Judaism in India | israeli girl reaction
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2024
- For me personally this is very interesting to learn about my people in different countries, especially in India
Instagram
/ that1israeligirl
koo app
www.kooapp.com...
original video- • Judaism in India (68 C...
I'm a indian jewish and proud to be an indian shalom
Is JFR Jacob sir your ancestor?
Shalom, my brother! Jai Hind! Jai Bharat! Jai Israel!
Love all jewi from India
but the bitter truth is that both Judaism and Hinduism is victimized as Devil against Islam/Christianity while deep in our heart we know that its just way of life for us, I can remain Hindu without even practicing it, still other religion hate us.
💪🕉️🇮🇳✡️
Hindus too never say anyone to convert to their religion , thats how similar and beautiful these two old relgions in the world are 🇮🇳🇮🇱❤️
Shoo idol worshippers. Stop worshipping cow.
@@fayaqun0 we don't worship . But one of our sage Shri Gorakhnath was very fond of cow herding, thats why we don't let anyone kill it
You can't convert anyone to Hindu no matter what. The concept of conversion doesn't exist in Hinduism
@@anithusiast. yea because everybody was hindu and then they made thier own culture and religion out of it
@@fayaqun0 stupid... Shut up your mouth... Truth is always bitter.
Hindu people never hate other religion people, even people who are from another country we respect them.
Many tribes who kicked out from their country they came in India and living happily.
Same in Hinduism.. There is no concept of converting the religion🙏🙏... Kudos 😎
What is kudos?
@@satyammaurya1915 it's an expression for appreciation❤
Stop worshipping cow and monkey
@@fayaqun0 stop worshiping demons.
@@fayaqun0
We worship whole universe what's problem?
Because we are taught how humanity matters .we live on this earth we worship her as bhudevi and we worship all the things present on this earth 🌍 rivers ,plants trees , animals, mountains ..... And solar system also we worship sun ,moon and all planets .
Because we are Humans and we are thankful to that God gave us this life to live on this earth and she is nourishing us with her love . You just keep on spreading hate 🌚🤥🤥
I am Indian from kerala. I feels proud how my grand parents treated jewesh people in our country. The raja ravi varma.. King did well.
Love to born as a Indian. Welcome jewesh any time to our country.. Love you guys from heart🇮🇳❤️🇮🇱
It is not RAJA Ravi Varma the famous painter. This is history of much earlier period.Hear the video again.
With the likes of PFI in Kerala, I’m not sure the state is so safe for Jews nowadays
@@vp922
Even decedent's of old Malayali jews just 4..5 are in Kerala.They also are just one of two dozen sects of Christianity and other religion Hibdus can not distinguish unless one goes deep with any specific member.Only castes in HINDUS ARE IN NEWS ALWAYS.No one can count really how many types of Christians or Muslims are thete around you SO abrahamic religions even have common calling names!
@@vp922Hinduism have always survived against all odds BRO, they will survive this time also if anything happens
India is may be the only country in the world where those who have been persecuted have come, those who have persecuted them have come, and both are living in peace, because they know that there is only India in the world that can keep everyone in its shadow. Love from India To Israel.🇮🇳❤🇮🇱
Those who are in search of peace should come to India... There are different ways to achieve peace in life in india... Not materialistically but spiritually
China too. Though they got assimilated to extinction
True 🙏🙏
India is hindu country and I want to tell something bitter truth about india that india is only were Jews live free from centuries but it is only country in which it's own culture religion hindu persecution was done in wast scale more than Jews
@@AS-jo8qh agreed!
Relationship between India and China disturbed after 'People's Libration Army' came into the power. Otherwise, India and China have shared a lot of knowledges in the history. Even It was the saint 'Bodhi Dharma' who brought 'Martial Art' to China in order to defend themselves from the local goons.
No, there has never been a problem in India with the Jews. What the narrator was saying is that the Jews were expelled from Spain and Portugal. Some of these Jews ended up in Goa which was a Portuguese colony. That’s why they faced the inquisition there and so they migrated to other parts of India. It was the Portuguese in Goa who were troubling the Jews, not the Indians.
Not just them(jews) Portuguese were also troubling the local Indians there, read about the horrors of goa inquisition. I think there is a video on goa inquisition in youtube channel sangam talks.
