ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ม.ค. 2023
- J Sai Deepak answered a question on why he supports caste based reservation.
#jsaideepak #jsaideepakspeech #speech #latestspeech #hindu #hindupower #jsaideepakspeech #reservation #caste #castereservation
J Sai Deepak, a native of undivided Andhra Pradesh, did his schooling in Hyderabad followed by a degree in Mechanical Engineering from Anna University and finally an LLB from IIT Kharagpur. Starting his career with Saikrishna & Associates, it is indeed heartening to see that he has now become an arguing counsel in the Honourable Supreme Court of India under his own banner. Over these years, he has specialised in matters concerning Civil Commercial litigation, Intellectual Property litigation, Competition Law, Indirect Taxation, Information Technology Law, Consumer Protection laws and Drug Regulatory Laws.
![ใจเสาะบนเกาะนาคี - อ๊ะอาย สกุณาพร เสียงวิหค [Official MV] | ค่ายเพลงเป็นหนึ่ง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jbcmGQkfyOg/mqdefault.jpg)
I belong to Scheduled caste and i can proudly tell you that i will drop all the reservations, i dont need reservation because im confident to face anyone and anything. Thank you DR BR Ambedkar for uplifting me from this
Yes yess reservation is soooo irrelevant
@@ashwinssn8266 it is relevant my friend but it's not anymore relevant for me
@@vivekvik8423 If it was based on economic reasons iam fine. Caste based reservation is utter b"*shit. Why would a rich sc/st enjoy reservation rights ???.
@@ashwinssn8266yes I do agree on the part of rich SCs/STs enjoying the reservation benefits, but you can't blame a poor SC one for this.. Maybe SCs and STs need a creamy or non-creamy layer like OBCs but I guess then the cutoffs will be even more lower than that as majority of poor SCs and STs are still doing labour work because they don't have any money to support their children's education..
@@gaurango_o1891 That's the whole point, why should rich sc/st enjoy reservation rights???. That's why it should be economical reservation and not caste. Even in economic reservation,the cutoffs should be same for everyone.
I have given up on reservation and cleared all my competitive exams without using SC reservation. I started to write my caste as General in all my documents since 8th standard. Still people are more interested to find out about my caste than my qualifications whenever I get posted somewhere new. It's a sad reality of our society.
Bro your are Really Talented and Humble ...You Derserve Reservation
Proud of you brother
I think it's in us, young generation of sanatani's hands , to not do caste discrimination and ensure that we can marry into any HINDU irrespective of caste . I say this as a girl whose own parents are casteist
@@Momomooo23 Sanatan is just another name for Brahmanical order. Wake up to reality sister.
@@Amanpundir please don't learn Sanatan From Internet and Shorts ..Try to Understand it with original Sources ..
@@RPSINGH-or2ikkindly quote the original sources I'll be more than happy to learn.
If it's a matter of confidence, reservation does an amazing job. It ruined my confidence that hardwork matters anymore.
Now imagine being called an untouchable and thrown out of society
@@Rahulkumar-ftw865 you're talking about past.
If this is the case in present day, RESERVATION SYSTEM failed for sure.
You need substitution for this.
@@vishwparmar4656 but for that reason why do you need reservation on exams?
How is it related...
After reading your comment I am convinced that you are educated...
Now why do you need a reservation for exams?
Why do you want a low cut off??
Or Do you consider yourself inferior intellectually that you need a lower cut off to compete with people who were not eager to give you houses??
@@alpha76523 all these POWERS available to handful people majority are still devoid of basic human rights. You don't know the reality in villages where majority of the sc st obc reside.
@@sgr2864 are you educated? Do you even know how cutoff is decided. Cutoff varies from school to school and state to state. The upper privileged caste have access to better educational infrastructure and educated family background.
I am a Khatriya from Odisha. I am a village dweller and the SC people are not allowed to enter the village temple or inside our houses. But, when a SC friend from a nearby city or town visits my house nobody complains.
Similarly when a SC visits a temple in the nearby town then nobody complains.
So, with passage of time the gap is getting closed. But, it will still take some decades to get completely closed.
right?? I think it's in our, the younger hindu's hands to not do caste discrimknation or let it expand. We have to remember we are hindus and read the actual Gita. Im a girl and my parents haven't read Gita and are casteist. They don't even know Gita says about Varna which is not brith based .And we are general. The fkn irony
Refer Shankaracharya on cast ... Not neo sampradaya
Strange. I grew up is Bihar. Nobody stopped me from entering temples. In fact, in my village if pandit ji is absent due to some reason, a lower caste pandit ji does rituals in the temple.But i think it will fade in 2-3 generations.
Wow so this still exists
I agree with you ଭାଇ
As a sikh belonging to general category I'm in total support of sc st reservation but OBC needs to removed completely.. I've seen that Dalits tribals face discrimination but not obc at any point. Hence keep 20% for st sc and 80% open for everyone
Bro you know many SC ST caste are added after 1950 due to politics.
Only ST deserves reservation
Obc category is joke
@@gksquad2024 no, here in our haryana, if someone from chamar community touched upper caste, they were beaten up. I am from so called upoer caste. But i don't think there is any difference between any caste
@@gksquad2024Poona pact suna hai...chutiye sc baad me add hue hai...Add hue hai to EWs... totally unconstitutional
Kya ghante ka discrimination ? A gareeb or middle class general student can not get admission or clear NEET even after scoring above 90% but a sc st in same or better situation can pass at 60%. This is a failed and incompetent society which does not rewards merit. This is why this country will never grow. IIT me reservation se aane waale me se 95% se upar bacche first year me hi fail hojate hain aur unko nikaal diya jaata hai. This is why general class students prefer to study abroad. These sc st people file fake cases on general class and shame our women.
Huge fan of his speech. I’m absolutely against caste system and untouchability and all those bull shit. I’m Brahmin and as he said, even I came from lower middle class family. My only issue with reservation is, once the family of is in certain position where they don’t have to struggle to earn money and once that family starts earning certain amount of money consistently because of reservations, that family should be removed from reservation system and it should be given to the family who needs it more. My opinion.
