Mythology, history, and confused thinking

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 ม.ค. 2022
  • Support this channel at / vimoh
    Or make a one-time donation at vimoh.stck.me
    Follow me on Twitter and Instagram at @vimoh
    Subscribe to my email newsletter - artless.vimoh.in
    Get my ebooks at www.instamojo.com/vimoh
    Please read these rules before commenting. Follow them to the best of your ability. The rules are meant to keep the comment space clean and a safe space for anyone who wishes to participate in good faith.
    1. No advocating violence of any kind against anyone for any reason. People doing so will get banned from the channel.
    2. No praising or abusing any religion for any reason. Proselytising is not appreciated, nor is making generalised statements about the followers of any religion. People doing so will get banned.
    3. No casteism, racism, or sexism. Discriminatory language will get you banned too.
    4. Trolling, spamming, use of fake accounts to deceive people about your identity, will also get you banned.

ความคิดเห็น • 174

  • @yogi3178
    @yogi3178 ปีที่แล้ว +74

    I'm so glad I found this video, A week ago this is exactly what I was explaining to my friend, imagine, what if Mr.Neel wrote books about KGF and didn't make any movies and then some thousand years later people find this book, people would think that this is the history of kgf because that place exists.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  ปีที่แล้ว +12

      Glad to know you found it useful.

    • @pikachu7311
      @pikachu7311 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Hi bro 😅

    • @pikachu7311
      @pikachu7311 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Hi bro 😅

  • @Zia_Ali.
    @Zia_Ali. 2 ปีที่แล้ว +47

    Brilliant analysis! Religion makes you subdue your rational thinking and forces you to literally believe in fantastical claims such as the Noah's ark story and the fact that Muhammad supposedly split the moon in half as a miracle!

    • @Joemama70minus1
      @Joemama70minus1 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      what ?🤣🤣🤣

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +28

      Oh yes. Totally. And claims about rocks floating on water after a name is written on it.

    • @sai_69
      @sai_69 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@vimoh But floating rocks do exist, but also I'm not sure if they can bear the weight of a person, let alone a whole army.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +21

      @@sai_69 There you go.

    • @bhimanjali
      @bhimanjali 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@sai_69 yes , true... The think floating rocks exists therefore ramayana was real but what about 1000s of false claims in it....

  • @anshulsharma6400
    @anshulsharma6400 2 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    I think that people don't understand the symbolism used in these texts and consider that things as history.

    • @greenpoison9342
      @greenpoison9342 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Mythology is rich literature, it builds character. I think Mahabharata and Ramayana are greater pieces of literature than Shakespeare.
      And you can't simply rule them out not being true, maybe they are exaggerated but their may be some truth in it as well.
      At least names of places are correct. like Bharata, Lanka, Ayodhya, Delhi(Indraprashtha), Ganga, Yamuna, Himalaya etc. etc. These are actual geographical places mentioned in the texts.
      Rama setu did exist, that is how elephants and tigers reached Lanka and are found their to the present day. Other wise why do you find the same fauna in Sri lanka? Why don't you have tigers in Africa, but have them in Sri Lanka?
      And humans did evolve from Apes, not like mentioned in the quran that god created Adam and eve with the swirl of his/her wand. So maybe earlier there was some connect between Humans and Apes? That's why we have Hanuman

    • @billybutcher6504
      @billybutcher6504 ปีที่แล้ว +11

      @@greenpoison9342 People like u would never change, ur mind is still repleted with all absurdity, u people would argue irrationally to prove myths as to be true history. This is not channel for u, bro, u are definitely in wrong place. U must watch dhongi babas youtube channel coz that only would satisfy u.

    • @greenpoison9342
      @greenpoison9342 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@billybutcher6504 People like you believe in virgin birth. They think they are superior because they worship one god and hate polytheists Hindus.
      They think they will go to heaven and Hindus will go to hell.
      People like you think Allah will reward you if you desecrate Hindu temples and destroy Hindu god idols. Allah is jealous of Idols. Allah hates Hindus and will send them to Hell for eternity.
      And you love Allah, the one true evil lord.

