Attack on Titan’s Ending Analysis | The Honest Truth
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 พ.ย. 2023
- I'm back to unpack the jaw-dropping ending of Attack on Titan. Whether you've read the manga or not, the conclusion might leave you with mixed feelings - I know it did for me. In this video, I'll share my candid thoughts on how the anime adaptation handled the finale. We'll explore the highs and lows, discussing what worked and what didn't. Join me for an honest, passionate conversation about the series we all love. Hit like, share your thoughts in the comments, and don't forget to subscribe for more anime insights! Let's dive in!
FOLLOW ON TWITTER ‣ @KingBullet_
SUBSCRIBE ‣ @KingBullet123
SUPPORT ‣ @kingbullet
BUSINESS INQUIRIES ‣ kingbulletbiz@gmail.com
#attackontitan #aot #anime - บันเทิง
Why does nobody care that Zeke's death stopped the Rumbling? Eren broke the requirment for the royal blood in the Path Arcs.
Yeah Ik I forgot to mention it in this vid I’ve talked about it I other ones.
Remember when Eren touched Dina and commanded the titans in season 2? Then even a little bit afterwards he ran away and still had some power to command?
I think the power lingers a little bit even after a severed direct connection.
Edit: Since he had this power for like a day and some change I’m sure it wasn’t all just gone super quickly.
@@UpturnTheUncool You don't even understand the matter here. Eren BROKE the royal blood requirement in the Path episodes. Royal blood wasn't needed any longer for Eren to use the power of the Founding Titan.
Not to mention that the Wall Titans are just 60 meters tall Pure Titans. Without the Founder's control they should have moved by themselves.
Mikasa Married Farmer kun just like Historia. Farmer kun real Chad what you talking about. Farmer kun told Eren and the other they should do the fighting while he lay seeds 😂😂😂
Feels valid.
Absolutely based and valid
I had never read the manga before so I had no idea they would spoil it this bad. They did Eren literally the gravest injustice. What was all that character development for until now? Why did he have to say those powerful and vengeful words, why was he portrayed with a conviction that was unshakable? That scene in the last episode where he had the conversation with Armin, watching it was a literal nightmare. They did him so bad. I cannot get over it. The story literally revovled around Eren. He was at the center of it all. And then in a moment, they just threw it all away. What a disappointment.
I literally dont understand why some people dislike the ending, could you explain yourself a bit more?
I'll tell you my pov:
Eren saw the entire timeline the moment he touched Historia (changed him forever) and he even tried to go against it but he saw there was no way to avoid the loss of his friends, so he turned himself into the villain so that his friends would kill him and become world heroes like the Tybur, this way keeping the peace in Paradise for decades if not centuries, allowing his friends to live a long life and removing titans from the world.
Zeke's plan or Eren's alternative of running away with Mikasa both would lead to Paradise still being hated and attacked and his friends dying, he saw no other way.
In the end, hatred will always exist in humans which is why they show us after many many centuries, civilizations still fall but Eren's goal was ultimately to keep the peace on his time and he succeeded, allowing his home to be safe and his friends having a long life like he told them. Btw, I'm not defending Eren I wanted his friends to stop him but I do love the story.
It's a bittersweet ending, I really liked it. This was never a conventional show with good guys and bad guys. It was great imo.
he was only acting according some dickheads
@@MrWestSkywhat u are doing is only summarising the ending. the ending isn't so hard to understand. We all hate it ended the way u said which imo is some bad writing and not in line of progression of the show Also the fact that he can't change ending is some weak af writing. Also Eren acting out of character for some weird reason. oh yea its because of his love his step-sister. very deep.
@@sidgrg280 This is gonna be long probably, sorry about that, no problem if you dont wanna read.
"we all hate it" is not true, I've seen so many forums and videos filled with people that love it because the anime explained the ending so much better than the manga.
I don't see the writing being weak since the whole point of "time travel" in this show is the fixed timeline scenario where it doesn't matter what you do, it always leads to the same place because the future has already happend, it's fixed. That means, if you time travel you are unknowingly causing the future you want to prevent.
Imo that's the best kind of time travel, in other shows where you can change everything it just leads to way too many plot holes and things that just can't be explained or imagined.
In any case, in AoT there is no time travel actually, it's just attack titan shifters able to see the future, but whatever.
Eren was not out of character, that's a misconception from people who just wanted him to be edgy and broody like in season 4. He wasn't acting either, he was just going through the story knowing exactly what had to happen, living in the past present and future all at the same time inside his head.
But in the talk with Armin, he knew he was at the last moment, about to die and he shows us the real Eren we've seen in season 1-3, just a regular person that doesn't want to die and is selfish like every other human, loves his friends and wants to live with them, etc.
I just think people who hate the anime ending (the manga wasn't as well explained) forgot the story, if you rewatch the show in a binge, you can tell the ending was always there, ever since the first episode and you can see Eren as he is.
Anyway I dont want to change your mind, I just wanted a talk because I'm still so hyped from just finishing the anime hehe but I stumbled upon this video filled with people that dont like the ending so I wanted to get your perspective.
I found other videos filled with people like me that love it so I dont mean to annoy here so in case I dont hear back, thanks for the chat!
@@MrWestSky We as in the ending haters not the whole fandom.
Well you can explain and polish all you want. A shiny turd is still a turd. The time travel shit I am not really a huge fan of but it created a lot of inconsistencies and plotholes. Like him killing his own mum is such a lame paradox.
Also idk what you mean the ending all was all there. We ain't got a short term memory dude. Eren didn't ever have romantic interest in mikasa. if anything its Historia who really connected with eren mentally and emotionally in many episodes we watched. The ending seems to have been ret-conned to have mikasa be the main character rather than Historia to explain their love for each other to please Japanese fans. Also there is a way to show his human side and that is not by making him a little crybaby wimp. i really do not accept the pathetic way they assassinated his character there. Even if we had to see him cry he didn't have to cry for the most pathetic thing which seemed so stupid.
The ending was too convenient, simple and straightforward. Like nothing of sort which we have come to expect from AoT. before we used to have to look out for small details which would be extremely important down the line. Everything was set up for an epic ending like all the puzzles fit together perfectly but unfortunately it seems there wasn't any puzzle to solve at all. Everything had to be taken at face value because it's the truth somehow.
5:29-5:53 Jesus Mikasa is actually crazy
Mikasa is actually based off the female lead of Muv Luv Sumika who is mentally deranged due to an alien experiment.
@@KingBullet123 oh my god
@@Odin69
If you want to see similarities. There’s A LOT.
muvluv.fandom.com/wiki/Kagami_Sumika
@@KingBullet123 awesome thanks!
@@KingBullet123how about a video on a what if hagoromo (hagoromo in his astro form with all tailed beast vs yhach or full power dms Obito who took on kaguya vs ichibe . Would be a good fight.
Eren's character was so consistent and had a huge development up until the last scene. Not that what he says to Armin about how he feels about Mikasa but it is how it came out of nowhere.
And people say "Eren always cared about Mikasa so it is obvious that he loves her" No, it is not obvious, I agree that he cares about her but it does not mean he loved her.
If you are an author, in order to convey your character's emotions especially romantic feelings, you gotta set that up and must have an actual build up and development in the actions and behaviors of your character, so that your audience can pick it up without having it to be plain and obvious.
I have no problem with Eren loving Mikasa, but writing only two scenes where Eren has an interaction that slightly hints the possibility of romance between him and Mikasa is not solid proof of him loving Mikasa for the whole time and it felt so off. Have Eren looking at Mikasa the same he looked at Historia, have Eren talking and defending Mikasa the same way Eren talked to Historia when scouts about to sacrifice Historia, then it sure works just fine.
Isayama is sht at writing romance.
Instead of thinking about historia when zeke was talking about love with him, eren could've recalled mikasa, scarf, their moments, anything. But no
Also, in order to be able protect itself better in 50 years, paradis, for instance, could have forced mikasa and levi to have as many children as possible (for the Ackerman army), just like historia, and it would be a perfect chance for eren to show how much he cared about his sis
While I did enjoy how much easier the anime ending was to digest, and even enjoyed it, there were just so many inconsistencies, plot holes, and things that didn't make sense. In all those years, Ymir never saw another person know how to love and let go? Zeke dying should not have stopped the rumbling as Ymir chose to support Eren and not listen to Zeke, which is the very reason the rumbling even started. How were the pure Titans so powerful and so menacing that even Shifters had trouble with groups of them, but now they are easily going up against many shifters? If Eren had the power to control Titans, he could have just stopped the titans from destroying the walls and his mother, yet did nothing. Historia's and Eren's conversation about the baby was pointless. The War hammer Titan served no purpose. Eren not knowing why he did what he did was terribly explained, as he said he also did to make his friends heros. Reiner and Annie both needed to die to atone for the crimes they committed. Had they tackled these things, the ending could have gone from a 5 to a 10. Overall, the anime is still my favorite of all time. And even if I don't agree with the ending and how they dismissed some of the themes of Eren's character, I still enjoyed it and accept it for what it is.
Bro it is not so easy to just write an ending everyone will like I get ur criticisms but I think if u look into it enough they were the best outcomes and they had a titan that could fly what was these other shifters finna do they could just camp the attack which they did and it worked and when were the pure titans a major threat
I agree with you with everything except the end😆😆 Just like AOT. Jokes aside I can’t ever accept this ending. There was even more things wrong with the ending than the things you mentioned. I’ve been writing about it for days just trying to cope with the pain.
This is gonna be long so just know I mean no offense here and just wanted to touch on the points you made. 😊
So there probably wasn’t a person who could help her in her specific case and if there was, there probably wasn’t one that would obtain the founding. It’s a little flawed yes, but honestly I think she was meant as a talking point of love and how it affects us all after the show was over. Like even if the ending were completely perfect in every other way she was meant to be a talking point.
