English is not a foreign language
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 พ.ค. 2023
- Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @vimohlive
Support the show at / vimoh
Make a one-time donation at vimoh.stck.me/profile
Please read these rules before commenting. Follow them to the best of your ability. The rules are meant to keep the comment space clean and a safe space for anyone who wishes to participate in good faith.
1. No advocating violence of any kind against anyone for any reason. People doing so will get banned from the channel.
2. No praising or abusing any religion for any reason. Proselytising is not appreciated, nor is making generalised statements about the followers of any religion. People doing so will get banned.
3. No casteism, racism, or sexism. Discriminatory language will get you banned too.
4. Trolling, spamming, use of fake accounts to deceive people about your identity, will also get you banned.
A language like Bhojpuri which is recognised internationally was never recognised as an official language in India because of this whole idea of "Hindi, Hindu, Hindustan". A language which is almost dying and has not been preserved even by the people from Bhojpur region because their political agenda aligns with the ruling dispensation, bothers me about the future of such languages. If I am given a choice to dislike either English or Hindi, I will be more opposed to Hindi compared to English, because it was not because of English that languages like Bhojpuri, Awadhi or Braj couldn't develop, but it was because of Hindi imposition by nearly all political parties.
True sir I am also a bhojpuri speaker.. When people were demanding bhojpuri recognition many hindi academics wrote letter to PM that hindi will be in danger if it happens.. Now today bhojpuri speakers themselves supports hindi by saying that it is a dialect of hindi but bhojpuri is a language of magadhi prakrit and hindi is of shauraseni.. Maithli a sister language of bhojpuri which have less speakers in terms of population in number is recognized.. Indian government do hindi divas programs in countries like Mauritius, suriname , fiji which have bhojpuri population most of them labourers were taken to those country during british rule , None of them used to speak hindi.. Bhojpuri region is a very poor region.. They don't have time to fight for language but the elites from bhojpuri region, they see their language as hindi.. Now even in villages people have started talking with children in Hindi.. This Hindi-Urdu politics destroyed whole region.. But also I think North Indian people and South India people should try to cooperate instead of hating each other.. Alot of people are just concerned about their day to day life.. They want to live peacefully but this politics of language is divisive and sometimes hateful too and sometimes we see violence too..
Precisely
Due to hindi
Maithaili
Bhojpuri
And many more language
Bhojpuri is a dialect of Hindi. You should look up the difference between dialect and language.
@@somewhereinindia6404 Hindi is descended from Shauraseni Prakrit, Bhojpuri is descended from Magadhi Prakrit. These languages diverged over 1500 years ago and have very distinct grammatical and phonological characteristics. Also, there is no clear cut difference between dialect and language. The similarity between them is due to shared contact, not due to Bhojpuri being a variant of Hindi.
Most of the Indians are fine with what language the other speaks. Just don't shove your language down someone else's throat.
There will always be some bully cannot judge the entire region based on it
The problem is the bully has no capacity to accept this fact.
Dudes is 15, change my mind lol
ye lol bro went to debate after getting motivated by lvish bhaiiii
@@YourParas lmfao
am 15 myself, can argue way better than him
The success of " Desh khatre me hai " propaganda 😂😂😂😂
Hindu majority country me Hindu bhi khatre me hai
@@HiSharma-ok8grmat bolo warna zindagi bhi khatre m aa sakti h 😂😂😂
@@openatheism Bhai mai RSS me hu, khatre me kabhi nahi aa sakti zindagi 😂, papa ne zabardasti dalwa rakha hai, i hate RSS, Din me rally jata hu rat me leftist literature padhta hu
@@HiSharma-ok8gr Arre bhaisaab 😲, bhai yaad bhi mat dilwa, mai bhi tha 12th me RSS me, kya bakwas organization hai nationalism ke naam pae hate bharti hai 17 saal ke baccho ke mann me, vaise recommend some leftist literature to a beginner
@@Udit873 Start with BR ambedkar, i am currently reading books related to caste and how it started, recommended authors (baba saheb, arundhati roy, Anand Teltumbde, periyar), before starting on the topic of caste i read (science in saffron, the portable atheist, who was shivaji?, the second sex, the righteous mind) random reads :- anything by "Christopher hitchens, Albert camus
This guy needs to learn how to make an argument first. 😂
Pointless conversation 😂
who?
The stupid "unbiased one"
The unbiased one being totally and shamelessly biased. What a conversation. 😂
These people consistently fail to miss the key point: Hindi is not native to India, it is native to Western UP. It is a language spoken in India, but the only thing that merits its use as a national language is the fact that it was spread across North India colonial powers who used Delhi and Agra as seats of power. A Tamil person will be expected to Learn Tamil, English and Hindi. An Adivasi person from Madhya Pradesh will be expected to learn their native language, English and Hindi. A Naga person will be expected to learn their native language, Nagamese creole, English and Hindi.