    • @NeKo19113
      @NeKo19113 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​​​​​​@@greenpoison9342doesn't hinduism say first man and woman were manu and shatrupa, made by hindu god? Okay Without my support one explanation is:- 1) Allah made the bridge 5000-6000 yrs ago to make way for adam to leave the god's eden
      2) in treta yug ( 1.3 million years ago) rama and his apes wrote his name on rocks which starts floating and used to cross the land.
      3)when ice age ended, the ocean floor got filled with water and submerged everything. Then water levels started dropping, so the land of palk strait and adam bridge/setu got exposed around 3000-2000 BC. Now sea levels are again rising, and the land along with the entire palk strait will again submerge in ocean as part of natural climate cycle.
      What's your opinion on these explanations.

  • @veerabhimanyusingh779
    @veerabhimanyusingh779 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    mahismati was a real place in india ===>> means bahubali was based on real events🤔🤔🤔🙂

  • @vaishs385
    @vaishs385 2 ปีที่แล้ว +32

    Exactly what I think.
    I can give an example. I am from Orissa and there was a writer named Fakir Mohan Senapati. He is a great writer. I heard this incident from my father. The writer used to publish his stories in the newspapers. The story used to come once a week. As the story progresses people get attached to that story. There is a case in one episode which is going to be heard in the court next week on Sunday. He used the names of real places. It felt so real that people went to court the next Sunday to hear the matter.
    I can give credit to the author. I also believe that whoever wrote the scriptures was a great writer. He used his imagination, fantasy in the best possible way. But believing all the characters are real is a bit silly.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Fakirmohan FTW

    • @greenpoison9342
      @greenpoison9342 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Mythology is rich literature, it builds character. I think Mahabharata and Ramayana are greater pieces of literature than Shakespeare.
      And you can't simply rule them out not being true, maybe they are exaggerated but their may be some truth in it as well.
      At least names of places are correct. like Bharata, Lanka, Ayodhya, Delhi(Indraprashtha), Ganga, Yamuna, Himalaya etc. etc. These are actual geographical places mentioned in the texts.
      Rama setu did exist, that is how elephants and tigers reached Lanka and are found their to the present day. Other wise why do you find the same fauna in Sri lanka? Why don't you have tigers in Africa, but have them in Sri Lanka?
      And humans did evolve from Apes, not like mentioned in the quran that god created Adam and eve with the swirl of his/her wand. So maybe earlier there was some connect between Humans and Apes? That's why we have Hanuman

    • @sumeetghai8867
      @sumeetghai8867 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@greenpoison9342 the answer to your questions is natural selection. I think you never heard about speciation and natural selection. At some they both originated from same ancestry but with natural selection and speciation both developed traits that suits thete environment. That why even being a big cat lions lives in herds while tiger and many other big cats don't. The ram setu you are talking about is nothing but a natural phenomenon same thing can be found near amazon. So you mean ram must have gone to amazon for a small vacation???

    • @akshat_2100
      @akshat_2100 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@sumeetghai8867 not just amazon, it is also near Australia, indonesia (and its neighbouring countries). So by this guy logic, ram did world tour.
      And that phenomenon is Coral Reef.

    • @himanshushekhardas1730
      @himanshushekhardas1730 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      can you tell me which story ?

  • @skepticsagar694
    @skepticsagar694 24 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thought provoking stream.... Great

  • @dkhan9456
    @dkhan9456 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    WOW
    Outstanding analysis.
    Very clear vision.

  • @jonathanRohan
    @jonathanRohan ปีที่แล้ว +8

    It would be great it if AbhiandNiyu just watch this one video by Vimoh. Just this one video.

  • @Joemama70minus1
    @Joemama70minus1 2 ปีที่แล้ว +16

    Gonna tell my kids "the witcher" is a true stroy

  • @uddipanchaudhury3023
    @uddipanchaudhury3023 2 ปีที่แล้ว +16

    Krishna did actually existed as a leader of the Yadava clan of Vedic period. But he was just a mortal guy not an avatar of Vishnu with enchanted powers he fought in the war of the Kuru tribes which came to be known as 'Mahabharata War' . He was a sort of a statesman or war strategist. Btw the historical Krishna's actual name was Vasudeva 'Krishna' was a later addition

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +35

      I will ask you for a source. But I am not opposed to the idea that these COULD HAVE BEEN real people. As I said, there is one aspect of mythology that's "things that did happen". But before we accept that, we need sufficient evidence.

