Here are the winners of the free set of propellers. Thanks to everyone for interacting and supporting! Edgar Raw, Thomas Hooker and Carol DeLuca - reach out to me, and I will also reach out to you to get your address! Thanks guys!
I like your video and your ideas to measure....However from a research standpoint, most of the results statistically insignificant...ie. no real measurable difference. Great idea to measure, however. Great video. As as quick side note, I don't think the extra money for the low noise props are worth the money because as you say, most sound levels are nearly identical above 100 feet.
I really love the DJI low noise props they bought out when they introduced the Platinum. They worked perfectly on the Mavic Pro. I noticed the difference straight away in reduction of noise. Thanks for the comparison.
Russ, this is yet another example of the quality of informative videos you produce. An awful lot of work and man hours went into all the testing you did to provide us viewers with really helpful and useful information. Unlike a lot of other well known drone channels that sound more like company infomercials, your videos sound like they are meant to educate and inform, which they do extremely well. Thanks for all your hard work. I’ve been a subscriber for almost two years but never clicked on the notification bell. I’m in the process of catching up now and even after two years of flying my P4 and MPP I’m learning a lot from all your videos. By the way, I use the low noise props that came with my MPP and I’m extremely happy with them. I have spare sets as well but never had to use them. Thanks again Russ!👍👍👍
Great comparison of propellers. Some interesting results, however, having flown model gliders for over 40 years, and being a sailor as well, I know about wind and thermals. I would imagine "speed test" results, which were pretty close in comparison would be pretty hard to measure in an outdoor environment as wind is never constant and thermals cause dead spots so a distance run would be better done in a gym where there is no movement of air flow. Anyway, thanks for taking the time to run these prop tests, and Happy Flying
This video was very insightful. Coming from an R&D background, it’s a better to see the reviews in action rather than taking the word from customer reviews, which I have found on several occasions to be inaccurate, so thanks again and keep up the great work!
Hi Russ: I tend to fly using the low noise blades, the aircraft is more stable and less intrusive, which enables me to capture the action without people noticing the drone straight away. I also carry a set of the original blades, these can handle higher winds better than the low noise type. In short - slice or hack, they both have their place..! L.N.P. TIP: Get the silver tipped ones. They are less noticeable, where the gold tipped ones can be seen in the top corners.
I too have been using the DJI low noise props since they were introduced. I carry the originals as back ups. Very interested in the Master Airscrews. Looks like a wider blade design. Keep up the great work, Russ.
Wow ...your video is amazing ...for anyone who wants to know about propellers.... I share it to my friends... Your speaking way is too good... Your dedication and hard work for this is fabulous.. God bless 😇 u...
I was just getting ready to buy propellers the other day when you read my mind and uploaded this video. THANKS! I went ahead and purchased the DJI low Noise props but would like to try the Master Airscrew props if they are available.
I stocked up on spare props when I first got my Mavic & ran into a table leg... Went with several sets of low noise props when they came out & did seem the noise level was lower...Then got a set of Master Airscrew props (orange color) to try...Liked the build & the Mavic flies great so I also got a set of black props...They work fine & I've been flying mostly with them lately... So... I've accumulated enough props to outlast several crashes and a couple more Mavic's ... The DJI low noise or Master Airscrew would be my choice...Makes no difference...Just get out & fly...
Great comparison. Thanks! I was hoping somebody would do this. I think for me it will be the DJI low noise. Its the best all-around prop. That low noise is super important to ensure you are not annoying people around you.
As several others have already mentioned, I tend to prefer the stock DJI props, simply because a few extra bucks is a cheap way of preventing DJI from using that as an excuse to deny a waranty claim. The results given by all of the third party props you compared don't seem to show me anything that would outweigh that concern. Also, like you, I like the sound of the low noise props best, so they would be my choice for first place. Knowledge is power though, so thanks for sharing the comparison stats!
An incredibly comprehensive guide on props, thanks very much for your time Russ. I figured there was a good reason to stay with the DJI props, if I were to turn from standard props it would be to the low noise DJI ones.
Awesome Russ, I like the carbon fibre props ad the 8331 low noice jobbies seem to do the job. Great videos my friend. You always put a lot of work into providing all the good information in your videos well done man 👍🏻
I have wondered myself - which is the best but in my area - the quiet DJI props are the one I like the best. When I am flying and people come around I have always gotten " Hey that not so loud remark" . thanks for taking the time to do a side by side testing.
Well done, Russ. I’m flying the MPP low noise props right now and, like you, I’m very pleased with them especially for the sound reduction in volume as well as timbre. If I were to be so lucky, I’d love to have the Master Airscrew props. I do a lot of still landscapes and timelapses which means I’m in tripod mode a lot which to my mind is a lot like a hover and I’d appreciate the extra minute or so of flight time. As always, a great video!