Faq you and your opinion.
Absolutely correct @supervish92
Absolutely correct, but I guess the govt is too slow to even react upon this
But even if the family is now prosperous, it still faces caste based discrimination in many ways in majority of places except metro cities (where more people have an open mind with higher education). This again leads to development of an inferiority complex.
Not entirely true. You're equating economical stability to social status. Lower caste who may achieve economical stability still face discrimination on a daily basis.
Nobody is actually against caste-based reservations for deserving candidates. Non-deserving are the ones who already have 2-3 generations taking advantage of the reservation and still want to continue with it.
Yeah absolutely the ppl who are receiving reservation benefits are APL people mostly.....
2-3 generations as opposed to 500 years of time too accumulate wealth seems not so bad actually
@@truptipatil6892 even crorepathis bhi kama sakte hai kya..... ? Reservation se? Tab gareeb ko kya faida? Matalab only reservation waale hi sirf gareeb hai aur doosre OBC muslim OC waale mein gareeb nhi rehte aapke hisaab se hai na? Wah bhai wah masth equality hai....
@@truptipatil6892 What? You think open category is wealthy? Or accumulated wealth for 500 years?
Reality is, in india most people are poor or middle class regardless of caste.
@truptipatil6892 500 years of societal oppression which can be made better by society. If 'wealth accumulation' did happen by upper castes for fkn 500 yrs then the top 10 elon Musk and Ambani of the world would be Upper castes🤣😅 Is that the case?
Solution to discrimination is not discrimination
It's so unjust when you see through the eyes of a General Student. It really hurts when a student who scored 40 marks goes to IITs and general student who scored 80 marks can't go there. Not every general category person is wealthy and confident.
thats why u got ews
@@prachiburman2475WS won't get reservation if they have 1300 sqft of land in urban areas. But if SC,ST and OBC have 24000 sqft of land they will enjoy reservations for generations to come 😢. This is institionalised inequality 😂😂
@@roshanbalaji2177 Correct!
@@akIndia10 Correct!
@@prachiburman2475 do u know anything about Cutoff of EWS and SC/ST. Recently SC/ST student has to score 43 to get IIT while EWS/OBC has to score 78 to atleast qualify JEE- Advanced.
Speak if you know something, don't flap un necessarily.
I belong to OBC, I was in love with Brahmin Girl. We tried convince her father for 1 & half year but we failed. Even though I have decent job & my own home in good locality, I failed. When I met her father for the first time he told me in clear words that its because I belong to lower caste. That day It hurt like hell. I could not eat or sleep for days. eventually she broke up with me & married person from her own caste.
I never thought someone actually think this way until I experienced it myself. Look in his eyes, thinking how dare I even thought I could marry his daughter.how he was looking down on me, I cant forget. Even though I am an adult It has scarred me for life. I cant imagine what it would do to a child.
Edit: So many people are butthurt.
1) I am not against any caste or their people but I am against rigid hierarchy that has been set in our society.
2) I am asked to change my religion - *No*
3) People are asking me to what if my sister or daughter wants to marry a person from SC/ST or other caste. The answer is if a person is well educated, financially stable and most important if they really like each other & have chance at better future they have my blessings. That's normal thing to do.
But OBC and SC/ST intercaste marriage is also negligible
Bro Brahmins alone can't be blamed the fact is no one wants to marry outside of the caste I had this OBC friend of mine whose family was thinking about his marriage and they found a girl who was also an OBC just one problem,my friends family rejected her because even though she was also from OBC her caste's people used to live on outskirts of the village and were considered a level lower.
I'm also a Brahmin,and the only solution here is that the government needs to get control over education system,we need to to abolish private schools and colleges,we only need public schools and government has to make sure that fees are low ,and the most important get the childrens of SC and STs in school ,Improve the education of country ,this poisonous idea of caste which has destroyed India and Hindusim,this snake of Caste needs to killed at the earliest stages of child's life,3rd Desegregate our schools make sure that childrens of General Category , children of OBCs and children of SCs are studying together, children are innocent when they growup together they form strong bonds,I'm myself used to study in a school that was the funded by a Government own company so you can it was just like a government school where fees were really low,in my class including me only 4-5 students were Brahmins from 50 students all of my other friends were from other general category like Maratha ,but many of my friends were from OBC category my bestfriend was also an OBC but none of us had a problem with eachother because of our caste,our teachers were also from from different castes from Brahmins to SCs but never in my entire school life I have seen my teachers discriminate with students,my Favourite teacher was a SC but I never faced any discrimination from him because I was a Brahmin,problem is that our education system is segregated most People of General Category and People from Rich OBCs families send their children to private schools and colleges where fees are expensive af it is impossible for a Child of an SC and our lower income OBCs to enter these institutions and those who managed to enter enter because of reservations,and let me tell you these private schools and colleges are Evil as fuck ,these guys keep students of low income families (mostly till 8th) because law requires them to give some seats to students from low-income families,but trust me when I say these fucker private schools don't give that seats to the children that deserve,and even if they do they humiliate them when they don't pay fees to the extent that the child will just want to die instead of attending these schools,and their classmates also starts to bully them well what the fuck do expect from students when teacher themselves humiliate these children infront of class ,and the children who somehow manage to survive till 8th gets kicked out in an instance by these private schools if fees are not paid,when I started my 11th and 12th was and entered a private college i saw a lot of difference first being that a lot of my my teachers were now of General Category,a lot of students were from general category and the students from other categories that were present were from richer backgrounds,and I also studied from State board and my other friends at college who were also from general category and among them only I was the one who studied in a public school,all my other friends were mostly from CBSE or even ICSE one of my friend was from an international School while discussing I was proudly telling him how our school took us for one day India vs Australia test match,but my friend from international school told me that for their school the went to Daman and Diu and there school made them stay in a 5 star hotel ,who could a education institute that on paper is not running for profit managed to their students for such expensive trips, ofcourse then these private colleges don't want children of low caste or low income students in their high institutions,just think being a kid of low-income who get in these schools,how must would he feel when all of your classmates are going to trip but you can't go,the sad facts is that our education system is being hijacked by the private institutions which secretly owned by politicians ,and is one of the leading causes for Castes discrimination in the country,we need to learn from other countries like US(note: I'm not a fan of US ) it also had huge problem of discrimination between the whites and Blacks but they also Desegregated their schools which lead to a Massive fall in the racism.