The same expectations will not be held of someone from Bareilly, someone from Agra or someone from Gorakpur. Because their language is the "default language" on the merit that it was spread by Mughals and then imposed by nationalist fanatics. The point is to level the playing field and ensure equal representation for all indigenous Indian languages, whether that be achieved by English or any other language.
wish i could upvote this comment multiple times
It isn't just that. Quality English environments where people learn English with native fluency are only available in higher income group environments in cities which most Indian people do not have access to. It just leads to bitterness and envy from the masses. If people from lower income areas in cities, from towns and villages etc. want to start speaking English with native fluency, they need to hire people from English speaking demographics as teachers in government schools etc. Honestly, I wish all Indian people, whether pani puri waale ka beta or CEO ki beti could speak fluent English. Not that that's the only language they can speak or have to speak, but that they can speak it fluently when they want to or when the need arises. I want fluent English to get normalised in India and be seen as any other language. Otherwise, it just creates resentment and inferiority complex in the masses.
@@hindiisonlyalanguagenotkno913 Absolutely. The only reason most of India resents english is its place as a language of the elite and is used to gatekeep opportunity. If we want to preserve the linguistic diversity of India we need to put our local languages first in priority and make English accessible as a link language.
i.) But that is the thing. It gatekeeps only some kinds of opportunities. Last month, 2 electrical-plumbing folk came to my house. Neither of them were English-speaking guys. They spoke Telugu. I had to pay them Rs. 3300 as labour costs for two people to fix my electrical-plumbing problems (only labour costs, not parts) for 3 hours of work. On average, that's Rs. 1650 per person. If each of them solves 2 such problems per day, that's Rs. 3300 per day per person. And say 25 days of work a month; that's Rs. 82500 a month. More than what a lot of software professionals make. Which specific opportunity were they gatekept from? Since they make money, personally, I would like them to admit their children to schools where they learn both English and Telugu properly.
ii.) If I, a guy who grew up in an English-speaking environment in a city, went to the polytechnic institute the aforementioned plumbers went to to learn their craft, or even if I learnt it as a trade skill from one of their people, I know they'd unwarrantedly discriminate against me and "gatekeep" me out of their group. I know because I have lived in those sorts of environments too, and paternally, I come from a very rural family.
iii.) Many jewellery store owners, sweet shop owners, etc. can't speak fluent English either. Some of them are crorepatis. The same with politicians (CMs, PMs included). Laxmi Niwas Mittal was a Hindi-medium guy (just one example, but there are multitudes). Even the dentists I go to (who may read books in English) don't prefer English. They speak Telugu and make all their social media videos in Telugu, but they still make a lot of money as dentists.
iv.) In any college or workplace, you will find the Hindi speaking guys sticking to Hindi speaking guys, Telugu speaking guys sticking to Telugu speaking guys, Bangla speaking guys sticking to Bangla speaking guys etc. There is some interaction between groups, but people tend to stick to their groups and gatekeep others as well. Similarly, English-speaking Indian folk gatekeep their own groups because they face a lot of mockery and ridicule also. They are “othered.” And they’re a very small number as a proportion of total population currently. People of every language group in India, including English speakers, have their own culture, likes, dislikes, and preferences, and English speakers get pigeonholed into certain jobs and certain places to live in also. Obviously, they will find people similar to them more relatable.
v.) Last I checked, exams like NEET and JEE are available in English, Assamese, Bengali, Gujarati, Hindi, Kannada, Malayalam, Marathi, Odia, Punjabi, Tamil, Telugu, and Urdu. UPSC is available in both English and Hindi. Most Indian TH-cam videos from vacuum cleaner reviews to politics to technical channels are either in Hindi/Hinglish or some vernacular language. Only a minority are in English, and people seem to have a problem with even that. Most parliamentary debates are not in English. When it comes to news channels, there’s plenty of them in Hindi: Aaj Tak, ABP News, India TV, NDTV India, News18 India, TV9 Bharatvarsh, Zee News, DB Live, BBC News Hindi, News 24. You can find similar channels in almost every one of the 22 scheduled languages we have. If anything, there’s plenty of ANTI-ENGLISH gatekeeping as well.
vi.) Now, usually fluency in English is correlated with wealth and urban living but it is not a 100% correlation, especially in the internet age (I should amend my statement of “ONLY available in higher income group areas in cities”). Also, those “elites” didn’t fall from the sky. Most of us who speak fluent English are children, grandchildren, or great grandchildren of people who migrated to cities from villages and towns. One of my parents studied in a Govt. Telugu medium school and cannot speak fluent English. I can. Some of my cousins who grew up in north Indian rural areas studied in govt. Hindi medium schools and cannot speak English well. I can. Why? Because of rural-to-urban migration, the school I studied in and the neighbourhood I grew up in. It will be the same with the current batches who are moving out of rural areas into cities. My cousins, whose parents weren’t as successful as mine, stayed behind in rural areas and do not possess the same English fluency as I do.
