Every Cuphead Boss Ranked (Including DLC)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ค. 2024
- Cuphead probably has the best lineup of bosses I've seen in a video game, and the DLC only added to this impressive selection. With this new release, I thought it would be fun to go back and rank every boss in the game. Credit to a friend of mine who S ranked every boss for giving me tips and correcting a few errors.
Patreon: / dafawfulizer
Twitter: / dafawfulizer - เกม
I love how a lot of the issues with the bosses come down to: "I had a skill issue"
Based opinion
"Hah hah FUCK YOU!" alastor 2024
"Skill issue" -👶
@@LogShaw1587
"-👶" -🤡
Well... Yeah? It's Cuphead, what did you expect? It's a game designed in such a way that every loss is your own fault. It's completely natural that some people struggle with some things. A lot of people thought the Khal's Robot was the hardest boss in the game. Me however? He was hard to go no hit. That's it. First phase required some tight strats, but that's it. Same with Cap Brineybeard.
And a boss that most people didn't really struggle with, Goopy, was one that I had a personal beef with. He's so damn simple, but "Jumping bosses" in games are my bane, I can never get good at them for some reason
Fun fact: grim matchstick s fire balls on the 3rd phase are just supposed to shoot 2 bullets but a bug happened which made it four
And they liked it more
Wat
This is the only time where a big made a attack look better than not
This is the only time where a big made a attack look better than not
Um actually its gauranteed🤓
Little tip for the dice block, if you parry the very second king dice claps his hands its a garanted 1, if you parry when he opens his hands its a garated 2 , if you parry right before the dice is fully revealed its a garanted 3
This is an ancient word of advice
@@Reddudetheog1219 I can agree
This made me getting the start over button on my winning run useless.
Really?
I thought I was the only person who did that
Grim is one of those fights people either love or hate.
I love how difficult he is (even with Lobber+Charge) and S-Ranking him was fun, but didn’t feel impossible like some others (Wally and Cala Maria)
Grim matchstick is in my top 5 favorite bosses, I really love him and seeing him at the bottom hurt me inside a little, glad to see someone else loves him too!
i dont get it tho everyone says grim, wally and cala are impossible or rlly hard i completed them in my few first attempts but the 'easy' ones are rlly hard for me
The only one of these I even considered being close to impossible was Wally Warbles. He is easily one of the hardest S Ranks, next to King Dice and Chef Saltbaker.
Is it bad that I find sally stageplay to be a harder boss than wally warbles
@@planti61 Absolutely not. For me, she was sort of difficult because of the scarce parries. I had the same issue with Mortimer Freeze.
The indicator that the fireballs in Grim's fight are about to jump is the fact that they stay down for a second with their teeth clenched before jumping. If you see them just move away, the only other obstacle is Grim's flames (occasionaly might I add) and really if you time the jump right you'll be fine.
They also look in the direction that they will jump.
And also I don’t know if this counts but only the angry ones with their teeth bared jump.
@@benma1116 perfect ....lil jerks literally been effing Me up every time
TL:DR: when they squash and streeech they jump
I can't believe that you forgot about Djimmi's secret phase. It's really cool how they used the baby plane like that.
Ikr
I've never heard of that!
He said he wont include secret bosses
Outside of Hilda Berg, I didn't care for the airplane fights until Esther Winchester. It brought back that same chaotic but balanced fun that NEVER felt like just a luck-based endurance test in any one of its phases. She's my favorite boss and taking her on was easily the best time I had in the DLC!
*Edit:* _YEHAW_ 🤠🐮
Yeeshaw
Yeehaw🤠🤠🤠🤠🤠🤠🤠🤠🤠
I agree but I love cala Maria's airplane boss fight
She rides on her spurs too, what an edgy punk.
@@chrysiewright4292 is this, maybe, possibly, a hollow knight reference?
my fave is chef saltbacker, because he invokes fear in the pre-boss segment, and that the music represents the chef in the entire fight, the music motief used in the rest of the DLC now giving a feeling of a finale that you need to bring, how the phases are represanted (especially his last phase), the plot twist, and just how hilarious he was easily redeamed, and the fight itself seems insane enough to be in 2nd place, with ester's fight insanity just barly at number 1, even if I haven't played the game once, makes the chef my favorite. P.S. the music and how the chef is shown during the phases, reminds me a bit of kefka from FF6, and sorry for typos.
