#Failed
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ค. 2024
- Adam Elmasri on Linktree (all links): linktr.ee/adamelmasri
The original video I made about the 3 historical errors in the Quran, which @syfetalk made a response to:
• Top 3 Historical error...
The Apologetics reponse video of SYFEtalk Which I'm responding to here is:
• EX-CHRISTIAN CLAIMS HE...
Adam Elmasri - Social links:
Official Website: www.adamelmasri.online
Patreon: / adamelmasri
Facebook Page: / youtuber.adam.elmasri
Facebook personal: / adam.elmasri.official
Instagram: / freethinker_adamelmasri
Twitter\X : / adamelmasri_ad
PayPal: adamelba7eth@gmail.com
Shouting makes it true - Islamist
You mean speaking quietly like Adam who makes numerous blunders about Islam.
A logical walk through his bizarre narration disproves everything he says. Anyone who agrees with him must be mesmerized by his strident monotone as well as being unacquainted with historical science and logic.
@@keksi6844 the Samaritan didn't exist until way after the Babylon captivity
@@keksi6844 "Allah closed my ears to this video alhamdulillah"
🤣🤣🤣
Youre one the few youtubers speaking facts without involving emotional biases
I appreciate that … thanks!
Could you give some examples of emotional biases? If you mean that it is fallacious to argue that Islam is false because one doesn't like it, you're right. If you mean that it is fallacious to say that Islam is false because it gets moral facts wrong, then, at least for moral realists (like myself), you're wrong. It is valid to argue that the claims that God is perfectly good and that he approves of something like slavery are self-contradictory.
Most islamic apologist don't know the difference between a commentary , an observation , refuting, debunking , proving wrong, or proving right, and fact checking .
Most lack Critical thinking ability, and its unfortunate you have to reply!
Is it morally "real" to have s€x with a nine year old girl? Please share your knowledge.
You opined, _"Youre one the few youtubers speaking facts without involving emotional biases."_
Did you watch the start of his video when he described him growing up?
After listening to his tale of woe as achild, wouldn't you conclude that Adam almasry filled with *emotional biases?*
Which is the opposite of your _'biased characterization of him!"_
_peace to the world_
Without lies islam dies
All religion does without deception.
@@AmmonRa-wm5kcwhat deception is in the bible 😅
@@albusai - The deception I was referring to is mainly church leaders. They don't tell the whole truth. There are tons of atrocities in the Bible commanded by Jesus / God that people try and hide, there are many internal contradictions as well. Two simple examples are Numbers 31 where God / Jesus commands the killing of all moms, pregnant or not, men, boys, and just keep the virgin women for yourselves. One of many conflicts is read Matthew 1 and Luke 3 and answer who was Joseph's father and grandfather? The two accounts do not agree with each other. The Quran and Bible are full of mistakes, contradictions and immorality.
@@AmmonRa-wm5kcclown man
That muhammad is rasool ul Shaytan allah@@albusai
The guy's voice is annoying 😒 and he seems so confident in his delusions of isssslllllaaaammm.
I feell like slapping that guy when he speaks he's too cringe😂 and lies yoo
Add to that his broken accent and how many times he must repeat "peace be among him" "al7amdulillah" 😂
The islamic guy sounds angry. Adam you are calm and explain things very well. I wish you much success in improving the world.
The response of Mohammed to a clear cut error showed that he knew he had goofed and rendered all his claims invalid. How many other cases could he mention where someone could be called the sister of someone who lived one thousand years before as a honour. He was simply trying to save his face.
That sister argument is already have been answered many times. Sister of Aaron is form of metaphore that is pretty common for middle-eastern languages, just like Children of Israel when you refer to jews (not literal children of Israel/Jacob), or Sons of Adam (not literally again, just descendants).
@@ogureckartophanov3283 this a false statement. Two different Mary's as sister of Aron? Then what of daughter of Imron, is that a honour too? Why is the mother of Jesus called the daughter of Aron who has a daughter called Mary? I know Mohammed was cornered and could not find an escape other than lie.
@@draconian8994 yeah, two honorable titles
@@ogureckartophanov3283 They are shameful errors, no more.
@@draconian8994 no it is not
I can’t believe how you watched his bullsh*t so peacefully, Mr. Adam. As well as his nerve-racking voice.
Bravo Adam
❤️❤️❤️
Holy shit my ears. The audio on your videos so far has been a little quiet, though it's gotten better, but this guy is just straight up yelling. I have never seen such a perfect example of "speaking in all caps".