@@irondisulfide7480 Agreed. But the point here is that the Portuguese were persecuting the Jews because they were Jews. They were oppressing the Indians, because they were colonizers and also wanted to convert them to Christianity. This lady is Israeli and she’s reacting to a video about Jews in India, I didn’t think it was relevant to state what the Portuguese were doing to Indians. I’m fully aware of what the Portuguese were doing in India. This is the nature of colonizers the world over. The British were the same.
Read History correctly . Idiot . Portugese landed in Goa and did Inquisition not Jews ..Jews were in india Much Before right from Kerala to Junghad
@@wwickedsunnyyAdding some thing there.PORTUGUESE TORTURED EVERY BODY.
FIRST HINDUS mainly uppercastes there( Saraswaths/ Konkanasthas) who escaped by Crossing Mandovi river or by moving in wooden boats to other ports in west coast till KOLLAM SOUTH KERALA.
The Portuguese tortured Muslims .
Portuguese even killed many Christians despite converting to Christianity from Hinduism, because they helped their relatives who were living there as Hindus.
And they attacked Jews..Budhists and Jains.
Goa region has places of worship of all these religions 800 years or more yrs old but recently rebuild.Thousands of icons idols of Hindu deities recovered from waterbodies( thrown by Hindus while escaping or by Portuguese while destroying temples.Rvery family has shrine with their family deity( kula devathas.Grama devatas etc)
So Goa is the only state from where people of every community made exodus.All living around the world speaking still a common language KONKANI
Problem started with the advent of the religious expansionism mindset of the two latest religions... India never had any issues with any religious practices.
I like Jewish people because of their honesty. Long live Indians and Jewish people friendship.
The biggest Synagogue in the world, outside Israel, is called "Ohel David Synagogue" and is in my city, Pune Maharashtra India. My colleague is a Jewish guy Sifron. His dad is official Shofar of this Synagogue. We Marathi people welcome people of all faiths. Love from Pune, India.
has any noticed that the map shown in the starting of the video has shown upper part of India in china region ... This is totally unacceptable... Full J&K is ours , intergal part of India ..🇮🇳
Two villages in Himachal-Dharamkot, known as 'Tel Aviv of hills' and Kasol, famous as 'Mini ISRAEL. INDIA ❤💙 ISREAL
I am an Indian Judaic Christian from Kerala... ♥️🕊️🙏🏻
The Inquisition in Goa was perpetrated by the Portuguese, as Goa was a Portuguese colony at that time. Even the Hindus had faced the brunt of the Inquisition in Goa, forcing them to leave.
Not just Goa but Vasai (near Mumbai) is also Portuguese colony where Mass Inquisitions were performed by Christian Missionaries.
@@proudsanatani2507 I'm from there, and yes you are right.
False statement. Please give proofs
@@Johnny-pi1vk It is part of history and there is ample literary proofs for the Inquisition!!!
"Relação das Perseguições que os Inglêses Fizeram aos Christianos em Japão" (Relation of the Persecutions that the English Made on Christians in Japan), written by Diogo do Couto in the 17th century.
Additionally, the "Notícias de Ormuz, e do Reino de Ormuz" (News from Ormuz and the Kingdom of Ormuz) by António Bocarro offers an account of the Inquisition in Goa during the 17th century. Bocarro was a Portuguese scribe and chronicler who wrote about the events he witnessed or learned about during his time.
Then there is the Inquisition records themselves, known as the "Cartas Anuas," another set of documents that contain information about the trials and interrogations conducted during the Inquisition. These records were annual reports sent to the Portuguese king, detailing the activities of the Inquisition in various regions, including Goa.
These are all recorded by the Portugese writers. Then there is personal experience by the Hindus of the region.
With all these evidences available to everyone, why do you think that it is still a false statement?
@@Johnny-pi1vkread government book Portuguese and maratha relationship if u have time
Goa was colonized by portugese after 1961 it became part of india 🙏
not after it's till 1961
The actual land of Goa was always part of India. Even historically. The Portuguese just captured it and laid claim to it whilst oppressing the people there. Read about the Goa Massacre where they systematically targeted Brahmins and killed them in an effort to cause fear and panic in the Hindu population to convert.
