NEW 2019 Android Auto VS Apple Carplay - REAL WORLD TEST
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ค. 2019
- Android Auto vs Apple CarPlay. Android Auto July 2019 Update
Support us on Patreon: / thestraightpipes
Become a TH-cam Member! / @thestraightpipes
Subscribe! th-cam.com/users/subscription_c...
Facebook! / thestraightpipes
Instagram! / thestraightpipes
Twitter! / straightpipers
Buy our shirts! Profits go directly to burnouts: teespring.com/stores/thestrai...
Check out Continental Tire at www.continentaltire.ca
-------------------
#androidauto #applecarplay #androidvsapple
------------------- - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Android Auto vs Apple CarPlay Round 4. Who wins this one?
Haven't finished the video but Andriod all the way baby 😅
Never came so fast!
ANDROID BROOOOO
Apple CarPlay all the way
Carplay ftw!
It’s good that you guys keep re-doing these videos. They have come a long way since they came out.
Joseph Schatz AGREED
👍🏻
one of these videos used to be their most viewed video ...now it's the second most viewed on the channel
Exactly what I thought! So much fun they keep on redoing it! There's an apple carplay update available for my car and I'm finally gonna do it today if I can
Danny Vazquez and you can really see the development of their relationship
The non-full screen is 100% vehicle dependent. My fiance's 2019 Mazda 3 hatch uses the FULL SCREEN with AA.
16:9 is "widescreen" and has been since the beginning of time.
@@user-ji3il6ce2o Actually CarPlay is way way ahead it now supports all shapes and sizes of displays in iOS 13 now so you could even make it on an octopus shape! Carplay also supports 2 seperate video screens so once manufactures add that in, it can also expand to your HUD!
Also in iOS 13 manufacturers can now include preloaded apps which appear in CarPlay which can integrate car controls such as your AC etc and cameras. Without ever leaving CarPlay! (I know other manufactures did this before but that doesn't count as they made a CarPlay app which you have to download and runs on the phone instead of an app which runs on the car alongside with CarPlay running of your phone)
Sorry but you can't just redefine the term widescreen.
@@user-ji3il6ce2o actually, 16:9 is widescreen because 4:3 used to be standard. Widescreen TVs, monitors, and phones are 16:9. It's only recently that we got these wider screens
Hold up did he say "typical Android thing to do" because they "copied" apple carplay, bruh apple does the same thing x10 and no one bats an eye
Very true
Most Apple users don't know what's happening around them
Sadly true
Literally most things in ios were in Android like 4 years ago... Command center... Swype typing.. Etc etc
@@ryanberardelli2363 totally. Since Jobs passed, Apple has been an utter blunder. They haven't innovated and don't lead the space anymore. Really really good at marketing though.
Android Auto wins because Android auto can control Spotify. CarPlay can't
EDIT: It seems that Apple has updated CarPlay to support Spotify, I no longer own an iPhone so I cannot test that for myself
Marco Morel ?? Spotify works just fine in my VW Golf with Carplay...
@@x0rbian I meant try asking Siri to play something on Spotify. Siri can't control anything else other than Apple music and basic skip and pause functions on 3rd party apps. Google Assistant can fully control Spotify natively
iOS 13 in September fixes ths
@@dalex7777 it's not a bug. Apple has deliberately blocked Siri from being able to control third party apps so they will be forced to switch to Apples in house apps or the companies pay a 30 percent Apple Tax on their product. And even then you aren't guaranteed that Siri will be unlocked to support your product
Marco Morel no Apple won’t allow third party to steal data
I have an Apple but I’m having trouble with face recognition... any advice?
Lmao ChrisFix team Android
Soapy wooder
Congrats! Apple's placed their seal of disapproval upon your face! 🤣
I think I see the problem. You don't have a face known to the world so Apple won't work for non-faced humans. Try holding up a Big Head of Yuri and you'll be set!