vii.) Translations from one language to another won’t be much of an issue in the age of AI. However, it isn’t as simple as language. Like I said, every language is associated with a culture. Highly vernacular areas in India with poor English fluency are on average, far more socially, technologically, and economically behind the times than the English-speaking areas of the world (including in India). The villages and towns that my parents, uncles, grandparents, etc. come from are nowhere near as developed as the city I grew up in. That also shows in the mentality, behaviour, social/religious views, etc. of people who come from those different demographics and speak those languages. You can see that even in comment sections on TH-cam.
viii.) This video is called “English is not a foreign language; it is an INDIAN language”. This video deals especially with the ANTI-ENGLISH gatekeeping in this country. Would you consider English to also be a “local language”? I think you are referring to “languages in which the majority have fluency” which is obviously the set of all languages other than English. My problem has never been which language people speak. The reason I brought up hiring people from English speaking demographics to teach in government schools etc. is because that same inferiority complex and resentment due to which people keep screaming “macaulay ka baccha”, “angrej ka aulad”, “angreji ghulami ke maansik rogi” or keep reminding you “English is only a language, not knowledge, nor a measure of intelligence” or think of you as being Chatur from 3 Idiots, does not exist in the next generation. They won’t care if people speak English beside them. It will be just as natural as breathing is or just as natural as speaking any other language in India. Also, people here, even with degrees in all kinds of fields (including in science) up to very high levels sometimes write HORRIBLE English. You can see it everywhere, from court notices, police reports, websites of hospitals, customer care chats, articles, comment sections, and every other place. They have difficulty with simple spellings and basic grammar. Words have set meanings for a reason (even if they gradually change with time) and if you want to convey something properly in any language, you should also practice writing properly. That will also come down if proper English language instruction is given to students.
I am from Kerala,here hindhi is necessary till 10th.What the hell is that dude saying.🤭
Humko Thoda Thoda Hindi Aata
Almost same in Karnataka.
State syllabus usually almost always has Hindhi as compulsory.
And I still don't understand gender in Hindi. Why is it so complicated?
@@Jinx-iw6zb It is a stupid construct. Assigning genders to shirts, belts, buckets and shit. Whoever designed that needs a proper spanking.
At 7:54, this caller 'The Unbiased One" claims that there is hatred of Hindi in southern India.
The *Dakshina Bharath Hindi Prachar Sabha* has been thriving for *more 100 years (i.e., since 1918-1920),* with its *headquarters located in* the SO-CALLED, ALLEGED hot-bed of the SO-CALLED anti-Hindi movement, *Chennai.*
This would not be possible if there was any hatred towards the Hindi language (and or hatred of Hindi speakers) in and of itself.
Biased people like 'The Unbiased One' need to become intellectually honest before they run their mouths.
inexperienced teenagers will see some videos online and turn that anecdotal evidence into "the problem of the millennia"
I too agree. What is this Hindi imposition on our Multi-lingual, Multi-cultural Nation? Just because Hindi originated in India, it shouldn't be logical choice that everyone in this country should speak it. I mean doing so, what exactly one trying to PRESERVE? There is already enough Hindi speaking population. In Non-Hindi States English only works as Mediatory language. It preserves local languages as it doesn't impose "National Importance" on them and used only in convenience.
Secondly, it is foolish to still believe English influence is only due to British. Majority of world influencing countries today speak English. Technology, softwares, internet is accessed through English. Even if colonization wouldn't have happened, we definitely would have influenced by English eventually.
Thirdly, Its just a fr**king language. Its just a TOOL for communication. People should stop affixing their PRIDE to a tool.
Fixing pride to language is not wrong, imposing it on others is
@@beactivebehappy9894 But language is just a tool for communication, dude.
"Meri kaichi"
"Nahi, nahi...mera hathoda"
Sounds silly, right? Because it is. Same applies to language also. Stop having PRIDE over superficial things.
@@warrior_of_liberation
"I too agree. What is this Hindi imposition [...] People should stop affixing their PRIDE to a tool."
=================================
I AGREE with you.
The generally insidious-and sometimes blatant and flagrant-insistence on (AKA imposition of) Hindi is a tool to establish the hegemony of Hindi chauvinists who consider all other Indian languages, especially those not belonging to the Indo-Aryan group of languages, to be inferior to Hindi.
It started during the days of the Congress Party, and it has become even more emphatic during the Modi-Shah-Bisht BJP's policy of Hindi-Hindu-Hindustan.
@@warrior_of_liberationwell be it sanskrit or English. Indo Europeans are winning one way or other
@@scienceroom7651
Nobody is winning with this bullshit. We are global species now, do something worthwhile contribution for humanity as a whole to be prideful than whine and cry over language.