Watch these Excellent video that shows,how private schools are destroying our nation :
th-cam.com/video/az_zvD06DFU/w-d-xo.html
brother, only thing we can do is educate upcoming generations. I am from a brahmin family, and my father often says we do this, or we don't do this BECAUSE WE ARE BRAHMINS and it irks me like nothing . me and my sister talks about this issue , i keep reminding her, choose someone who likes you for you regardless of caste or race . no Muslims though not because i hate them but because in india marriage is between families not individuals , even if that Muslim boy loves a other religion girl ..his family WILL harass or mentality torture that girl to convert.
Will an OBC marry sc?
Grandparents- Govt Jobs ( reserved category)
Parents- SHO ( reserved category)
Third gen Kids driving in cars going IIT. Life is so awesome 😎
Smooth smooth life 👌 😎 😌
dekho dekho baap ki dukaan pe baitha koi baniya jal raha hai..
@@TheCainaktum to bohot Sharif ho jativad nhi kr rhe aabhi hai na?
You are seeing just 1%
@@saibhaskaryenumula9624 we dont have actual amount of data then how can u conclude that it is 1 percent
if u think ur assumption is right then i also can conclude my statement
Exactly. It's all about confidence. Reservation destroyed my confidence that merit and ability will be evaluated rather than the birth. Thank you so much.
on point.
Before it is 100% reservation for 30% people.. Then where was equality
Cast based discrimination by birth..
Sab doglapan hai.. Merit ki yaad aa gyi ab..
@@aravindr740 yes I am what u can do? Go to court
I am from S.T. caste. And i say that rarely someone from our caste actually takes benefit of government policies. Most people are still stuck in villages doing farming and other odd jobs rather than actually educating and making great career. Im thankful for all the government benefits because of which i was able to uplift myself.
rarely? Do you know how many people givee JEE or NEET? If you have ever been in any colleges you know how many take advantage of that. People taking advantage of caste is the norm not the exception. And people not moving out of villages and doing advanced labour or blue collar jobs and white collar jobs is on you alone, all villages are not to mention the same in this regard as they are also stuck in the past and do not BY CHOICE move out of the village.
@@rickycool6083 that's for SC caste. I'm talking about tribal people.
Look now the Reservation fight Is not between General vs OBC/SC/St
But now it's Elite Sc/St vs Actually poor Sc/St
But then Iam in mud despite all hardwork and results.
@@mr.gubagub1899Haan toh sare village may he pade na abhi tak. Tribal walon pe koi bhi ek sabd nhi bolega but Delhi,up...etc ghar, vehicle,gold chain still begging for reservation
I did my medicine by paying 7 lakhs per year. My family has always struggles financially and was never able to pay my fees. Meanwhile my ST caste batchmate had to pay only 1000 rs yearly as fees. He lives in a huge bungalow and his dad is a high level police officer. I know this cannot be generalized, but we need to come up with better systems where only those reserved category students are benefitted who actually need it (and are worth it)
@@jaymin2143 not all STs are poor, not all general had rich ancestors...that's why our country needs to come up with a better system and scrape off this shitty reservation system
Then force them to end caste discrimination. All the upper castes introduce their identity in a very proud tone. They do even if they are poor, that no matter if I'm rich or not but if I'm from this caste i should be proud of. Why don't you doubt during that instant?
@@pratyush7148 everybody should be proud of their identity. people of many caste which comes under obc are proud of their cultural identity so you cant force them to not celebrate identity istead we should encourage sc st people to celebrate their cultural identity
@@dhairyamittal1313No ....I am from kumhar caste....I don't know shit about pottery even though I am from rural area...We should end this caste proud bull shit ....And Stop keeping surname on basis of caste system.......And When people from lower caste is economicly good they should leave reservation......
@@pratyush7148ofcourse you are getting a gov job or college by less marks with less efforts so it is enjoyable by giving a same excuse of discrimination
The discrimination will end only once the pride of being from of certain caste will ends and pride will come along with the karmas we do
Very true
Very much true. We all shall take pride in our nation and especially in the Humanity. 🇮🇳
😂 constitution itself says caste is by birth
@@gksquad2024 lack of knowledge and huge narrow-mindedness.
But the weird thing is that persons who take reservation show their caste pride.
Now what can be the solution?
J Sai Deepak proud of you. If every Brahmin becomes like you then No bogey will dare to say that Hinduism is casteism
why? why not the others enjoying reservation, give up and become like him.. now that's a good thought to remove casteism..
Every brahmin support reservation
If they not they will not pay income tax
Satya toh yeh ki tum hamse jalte ho
Saurabh diwvedi is also a support of reservation
By the way why rich Dalits never oppose reservation because they want freebies from brahmin tax money
Even he acknowledges that his opinion is an exception among other people from his community. I'm from a Brahmin family and 90 percent of my relatives and family members are strongly against reservation.
@@aradhymishra8419 people pay taxes because they have to. And you say that you're not against reservation but your assertion that others are jealous means that you do have some resentment against the system.
@@aradhymishra8419they didn't demanded for freebies first . You started discrimination and hence they should get it . I feel it as a compensation for the discrimination you give them. Ethically Brahmins or anyone belonging to General caste haven't change d they feel above others . That's reality.
I belong to SC community but Me, My Father and My Grandfather don't have any caste certificate means we are not using any Reservation.