😆
You know I was asking for this 😊
You did. I listened 😊
It’s like talking to a brick wall.
Great video. I love to hear your perspective as an arabic speaker talking about Islam, there is so much value in that. I dont speak arabic but I am an exmuslim and I am always accused of having left islam just because I dont speak arabic. Being validated by arabic speakers is therefore very comforting :)
Even the translations themselves debunk Islam. If even the Arabic scholars can't translate the quaran properly, and we have to be a native Arabic speaker in order to understand the quaran, then Allah failed to make it clear, like it says it's designed to do. So that debunks the quaran based on that fact.
Yeah it’s crazy islam is open to converting as many as possible without full understanding of Islam or Arabic
The translations seem to cover over mistakes in the Quran, so if you knew Arabic you'd be more likely to leave. Odd there, Mohammed's worst comments on the Torah is that they were covering over things (not corrupting it, but being selective), yet their translations do the same thing. One can see Arab christians and atheists show these errors - eg 33.56 Allah and the angels pray for Mohammed, is frequently mistranslated, as Allah should not be praying since He's God alone, it would work for a Trinity God or a pantheon idea.
You read the quran, you become muslim. When you understand the quran, you become ex-muslim.
I didn't need to read much to figure out that Islam is false.
@@Nexus-jg7evbecause your brain is behind your Ar..e
@@zarabees2123 The irony of your statement - for significant periods of time the Muslims ar..s is higher than his brain. Think about it!
just looking at their ways tells me its evil. "you will know them by their fruits".
Do you think you are smart?!! Really?!!
ياريت تتكلم عن حرق بيوت المسيحين فى المنيا زى ما حضرتك اتكلمت عن غزة
also according to the bible, jesus christ (and thus mary) were direct descendants of king david, of the tribe of judah, and not descendants of Moses or his direct family, whom were of the tribe of levi, thus saying that mary was a “descendant” of aaron or imran would also be inaccurate, i might be wrong tho
You are correct.
Nice videos. 👍
Thanks 👍
@@AdamElmasriEnglish you did great justice to this muslim miskeen.
His voice and style of presentation is so irritating it's difficult to listen to him shouting angrily.
I guess the Muslim dawah prefers loud and bold faced liars.
Keep up the good work exposing Islam for humanity's sake!
That guy is just a blabber-mouth who does not know what he is saying. Always letting his emotions lead him
Islam like other religions is a faith. The word faith is the 2nd most frequent word in the Qur'an. What is faith? Faith is to accept things as true without verifiable evidence. If you have verifiable evidence that something is a fact you don't need faith.
The Qur'an, like other religious scriptures, does not prove it is from God. Rather, the Qur'an makes a claim that it is from God and then asks you to disprove its claim. This is called shifting the burden of proof upon the denier. In the real world when you make a claim you are supposed to prove your claim not demand that others disprove your claim.
Teaching Zakir Naik: Angels Prove Jesus Is God th-cam.com/video/Akr-QBDO9v8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=2QrsxFfekMVbct4v via @TH-cam
Exactly.
You say with certainty that the Quran doesnt give proof it is from Allah??
@@karimmoorad9649 There is no proof. You are starting from the assumption that it is and demanding proof that it isn't.
@@dragonade85 what I am saying is that the Quran itself is the proof. The style of writing, the content, its effect on millions of people's hearts, the fact that it addresses all issues across different aspects of human life, the person whom it was given to, his character and so many other reasons, make it a miraculous book which can only be from the one who made us. You are speaking from a point of view of someone who hasnt read the book and lived it. Because its one thing to read the english translation of a deep language such as arabic and then claim to know the meaning, and actually living the book. I invite you to learn how to read the quran, without learning arabic, then see for yourself.
Ps. English is not my mothet tongue so forgive any errors here lol
Poor guy's clearly outmatched. I hope he'll watch this video so he can learn not to pick up fights he cannot win, and learn how to think for himself instead of blindly triggering the "defend the Quran" mode in his brain.
Quality content. Thank you, Adam. ❤
The Bedouins will say "it's refuted" without even watching the video.
I like the cancer analogy 👍👍👍
Momins don’t even have their own lies , they copy pasted whole apologetica of Christians after copy pasting Religion.
You're very knowledgeable ❤❤
Great going, Adam. By the way, could you please make a video on the simple math fail in Islamic inheritance law (Surah 4.11-4.12)? I have recently made a video on this topic but you can reach a much wider audience.