As an Indian from Telangana, English is not a foreign language for me as compared to Hindi. Hindi is way more foreign to me than English.
Ah 😅 lol it really doesn't matter, be it hindi or English. Both belong to the same family and come from the same language. A North Indian should not hate English it's the language of our brothers and come from the same origin.
Which is the closest language to you. I mean what's ur mother tongue and what is mostly spoken in your surrounding
@@rupendrasharma6291 Telugu. In surroundings mostly speak Telugu. My mother tongue is also Telugu.
Dude, in maharashtra, you can easly live without even knowing a single marathi word
Hindi is soo common in maharashtra that right wing parties had to kick out and discriminate these north indian garbages
@scienceroom7651 what crap English and hindi aren't the same nor are from the sane origin
@4:10 Please read Article 351 in The Constitution Of India 1949. Everyone has promoted Hindi as it is a directive to the Union.
What kind of arguments he’s putting in? Like neither hes answering the counter questions you are asking nor he is able to explain his statement.
Vimoh live❤ you are absolutely right ❤❤❤
Diffence between hindi and english is.. hindi is being imposed and a lot of fund is used in its propaganda.. English is an useful aspirational professional language which everyone wants to learn given a chance.
Language is just a medium to communicate.
This binding of nationalism to languages is nonsense.
English is just a utility. I have no advantage to learn Hindi over English.
Well so then why do you learn your mother tongue it's of no utility right english is useful clown
Language isn't just a medium to communicate its a symbol of your cultural roots in India we relate to people of the same language
"I myself".
Yes dude.
Suppar Ingliss.
This guy is a "Hindhi Is The National Language Of India" fanatic.
South Indians aren't justified in hating Hindhi?
Cool, then North Indians aren't justified in asking to make Hindhi the National Language.
yes you are 100 % right even if English is not Indian language it is THE language which has united INDIA where as Hindi can divide us. And as kannadiga Hindi is as foreign as English.
We don't hate Hindi but we hate the imposition of hindi and North Indians or Should I say Hindi Speaking people should understand our concerns , Our country is more united than you think and we are nationalist like others and more indian than others but we will oppose anyone who tries to define this country according to their ideas. Hindi is just another Indian language not a national Language.
nobody is imposing hindi but if you learn only English without native tongue then whats the crap
Thank you for saying this, Vimoh. English is my mother tongue and try as much as I do to make people understand that it is so because that was the language I was brought up with here in India, rarely do people understand... Mostly it's met with a dismissing silence.
It's mostly bitterness, insecurity and envy/jealousy on their part (which they admit in more vulnerable moments). They justify/rationalise that insecurity under the garb of "pride and nationalism" or "colonial mentality" (despite the fact that they're literally trying to colonise your mind into following their writing/speech patterns and sharing their insecurities), keep ranting about Russia/Japan or just respond with aggression and unwarranted insults. Generally speaking, I tend to keep such people off of my physical property and limit my interaction with them. Paternally, I come from a pretty rural family, and I was the first guy out of nearly 30 people starting from my father's generation who could speak crisp, fluent English since I was a child (due to my predecessor's rural-to-urban migration etc.). English is cognitively my strongest language too. I grew up in a higher income group area in a Tier-2 city and have been speaking English with all my close friends since I was in kindergarten. Contrary to the constant bullshit that discrimination largely takes place because you can't speak English, I know how much beijjati and battameezi we have to tolerate because we can. Experienced it my whole life. Frankly, Indian English speakers (born and raised in India) need to group up and stand up for ourselves. It's not like ALL people from other countries will welcome us with open arms either (experienced that too, though I've made some good foreign friends and it's my ability to speak English that has enabled me to do that). And why should we even expect them to? Everyone is tribal to some degree and wants their native lands to be their own home. We have a different skin colour, different accents and our own culture and nuances. We are Indians, first and foremost. India/Bharat is our home, a place where we own properties and we have as much a right to speak English as they have to speak Hindi, Bangla, Tamil, Kannada, Bhojpuri or whatever they prefer. I can also speak Hindi and Telugu and I do so with people who prefer those languages. I don't have an "everything should be in English" craze either (though I wish all Indians could speak fluent English but not that that's the only language they can/should speak or prefer either). Cheers from one Indian English speaker to another.