Zeke dying being what stops the rumbling makes sense. She was still attached to the king/royal blood. Once he was detached from Zeke and his founder body, Eren still had residuals of his power (just like he did in season 2 after touching Dina).
Just like in Season two even Reiner had trouble holding them back and some of them were people he knew like Connie, his mom and Jean making them more hesitant I’m sure, plus that thing was persistent in getting to Eren and was giving Reiner a hard time before Eren became the colossal.
For eren having power to control the titans, I believe some sacrifies are necessary for progression. You really can’t save everyone especially since you don’t have control of everyone (Ackerman memories and Titan shifting, Marley, Azimobito, other nations etc)
I don’t remember the talk about Historia’s baby, I just know Historia wanted to do what was best for the island and the Mp’s made it so that she basically does nothing. ’ll leave that alone though.
Without the war hammer Titan Eren would’ve died in the fight between the armored and the Jaw. If you mean that the war hammer person served no purpose…well…I really can’t argue with you there. Like they tried but…😂
Okay here’s where a lot of people get things messed up. I agree it wasn’t explained the best, but the subtext is what matters. It seems like you understand there is subtext so I won’t go into detail about what it is but they’ve gone over almost all reasons and explainations for why someone would do this and what would happen afterwards etc. the logical way. At this point it’s time for emotion-true emotion. No more of this stoic “I can do it all” attitude especially after talking for SO long in the paths.
Reiner and Annie needing to die is opinion-based. Plenty of deliberately bad people, and people who are bad against their will live long lives. By that logic everyone should be dead. I get they did horrible things but whose to say that, like Reiner has been doing since season 2, they’re not both lamenting outside the scenes we see in the end.
The reason Eren started the rumbling is because he truly wanted it to happen.
I feel like it’s worth noting that when Eren talks about him being a “slave to freedom” it’s the freedom by his own definition-the one that he refers to when he reverts back to his child self among the colossal titans and says “this is true freedom.” Which loops back to the point of the real reason why he started the rumbling which was to achieve his childish desire-the ideal world he saw in armin’s book essentially, an emptied world with a clean slate that he was able to experience. Like he said to Ramzi (that kid he broke down to) he was disappointed at the mere fact that humanity EXISTED beyond the walls not disappointed necessarily with HOW they acted (even though that might be a secondary thought)
By no means was Eren controlled. He HAD a choice. In the Marley Arc, Eren made it in such a way that he had "no choice". He saw the future, yet does not choose to find alternatives. He CHOSE to believe what he saw because he WANTED it to happen. For example, if you saw a future where you would have to kill your best friend and didn't want it to happen, you would probably avoid meeting up with your best friend. Simply because you want to avoid such a situation to happen in the future at all costs. Eren's action, on the other hand, made such a way that he was able to do the rumbling.
Eren uses noble deeds and thought processes like "saving" Paradis, protecting his friends for his selfish desires ( the ideal world he wished to see in Armin’s books )
That’s why people are wrong when they try to say that Eren “hoped” for his friends to stop him. He simply hoped for his friends to SURVIVE the rumbling he initiated. And when Eren said he tried so many solutions and none of them worked, those solutions were ONLY valid to him if it succeeded in achieving his own true definition of “freedom” and hopefully his friends surviving his choices based on the choices they made/make thus-forth . He wouldn’t budge HIS dream of freedom- he only chose solutions where it was in a way a “win-win” for him and his friends. For example if Eren wipes out the entire population, paradise and his friends would be ok, if he wipes out 20% like in canon it would “level the playing field” for years to come at least for all his friends to live long lives out of conflict. If you really think about it he didn’t really even care about paradise because when he started the rumbling the walls crumbling killed so many eldians in paradise just to initiate his freedom dream.
Again, Mikasa’s dream sequence was one of those alternate solutions Eren thought of, but he even said when talking to Mikasa that he regretted the outcome so much. That’s why Eren calls himself an idiot, it’s a deflection. He knows the solutions he seeks is totally motivated by selfish desires and just like his nature pushes him to act the way he does-he had to of known his friends, especially Armin would act in their nature and disagree with that solution for its absurdity and thus conflict between him and them would ensue. Again he hoped they would deviate from that choice for their own survival for he even admits if they didn’t stop him he would of flatten the entire earth. This is why Eren went from "I did this for you guys" to "I had no choice, the FT's power messed up my head" to "I just wanted to do it" during his conversation with Armin. Because he tried justifying his actions.
Even symbolically in the anime when Armin handed him the shell which represents his version of their dream the hopeful one of freedom; it’s handed to Eren in his bloodied hands. He could never achieve the dream that he and Armin wanted without it inherently being interwoven with bloodshed even though Armin said this dream was “at your feet” the whole time. It was accessible in a different way, a way that was “closer to home” except Eren kept neglecting that option in pursuit of his own desires pushed by his nature. That’s why I even think that Armin shouldering the blame was a complete act of consolation for a friend who has done the unthinkable. How do you console somebody that has done that type of action accept trying to lessen the load. Armin did his fair share of atrocities like when he killed all those civilians in the Marley invasion. But he was ultimately put in that position by Eren because Eren knew that Armin and everyone else would have to rescue him allowing Hume to continue on his path to initiating the rumbling.
So all in all
Being so unsure of the future, Eren kept it to himself which is reasonable. He isn't "controlled", everything he does is because he wants it-it’s his nature like he conveyed back at the cabin when killing the kidnappers. Eren CHOSE to believe what he saw in the future, instead of trying to change it, he did exactly what he saw. Why? Because he WANTED the rumbling to happen.
TLDR: I don’t know what I just read
Or maybe Eren wasn't controlled and just didn't have a choice other than the rumbling? He literally begged Hange for another option, he tried weighing out his other options and didn't immediately just go for the option where there'd be the most bloodshed, he is not doing the rumbling for funsies, it's because he doesn't have a choice, kill or be killed.
Ping me so I can go back to this
and also Eren didnt care about views in Armin book.
Thank you for putting this down, lots of people want to see media for its entertainment value only. What irks me about this story is its messy philosophy. Eren doesn’t make sense to anyone and not even Eren himself. The story subtly admits that Eren has always acted selfishly but doesn’t do enough to oppose his philosophy. Nobody in the story questions the whole “I don’t have a choice” BS which is exactly why we get Eren genocide apologist fanboys.
I’m pretty sure that falco’s Titan represents the call to action telling mikasa to leave the dream. Remember that while she is having this vision she is riding on falco’s back
Just wanna say I've been subscribed to you ever since your first AoT manga ending video, so this video feels kinda nostalgic. Overall this is really a good analysis.
Armin: Eren why did you do the Rumbling?
Me: He's gonna say it was for Paradis.
Eren: I don't know why I did it. I'm an idiot.
Me: Bruh .....
Eren: The Truth is that Ymir ...
Me: Ymir had love for her children right?
Eren: Ymir was in love with King Fritz
Me: ....wtf?!
true. i never understand ymir loving fritz. blind stan would say "oh she's just so blindly in love that she accepted toxic relationship". bruh.
ever heard of stockholms syndrome? AoT isn't for everybody.
@@aidan2849 "AoT iSn'T fOr eVeRyBodY"
Really is this your response to a differing viewpoint than your own? The whole problem with the reveal that Ymir was in love with Fritz is problematic because we were told this rather than it being organically shown to us.
@@GM-dg6mj It's also a disservice to Eren and Mikasa too.
@@aidan2849for 300 years while being able to see what he does to her children than admits the love was fake anyway ?
I was surprised when I saw that they removed the "you became a mass murderer for our sake" line since I knew a big number of manga readers did like the ending and I didn't knew Isayama made multiple apologies for the other half of the fandom
I remember reading the chapters as they came out and debating on various platforms, we thinking multiple possible outcomes as we consumed inhuman amounts of copium (like the AoT no Requiem alternate ending) and each chapter seemed to take the LITERAL WORST PATH, I mean like, Isayama had multiple ways of making a good ending but he wrote himself into a corner where the only reasonable solution to giving the story proper clossure was justifying genocide so he got scared and decided to give us a lame ending
This is more personal for me but I really get bittersweet feelings and kind of annoyed when I think how dirty they made my girl Ymir (the fake one) she was my favourite character and died offscreen and Historia ended up marrying the fucking farmer (I would be pleased if Historia decided to name her daughter Ymir or something but nope)
Isayama said in a recent interview that he apologises because he didn't make clear what he ment with that scene. This is why he improved it
In isayamas defence im pretty he recently said that he already concluded the ending of aot since the beggining of him writing aot so he was just writing on how to get to that ending
>improved
There’s no improvement. It’s just more bad writing.
weebs are allergic to good writing, because they never read proper literature. Not to dis on the manga, but the medium suffers from overusing the same tropes and getting away with murder due to overreliance on popularity polls, which incentives authors and editors to change/milk the work in order to satisfy the community. Books are usually less vulnerable to those issues.
@@Alessio-tt6pp Not by much though.
so pissed what the author did to eren at the end
How so
the author knows his character the most. ya'll just forgot who the real eren is.
@@meepmeep2706lmaooooo. He admits he didn't know what to do with the story and admits he changed the Initial ending.
I hope the conclusion of Attack on Titan is similar to the Breaking Bad finale.
@@meepmeep2706 Creators also make stupid decisions with there own work and characters all the time, remember when George Lucas has said that the force is just magic Bacteria that certain people can interact with.
I think that most of the narrative in the very last chapter of the manga that contains the talk with Armin and Eren explaining why everything happens, and the reason why Ymir was the one who create Eren the way he was, to do The Rumbling and see if she can kill someone she loves, is too forced and also unconvincing.