Good idea!
That Syfe is refuting everyone who brings out the truth of the errors and contradictions in the quran. You are the first I came across now to refute this guy. Kudos to you.
*You're the guy who is always right, who never retracts, never applies self-criticism to his own beliefs* !!!
Only Muslims are invited to practice self-criticism!!!
Very logically explained by Mr. Adam and very pleasant tone. God bless you.
God give you and your channel God's love and many good things to come 🙏🏽
تحياتي اليك اخي ادم من لاديني
you may need to make an illustration with drawings and clear words so they find less space to maneuver and manipulate. Great video:)
I really appreciate this guys approach and ability to be respectful and critical at the same time.
Some Christian apologist can learn from him
Never read the quran I don't want to waste my time on a nonsense book however this story about Pharoah building a tower sounds like a confusion including the story of the tower of Babel.
"For us, muslims, it dosen't matter what historians are claming... what allah says in the Qur'an is the absolute truth"...
That says it all : they don't care about reality . Allah is right, always, since they want to believe that.
Ants can talk and knew Suleiman : entomologists are wrong.
Hearts think and believe : transplants are wrong.
Earth is flat, and the sun goes through a muddy hole to prostrate in front of Allah ; satelites are wrong.
Truth is wrong if Qur'an says so.
Well said🎉🎉🎉🎉
Ok, I understand talking ants point, because it's a miracle, an impossible thing to be happen, fully-rational human would never believe in that.
But flat earth and sun setting in muddy water are wrong claims.
Havn't you heard that every nignt , the sun goes and prostrates in front of the throne of Allah to ask for the permission to raise again ? One day, A llah will tell him to go the other way.
@@frankehlig1856 bring evidences
@@ogureckartophanov3283 sahih bukhari 4802 :
Once I was with the Prophet (ﷺ) in the mosque at the time of sunset. The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "O Abu Dharr! Do you know where the sun sets?" I replied, "Allah and His Apostle know best." He said, "It goes and prostrates underneath (Allah's) Throne; and that is Allah's Statement:-- 'And the sun runs on its fixed course for a term (decreed). And that is the decree of All-Mighty, the All-Knowing....'
Mr. Adam, would you like to unveil about "alaqah" , a clot of blood blood. Can the "has been differentiated cell" like a clot of blood become another cell, for example it become a brain cell, a bone cell or a kidney cell medically without any genetic engineering ?
Thank you sl mashrii
His entire adjustment is falesius
Typical apologist, talking endless monologs without facts and condescending sneers.
Not even talking endless monologues. Shouting them!
Damn his voice is really irritating
When you start to lose your argument, strt shouting "allahuakbaal". You'll win. - moslems
It stings them, you know, and that's very good and encouraging. They have reason and conscience like the rest of humanity, but they have also been bribed and corrupted by Islam. It'll be a long fight. Thanks for the video Adam, please stay strong man.
Thanks, Adam
He's just blabbing out illogicality.😂
Bragging and chest thumping without essence are truly the hallmarks of muslim apologists
Adam, this video is awesome, these are powerful points, going to start doing some reading on these arguments you’ve made now, thank you for sharing your vital knowledge on this subject!
Appreciated 🙏
حلقه عظيمه اخ أدم ❤❤
12:13 It's like referring to "Christopher Columbus, the American"
Adam, please make a video about Hijri in connection with 9 : 36-37
Seems someone in 7th century didnt know about earth's revolution and the effect of 11days deficit to the calculation of seasons.
This atheist kept repeating you are assuming you are making assumption while he assume the guy does not know arabic. He is from an Arab country called Morocco so he speaks Arabic
The guy is very smart according to his gullible followers
The daughter of someone vs "of the daughters of" gives it a completely different meaning. He proved himself wrong in the english because he also isnt a nstuve english speaker.
I thought Mary was from the tribe of Judah and not Levi.
If true then she is no daughter of Aaron, who was a Levite...
thanks
lol that kid just made another mistake referring to marry peacebe upon him instead of saying peace be upon her 😂. Without lies Islam dies
He would have to admit that a female was a prophetess!
@@ImCarolB 😆🤣
@Stayawayfromislam2
Trans friendly muslim 🤔
Great
Samaria founded around 880 BC. Well after Moses.
🌹🌹🌹🌹
This was inadvertently quite funny. The way you keep your calm listening to these Dalek-style rants of righteousness is beyond me.