Wash it
You forgot that if lets say your wife plugs in her phone and she has an IPHONE. You cannot use any other APP on the phone itself while using navigation because it will minimize the navigation on car play. Also anything you do on the the car screen will also mimic a function on the phone.. This means if you swap between screens on car play it will interrupt whatever your wife is doing on her phone..... Android lets you use navigation and multi task on the phone without issue at all .. so if your passenger is linked up you can use nav from their phone while they use their phone for other things...
dattebyo It's already fixed with iOS 13
@@dattebyo The update wont come for normal users until september but they've already given it to developers so we know its gonna happen
My car has a dedicated USB for CarPlay/AndroidAuto so I don’t experience this. Should be the same with all Kia/Hyundai
@@tannerclark5374 my sister has a 2019 Elantra SEL and it has the mirroring problem.
Exactly! We'll it might be fix on ios 13 but AA had this all along though and this will always win in my book over anything else.
Siri sounded better 👍
But
You can set Google assistant voice to John legend
Sooo...
Unfortunately John Legend's voice was discontinued last year. Sadly.
I absolutelly love the way you do this!! I was smiling the through the whole video :) There is a little bit of competition, but there is no loosing or winning side, its just a game, nothing serious and i love this
Do a round 5 when iOS 13 comes out. CarPlay is so much different.
The Big Shebang also Apple maps will be much better I think
Exactly this is going to make it even better!
You friggin know it
But still inferior from my experience :/
Multiple screen support in iOS 13 I wonder how long it will take OEMs to implement developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2019/252/
That's incorrect, you don't have to connect to Bluetooth first with Android Auto. When you plug it in it connects to Bluetooth seamlessly. @thestraightpipes
No, it is correct. You must have Bluetooth enabled but it does it automatically. That's what I meant by that. You can't turn it off while in Android Auto
@@TheStraightPipes Ah yes, sorry. Thought you meant you have to go through the painful Bluetooth pairing first.
@@TheStraightPipes With android auto I don't even have to turn Bluetooth on, it turns on automatically when I connect with USB. Must just be a car specific thing.
@@TheStraightPipes You said it in the video like it's an issue. However, there's no setup or effort required - unless your test vehicle is more difficult than my simple Chevy Cruze...
@@TheStraightPipes slightly confused. So there's no action required at all from user's point of view, correct?
You can change the voices in android. .. so that's not a point for apple.
You can change it in apple to
In apple you can change it from female to male and there’s different accent and that they can both speak
Okay, fine answers but then you need to agree no point for apple, and no point for android it's a tie here
Roberto Carlos yeah that’s true it’s a tie then
Nope, the Apple voice sounds natural, so def a point there to Apple
Erm, the Bluetooth connection is automatic on Android Auto. It is an option in settings.
I just have to connect my phone through USB and Android auto itself connect to Bluetooth and everything, i don't have to manually do that
Exactly same for me
Same here
@Gob Comon no but yuri was saying that he lost a point because of it but its not the case in all cars
Yeah, that's been one of the day-one features for AA for me. Automatic Bluetooth pairing.
@@papaannefranku9693 lucky what kinda car do you have
This series is honestly one of my favorite things you've done over the years. It would be great if you did more side-by-side comparisons for entertainment stuff.
The energy between both you guys, makes the video more fun to watch! Thumbs up for sure.
"typical android" to copy apple? Really? Like ... REALLY?!
Exactly what I thought..
yeah this is objectively wrong
Android, maps are the most important aspect to me.
Google Maps*
@@MrMentalSoul you missed the comma
You can use google maps on iOS 🤷🏻♂️
@@HOTPLATEGAMING but it's not as good as the Google Maps on Android Auto. The video goes over this.
@@HOTPLATEGAMING yes but functionality is dumbed down on apple as shown in this video.
You guys are so funny and generally entertaining! Great work as usual. Much love from the Uk
5:59 I don’t think Jakub’s “aboot” was Canadian enough, but your “Send It”s were on point!
You guys rock! Looking forward to the road trip vid!
Android Auto wins because it doesn't force you to use apple maps when using voice assistant!
Bryan Laseter exactly
Bryan Laseter I get the sneaking suspicion you’ve never used CarPlay 😂
iOS 13 has changed that by just adding “in Google Maps” after your direction search from the home screen ;)
I stand corrected! Thanks for the info!
@@maxfic So we have to waiz
Should have installed iOS 13 beta for this video, CarPlay has changed a lot.
That is correct
@@jaisal_mehrok with ios 13 changes carplay scrapes android auto from the map totally
Replying to all: Yes, just as Android Auto caught up to what CarPlay was in iOS 12 it’s going to leapfrog them all over again in iOS 13, it’s literally becoming unbeatable, it’s so good it isn’t even fair for Android Auto.