Same if you don't have cast certificate you will not get any benefit
I support reservation to who to really need ,my friend got government medical seat through reservation,his father was also got job through reservation,...you think this guy really need reservation
@@siddanagowda4066 is discrimination is based on economical or social 😅. Even ias getting discrimination. how many Sc ST chief minister cabinet minister u heard off. Azadi ka amartutsav bnane ja rhe ho ek SC ya St ka PM nhi de paye😂😂😂 shadi se phle tumhare ghar wale caste dekhte h waha se suruaat kro tb desh badal jaye.
Even u dont have a certificate u still belong to some cast. I want to know if any time u getting discrimination because of your cast even when u dont have certificate?????
@@sunilrathore7400 Every time because it doesn't matter to them, they don't want to see you ahead. We are not using reservation just to take this challenge.
I am from Kumhar caste which makes me eligible for OBC caste but my father was always of opinion that if you will stick to reservation mentality it will somehow hamper your mental flexibility. So he has always kept himself and my family general in all certificates and even with this small change I experience that noone is able to guess my caste. Because being too aware of caste and reservation also kind of restrains you.
So I am not disagreeing with him given the fact that he is mostly correct in all other things but still I will differ as politely as I can.
Just like Armed Forces I want there should be some central and state services where there is no caste based system and you will see the difference.
W father
Your father is very heavy chumtiya
Correctly said. We can see major difference between SSB selected candidate and other reservation based candidate.
@@savage00713 yes man. If the same style goes for Central and State Police force even there you will see a major difference.
so do u face any discrimination ?
For S.Cs and S.Ts , it is O.K. Regarding reservations to the B.Cs and Muslims , the Government has to rethink and reanalyze the entire matter . All parties must have a common agenda on this , keeping in view the future interests of the nation .
We are proud of our castes but you are not so it is not our problem you maleech. We get power from our ancestors who died for this country. Kya ghante ka discrimination ? A gareeb or middle class general student can not get admission or clear NEET even after scoring above 90% but a sc st in same or better situation can pass at 60%. This is a failed and incompetent society which does not rewards merit. This is why this country will never grow. IIT me reservation se aane waale me se 95% se upar bacche first year me hi fail hojate hain aur unko nikaal diya jaata hai. This is why general class students prefer to study abroad. These sc st people file fake cases on general class and shame our women.
Why not muslims ? Read sachhar committee report on muslims which is not implemented yet fully . It clearly says muslims in india are more backward than STs.
Where does muslims get reservation..?? Muslims doesn't come in OBCs..only muslim Butchers, Muslim sewage cleaners get reservation only in Karnataka and UP.... Correct your knowledge..
@@hussamuddin2361 Bro in Tamil Nadu Muslims get 3% reservation.
@@varunsubramaniamby your logic hindus get reservation in every state under obc
He spoke honestly on this issue.
Kya ghante ka discrimination ? A gareeb or middle class general student can not get admission or clear NEET even after scoring above 90% but a sc st in same or better situation can pass at 60%. This is a failed and incompetent society which does not rewards merit. This is why this country will never grow. IIT me reservation se aane waale me se 95% se upar bacche first year me hi fail hojate hain aur unko nikaal diya jaata hai. This is why general class students prefer to study abroad. These sc st people file fake cases on general class and shame our women.
@@blackwolf6719 same 😭😭
How many ST Sc candidates apply for NEET compare to UR.
@@blackwolf6719 No, Cutt-ff should be same
@@sagar_youbee cutt off should be same
What a brilliant answer to the question sir !! First time ever I have see someone addressing this issue with lot of maturity and sensibly with justice
After all that education, one is not mentally prepared to face competition 😂, what an education, failed.
@prabhakar0076 ready to face the competion , not ready to face unfair judgement
@@Momomooo23that's your religious issue and keep your religion personal.
I have given up my reservation. Everyone in my family have.
Similar thing was done by my friend also
Great man someone needy will get
@Bread Pit bahiya can I get your number please
@@skmr5160 tab toh epigenetics zaroor karne hoge
@@editkiya He isn't a topper or anything. He is a liar tho. See this guy's other comment on this video.
As a non Brahmin i got to say that people vilify Brahmins for few wrong things but no appreciation for their contributions such as education, culture and scientific advancements.
This generation who glorify corrupt politicians, movie stars can't see the good side i guess
Without the contribution of Brahmins there is no Bharat worth the name
@@myperspective4287 No Brahmin EVER opposed the education of Shudras. Metallurgy, musical instruments, temple building, architecture, medicine were all the domains in which the Brahmin ´domination’ was absent . It was the Brits who did not allow the women and Shudras to enter the convents and universities, as per Anglican Christian customs
Had those So called Low caste been given the opportunities,they would have contributed massively, not only UC denied it but also pushed the country backwards by manipulating and playing dirty politics for their own gains...see what happened to Eklavya...Brahmin Dronacharya asked for his thumb else, Arjun so called Kshatriya would have been outshined by him...
@@myperspective4287you yourself said that apart from Vedas domain , Brahmin we’re not active. So answer why they failed at Construction, Astronomy, Medicine, ship building and failed to be a specialist in any part of life even before britishers ?The fact which You can’t digest may because of your mentality is that We are the result of our Karma only.
Ambedkar broke 3% brahmins who wanted to rule with their shitty book manusmriti. The audacity and the sinister plans of the brahmanical society was exposed by ambedkar. He did many good for women empowerment, society. But the brahmins will always find fault and hate him.
Our society need this type of mentality form Brahmin for unite our hindu dhrama
There is a difference between integration and it's acknowledgement!! You can choose to disapprove of integration even if it has happened in reality!! That is also a fact!
The last point is logical.
Caste based reservation is a guarantee for survival of sanatan dharma but cannot be an extension of injustice of past centuries.
Many sane voices from obc and sc st communities are already being heard to do justice for those communities who are affected by reservation policy.
Let us hope for the best.
