Now (also, Tilburg). Sleep Together is another mind blowing performance too (again, Tilburg). So many to choose from.
best organised chaotic sounds you can hear by nick cave concerts, but porcupine is directly in the next row...^^
My favourite band since early nineties, seen them many times live, soooo good.
goosebumps each time
Epic Reaction!!!
Porcupine Tree - Russia on Ice(90's PT is trippy as hell. In my opinion this is on of their best songs ever)
Porcupine Tree - Blackest Eyes
Steven wilson - Drive Home (one hell of an emotional ride)
Please do all studio versions of these
Love your channel guys!!!
I’d love to see them react to Open Car. Time Flies. But Russia on Ice live is so ridiculous.
Good reaction. You need to see this several times to really appreciate all the things that going on here
What a masterpiece... Love you 🤩💖 ... (9 mins song she said ...lol) 😆😅😘
Looks like these two are having a musical eargasms
just top class musicians in the zone having a fucking good jam
This is great !! Saw them last time in Amsterdam 👍🏻😊
PT will always be my favorite band. I was at this video taping in Chicago. It was over 2 nights and I was there on the 2nd night! Epic!!!
I was at the concert at Tilburg, awesome......
Now at the top of my list of favorite bands, a list I started back in 1970, lol.
Been a fan from almost their beginnings, they never fail to impress. I obtained this dvd that this is on when it was issued, and it is played often. The best sounding live performance ever. ❤️👏👏👏
Thank You!
Next - A cool, funky gem... The Start of Something Beautiful, live from Chicago.
Fantastic performance 👏 👌 🙌 👍 ❤️ 🤟
That moment when you see Gavin make a perfectly pitched trombone drop with his thumb and drum head.?.? Really?
I always had Neil Peart as my favorite drummer ever ... then I saw Gavin Harrison!
@@amazingronaldo9656 Checkout Danny Carey!
@@DuhQuanNigstix Carey is overrated as all hell. Who even recommend him?
@@mrdeathamore Overrated? LMAO... I don't think so!
@@DuhQuanNigstix He is everywhere, on every reaction channel etc, I don't think he needs more attention
So lucky to catch many early tours in small clubs in Seattle. FOABP at the Crocodile Cafe with a capacity of 500 was indescribable standing in front of Steven with essentially no stage. Welcome to the PT family, folks!
Omg im so glad you guys did the live version, gavin is one of the greatest drummers of all time and this song really showcases his creativity and skill
Gavin is an absolute monster on the kit
Gavin Harrison = the best drummer alive on planet Earth !
Marco Minneman?
@@goldenboy140 he’s pretty darn good as well. Different style - he would be a solid #2 for me.
He's very good but that is not true. He doesn't attack the drums like a Bozzio, he's brilliant, but he doesn't do light and shade, only shade.
"Russia on Ice" will blow you away.
Or... Cheating the Polygraph, live from Tilburg. (The video title says Live from Anesthetize)
Quite possibly the quintessential Porcupine Tree live performance.
Saw Porcupine Tree in Chicago on their “The Incident” tour. I was grinning ear to ear to see half the crowd wearing King Crimson shirts and the other wearing TooL shirts. Not sure there could be a better compliment to this band really.
It's been awhile since I've listened to Porcupine Tree. One of the best progressive rock bands out there.
You ever heard any Ozric Tentacles?
Thanks for this video. I was having a really sh1tty day and watching your reaction to this performance really cheered me up!
I love how this song serves as a showcase for each musician. Everybody gets a little freestyle spotlight. 🤘 (Except John Wesley I suppose, but he's got the velvet pipes so he wins by default)
John didn't play on this song live. It was just the 4 piece with the band members :)
@@omairsh8 Isn't that him doing backing vocals and doing the acoustic guitar parts, no?
Love u finally got to this!! Gavin Harrison is Danny Carey's british equivalent!
I don't know why danney has to be brought up every time, these two are completely different. I like having because of the attention to small detail, like the way he plays a ghost note or plays quarter notes on a ride cymbal when most people play 8th notes. All that flashy stuff is cool like a 100 hit rip through the tomms or blast beats on the kick drum all stuff gavin can do but chooses not to for the music. Danny on the other hand is great but I just see him as the best rock drummer ever and nothing more.