Other than Dark Mode, the changes to CarPlay were one of the main reasons I bit the bullet and joined the iOS13 Public Beta program, I use it all the time and the difference to iOS12 CarPlay is Night and Day.
CarPlay finally feels like a properly refined and finished product, it’s fantastic.
Matt, I think it’s probably a good idea that they wait until it’s out of beta so they can create another video when it happens, which is also a great way to game the TH-cam algorithm as lots of people will be performing searches about it.
Still a little too buggy for prime time.
Hi guys, you did nice job as always, but I was a little bit disappointed that you didn't mentioned the new feature of Android Auto: If you are on the media facet, current navigation will be shown bottom of the screen as small notification bar.(non wide screen). And if you are on the map facet, then media controller is shown bottom of the screen..! I think this is most important feature for this new design at all..!
Love these tests keep up the great work lads. September Round 5 will be awesome.
Yuri happy as hell to say android did something apple already did 🤣🤣 what are you at now?
Apple: 3
Android: 35
Team Android 💪🏻
@@TheStraightPipes My Man
Most Android users have a more rounded understanding of tech and can appreciate many companies and manufacurers, including Apple. They usually give Apple credit where credit is due. Where as Apple users seem to lack some knowledge and are obsessed with demonstrating how Apple is the best and nothing else is worthy and showing where Apple copied Android (even though Android has always had every feature first and 2-3 years earlier than Apple) 😂😂😂😂
@@ChannelTwentyTwo I have MUCH second and first hand experience with this! People who have understanding of Android are less biased. Apple users are TOTALLY BLIND FOLLOWERS! It is the ONLY thing keeping me from buying one. -I can't be a part of ignorance. Shame because I think Apple is a MUCH better company. However the bar is pretty low with CIA/FBI/Alphabet Inc..
Channel TwentyTwo I disagree. This might be true for people who actually prefer Android and use the higher end Android devices (which I don't believe is a ginormeous part of the Android users), but it's incorrect to automatically assume apple users equal to having less knowledge when it comes to tech - or Android users have more of it. I'm an apple user and definitely appreciate Android as well.
I agree a lot of people get iPhones because it's trendy, it's what other people have (so it's easier for a friend to help or to use apple-exclusive features like airdrop), it's what they're familiar with and for some people: it's American made.
But there are also a lot of people out there (and I wouldn't be surprised it's the biggest part of the Android users) that get an Android just because that's what happens to come with the phone they bought. They didn't do a lot of research and don't care about specs either. If you look at a smartphone for under €400 for example, chances are pretty high it's gonna be an Android. Doesn't mean it's gonna be a good phone and nowhere near as good as the experience a €1.000 Android phone could give you, but it does count when somebody mentions how many people out there use Android's.
From my experience, people with iPhones just don't care about what anybody else has. It's just inconvenient some things are not compatible. Whereas Android users (the cheap kind) can't stop telling us how stupid we are for wasting money on an iPhone, even though I've seen some of them SWITCH to iPhones when it was gifted to them or when they could afford it.
My friends with higher-end Android's (actual Android users) don't care either, and I appreciate them a lot. These are the Android users you were talking about. The iPhone users you were talking about, are moms, dads or average consumers.
Great video guys.
Following my original earlier comment about CarPlay in iOS13 beta, these are the new noteworthy features:
1. Additional video stream support to show information in the cars built in gauge cluster or hud. (Vehicle dependent)
2. Independent app views so you can use a different app on your phone to what’s displaying on the cars screen. (Handy if you’re the passenger and still want to use your phone whilst the nav is on)
3. Redesigned home screen with new dashboard and a new light theme option.
4. A new settings app on the CarPlay screen for adjusting the new light/dark mode etc.
5. A much smaller and less intrusive Siri interface.
6. Tweaked and much better looking music UI.
7. You can now pinch pan and zoom on the map which you couldn’t do in iOS 12 as you showed.
8. I’m pretty sure you can now use Siri to control google maps if you specify you want google maps, although I haven’t personally tested that yet.
