they are a calm in the sea of ambitions..gentleman singers who have stayed together. they espouse so many virtues that we need to hold close to ourselves in these times of despair. in their concert their shared values of mutual respect towards each other, their love for singing and their gift to make people smile comes out very naturally. thanks for sharing
I had ended an engagement and ppl I thought were best friends were not there. I bought 2 tickets to lower bowl to this concert and had to end up going by myself paying for both tickets. I didn’t know if I wanted to take the 4 hour road trip to go because I couldn’t afford it at the time, and I didn’t want to see the show by myself. I took the courage the see it for myself. To Bono, Edge, and the rest of the band and crew, you saved my soul. Thank you.
true. roundhey Park Leeds pop mart tour 1997 with or without you disco ball lights slowly spinning around a field with thousands of people in it and I'll never forget it.
Never a day without U2 music.They rythm my life since their begining.Thanks U2. U2 is MY LIFE, U2 for ever !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! someone that can sing like this at 57....well done still amazing band...age comes to us all....
I’m a big U2 fan, and honestly this has to be the worse performance / version of the song. If you want to listen to a great live performance of this song in their prime then listen to the version they sung live at Slane Castle.
Went to 360 concert in Sydney.. met all of them 3times.. BONO is such a gentle kind loving Guy.. very personal meeting with him, and something I'll never forget... He still has My texter asking Can he keep it. To sign other Fans.. ❤️❤️❤️
See the stone set in your eyes See the thorn twist in your side I'll wait for you Sleight of hand and twist of fate On a bed of nails, she makes me wait And I wait without you With or without you With or without you Through the storm, we reach the shore You give it all but I want more And I'm waiting for you With or without you With or without you, ah, ah I can't live With or without you And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away My hands are tied My body bruised, she got me with Nothing to win and Nothing left to lose And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away With or without you With or without you, oh I can't live With or without you Oh, oh Oh, oh With or without you With or without you, oh I can't live With or without you With or without you
Люблю Боно и его голос. Эта любовь началась с этой песни и еще с одной. Береги себя - и знай, что есть человек на этой земле, который без ума от тебя и твоих песен! Ооо! Как это прекрасно!
Esta é a música da minha vida. Ouvi pela primeira vez em 88 eu acho e mesmo sem saber como eram, me apaixonei pela música e pelo Bono. Não sei que ano q consegui ver eles pela primeira vez, mas chorei tanto tanto, que meu rosto ficou inchado. A partir daí, eu só me apaixonei a cada dia mais pela banda e pelo que o Bono faz pelas pessoas tão carentes, não só de alimentação, mas remédios, atenção, respeito, compaixão, carinho e amor. Que o Bono juntamente com a banda tem de sobra. Eu os amo eternamente ☝✌🌟⭐⭐⭐💫🙏🙌👐👐👐👐
Que história linda a sua.. imagino a emoção...tbm amo demais essa banda essa música em especial eu era garoto meu irmão ouvia U2 mas eu nem conhecia quem se tratava,foi amor a primeira ouvida rss....desde lá até hoje sempre ouço essa banda espetacular,sem igual esses caras são gênios,e o Bono realmente é um ser humano fantástico, formidável demais,ele e os outros ajudam muita gente mesmo,tem projetos sócias muito bacana, é louvável demais isso..... abraço ✌🏽✌🏽✌🏽😘
Best present I ever received was 5th row Joshua Tree concert in Philly on my birthday. “Live” mind you the best damn version I ever heard !!!! “Live” TurboJimbo
You almost remind me of that "preacher man" in Grapes of Wrath...hopefully your own "fate" will turn out much better, and will try to remember you in prayer, along with all my other many "issues"(LOL)...but maybe if you subscribe to my channel that will help to remind me about it? Not that i'm anything special, just have a bad memory sometimes...
Porque cuando te fuiste solo me quedo la música, no hay un día que no te recuerde y quizá no te superé nunca, me duele no saber de ti a la distancia 🖤🤘☮️
U2 is simple one of the greatest bands of all time, right up there with Led Zeppilin. Although I've never caught a live performance of Led Zeppilin, I've seen U2 4 times. 😜👍👍
![U2 Bad (360° Live From Rome) [Multicam 1080p By Mek with U22's Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LEzIV1Lc-cQ/mqdefault.jpg)
2,000,000- views! Thanks all!!!
they are a calm in the sea of ambitions..gentleman singers who have stayed together. they espouse so many virtues that we need to hold close to ourselves in these times of despair. in their concert their shared values of mutual respect towards each other, their love for singing and their gift to make people smile comes out very naturally. thanks for sharing
@@pashbags love bless
Ñpñññp
Thank u!