Hi Russ, I am not sure the best way tocontact you from the UK so I am just using what i believe is your last Mavic Pro youtube video. A personal very big thank you for all your Mavic pro videos and the massive amount of time you have spent over a couple of years. I have found them very helpful and I am now determined to to get back and fly my Mavic pro much more which I started this week while away on holiday on the South coast of England. I realise the Mavic Pro is now realitively old and there is now the newer 2 Pro & 3 but I will stick with what I have as it is good enough for my needs. The only issue I have is that some times a get the gimbal shake amber error but no idea why; hopefully I will find a fix somehwre on the WWW. Once again many thanks Alan
Very good comparison! When I first got my Mavic Pro I bought a complete extra set of props for spares, luckily, no crashes "yet". When the Mavic Pro Platinum came out I was very interested in a quieter Mavic! A month later after several reviews made it to TH-cam that platinum props were safe for the Pro I bought a set of those and have used them for almost every flight. If literally out in the middle of nowhere I'll use the stock otherwise I use the quiet props. I'm not interested in speed, just quietness, and stability! I wonder with the tests would the faster turning or the slower turning be the most stress, and wear on the motors? I mean, they will all wear out with time but what would work best for the longest life of those electric motors?
I’ve used the led blades for night flying and they are great. If you like night flying, you have to try these out. I got mine at Amazon. There is at least one review on another drone channel. The blades I received are rechargeable and recharge cord comes with them.
Thank you Russ. Great vids always enjoyed. It's good to have choices. My philosophy however, is that DJI has done all the research and if a drone comes out of the box with props, they should be assumed to be the best for that drone. I still consider myself a newbie (it's unbelievable the mistakes I make!) and have recently purchased my third and long-awaited-for Mavic Pro Platinium. I'm perfectly satisfied with the original props. I love their whisper mode (remember Airwolf?).
I try to watch all of your videos, I like that you help beginners and intermediates like myself. Anyway thanks for all your help.I'm not rough on props so no need to send them my way.
Excellent video. Well thought out. Well executed and well edited too. TH-cam should have more channels like this one. (third or so time i subscribe to a channel on the first video, and I watch ALOT of different topics and vids a day). Thank you for your hard work :)
Russ, a Very nice comparison test of the five different props. I agree I've been using the DJI Low Noise props on my Mavic Pro since these came out, they are a lot quieter than the original Mavic Pro Pros. Very nice test, thank you!
Excellent effort to quantify prop performance/quality. Thanks. One issue that might be very important but will be difficult to quantify is the impact different propellers have on the drone reliability & maintenance requirements. If a prop is impacting the rpm of the motors, that seems like it could be an indication that the drone motors are having to work harder/easier in order to hover. So what impact does that have on motor reliability? And also, I assume the carbon fiber props were created primarily to avoid prop chips and breakage. If that matters to a pilot, it could dominate their decision yet is not considered in this comparison.
Hi Russ, great comparison - thanks! As soon as I saw the title, I immediately thought about how much work would go into such a video. Here are a couple of my observations: 1. Your video is in 4K. Nice! I recently got all set up for processing 4K myself. It's more of an investment than a new MP2 (that I still want). 2. I use the quiet props. There are too many folks around who are drone skeptics, so the less conspicuous, the better. 3. Just a thought on the speed test - I think the speed is limited by the software, not the limitations of the props, motors, wind-drag, etc. That being said, it is interesting that you did get varying speed results, and that they fell in line with your other metrics. I'm wondering if looking at the percent-of-power gauge in Sport Mode might be an interesting comparison? In other words, how much power does it take to fly at the governed speed with the different props? (I know... if I'm so smart, why aren't I posting all these cool videos? I'm not that smart.) :-) Thanks again for continuing to roll out all the great content.
Hey Russ, love your videos! They really have saved me more than once. i.e. RTH set to the controller and the RTH take off to 10m! Anyway, I have an unrelated question, the DJI Smart controller has no cell service, neither does an iPad WiFi only... How come it is recommended to use the iPad with cell service and not necessarily with the Smart controller?
Thanks Russ for a very informative video as usual. Your informal and clear presentation makes too understand better the subject that you are presenting. As for the Props, well I only have used the DJI low noise as they came with the Drone when purchased ( Platinum ) and I am very satisfied with these, so why change, but the Master Airscrew would be nice to try out !!
Hi Rus, I would like to get the Master Airscrew version. Once again an awesome video with lots of useful info. Keep it up and a very Merry Christmas to you and yours.
I just got my Mavic 2 pro for a couple of days now (my first drone), and ordered the 3 blades props… Just for fun (together with a lot of other stuff) I did (at this point), only one test-flight, the weather was too bad. The noise of the original blades was nice, not too noisy. Did you test the 3-blades props ? How about the noise, battery power and speed ? Pardon my English, I'm Dutch :-) … Thanks for the nice videos !