9. There’s a bunch more just go look on Apple’s website, iOS 13 preview and look under ‘All New Features’ where it lists all the new features, and then look for CarPlay, it’s quite a way down the page. www.apple.com/ios/ios-13-preview/features/
I’ve been using the iOS 13 public beta since beta 2 and the new features and tweaks to CarPlay are massive for me, it’s changed the whole experience and taken CarPlay from being good the being downright unbeatable.
It’s that good in my opinion.
Android Auto just caught up to where CarPlay was/is currently in iOS 12, but when iOS 13 drops for the public it’s going to leapfrog Android Auto all over again, the new update really has finished CarPlay off nicely.
Please do another video like this when iOS 13 drops in September, it’s definitely worth a revisit because they’ve basically fixed all of the little gripes you still have with CarPlay.
Love your reviews, especially the Android Auto vs Apple Carplay videos.
I didn't realise how much I look forward to these each year until you came out with this new one.
Looking forward to a new one when the updated Apple Carplay is released.
Siri won't control a number of 3rd party apps like Google Assistant does
about the voice-quality of android auto:
I just played around with android auto in my new renault Zoe which only supports android and:
I had to manually switch the audio-connection for the voice from bluetooth to USB.
after that the voice sounds as clear as siri would
In a Jaguar calling for the inevitable tow truck would have been a more appropriate test.
This should be the top comment
3 years ago i got to know you guys from the 1st round of Android Auto vs Apple Car Play. Back then you guys just have less than 5k subscriber. And look at you guys now! I really proud of both of you! Hope i can be like you one day!
I enjoyed this video. You two are entertained
Great video!
Can you guys review the Acura TL Type S please!!! Btw big longtime fan of the channel keep the growth and the good work!!
I can control all of my smart home devices attached to Google Home from my car! "Hey google! Cool my living room! " or "Hey Google! Turn the Boiler on!" and much more....
What a great video! really enjoyed it
Awesome video, love the way you compared the two platforms!
Great video series. You guys looked so much younger at 1:10.
Would love for you guys to do a comparison on an aftermarket kit since built in ones generally have really weird exceptions or restrictions.
I think they are basing their judgment solely on that car without fill knowledge of the program. My mail is 100%, Australian voice, and don't have to hook up Bluetooth. May be Jaguar or manufacturer specific
Randy Treadway bebey
Been waiting for it for so loong 😂
I liked the older android auto interface better than this poor carplay clone. It was much simpler and easy to use while driving. Now you have to look at 20 icons to launch apps.
Agreed
As someone with shorter arms and small hands I prefer the android setup for icons because I don't ever have to reach to the far side.
The only piece I wish I could do is full screen the whole map but having the widgets there is a pretty good compromise since it is nice to be able to see other things like phone calls and music without hitting buttons and losing your map.
Y’all hilarious and best friend petty!👊🏿🔥
hahaha Maps in 80% of the reason for plugging in your phone, so AA wins
Nope I plug my phone in for music
@@SeoulDaebak7 but music is a tide tho..anyway they both have their good and bad...
I use BMW’s maps and I can always use Apple Maps on CarPlay and switch it to BMW from there
Why do you say that AA won here. Yes it uses more of the screen but no pinch to zoom makes it at best even I would think
@@SeoulDaebak7 For music you really don't have to purchase either of them. You just need a bluetooth connection and thats all.
Both are overkill in your case.
Jakub Jetski pointing out carplay subscription for BMW 👍
“Did you notice that my girl’s voice sounded a little clearer?” 😂😂
Greatings from Poland :D I just saw your video and I stayed because of Jakub Wrobel :D Of course the content of video is cool too, but seeing somebody with polish roots in USA is fun :D Especially if he is TH-camr :D!
LETS GGOOOOO ive been waiting forever
Am I the only one who likes the old android Auto, I like the main screen that shows my notifications with gps at the top then song playing and messages and calls. The only apps I care about while driving is music, maps, and phone. And the old android layout had it set up nicely with no clutter. Just a simple menu at the bottom and that's it. On my car Android auto fills the whole screen also.
CarPlay is great, except for when it’s not. I’ve used CarPlay in both a Honda and a Subaru. Both systems have issues with the volume getting stuck (usually at a high setting) when CarPlay is enabled. CarPlay doesn’t always seem to integrate smoothly with the manufacturers’ proprietary software. There’s definitely room for improvement.