Saltbaker*
Favorite*
don’t gotta tell me
@@christadoherty9341 don’t gotta correct him
@@christadoherty9341 It could also be favourite*
As with every list theres obviously going to be placements people disagree with, but my god esther getting the love and attention she deserves is always great
Ikr
Yea
best boss
Don't kill me but my personal favorite is Dr. Kahl. His first phase is so unique, and I love that it tailors itself to each player and the order in how they kill the boss (almost everyone has a different preference), I love the progression to his final phase where he pulls out his last attack in desperation, how the robot slowly falls apart until Dr. Kahl is exposed in the small little bottom half of the head. Dr. Kahl's laugh and his design also give him so much personality. I also like dodging his 3rd phase because it's incredibly difficult whilst being linear and fair, and never feels cheap unlike other difficult phases i.e. Grim's 2nd phase.
Bro same i like robots
I like dr kahl but he isnt my favorite
preach 🙏
Fr
I may be Late but Same. I just love his last phase to make things harder. It’s just awsome
I'd say that Grim is at least in my top 3 personally, sort of tied with cala maria and saltbaker. It's crazy how people have such different opinions on stuff like this
Everything is different for people. Some say Cala was the hardest but was decent for me and the robot was the bane of my existence but I know people who beat him on their first try. I guess different aspects are what do it like people who are great at platforming like Grim or honeybottoms but people who like gauntlets have a better time with Bon bon or king dice
Take a shot every time he says "Keeps you on your toes."
Ya ded.
you physically wont be able to after 5
This guy placed two of the hardest bosses all the way at the bottom, coincidence? I think not.
My fave is bootlegger boogie/moonshine mob just from the music alone along with them being still fun once you get the hang of it, the crack shot I found does similar damage to the chaser depending on the situation yet still dominates root pack’s secret phase and the dlc was all I wanted!
My personal favorite boss in the game is honestly the Devil. His attacks in the first phase are cool, referencing several of the Devil's biblical forms, the goat, spider, and the snake, and his second phase in hell is awesome as well, even if they could have done better with the final phase. Even his two battle themes are awesome(he's actually the only boss in the game with two themes I think). Overall just a great finale to the base game. Saltbaker is great, but I just prefer the Devil, both as a boss and a final boss. I also feel like I'm one of the few people who actually appreciates goopy le grande for what he is lol.
Grim matchstick is the TEXTBOOK DEFINITION of OVERHATED. Every single person I’ve seen talking negatively about Grim just needs to get good with this fight. I genuinely don’t know how anyone could rank him lower than Goopy or Beppi…
You are so incredibly right on Esther Winchester. The art is great and it is an extremely well done boss. This list is great, the only boss I would bump up is chef salt baker
I also had the misfortune of fighting the moonshine mob first out of all the dlc bosses, but that sorta helped me get back into the mood of cuphead(difficulty wise) and made the upcoming bosses more easy to handle
im gonna be honest i was so ecstatic to see esther be number 1 on this list because i 100% agree with her placement here
she has such a good balence between complete chaos but also fairness, she's not an easy boss but everytime i lost i didnt feel like murdering my switch over it. that helped make her a good and fun challenge
also i love her transformations throughout the phases and, in my opinion, she has the most dynamic changes between phases
while yes phase 1 and 2 didnt change too much since the only difference was that she left the moving saloon, if you were to tell me that a boss in cuphead accidentally cooks herself and turns into a sausage, i would think you're insane
and the crazy transformations help amplify the chaos in her fight and its just genuinely so good and i love it so much
sry for being off topic but nice claus pfp!!
For Grim Matchstick, the fireballs in the second phase that have the sharp toothy smile are the only kind that can jump. It’s not guaranteed that they’ll jump, but keep an eye on them and you should be fine.
PS: They jump to your current position or where they think your going to go. Just stay calm and pay attention.
From a gameplay standpoint, Captain Brineybeard is my fave! Just a really really fun fight!