Adam! I would love to see you talk on the line with Matt Dillahunty or the atheist experience!
I had one or two episodes on the atheist experience. I don’t think Matt does it anymore!
@@AdamElmasriEnglish aha I haven’t seen those! Will look at it! Heb switched to the Line I see him there every week🙌🏽
His is the biggest cry baby online. Islam has to be exposed for what it really is ex Sunni
don't worry, Syfe won't respond to any of that, he loves to clickbait his low quality content and it seems like his audience loves it too
Hope you live a good life ❤
Mary daughter of Amara was a levite from the tribe of levy while Mary Mother of Jesus is from Juda’s tribe
❤
Hello sir, nice video and nice responds...
Do you have the studies of Abraham's father?
In islam it say it is Azar, while in the bible its Terah....
Ofc Islam is wrong. They took biblical stories and corrupted the details. Details that have nothing to do with Muhammad and which no jew or christian would deem worthy of corruption.
05:08
13:42
24:56
conclusion
36:12-37:01 😊
please make a video on flat earth in quran and hadith
theres no flat earth in quran its says spread out there is no quran scientific mistake
.... 😂😂😂 this so called argument is refuted thounsand times....
debunked thousands of times
He actually claims to read both Arabic and Hebrew. I had the audacity to tell him once, about his poor English. Then he informed me that he also speaks French. He's Moroccan btw, don't they speak Arabic?
Anyway, thanks for a great video.
Moroccans speak an interesting type of Arabic that is heavily French influenced.
I would probably trust his French a lot more than his English (or Arabic)
@@AdamElmasriEnglish
Ok, thanks for info. His English melody is extremely difficult to follow, it almost has a Scandinavian touch to it. Do Egyptians speak Arabic?
@@chriss2452 yes. And also mandatory in the school curriculum to study formal Arabic for 16 years.
@@AdamElmasriEnglish Ok! Are there other languages in Egypt? I mean like, is there such a thing as "Egyptian"?
@@chriss2452That would be Coptic, which is sometimes used in Coptic orthodox religious ceremonies.
What about 4-157
Islam cannot prove from a historical
Point of view that the crucifixion never happened
That Surah is a Big Lie
1 He straight up went into the Bible 😂.
2 Even though he believes Bible is corrupted 😂
3 that's a circular argument, since he is appealing to something which he claims to be false or corrupted. Although no where in Qur'an or Hadith it says that.
he is just tryna prove bible is also wrong in that claim THEN and then he refuted the arguement
We AHULD NOT WORSHIP OF DED AMEN 🙏
It's completely understandable why they ignore the "daughter of Imran" bit, despite it being 50% of the entire argument. They have no counter.
In ant case, the quaran is supposed to be clear and for all times. If its divinely inspired, and supposed yo be clear, why isnt it clear? The fact its unclear debunks it.
Good job dear Adam, I have one concern, you should not agree with debater for Haman, or study your subject better because we're confused is it an error or it is not.
Kindly correct this part please.
May God bless you and your team more in Jesus Name brother AE
If you can find relics/statues of mathematics, then you can claim putting your hands on the "traces of Abraham, Moses, Jacob..."
*The oneness of God is an abstract concept*
That's why *you can't find physical statues/relics/traces* referring to the messengers/apostles of God. As simple as that.
A brick wall made of 💩
Hi again mr Elmasri!
Dr Luxemburg believes that the traditionalist might be right when it comes to the Sister of Aaron and the Mary Surah. He believes the title to be a comparison with the "moral" behavior of Aaron’s sister, who (like her mother) was not a "whore".
There is a possibility that ”the syster of Aaron” could be a dishonorary title that Mary’s people gave her in the sense of ” syster of the Samiri” or ”the Sister of the Missguided One” like son of a B.
In 4:156 the Quran is accusing the People of Israel of uttering a gross lie against Mary and this could be a direct reference to the syster of Aaron or the syster of the Samiri.
”They are condemned) for disbelieving and uttering about Mary a gross lie.”
He sounds as good as he argues.
Its wrong just because you have decided that it's wrong !
When the blind argues with the blind
Very Christian of you. Thanks!
Imran was the father of Moses, Aaron and Miriam but NOT the Virgin Mary….her father was Jaockim and he lived about 1,500 years after Imran. In the Roman Catholic, Orthodox, and Anglican traditions, Saint Joachim was the husband of Saint Anne and the father of Mary, the mother of Jesus. The story of Joachim and Anne appears first in the apocryphal Gospel of James. Joachim and Anne are not mentioned in the Bible.