    • @uddipanchaudhury3023
      @uddipanchaudhury3023 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@vimoh You can check the Khandyogya upanishad which mentions Vasudeva as the warrior of the Yadavas along with his brother Balarama

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +32

      @@uddipanchaudhury3023 Proof of a religion's historical authenticity cannot be that religion's texts. You need external verification.

    • @uddipanchaudhury3023
      @uddipanchaudhury3023 2 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      @@vimoh No I just want to say that the stories written in religious scriptures are sometimes based on certain historical events like Iliad and Odyssey are actually based on the wars waged by Mycaenean Greeks on the on Trojans of Anatolia in 12th century BCE. I certainly discard the magical and mythical elements of Krishna's story. But the possibility of occurence of certain events in real life should not be neglected for eg. the dynastic feud of the Kuru tribe
      during the Vedic period which has possibly taken place.

    • @uddipanchaudhury3023
      @uddipanchaudhury3023 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @UCFnNSVYBlJeOe0GTtm06CVw Do you know what, I am manifestation of Paramatman itself. You are living under Maya that's why you are abusing me, once you realise my reality you will submit yourself to me and believe in my words. Otherwise you will stay in your ignorance and believe in pseudoscience😂😂😂.

  • @punith.3488
    @punith.3488 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Spiderman dont only have books. It also have movies which has a Disclaimer says 'This is Fiction'. Itleast we know that future will be advanced that will not erase movies.

  • @sujilkumar866
    @sujilkumar866 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +9

    I wish atheism in India will increase.

    • @faruqsha6456
      @faruqsha6456 หลายเดือนก่อน

      If it happens no doubt India will become superpower and first world country for sure

    • @Aekeofficial
      @Aekeofficial หลายเดือนก่อน

      Oh please dont follow this guy. He has no idea whats hes talking about. He doesnt understand basic difference between abrahamic and Indic ideas.

    • @fazer79
      @fazer79 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      ​@@Aekeofficial technically you both preach the same ideas of God being the creator. Having multiple gods doesn't make your religion any better. You are still living in delusion of God!

    • @TruthSlap9
      @TruthSlap9 20 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      ​@@Aekeofficialaccording to Hindu scriptures Ram existed in Treta Yug which was before Dwapar Yug.
      Let's do some math
      Dwapar yug - 86400 years
      Treta Yug - 129600 years
      We are in 5126 years of Kalyug
      Ram rajya was 11000 years and dasratha was 60000 years old when Ram was born
      Do ram existed atleast 870000 years, how is that people when homo sapiens evolved barely 300000 years ago and came to Indian island 65000 years ago

    • @Jatin_Kukreja
      @Jatin_Kukreja 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@TruthSlap9that’s why it’s fictional

  • @trashbarbarian5231
    @trashbarbarian5231 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    The new channel logo is nice.

  • @vivekkk116
    @vivekkk116 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    It's hard to roam around your close friends who think that Mythology is history and they feel proud about the religion and it's so called greatness just because of some brilliant writers in the past came up with an excellent collection of stories.😅😅 They like mythology because their favourite genre is fantasy. Nothing else.😂

    • @punyashloka4946
      @punyashloka4946 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Mythology is a form of history, yes it is primitive history but still it has actual historical accounts. People back then were not well equipped like today so they write it in form of Mythology.

    • @vivekkk116
      @vivekkk116 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@punyashloka4946 Sorry what kind of equipment lacking made them write mythology? Be specific please.

  • @nitinnihal1
    @nitinnihal1 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    The image of book "Bal Narendra"...if you know 🤣😀🤣

  • @sundarjialagirisamy3017
    @sundarjialagirisamy3017 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Super

  • @subhadeep_2001
    @subhadeep_2001 23 วันที่ผ่านมา

    For me it doesn't matter whether its history or fiction. The fact that Ramayana and Mahabharata give many important life lessons matters the most. Again who knows what is real. Are we real or we just believe it to be? The universe is huge with lots of mysteries and secrets. We dont know even a smallest fraction of it. So claiming anything as entirely true or entirely false is not the proper way. Keeping beliefs and rational thinking in a balance is the right way according to me.

  • @chetansharma-ei7ee
    @chetansharma-ei7ee 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    What are your views on Acharya Prashant?

  • @ananyesinghal1974
    @ananyesinghal1974 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Great video as always

  • @glamouriq
    @glamouriq 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thank you sir. Can you suggest good books for thought clarity..