With Grimm’s second phase, the fires do a little crouch before jumping and jump for the last cloud you were on
Am I the only one who loves Beppis laugh Ashe enters his last phase? So terrifying and fitting to his aesthetic
I rarely comment on videos but I just wanted to say that I have been watching your content since around 2015 when you did those SML countdowns, and I am astounded at how much your videos have improved over the years while still having the same feel as if they haven't aged a day. Keep up the good work man !
i personally really like the fact that grim's last phase forces you to switch up your strategy, it feels really unique! and i never found the random placement of the clouds that bothersome, but maybe its just me.
i'm also bad at parrying the dice in king dice, but i still like his fight a lot. it can be frustrating at times, but i was sooo proud of myself when i first beat him without p sugar (with chalice, admittedly). none of the specific minibosses cause that much trouble for me, cause due to the aformentioned being bad at rolling the dice, ive accidentally landed on the ones i was bad at so much that i can beat them pretty consistenly now lmao
while i love dr kahl as a character, i'd have to agree with your placement of his fight. while i usually dont mind difficult bosses, his difficulty made the boss fight borderline unenjoyable for me, even if i really love the first phase when it comes to mechanics, and it really taught me to use the miniplane lol
i absolutely love capn brineybeard gameplay wise, dodging all of the different attacks is super fun, and made me feel very skilled, even if im not the best at this game in actuality
sheriff winchester is an absolute delight, i love her as a character and i love how chaotic the fight is! on my first few attempts i had absolutely no clue what was going on, and slowly finding myself in all that chaos felt super good. although the last phase gave me a ton of trouble, i kept dying just as she was about to die
the howling aces, while not that difficult, i really love just for the sheer "WHAT THE FUCK /POS" feelings it gave me. first the fact that its not an actual airplane fight, and then the last phase, oh man! the sheer gleeful surprise i felt when MY SCREEN FUCKIN ROTATED was unparalleled, and i literally said "THAT WAS SO COOL" out loud when i beat this boss
overall i'd say my favorite bosses in cuphead are werner (fuckin love that guy, he's so ridiculous), king dice, brineybeard and the howling aces
I’ve s ranked every boss, I guess I hate myself now
Djimmi the great was always my favourite boss designwise. All 5 of his phases are challenging yet really cool. His music is also an absolute bop.
This list is incredible! I agree with 95% of your placements and you had very good points to make about each boss. Great commentary and explanations.
Also, I LOVE what you had to say about it Rumor Honeybottoms because I absolutely agree! Awesome video.
For Grim, the second phase does have an indicator for the fireballs. If you look at them, the fireball that is about to jump will be crouching down before they do jump
I am very pleased to see Esther getting the appreciation she deserves, she’s a big favorite of mine as well
Also, I feel the exact opposite with Grim and Rumor. Grim’s clouds felt way more predictable, fair, and simple to deal with while being fun and exciting, whereas Rumor’s platforms seemed way more random and unfair for me. Plus, in Rumor’s fight, it seems like you can get hit off screen significantly more than you ever would during Grim’s fight.
That being said, neither were too difficult for me. I’m playing the game for the first time and recently got to world 3. It took me like a little over an hour to beat Grim, and Rumor took maybe 2-3 hours total. Both were fun, and I absolutely adore the aesthetics and design of the levels as I do with all Cuphead bosses, but Rumor for some reason felt a bit more boring, at least gameplay wise. She was tough, and harder to fight compared to Grim, but also just kinda boring and frustrating to the point where I was getting a bit annoyed with her. Again, the attacks are cool and I love the design, but it’s just not super fun (in comparison to other bosses) to actually play, in my opinion.
Weird how people have such different experiences with the bosses, lol
Loved the video man. great commentary, editing, everything.
Grim's living fire things (or what i like to call hot tamales) actually have different face expressions, and the ones with angry eyes and large smile will jump
I like how the barrel is separate from the other bosses since it’s the true boss of that fight
This was a killer List , can’t wait for your next top list and ranking videos . And my fav boss …. Phantom Express
The root pack is personally one of the best bosses, imo. They’re the easiest to S-rank, and they have some of the simplest attacks, but it’s still fun to go back to them and it’s satisfying to use spreashot and EX’s to absolutely kick their a-
Mam I love random countdown topics, keep em' coming, please!
I totally agree with you, with sally stage play. I find her pretty challenging
I think the hardest boss in Cuphead will always be Grim Matchstick and the best boss fight in my opinion goes to Baroness Von Bon Bon.
Grim is not that hard but I respect your opinion
baroness von based based opinion
Excuse me, can you please elaborate on how your best boss in your opinion is BARONESS VON BITCH BITCH!!?!??