That’s not Apple’s fault. Apple Car Play works perfectly fine on my Kia.
HOLY CRAP YURI I JUST SAW YOU ON AN EPISODE OF STORAGE WARS!!! 🤣
The winner is Android auto in my opinion . That map on apple car play is a trash. It is unuseable while driving.
You can use google maps with apple carplay and also Waze.
@@SoundMan1985 google maps on apple car play doesnt work as well as does on android auto.
What's an apinion?
@@deepee1544 Opinion.take it easy.
@Antonio Zamudio i agree.
Tell me they changed it so you can actually fiddle through Spotify with out getting shut down for safety
Watched a couple of your videos for the first time and very entertaining. I've been using Apple products since the mid 80's but I have to say when it comes to my car and phone I'm definitely digging Android Auto. Love in particular the full access to google maps. Can't beat it.
I have an iPhone.
I’d have to say google wins everything. It just seems way better - especially because google maps work sooo much better.
Except the stores. Google play really blows.
@@Slays_Media wym? google play store is much clearer than app store
@@Slays_Media there's a new look at the Play Store now though, it looks much better
@@Jean_Baptiste I haven't looked at the Apple Store in like a decade, but I hate purchasing music on the play store, since it can't be downloaded to the device's music app.
@@Slays_Media that's not something i look into, so cannot say
For the next one, can you try do the music test with Spotify?!
There’s a new Apple CarPlay now, Round 5, please
The new android auto version jumps straight into your prefered navigation app, and it can also start the music automatically. You should've mentioned that in the video
2 Points AA! 😂 I actually like this new update as for me it runs in the normal non-split screen widescreen mode.
Can't say I agree with your review, I use both the new Android Auto and Apple car play in my Audi. Android Auto looks slightly different to the one you shown, I suspect it adapts differently with different screens, for example mine has the background app info at the bottom of the screen not to the sides.
The widescreen problem is only in some cars.
My ford fiesta uses the whole screen, so i guess it's jaguar problems.
That wide-screen function can be change in developer setting, set it to 720p and above gives u widescreen mode. If ur headunit doesn't have native hd resolution it will default at 480p, but u probably still can use hd mode
I have a 2017 Si. And my whole android auto screen goes all the way across. Next video try using a new civic. #TeamAndroid
i really love your videos from all rounds i am following you guys. you are doing great job.
i have seen on the internet there are some wireless dongles in the market for apple car play and Andriod auto for the android head unit. Can you please please please make a review on it.
5:03 He sounds more like a robot than siri XD
"Hey.. Siri...Play.. A.. Song.."
"Ok, playing Darude Sandstorm"
Yuri is the typical apple fanboy, almost every time he compare android to IOS/apple he gets it backwards.....
I agree with other posters, widescreen is vehicle dependent. My Ford Fusion allows Android Auto widescreen and looks way better than that Jag.
2019 honda cr-v. 2016 Chevy Colorado. Use the full screen with android auto.
I appreciate these videos but I think the big issue here is the car that's being used. I've got a 2018 Cadillac XTS that has both and they both fill the entire screen 🤷🏾♂️ In regards to the assistant voice they both have options to change how they sound so yes there are more natural sounding options available. I'm not a fan of either of the icon setups but I do appreciate having widgets. I also love having a map that can be used the same as if on the phone. All that being said neither is worth the hassel compared to my cars actual built in functionality. Oh and one other thing.... why in the world would you need to use bluetooth when you have your phone directly connected via USB? I don't need to use bluetooth with my android auto connection. It sounds like the car's interface is the issue here and not the app itself.
Yeah i never have to worry about Bluetooth, I just plug in and AA is good to go.
I'd say that maps feature (being able to pinch and move) is the most important. Therefore I gotta go with Android Auto. These are driving assistants after all
Aplinderjit Singh: Not most important. What’s important is for the assistant to understand instructions. More functions you can do with voice, the better. No hands!
@@ntokozontombela6968 that's completely fair. I personally only drive with 1 hand anyways so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I actually like the more options on the home screen of Android
Full screen in my KIA Proceed GT 2019!
Can't wait for the Android Auto update. Apple Car Play map zoom feature LOL
Shoulda waited another month until the new Carplay with iOS 13 is released. It’s also completely different.