@@hindiisonlyalanguagenotkno913would you rather learn a foreign language not native to India but only speak english and btw guys like you are why people see learning english is a sign of iq when people learn best in their native tongue
What crap the people whomsoeak just english lost their mother tongue
Yeah, and guys like you are why people see those who speak fluent English as Chatur from 3 idiots or hollow fools with no substance. Stop with this constant default victimhood of toota-phoota angreji batches. You're not the only people who face problems and are unwarrantedly discriminated against. People who speak Hindi lose their "mother tongue" also (which could be Gujarati, Marwadi, Maithili or whatever). I can speak Telugu and Hindi. But I am not a bitter, envious anti-English hater. "Native tongue" differs from person to person. There are cultural native languages and cognitive native languages. Cognitively, my primary native language is English. Culturally, it is something else. I learn best in English. Good for you or people like you if they learn best in Tamil or whatever. Don't stuff your bitterness and envy on our heads. It is not our fault that other people's English is not good. It's like blind people blaming sighted people for not being able to see. Everything you have stated has already been addressed in my original post and several posts on this video. Don't bring up the same crap.
"The unbiased one" 😂 people only claim themselves to be unbiased when they know for sure that they ARE biased.
Lol on point
Baton ko jalebi ki tarah ghumana koi inse seekhe!
The unbiased one is fully biased :) Also, that person is not at all good at LISTENING.
Name is “The unbiased one” 😂😂😂
Britishers ❌ Indian political parties ✅
Hindi imposers
Main South Indian gyi hun and waha mujhe ache log mile
Sir, u need intellectual people for convos, like me😅
I feel vimoh missed the point,but that guy wasn't particularly clear as well
The central government of India has shoved Hindi down everyone’s throat, from 1947 till now, irrespective of party or leader in power.
Until central government takes exams in 14 major Indian languages, equality will never come.
Actually the guy meant to say that irrespective of all the other languages spoken in the country, English has its origins outside the country which he is terming as foreign. I guess Vimoh should have allowed that guy to say his point completely for once. I don't think this was a productive conversation.
But really that's not make any sense english is foreign or not buy it is important it's a fact!
Hindi is not native to most parts of India. I agree with Vimoh on this. The Unbiased One was biased and was trying to push a subjective opinion without any real value addition. So, yes, it was an unproductive conversation and so was cut short.
Vimoh he's objectively assessing a language and how it became popular in India. Whereas you're thinking that he's claiming English usage is anti national
If he wanted to talk about Hindi not being accepted in South India, he could have simply talked about Hindi and not dragged English into the mix at all. Why bring up "English foreign language hain aur hamare uppar impose kiya hai" at all. Talk about Hindi and leave it at that. Having had years of experiences with these guys, I know that when they bring up this issue, somewhere inside they have resentment against English and English speakers even if they outwardly say that's not the case. That's how they start: "foreign language hai aur impose kiya gaya hai". Then, if not from the specific individual saying it, from other individuals it moves into "anglophone coolie", "angrej ka aulad", "macaulay ka baccha", "kanjra", "pajeet", "colonial mentality", "Russia, China, Japan, Europe" territory and worse. You can go down the comments section and see similar discussions I've had on here. Even Vimoh could sense that and shut it down before it got worse. MAYBE, just MAYBE it isn't the case that this specific caller resents English and English speakers, but many many people do. And it's correct that Vimoh rebutted it at that point without adding fuel to the fire of other bitter, insecure individuals (even if the caller is not one of them).
Languages is just communication medium...
Kehna kya chahte ho? Aur kaunse language ke baare main specifically baath kar rahe ho? English ki, ki saare? Generally, "languages is just communication medium...", "English is only a language, not knowledge", "Russia, China, Japan" yeh sab voh loh likhte hain jinka English weak hota hai kyunki unko apna khud ka naqabilyat ko justify karna hota hai or apne likhne ka dhang practice karke nahin sudhaarna hai. Us context main likh rahe ho kya? Agar ye video ka title "sanskrit is not a foreign language" karke likha hota, tabhi bhi "languages is just communication medium..." likhte kya? Aur "Languages is just communication medium.." nahin hai, "Languages are just a medium of communication" hai. Jab communicate karthe ho, dhang se tho communicate karna seekho. "Languages is just communication medium..." ke mentality ke saath customer care chats, police reports, court notices, textbooks, answer papers, articles, comment sections sab main third rate writing likthe hai idhar ke log. "I has keys", "I am be help you", "he didn't done his homework" vaala writing.
He is stuck in his sweet little echo chamber, regurgitating the same old tropes used by many before him.
Sanskrit is an Indo European language having it's origin in Steppe or West Asia
The ancient Harappan genome, sequenced and described in the journal Cell, was compared to the DNA of modern South Asians, revealing that the people of the IVC were the primary ancestors of most living Indians. Both modern South Asian DNA and the Harappan genome have a telltale mixture of ancient Iranian DNA and a smattering of Southeast Asian hunter-gatherer lineages. "Ancestry like that in the IVC individuals is the primary ancestry source in South Asia today,” co-author David Reich, a geneticist at Harvard Medical School, said in a statement. “This finding ties people in South Asia today directly to the Indus Valley Civilization.”
marathi bhi language from inside hai , tamil bhi , sabko sab sikhao
India as a nation didn't exist before independence. There were princely states. Each having its own culture and language. When the union of India was formed, it was thought to make a national language. But it was impossible to give any language a preference of choice, since, in the union of India, every language was equally important. So, the concept of official language was introduced which were namely hindi in devnagri and english. Now why English and hindi were chosen. Hindi was chosen because it was majority spoken. English was chosen to compensate for not chosing any other Indian languages. Here English, acted as a bridge for different Indian languages and also as it was the language of colonial India, which was present for more than 200 years, it was convinient also to keep using English.