Having = Gavin lol
Nobody is Danny's equivalent
ONLY the greatest ROCK drummer ever? WTF is Tabla then? Why does he have another band called VOLTO! that is a jazz fusion band? You definitely don’t know what you’re talking about.
Interesting, I never knew he was in another group. At the end of the day, I find Porcupine Trees music to be better and I have a feeling these people think so too. Tool is boring to me for the most part, lateralus was good for what it was an 8/10 a little long. The last disc felt like they were trying too hard. The title track off fear inoculum builds up and nothing happens lol. Tool just feel uninspiring to me. Like they get together get all high and never finish lol.
Thx a lots Both !!!
Take care & salute from France...
I love watching and hearing PT for the first time 😊❤️
The guitar solo and Gavin Harrison's drum performance was what made me as a teenager realize that this band was special and unlike anything Ive heard before.
Live- Octane Twisted/The Seance/Circle of Manias concept suite. It's mindblowing.
Single songs live from Tilburg
-Fear of a Blank Planet
-Strip The Soul
-Cheating The Polygraph
Live from Chicago- Halo, Don't Hate Me, Open Car
At first you think it would be Colin's song, but by the end you realize it's Gavin's.
Colin never got the credit he deserved
Each member has their part but Richard and Collin are more the glue in the song. Steven tries to steal the show but there is no stopping Gavin
it's actually Chris' song, but Gavin really pushes it to next level
It seems it's always Gavin's somehow haha. The man is such a master. The most creative and musical fills I've ever heard.
P
Next live suggestion for Porcupine Tree - "FEAR OF A BLANK PLANET". Period.
Such an under-rated band and such an under-rated guitarist.
love you guys!
Just bought tickets to see them in Sept.
I would say that you should react to Luminol by Steven Wilson live, amazing performance
Marco Minneman
this is so me taking my convertible top down, parking under a tree, turning up this song and easing my seat back during my lunch hour.
Please Please do PT “Normal” Live from Tilburg!!!!! It’s one of the tracks after Anesthetize, which you guys loved, and is according to SW the hardest song to play.
The drummer is phenomenal
I was at this show aswell! Park west in Chicago over 2 nights. Magical! Put the band back together Steven!
Loved your reaction. One of the most incredible live performances I've ever seen. All 4 band members are frickin' virtuosos, but Gavin Harrison really shines on this one
Another brilliant reaction, you guys probably do this the best, thanks a million for reacting to this one, really showcases every member of the band. Where do you go next with PT? Easy - Dark Matter (live) or sleep together (live) , cheers guys - keep rocking.
Steven Wilson - Home Invasion/Regret #9 live in Los Angeles (Yahoo concert)
Shes got her groove on
He looks like a bobble head!!!
Wonderful stuff- being a progressive rock fan since the late 1960's, I thought nothing much could motivate me as we got into the 80's, until I started listening to Steven Wilsons music in the early 90's- being an avid vinyl collector I also appreciated that he never gave up on the format and I now have most of the LP's he produced especially Porcupine Tree, Bass Communion and Blackfield plus of course his later music published using his own name. Porcupine Tree takes the biscuit though as the music was fabulous, the albums were prolific and so much of it was outstanding.
I was waiting for this, oooooh boy
Wow I'm fucking tripping. You and your lovely wife digging Porcupine Tree!!!!
You should try Gavin's most recent band : Pinneapple Thief. Try "Final thing on my mind", the live version is on TH-cam
I love The Pineapple Thief. Discovered them recently and can't get enough of them. "Tear you up " is amazing too, but they have so many great songs. They deserve much more attention
@@gabriellacsarsen7814 True, but they are nowhere near Porcupine Tree, Pretty damn good though.
Opeth and Porcupine Tree, gotta love it
Vektor- Recharging The Void
The Ocean - Jurassic | Cretaceous
Porcupine Tree - Trains
Trains must be live from Chicago
Great song, fun reaction. The drumming in this one is outstanding.