💙💙
My number 1 favourite song. Finding all the live versions of it on here is like a drug. I need more. Each one unique and brilliant.
have you found the "Love Town" version from Dublin in 1989. Its also up there.
This one for me is not only my fav u2 tune but best version gives you goosebumps 👏
same!
amen to that feeling mate, I know EXACTLY where you're coming from
that's exactly what I feel, nice to know someone experience it too
For me, the best song ever written. Timeless and brilliant.
Check out their 1997 live performance of One here, on YT. there's something resembling coronavirus on the screens in the background 🤯
I AGREE
@@marlenesullivan3113 Thanks Marlene.Hope you are well.
Best song ever written
I agree and would add that this is the best version of the best song ever written. Love that the Edge’s guitar is showcased.
I had ended an engagement and ppl I thought were best friends were not there. I bought 2 tickets to lower bowl to this concert and had to end up going by myself paying for both tickets.
I didn’t know if I wanted to take the 4 hour road trip to go because I couldn’t afford it at the time, and I didn’t want to see the show by myself.
I took the courage the see it for myself.
To Bono, Edge, and the rest of the band and crew, you saved my soul. Thank you.
T±@ sr1+q¹¹
This band has carried me through a lot of hard times in my life
I would agree 101%
same here, amazing band
true. roundhey Park Leeds pop mart tour 1997 with or without you disco ball lights slowly spinning around a field with thousands of people in it and I'll never forget it.
Yes Sir,,,me too
This band has made me a more positive person
The only way to listen the best version of this masterpiece is waiting for another U2 version. No one can sing this song better than them.
This band has put together one of the greatest catalogs of music in history
Never a day without U2 music.They rythm my life since their begining.Thanks U2.
Same here Sylvie xoxo
Never a day without U2 music.They rythm my life since their begining.Thanks U2.
U2 is MY LIFE, U2 for ever !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
someone that can sing like this at 57....well done still amazing band...age comes to us all....
I could listen to this song on repeat for eternity. The end instrumental especially... In fact, I imagine this is what Heaven sounds like.
Lets hope so
this is what Heaven sounds like
This is hands down the best performance of this song that I’ve seen .. amazing quality , thanks for sharing
I’m a big U2 fan, and honestly this has to be the worse performance / version of the song. If you want to listen to a great live performance of this song in their prime then listen to the version they sung live at Slane Castle.
This is a good one but this version from their Boston 2001 show is my fav.
th-cam.com/video/_Ye8GLPUVsM/w-d-xo.html
Milan 2005.
This audio is amazing, every time listen to it find more powerful notes in Adam's bass.
WOWW INCREDIBLE MUSIC..I ADORE THIS SONG.
ci sono canzoni che rimangono eterne, questa è una di quelle!. fantastica
I can lissen this amazing song every day....
Went to 360 concert in Sydney.. met all of them 3times.. BONO is such a gentle kind loving Guy.. very personal meeting with him, and something I'll never forget... He still has My texter asking Can he keep it. To sign other Fans.. ❤️❤️❤️
Favorite band uplifting to see live.
The edge smooth guitar ! Fantastic ! Best live performance ever ofthis song!
U2 es incomparable, estan a otro nivel musical. Gracias por tantos años de canciones inolvidables!
Amo ouvi u-2
La banda más grande del mundo!! ❤️
See the stone set in your eyes
See the thorn twist in your side
I'll wait for you
Sleight of hand and twist of fate
On a bed of nails, she makes me wait
And I wait without you
With or without you
With or without you
Through the storm, we reach the shore
You give it all but I want more
And I'm waiting for you
With or without you
With or without you, ah, ah
I can't live
With or without you
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
My hands are tied
My body bruised, she got me with
Nothing to win and
Nothing left to lose
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
With or without you
With or without you, oh
I can't live
With or without you
Oh, oh
Oh, oh
With or without you
With or without you, oh
I can't live
With or without you
With or without you
I am so proud of them to being in Sarajevo... My Sarajevo. Thanks B. ❤️👍
This song brings me always back to ground. Wonderful 💗💗💗
Excellent video and version, U2 at its best.
Easily the best band on the planet.
Incredible tour . Their best I think . Everything about it .
Люблю Боно и его голос. Эта любовь началась с этой песни и еще с одной. Береги себя - и знай, что есть человек на этой земле, который без ума от тебя и твоих песен! Ооо! Как это прекрасно!