Because, Nehru kick the Portuguese out from Goa, Daman & Due. in 1961 by force. Portugal was trying to send their Navy ships via Suez Canal to fight against India, but India’s Nasser, the president of Egypt close the door of Suez Canal so that they csn not come to India. That is call real friend. 🙏🙏. Thank you Egypt.
🇮🇳🇮🇱❤️ You're so sweet :) Hinduism is also similar to Judaism in the sense that even Hindus never force anyone to convert them into Hinduism. Hindus and Jews have long ancestral ties :)
Is there no concept of conversion in Judaism too?
@@SatyamSingh-fm2bnyes, Judaism isn't missionary. They do accept the converts but they don't try to convert others. There is no concept of conversion in Judaism as far as I know
Come in india with your friends and family , trust me it will be memorial
misscorect - come to india not came in india
Every culture is safe in our country except Hinduism.. 😑
Well said dear
JAI RSS JAI ISRAEL
Jai shree ram bhaiyo 🚩🙏
@@darthvader5558 JAI SHREE RAM BHAI SAHAB 🙏
it's only because of radical chuslims
Similar to Hinduism, Jainism and Buddhism. person have to learn each and every thing about religion and then get examined that is he or she 100% sure or not only then they can.
@4:08 In Goa Jews had problems because in the 1400s Portuguese were the first European colonial settlers in India although the Portuguese weren't successful much in colonialism as they tried to forcefully convert people to Christianity and so, challenged mainly by the Indian Maratha Kingdom. But, the Portuguese with an alliance with Britishers managed to make a stronghold in some small regions especially in Goa. And Jews who arrived in Goa were fleeing from the Portuguese landed in Portuguese controlled area.
And, do you know "Judaism" in Indian languages is called "Yahudi" religion somewhat pronounced like in Hebrew. This also tells that Indians had direct contact with Jews much before European influence.
Yepp
You hurt me today.... You said your people in our Land.... We never consider jews as foreigners.... India is land of many Religions.... That includes Judaism too.... See India as your 2nd home not as we're neighbors or something.....
@Berta Maria Mota so whose land is India yours?
lmao
@@Jambudwipvasi 😂 good reply
@@Jambudwipvasi india belive in 'us' 'our' not 'my' 'your'
@@JambudwipvasiIndia belongs to humanity 😊
There is also a very famous Jewish bakery in New Market in the heart of Kolkata (Calcutta) in eastern India. This is more than a century old. There is also a synagogue there; the street is named as Synagogue Street, in the business district of the city. At present very few Jewish families are staying in the city, including the owner of the baker's shop.
The curious thing is that this bakery shop is owned by a Jew, most the workers are Hindus and Muslims. On the Christmas Eve, there is a long queue in multiple turns round the shop, some standing even overnight to buy the Christmas cakes. Most of the clients are Hindus and many Christmas too.
It is a perfect example of people from 4 different religions Hindus, Muslims, Christians and Jews living together in a symbiotic relationship, with lot of goodwill for each other. Israel and Palestine can learn this art of living together, which is found only in India, the ancient land of wisdom.
Yeah 100% right 👍▶️
Imagine Jews, French, English, Portuguese, turks, Uzbeks etc all have lived in India in different times.
.
India was/is a true multi-cultural country that the world must acknowledge.
Invaded/enslaved/brutalized, not lived. Except for d ones that came as refugees, like d jews
In india we respect all religions and cultures and even adopted Good practices from Every religion. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
The most famous Jew in India was Indian army General J. F. R. Jacob. A hero of India’s 1971 war with Pakistan.
He was later governor of the states of Punjab and Goa.
Indians are proud of him.
I lived at Hendon , I had many wonderful jewish friends , I miss them a lot ! My best regards to Cathy wirgin! Her great family hailed from Germany and settled in US . She worked in Kitbutz cultivating citrus fruits despite her fine art degrees (Paris ). God bless her !
Jai shree ram 🚩 jai shree krishna 🚩 🕉️ Radhey shyam 🚩 love from India 🇮🇳 🇮🇱.... God bless both of us.... Take care
Learn something new today that different tribes have different holidays.
Lots of love and respect to you and Israel from India.
Everytime I see your videos it puts a smile on my face through the entire video.