He also said about the intercaste marriage mentality. I don't think it will be possible even if India become akhand Bharat. Or the whole nation is introduced to sanatan dharma. Because the one who do casteism are the UPPER CASTE HINDUS. Also, just belonging to a particular community or a caste already gives u a certain social privilege ( a kind of social reservation). If you want the reservation to end, U shuld ask the Upper caste Hindus to give up their Privileged Social by BIRTH STATUS!!!
@@sushrutjadhao8495 I believe you aren't quite right about this, I've seen casteism among all of us, not just so called upper caste but all of us.
Ok. Just make it available only once in a lifetime; Either in admission or job or promotion, not at every step. But as of now even kids of IAS officers enjoy reservation throughout their life!
Do you have sense or not.??
Which IAS officer's son got reservation..?
Do you have any materials to support your preposterous claim..?
Have you every read about eligibility criteria to avail reservation...??
Officers those who belongs to all india services, Gread A or B services and their children can not avail benifits of reservation once after they got into the service..
Half baked brain belongs to so called upper caste which is only can claim hollow proud without having even basic sense and Skill😂w
Give me one example where you have seen kids of IAS officers enjoying this.
@@jkluha2891in my neighborhood a person from Meena caste got selection through reservation in ibps po
Even though his father is a government officer and he passout from districts most reputed school.
It sounds good to you
Give reservation who need it not the family or person who is already in government service and enjoying facilities from government
@@riteshsaini907 u got everything whatever u wanted…for centuries…had luxurious lives at no tax at all…and now u can’t even bear the reservations for 70 years also…pathetic..if selfish…greedy… jealous have a face…it will definitely looks like you people
And you will have upper caste tag for a lifetime ?
So true, caste is totally active in village level. Still lower caste are not equal in community. Till that happens we need to keep the reservations. However reservations make no sense at degree level or promotions level. Reservations is much needed at kindergarden and school and pre university.
We (cbse students) also have inferiority complex against ICSE students……..give us reservation too 😢😢😅
You are comparatively less.
But, the economic and social condition of SC, ST is less than average.
@@RAJEEVKUMAR-bt9ks Bhai baat SC/ST ki nhi hai yeh 27 percent OBC aur EWS kyun hai
@@adarshdwivedi1950 OBC & EWS average me count hoga,
Inferior category me to SC & ST ka hi counting hoga.
Students from state board disagree with you!
Not me.
Am glad that #saideepak acknowledged this fact about oppressed communities and importance of reservation for them
caste based reservation never helps in removing caste discrimiation. It actually promotes it more
@@yashjindal6234how?
@@ashishramteke5532 if people who work hard get pushed back by people who get reservation with just bare minimal work the result is communal hatred. its like in school if you are getting bullied and the teacher knows it and if the teacher gives full marks to you for getting bullied. it not only doesn't stop bullying but also increases it also the rest of the class get pushed down rankwise.
@@nikilmanu334 with all due respect, this video was just for people who think like you.
Please grow up from the kids mentality.!
@@ashishramteke5532 i am sorry. I hate discrimination too. But the reservation is just making things bad. I dont even know much of castes.
Bro.
I think its better to fight for eradication of caste system
Neither caste nor reservation will exist
what's CASTE ?
@@ARYAAGNIVRAT i think its actors that work in a movie/tvseries.
@@nikilmanu334😂
@@nikilmanu334 it proves that reservations didn't helped you at all.
That's a great way of explaining reservation based on caste system.
Really admired from Sai Deepak speech .. he is talking about practical solutions which will work in a larger contexts and nearly a permanent solution but might take years and should accept it.
I feel individual Economical growth only be a suitable weapon to remove caste system.
How many years should the caste based reservation should go on ?
With the caste based reservation we are only recycling the trauma and exploitation.
Ultimately , both in past and present, Merit is being made the scapegoat.
reservation definitely needs reforms. but till we accept the fact that casteism is not just a fantasy, it's a reality... reservation must go on. merit is being made a scapegoat... definitely i agree with you on this...but are you ready to make human dignity a scapegoat instead of merit???is this a justification to this???
First leave your surnames
First remove caste from your mind do intercaste marriage with sc /st than it will help to eradicate this caste system and also reservation..
@@jaiveeratri9318
Reservation will be rationalized. Be prepared for it. Reservation is not eternal birth right for future generations , it's at the cost of someone else. It will sooner get consolidated at right time.
Respect is earned not reserved be it's so called brahmins or any other caste.
People will say enough to un rationalized reservations.
@@samsanglikar6704Bro uske alawa bhi to aur solutions hai. Ayesa thodi hai zabardasti Sc st se hi shaadi karna hai. Like kuch marriage protection hote hein Jo married couples ko protect karte hein. So people should marry with mutual consent and caste should not be considered.
I ain’t from a Dalit community but I have seen what they go through which made me a liberal despite being a liberal for so many years I absolutely enjoy the way you speak sir. It is all about either taking stand with what is right or swaying with popular opinion. The latter is easy everyone is easily succumbed to it, but to acknowledge the latter, one needs to have moral conscience. The less number of likes reflected here shows you stood with right. God bless you Deepak Sir.
Now you have reached around true Hindu ideology. Congratulations 🎉
I have seen pandit ... jo begger h
@@sib9716 looks like we need more such concrete evidence every where every state in large numbers doing that thing.
@@gauthamsaip6549 bro have you seen the condition of Dalits and studied it??
@@gshockzen8669 to experience what they go through there are three ways, if any of your best friend is from Dalit community, second- You tell the world you are from Dalit community even though you are not, to see how life fares for them, third- being Dalit.
This was an amazing outlook on this issue! 🙌🏼🙌🏼
It’s amazing & a practical answer with a good example.
I accept your opinion regarding reservations in India Based on cast system 🙏
ఈ సమాజం లో ఉన్నవి రెండే జాతులు. ఒక్కటి ధనవంతులు మరొకటి పేదవరు
🤡
@@SahilKumar-zs2mycope
True
Belonging to SC community I strong agree with him.
I've always wondered there is this debate that financial reservation should replace caste reservation it is not an equal compensation.