One reason now Eren is an idiot with too much power that is just following what Ymir wants, and he kills his mother because is what like that but in the chapters where he comes and talk with Reiner in Liberio he ask why his mother has too die, and also where reach Marley's coast with the march of the colossals he curses the humans remembering when he sees his mother dying, and then when he talks to Armin he says he is just a stupid dude with power who is just following the path of Ymir his whole life even the death of his mother
And two I don't see any parallel with Mikasa and Ymir other than both loves someone that apparently there feelings are corresponded, with just that lt makes me understand that Ymir craft Mikasa's love for Eren to be in some way parallel with her to king Fritz but there is a difference king Fritz saw Ymir like a slave, Eren don't see Mikasa in that way so she could recreate king Fritz in Eren.
Thats why I don't feel convince with the narrative of the very last chapter with the extend content in Attack On Titan and ruin everything what was elaborated from the start of the story because all was a craft of Ymir.
Isn't it supposed that when Eren said that to Reiner, he said it in the form of a question?he also is some like about to ''cry''when he talks about him directing dina to kill his mother.
@@Joyscp999 Yes indeed and also at that moment know the answer.
@@verron1600
Yes, but he was still saying it in the form of a question, and as we know, he mostly faked many of the things he did.
@@Joyscp999 Mostly faked? I don't get it.
@@verron1600 ok
Imagine someone serves you the most amazing meal, and during dessert they place a giant turd in your dish. Now they proceed to take out a few pieces of the turd from your plate, but there is still a turd on your plate.
That’s how I feel about this whole situation.
Also that scene where Grisha and Kruger help the alliance still makes my blood boil. Based on their past actions they, nor any other attack Titan, have absolutely no reason to save a world the openly advocates for the eradication of Eldians.
☝️ I'm glad to see how many people understand how and why the ending is bad.
On the note of Freckled Ymir, her parallels and, by extension Historia's was thrown out the window.
That shet right there is Pain
But no, it was Mikasa who paralleled Ymir..
Remember that grisha didnt want the rumbling to begin with, and based on this is safe to assume Kruger either.
Man, the volume of silly headcannon ending haters have never stops to amaze me..
"Also that scene where Grisha and Kruger help the alliance still makes my blood boil"
What the hell are you even saying? So in your head Grisha was like "yea, genocide is a really nice thing, wont gonna help to stop it for sure"?
He even said he was disgusted by the future he see and never imagined it will be so horrible.... And yet you somehow imagine that Grisha would be totally okay with it. HOW???
@@nerdError0XF What headcanons are you referring to bruv? Marley’s entire warrior program was to identify Eldians with the best attributes suited for their corresponding titans. Why would the inheritors of the attack Titan be chosen differently?
Yes watching them fight to save the very people who call for their eradication, after seeing the lengths they went to restore Eldia, does indeed make my blood boil. You’d have to be insane, or a self-hating white person crippled by ‘white guilt’ to protect your oppressor.
Also if Grisha was so against the rumbling then WHY THE HELL DID HE GIVE EREN THE POWER TO ACTIVATE THE RUMBLING?!??
There are blatant and plot holes in the ending that anyone who actually paid attention to the story can spot.
@@wobbegong4366but dude was right, you just ignored the main point he made to keep complaining. Y'all wanted something you didn't get but the ending was fine. The wasn't plot holes. Maybe plotlines that didn't get fleshed out. But because you didn't like something doesn't make it a hole
Carla Yeager has brown eyes, so it would make sense that Eren would pass those genes to his daughter.
I’m glad to see more videos poppin up that are actually criticizing the flaws in this ending. Seems the majority are this endin up & that’s fine and all but it’s fuckin annoying to see one of em talkin bout how we didn’t get the story when we ain’t really sayin shit bout them😭
Eren did nothing wrong
Also Eren:
Mass murder
Genocide
Nigh-omnicide
Mass destruction
War crimes
Terrorism
High treason
Abuse of power
Assault and battery
Blackmail
Usurpation
Kidnapping
Mutilation
Jailbreak
Insurrection
Crimes against peace
Animal cruelty
Ecocide
Identity fraud
Parricide
Cannibalism
Psychological abuse
Conspiracy
Brainwashing
Crimes against humanity
@KingBullet123 wow its not like Thanos or griffith did some bs. Why you never call that out? Unlike them, eren was justified
Real
@@CombatUnit621 exactly
I will still say the baby is Eren's
Great points. But I would like to add to the message turns to be pointless and that nothing ever resolves, i am sorry but i think it is worse than that. If in AOT the future is predetermined and eren cant change it, because that is what his excuse was to what he did, then the story is not about erens journey or any of the character we went years with. But about Ymirs disturbing fantasy of knowing that Mikasa will kill eren, so she makes eren take these decisions so that she can then sort of, not really end the titan curse. It is so dumb.
This comment needs more upvotes. I couldn't believe what I was seeing when I read the manga ending, so I was 100% sure that an AOE was happening. Couldn't have been more wrong.
@@blackeuropean4700lmaoo thats tuff
I agree with everything you said. Sadly ending defenders will still come up with bs excuses 😂😂😂
I wonder what Ymir would do if mikasa died before murdering eren or at the last moment changed her mind and didn't decapitate his head. Wait for someone for 2000 years again?😂
Not only that but if Mikasa's future was predetermined too and there was no other option, that leads to the conclusion ymir saw it 2000 years ago and knew it would happen, which is even worse because that means she didn't need to witness it in reality and help eren kill 80 % of mankind. And what choice exactly did she wanna see so bad? The girl killing eren or kissing him? How can any of these 2 factors end titans?
What a stupid character. So many people died meaninglessly
For all the people saying “I’d like to see you write a better ending”. Like damn can I not criticise or have an opinion on sports or politics either because I’m not an world class athlete or politician.
EDIT:
I will concede on one mistake I made during this video. The Marley solider who spared the alliance already changed his minds on hating the Paradisians before Armin’s speech so sparring them makes sense since they tried to stop the Rumbling.
I despise the people attempting to endorse Eren at the end.
This whole 'He WaS a GReAt gUY' "I WiSh I cOuLd'VE CHatTEd wItH hiM" comments by the protagonists at the end was the most toxic crap I've ever heard. Eren wanted to lure every one he ever cared for into an unbeatable battle and had multiple legit opportunities to end all the titans powers without killing 80% of humanity. How the hell Eren gonna say "I tried but I can't change the future." when he ends the convo with Armin with "I wanted to see it through." The most toxic friendship I've ever seen in anime.
NEW KING VID LETS FUCKING GOOOO!!!!!!
I think the ending is good but this is probably one of the best critiques on it that I’ve seen compared to other people💀
Most other people just cba to make in depth videos anymore if you where here around 3 years ago this shit went in depth there where vids around 1h 30 pointing loads of plot holes and bad narrative and they where barely scratching the surface because beside the bad writing and plot holes there was multiple plot points that where just never ever addressed I know the Titan hallucigenia is one of them but that’s all I remember
@@little_error295Balls deep video was insane that video will destroy all ending lovers
@@aotgoat3267 there was a video made by some guy he’s changed his name now and does GOT vids so can’t remember him sadly but he made a crazy long video going into depth of the problems with the last chapters alone 💀 not even the whole thing was mad entertaining to watch man I miss those days with all the bird memes
@@little_error295 hopefully anime only fans wake up and realise it’s crap. I saw 2 reaction vids. 1 guy was saying I don’t know what is going on throughout the ending and bro was just lost and at the ends bros crying and saying it’s the best way to end aot😂 the other one was 2 people trying to explain why it’s so good and all they were doing was waffling and stuttering through the whole explanation. I think the ending is….. yh this part was …… I think aot is trying to sh……..💀💀💀😂
@@little_error295 reactions channels starting from now who watch it should say it’s dead cause the hype is now gone and they watched the episodes days apart not years so they should still remember how old Eren was and how he contradicts himself
Anime fans are phantom menacing with this ending
I feel a bit sad its like gt ending where everyone gets old and die
atleast they live most of their lifespan like a normal human being where they won't be thrown to fight wars or die of titan curse.
Reasons to why it’s a terrible ending.
1 How did his friends survive the titans? They lose Sasha to 3 titan shifters and 2 kids but lose no one against 100s of titan shifters?
2. Zeke dying shouldn’t of stopped the rumbling. Ymir’s goal was to destroy the world so why didn’t Ymir just continue the rumbling after zeke died?’
3. Zeke should of stopped the rumbling earlier because his dad telling him “ please stop Eren” didn’t give him motivation to die so he can stop it but armin showing a ball did?
4. How did mikasa free Ymir?😂 and no it isn’t because she was able to kill her lover and move on no no no she didn’t move on for crap she still had that scarf on and got buried next to Eren.
5.Ymir doesn't have Stockholm’s syndrome, if she did why did she not heal herself when a spear went through her? If she had Stockholm’s syndrome she would of had the will to live for the king. Ymir’s character is terrible. She is in the paths because she is a slave to Fritz but disobeyed him ?
6 Eren ch139 (last 30 mins)
“ I’m an idiot”
“I don’t know why I did the
rumbling”
“ I moved forward for mikasas choice”
“ I did it to portray u as heroes” 💀💀💀💀
“ I would of killed them all if u didn’t stop me”
Pre ch139
“Ill keep moving forward until I destroy my enemies “
“The only way to end the cycle of hatred is to bury it”😂
7.Ain’t no soul answering this question. If Ymir can see the future then why did Ymir wait till mikasa kills Eren who somehow frees her when she can see the future and knows that mikasa will kill Eren? Why did she wait for it to happen when she knows what the result is? She should of been free since she entered paths
8. What was the point of destroying 80%? eldia got destroyed. What did he achieve by doing that? He made the outer world hate eldians more and doomed paradises safety which he promised ( Eren only cared about Eldias safety not cycle of hatred so eldia bombing themselves is irrelevant for him)
9. What was the reason for the rumbling ?
It defo wasn’t to make them look like hero’s because Eren said if u didn’t stop me I would of killed them all which is a contradiction.