There is many ways to confirm if it the same Mary from the bible and the Quran you should do more research.
Yahushua the messiah son of yahweh is the ONLY hope of salvation
ahhha haha adam is ex christian christianity is most illogical
@mffouzaanmd yahushua the messiah son of yahweh is the ONLY hope of salvation
His first "refutation" also contradicts the Quran.
If it's okay to say that people belong to the same group as their descendants, like this guy argues for the Samaritan, then the Quran is wrong to say that Abraham wasn't a Jew.
So if this guy is right the Quran is wrong, and if he's wrong the Quran is also wrong. Gee, I wonder if the Quran might be wrong!
..... get your things right dude... how can abraham be a jew when "juda"ism didnt exist then.
He was ofc a Muslim, which literally means "someone who submits his will to GOD".
With GOD i mean Allah, the All-Powerfull, the All-Knowing.
@@kolavithonduraski5031 so when the Quran says there was a Samaritan during the time of Moses it's objectively wrong, since the Samaritans weren't a thing yet. Good to know that you believe the Quran is written in a flawed and ignorant way.
P.S According to Judaism, people like Abraham are categorized as "Noahides" (people who know Judaism is true but they're not descendants of the people who were at Mount Sinai so Jewish law doesn't apply to them).
@kolavithonduraski5031 someone who submits his will to God is such a poor description. By that definition anyone who practices a faith is a Muslim. Jews Christians Hindus Mormons. It belittles the Muslim faith with that charactisation
@@milamber2553 i wrote GOD, with big letters.. ofc the only true God, the Allmighty (who is only worth of worship) is ment.
this what the other religions submit to, is surely not the Allmighty and Allknowing God i meant.
It is what is literally meant by muslim, because there is obviously no Deity worthy of Worship except GOD.
@@kolavithonduraski5031 so you're rectifying the statement to those that worship your God? So Moses and Abraham and Jesus aren't Muslims.
37 min : I don't understand english that well : did he really consider his video as "accademic" ? ... Oh yes !
100% fact on point 1. This poor Muslim apologist doesn't know history or logic or possibly neither. Yeah, same conclusion for the 2nd point and I'm just finishing my comment with how sad it is this guy is so confidently embarrassingly wrong.
Moroccan English is in another level.
How long have Moses been with the Israelites before Moses was called to take the codes of law (that is today called TORAH). Remember, the Quran never said Allah gave him a law by the name "TORAH". Thus, it is plausible that the Israelites were already given sets of instructions to follow before the ones on tablets was given to him
The observers of the law cannot exist before the law!!
iknow yeah bro adam is refutable dr luxemberg refuted this
If you are muslim stay away from Adam.. It is possible to find out some stuff nobody wants you to know 😂
Is it True that in The Holy Bible Why the Gyneology of Jesus Christ is Different in Mathew 1-1 and Luke 3-23.. In Mathew 1-1 The Father of Joseph the Carpenter is Jacob And in Luke 3-23 The Father of Joseph the Carpenter is Heli..??🙏🙏🙏
Can you give me your English video criticizing Christianity. I need to know why you left Christianity and the reasons for it. Thanks.
Perhaps Mary had a brother named Aaron what do you think guys.
What about Imran, father of Mary and Aaron?
@@AdamElmasriEnglish imran is just a name of chapter bruv
@@AdamElmasriEnglish good point was just wondering perhaps that the Quran is saying that Mary mother of Jesus had a brother named Aaron and a father named Imran.
@@mffouzaanmd Thus labelled, as surahs are, using a verse referring to him. As in the surahs contain much differing matters, slapped together, so they could not sometimes chose logical titles, but instead selected a colourful verse reference. Surah 3.35. We see Mary is meant by reading on, where an odd very distorted version of the Bible's narrative is given.
A reminder: *Adam is an ex-Christian who almost never tackles the biblical beliefs* 😁
Adam is not an ex-Muslim Just remember this much
*Where are the videos on Genocide in the Bible. You do know the explicit verses*
You mean sahih al-bukhari 2926 😮
Or all the verses in quran 😮there are to many of them 😢
Christian Logic
Q: Who is God?
A: Jesus
O: ls Jesus the son of Mary?
A: Yes,
Q: Who is God?
A: Jesus
*God Jesus was born from the mother
he created (Mary)
Q: ls Jesus a born son?
A: Yes,
Q: Who is his father?
A: God
Q: Who is God?