There was another incident , when Hitler was persecuting Jews....one ship full of Jewish people was looking for help or shelter from other places. When they reached Indian shore .. Indian. people were reluctant at first...then a king of Rajasthan ( don't remember exact details ) gave them shelter and helped them.... They lived in India happily...and returned to their land only after the war was over...and they still remember the generous king who helped them in trying times.
Jamsahib of Jamnagar
@@rakeshmehta4869 Also the Maharaja of Kolhapur, but not on the scale of the Jamnagar Maharaja.
No you are confusing. It’s the Parsis you are talking about
@@holywarrior5719 3 different groups are being mixed together
The first major group were the Bene Israel Jewish group who landed on the Konkan coast in the 1st/2nd Century CE.
The second group were the Zoroastrian Parsis who landed near Bharuch Gujarat between the 8th and 10th Century CE.
The third group were a shipload of Polish exiles (mostly Roman Catholics; there may have been present some Jewish people, too) who had traveled through USSR and had caught a ship from Persia and come down to India during WW2.
While Jews left their land and arrived in India many locals adopted their faith while retaining their local traditions and their names. I too have some Jewish friends who have purely Indian names and some even migrated to Israel.
the girl spoke about the video creator, she spoke about jewish culture. But darn ! Not a single word appreciating only other country where jews were not just free from persecution but also thrived. Gratitude is a rare virtue.
we in India never understand the hatred against Jews. They have suffered immensely during Nazi regime. Credit to these people that they remained positive and contribute a lot to the humanity. It has given lot of scientists. The more I read about them, more I fall in love with them. All of you are welcome in India. We will feel indebted to receive you. May God bless you. Before closing, I must say something about people from Tibet who are living in India for last 75 years. Pl find me one person who has created law and order problem or have demanded something from the government for being a minority or have done any act of treason. Rather they join army and die for India.🙏🇮🇳
2:26 pre-Paul Christianity was still viewed as a "Jewish" cult, and only really aimed at preaching to Jews... hence he went where the Jews were.... in fact, until Portuguese contact several centuries later, many Kerala Christian groups (Nasranis, I think) were Judaizers.
Interesting point
In context to inquisition in Goa, it was due to the Portuguese had colonised Goa, it has nothing to do with India, Jews were never persecuted in India, probably the only place in world.
And we are proud of it.
You are always welcome to our country. We would be glad to be the host with our national greeting Namaste!!! 🙏😊❤
Loved to watch along with you. I knew jewish personalities already, but the history is interesting. Less jewish population shows that hindus & jews lived peacefully & never forced conversions, unlike other religions, who resorted to violence and persecution.
Jews from Poland, mostly children, were on the run during the Nazi rule....they arrived on the coast of Canada but we're turned away. They then reached India where a Maharaja in Gujrat took them under his care, provided them education and shelter for nearly 12 yrs until it was safe for them to return to their country.
Yah.there is a church of Jews in kochi at Kerala. Very old church 🇮🇳🤗🇮🇱We respect all culture's and help them to thrive in India.'vasu deiva kudumbakam'
Not church bro , Synagogue
Jews got special representation in Kerala Legislative Assembly and Cochin Corporation elections. Simon Britto Rodrigues is well known personality in politics from Kerala
Those religions are beautiful that don't want to convert other people.
Sanatan Dharma(Hinduism, Jainism, Sikhism, Buddhism) and Judaism are like those. As an agnostic Hindu I love Jews.
India's simple principle "Live and Let Live"
Goa was under Portuguese rule until the 1900's ! Hence the situation
*I love Israel❤and Japan❤ the most!!!!!!!*
Islam and Christianity was a part of invasion, not an importation. While Orthodox Syrian Christians, Zorastrians and Jews were welcomed by India due to their sufferings from Islam at their homeland before medieval era
Only Yeshu Masiha is God almighty but alla is kutil and false god.
Love from Mongolia 🇲🇳
Wow love from Bharat 🇮🇳
Some Jews in Maharashtra and Gujarat adopted the business of oil pressing mustard or flaxseed and they observe total abstinence from work on Saturday, the day of sabbath, so they were called “Shaniwar teli “ which means the Saturday oilpressors.
When Yusuf Rabban first arrived in Cochin, India in 52 a.d. he was even granted as a prince by the king.