Well I think the reason why the stock DJI propellers will let it go faster is because they have less drag because they're not as wide... And the low noise DJI propellers are more for low noise but I'm sure they bounced out just because it don't have the best top speed don't mean it's not as efficient... I'm glad you did this video now I have some kind of idea of what works the best
I love the speed the stock DJI props give me. I think they are the best in heat and cold even extreme cold as i have watched my friends fly in -26C with a windchill of like -60! up hear in canada. I would like to try the master air screw if i win please. Luck of the draw will see. ;-) You have the best drone channel and i lov your video. Please keep it up. Merry Christmas.
Great review 51D I’ve been thinking about Master Air Screw as they have color choices. My MP is Alpine White so I need a little color. Happy Holidays Russ
I like your channel-I’ve learned a lot from it. I like the low noise propellers, but any would be good for spares. Thanks for taking the time, and effort, to make your videos.
The reason the carbon fibre props are quieter at 100ft is because they have lighter mass (and much less flex!), I find they cut through crosswind much easier; i.e. they don't have to work as hard with crosswinds (so won't produce as much noise). The straight 8330 Mavic blades will be fastest as they don't have the leading edge drag that you get on the quiet blades (the curve on the end produces a tiny bit of air drag to help reduce noise), so that makes sense. And I'm not surprised that the Master Airscrew have the longest flight time due to the enhanced profile of the blade. If you notice that they flick up at the end (called winglets) which helps with air shear of the propeller, which reduces friction - But only when the blades are vertical. Unfortunately this sacrifices some of the top-end speed compared to non-winglet 8330s.
Interesting test. I'm not so sure it is necessarily all about db level I reckon it is all to do with pitch. Even though all props came in around the same volume level they all sounded different! Perhaps the pitch is what makes the drone appear louder to the ear? I have an air and although I don't think the air is necessarily louder than the mavic the pitch is awful which makes it so conspicuous. Great test!
Hi Russ, nice video but I miss the triple carbon propellers in your test. They are difficult to obtain. I have these triple propellers of carbon and I think these are pretty quiet but do require a lot of battery. Now I am still planning to screw the carbon props off and put the platinum on it to see if that also makes a difference. Happy New Year to every one and fly safe.
I have my mavic Pro under the Christmas tree waiting for me on Tuesday morning as well as a Spark for my son. I do love the idea of the Platinum blades also.. new subscriber love your videos and keep up the good work
It was great to test the noise level of each prop, lower noise is a must when you don't want to attract the attention of others. As mentioned at the end, a single test will not produce an accurate result. For speed tests, big factors are wind speed, wind gusts, and wind direction at the time of each flight. As they vary, you will get different results, even with the same props. The hover tests are also a factor of battery charge. A drone will stay in the air longer if the battery maintains its charge longer, and that can be slightly different with each flight. So you can't say the hover time is a factor of the props alone. For more accurate results, these tests would have to be done 10 to 20 times each, and on different days. Then average out all the results. Yes, alot of work, but the results would be more accurate.
Well done! Thank you very much for sharing this informative video. Love your channel. I am going to get some of the low noise to try them out. Thanks again!!
I use the stock Props have had the quite ones on loan for a day but couldn't be sure if they are good or not for me, but this Vid helps me out Thanks for your info.
hi russ,,geat video as ever,,,so what Propellers out of all of them would you say would be the best in the wind ?,,and what is the highest wind you would fly your mavic in ? would it be worth you doing a video on testing all of those Propellers to see whitch would be the best and strongest in the wind ?,,,,keep up the good work and stay safe from uk
I bought low noise from Mavic and the drone flies great... one major issue is that they are so fragile. The trailing edge on one rear blade was chipped by the fins on the bottom of the drone when folded. I bought low noise copies on eBay and they fly well but are more sturdy, I often fly with stock. Interested in the master screws, they look well built
Good video, thanks. I wonder what your results would be if you did the exact same test with a Mavic Pro Platinum which has the different controller design for it's motors. I believe the RPMs were lower on the Platinum than the older Mavic Pros. This plus the different prop profile may be the reason the Platinum has a lower pitch motor sound.
I think the high wind spoilled your otherwise good test. As you compare peak values, they are easily affected by some short wind bursts, especially noise levels and speed.
Just for fun. I have to ask. Why are drone props... called propellers and not rotor blades? Or rotors? As a pilot for 45 years in fixed wing and rotary wing... Props go forward. Rotors hover. I am simply puzzled by how the English language decided to call them props and not rotors. Picture a puzzled emoji. Just a fun comment. I do enjoy following your channel. Oh, and I'll take what ever props you send. LOL
Good question, but i also have a fun answer for what its worth. Also why are they called drones instead of quad copters? lol .. Anyway, back to the fun answer. Rotor blades are mainly associated with helicopters that people actually fly in. Then came along quad copters which have 4 little motors with 4 little propellers flown mostly by people in the model aircraft hobby. I guess its all because of size. So you see, size does count! Happy Flying
@@KenKneknaneek Was going to say the same thing. They get called what the masses ultimately want to call them. Drones are autonomous. These really are quadcopters. Happy Holidays to everyone!