    • @greenpoison9342
      @greenpoison9342 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Mythology is rich literature, it builds character. I think Mahabharata and Ramayana are greater pieces of literature than Shakespeare.
      And you can't simply rule them out not being true, maybe they are exaggerated but their may be some truth in it as well.
      At least names of places are correct. like Bharata, Lanka, Ayodhya, Delhi(Indraprashtha), Ganga, Yamuna, Himalaya etc. etc. These are actual geographical places mentioned in the texts.
      Rama setu did exist, that is how elephants and tigers reached Lanka and are found their to the present day. Other wise why do you find the same fauna in Sri lanka? Why don't you have tigers in Africa, but have them in Sri Lanka?
      And humans did evolve from Apes, not like mentioned in the quran that god created Adam and eve with the swirl of his/her wand. So maybe earlier there was some connect between Humans and Apes? That's why we have Hanuman

    • @warrior_of_liberation
      @warrior_of_liberation ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@greenpoison9342 *NO*

    • @Vor567tez
      @Vor567tez 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      @@greenpoison9342 1. Having real place name doesn't mean the events are actual. Otherwise Spiderman is real.
      Ramayana and Mahabharat could be inspired but word by word event , impossible.
      2. "Bcs of Ram Setu elephants exist on Sri Lanka " 😂??
      Have u ever heard of Pangea? Timeline of Indian subcontinent? Sea level raising over the years?
      Also RamSetu is not manmade. You should read Indian Oceanography Report.
      As from Ramayana side, RamSetu got dissolved after whole army reached Lankapuri and no Lankapuri is not Sri Lankan. Baffling? I know.

  • @mangakhoon4517go
    @mangakhoon4517go 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    nah i didnt know there was a comic on modis child hood💀

  • @shrivathsabhargav7442
    @shrivathsabhargav7442 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    If Shri Krishna is mythology what's the submerged City of Dwarka?can someone answer.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +9

      It's a submerged city.

    • @shrivathsabhargav7442
      @shrivathsabhargav7442 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@vimoh so???

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Soya thha. Abhi uth gaya hoon

    • @parthsarthi2953
      @parthsarthi2953 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      What's the proof that that city was ruled by krsna (as mentioned in bhagwat puran)...you are saying that the Spiderman movie is set in New York...New York exists in real life therefore Spiderman must be true....😅

    • @punyashloka4946
      @punyashloka4946 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@parthsarthi2953 but Spiderman did represent the cultural ethos of America or New York of that time. Give an actual insights of people of that area of how they think and behave , foods, clothes etc. The writer of Spiderman has taken its inspiration from his culture and society not from some alien planet or different culture like Islam. Spiderman is based on American culture because that's where the writer of Spiderman belong. Stories or mythology represent that culture where it comes from, it gives an insight into that society and how it's people behave. Ramayana and Mahabharata both are mythology but both comes from people who comes from land of India, people who live in land that time. So the writer has included its cultural ethos , how people behave, what were the food people eat, clothes , how people used to govern in the society at that time. You cannot just deny that and pretend it's not exist. For example Marvel movies and comics even though it's fiction it is based on American culture and people. It reflects how American society thinks, and behave, what food they eat, clothes they wear, how people interact with each other, captain America literally represent America. People who wrote mythology they usually take inspiration from their own society and culture they live in.

  • @arshadagr
    @arshadagr 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    But islamic texts has a chain of transmission / all the ppl which includes in in chain has thier own story

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  7 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

      So does Game of Thrones.

  • @chess.tips47
    @chess.tips47 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Please 🤔make video on current controversy hijab and orange
    Yeh jada important h ya padai likhai 🤔

  • @m.qaiserrehman2057
    @m.qaiserrehman2057 หลายเดือนก่อน

    your words actually make sense if we put the CREATOR out of the picture and say that metaphysical world doesn't exist....