All your videos are good because you put a lot of honest feelings into them. But sometimes when you get upset I feel bad. You're not usually upset about things without reason. Loves from India😃
Former Army Lieutenant General J.F.R Jacob the person who played an important role in getting the Pakistan to sign a Surrender Agreement in 1971 Indo Pak war which resulted in creation of Bangladesh (formerly East Pakistan ) was of Jewish Ancestry. He passed away few years ago. Respect, daring and a true Indian
i heard once the king Solomon `s poems were impact of ancient tamil poems of india
I'm an Indian Born In Guyana, I support Jews Because Of Our Ancient Friendship Between 2 Ancient People 🕉️💖🕎
Judaism and Hinduism is pretty same
Religious
👍👍👍🥰😘😍😍😘🥰🚩🙏🙏🙏
This young israeli starts the video with the statement "my people in your land." No young lady, they are our people with relatives in your land.
@that1israligirl In my city Calcutta the Baghdadi Jews settled and the community invested a lot in the early development in the city during colonial days. Although today their numbers are dwindling(mere 100) yet their contribution can be measured by the number of roads and monuments named after the people from the community
4:16 where you said I didn’t knew that Jews had problems in India the answer is no the problem was in goa which was a Portuguese colony at that time and with the Portuguese as he mentioned when inqaesition (Catholic Church) came to Goa they had migrate to Hindu Ruled area.
I think since both Hinduism and Judaism are really old religions, and are both the original religions of their respective regions, neither perceived any threat to them from any other religion and thus did not establish any strong defence mechanism, or any compulsion to spread the religions. We have great love and respect for Israel.❤
The Marathi jews he mentioned, in Marathi, many surnames are formed by adding '-kar' to the village name which means 'resident of'. That nomenclature is widely used among Marathi hindus. But there are some Jewish surnames too which were formed using this nomenclature. Also, there's Marathi-speaking population in Israel, who are jewish people from Maharashtra.
Indian Jewish people r geat ,and they r mostly honest,we wish them all success in life..
Dear sister we may follow any religion but we are all children of this mother earth and we are all family. Love you dear sister god bless you and Israel and God bless India Israel friendship
Proud to be Indian and we welcome all religion from around the world in India. I wish I can marry Israeli girl because our religion is almost same. We Indians are smart enough to be independent too.
Talking about persecution came to India from Portugal- Goa was Portugese colony so it came there, hence they moved out of there to other parts of india which was ruled by British and no persecution of jews
In Chennai (Madras) not far from Mint Street, there's Coral Merchant Street, which used to be the 'Jewish quarter' in the day.
The inquisition done by Portuguese missionaries not by Indian’s, even Indian’s got persecuted in their own land by the Portuguese missionaries in infamous Goa’s inquisition. Plenty of details available in internet about that.
False. Please see glory apologetics
We are the only country in this world to recognise Jews & have them settled in our country.
We have synagogues & Jews graveyards on our land.
We respect Jews & their culture on our land.
Every Indian loves & respects Jews.
No Jews who landed in Goa were not persecuted but later when Goa was colonised by the Portuguese they banished the Jews . I think that's what I learnt
Lot of love from India 🇮🇳
We love Israel and Jews .. love 💘 from India.. we actually loved all.. Islam ☪️ only backstabbed India and divided the country facilitated by British..
Jews in India were well mixed up in the society. Particularly in the state of MAHARASHTRA. So when some of them left for Israel, we really felt sad. Still there are many Jews in India. We wish they come back to India again. They are an integral part of our society.
I have a marathi jewish friend , we did project together..i never had a thought or have known what it means by being Jewish by now
8:45 all these three actress have been legends of those times. One is also the first miss india ever.
As an Indian, it makes me proud that our nation not only hosted and sheltered the Jews but they thrived and prospered in our country without any persecution.
When the Zoarastrians of ancient Persia landed on the shores of India as a refugees, India hosted them too and they became known as the Parsis (from Farsi). And they too thrived and prospered. Some of the most celebrated Indian scientists were Parsis.
India's problem was never the so called multiculturalism. It is with conquests and conquerors that India had a problem.