@@Proost1 Any smart UAV can be called drone. Yes you "control" it but these drone also do lot of things autonomously. So they're not your typical walmart quadcopter.
Great video! Can tell took some time to Make! I use MAS orange for VLOS easy for me to see agains blue sky since mine is Decaled white! Thanks for info!
Did the Mavic Pro Speed controllers get updated because they (DJI) came up with the 8330 prop. Are the speed controller totally new, or just recalibrated? Thanks for all your super helpful Videos - indepensible!!
Greatly appreciate the video Russ. My thoughts are ... why would anyone skimp on the cost of replacement props? If performance was improved I’d buy the best of the best. The UAS is over $1000... putting cheap props on these aircraft is like putting Walmart tires on a Porsche!
Hi mate, thanks for sharing your comparison. I have a question for you, now that the Mavic 2 and Air 2 are out and both nice competitors for the Mavic Pro we own ; if I have extra propellers, will the fit as spare propellers on the Mavic 2 or the Air 2? Have you tried?
like you, I will stick with the DJI low noise props my Platinum came with. Still flying with the original props (still in excellent condition) and have the extra set as back up. The 1+ mph loss means nothing to me. Quiet and time of flight / warranty means a lot. I do like the looks of the white props though (if I had the white Apple Mavic Pro). Interesting video and thanks for the work you put into it.
There are now carbon fiber 3 bladed props available that fir the Mavic 2 Pro, provides 33% more lift if you want to piggyback a load or fly in higher winds...
Hi Russ. Great comparison vid. Just the warranty issue with using non dji products but if your not concerned what the heck.... I'll take any freebies. 👍🏻👌🏼
Hi Russ. Thank you for the insight into props. I am guessing that if you carried a set of different branded, or even, a different design of the same branded props, you need to ensure all props are changed to the same. I would imagine the weight and design may differ and thus function slightly awkward. You obviously can’t mix props. Though your idea of an extra full set of props (cheaper set avail. in Australia) is a very good point. It would have been a useful idea for me in the past. Regards, Sam C.
Thanks for the review. I love the look of the white master props, wouldn’t mind a set of those. Until now I’ve been enjoying the low-noise props from DJI on my platinum pro, have done some insane flying with those. I find the tips are a bit soft, so I lost one pair during a risky landing on a moving boat during a waterski session. It clipped the tips off and immediately the noise got much louder, but she still flies. I also lost a pair to my cat, who decided they make a nice chew toy when I wasn’t watching. 🤦♂️ hahaha. Idea for a future test/video: How much damage can the props have until the drone becomes totally unflyable? Be safe, happy holidays.
![ALLY - OH MY! [ REACTION ] 'Amarin Nitibhon' #ALLY_OHMY #ALLY #allynitibhon #แอลลี่](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nX9qpHjVfbQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Here are the winners of the free set of propellers. Thanks to everyone for interacting and supporting! Edgar Raw, Thomas Hooker and Carol DeLuca - reach out to me, and I will also reach out to you to get your address! Thanks guys!
Great INFO and thanks for taking the time to do this!
If you have any left I'd like to try some out!
I have the new M2P
I like your video and your ideas to measure....However from a research standpoint, most of the results statistically insignificant...ie. no real measurable difference. Great idea to measure, however. Great video. As as quick side note, I don't think the extra money for the low noise props are worth the money because as you say, most sound levels are nearly identical above 100 feet.
I really love the DJI low noise props they bought out when they introduced the Platinum. They worked perfectly on the Mavic Pro. I noticed the difference straight away in reduction of noise. Thanks for the comparison.
Russ, this is yet another example of the quality of informative videos you produce. An awful lot of work and man hours went into all the testing you did to provide us viewers with really helpful and useful information. Unlike a lot of other well known drone channels that sound more like company infomercials, your videos sound like they are meant to educate and inform, which they do extremely well.
Thanks for all your hard work. I’ve been a subscriber for almost two years but never clicked on the notification bell. I’m in the process of catching up now and even after two years of flying my P4 and MPP I’m learning a lot from all your videos.
By the way, I use the low noise props that came with my MPP and I’m extremely happy with them. I have spare sets as well but never had to use them.
Thanks again Russ!👍👍👍
Thank you Paul!
Great comparison of propellers. Some interesting results, however, having flown model gliders for over 40 years, and being a sailor as well, I know about wind and thermals. I would imagine "speed test" results, which were pretty close in comparison would be pretty hard to measure in an outdoor environment as wind is never constant and thermals cause dead spots so a distance run would be better done in a gym where there is no movement of air flow. Anyway, thanks for taking the time to run these prop tests, and Happy Flying
This video was very insightful. Coming from an R&D background, it’s a better to see the reviews in action rather than taking the word from customer reviews, which I have found on several occasions to be inaccurate, so thanks again and keep up the great work!