Hindi is not everyone's language and surely not a national language. It is at most a regional language specifically in the north Indian region. Tamil is one similar regional language in south india along with others.
If one goes by Aryan migration theory, the indo iranian languages sanskrit and its derivative Hindi all are foreign to the Indian subcontinent, since Indo Iranians were not native to the this land. By this logic, the aryans and their languages are all foreign. Again, Pariss, Musalmans and their language and culture are all foreign. But the issue with this faulty reasonig is wrongly understanding what makes something foreign.
English has been and its culture has been part of Indian subcontinent for a long time. Muslims and their culture and language have been in this land for a long time and people have adopted and at present its indistinguishable. So all thes things are no longer foreign.
Foreign mean non native
Useless debate 😂😂
😂😂😂😂bhai kahena chahate ho😅
Bechara :P
Even cricket 🏏 is foreign sports but cricket 🏏 can be termed as a slave sports beacuse it's played by country where were slaved by Britishers so stop playing and watching it 😂😅 while English as a link or common language is used world as a source of communication 😊😮
A better way to write this would be: "Even cricket is a foreign sport. Cricket can also be termed a colonial sport because it's played by a country colonised by the British (i.e., our own). English, as a link language, is used worldwide as a common mode of communication.".
Not trying to be a show-off. Just corrections for self-improvement. Everyone has to start somewhere. "Source" means the starting point of something. "Mode" means a medium through which something travels. Google "Quillbot". It's an AI grammar checker tool. When you write something, type whatever you want to write in it and see if it throws up errors. It will improve your writing.
English and Hindi are both foreign indo-european languages 😅
Vimoh me apse thoda sehmat nahi hu ,vo log keval 13%hi he magar des vo chala rahe kyonki vo english bolna chahte he to sari padhai english me hogi sara accha content english me milega, democracy me bahumat dekha jata he bahumat ko jabarjasti english sikhna he ,or ha jabarjasti he kyonki sare bade school college english me hi he ,supreme court english me chalta he bhali victim ko english na aati ho ,english kitni badi dikkat he age badhne me ye hindi bolne vale se pucho
Hum log jinko aaj fluently angreji baath karna aatha hai, havaa se agaye kya? Angreji hum baat kar paate hai, kyunki hamare maa baap vahi hindi, bangla, tamil baat karne vaale gaon ko chodke shehero me base the, aur isliye hum angreji seekh paye. Aur doosra cheez: saara padhai, saara accha content? Hindi medium schools, UPSC main Hindi medium, majority TH-cam channels Hindi ya Hinglish main, Hindi medium PM, Hindi medium home minister, Hindi ke news channels (Aaj Tak, ABP News, India TV, NDTV India, News18 India, TV9 Bharatvarsh, Zee News, DB Live, BBC News Hindi, News 24), majority debates parliament main Hindi main, ye sab nahin hai? Aap log bhi jabardasti karke Hindi thopthe ho hamaare sar ke uppar. Aur doosra cheez, jinko English aatha hai vo log jo kaam kar paa rahe hai, isliye kyunki unlog ko English aatha hai aur baat karna seekhe hai. Agar aapko ek Swedish aadmi ke saath baath karna hai, aur usko Hindi nahin aatha hai, aur aapko English, tho translator mere jaise aadmi banenge na? Voh Hindi nahin seekhne vaala hai, aur aaplog ke log ko English se chid hai. Aur mereko Russia, China, Japan yeh sab bolo math, kyunki main 1000 baar sun chuka hoon. Aap log Hindi preferring vaale kitne bade dikkat banjaate ho, aur kitna beijjati aur battameezi karthe ho hamare saath vo hum log se pucho. Majority channels Hindi main rehte hain TH-cam par, phir bhi English channels pe aakar "Hindi bol saale" karte ho. Behrampur, Sambalpur, Paradip, Rajnandgaon, Korba, Khorda, Chapra, Amalpuram, Srikakulam, Madurai, Sendurai, Palakollu, aise jagao main raho, koi aapko fluently English baath karne nahin bolega. In fact, jab hum log aap log ke aabadiyo main aathe hai, aap log kitna discriminate karte ho, vo hum log se poocho. Aap logo ke mentality ke vajah se, jo hamare careers, hamare jindagiya kharab hote hai, vo hum logo se poocho. Jinko English aatha nahin hai, vo default se hi victims nahin hai. Learners hai. Agar mereko apna gaadi thik karna hai, par main Tamil Nadu main hoon aur mereko Tamil nahin aata hai, tho main victim hoon kya kyunki mereko Tamil baath karena vaale mechanic ke paas jaana hai? Aur jo court ka baath kar rahe ho, kabhi court ke videos dekhe ho, jaise ki Law Chakra channel pe jiska title hai "You are 69, Immature, English Speak Goes Wrong High Court" jaha pe judge stand pe aadmi ko daat tha hai aur beijjati kartha hai uski kyunki voh English main baat kar raha hai? Main court main jaunga aur mereko aisa Hindi vaala judge milega jab ki main apne aap ko best English main express kar sakta hoon, tab nuksaan mera hoega. Aapke Hindi vaalo ka nahin.