10. Erens mom death was pointless. He already said he killed her because it wasn’t bertholdt time yet which means it wasn’t to fuel his hate for titans💀He already had the determination to lead him were he already is. When mikasa’s parents got killed he said “ if anyone tried to take away my freedom I won’t hesitate to take theirs” he also said to his dad that the kidnappers were scum and animals that needed to die. Eren before his moms death wanted to join the survey corps and venture outside the walls. If he found out the world wants to kill him he would of started the rumbling because they tried to take his freedom and we knew what Eren thinks about that. Erens view of freedom was killing everyone outside the walls so he 100% has the determination to do the rumbling. (Anyone who says Eren view of freedom wasn’t killing everyone u need to rewatch the last episode where he was talking to ramzi the kid
11. In ch130 ( episode where the ships get destroyed in Marley) Eren thinks about his mom getting eaten by the titan and it being his main motivation for the rumbling which makes no sense since Eren should know that he killed his mom because this is when he sent armin to paths and told him everything.
12.The whole Eren at the cabin scene. How did eren interact with mikasas memories? She is an Ackerman he Shouldn't be able to do that. people who are saying this is a different timeline pls provide ur proof. If it is a different timeline why does Eren have titan marks? Why do they also grow bigger the closer Eren gets to death? They become massive when she is holding erens head representing that it was a fake memory. The bigger the titans marks the closer she gets to reality
13. Eren crying like a baby for mikasa is a retcon. When did Eren ever cry like this for mikasa? He alway pushed mikasa away from him. When Eren found out he has a 8 years to live mikasa was in jail with him, did he care about her then? No he didn’t even care about mikasa when he found out he dosnt have long left to live even isayama said mikasa is a mother figure for him so how exactly does him crying like a baby fit his character?
14. Eren said to armin he will show them the memories after he gets killed but shows it to mikasa before he gets killed?
15. How did Eren turn into the collosal titan after zeke died and the worm left him ?😂😂😂
16. There was literally no point in the rumbling, the outside worlds wants to kill then because their just eldian. What makes Eren think destroying 80% of the world then letting armin kill you to look like a hero does? Stop them from hating eldians? No😂 they will hate u more💀
I DONT WANT TO HEAR ANY HEAD CANNONS. I WANT YOU TO SHOW PROOF
Ymir’s motives never made any sense to me also did they ever explain what that worm thing is? The thing that made Ymir into the first titan
Ymir wanted everyone dead what zeke was the only thing allowing eren to use the power when zeke died everything stopped cause the physical royal blood was the thing that even let eren get into the paths
1. How did his friends survive the titans? They lose Sasha to 3 titan shifters and 2 kids but lose no one against 100s of titan shifters?(Eren dosnt even know if they would survive so no Eren didn’t let them survive
1 response: Sasha died to one kid with a rifle. Titan shifters didn't even see her. Idk why we act like feats from our protagonist's group shouldn't be ridiculous in a world that is ridiculous. Titan shifters weren't in their full capacity as we see from when they turn after Armin's and Zeke conversation.
2. Zeke dying shouldn’t of stopped the rumbling. Ymir’s goal was to destroy the world so why didn’t Ymir just continue the rumbling after zeke died? (Ymir already disobeyed zeke when he has royal blood so his death should be irrelevant)
2 response: Ymir just created titans. The rumbling was devised after her with the intention of collateral damage if Marley invaded the pacifistic King Fritz. Ymir could disobey, but that only stopped Zeke's plan. Once Eren had Zeke, it was just his existence that fueled the rumbling.
3. Zeke should of stopped the rumbling earlier because his dad telling him to please stop Eren didn’t give him motivation to die so he can stop it but armin showing a ball did?
3 response: Zeke tried to stop the rumbling. He was probably the closest to anyone prior to this last movie in terms of stopping it. Again, his own dad (like you mentioned) said he literally couldn't stop Eren. If you didn't get Armin's speech then that's on you, not gonna explain that.
4. Ymir doesn't have Stockholm syndrome, if she did why did she not heal herself when a spear went through her? If she had Stockholm syndrome she would of had the will to live for the king. Ymir character is terrible. She is in the paths because she is a slave to Fritz but disobeyed him twice?
4 response: your argument: "she did what her captor asked" wild that this is exactly how Stockholm syndrome is described: "the psychological condition of a victim who identifies with and empathizes with their captor or abuser and their goals. " (link below since it's a tough concept apparently) If her captor wants her dead, and she goes along with her captors wishes, does that not describe Stockholm syndrome?
@@Jay3up yes, they did explain it. I have no idea how you missed it, it was pretty straight in the face :/
Wiki page is called "Source of all living matter"
@@haydenbrown2090to point 2 I would add that it has already been explained that Eren can only tap into the full powers of the founder with a physical connection to someone of the Royal bloodline. We saw it when he punched the smiling titan and was able to control them for a short moment against Reiner.
So with Zeke gone it's not weird he could not continue the rumbling. The gang knew this, that is why the plan was to find Zeke and sever the connection. Many of these nitpicks I see can be explained within the established rules of this universe. I'm not going to say it has zero plot holes, but this series was very well put together from beginning to end.
We can see the story was planned out beforehand. I don't know why some people so desperately want the ending to be bad and find things to nitpick when there are very few shows that remain as consistently good as AOT.
How would Eren know what comes after his death? The entire point is that he can see the future of Attack Titan holders, including his own. If the Titans are removed from the world and he dies, then how is he meant to see anything after that point?
You need to rewatch the video. There were two possibilities. Either Eren meant that he knows the true nature of humans and that the island would be destroyed based on that notion. Or Eren never truly died post decapitation hence was able to wrap his scarf around Mikasa one last time. So witnessed the destruction of paradis through birds most likely.
@@KingBullet123
I don't know what the first part has to do with him being able to know the future past his death, and the second is just the assumption that Eren is the bird.
Also, is there reason to believe that Eren would be able to see a future past the point that he no longer had the Titan powers?
The colored baby in the crowd of Black and White people is a direct reference to Schindler's List's "girl in a red dress" btw. Just felt like pointing it out.
Armin: Eren why did you genocide 80% humanity.
Eren: Ah eto bleh. And lmao I felt like it.
i just realised something eren isn't really the main protagonist it has been secretly been mikasa this whole time even the speech that eren gave to ymir about choosing whatever she wanted to do meant nothing and hajime isayama cannot write female characters to save his life first he butchers historia then mikasa then annie and finally ymir was always in love with her rapist warlord and made annie completly dependant on armin and made mikasa revert back to eren even after he died
1:16-1:20 what is the ost pls ?
Since Eren and Zeke went into the paths this show has been going down hill.. I don't have a problem with people liking the ending. I just don't understand how so many people are able to call this a masterpiece when it is far from a perfectly written work.
Exactly the moment they went into the paths, the story was all doomed!
You make some valid points. It would’ve been nice for certain things to be resolved, but I think the ending could’ve been a lot worse than what we actually got.
Same, I only think Isayama rushed it a little bit which led to a lot of confusion
The copium is strong with this one
Great Analysis, just like last time. Hopefully this gains traction with the anime ending-you deserve the views to be honest. It’s definitely one of the better critiques of the ending, giving anime onlys context as to why many disliked it.
Not really though. This guy takes the symbolisms and paralelisms (and even the dialogue) waaay to literally. The titans are officially gone. Why would you believe that years in the future the Titans would come back? It's just another story, starting the same way as Ymir's story did. Eren's breakdown is mainly human because HE KNOWS he's about to die and doesn't want to be forgotten by his friends (especially the one he loves the most). The scene where he says "I'm just a simple minded idiot with too much power in his hands" makes sense when we take into account who Eren is: A kid (who's not right in the head) that thought that the solution to all of his problems was genocide. That in itself is a pretty stupid take. Still, it is kinda pathetic how he breaks down, but when you get the context, you understand why he cries like that.
Also, if you think that Eren's character was ruined in the last chapter then that doesn't make sense. By that logic Eren's character was ruined since chapter 131, when he feels sorry for the innocent people he is about to kill. If Eren was truly the cold hearted bastard we see at the start of S4, he wouldn't have cried at all, much less ask for forgiveness. Sorry for writing too long, but the reasons this guy gives for the ending being bad are either misconceptions or nitpicks.
I had to watch 7 hours of Musk podcasts just to ensure I didn’t go fully autistic from seeing Falco turn into a fucking pterodactyl.
No…just the fact that you point out the bird makes me think you watched the ending with your own prejudice embedded. You pointed out things opened to interpretation to make an negative argument about the ending. You got it all wrong.
Stop getting such a sophist. My criticism is vaild. The bird doesn’t have the cognitive capacity to do something like wrap a scarf on its own. It was most definitely Eren’s doing since he knows how much the scarf meant Mikasa and has an established connection to birds.
@@KingBullet123 in what kind of metaphysics he could do that??? I knew he could transform himself in a titan , not a fucking bird for god sake. That is a common technique that authors use to put things still up to interpretation there is no statement that the bird is Eren.
@@nothingandnobody9 its a series where titans and other supernatural abilities exist goober. You fallaciously appealing to reality. Eren has already factually seen through birds. Hence he has a a memory of looking over Falco.
Eren controlling Birds is the fairest assumption based on evidence. Much fairer than assuming the bird randomly wrapped her scarf for no reason.
@@KingBullet123 Eren was already dead by the time. It’s power vanished after his death. As I said the bird is an ambiguous symbol. You might believe it’s Eren but that doesn’t mean it’s the truth.
That would be a nice circle if Jean married Misaka. Eren and he fought when they first met even though Eren goes his whole life treating her like a sister.
i think you’ve misunderstood the situation with ymir and mikasas parallel. mikasa was never meant to “get over” eren fully because that’s not how grief or emotions work. she was meant to put her feelings in order to do what she needed to do for the greater good of humanity and for the good of herself. this was what ymir was unable to do. yes they were both heavily influenced by their love but the goal was never to stop loving, it was to not let love get in the way of what needed to happen.