  • @suga667
    @suga667 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    👍

  • @Aman-qr6wi
    @Aman-qr6wi 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Hi Vimoh,
    Myself as a history enthusiast,
    Often,what many people in india don't get is that unlike china, persia/Iran, greco-roman civilisations, indians didn't systematically(i.e.chronologically) record their pre-islamic history. Ancient indian history is traced through archaeology and foreign sources who visited india mainly greeks, persians and chinese.
    There's a difference between chronologically recorded history of China, Iran and Greeco-Romans and mythological tales of ancient india. As early as in 1030 AD, Alberuni, in his Tarikh-Al-Hind, expressed reservations about the historical and chronological Sense of the Hindus, which according to him was invariably replaced by
    ‘Tale- telling'.20th century British scholars wrote the same about indian historiography. Scholars like James Mill and Vincent Smith blames the lack of historical consciousness on the static nature of
    Indian society and a ‘Discouraging environment’ for writing history. They essentially said,"hindus lacked the sense of history writing." H.H wilson wrote that despite huge sanskrit literature, only Rajatrangini can be associated with anything called history.
    A.B Keith wrote "Ancient Indian history has been fashioned out of compositions which are purely religious and priestly, which notoriously do not deal with history and which totally lack historical sense."
    First native historian of india was Kalhana who wrote kashmir history in sanskrit(Rajatarangini- रजतरंगिनी), that too he was born in 12th century AD which is too late. Essentially, history writing started with advent of muslim rule in india who themselves learnt it from persians. India was ruled by turkic Mongolians(not by arabs or persians) but turkish rulers were completely persianated(which means they followed persian culture and language.)
    I would've loved indian history more but much of pre-islamic india has no native written historical records. We know about indian history only through archaeology & foreign sources and all the interesting stuffs like war and military history is unknown.
    Chinese sources, greek and persian sources give us some account of mauryans and guptas but even many more bigger empires might have been lost to history due to non recording of history.

  • @bhimanjali
    @bhimanjali 2 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    Their logic :: if vrindavan , Benaras , brij dham, ayodhya , Mithila, kailash exist therefore ram , shiva , krishna also exist.....
    Same with people of other religions.

    • @chess.tips47
      @chess.tips47 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @chess.tips47
      @chess.tips47 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Now you will say they exist lakh years ago 11 thousands year men sharp blade but Mahabharat happened when dinaosors was roaring each other 🤔

    • @spuriusscapula4829
      @spuriusscapula4829 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      @@chess.tips47 Karna was a velociraptor, people do not know this.

    • @tide7107
      @tide7107 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      ​@@spuriusscapula4829 Arjuna T. Rex confirmed??

    • @Nikhilgoswami7777
      @Nikhilgoswami7777 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Mahabharata is said to be happened approx. 5000 years ago , were dinosaurs present at that time ? ​@@tide7107

  • @kartikkishan6095
    @kartikkishan6095 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    New logo is nice

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@pratyushkumar7871 Feel free to come to my live stream any time and make your argument.

  • @Wayne10Rooney
    @Wayne10Rooney 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    Bal Narendra 😂

  • @cosmiclegend4181
    @cosmiclegend4181 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    No need to add the BG music. Seriously the BG music was irritating better to not use BG music without it your videos seems better

  • @deepraval.tcupod
    @deepraval.tcupod 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I don't want to argue vimoh but you have raised a good point, but even many scientists and scholars have acknowledged the proof of Hinduism.

    • @shahzadzaman2957
      @shahzadzaman2957 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Can you give the name of a scientist and their statement?

    • @deepraval.tcupod
      @deepraval.tcupod 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@shahzadzaman2957 Schrodinger: " The Bhagavad Gita… is the most beautiful philosophical song existing in any known tongue.”
      Oppenheimer: Access to the Vedas is the greatest privilege this century may claim over all previous centuries.
      Carl Sagan linked cosmos with Hinduism and Lord Shiva's tandav. He said god has four hands in one hand he holds damru.
      Werner Heisenberg: Quantum theory will not look ridiculous to people who have read Vedanta.”
      Even before the modern discovery of none planets, ancient hindus used to worship navgrah or nine planets.

    • @deepraval.tcupod
      @deepraval.tcupod 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      If an atheist like Carl Sagan has appreciated hinduism then there must be some reason behind it🤷🏻

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

      He said Hindu view of cosmos is an accident.

    • @NeKo19113
      @NeKo19113 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      ​​​@@deepraval.tcupod He raised another good point "if 9 out of 10 things are true, does that make the 10th thing true" and correlation is not causation ... The above scientists you mentioned are praising some of the hindu philosophies which they personally thought as a great piece. People have been praising buddhist philosophies and cosmology as well, but praising a thought process will not prove that buddha is 2600 years old or that he can do miracles or other mythological things...