Aaj ke duniya main, jab poora internet aapke ke disposal main hain, grammar and spell checker tools hain, movies or kitaabe free main download kar sakte ho, free English tutorials hai, thoda bhi effort daalte nahin hai apna English sudhaarne main aur seekhne main; court notices, customer care chats, police certificates se lekar answer sheets main kachra likthe ho, tho gaalti hamaara nahin hai. Hum log ko blame karke "angrej ka aulad" aur "macaulay ka baccha" karke hamaare peeche padh jaate hai aapke log. Aisa nahin hai ki aapko mandarin ya russian sikhna hai. Jab Roman main itna Hindi likh lete ho, English seekhna koi badi baath nahin hai. Hindi medium schools main bhi English ka subject hota hai aur har aadmi, even jo gaon main rehta hai, unko basic words aathe hai: light, fan, oxygen, hello etc. Agar koi English aane vaale aadmi ko aap bologe "mera English itna accha nahin hai, main hindi me bol leta hoon", voh jo kaam karna hai, karke chhod dega. Peeche aake Hindi, Hindi, Hindi karoge tho chid ke, aur jyaada English bolega. Aur agar koi aadmi sochta hai ki kisi bande ko English nahin aatha hai tho uske paas technical abilities nahin hai, tho vo khud bewakoof hai. Kyunki Hindi, Bangla, Telugu medium se log doctors, surgeons, lawyers, engineers sab kuch ban chuke hai. Sochte ho ki vo log hamaare against discriminate karte nahin hai? 3 idiots main chatur ke jaise dekhte nahin hai?
@@hindiisonlyalanguagenotkno913 Mera matlab keval Hindi se nahi Tamil,Telugu ,or dusri language me bolne vale garib ya middle class jo apne baccho ko English medium me nahi padha sakte ye padhate he to low English medium me jaha English thoda bahut likh lega magar jyada nahi Sikh pata kyunki school me environment vaisa nahi,isliye college University me jaha dabdaba English ka he apne apko inferior feel karta he Hindi me hi answer likhta jisme book bhi utni acchi nahi milti accha content English me hi milega kisi bahar ke vyakti ka agar koi accha course karna chahta he to,13% matlab Tamil Telugu Hindi vale nahi in state me pitaji ke pas paise hone ke karan top ke English school me padhne valo se he ,to khud ko Tamil Telugu ka representative mat mano,dusra court vagerah me Telugu Hindi Tamil sabhi bhasha me debate ho ye me chahta hu kyonki vo vyakti un judgo ke jaise top school se padhkar ya pure English environment se nahi he vo keval Hindi Telugu vagerah hi bol sakta he to ye uska adhikar he ki usko debate me uski bhasha me sunaya jaye, dusra koi bhi Indian English fluently bolta he to Bo apni native language bhi janta he college court me Aram se apni native bhasha me bat kar sakta he ,or jis bhasha ki population jyada (Telugu Hindi Tamil other native language) vo kyo embarassing feel kare bhai ,magar use hi karna padta he ,English caste me bhraman he dono ko privilege Mila he or dono ki population Kam he
Samaaj main "division of labour" karke ek cheez hota hai. Alag alag log alag cheeze karte hai, kyunki ek aadmi sab kuch nahin kar sakta hai. Isiliye brain aur nervous system ka surgeon alag hota hai aur kidneys and urinary-tract system ka surgeon alag. Main rona shooru karunga ki "mereko surgery nahin aatha hai, yeh discrimination hai, mereko surgical theatre ke andar allow karo" tho kuch nahin hoega. Jo cheeze angreji aane karne vaale log kar sakte hai, voh angreji baath karne vaale log karthe hai. Dusre log, dusre kaam. Kitne saare shehero ke angreji baath karne vaale log ko ek truck chalaana aatha hai? Kitne logo ko kheti baadi karna aatha hai? Kitne logo ko plumbing aatha hai? Kya sabko surgery aatha hai? Electrical repairs karne aathe hai? Ghar ka khud se painting karna aatha hai? Welding aatha hai? Almost kisi ko nahin. Lekin fir bhi jab vo kaam karwaane hai aapke sanskaari hindi, tamil, bangla baath karne vaale log ka madat lena padhta hai aur unlog ko payment dena padtha hai na? Colleges main books translate karenge Indian languages main. Lekin unko English se vernacular languages main translate karne ke liye ek angreji aane vaala aadmi chahiye. Log Japan ke jaise desho ke baare main baath karte he, lekin vaise deshon main ek aabadi hota jinko angreji aatha hai aur translations karte hai. Main bohoth logon ke saath baath kartha hoon Germany, Sweden, Finland, Netherlands