This is simply not true. I think you’re not quite understanding. King Fritz was dead for 2000 years yet Ymir could not get over him.
Think about it king Fritz is DEAD yet Ymir was still in love with him. She needed a reason to not love him. So why should she separate herself from him if Mikasa hasn’t after Eren’s death?
The idea is Isayama believes Eren and Mikasa’s relationship is toxic since Mikasa believes it’s fated hence separation needs to happen. He admitted this in a 2014 interview.
Cope harder. You got the game of thrones season 8 treatment and there’s no way to defend it.
@@KingBullet123you are the one who doesn’t understand or pretend not to. Ymir wasn’t able to let the king go. Stop loving someone isn’t as simple or easy. Human emotions aren’t something you can control. Yet, our capacity to put our feelings a side for the greater good is in our hands. It’s not easy of course, but that’s exactly what this is about. If it was easy then there is no meaning. Mikasa putting her love a side to save humanity is something Ymir couldn’t do because her love for the king had Eldians and humanity suffering the consequences of titans.
@@bummiefanart5636stopping loving someone isn't simple or easy but it is inevitable. Obsessing over a long dead man for 2000 years is so unreasonably long it shouldn't happen.
Actual children don't cope that long.
@@mistake1197 but it happened. Thats her flaw. There is no reason or formula to explain it because it’s humans nature. Some do forget some others do not.
Bro even if like the ending this video of yours i love the bfact that's it wasn't a rant and.that you were more considerate of people you disagree with . I hope all aot ending critisizers or even haters were behaving like you in theirs content creation. Anyway disagree in many things but good video😊
Do you know how mikasa made it back to paradise carrying eren’s head?
Honestly I really didn’t like that they made Ymir in love with king fritz, it would’ve been better if she was only loyal to him for their children sake.🐱
Tbh I think it was more of years of slavery/ brainwashing rather than love
Stockholm syndrome
@@flowerboy821 It actually is not. For Stockholm syndrome be a thing, abuser should show at least a shred of compassion toward his victim. Here is zero. So Ymir is more like being pervert who love be raped humiliated by King Friez
@@flowerboy821more like Trauma Bond
@@flowerboy821lol 2000 year old Stockholm syndrome that for some reason mikasa was the only one who was able to save her from. Why mikasa you ask only Ymir knows 😂
I’ve never hated anything in life more than this ending
it was perfect
@@bozy0223real,idk wtf are these kids are talking about,lol
How so? I want valid reasons why you hated it. Put personal feelings aside and give me valid reasons why you hate it. Go on
Is there any actual reasons for the hate or it just didnt match with your headcannon?
@@bozy0223ed detected
I feel like anime’s that are great just end poorly sometimes for some fans. I wasn’t a hardcore AOT fan I watched it here and there so I don’t have a take on the ending
Just think about it: Isayama managed to create a silent character, with ZERO dialogue and ZERO monologue but still explore her backstory, struggles, suffering, mystery around her motivation, set such amazing parallels between her, the mc, historia, freckled Ymir, zeke and frieda only through her emotions and actions, symbolism and visuals, he connected it with aot's themes and its lore. He managed to write THIS... so she, ymir fritz, got to be destroyed by 3 gd lines ("only Ymir knows...", "ymir loved the king fritz" and "she was waiting for mikasa")
Just... why? WTH? FOR WHAT?
Where do I begin? Well, her love for the king... Firstly, no way it's Stockholm syndrome as this shit works differently. So, no. Secondly, even if she loved the king, WHEN did she start to develop feelings for him? Before freeing the pigs? After their marriage? After getting pregnant? When? Thirdly, WHY does she have affection for fritz? He ruined her life in every way, he abused her physically and mentally, he did the same to their children but she... Uh, ok, let's see (as if we can). It's clearly shown in 122 she hated her life with him. But fine, if she loved him, why did she disobey him by freeing the pigs and not regenerating? Why didn't she smile or wasn't happy when he was around? Why did she want him dead instead of her and regreted not letting fritz die? If she regretted this whole time, doesn't it mean she already put herself and her daughters above her husband so the titan curse could end sooner?
Now, ymir and mikasa... Their connection has NO buildup. It's never hinted at something common between these two throughout the entire show. The Ackerman's headaches had no allusion to the goddess. So why her? What about this woman made fritz choose mika? The fact she was an Ackerman? Or the person who was able to kill the love of her life? Um, couldn't ymir find someone else, like, sooner, 282 years ago FE, among millions of people, within 2000 years? Or it's because mika killed the founder when it separated from the hallucigenia? How does mikasa know her headaches are caused by ymir messing with her head if eren didn't tell her about that? Who knows, who cares...
Why even show so many well-written parallels between ymir fritz, eren, historia and freckled ymir if they have no payoff? Why does Ymir find herself in mikasa but not historia whom she has much more in common with? Historia is a better version of her, so why not wait for reiss? For what reason does she pick a girl with no dignity, self-respect and ability to move on or grow up? How are her relationship with fritz and eremika bond even similar? Eren didn't treat mikasa the way fritz treated his wife. Eren saved and freed mikasa, that assh*le enslaved and turned his woman's life into a nightmare. The mc and the king are completely different just like mika and ymir. What'd she do if mikasa suddenly changed her mind and didn't kill eren? Wait for 2000 years for someone again? How can mikasa help her move on from the king if she herself didn't move on from eren?
Next, if Ymir was the one to make titans in paths, who made her titan? Was the hallucigenia a separate organism or was it connected to fritz after giving her titan powers? If it wasn't connected to her, then why did it disappear instead of trying to find a holder? Why was it trying to find one at first but vanished after Eren's death? So the founder's death affects it? Then the hallucigenia should have died when Ymir died. But they're not connected, are they? Or the opposite? Ugh... Why did the founder split into 9 titans? Why not 6 or 27 or 3 if she had 3 daughters? If maria, rosa and shina were able to get their mom's power at the same time, does that mean both erwin and armin could eat bertholdt and become shifters together? And if these 3 ate the founder, shouldn't every descendant of the royal family possess it? Whose child inherited the founder? Rosa's? Maria's? Shina's? Or all simultaneously but after that it split into 9 titans? How did fritz know about the way of passing titan powers to new holders? Was Ymir dead when he fed her to their daughters? If she was, then her power should have been given to a newborn eldian. If she wasn't, then she let the king chop her into pieces and saw her daughters eat her? Is that even possible to stay alive after getting dismembered so many times? If she can rewrite her people's dna, that means she can lengthen their lifetime or make them invulnerable or immortal? Can she provide them with armor appearing out of their bodies or weapons out of the air? Or just stop them from turning into titans? About paths... I refuse to talk about how they work. It'd take one more paragraph
Additionally, whose side is Ymir on throughout the story? On fritz's, who planned to build Eldian empire? Or on Zeke's and Karl's who wished to end this empire's existence and wanted her descendants to die? Or on Eren's who tried to save some of them? Is she with mikasa who stopped eren from doing it? Or is she with the alliance who did everything in their power to save the rest of humanity on the continent? Or is she on the royal family's side? WHOM does she obey? Or is it just going with the flow of events? If that's the case, then how can she wait for mikasa? But if it's still for witnessing mika murdering eren, then why does she listen to zeke when eren enters paths? By this logic, she should join the mc right away to see him get killed as soon as possible. Why does she join eren at first and start the rumbling with yeager but then help the alliance defeat him? Why'd she do that to someone who made her moved to tears for the first time after 2000 years of suffering, who told her she's just a person, not a slave or a god, that she gets to decide and choose? Why are we told in the final mikasa saved her if eren already did that? Did she need help twice? If the mc wasn't the one to free her, how could she disobey zeke? Is eren her liberator or pawn? If a liberator, why didn't she tell him what tf she wanted or write shit on the sand, anything? If a pawn, why make a show "at your service, mr zeke" and weep after Eren's speech? Did eren and she even need zeke's royal blood after the rumbling started? Yes and no?
Also, what exactly made titans disappear? Eren's death, his refusal to live, the fact the hallucigenia separated from the mc, fritz seeing the kiss? What? Ymir's desire to stop? So you mean to tell me she wanted them to exist? She could refuse to make them anytime? Are you kidding me?
Why did she smile at the end of ch 138? Because eren got killed or because the goddess saw the kiss? What were those scenes with her watching everyone during the rumbling all about?
To think that for more than 100000+- years (if we take into account time in paths moves slower) she created MILLIONS of titans when shifters transformed and when eldians turned into them (dozens times a day), healed her descendants (once again, dozens times a day), changed or erased their memories, rewrote their dna, made shit from crystals, walked millions of kilometers to build titans, carried many-many pails with water and sand, climbed high to make enormous arms, heads, necks etc... for TWO THOUSAND YEARS she made her children and their children suffer, made the world endure, helped the mc start GENOCIDE, watched millions of people die and kill each other, witnessed her people eat one another and so on just because she COULDN'T MOVE ON FROM HER ABUSER! Do you realize how absurd and unrealistic it sounds?
What else should I say... Saintitchief is right: either she's the dumbest or the most despicable person ever. Either her plotline is retconned at the last moment or the author just didn't think it out properly (which is so unlikely if you remember the 1st episode's name). Or after all, maybe, just maybe, she was the true aot villain all along, not a victim as we thought. We were just ignorant to see it or didn't want to notice. Tmm, Ymir's character gained the worst conclusion in snk, even worse than eren as we didn't even get to know about her motivation. It remained a mystery because "only she knows...". Her arc was so unresolved and so underdeveloped. What was isayama even thinking?
I wish I could like this comment more than once.
isayama was trying to search for a excuse to try to explain the origin of the titans...well,two excuses,one worked,kinda,and the other was weird.