Your channel is so underrated. You're great!
Hi Russ: I tend to fly using the low noise blades, the aircraft is more stable and less intrusive, which enables me to capture the action without people noticing the drone straight away.
I also carry a set of the original blades, these can handle higher winds better than the low noise type.
In short - slice or hack, they both have their place..!
L.N.P. TIP:
Get the silver tipped ones. They are less noticeable, where the gold tipped ones can be seen in the top corners.
I too have been using the DJI low noise props since they were introduced. I carry the originals as back ups. Very interested in the Master Airscrews. Looks like a wider blade design. Keep up the great work, Russ.
Wow ...your video is amazing ...for anyone who wants to know about propellers....
I share it to my friends...
Your speaking way is too good...
Your dedication and hard work for this is fabulous..
God bless 😇 u...
I was just getting ready to buy propellers the other day when you read my mind and uploaded this video. THANKS!
I went ahead and purchased the DJI low Noise props but would like to try the Master Airscrew props if they are available.
I stocked up on spare props when I first got my Mavic &
ran into a table leg... Went with several sets of low noise props when they came
out & did seem the noise level was lower...Then got a set of Master
Airscrew props (orange color) to try...Liked the build & the Mavic flies
great so I also got a set of black props...They work fine & I've been
flying mostly with them lately...
So... I've accumulated enough props to outlast several crashes and a
couple more Mavic's ... The DJI low noise or Master Airscrew would be my
choice...Makes no difference...Just get out & fly...
Great comparison. Thanks! I was hoping somebody would do this. I think for me it will be the DJI low noise. Its the best all-around prop. That low noise is super important to ensure you are not annoying people around you.
As several others have already mentioned, I tend to prefer the stock DJI props, simply because a few extra bucks is a cheap way of preventing DJI from using that as an excuse to deny a waranty claim. The results given by all of the third party props you compared don't seem to show me anything that would outweigh that concern.
Also, like you, I like the sound of the low noise props best, so they would be my choice for first place.
Knowledge is power though, so thanks for sharing the comparison stats!
An incredibly comprehensive guide on props, thanks very much for your time Russ. I figured there was a good reason to stay with the DJI props, if I were to turn from standard props it would be to the low noise DJI ones.
Awesome Russ, I like the carbon fibre props ad the 8331 low noice jobbies seem to do the job. Great videos my friend. You always put a lot of work into providing all the good information in your videos well done man 👍🏻
I have wondered myself - which is the best but in my area - the quiet DJI props are the one I like the best. When I am flying and people come around I have always gotten " Hey that not so loud remark" . thanks for taking the time to do a side by side testing.
Thanks for putting in your time to benefit drone pilots.
Love ur channel
Well done, Russ. I’m flying the MPP low noise props right now and, like you, I’m very pleased with them especially for the sound reduction in volume as well as timbre. If I were to be so lucky, I’d love to have the Master Airscrew props. I do a lot of still landscapes and timelapses which means I’m in tripod mode a lot which to my mind is a lot like a hover and I’d appreciate the extra minute or so of flight time. As always, a great video!
Hi Russ, I am not sure the best way tocontact you from the UK so I am just using what i believe is your last Mavic Pro youtube video. A personal very big thank you for all your Mavic pro videos and the massive amount of time you have spent over a couple of years. I have found them very helpful and I am now determined to to get back and fly my Mavic pro much more which I started this week while away on holiday on the South coast of England. I realise the Mavic Pro is now realitively old and there is now the newer 2 Pro & 3 but I will stick with what I have as it is good enough for my needs. The only issue I have is that some times a get the gimbal shake amber error but no idea why; hopefully I will find a fix somehwre on the WWW. Once again many thanks Alan
Very good comparison! When I first got my Mavic Pro I bought a complete extra set of props for spares, luckily, no crashes "yet". When the Mavic Pro Platinum came out I was very interested in a quieter Mavic! A month later after several reviews made it to TH-cam that platinum props were safe for the Pro I bought a set of those and have used them for almost every flight. If literally out in the middle of nowhere I'll use the stock otherwise I use the quiet props. I'm not interested in speed, just quietness, and stability! I wonder with the tests would the faster turning or the slower turning be the most stress, and wear on the motors? I mean, they will all wear out with time but what would work best for the longest life of those electric motors?
Commenting before I watch, but my bet is on the MPP Props as being the winner.
I think the Master Airscrew props are the ones I would like longer flight time :)
Great info. I've always stuck with DJI props but the chance at longer flight times makes me want the Master Air Screws!
Oh snap. What do I need to do?
I’ve used the led blades for night flying and they are great. If you like night flying, you have to try these out. I got mine at Amazon. There is at least one review on another drone channel. The blades I received are rechargeable and recharge cord comes with them.
Thank you Russ. Great vids always enjoyed.
It's good to have choices.
