At least once a year, Fantano shits on an album I absolutely love, and I wasn't expecting this to be one of those reviews. Don't let the 5 dissuade you from checking it out.
Pretty much agreed on which songs are strong and which are weak, but I do think the track sequencing saves it. Just when I'm ready to give up on it, something awesome comes along. And I *cannot* get Tux out of my head. I just love it, it's such a fun concept for a song and so well executed, just hooks all over the place.
The problem is that I feel it is too long and some of the tracks like "so typically now" sound so good in comparison with the other songs and because of it, the album experience feels inconsistent. Even tho you focused on the story of "tux", the instrumentation of the track and the way it was mixed also deserves props because I think it feels more compeling than the way you described it. It is a song with a lot of feeling and a lot of heart not because of the content but because of the way the content was delivered. I didn't mind most of the corny lyrics because of the way they were incorpored with the melodies.
This review may be what makes me unsubscribe. The lack of love, understanding, nuance, and appreciation towards experimental female musicians who don't have clout within male dominated bands is toooooooo much for me to ignore.
Hello Antony, would you mind taking a listen to the growlers and their album, Natural Affair. its one of my favourite albums of all time and would love to hear your opinions on it!
Bro I'm fully convinced needle drop purposefully takes as long as possible to release people's most anticipated reviews. Where tf is slowthai you fiend.
Gonna have to join the disagreement train on this one, this album is a very blessed mess. A bit clunky at times, but feels brimming with creativity in a way that her last album was way more lacking in. Gonna be boppin along with this one for a while.
theneedledrop Could someone ask melon to react to and review (any of) the following? I live in The Netherlands, so I cannot watch the stream. Thanks in advance
@@ExtremeGutter Solid 7, kinda what I was expecting from him. Seems like he didn't like the way the album was recorded live, but still calls it their best record to date? Hmmm
If this was by U.S.S.R. Girls you would've given it a 10
Девочки СССР
Shit goes hard ngl
At least once a year, Fantano shits on an album I absolutely love, and I wasn't expecting this to be one of those reviews. Don't let the 5 dissuade you from checking it out.
I wouldn't call a 5 "shit on" more that it was meh, although I personally liked the album
nah melon is being too generous here tbh
Tell me about it. I'm an Arctic Monkeys fan.
Album is garbage. I'm really starting to think "In a Poem Unlimited" was a fluke.
How could In a Poem Unlimited be a fluke when Half Free is twice as good?
So Typically Now is such a bop
So true
I can't stop listening to it
their song 4 American Dollars is a goddamn classic
Hey this isn’t the XIU XIU review
Not Slowthai 😢
or screaming females
Or shame, why has he still not reviewed shame???? 😫😫
still editing for him to listen to new “Avey Tare” album :(
lol
Xiu Xiu sucks
wake up Anthony, Slowthai released AOTY
you would've liked this album if it was made by U.S. Boys
The patriarchy has struck again
No he would have given it a 0! Damn feminists strike again 😤😤😤😡😡😡
I'd be interested in hearing their equivalent of Pump
You are wrong
Give us that Slowthai melon head
Ugly is so good
I liked In a Poem Unlimited a lot so I still think I will check this out for the highlights.
Check out her album “Half Free” as well if you haven’t!
Pretty much agreed on which songs are strong and which are weak, but I do think the track sequencing saves it. Just when I'm ready to give up on it, something awesome comes along.
And I *cannot* get Tux out of my head. I just love it, it's such a fun concept for a song and so well executed, just hooks all over the place.
The problem is that I feel it is too long and some of the tracks like "so typically now" sound so good in comparison with the other songs and because of it, the album experience feels inconsistent. Even tho you focused on the story of "tux", the instrumentation of the track and the way it was mixed also deserves props because I think it feels more compeling than the way you described it. It is a song with a lot of feeling and a lot of heart not because of the content but because of the way the content was delivered. I didn't mind most of the corny lyrics because of the way they were incorpored with the melodies.
If Fantano were to re-review this album he’d give it a 5 and 5 + 5 is 10 so this album is the first 10 of the year
U.S. Girls are becoming the new Weezer. Like she's got bangers, and puts out some interesting stuff,, but this discography is not that impressive.
Thanks for making me a fan of Charlie XCX and US Girls
Comented before actually watching the review lol
@@Turkeysubs21 pain
This review may be what makes me unsubscribe. The lack of love, understanding, nuance, and appreciation towards experimental female musicians who don't have clout within male dominated bands is toooooooo much for me to ignore.
If this was made by UK Girls you would have given this a 0.
Please review ugly by slowthai 🙏🙏
review notorious dump legenda vol 2 please anthony tony fantano
You can’t give it a 1 just because you prefer U.K. Girls, Anthony.