Ok. I read it all. Holy shit, man that would have taken a long time to write. I have found much better stories than AOT to spend my time on. Fucking hell. I cringe everytime I try to remember how the Manga ended. Damn.
If you are into Novels, then "The Beginning After the End" is one I am reading currently. I have caught up, and await a new chapter every week. Ubel Blatt is also really good. Ignore the fanservice, the story underneath is good. Holyland, Akumetsu, FUCKING Vinland Saga.
PS. Helck has a better story and more character depth than AoT. I cried more times reading that.
I ain’t reading allat
@@ShahjahanMasoodthanks for recommending TBATE. I read every single chapter released until last month and I must confess I didn't like it. I have no desire to wait for its continuation: 1) it's not the type of stories I prefer 2) the mc is boring, nothing but a garty stu and there are no exciting characters to watch. Kinda reminds me of solo leveling. Aot at least was interesting and intriguing until ch 122, I liked it for historia, grisha, reiner, eren, zeke and jean until all these characters got ruined. Now only gabi is my favorite. The 2 stories I mentioned above don't make me care, unfortunately
Eren isn't a bird and the bird didn't wrap the scarf around her. If you look earlier in that scene, she still had the scarf already around her neck. The bird just tugged at the scarf and Mikasa interpreted as Eren sending a sign, because grieving people want signs of their lives ones watching over them.
And Mikasa did let go. She was fated to protect Eren at all costs due to the Ackerman curse, and could never hurt Eren. She was a slave to him, like the founder was a slave to Fritz... but, she broke free, did the right thing by ending Eren, and showed the founder she could be free of her curse as well.
But, breaking free from fate and not being a slave doesnt mean Mikasa has to stop loving that boy. You can still love and long for someone after moving on. Its a mature concept that many might not understand. I hope that, one day, you will... because that type of love feels great and hurts at the same time, but beautiful all the same.
Like the quote from Wandavision, “What is grief, if not love persevering?”
@@junethanoschurchill6750 Wow, nice quote!!!
👏👏👏👏exactly!
Do you think mikasa still would’ve killed eren is she didn’t get that memory?
When eren dies along with the curse of ymir he can not see any further then that, so he can not determine future events except possibly the next founder in 20,000 years which is a indication that titans will return.
Eren the birb was trying to take the scarf bc he wanted Mikasa to get rid of it…
"historia is a fascist" is a wild line bro 💀
Even though I disliked the manga ending but I gonna give credit mappa and even Isayama so much for anime version, I genuine liked Eren and Armin conversation more than manga version, I also like that added original scenes, my favorite one is that mappa removed arm thanking eren for being a mass killer to instead Eren and Armin promised each other that they will have a reunion in Hell. Felt more organic, and they made the ocean scene into blood and Ereb holding teeth, hair of his victims and he felt remorse.
My rating for manga ending rating is 4/10, for anime version, 5.5/10
I think the thing I dislike most about the ending are all the smartasses being all "but you see, it was about how there will always be conflict no matter what happens" as if we havent seen that a million times before and they are such intellectuals for noticing it
or the "you just wanted a happy ending", no a good ending doesn't have to be a happy ending, and if that were to be what we wanted......that was pretty much what we got, the whole point of Eren's genius plan was to make sure everyone else could get a happy ending
The final message isn't something with a lasting impression since it's literally the same as every other season that passed before: "The Cycle of Hatred never ends"
I'm taking Season 3 as the final ending.
got two main criticisms
the bird that wrapped the scarf around mikasa could just be symbolic, eren doesn’t have to still be able to interact with the world
mikasa killing eren doesn’t represent moving on, it represents being able to have feelings for someone and still choosing to go against those feelings to do what’s right, which would be her killing eren in this case. although i kinda agree that’s it’s a weak motive for ymir to still be attached to the world.
sorry if i explained myself poorly, english isn’t my first lenguage
Armen tried talk a no jutsu in season 1 too it’s not out of character
And it was shown that it doesn't work.
He failed in s1 with better logic than the finale
@@wolware24 why would he not try again it be dumb if he just like I tried once now the be like it’s time to give up on you
@@mrbrightside6264 ^
How could you think to this day that Eren is the father lol 😂😂😂
Idk maybe considering that literally the most important themes of the story revolve around it.
@@KingBullet123 They don't because EH was never a thing.
So, the themes never resolved around them and their non existing chield.
@@affebanane3039 I means it’s undeniable those themes are directly and verbatim stated to exist and surround them in the second guidebook and should be pretty obvious regardless.
@@KingBullet123 just that it is without them banging like tennagers
@@KingBullet123 they exist on their own without Eren needing to be a Baby Daddy
Also there is a severe retcon eren said outside the walls the population is the same as paradise but paradise had a population of 1 million meaning killing 80% of the world would put the world population at around 5 million but marley had an army of 1 million men 💀 how is that possible and let’s assume that’s the case somehow and we be incredibly generous and assume there are only 1 million marley civilians why tf where they scared of falling behind militarily when there military population was 1/4 the entire planets population could you imagine a real world military with 2 billion soldiers and that’s assuming that there military is 50% of there population which is impossible marleys invasion of paradise doesn’t even make sense anymore
Did some searching and the highest soldier to population ratio is 5.76% being North Korea 😂 using that best case scenario ratio that would mean for marley to have a million man army they would need to have a total population of around 20+ million 4 times larger than the population of the entire aot world
Attack on titan phylosy is literally naruto war arc phylosophy
One of the most insane ending of all time and not in a good way sad to see such a good go out like that
People be saying things without thinking.💀
I hope the conclusion of Attack on Titan is similar to the Breaking Bad finale.
Levi, his rival. You mean Levi, his daddy
Agree with everything you said. I love you aot and I’m so sad that the ending had some much weird scene and just nonsense for such an amazing story.
1:58 "WALKING ALL THE WAY DOWN THIS PATH."
"...YOU EXIT THE FOREST."
Attack on Titan is Rashomon effect.
THE FOREST is Rashomon forest.
Idc what anyone says, eren failed, the aliance failed. Many characters personality and development were sacrifices in order to let the aliance win.
Kruger said something like love someone build a family or else the cycle will repeat.
Funny enough that Kruger joined the aliance, makes no sense. Frecles ymir makes no sense either lol.
For Aot gave me one message, believe in urself rather than in others.
I could easly write what was bad here for hours but other people perfectly summoned it up in videos.
Its still my fav anime and it will be in the future but i am disappointed by the conclusion.
Nov 19th or Spring will come.
What's on Nov 19th?
watching your videos and how dept they are how could you not peace out that Ymir was in control all the time.
she wanted to be free from the hallucigenia and the power cycle so she manipulated eren to kill him self/be killed to be free
The little girl turned 3 and how many timelines are ther (supposedly) cabin (debunked into false memory) manga timeline anime timeline bruh I can’t keep taking it 😂😂
I just want to mention, even the author admits the ending was rushed and forced, like theres literally an interview you can watch where he admits it. Thats not to say isayama is a bad writer or anything just proves that he is a good writer and knows that erens action at the end was uncharacteristic of him and of course he knows best because he created the guy lol.
NGL, i sometimes think ending something is a heck of a lot harder than most people give it credit being. Is this just me going to bat for Yams and Stephen King (infamous for his books having meh endings)? Maybe, but IDK, I feel like unless you do it early or work backwards...the ending is something crucial, but also something you can VERY easily mess up, and can even lead to stuff being soured retroactively if it's bad enough (See: Game of Thrones Season 8. I know several people who can't go back to the older seasons knowing the mess of an ending it all leads to).
For what it's worth, the ending to AOT wasn't complete trash for me...then again, AOT isn't an anime i was heavily invested in, so it was kinda "that was weird but also, no skin off my bones" 3 years ago, and the same now.
Hopefully Berserk doesn't end similiarly (Frankly, I'd like it to just end before I die of old age lol) but again, well...the above stands
I liked it.
Some guys just want to watch the world burn......because know we live in a society
The ending is trash and the people who like it either only watched the ending or they just forgot the whole story and believed in eren armin bullshit conversation
and most of yall only ride the hype of aot after season 3 part 2 got traction and when season 4 is still being release in manga.💀
if they liked it they liked it stop trying to force other to believe your opinion.
I don't think it's over. The story isn't finished. I still believe in AOE. I believe it will be episodic
Nah it's finished pls
Impossible y’all need to accept that japanese fans are the catered audience & they loved the ending so much some of you guys feel so entitled, imagine japanese fans hate & make a petition for western movie bc they hated the ending y’all will say they are crazy
Do you really think they are gonna reveal that more chapters are on the way? stop the copium man
@@nxxxlooo5726 not true. A lot of my Japanese friends over seas didn't like and say people were as divided there as people in the USA
@@attackontitanbeautytheking2725 they didn’t make a petition to rewrite the ending the chapter unlike western fans
Eren = Bird
I see it like Bird represent as "Freedom" = FLY.
I don't know why people are so into The Bird is Eren just because coincidentally The Bird came to touch the scars which Mikasa was crying over Eren.
"Because ethere is no way that is just a bird"
Symbolism, like in theatre this is entertaiment. That is also a very common trope in books ans mvies. No, Eren was not a bird.
Just reminder of Eren to Mikasa. Unlikely in real life bird would do that, but that just a drama's sake.
The bird grabbed the scarf and wrapped it around her LooooL be serious. We already know Eren can see through and control birds. Eren draws many inspirations from Odin in Norse mythology. Saying it’s just a random bird is a massive stretch considering what we know.
@@KingBullet123 Eren is dead
That is really common cliche. It is symbolism
Sure in real life it would be unlikely to birs to do that but thisbis entertsiment. The bird (symbol of freedom in the series) serves as reminder of Eren to Mikasa
Not "Lol eren is now bird", who says that has never seen movies or read a book before
@@perkeletto640 It’s not common when it makes no sense. Reasonable doubt tells us it has to be Eren use your brain. Otherwise it wouldn’t make sense. Eren isn’t a bird nobody claimed that, rather he can see through and control them which he was already shown to do so it is CONSISTENT. I’m not using real life logic, birds can’t be magically controlled irl however they can in the AOT world via founding Titan powers.