My philosophy however, is that DJI has done all the research and if a drone comes out of the box with props, they should be assumed to be the best for that drone.
I still consider myself a newbie (it's unbelievable the mistakes I make!) and have recently purchased my third and long-awaited-for Mavic Pro Platinium. I'm perfectly satisfied with the original props. I love their whisper mode (remember Airwolf?).
I try to watch all of your videos, I like that you help beginners and intermediates like myself. Anyway thanks for all your help.I'm not rough on props so no need to send them my way.
Hi Russ, as you do realize I'm sure, the decibels are a factor but the sound/pitch is probably at least as important.
Thank you for taking the time for this review! Loved it!
Excellent video. Well thought out. Well executed and well edited too. TH-cam should have more channels like this one. (third or so time i subscribe to a channel on the first video, and I watch ALOT of different topics and vids a day). Thank you for your hard work :)
I appreciate that!
Russ, a Very nice comparison test of the five different props. I agree I've been using the DJI Low Noise props on my Mavic Pro since these came out, they are a lot quieter than the original Mavic Pro Pros. Very nice test, thank you!
Russ, you are the OCD man like myself. I am glad there is someone else like me who thinks in detail. Thanks.
Flyboy K85
Good comparison Russ. I bought 4 sets of low noise props with my Mavic platinum so I’m good for now.
Excellent effort to quantify prop performance/quality. Thanks. One issue that might be very important but will be difficult to quantify is the impact different propellers have on the drone reliability & maintenance requirements. If a prop is impacting the rpm of the motors, that seems like it could be an indication that the drone motors are having to work harder/easier in order to hover. So what impact does that have on motor reliability? And also, I assume the carbon fiber props were created primarily to avoid prop chips and breakage. If that matters to a pilot, it could dominate their decision yet is not considered in this comparison.
Hey Russ, just got myself a set of the DJI low noise. Hopefully they perform well. As usual, great vid. Thanks from me in 🏴
Thank you for your effort. Helps me a lot to choose the right propeller for my Mavic Pro.
Hi Russ, great comparison - thanks! As soon as I saw the title, I immediately thought about how much work would go into such a video. Here are a couple of my observations:
1. Your video is in 4K. Nice! I recently got all set up for processing 4K myself. It's more of an investment than a new MP2 (that I still want).
2. I use the quiet props. There are too many folks around who are drone skeptics, so the less conspicuous, the better.
3. Just a thought on the speed test - I think the speed is limited by the software, not the limitations of the props, motors, wind-drag, etc. That being said, it is interesting that you did get varying speed results, and that they fell in line with your other metrics. I'm wondering if looking at the percent-of-power gauge in Sport Mode might be an interesting comparison? In other words, how much power does it take to fly at the governed speed with the different props? (I know... if I'm so smart, why aren't I posting all these cool videos? I'm not that smart.) :-)
Thanks again for continuing to roll out all the great content.
Lol! Thanks!
Hey Russ, love your videos! They really have saved me more than once. i.e. RTH set to the controller and the RTH take off to 10m! Anyway, I have an unrelated question, the DJI Smart controller has no cell service, neither does an iPad WiFi only... How come it is recommended to use the iPad with cell service and not necessarily with the Smart controller?
I think OEM low noise is the way to go, but as you said Russ, it depends on what an individual's needs are...
Keep the Vid's coming!
Just tried out my new Master air screw props. Wow very nice quality. Sound nice n quiet. It was crazy windy out but they handled it very well.
Interesting test Russ , thanks for taking the time and effort . I think I will try the low noise ones . Have a great Christmas , and New Year .
Another fantastic video Russ. This channel is Top Notch!
Great video Russ I’ve always wondered about this topic but from the results I would go for the low noise propellers!
Thanks Russ for a very informative video as usual. Your informal and clear presentation makes too understand better the subject that you are presenting. As for the Props, well I only have used the DJI low noise as they came with the Drone when purchased ( Platinum ) and I am very satisfied with these, so why change, but the Master Airscrew would be nice to try out !!
Very comprehensive and detailed video, I think I will stick with my DJI low noise props with MPP
I would absolutely love a set of master airscrew for the Mavic pro. Great info. Keep up the great work
Would like to try out a low noise prop. But not choosy when it's free. Keep making those good videos. thanks! 👍
Hi Rus, I would like to get the Master Airscrew version. Once again an awesome video with lots of useful info. Keep it up and a very Merry Christmas to you and yours.
Just ordered the master airscrew for my mavic pro 2 , subscribed! From 🇳🇴
I just got my Mavic 2 pro for a couple of days now (my first drone), and ordered the 3 blades props… Just for fun (together with a lot of other stuff)
I did (at this point), only one test-flight, the weather was too bad. The noise of the original blades was nice, not too noisy.
Did you test the 3-blades props ? How about the noise, battery power and speed ?
Pardon my English, I'm Dutch :-) … Thanks for the nice videos !