ke jaise deshon se. Vo ek combination mai padhte hai. Dono apne desh ke majority bhashao main + English. Aur jo idhar ke log jis tareeke se ghatiya angreji likh te hai, unlog se bohoth jyaada fluently likhte hai. Last main, mereko ek hi cheez pata chala hai, itne saare saalo ke experiences ke baad. Aapke aabadi ko hamaara type ka jindagi chahiye. Hamaara lifestyle, hamaare type ke ghar, hamaare social circles etc. Lekin nahin hai. Tho "English discrimination", "pajeet", "kanjra", "chatur", "macaulay ka baccha", "Russia, china, japan", "colonial mentality" karke peeche padh jaate ho. Jo cheez hai hamare paas hai, chahe hamaara physical lifestyle, yaa hamaare angreji baath karne vaala ability, voh saalo ke kaam aur hamaare parivaron ke bohoth saare generations ke baad aaye hai. Havaa se nahin.
Main bhi saare vernacular languages ka baath kar raha hoon. Sirf Hindi nahin. Mereko pata hai ki gaon main, aur shehero ke lower income environments main English logo ko itna aatha nahi hai. As far as inferior feel karna, inferiority complex har aadmi feel karta hai. Sirf jinko English nahin aatha hai voh nahin. Shehro main angreji baath karne vaale log aaye kaha se hai? Gaon ke vernacular bhaashao ke log se! Lekin voh log, jo socially, economically successful the. 3 bande hai, Rakesh, Ravi or Rohit. Teeno gaon ke Hindi yaa Telugu medium sai. Rakesh IPS officer banta hai, Ravi sub-inspector or Rohit ek constable. Rakesh ka baccha acche English medium school main padhta hai, use English fluently aatha hai. Ravi ka bacche ko thoda English aatha hai, aur Rohit ke bacche ko almost kuch nahin. Lekin teeno gaon se hi shuru hooe hain. Mera bhi poora father ka side ka parivaar gaon se aatha hai, lekin mere parents bhi Rakesh, Ravi or Rohit ke jaise the. Mere parivaar main jo log mere parents ke jitne successful nahin the, vo log gaon meh hi reh gaye aur unlog ke bacchon ko angreji baath karna nahin aatha hai. Ab voh log bhi successful ban gaye hai, aur unlog ke bacche angreji accha baath karte hai.
I fully support the unbiased one
Hindi hindu hindustan ka promoteerr😮
Hindi is native to india unlike English its absurd to make others learn english while dusliking hindi
Fine. Use only things which are native to India. Forget about learning Newton's laws of motion in school. Say that's a colonial imposition too because it came from an English man. Don't use TH-cam, a company headquartered in San Bruno, California. And who is forcing you to learn English? Feel free to live in Bhetua, Bihar or Rayaprolu, Andhra Pradesh. You don't need English in those places. No one speaks it and no one will ask you to learn it. But if you're going to come over to cities, get used to the fact that people many people speak English (in addition to Kannada, Bengali, Telugu or whatever) in these places. Your problem is not even English. All of you will use 1 English word in between 5 words of whatever language you're comfortable with. It's just that as the proportion of English words increases, your issue increases because you find it harder. I am not anti-Hindi, anti-Telugu or any of it, as much as you people are anti-English.
@hindiisonlyalanguagenotkno913 nobody said we shouldn't take knowledge from other nations what I said is we shouldn't dislike or disregard hindu and put english over native languages
@hindiisonlyalanguagenotkno913 btw I speak good english unlike you who don't speak hindi fluently
@@hindiisonlyalanguagenotkno913 the username shows whether you're anti hindi or just not anti hindi
@hindiisonlyalanguagenotkno913 Nobody is an anti english clown. They discussion was why should the medium of communication be english within India why can't it be a native language let's be honest the only reason you clowns are against himdi I because it's a north indian language
English is a Indian language and Sanskrit is a foreign language .
Yes language of Steppe people
English is also Indo European Language as Sanskrit.
@@sahityak33 chutiye sanskrit is Indian language and English is foreign language gaath bandh Kar rakhle.UPSC ki kitab se gyaan mat chodo . Hindu scriptures padho chodu.
Most of the Indian languages!
Lol English and Sanskrit belong to the same family 😅