A person whose family is always looked down upon and treated as inferior to others cannot have the same mental ability to compete with others even with financial support.
Nowadays a well settled SC/ST/OBC parents children are becoming more competition to non settled parents children in same category (caste).
Settled parents are providing best education to their children which could not be provided by non settled parents.
I think govt should support reservation system and bring some changes to it which will benefit more to the poor chidlren.
Stop caste based reservations. Erase caste system, erase caste certificate, remove the column on any application / form asking for caste. It can only create conflict among human beings.
What rookie argument is this...these things don't create caste system , caste system exists and these are just iconography
If caste system is to be removed the first to take weapons are those Brahmins and general caste categories.
How to?
Casteism is so addictive
First make so called upper caste to do so then target reservation
Remove using title & praising possessiveness of belonging upper caste & feeling proud by suppressing people who don't acquire to a level that people feel proud of.
I'm from ST community and I would like to express my sincere gratitude towards Sai Deepak ji for talking on this issue and supporting reservations.
I am Brahmin and same as JSD i was also from state board and i did always feel inferior to people from CBSE and ICSE board but still i always tooped later when i got into college when i had to compete with those students. It's always about the hardwork and talent that gives you results. Being from upper caste community or being from more prestigious board doesn't ensure anything. It's so wrong to say just because you are from a particular community that's called upper class that means you have to get atleast 10% more marks than people from different community to pass the same examination just like it would have been unfair if they had let me pass with lesser marks than the cbse board students just because i was from state board.
I completely agree that caste based discrimination still exists in our society even though not in a huge margin but in remote villages of our country. I have seen it from my own eyes and we do need to fix that but providing reservation to the entire community isn't the way out.. because trust me people who are still exploited are not getting any help out of it. The only ones benefitting from it are the people from the category who doesn't even need it anymore and that's where it goes wrong. It won't be pleasant for me to see my classmates or friends from SC ST category who have all the resources they need because they are from a financially well background and that's because their parents and grandparents both were in govt services, pass the examinations without even working as much hard as i am.
The point is you won't find many cases of people from the SC ST community getting discriminated on the basis of caste who actually are financially strong. It's always the poor ones from that community who is facing this. That's the main reason why reservation should be based on economic conditions and not on community.
The irony is caste based reservation was brought to even out the difference and promote equality and brotherhood among people from all the category but today it's only doing the opposite. Caste based reservation is inducing hatred and anger among the general category people for the SC ST category which will only broader the gap between them.
And it's not little margin... India have 70,% population living in rural area. How many bramhins got married to dalits??? Very very very few. Yes inter cast marriage is there... But among upper-upper cast. Not with sc-St cast.
Most of points I totally agree.
Of course reservation making little bit trouble, for division of society. But I believe there's still division in our hearts. But atleast reservation makes them to reach some position, help them to take part of our elite society, access main stream society.
@@shibajidalai2014 okay tell me this if a person who has gotten the benefits of reservation and now has reached that position you were talking about do you think they can now marry a person from the so called upper caste community. I don't think so. At the same time a person from SC ST category will also not allow their children to marry someone from the Brahmins community and the same goes for OBC's too. That's what casteism is. It is not about rich and poor it's about the community difference and this thing called caste based reservation is only widening those differences. If you want to remove the caste difference you ll have to remove the caste identification of the society and not remind everyone that they belong to certain community which is what caste based reservation does. We weren't even aware what caste does our friends belong to untill we got to know our cut off marks for the same examinations are different.
If you ask me I don't believe in marriage within caste. I think people should marry whom they want to marry irrespective of caste. Bringing the issue of inter caste marriage is distracting from the entire discussion that reservation should be based on financial conditions and not on caste and community.
@@awwnamikatrivedi barrier created by upper cast.. Not by lower cast.. It's responsibility of acceptance should begin with upper cast.
I have friends being from lower cast got married to upper cast... In all 3-4 cases restriction and denial mode done by bramhin family. All cases bramhin family member told, they would have agree to khyatria.. But to a Sc St... It's a matter of reputation.
Ask any bramhin girl... Or boy if their family got to know they are in relationship with SC/ST boy/girl what would be their reaction vs choosing a bramhin boy.
Yes, if you are a IAS/PCS. That's a different case... But still oppose will happen.
I don't know.. Perhaps you are in not that age to discover these things.. Wait.. Soon it you will see these things. Castesim Society difference has been reduced .. I agree.. But only untouchability, respect each other in these cases have been reduced.
But in marriage still unacceptable.
I am giving u a link please watch that...
@@awwnamikatrivedi
th-cam.com/video/oOSuGZeLxFM/w-d-xo.html
@@shibajidalai2014 it seems like you are not even reading my comments and replying back. I agreed in the above comment only that yes a Brahmin family will not accept their kids marrying outside their caste but same goes for others as well you are completely ignoring that part. My bestfriend belongs from ST category her eldest sister got married to a Rajput man 8 years ago they now even have a kid together but her family still haven't talked to her even once. That's what i am telling these are caste based separation which is very much prevalent in our society no one can deny this. But here you are completely deviating the topic away from the actual problem that financially well to do families whose earlier generation had already taken the advantages of reservation system should not be given any more benifits. Rather it should only be given to those who are actually deprived of resources and are vulnerable to exploitation.
I am genuinely excited about the prospect of witnessing an India that slowly reduces its reliance on reservations. However, it can only be possible when the individuals who have benefited from these opportunities can leverage their education and influence to uplift the community, and actively engaging in positive change rather than treating reservations as a passive privilege.
Reservations are given for caste based discrimination
So there should be caste based discrimination
Absolutely! They should take their reservations and then shut the f*ck up and stop lusting after upper caste women.
In Bollywood movie "Swades" there's a particular dialogue when Mohan Bhargav (SRK's charcter) interacts with local villagers. One of the elderly villagers goes like: Jaati pradha (caste discrimination tradition) woh hai jo jaati nahi (is that which doesn't disappear) . So true! This social evil will continue forever and ever! And frustrated Indians will migrate and settle down abroad.