A: Jesus
*God Jesus is the father of God Jesus
and the creator of the mother he was
born from her the son of his wife
Q: Is Jesus the servant of God?
A: Yes,
Q: Did Jesus die on the cross?
A: Yes,
Q: And for whom did he go up?
A: To God
*God Jesus was crucified & ascended
to God Jesus
Q: Is Jesus a Messenger?
A: Yes,
Q: Who sent him?
A: God
Q: Who is God?
A: Jesus
*God Jesus was the messenger of God
Jesus. God sends himself as a
Messenger of himself
Q: Did Jesus pray when he was alive?
A:yes,
Q: Whom was he praying for?
A: For God
Q: Who is God?
A: Jesus
*God Jesus worships God Jesus
himself
Q: Does God have a beginning?
A: No
Q: So who was born on December
25th?
A: Jesus
Q: Who is God?
A: Jesus
*God Jesus is eternal before everything
but he was born in 25th Dec
Q: ls Jesus a God?
A: Yes
Q: So who many seated gods are
there?
A: Only one God?
Q: Where is Jesus?
A: He is sitting next to the god
Q: How many gods are in heaven?
A: Only one.
Q: Are they sitting on the same chair?
A: These words are understood only by
the one who has the holy spirit.
*so.. God sacrificed God to God in order
to save God's creation from God. God
prayed to God for help but God didn't
help God, and God killed God with help
from humans. And that God is a father
of himself and the mother of himself
and the son of mother he created at the
same time. He is also eternal but his
birthday is...?
Sura 33:43?????
Sura 33:56?????
Sahih muslim 34424😮
Sura 4:94-95😂
Sura 29:46😂
Sahih muslim 2749😮
Sura 4:159
Sura 21:91
Sura 4:157
Sura 19:16-23
Sura 3:49
Sura 3:55
😮
38:02 and then he calls his videos academic???
My ears 😅
syfetalk is a joke...he even blocked me
blocked you where ?
Is the same thing for me!!
SYFE BLOCKED ME
*"404" * video
@@roginyappl7158 where?
you need to be blocked...both...
why did he blocked you ?
Hi mr Elmasri!
I have good news for both you and mr Syfetalk. According to dr Luxemburg you are both wrong. The Samiri is not arabic and it does not mean the Samaritan nor the Observer. Rather in its syriac original al samiri is not a proper name but a verbal form refering to the Confused one or the Missguided one and is a direct reference to Aaron who was missguided and confused by his people into crafting the golden calf.
And why would the Quran refer to Aaron here as “the confused” Al-Samiri instead of using his name like everywhere else. Non-sensical argument!
Because that was an emotional moment between Moses and Aaron. Aaron is being tormented by his consciesness and calls Moses ” the son of my Mother” while Moses is infuriated because of the idol worship and calls Aaron ” the Missguided One”.
Read carefully the conversation between Moses and Aaron in 20:92-97 and you Will notice that it is all a conversation between the guilty ridden Aaron and the infuriated Moses, a conversation between ” the son of my Mother” and ”the Missguided One”. Read it carefully and recognise the original syriac. Do not let traditionalist arab nationalists confuse you into thinking that there are Three persons in the dialogue in 20:92-97.
@@economician
The Quran using Aaron would have gone against the Islamic doctrine about their prophets.
Muslims accuse Christians that we lie about the prophets and one of their accusations is that, we accuse Aaron of helping the Israelites to build the golden calf which a prophet would never do.
According to the Tafsir, this Samiri was called Musa Ibn Zafar, NOT Aaron.
I simply believe the writer of the Quran confused the story of the golden calf in Exodus with the Samaritans and their calf idol in Hosea 8:5-6.
What today’s muslims claim and the midevil exegetes who lived hundreds of years after the Quran is a completly separate issue.
The origins of the Arabic Quran are grounded in the syrio-aramaic Qeryan and in syrioaramaic the Samiri is not a proper name but a verbal form meaning the ”Confused One” or the ”Misslead One” and contextually 100 % refers to Aaron and confirms the exodus account but is told in a creative way because of liturgical reasons. The Word Quran in Syriac means a book of liturgy.
The Quran and its writers are not confused. Later readers of the Quran were confused because Abd al Malik hade replaced the lingua franca status that syriac had with the new arabic language. Later the Abbasids erased the syriac christian element and the confusion was irreversible.
Without double standard Islam dies.
16:17 didn't you do the same thing you criticized him for doing?