Well I think the reason why the stock DJI propellers will let it go faster is because they have less drag because they're not as wide... And the low noise DJI propellers are more for low noise but I'm sure they bounced out just because it don't have the best top speed don't mean it's not as efficient... I'm glad you did this video now I have some kind of idea of what works the best
Those master airscrew props really sound good. Thanks for doing the review.
I love the speed the stock DJI props give me. I think they are the best in heat and cold even extreme cold as i have watched my friends fly in -26C with a windchill of like -60! up hear in canada. I would like to try the master air screw if i win please. Luck of the draw will see. ;-) You have the best drone channel and i lov your video. Please keep it up. Merry Christmas.
Very excellent comparison. Thank you.
Great review 51D I’ve been thinking about Master Air Screw as they have color choices. My MP is Alpine White so I need a little color. Happy Holidays Russ
I wouldn't mind trying the Master Air Screw propellers! Another great video!
I like your channel-I’ve learned a lot from it. I like the low noise propellers, but any would be good for spares. Thanks for taking the time, and effort, to make your videos.
I really love your work! I feel I have a lot to learn and watching your stuff helps thank you!
The reason the carbon fibre props are quieter at 100ft is because they have lighter mass (and much less flex!), I find they cut through crosswind much easier; i.e. they don't have to work as hard with crosswinds (so won't produce as much noise). The straight 8330 Mavic blades will be fastest as they don't have the leading edge drag that you get on the quiet blades (the curve on the end produces a tiny bit of air drag to help reduce noise), so that makes sense. And I'm not surprised that the Master Airscrew have the longest flight time due to the enhanced profile of the blade. If you notice that they flick up at the end (called winglets) which helps with air shear of the propeller, which reduces friction - But only when the blades are vertical. Unfortunately this sacrifices some of the top-end speed compared to non-winglet 8330s.
Interesting test. I'm not so sure it is necessarily all about db level I reckon it is all to do with pitch. Even though all props came in around the same volume level they all sounded different! Perhaps the pitch is what makes the drone appear louder to the ear? I have an air and although I don't think the air is necessarily louder than the mavic the pitch is awful which makes it so conspicuous. Great test!
Hi Russ, nice video but I miss the triple carbon propellers in your test. They are difficult to obtain. I have these triple propellers of carbon and I think these are pretty quiet but do require a lot of battery. Now I am still planning to screw the carbon props off and put the platinum on it to see if that also makes a difference. Happy New Year to every one and fly safe.
I have my mavic Pro under the Christmas tree waiting for me on Tuesday morning as well as a Spark for my son. I do love the idea of the Platinum blades also.. new subscriber love your videos and keep up the good work
Thanks, and Merry Christmas!
It was great to test the noise level of each prop, lower noise is a must when you don't want to attract the attention of others.
As mentioned at the end, a single test will not produce an accurate result.
For speed tests, big factors are wind speed, wind gusts, and wind direction at the time of each flight. As they vary, you will get different results, even with the same props.
The hover tests are also a factor of battery charge. A drone will stay in the air longer if the battery maintains its charge longer, and that can be slightly different with each flight. So you can't say the hover time is a factor of the props alone.
For more accurate results, these tests would have to be done 10 to 20 times each, and on different days. Then average out all the results.
Yes, alot of work, but the results would be more accurate.
I like the looks of the master air screw props. They all perform pretty equally.
Well done! Thank you very much for sharing this informative video. Love your channel. I am going to get some of the low noise to try them out. Thanks again!!
another good explanation I have been following you since last year
I use the stock Props have had the quite ones on loan for a day but couldn't be sure if they are good or not for me, but this Vid helps me out Thanks for your info.
hi russ,,geat video as ever,,,so what Propellers out of all of them would you say would be the best in the wind ?,,and what is the highest wind you would fly your mavic in ? would it be worth you doing a video on testing all of those Propellers to see whitch would be the best and strongest in the wind ?,,,,keep up the good work and stay safe from uk
Great review, thanks, I agree, mp low noise is my preferred set
I have been wanting to give the Master Airscrew a try for a while now. I know they have been around a long time and have good quality.
Great vid dude. I been thinking about trying out some props for my Mavic PP
I'd love a set of Master Air Screw props. Thanks for the great info . Looking forward to your next video.
I bought low noise from Mavic and the drone flies great... one major issue is that they are so fragile. The trailing edge on one rear blade was chipped by the fins on the bottom of the drone when folded.
I bought low noise copies on eBay and they fly well but are more sturdy, I often fly with stock. Interested in the master screws, they look well built
Great work! This is exactly the sort of info I was looking for.
Great review. I would like the Master Air Screw if selected. Thank you!
I bought some of the 8331 props for my mavic and it made it vibrate
My choice would be the HI-RC props...thanks for the chance!!!
Good video, thanks. I wonder what your results would be if you did the exact same test with a Mavic Pro Platinum which has the different controller design for it's motors.