Ye baat Munshi premchand ji ne kahi thi ki
Jati hai ki jati nahi😢
It's insightful especially to youth who matter lot in many respects. Till level paying fd is reasonably attained,the caste system should continue. Sai Deepak forthright in opionating the politicians never ever do away with any of reservations .Appreciated.
Such a precise and honest answer !!🙏
We all know the reality but never accept it because in the end who don't want inborn superiority...even its matter of just surname
Very well said. Hindus can be united only by acknowledging and removing the scourge of casteism.The other point Mr. Sai Deepak stressed on was the psychological inferiority.But I would add that caste system creates social capital that unduly favours some over the other. I,as a Brahmin,enjoy a lot of benefits in terms of a highly educated family,social and professional networks,which a lower caste individual would never enjoy.That is why reservation is still required.
I need No caste India. Are hindus are up for it?
❤ your answer.
Glad to see someone understands the role of social capital. And you are definitely a progressive thinker to acknowledge this social malady called casteism. 🙏
U said right... But what is the fault of today generation of upper cast they have to suffer a lot for job specially general category last year I lost my seat of medical clg because I belong from general category and their cut off so high in comparison of lower category but what is our fault yaar 😞 why they got a seat in so lower marks and we can't
Answer is in your question itself. Bcoz they are not getting high marks. We as a country can put an end to this system once they also start getting high marks
Do your medical higher education from pvt college and choose dentist or dermatalogist specialist as your trade and make your own clinic and earn. You haven't seen world outside my boy.
@@Mozillafire-gi9do ❤️
@@healermusic4734 They do not get high marks cause they don't work as hard as such they don't deserve the position as well. High marks are not given you need to earn it.
@@Mozillafire-gi9do Or rather a Dalit only insitute and make them compete against each other and see how they fare natonally? Making excuses for obvious wrong never works.
Highly reasonable and genuine explanation.
From all sanatani leaders i like sai most. He talks no bs just only facts
From what I could see as a child before my 10th, we couldn't care less about what caste we are from. It only started to matter when these reservation came into picture. Caste is just merely a tool these days
I totally agree with his stance on this. It's good to know that learned people like him exist as opposed to the people who are uninformed and like to jump to conclusions by invalidating the experiences of the oppressed.
As long as there's a 'caste' in india, all the privileged and talented leave the India no matter what.
Ultimately everyone wants to please public . Even Sai Deepak , and Narendra Modi are no exception. Not surprised .
But you now somewhere this also applies on the general category. Imagine the situation of a student who is working hard for his dream . He knows that his or her family Cannot afford his fees for a long time. Still trying hard but when you realise that people from different categories will get the same position even in much lower marks then you . Just imagine the pressure 😢. We are also humans.
Work harder,,,don't blame reservation blame your ancestors
Don't teach that to us bhimta@@kirank9086
@@kirank9086even if he work hard those so called reserved students get seat with lower marks....
@@Terminator12342work even harder then. leave no stone unturned. life is not supposed to be easy. I am saying this as another general category non EWS male guy, dont think of what they are getting. think of what you are lacking, and keep improving everyday
if BR Ambedkar can face the ENTIRE society (at the time) to get himself educated and progress in life, you can surely fight against a few lakh people.
Consider a scenario where a poor general category student, despite being exceptionally intelligent and capable, faces significant financial constraints. This student may have had to overcome numerous obstacles to access quality education, including limited resources, inadequate study materials, and a lack of access to expensive coaching classes. Despite these challenges, they managed to excel academically through sheer determination and hard work.
On the other hand, there might be a rich reserved category student who, due to their family's financial affluence, had access to the best educational resources, private tutors, and extracurricular activities. While this student may not have the same level of innate talent or determination as the poor general category student, their privileged background provided them with a significant advantage in terms of educational opportunities.
In such a scenario, when both students compete for a limited number of educational seats or job opportunities, the rich reserved category student, who might have had a more comfortable educational journey, could secure the position solely based on their category reservation. In this scenario who do you think will have an inferiority complex ?? Who do you this has an unfair advantage ??
Brilliantly answered by Sai Deepak.This was the only instance when I couldn't disagree with this gentleman.
This man earned respect ❤
Reservation is social representation with threshold cutoff where standard is maintained with slight marks difference which will fetch massively for huge population 52%obc 27%,25%sc 15%,15%st7%, but there is 10% reservation for EWS for 7% oc population
Source of your information please....EWS IS FOR EVERYONE NOT COMING UNDER ANY RESERVATION.....INCLUDING MUSLIMS ,CHRISTIANS AND SIKHS...I WILL BE WAITING FOR YOUR REPLY.
@@sanatkumar1945 there are more like parsi etc. But they all constitute 30 % of total population. But not all are poor. Poor general population is less.
And ews is a vertical reservation like sc st obc.
@@realitycheck119 rubbish. CSE Bombay takes 99%tile, iims take 97-98%the, aiims Delhi takes 99%tile.
Ironically, his experience of inferiority was also rooted in economical reasons rather than caste. Caste based inferiority would be the case only for people who are ALSO economically challenged and very very less for people who are not.
I have deep respect for Dr .Ambedkar because he made further easier to underatand that inspite of putting immense pressure of bhramins by caste based reservation ,brahmins are contnously gettings jobs in every sector and tgat js why they are great
I am a Brahmin and I totally agree with what he says, yes I always find a different level of confidence and not aptitude
Salute to S Deepak , it feels like we have same words .
Can't there be some other way to infuse confidence in the downtrodden community? I feel scared when I think of compromise with the quality of human resources in the fields like education and health services. I believe there should be no ifs and buts when it's the question of life and death. I, however, respect J Sai Deepak for his opinion.🙏
Things will change when you won't use word like downrotten community ...till then reservation will be there ....this is what he wanted to express ...still people use such terms
How the fuck did you misunderstand so bad, read again it's downtrodden meaning oppressed or treated badly by people in power not downrotten.