Не гони...
Esta é a música da minha vida. Ouvi pela primeira vez em 88 eu acho e mesmo sem saber como eram, me apaixonei pela música e pelo Bono. Não sei que ano q consegui ver eles pela primeira vez, mas chorei tanto tanto, que meu rosto ficou inchado. A partir daí, eu só me apaixonei a cada dia mais pela banda e pelo que o Bono faz pelas pessoas tão carentes, não só de alimentação, mas remédios, atenção, respeito, compaixão, carinho e amor. Que o Bono juntamente com a banda tem de sobra. Eu os amo eternamente ☝✌🌟⭐⭐⭐💫🙏🙌👐👐👐👐
Que história linda a sua.. imagino a emoção...tbm amo demais essa banda essa música em especial eu era garoto meu irmão ouvia U2 mas eu nem conhecia quem se tratava,foi amor a primeira ouvida rss....desde lá até hoje sempre ouço essa banda espetacular,sem igual esses caras são gênios,e o Bono realmente é um ser humano fantástico, formidável demais,ele e os outros ajudam muita gente mesmo,tem projetos sócias muito bacana, é louvável demais isso..... abraço ✌🏽✌🏽✌🏽😘
@Bom gc... muito obrigado pelo carinho na sua resposta!!! Um abraço a você também 😘❤️✌🏽✌🏽🙏🏽🙌🏽 Feliz 2022
This is an awesome version..the audio is magnificent..thank you for uploading it..my favourite band U2
I remember watching this show very vividly. 12 years later I am still in awe at how awesome it was. Hundreds of concerts later still top 5!
This is a fantastic version. The piano definitely adds a lot and Edge's crystalline delays are beautiful.
You all act like it was never in the original recording
Edge used an infinite guitar on the Joshua tree recording, which sounds like a keyboard.
@@gandalfthegrey8236 but, the piano wasn't on the original version!!!!! C'mon
@@gandalfthegrey8236 This version is on a whole other level. Sorry you can't hear that.
@@bassnbrim He has a point the piano is on the original, but not at the start.
Probably one of the most beautiful live versions of With or Without out.
Best present I ever received was 5th row Joshua Tree concert in Philly on my birthday. “Live” mind you the best damn version I ever heard !!!! “Live”
TurboJimbo
You are absolutely right, IT IS a fantastic version... watching it again and again...
Fantastic concert U2 thank you.
Love this performance, love when they put a spin on their songs!! 💚
The drum and the guitar sound are sooo good...
I love U2 from Italy 🇮🇹🎼🎶🎵❤️❤️👏👏👏😎👍👋
U2 is from Ireland, not Italy. Check their bio for yourself to see where that is.
beautiful beautiful beautiful song
I love this song
Best band of all time. It's great!
U2 only i have to Say a Word....
Amazing!!!!!
Fantastique ! Les anciens morceaux me font toujours autant vibrer voir plus même U2 you are ma Cam ❤
Magnifique magnifique magique grandiose.. Frissons en l'écoutant merci U2. Voix et musique sublissime
@@helenegigli7056 😉🤩😎
4:22 the guitar solo here gets me every single time. beautiful
Thea Tingstad Quem sabe
Blz
Thea Tingstad If only the album version was longer on the outro.
That's not a guitar solo
The Edge classifies it as the opposite of a solo!
EVERY TIME...I HEAR THIS SONG..IT FEELS ..AS IT I NEVER HEARD BEFORE..!! AND MAKES ME CRY!! BRAVO U2 FOR GIVING US SONGS LIKE THIS..THANKS!!
TEMASO BONO !!! UNA BANDA IMPRESIONANTE U2!!! GRACIAS 🎼🎵🎶🌍👑🎼🎵🎶🎼🎵🎶🌍🇦🇷🎼🎵🎶🌍🎼🎵🎶🎼🎵🎶👑🌍🎶🎵
Absolutely love that tune, and larrys drumming
No ano de 1999 ouvindo essa musica comecei a namorar uma menina e hoje ja faz 21 anos juntos e casados curtindo U2. ESSA MÚSICA É LINDA...
Você ouvirá essa música mais de uma vez e nunca cansará disso...
Sounds great u2 still one of the best bands in the world 😎🇬🇧
Are you trying to troll? They are certainty not british 🇮🇪☘
@@ronandonnelly1 Obviously he is referencing his home country dumbass with the British flag
The Edge's guitar playing for this live performance is outstanding.
U2 a melhor banda do mundo amoooooo
Seen them 3 times. Every time an adventure in joy.:)
Fantastic !!