  • @nitinmetkari-qz2yd
    @nitinmetkari-qz2yd 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    @vimoh
    Two questions for you:
    1. In Ramayana and Mahabharata there are mentioned number of places of India and subcontinent. Was that possible for a person who didn’t have modern gadgets to know the whole India.
    2. What is your take on Sugriva’s tales to Rama about 4 sides of India and sub continent and weather there of which is actually going beyond Indian continent.
    Plz answer.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  10 หลายเดือนก่อน +30

      Yes. People used to travel in ancient times. Travel doesn't require advanced technology. People used to walk. Walking is still possible btw. You can walk the length of India in a few months, as demonstrated recently by Bharat Jodo Yatra. People used to make maps and develop relationships with people in foreign countries back then also.

    • @therealkendallroy
      @therealkendallroy 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      do you think that people never traveled far and wide, or chart their course before the advent of modern technology?

    • @NeKo19113
      @NeKo19113 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Dude 4 sides of india is according to current world maps... It could also mean 4 directions as well...and please don't tell me 3000 year ago people knew what political boundaries in 2024 will look like... And about the descriptions and weather, duh take a trip to sri Lanka and write down the weather in your holy diary.

    • @vinaychauhan6834
      @vinaychauhan6834 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Bro these things are humanly possible, there is nothing to reason about it. Pyramid is a work is done by humans only, initally many theory came about it being aliend made. But it has been scientifically proven that its work of mass labour and mathematics. So people in ancient time too have basic understand of dierction and mathematics.
      Besides if you talking about Ram yuga, its didnt happen thousand years ago, accoriding to Ramayan it happened in lakhs of year ago. Satyuga even happened millions of years ago. Way before stone age. These all things are exaggerated. A war might have happened like Ramayana or Mahabharat but its not in the way it has been shown. It must like other normal wars but got exaggerated with time. Just think the god of universe get involve in a mere war of India. Why did he have interest in India only, why not the whole world? Have you ever thought like that? The obly reason because writer of these scriptyres have limited information of the world.

    • @calisthenicaksh-27
      @calisthenicaksh-27 23 วันที่ผ่านมา

      why none of the avatars of Vishnu took birth in any other country?

  • @spuriusscapula4829
    @spuriusscapula4829 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Chaddis ko kaun samjhaye, unme aur musalmaano ke basic fundo me zyada farak nahi hai

  • @chess.tips47
    @chess.tips47 2 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    I appreciate you vimoh 🤣 all religions people claim all of them our culture religion is oldest 😂in this universe 🤔 maybe Their god's killed all dinaosors million year's ago

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +21

      Maybe because the dinosaurs refused to worship them. #kidding

    • @chess.tips47
      @chess.tips47 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@vimoh yes 🤔 when you ask beliver when your god's exist they say 3 thousands years ago i said that's Gupta Empire periods so your god's existed in that time they say change their statment no no it was 10 thousands year see time jump 🤣 directly well 🤔i ask them bro that time ☺️ sharp blade 🤣 like sword doesn't exist it they even say maha Bharat happened lakh year's ago 🤔 50 year ago human's civilization start to learn to communicate each other there is alot logically not fit their story according to what we know so far from history prospective

    • @chess.tips47
      @chess.tips47 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@vimoh from my perspective 🤔that God never existed in past or maybe it's just a part of our timeline that start end maybe in near future human's become stronger super human from Their knowledge of science and modifications of biology and they goes to past start our timeline because possible in future big happened or human's 🤔 annihilation time traveling possible became a reality in future they come to past start beginning 🤔 but point to be noted they are so advance i think some people like them worship them and eventually this cycle repeat again' Their teaching might be successful for few years but latter Human understand political power and throne they use relgious agendas to fulfill their own selfish desire there is 🤔a game in china you say something in one person in ear and eventually it's goes to end meaning changed completely this is little theory as my perspective far logical there wasn't any god in past actually we humans was in past from future

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      I love science fiction. But again, it's important to draw a line between what could be, and what IS.