I believe the RPMs were lower on the Platinum than the older Mavic Pros. This plus the different prop profile may be the reason the Platinum has a lower pitch motor sound.
Great info Russ, keep them coming
Thanks for the videos.
I liked the DJI low noise best.
i like the DJI Mavic Pro 8330 Props. Thank you so for the review.
Hey Russ. Nice review. Master Air Screw would be the ones I would like.
I think the high wind spoilled your otherwise good test. As you compare peak values, they are easily affected by some short wind bursts, especially noise levels and speed.
Just for fun. I have to ask. Why are drone props... called propellers and not rotor blades? Or rotors? As a pilot for 45 years in fixed wing and rotary wing... Props go forward. Rotors hover. I am simply puzzled by how the English language decided to call them props and not rotors. Picture a puzzled emoji. Just a fun comment. I do enjoy following your channel. Oh, and I'll take what ever props you send. LOL
Good question, but i also have a fun answer for what its worth. Also why are they called drones instead of quad copters? lol .. Anyway, back to the fun answer. Rotor blades are mainly associated with helicopters that people actually fly in. Then came along quad copters which have 4 little motors with 4 little propellers flown mostly by people in the model aircraft hobby. I guess its all because of size. So you see, size does count! Happy Flying
@@KenKneknaneek Was going to say the same thing. They get called what the masses ultimately want to call them. Drones are autonomous. These really are quadcopters. Happy Holidays to everyone!
@@Proost1 Any smart UAV can be called drone. Yes you "control" it but these drone also do lot of things autonomously. So they're not your typical walmart quadcopter.
"Propel air one way" consistent speed will create a consistent altitude.. mind you they are mounted topside (your fixed wing, mounted frontside)
Props to you for asking the question ;)
Thanks, very good review.
Great video! Can tell took some time to Make!
I use MAS orange for VLOS easy for me to see agains blue sky since mine is Decaled white! Thanks for info!
I use stock props on my MPP, as such I'd like to try something different to compare. Your choice if selected to receive a set.
Great information. I'd prefer the low noise set.
Did the Mavic Pro Speed controllers get updated because they (DJI) came up with the 8330 prop. Are the speed controller totally new, or just recalibrated? Thanks for all your super helpful Videos - indepensible!!
Greatly appreciate the video Russ.
My thoughts are ... why would anyone skimp on the cost of replacement props? If performance was improved I’d buy the best of the best. The UAS is over $1000... putting cheap props on these aircraft is like putting Walmart tires on a Porsche!
Nice video, agree with you, quiet drone is the wy to go because people doesn't like drones. I have a Parroty Anafi and it's extremely quiet
Hi mate, thanks for sharing your comparison. I have a question for you, now that the Mavic 2 and Air 2 are out and both nice competitors for the Mavic Pro we own ; if I have extra propellers, will the fit as spare propellers on the Mavic 2 or the Air 2? Have you tried?
like you, I will stick with the DJI low noise props my Platinum came with. Still flying with the original props (still in excellent condition) and have the extra set as back up. The 1+ mph loss means nothing to me. Quiet and time of flight / warranty means a lot. I do like the looks of the white props though (if I had the white Apple Mavic Pro).
Interesting video and thanks for the work you put into it.
Those Hyeic's seem like a huge bargain to me!
There are now carbon fiber 3 bladed props available that fir the Mavic 2 Pro, provides 33% more lift if you want to piggyback a load or fly in higher winds...
Good Info Russ, Merry Christmas to all!
Hi Russ.
Great comparison vid.
Just the warranty issue with using non dji products but if your not concerned what the heck....
I'll take any freebies. 👍🏻👌🏼
Hey Russ! Thanks for the comparisons. Would love to have some extra props!
Hi Russ. Thank you for the insight into props. I am guessing that if you carried a set of different branded, or even, a different design of the same branded props, you need to ensure all props are changed to the same. I would imagine the weight and design may differ and thus function slightly awkward. You obviously can’t mix props. Though your idea of an extra full set of props (cheaper set avail. in Australia) is a very good point. It would have been a useful idea for me in the past.
Regards,
Sam C.
Thanks for the review. I love the look of the white master props, wouldn’t mind a set of those. Until now I’ve been enjoying the low-noise props from DJI on my platinum pro, have done some insane flying with those. I find the tips are a bit soft, so I lost one pair during a risky landing on a moving boat during a waterski session. It clipped the tips off and immediately the noise got much louder, but she still flies. I also lost a pair to my cat, who decided they make a nice chew toy when I wasn’t watching. 🤦♂️ hahaha. Idea for a future test/video: How much damage can the props have until the drone becomes totally unflyable? Be safe, happy holidays.
Thoughts on the tri-blade props? Love your channel keep up the great content 👍🏼
I wouldn't get them. Not worth the risk.
Good to know. I went ahead and just ordered the low noise ones. Thanks!
Would love to try the low noise ones!