@@aesiro1336 fun boss
My day always gets better when I watch your videos
I'm subscribing to your channel I was stuck on dr kahls robot for 2 days I had this video on in the background and finally beat the boss today you were my good luck charm thank you
I think moonshine mob is one of the top 5 because it has such a backstory and the music is so good and the designs and they brought back the old spider designs
I agree with you :)
Moonshine mob is just. Such a boss. /pos
My favorite boss is the moonshine mob because,
A. It has mobster bugs.
B. It has the best cuphead song in my opinion.
C. It took two scrapped bosses and made them even cooler.
And D. It punishes people who get too cockey by having a fake knockout.
1. I agree
2. The anteater and snail suck doh
@WhiteManCandyVan yeah, but not getting too cocky/not celebrating too soon and keeping your guard up definitely helps.
@WhiteManCandyVan either way I found people's reaction to it pretty funny, my favorite reaction was Dawko's when he yelled at the snail and called him a little troll.
Captain Britneybeard and Esther Winchester are definitely my favorite boss fights. They’re just so fun! It’s chaos, but chaos with a pattern that i really love. Plus Esther’s design is just everything to me (along with her theme, it slaps)
Glad to know that you have good taste! lmao
For Grim Matchstick's second phase, there's both visual and audio indicator for his mini fireballs jumping.
1) they make a little "eee" noise when they're about to jump
2) along with the "eee" noise, you can see which one is about to jump by it squatting down
3) Finally, when they jump, there's an audible giggle
Heres a tip for Sally: Use the Twist-Up for her final phase or a homing weapon. Preferably Krack Shot.
Not in a rude way but it’s spelled crack shot
I love ranking videos and dafawfawliser does it the best
Great ranking! Esther is my favorite boss too and High-Noon Hoopla is easily the best song in the whole game
I think the 2nd phase of Glumstone the Giant is my favorite. I just love references to the og game.
I agree that’s my fave phase in all of cuphead after all
I also love cala maria and ester since their costume designs and character designs look unique and stand out.
Bro said difficulty isn’t what he’ll take into consideration for the ranking and started going on about how Grim Matchstick was hard asf💀
Reel all the bottom bosses are there because he had skill issue
I've been watching you for a few years now and how don't you have more subscribers your content is so good
I love the first phase of glumstone too. There IS something so satisfying of parrying those pink clouds with mrs chalice
Junkyard Jove is my favorite boss theme! Kahl was a decent boss
With King Dice, I just paused the game right before the number I wanted to land on and then unpaused it and immediately hit parry right after to get the number I wanted. It always worked for me
wtf i never thought of that. thats actually smart
My favorite boss was definitely the Moonshine Mob, because it is the embodiment of everything that I love in a fight: Beautiful backdrop, creative ideas, Hard but not insanely so, and, most importantly, an amazing theme. (The music is my favorite part of the entire Cuphead series)
Cupheads boss lineup is probably the best there creative varied and fun. Kinda just sounds like undertale
Esther straight up just turned herself into sausages to avoid giving you her limes.
she must really like thoes limes
0:06 we all love cuphead :)
:')
My top 5 favorite Cuphead Boss Fights
1: Cagney Carnation
2 : Werner Werman
3 : Esther Winchester
4 : The Phantom Express
5 :The Root Pack
My top 5 most hated Cuphead Boss Fights
1: Dr. Kahl's Robot
2: Grim Matchstick
3: The Devil
4: Djimmi the Great
5: Mortimer Freeze
Why do you hate the devil boss
@@amiibojeremiah809 well, I don't necessarily hate the Devil boss, but the reason I "hate him" is because of the difficulty
Thanks, this video taught me about bombs, I’ve been struggling with Wally Warbles last stage,
My favorite fight is Dr. Kahl tbh
The fight is so much fun on Expert, and to me, it felt like a perfect end to Air Fights in base cuphead, since you can either fight him or Cala as the last one.
The First Phase is so fun, the second is a nice breather to relax.
I LOVE Phase 3, a harder variation of Wally's attack (well, to me its actually easier than that.) It feels like an intense and fun desperation round!
Yeah, he was pretty fun to S rank, without being too much of a challenge.