    • @chess.tips47
      @chess.tips47 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@vimoh 🤔i mean ultimately I was saying that there is many architecture build in past from today's perspective it's impossible to build them without advance technology that those human lives in past they come from future they devloped human's as far they can but power corrupts 🤔 couple of hundred years ago and they use them as God relgion use Thier propogenda control on majority of people 🤔

  • @_theabhinav
    @_theabhinav หลายเดือนก่อน

    Wait what the actually happend here? I swear on myself and all the “intellectual” i have,while u were telling a story of delhi/mumbai meanwhile in my mind iam thinking abt Spiderman comics……….and now you are too giving eg of spiderman…how how how???? 3:30

  • @__atheist_aarif__5665
    @__atheist_aarif__5665 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    Ayodhya existed = Ram existed
    Newyork existed = Spider-Man existed
    Utter gutter logic 😂

  • @gigachad6844
    @gigachad6844 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    It's funny how none of Hindu gods ever existed but Buddha(576BCE), Mohammad(570CE) and Jesus(4BCE), Mahavir(599BCE) did exist, unlike Ram, Krishna, Hanuman, Parshuram, blah blah.

  • @weebdesu4973
    @weebdesu4973 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    you look 60 year old in new Logo Lmao.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      That's ok. What's wrong with being 60 years old?

    • @weebdesu4973
      @weebdesu4973 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@vimoh kabar mai pair 💀

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@weebdesu4973 Wo toh hamesha rehta hai.

    • @weebdesu4973
      @weebdesu4973 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@vimoh more risk at 60

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@weebdesu4973 Risk is always there. People of my age have died in Covid. And in accidents.

  • @mrawin8293
    @mrawin8293 หลายเดือนก่อน

    watch the videos and read the books of Nilesh nilakant oak who spent 10 to 15 years in research work of Ramayan and Mahabharat and i guess you will get the idea of why indian history is different other mythology

  • @StrawHat_guy
    @StrawHat_guy 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Sir ji namaskar
    Pradeep Mishra (sihor wala) ke bare me 2 shabd kahenge?
    .
    .
    .
    .
    Paiso ke liye kuch bhi bol rha hai vo

  • @greenpoison9342
    @greenpoison9342 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Mythology is rich literature, it builds character. I think Mahabharata and Ramayana are greater pieces of literature than Shakespeare.
    And you can't simply rule them out not being true, maybe they are exaggerated but their may be some truth in it as well.
    At least names of places are correct. like Bharata, Lanka, Ayodhya, Delhi(Indraprashtha), Ganga, Yamuna, Himalaya etc. etc. These are actual geographical places mentioned in the texts.
    Rama setu did exist, that is how elephants and tigers reached Lanka and are found their to the present day. Other wise why do you find the same fauna in Sri lanka? Why don't you have tigers in Africa, but have them in Sri Lanka?
    And humans did evolve from Apes, not like mentioned in the quran that god created Adam and eve with the swirl of his/her wand. So maybe earlier there was some connect between Humans and Apes? That's why we have Hanuman

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      The video has all the responses to your points.

    • @baivabsarkar3477
      @baivabsarkar3477 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Builds character?
      What do you mean by character?
      Every religion , every culture has own idea of character
      Like in Vaishnava culture smoking and drinking is a bad but in Bengali Shaktism smoking and drinking is allowed
      In Islam marrying and having sex with daughter or sister is allowed, other religions may not agree
      We cannot simply tag someone good character or bad character based on our own projection
      There is no fixed set of habits which builds character
      And i have seen this same comment many times, why so insecure? Trying to prove what?

    • @rrrabad1234
      @rrrabad1234 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@baivabsarkar3477 trying to prove that he is an asshole.

  • @mitzavor8468
    @mitzavor8468 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I'm sorry but this is a really bad analysis. To start with you're conflating mythology with fiction. These are two seperate categories. Mythological stories are not fictional. Just as fictional stories are not mythological. Secondly, this idea that religious texts were written as fictional stories is absurd. The writer of the Mahabharata, Veda Vyas, along with his disciples who added parts to the Mahabharata clearly believe that these events were real. The writer (Veda Vyasa) claims that he was there and he saw these events happen. He's clearly not writing it as a fictional story to entertain the masses.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

      There are plenty of stories that claim to be based on true events. Fiction relies on credibility. We don't accept fiction as reality just because someone claimed so.