Yes i love it , one of the best . The Band ist so wow .
How in the world did someone manage to get an audio of this performance so well-mixed? I'd have thought it'd have all sorts of distortions, etc.
Pure Music! Where memories exists and No one Grows Old👏👏
U2 is the best Rock Band Hall of Time 🇧🇷
Such a beautifully romantic song
Beautiful
One of the best hit of U2 songs.
BEST SONG EVER,YOU GIVE ME CHILLS&MORE CHILLS.😎🎸🎸😀
For me, this Song is the best in history.
Для меня эта самая любимая песня! Боно лучший!
U2 fantastic band.......my love forever
Es un genio total /// mi vida escuchándolo !!! cuántos recuerdos sus canciones , simplemente gracias x poder escuchar x siempre tu música
Omg! Thank you I don’t know how I came across your channel but I love JUST LIVE MUSIC TOO!! Match made in heaven!
The best song ever written x
Man im loving the piano at the start
Epic. This makes me believe in Beauty. Thank you.
someone that can sing like this at 57....well done still amazing band...age comes to us all....
Yeah well Mick jagger is in his 80s and still singing and rocking his ass off
Edward Marshall guess how old Joseph Williams of TOTO is. .
Bono was 51 in this video
...merci...the experiance...to live...with or...without your...love...xxxkarin
The edge absolutely on 🔥 here
Espetacular ... Um dos maiores do infinito espaço temporal ...👏🏻👏🏻
The drumming is so underrated in this track.
Who is under rating it?
@@danieljoeoconnor Well, it never gets any praise, thought that was kinda obvious.
Love 😍 any versions of this song 🌟 🎤 🎸 🇬🇧 💯 🎹
son los mas grandes !!!!! amo a u2 ,aqui de argentina 2020
This song is incredible ! U2 is the best band actually.
Most definitely. Always has been, Always will be ❤🥰
Amazing
Aria,acqua,terra,fuoco.......batteria,basso elettrico,chitarra elettrica,voce......semplicemente gli U2.
Best band on the planet. This song might just save my life, or lead me towards ending it all for good. The balance is so fragile... 💔 ;
You almost remind me of that "preacher man" in Grapes of Wrath...hopefully your own "fate" will turn out much better, and will try to remember you in prayer, along with all my other many "issues"(LOL)...but maybe if you subscribe to my channel that will help to remind me about it? Not that i'm anything special, just have a bad memory sometimes...
The darkness never lasts for ever my brother. Stay on your feet, you got this :)
Protosser Thank you, still here and fighting this every day.
Porque cuando te fuiste solo me quedo la música, no hay un día que no te recuerde y quizá no te superé nunca, me duele no saber de ti a la distancia 🖤🤘☮️
Fantastic
Magnifica version,para mi de las mejores.
Sorry paper dolling , but is there a version of this masterpiece that is not fantastic??? Pure Magic every time!!!
The greatest perfomance ever !!!
Great video - thanks. Saw this a few months later in MN, in the pouring rain.
Hermosa composicion de U2...
Super ....nunca pasaran de moda.
One of the Best Bands EVER!
Fantastica.
Ich liebe dieses Lied
Alte Erinnerungen.....
So schön für immer Bono!
1980 bis heute
Anyone here in 2025? I am visiting from the future, with or without you.
Love the piano in the beginning! ❤️
It would be even more beautiful without this Bono dead-walking Voice...;)
It's just the in-ear beat track. It allows bono to get the right tune. Also used in the Joshua tree Tour
( ´◉ω◉` )σ！！
Soy yo por todos lados, es la canción de mi vida y las melodías y tonos de Bono imposible de describir la energía que trasmiten ❤
Thanks U2, from the Music to You .. thank you very much 😘😘💙🤍
U2 супер Рок группа всех времён. Британия рулит ❤
U2❤ MASTERPIECE!!!!!!!!!✌✌🎸🎙
Essa banda sim a melhor de todas desde qui a música existe inconfundível a melhor 2019
Concordo estes caras são de mais
One of the best Songs ever....
The best U2 !!
Please keep going u2 never stop bravo
Esencial. U2. Fantástico. Mágica. Irlanda por. Semper. ❤👍✌️
U2 is simple one of the greatest bands of all time, right up there with Led Zeppilin.
Although I've never caught a live performance of Led Zeppilin, I've seen U2
4 times. 😜👍👍
Bono simplesmente o melhor d todos os tempos
The edge is a best ! What a performance guitar ! Incredible wow