Maybe you try wintersun sometimes?
Another great band.
DO NOT sleep on Steven Wilson...he has been at this for 35 years!!
mother and child divided, live... you wont regret
good suggestion
"Fear Of A Blank Planet"
The progressive guys. Nice music taste
The funk is strong in this one
Porcupine Tree - Trains
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY
FIRE
Have to do PTree Blackest Eyes, Live … Also HALO is special…yes, Gavin plays around in 17/16
King's X
2:30 Se la pela Gavin Harrison con esos grooves.
Steven Wilson: Drive Home, and Luminol are both really good. both are different. Luminol is kinda Jazzy, and Drive Home is a Complete Emotional Trip. By the way, if you're doing Drive Home, do the Video. the Storytelling is insane, and makes the Music 1000% MORE Impactful. Luminol should be the Studio Version this time.
Drive Home and Luminol are Steven Wilson solo songs. Please edit your comment.
I first heard (I think heard, maybe saw) this song as the live version and this live version is certainly the quintessential version of this song, you guys are right.
Steven Wilson, Luminol, live in Mexico city...a must
good one! live in tilburg. even better.
Cool song.. you should check out Ne Obliviscaris - As Icicles Fall
What Happens Now Live in Tilburg by PT. You will enjoy that a lot. Another choice is Time flies live.
Great reaction guys. Lovin it. Lovin Porcupine Tree. I'd love to see your reaction to Slave by Leprous live at Rockefellas Pleaasseeee
I wonder how would you react to their highly underestimated album The Incident. It is their last album together from 2009. The song The Blind House is really captivating
Porcupine Tree - Cheating the Polygraph (LIVE) next please :)
You must react to Steven Wilson solo group more. (The lead singer of porcupine) Home invasion and drive home.
Gavin Harrison is more than a God. The man is a Titan.
Dream Theater - Stream of Consciousness live at Budokan... prepare for face meltage!
Loving the amounts of PT and Opeth.
Please get some Wintersun on the to-do list. Time or Sons of Winter and Stars.
More PT guys 😀
I would say you picked the right version of this to watch, not just to see it being performed, but also because the studio version is a completely different sounding track, much more basic and without all the crazy technical musicianship. It's still good, but this is definitely the definitive version as it combines the main song with an impressive jam performance.
Power Trip - Divine Apprehension
Power Trip - Hornet’s Nest
Power Trip - Crucifixation
Amon Amarth - War of the Gods
Amon Amarth - Free Will Sacrifice
Amon Amarth - Valhall Awaits Me
Check out DON'T HATE ME from the same concert
Porcupine Tree, are fantastic live. They are probably one of the best live bands ever. Steven Wilson is, also one of the best, producers ever. With that said, he would be the 1st to admit, he couldn't recreate, his studio production live. Everyone should marvel, at how close P.T. come to reproducing their albums. With that said, you cannot truly appreciate, one of their tracks, live. It's like viewing a George Lucas story board, or a Looney Toons still panel. You can appreciate it. But it as part, not a whole.
The only group that comes anywhere close to PT are Riverside. Great song from an album I love, somewhat underrated by PT fans.
How about that tom rim roll?! So freaking good.
Set your reminder for the new Spiritbox song, "Circle With Me". It premieres in 20 hours.
😍🤘😝
Gavin Harrison is a fucking god
Also check out 'strip the soul/.3" live of course...
imagine how in trance that bass player has to be
Porcupine Tree:
Normal
Trains
Remember Me Lover
Have been waiting for the two of you to do this PT track. Off camera check out "moonloop" on the utube also "metatonia". You rock!
Karnivool - New Day and Deadman. You'll love them.
For a change of pace, 'Halflight' live in Tilburg is good. Mind you, any song you care to pick from that concert is astounding.
Sleeeepy song
Step up to Steven Wilson Luminol live. Routine with Nanet. You’ll be blown apart. Great reactions guys. Thx
Check. Open Car (live) by porcupine tree!!!
Karnivool - New Day live
I prefer the studio version in Lightbulb Sun