    • @mitzavor8468
      @mitzavor8468 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@vimoh Fiction refers to imaginary stories that are created primarily to entertain an audience. The author of a fictional story does not purport to be telling an account of events which actually happened. Ian Fleming may have been inspired by his own military career when writing the James Bond novels but he does not purport to be describing real events. He does not claim that James Bond is a real person or that any of the events that are described his novels actually took place. Nor is the audience under any illusion that these stories are true. They know that they are reading imaginary stories created by Ian Fleming in order to entertain them. If Ian Fleming wrote in his books that James Bond was a real person. That he was friends with James Bond. That James Bond was actually a celebrated military commander and that he initially served in Ian Fleming's platoon. If Ian Fleming claimed that he was there during the events described in his books. If Ian Fleming's James Bond books described Bond's military exploits and his victories and losses. Then the James Bond books wouldn't be fictional books. Now does this mean that these books would be necessarily be an accurate rendition of reality? No of course not. But they wouldn't be fictional.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      Fiction isn't determined by authorial announcement alone. It also depends on credibility of narrative. A story can be realistic and still fictional. And a story can be declared true and still be fictional.

    • @mitzavor8468
      @mitzavor8468 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@vimoh Do some reading on the ontology of fiction. A fictional story has to be imaginary in order for it to be fictional. Fiction is a form of make-believe. If the author believes that they are giving an account of true events, then it's not fictional. Even if you question the veracity of the author's account. Fiction /= inaccurate.

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @mitzavor8468 Thanks for the condescending advice. But I already explained what I meant.

  • @user-fb3js8zw3i
    @user-fb3js8zw3i 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Your assumption - who told you that civilization was destroyed and only one book remained and it was excavated.. your whole argument stands on this assumption..
    Vedic literature is passed down from generation to generation through disciplic succession. All Vedic literatures instructions if you apply it in your life, you will get the results.

  • @babithab1716
    @babithab1716 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    In his opinion mythology is not history. Nothing wrong

  • @user-fb3js8zw3i
    @user-fb3js8zw3i 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Now you are telling nice and wonderful story.. your story fully depends on your poor fund of knowledge and assumptions.
    You are fully trying to disprove great Vedic literatures based on assumptions not on your so called "evidences" .. first apply it on yourself sir before applying it in others.. how are you so sure and proud that your assumptions and thinking are so accurate.. Vedic literatures is not just history sir it's a philosophy.. absolute truth can be deciphered through science and philosophy..

  • @mr_gaming77755
    @mr_gaming77755 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I think many things you say are right
    But you can not deny mythology to be history
    You will need a time machine to prove it
    This is only your opinion that mythology is not history
    You and I can not prove whether ram existed or not but is it good to say that these all are fake

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  10 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      So we should accept everything as true because we don't have a time machine? What about claims from other religions? That also we can't prove wrong. So should we accept them as true also?

  • @sohamsantani
    @sohamsantani 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    we have got evidence bro and stop spreading non sence start reading history

    • @vimoh
      @vimoh  9 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      nonsense

    • @sohamsantani
      @sohamsantani 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@vimoh come like are you for real dude even chinnes travaller mentioned in there books about our ithhas ok i will show you every singal thing if your ready to live on your or our channle @heateddebate

  • @user-fb3js8zw3i
    @user-fb3js8zw3i 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Basically You are telling don't believe in stories present in Vedas which is compiled by Vyasadev but believe in your naive stories born from your little brain.
    First of all you create such a literature with full of history, religion, philosophy, absolute truth, politics, moral codes etc all aspects of life.. with no contradictions and which can produce great results in our life if applied , then you have right to speak like this. Not without doing anything simply speech is all you have.

    • @Dhananjay0071
      @Dhananjay0071 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Wo stories sirf isliye likhi gyi thi jisse logon ko kuch siikh di jaa sake stories k form me like Panchatantra. What is right and what is wrong etc etc... Symbolism hai wo sab kuch... Jab ham kehete hain ki Hanuman Ji ne suraj nigal liya tha iska matlab kya ye hai ki sachme sooraj ko nigal liya tha?? Kya ye bhi history me count hoga ki bohot phele ek bandar jaise aadmi ne sooraj nigal liya tha. Obviously nhi ye symbolism hai clearly similarly Shree Ram, Shree Krishna ye characters hain story k. Rather than proving there existence start learning from them. I am damm sure tere andar ek bhi quality nhi hogi bass internet pe logo se iss baat pe ladna aata hai tujhe ki Mythogy history hai ye nahi

  • @Aekeofficial
    @Aekeofficial หลายเดือนก่อน

    In this channel you talk about how to think inside a box lol.