I managed to s rank it using a really cool strat that makes it very fun
@@xmanthegreat370 what was it?
Werner Werman is the most underrated boss in the entire game, he’s my personal fav in cuphead
Agreeable point
@@flashlightpistolgaming9753 is this the real werner werman
@@symmetricksambigrams if the show is cannon, yes
Dude I feel you on your King Dice take...
That fucking die makes me mald more than Grim Matchstick and Dr. Kahl's Robot combined. It makes me do more bosses than I should and has made me "start over" almost 10 times throughout my gameplay.
My favorite boss theme is moonshine mob I just like jazz
Fun fact: Grim Matchstick’s fireball was supposed to only shoot out two fireballs, two horizontally or two vertically, but due to a coding error they shoot out two horizontally AND vertically.
It's very hard to see but the indicator for the fireballs that jump at you in Grim's fight are the angry eyebrows
Bro moonshine mob is my favorite not only does it bring back scrapped content and has the theme of a mafia boss but the theme is a banger
great enjoyable video!
I can’t take this guys opinion seriously. Maybe I was just too good at the game. I finished it in less than 3 days with all expert rank. I agree that S rank is for people who hate themselves =>
I can’t agree with grim matchstick and junkyard jive being worse than intro bosses, I can’t believe king dice places so low.
When I replayed the game a few months ago (after not for about a year), I beat the game regularly in 5 hours, and I S-Ranked everything in a few days.
This *Guy's*
@@henryapplebottom7231 I personally don’t care what he thinks, we all have different opinions. But his opinions are so un-based lmaoooo
There is a way to know where the fireballs in phase 2 of grim matchstick go they lean towards the place they jump so there is a indicator (I consider the phase easy)
My favorite cuphead boss was the moonshine mob because of the macanics are very unique the music is amazing and the background and boss disign is gorgeous
2:28 this stage gets a giant increase in difficult if you play with sound, the fireballs make a noise every time they jump, so it can be very easy to know when you should dodge them with practice
26:46 wait molten honey? what kinda honey do you have!?
I think my favorite part of Cuphead is how different everyone's opinions are like how dr.khal was second to last on your list but on mine he is top 3 and just think it's really cool how much variety there is when it comes to peoples opinions
Yeah I say grim is my top 12 (number 11)
The indicator is that the fire should be yellow and a evil is face. The orange-ish ones that are evil don’t jump, and the yellow ones that are scared don’t jump aswell. It’s just the direction that’s random.
I love how when fast forwarding you see sally stageplay, baroness von bon bon, and Hilda berg right after each other like in the song “You signed a contract”
Holy crap. I swear that wasn't intentional
In my opinion the hardest boss in expert mode is Wally warbles my favorite is Werner werman
Me too I love Werner werman
Interesting Fact:In first versions of Cuphead were public DR KARL BOSS HAD 2 PHASES bcz modern 2 phase was just transformation between first and second phases so 3 phase WAS EVEN LONGER
For me in king dice my strategy to time it is once your number passes and it’s on the next one you jump and when you parry it matches up perfectly it’s hard to get consistent at first, but once you figure it out king dice gets so much easier as long as you have a few particular bosses you want to face
Saltbaker 2nd phase is honestly my favorite phase in all of Cuphead, it’s the only phase in this game which does something completely different with how you’re supposed to hit the boss, and I really love that, no other boss does that so, I applaud you Chef Saltbaker! For having the most unique phase in out of all of Cuphead!🤩
where have you been? are you OK?
p.s, Does the new season of TD live up to your hopes of it being on-par with the early seasons?
I haven't gotten to see the new season yet. Yes I'm ok. I'm just really busy
OK, just that you not uploading in a while, and your mental health issues
@@Dafawfulizer Ah okay, good to know you’re still around.
Esther Is my least favourite boss, there’s always way too many projectiles on screen at once and the 3rd phase feels way too fast for me
I can see where you get that opinion from.
34:51 damn bruh that poor pup
Lol 😂 love yur ranking mate 👍
"The best part though, is phase three. When RIbby and Croaks fuse to become a slot machine, as frogs are known to do"
-Dafawfulizer, August 8th, 2022
I’m sorry you said you weren’t going to rank them on difficult but the lower part of the list is litterly just the hardest bosses. There really fun and creative and there so far down. Sounds like you just don’t like hard bosses?