Love you Israel ❤️🇮🇳🇮🇱
Please pray for our friendly afgani 🇦🇫 people😭 .🙏 those who suffered by Taliban terrorists created by pakistan
Incredible india....🇮🇳✌️👍🙏💐🤝🌍🌎🌏🗺️👽
I am proud of the fact that india never persecuted jews brothers❤️🇮🇳🇮🇱
Goa was under Portuguese rule at that time. Thats why Jews had to migrate from Goa to Madras
The Hindu rulers in Kerala welcomed people of all religions and gave some of them high positions in their Kingdoms. But as history says some of them turned back and bit the great culture that fed them. They still do.
Love from India 🇮🇳 🙏
I just need a flan recipe, man. I don't know why TH-cam is recommending this video at 2 AM.
Jews have been safe in India because of its Hindu heritage. Hinduism has respect and tolerance of others at its core. This has allowed Jews and Zoroastrians to live and thrive in India.
Lots of love from India ❤
I am indian 🇮🇳 🕉️hinduon but i love ❤ Israel🇮🇱 jews&yhudi community full sport ❤❤❤❤
One of mine friend he is Jew his parents migrate usa to India because his dad was working for a software company than he told me something about antisemitism before never heard anything what is antisemitism nd didn’t even know meaning of this 😂 he used to say mostly Muslim countries this antisemitism prevail nowadays we cannot openly roam there after that he was shocked when he came to know most our classmates don’t know what is antisemitism he surprisingly said really bro than he took me his home than his dad explained that most of Indian don’t know what is antisemitism 😂 many of the Israel people come to india even one place at Himachal you go there many Israel people live there nd people call it mini Israel
Hi, I'm from Cochin princely state, just northern district of Ernakulam called Thrissur (TRICHUR). We are happy to be acknowledged as good hosts for jewes community and never considered them as outsiders unlike other nations were they were said to be persecuted. Lots of Love Israel from India
The story of the Jews seems to be similar to the story of the Parsis of India, except the fact that the Parsis of the world never got any opportunity to form a separate nation.
Major General Indian Jew Gabi Chahulkar has worked in the Isreali army. He explained us all situations about Palestinian issue in our language. He migrated to Isreal in 1990 due to some financial problem but he wants to live in India.Unfortunately,he had to leave his country for his better future.Another example is JFR Jacob who played major role in the formation of Bangladesh during 1971 Indo-Pak war. He was offered to join Isreali army but he refused to accept offer. He told that he is Indian by birth and he will serve only for his nation. Lastly, I want to conclude you that Majority of Indians are nationalist but a group of people always speak anti-nationalist statement for their own political issues.
Sam Manekshaw !! The Most Dangerous Indian Jew 😂😂😂 Pakistan Cries whenever they the Picture of Sam Manekshaw
As a Maharashtrian the Bene Israeli community to me at least doesn't seem like an "other" people but my own since they're also known as Marathi Jews or Marathi speaking Jews. They mostly settled in rural Kokan region & some even have typical Kokani sounding surnames. There's even a documentary video on youtube along with many other videos of Marathi speaking Jews. One thing is that Indians in general has no reason to have problems with Jews since we've no scripture based animosity or history like other Abrahamic religions do. Also it helps that Jews don't seek conversions, so them even believing Hindus are committing some sin by worshipping multiple deities or idols doesn't really becomes a problem.
I love Jewish people's because they are very hard working.
Hindus are peaceful intelligent people who live in harmony with other religions. We consider Jews and Israel as our friends.We are against all forms of violence.Finally we want the world to be peaceful and happy for all the people on the planet.
Hinduism already have many gods, and we dont have problem if another community follow another God , We never force anyone to convert or missionary , Live free let live free , spread happyness
You will always be safe and welcomed in India, among Hindus.
The name Zion or Sion which Hebrews know well is actually the alternate name for Lord Murugan (Ceyon) of the Tamil people, and His most characteristic symbol is the 6 pointed star, which Jews call " the Star of David". It actually is the star of Lord Murugan.
India is land of spirituality because hindu dharm is very vast therefore for a Hindu it is common to accept other religion.
Pune synagogue is closed, it's not open for general public, it should be open to visitors
We need more and more Israilis in India and whole world❤
Thanks for this video. Today some fanatic Christian and muslims are blaming Hindus as fanatic.
Changes required in map of Bharat.
Include PoK as well.
india and israel together !!!! always
We don't force anyone to convert