@@KingBullet123 plenty of people claim that.
And eren is not using the power when he is dead.
It is symbolism, don't over think it
I stopped caring about AoT once the Manga ended. The ending sucked ass, Floch was right, Historia should have been chosen blah blah blah. I am only here for the amazing score that Sawano and Kobayashi have created for the 3? 4? parts of season 4 that we have got? idk. I wait until the tracks are released then I download them. Fuck the story.
I like thee part where kruger and grisha gave thetitan to eren and then proceeds to team up with the alliance and help stop eren. like wtf
Specially how Eren makes a big deal to tell Zeke "wait we haven't seen the part where I eat him" I had high hopes that we WOULD get to see that scene and that would give us an answer as to why Grisha decided to inject Eren in the end even after beging Zeke to stop him, I guess Isayama couldn't think of any solution for that so he just decided to never show that
Almost as compelling as Zeke and Armin's conversation amounting to:
Zeke: Life Sucks
Armin: not all the time tho
Zeke: you are right, I am on your side now
Bro, I think the two endings were from the decision of Ymir Fritz after concluding Mikasa's choice. After seeing her kill Eren, she made up her mind to not be slaved forever. After Mikasa told Ymir that her love was a nightmare, then it flashed a scene that Ymir didn't save King Fritz at that time. So there are two endings. One that is the true route of the Aot timeline (Ymir saving King Fritz) causing the world where there are titans, and second is when Ymir didn't save King Fritz causing the titan powers to not get passed down to her daughters (world without titans). So maybe, just maybe there was a timeline where titans don't exist and the characters were just having a normal happy life.
This was a great ending for the anime at least. 8.5/10
The whole series or just the ending?
@@ksya473 I was talking about the ending but the series as a whole is also an 8.5 or 9
@@CombatUnit621 nothing about the ending was shit Im not saying it was perfect cause it wasnt but it was fine
@@CombatUnit621 mfs like this been saying this yet thinking jjk or one piece is the best thing they watch.
Eren being a slave to freedom doesn't make any fucking sense both words are contradictory to each other like How?! What has this story even concluded everything was in vain what a waste....
I think it’s an oxymoron.
Isayama wanted to sound like he was a literature genius that’s why lol
Yeah it seems like that 💀
@@KingBullet123 I don't know man the ending put everything in a negative light like after this character assassination I can't see it maybe before I would think that it's something deep like we thought he was fighting for his freedom, for his people to be free to end cycle of hatred.etc which makes it a good conception to his character but now after he gave up and stop at 80% to make his friends heroes and all that shit I only see it as a comedy 😂
@@little_error295 this is the most accurate take I've heard about aot lmao
Everything was going fine until they drop the ymir love king fritz bs on me with no apparent reason or maybe logical explanation. The story fell apart for me thinking what could possibly this harem king do to even make his slave simp for him 😂😂😂 and I could only guess one reason.. Maybe she's a hoe 😅😅😅. The antagonist ending and the animation was great but that ymir love king fritz bs which layout the end plot of mikasa have to kill eren is what killed me 😂😂😂.
It's a childish dream founder ymir had hence why she's in her child form when she's at the paths and when she sees mikasa letting go eren we can see her showing up in her adult form then a glimpse of what she should have done regretting her 2000 years of commitment.
@@meepmeep2706
I kinda get what you're saying but think logically
As a child she may have yearn for a connection i.e being loved and cared by somebody it may be not be fritz at all but surely by the time she's an adult and had three children she probably mature enough to understand that what she yearn for is her parent murderer,her torturer and her abuser but despite know all that if she still simp for fritz then most people are correct when they say she just have a stockholm syndrome
@@meepmeep2706
When she died she was an adult who could not bear the suffering of not being able to be love by her beloved king fritz but in the path she revered back to her child form, the lonely girl who just wanted to be loved and cared by someone(the connection that armin was implying )... Atleast that what my interpretation looks like 😅
So weird everyone is glossing over that kiss, has anyone ever done that? Kissed the lips of a freshly decapitated head? That was grotesque! You telling me thats what Ymir wanted to see? She wasnt grossed out at all? Mikasa is the only person ever to disagree with someone she loves n Ymir had to see it to believe it was possible? Omg this ending gets worse the more I think about it
I don’t get how Eren is a slave to freedom. he did the rumbling to make armin look like a hero so where the slavery there? Well that was one of his many reason he gave which make no sense
I'll never forgive Isayama for ruining this show.
Meanwhile Isayama doesn't even know your sorry ass exists 😂
@@dextoppablehe knows the opinion does and that will help him with any future writing
For the eremika Ymir thing it’s not that their relationship is toxic it just emphasizes it more that their relationship was never meant to be eren since s1 has always moved foward whether for violent reasons or not just like Karl fritz kept conquestiong places and don’t even give me that paralleling eren to Karl Is bs cause erens a physco path well a little bit while both mikasa and Ymir just wanted to live a normal life so you can see here they realistically aren’t meant to be however Ymir thought yk maybe if I loved king fritz maybe he’ll love me so no Ymir didn’t actually love Karl fritz she just wanted to try to love him in order for him to stop slaving away to his goals and just settle down with her and that scene with Ymir and her kids is what Ymir wanted Ymir never actually did what she wanted she just slaved away to eren simple contrast to mikasa as everything she’s done is cause she wants too so no. I don’t think Ymir wanted to “move on” more like realize what eren told her what did she wanna do which would also allow her to move on
Now for the theme of aot I agree it’s not just war will always repeat itself I think the message of aot is h to at though humans are incarnately bad their is always beauty is that bad and if we grasp that beauty their is hope for a better tommarow this can be shown in the survey corps,mikasa, eren finding a drive to kill the titans and more and the everybody is a slave to something is not about desires it’s about going so far with that desire that it will kill you now I will say this for the last time THE TREE IS NOT TITAN POWERS COMING BACK if that boy even gets powers it will not be titans it will most likely be something hopeful
For historia ima make it short isayama did a mikasa historia moved on married farmer king wasted potiental fuck yes should it have eren fuck no they have 0 compatabiltiy the oh it would help the theme of aot??? And historians whole charecter is about living her life with pride that was already somewhat ruined in s4 so what ruin it even more by making her forcefully get impregnated by eren to achieve his own goals??? Yeah no
And for the godamm rumbling I will say this till the end of time floch will never ever be right whether rumbling or not eldia will be destroyed and yk what would be even worse titans still exist so if that ending actually happened it would probably be the worst ending in actual ficiton cause eren would of achieved absolutely fucking nothing his friends dead eldia dead titans still alive freedom? Never existed in the first place so yeah aoe is only a good theory if you sideline every single charecter except historia and eren even though historians role died out after the world was expanded
In the end this AoT writing was mid. What a disappointment for what it could have been....
I implore everyone to try to read between the lines. This whole last episode is so fishy. Isayama is straight up trolling, don’t fall for it. Isayama introduced timelines when Eren saw the school caste when he entered paths. This timeline is Eren failing, not being able to change anything. A slave to fate, a bird in a cage. The ending leaves you bitter on purpose and making you feel powerless and disappointed like Eren. Part of the mesage that War never ends and that the cycle continues. The whole point of the story was for Eren to break that cycle of hatred towards eldians in Paradis. To protect his home. He will have his redemption
MOE is coming
Fair criticism but for me I like the ending. I respect this view honestly.
Garbage ending in both the manga and anime
Masterpiece ending*
@@darrentafoya9197far from a masterpiece, genuinely mid at best.
Thank god I'm not the only who thought this was trash years ago (Manga) .. so much potential and it pulled a Bleach/Fairy Tail maneuver.
Just curious how would you have ended it?
Stay mad😂
Here goes my breakdown of some wrongs things and bad plot of AOT and my dissatisfaction as a manga reader. I disagree that AOT was good until the last chapter, and only the last chapter ruined everything like most maga readers say, AOT started to lost himself and go downhill after Erwin death and the reveal of the basement, and then you have a 3 years time skip that skipped possible development's for characters and the original cast of characters became useless and without purpose, three examples is historia useless, mikasa without a purpose or goal, and armin that became dumb after he ate berthold and likes annie just because he ate berthold. After the time skip the only characters that do something and have a plan is zeke with the euthanasia plan and eren that became a one man army, eren became a cold strategist like Erwin, smart like armin pre time skip, and badass like levi and mikasa, everyone else become stupid and useless. And then eren and Zeke go to the paths and then meet ymir, its heavily implied that ymir wanted eren and choose him to go to her and free her from being a slave to the paths, eren himself said that, and you have the plot twist of grisha seing eren all along, and eren goal would be using the colossal titans to fight marley and everyone one outside of the island, because eren goal was freedom for the eldians in the island and his friends. this was the story until chapter 122 and 123. evething else after is a shit show and makes no sense, armin and mikasa created the alliance forces with marley to stop eren from saving the eldians from certain death from the people outside the walls, it makes no damm sense. And eren taking the role of villain just to sacrifice himself because suddenly now ymir plot point is that she loved the king for some reason, but in paths when eren saw her past she was a slave to that king and was very sad all the time and choose death by the spear to escape from the king, but in last chapters ymir sudenly loves the king fritz and the one ymir choose was not eren to free her like showed in paths when eren hug ymir and she cried, mikasa is the one chosen to kill eren and for some reason free ymir, the story gives a 360 and the story at this point betrayed everything that it was about, before chapter 123 and 122 (the paths with eren and Zeke meeting ymir). and eren talk with armin in the manga after he died in the paths saying he doesn't know why he started the rumbling and accidentally send dina titan to kill his own mom by accident, WTF? if he can time travel using the paths controlling eldian people, why didn't eren controlled Reiner berthold and annie and stopped them from destroying the walls?, makes no sense this time travel path bullshit. and then you have falco bird titan bullshit aswell none of the 9 titan became birds, zeke spinal fluid making someone became bird titan makes no sense it came out of nowhere. Eren killing 80% of everything outside of the island just to back down in the last minute and let 20% alive, that definitely will take revenge in the future over all the killing by eren and the island, and then eren removing all titan powers from eldians that are the only advantage against everyone outside the island, makes no sense is very stupid. isayma copied code geass ending but in a dumb way. Erwin died for nothing , zeke actually had some good plan in comparison to eren that back down in last second, and floch was a hero. And eren is a cry baby piece of sh4t that was pretending to be a cold badass after the time skip, but in the end he saying to armin he doesn't want mikasa to ever forget him, f1ck off, never was confirmed that eren loved mikasa in that way and in the end he is crying like a baby over it. Just disappointing. AOT Should have ended in chapter 122 and 123. Eren uses the coordinate the walls falls colossal titans awaken, roll credits, the end. a open ending just like that.