It would have probably had a few more glitches though since it's not a mass release yet
Should have waited until ios13 Apple CarPlay has change a great deal
I will second the notion that you guys should definitely do a new video when iOS 13 comes out in September, as CarPlay will be completely redesigned, and looks amazing so far.
But also, I would suggest Yuri re-install Apple Maps around that time as well. While I don't think the redesigned Apple Maps will have reached Canada by then, I think he should be ready to add that to the review, since he's always trashing it. It's actually getting really, really good, and I've been using it over Google Maps for the past few months, even though New York City hasn't received the redesigned maps yet.
I've been using iOS 13 carplay..... It's in another league. Can't wait till your next video!
ANDROID as I demand flexibility to utilize some preferences plus my car lacks a widescreen (that be a negative of the car first) haha!
@@AutoVantage. instead of telling you what I mean I'd rather ask you if you would want to change anything with iOS or better yet prefer it give you some other capabilities you don't currently have. If so would you want to implement and/or display said additions in a way that makes your interaction with your device as quick and efficient as possible? If the answer to the first or second question is no, then you Sir have answered your own question and should stay with the mobile platform and ecosystem that serves you well already. I hope that helps and I appreciate the question!
I prefer Android Auto although I dont like Apple products, so I guess Im biased
Are used Apple CarPlay for the first time this past weekend and I liked it a lot. Normally I use Google maps and I just listen for the voice prompts or I look at the screen of the phone. Having Apple CarPlay makes it so much easier to use iPhone and still use Google maps. The one downside was that there was no zoom in and zoom out feature that I can find.
The screen goes full for Android auto depending on what vehicle head unit you have . And you can customize the voices to celebrities like Waze used to allow I'm currently using John legend as my assistant voice . And there's an option in AA settings to go lite mode or dark and in the iOS 13 betas you can use the new carplay right now there's also an option in AA to use wireless, Bluetooth, or plug in connection
You guys should stay tuned for carplay with ios 13 ^^
I got the beta and it has some neat new features.
The widescreen on Apple Carplay made it look too chunky. You want those icons as close to the driver as possible, while giving DJ duty to your passenger, which Android did perfectly there.
Maybe there could be a button to make it full screen so the user has options. Sounds like the android thing to do.
Love your videos, really good as always.
Here is a fun test for you guys:
When you want to do the Send text message",
Make it so that Jakub has 2 phone numbers. One a standard phone and the other a mobile phone.
When you will ask to send a text message to Jakub, notice the difference.
Google will ask to select which phone number. Apple.wil not and will,immediately choose the mobile,phone (as it should)
😉
I like being able to always see the time and the song information. I don't need all that space wasted by 20 icons I'm never going to use.
Android Auto!! Also, can't wait to see the M340i review. I've been waiting for it!
Android auto works full screen on my 2017 Audi
You are so cool! Nice comparison ;-)
I like that you can control music while having maps open. But i like both equal
You can ask Siri to navigate via Google Maps I use it every day on my CarPlay.
I think you need to use this while driving, since that's the point of Android auto and Apple car play.
We did, in previous videos. It's the same
You can also change the voice of your Android auto to your favorite celeb
I'm excited for round 5
Android Auto by far. When driving home and I'm 5 min away, i can say "okay google, turn my thermostat to 72 degrees, and turn on my porch light, and living room light."
Android Auto has always had icons at the bottom of the screen.
In AA if there's someone sitting next to you who might want to play music from any app, they can use the music app and select songs while navigation remains on but in AC, if we open the music app it also shows up on the car screen which we might not want.
It all depends on the car for the wide screen, also it's slot easier to see the time on the AA wide screen, with better music control while not leaving the maps
In smartphone world it's Apple following Android.
I’m curious about your reasons for not liking Apple maps. I think it works very well.
E J exactly. I don’t like this review because a typical iPhone user actually uses Apple Maps. Apple Maps is wonderful now.
Google maps is on another level tho
One thing you missed about the Assistant Voice in Android Auto is that you can change the Voice in Android and it now users your preference in Android Auto. You can also choose quality levels. YMMV
Why aren't there links to the other rounds in the description or embedded in the video?
Another Android Auto vs CarPlay coming after iOS13