I mean, seeing how the easiest ones also made the bottom of the list, am gonna say he prefers medium-difficulty.
I dont see how changing up the gameplay a bit is bad. I kinda like grim's last phase. Those platforms suck tho
Hilda Berg is one of my favourite bosses, the concept is just so unique, I mean a zepplin that summons star constellations and becomes the moon? Also Phantom express mega unique, but the dlc bosses are all just awesome, they really outdid themselves there, but honestly, all bosses are special as they are
the guy in the plane platform you stand on is actually the little glue-bottle guy who INTRODUCES you to the *plane* levels
I still haven't beaten King Dice. Can I get some advice for him please?
Just... Stay calm. It took me a fuck lot to beat this boss as well and with the dlc new weapons and charms... It still not easy. So the only advice i can give is that stay calm, if ya keep ya cool, think of weapons that can personally help ya, ya will beat the boss! And when i did... I was happiest enby in the entire house hold! Ya can do this! Don't let king dice intimidate ya!
@@miilexthemii9353 yeh, the worst part is I wasted one of the Game Djimmis. Because apparently beating one of his mini-bosses counts as a win
First goal,learn to time the dice, it doesn’t take much time to learn, then find your preferred fights,(I prefer fights 3,5 and 7 because of smoke bomb) Then once you get to king dice try to hug the left or right sides of the screen then alternate left to right after he finishes his attack, most of the time you will go under his arm and will completely avoid his attack, otherwise you better be good at parrying. Then just keep trying until you get the win
Get good at parrying if you want the “fun” part. To cheese it, just stay behind where his hand will summon cards from. I never did the cheese route tho.
I like the fact that Werner werman's boss fight has a lot of hidden WW2 symbolism, with Werner being somewhat based on Wittman, and the cat being based on the British.
Yeah, they reminded me of tom and Jerry too.
I like how they switched from the base game having a late Fletcher brothers character design with Disney style animation, to a more high budget disney animated movie, like Rescuers down under. Bosses like Goopy La Grande or Bon Bon feel like an animated short akin to Silly Symphonies (BBB was directly based on the Cookie Carnaval anyway)
“When rugby and croaks fuse into a slot machine, As frogs always do.” YOUR AN ABSOLUTE SCIENTIST!!1!1
Grim felt like a challenge to overcome, a rite of passage for the game
But I hated Beppi so much more
A lot of people have pointed out how Goopy was likely based on the iconic blue Slimes from the Dragon Quest franchise. Besides Goombas and Waddle Dees, they’re probably some the most basic minions that you can find in video games (RPGs specifically). While is doesn’t excuse how pathetic Goopy le Grande is compared to the other bosses, I think it’s supposed to be a tongue-in-cheek joke about him being one of the first (and easiest) enemies in the game.
King dice actually has timing for his dice which you are able to time.
His fight is amazing honestly.
My ranking:
25. The Devil
24. Sally Stageplay
23. Beppi the Clown
22. Phantom Express
21. Cala Maria
20. Mortimer Freeze
19. Grim Matchstick
18. Goopy le Grande
17. Glumstone the Giant
16. Captain Brineybeard
15. Barones Von Bon Bon
14. Hilda Berg
13. King Dice
12. Ribby and Croaks
11. Esther Winchester
10. The Howling Aces
9. Werner Werman
8. Moonshine Mob
7. Djimmi the Great
6. The Root Pack
5. Wally Warbles
4. Rumor Honeybottoms
3. Cagney Carnation
2. Chef Saltbaker
1. Dr. Kahl's Robot
You have an unhealthy opinion of karhls robot
@@henryapplebottom7231 I just like the difficulty level of this boss. And idea is good
Reason why I love chefsalt Baker is context all of his attacks in the first phase are the ingredients you’ve been collecting and the leaves are also the pineapplemint leaves
fun fact about the moonshine mob, both the spider mobster and the dancer bug were scrapped concepts reused for this boss, specifically the spider mobster was the gentleman spider seen in the trailer, and the dancer bug was the light, a boss concept where beams of light rotate around the boss and with multiple floors to move between
Def Mortimer freeze I hate fighting him but the animation when he rolls as a snow man is so satisfying and great animation
Great list! My favorites are captain brineybeard and howling aces. My least favorites are dr.kahl's robot and esther winchester