Too late Anthony. Already reviewed it myself. I think it’s a 7
RED MOON IN VENUS KALI UCHIS 😤
The bangers on this album completely outweigh the few non-bangers, I would give this an 8/10. Sorry Anthony I'm stealing your job.
L
Hello Antony, would you mind taking a listen to the growlers and their album, Natural Affair. its one of my favourite albums of all time and would love to hear your opinions on it!
You would have given this a 10 if the group was called “U.S. Boys”
US Girls is just Kylie Minogue for hipsters.
Kali Uchis, Don Toliver, Slowthai dropped albums, when are you going to review them?
What's the record on top of the Danny Brown record?
Teens of Denial by Car Seat Headrest
Bro I'm fully convinced needle drop purposefully takes as long as possible to release people's most anticipated reviews. Where tf is slowthai you fiend.
Review don toliver already😫😫
Hope he does Macklemore soon
BEN 🍻
Looking for Kali Uchis Red moon in Venus review. Enjoy
I absolutely loved this album and I especially loved R.I.P Roy G. Biv. I’m just hopelessly but happily a fan.
Can you do new Kali
Melon would’ve liked US Gender Non conforming
Anthony, I really enjoyed this review. You did a good job! 😊
Where’s the Red Moon in Venus review, melon guy?
here before Kali or Slowthai get a 4
not to be that guy but can u pleek review the new full of hell and primitive man project 🥺
when i hear 'US Girls' i think of 'US Gold' and imagine they're making british bootleg toys
This is not slowthai review
Why are you avoiding the Don Toliver album?
where is don toliver and kali
No don toliver¿ it’s been a week and a half
Do a review of the new masego album
I'm excited for your Algiers review.
Unironically I agree with the melon. The album has some okay points but it does not come close to Poem.
Anthony! What’s your favourite US GIRLS song??
You should review Hania Rani’s On Giacometti. Gondwana one of my favourite labels out there
why havent you reviewed Love Sick
Gonna have to join the disagreement train on this one, this album is a very blessed mess. A bit clunky at times, but feels brimming with creativity in a way that her last album was way more lacking in. Gonna be boppin along with this one for a while.
Where’s the Don Toliver review
Please do a classic album 💿 review for De La Souls entire catalog or at least their debut album 💿- 3 Feet High and Rising - thanks ☺️much appreciated!
X2. 🔥
could you review wyatt james' new record? pls
Key Glock has potentially the rap album of the year, I know it’s a lot of new music lately but we need a Glockoma 2 review 😐
theneedledrop Could someone ask melon to react to and review (any of) the following? I live in The Netherlands, so I cannot watch the stream. Thanks in advance
dude where’s the Don Toliver review
Review the new album from Ruel: “4th Wall”
I'll give it a listen, but my hope for another bop like IaPU is gone
Review Don Toliver
Norm review????
If you could check out and review DÆV- Back Home, that’d be awesome!!
REVIEW ON THE NEW MASEGO ALBUM
Anthony just because
So we’re just not getting a Don toliver review then? 😢
I'd love to see him review Director's Cuts
If this album was called Curse the Cleanliness It would have been a 10.
And rightfully so
🤦🏼♂️
I didn't think Slowthai was from the U.S. or a girl, but okay.
Review Shaaaaaaame
where slowthai
React to UGLY by slowthai
Are you just gonna ignore lovesick
y u no review don toliver
Interesting album review.
Where’s Don toliver
Bro listen to raye's 21st century blues please.
Review pardans - peak happiness
go review kali uchis
Antknee
What?
Do morgan wallens new one
Review love sick please fantano
DID YOU LISTEN TO THE JPEG AND DANNY BROWN TRACK LEAN BEEF PATTY???
I know you probably won't review it but it would be Hilarious to hear "This new Morgan Wallen album it's Not Good" 😂
nah this is an 8 for me. groovy as all hell, fun and flirty. my fav u.s. girls project i think
Please react to Dro Kenji anwhere but here
We need to do a UGLY review by slowthai
RAHHHHHHHHH
Anthony my family is starving. Please release them from your basement dungeon. I’ll even agree that MBDTF is 6 if you let them go….
Antonio el Fantas
this isn’t young Nudy 😠
BBC lockdown time
A 7 for Yeet and now this. Smh
You can't say this album sucks just because you can't lactate.
Blup blup blup blup
Canthony cantano
gorw hair NOP0W
Review the new shame album goofball
Pls review Shame - Food For Worms
he said that he's gonna review it!!! i'm waiting for it too
@@ExtremeGutter yesssss thank you! Did he say that on a live stream or something?
@@ripclips in the weekend when they released the last single
@@ripclips bro!! he reviewed it!!!!
@@ExtremeGutter Solid 7, kinda what I was expecting from him. Seems like he didn't like the way the album was recorded live, but still calls it their best record to date? Hmmm
Like please do the new don toliver album I beg
Day 5 of asking for a review on “mudai 1” by downy