Great video man, but I honestly think you're just misunderstanding some plot points just to prove that you didn't like the conclusion. The ending is really not that bad, at least I don't see that as a 4/7 (it's at least a solid 7/10). The anime did flesh out some stuff and elevated the ending showed in the manga. My understanding is that you wanted things to go a different way, but got disappointed by the actual result. There's nothing wrong with it, but your points shown here don't really make this ending bad, they're kinda just nitpicks. If you want I can elaborate, so you can try to see things for a different angle to help you digest this ending.🤔😉
Pla elaborate and don't use any headcanon to explain plotholes.
@@EdwardHohenheim Sure. Give me some things about the ending and I'll see if they can be answered. Here's the thing though, the author clearly left some things about the ending up to the interpretation of the audience, so maybe different opinions can help you understand why some of us liked it, even if at the end you don't fully agree with them🤷
From the ppl I know and read that do not like the ending they just dont have a real solution in the AoT universe so they just hate because they wanted something else but are not able to articulate what do they actually wanted.
Yes. Some things could have been fleshed out a bit more like Eren going Colossal when the Spine monster is out... I Have no answer for that but for that thing dying I believe tha when Ymir saw Mikasa overcoming the chains she had for Eren she got the strength to do the same for her and Fritz and JUST like the first time she left herself to die with the spear then this time too
@@juliannieves962 It's not that they don't have a concrete solution, they just wanted a full Rumbling. That's the main criticism about the ending I heard over and over again. That and the claim of Eren's character being "ruined" at the end (which I call bs, since they were signs of him not being the cold MF he was pretending to be during this season). I would've liked for the whole convo between Armin and Eren to be fleshed out even more, like having an entire 20 min. episode of them talking, but still what we got here was great.
Regarding Colossal Eren, I believe Ymir helped him, just like she did with Zeke, so he can continue destroying the world (even if it would only be Colossal Eren doing the Rumbling lol).
I'm not changing my opinion. Still a garbage ending. Bye aot
King Floch was right 👑
Yeah hate attack on titan but applaud Naruto ending 🤣🤣or even the show as a whole
Attack on titan ending will age like fine wine, I can see why some people don't like this but if you really think about it, this was really the only way attack on titan could end. Yes it's not perfect, but that was intentional. Isayama, like eren, was confined to the ending he envisioned and it couldn't go any other way. I hear people complain about the ending but they hardly ever offer a better alternative that makes sense within the universe.
😂😂
I disagree entirely. The only reason anime onlies like it because they forgot a lot of dialogue since it’s been months to years since some of those scenes, but if you watch the show in a month, you will see how the last 1/4 of the anime and the ending are thematically different from the rest of the anime, and will remember the character and how they acted. An example is how eren was a man with plan that even made his father do terrible things for his plan and showed how calculating he was, until the end where he is a idiot, even tho after the time skip there were no plot significance to that.
I hope the conclusion of Attack on Titan is similar to the Breaking Bad finale.
Man eren sacrificed himself for there freinds and his friends sacrificed eren for saving world the world who treated them like cattles the world the peolpes who kill their comrades brutally thise ending is masterpiece you think that come on
gentlemen, we gather here today to share in our experience as the media illiterate
WTF Mikasa never said she will move on. She said No. 😂 Before killing Eren.
Man you guys are on your own Narrative than story given to you.
Crazy how to ppl took stupid persons opinions
The audience if this show is so big and massive that having immature fans worrying about who is the man next to Mikasa is imposible to ignore. To me, thats the least of concerns.
And who told you that Eren or anybody could destroy the cycle of war? This isn’t a fairy tale where the MC gets what he wants after the biggest sacrifice. My boy, this is realistic story about human nature. Just because he gave it all for Paradis doesn’t mean he succeed.
@@robertgarza5488 you sound exactly like the typical hater who didn’t get the ship you wanted how sad. Well, too bad this is an story with grey characters weather you like it or not. This isnt a fairy tale where your boys and girls get what you think they deserve.
They are flawed and so its the world they live in. Sorry this isn’t the romantic anime you all expected
nothing is more fairy tale-Disney style than the ending we got. Eren completing the rumbling and killing his friends and continue to live in regret is far darker and fitting.
also it literally turned into romance when eren bitched about mikasa, a girl who he never gave two shits about, and all the development, his agency, all went down the drain.
@@sanz9912 the ones bitching about something is you all. Eren was afraid of dying and being forgotten by the people he loved. He wasn’t the Chad you invented in your heads and when he showed who he really is you felt it too close to home because thats how you all are too. He was never a chad, never a hero.
I don’t see how is it a fairy tale when Levi ended up alone and mutilated. Mikasa cried for ages. Paradis turned into a totalitarian state and eventually after years of peace it was destroyed anyway.
The fantasy of EreHisu hit you all too hard. It never existed.
@@bummiefanart5636 nobody expects eren to be a hero nor a chad, and I don’t care about shipping so erehisu is irrelevant, and I don’t have a problem with him being afraid of dying, in the cave with historia, he was in a life or death situation and he cried, and I thought it was done well.
I do have a problem with him specifically crying over mikasa, a girl whom he hadn’t shown any romantic interest throughout the whole show, the two never had any chemistry together, and for some reason it was shoehorned at the last minute, every time eren was in a life or death situation, he never thought about her. By the way, attacking people personally, which you did, means you lost the argument.
It’s a fairytale ending by AOT standards, eren’s friends lived long lives, Levi started a new life with his new friends, and I don’t really care for mikasa so whatever her future is is irrelevant to me.
I don’t care about chad eren, nor erehisu, what I care about is a cohesive, satisfying ending, which this one is not, not by a long shot.
erens plan involves convincing irrational racist who judge an entire race for the actions of a few from 100s of years ago that even tho an eldian proved their worst fears true tried and successfully killed 80% of the world population that because a few of them allegedly killed him and claim they don't have titan powers they can all be friends now anymore because marleyans and the outside world as a whole are known for giving eldians the benefit of the doubt of course not like eldians have been helping their military this whole time and it never changed their opinions on eldians if this story was "realistic" armin would have been shot point blank 💀
There’s just so many flaws with this analysis. But people who don’t understand the ending or really the story at all tend to dislike the ending so is what it is Ig
I dislike the ending but this analysis was just... weird. Eren's a bird and titan magic? What?
Pls elaborate on the flaws.
Stay Mad😂
Ppl mad cause the ending was realistic and not a happy ending
It would be realistic if everyone after losing the Titan power gets gun down
Lmao you people don't even know why ending is criticized
incels are mad because the ending wasn't a doom and gloom ending where eren's friends died and eren get to live walking into the sunset abs out and being hailed as a king of paradis and marrying historia💀
@meepmeep2706 oh so now it's not because people want a happy ending 😂? You don't know or care why people don't like it, you're just a blind fanboy that will defend it no matter what.
@@bigballs7911man stop 😂😂 these “people” are just bots following their programming. give em enough logic and they’ll break
Perfect ending
People say the ending is garbage.
I'd like to see how some of you would have written the ending... It would be an abomination
This is a non argument. Has nothing to do with the valid criticism.
@@KingBullet123 I was referring to the people in the comments calling the ending trash.
@@Natsumi_san0
well they’re allowed to have there own opinions. You don’t necessarily need to be an author to criticise one. Remember an author’s work is a product made for the consumer. So it’s up to them on how they costume it and if they like it.
@@Natsumi_san0lol you can’t call food bad unless you’re a chef 😂 goofy argument
@@KingBullet123 I know people are allowed to have their own opinions.
It's just that people are being very toxic about it.
The ones who dislike the ending never respect those who liked the ending's opinion...
The honest truth is that Manga only’s was yapping on about how “oh so awful” the ending was and then everyone realises its another case of a vocal minority just not ubderstanding the otherwise pretty strsight forward ending.
Its fair, you are entitled to your opinion though
it's not a vocal minority when the ending is being treated as controversial by all the fandoms
@@sanz9912 No it isn’t stop making shit up lol. Some people can’t grasp nor have the maturity to understand the ending so they moaned and complained. Basically anyone who’s watched the show recently as their first viewing has been praising it to high heaven!
@@hitrapperandartistdababy “yOu JuSt dIDN’t uNdeRStAnD tHe eNdiNG” yeah right, if you don’t want to see how flawed this ending is and how many plot holes it has, and just wanna enjoy it as it is, more power to you.
@@sanz9912 By all means show me the plotholes, short and concise
@@hitrapperandartistdababy eren literally crys about how he cant change the future and how he tried to but just cant then we are shown he killed his own mom not to even mention how he told his dad to kill the reis family does eren I mean isayama not realize changing the past is changing the future?
the ending is bad you just dont think try thinking for once silly yesman