@@divyaranigodas705 They will continue to use those term until reservation exists. Why not call a freeloader and cognitively inferior person the same?
@@divyaranigodas705 first of all, educate yourselves. He said downtrodden, not 'downrotten'. The word you said does not even exist in English language. You are proving his point by showing yourselves to be poorly educated here.
Anyways. Downtrodden means someone or something that has faced abuse or harassment or poor treatment for some time. Isn't that what SC/ST actually admit what they are when they accept jobs and admissions for half the hard work 'upper' caste does?😊
Our social structure is such that to eradicate the caste system we used the caste based reservation. So it's a loop and we can't really have a caste less society. Reservation is the new form of discrimination against General Caste.
The most sensible argument i have ever heard about reservation.
Reservation should be given once in a family......here we have examples where the whole family of 4-5 have become govt officers......there should be a cap....once a father has availed reservation, his children get all the facilities........thank u🙏
I don't know but literally I got tears in my eyes
Very true
Solutions to Indian problems should come from community
That has to be the best solution which even the government will have to accept
I came from a state board.Never felt like you.Made sure Doon school guys ate a humble pie.
Sai Sir,
My personal Opinion is
Reservations & welfare Aids are good for Oppressed people in Educational Institutes and for educational opportunities.
But these Reservations are Harming the Ecosystem, when it comes to JOBS. Because the Qualified and meritorious candidates are continued to be jobless and Unqualified and Unskilled people are on certain positions and making the system ineffective and lethargic. These negative affects are much severe in the fields of Medical & Administrative positions.
Guys,
feel free to give your opinions.
Sir , Do you think reservation candidates has no knowledge to do the work ...reservations can only useful for certain percentage. But you forgotten the compitation of same cast people that are applying for the job , then we have to chose the merit one who has high grades on that cast....so reservations is only way for people to competition on their own cast people and be the merit to get a job , without other caste involvement........I think you understand sir.
See....if I have a reservation I get job at low marks..it don't work like that ,I have to compitate with my cast based reservation guys and be a merit of them to get the job. so don't discriminate us as a unskilled & unqualified based on reservations.
@@vamsinani3855 Almost 80% many Doctors, Teachers, MRO's or other administrative people - who came because of reservation are not doing justice for their professions.
They simply manage the show or manipulate and corrupt the eco system by giving bribes or by doing Bhajan to their superiors. Only 20% are doing justice to their profession despite coming through reservation.
I bow down to those 20% people. But I can't admire the system, as it fails in the majority cases.
I believe you understood the reality of the reservation system.
Sorry man you are totally biased , pls try to analyse the things logically 👍🏼
@@manuponnappan3944 Explain me the things logically. Give your Analogy. I mentioned it as my personnel experience. So I came to an understanding based on the observations made in my life.
Definitely my understanding shouldn't match yours. But you can prove your point.
If I can see the truth in it, I will take it.
I’ve seen a low performance student in my class securing admission into a Tier-1 institution, didn’t even knew if he belonged to reserved category for all the time( he never was short of any confidence or financially deprived), never discriminated him but after knowing this whole debacle now I will surely do 😊
So basically you are not even qualified in the rest of 50 percent.. not even the last in rest of 50 percent..come on..work more hard..
@@savinay999 You are right, he should have worked more. But what you are missing is the open category is not just for general, even reserved people can get seats in open category. Also the students from rich family shouldnt get these reservations,but those who are actually deserving... Imagine if it was actually used by those who are worthy of it, he would have brought his family out of poverty.. Not saying that every seat is being used by the unworthy but some seats are gone that way
There must be reservations but you should also consider other factors than just caste.
@@Ashk_- so generals need another certificate for upper castes, is that what you are saying?
@@savinay999 he never said that he didn't get the last seat . He's talking about the last person getting a top college. If reservations were not present then the person this guy is talking about wouldn't have gotten even the last seat . So let's be peaceful and not make instigating comments
Face of discrimination has changed itself with changing nature of the society
Best part of this video is that it started with Namo Shavayah.
Let me tell you the hypocrisy: A general category friend of mine got 118 marks in JEE Advanced and he's not getting any good branch in any IIT. But on only 90 marks, a SC friend of mine is getting very good branch in IIT Delhi, and guess what the SC friend is 100 times richer than the general friend of mine.. Now this is happening all over India. No wonder why IITs, NITs, and other colleges are not able to produce much researchers and good engineers as compared to when there were no reservation when our Gurukuls used to produce top notch mathematicians, astronomers, etc
Very well said! True talent and progress can be achieved only by DESERVING student and not a RESERVING student.
and the general category student who stole his seat is thousand times richer than SC friend. hope you understand.
@@arulstalin4834 ae Bhai pagal h kya.. poora comment pdh
@@mathophile1912 i can't understand bro
@@arulstalin4834 mtlb ki SC/ST/OBC ko agar 100 marks pr iit Delhi me shi branch mil rhi h to general ko 200 marks pr bhi iit D me achi branch milna mushkil h.. Jee adv me 200 marks Lana majak ki bat ni hoti
Reservation controversy is so wide in its dimension that certain facts and figures and a laid set of laws will not apply to everyone. It will be flawed till individual parameters are not taken into to check creditability of candidate. A set of moral ability checking parameters must be incorporated and if someone doesn't live up to those must be rejected. Left over seats then must be filled over.
Left over seats must be filled over. That's a valid point
Most people don't have a problem with SC, ST and OBC getting reservation, if they are poor. The problem is if the father is earning 10 lakhs per year, and his son is still getting reservation, is he not depriving a more needy candidate of the job, having studied in light, fan and AC as against a poor slum dweller's son...
Appreciated your thoughts and opinions on this context....!! Sir🙏Thanks for giving the clarity on it!!! Several times I asked the same query many people, but no one would answer!!
If the system of caste reservetion was on the basisi of confidence,then it did its job very fine. Being a general male candidate for the upcoming JEE examination,i am in low confidence and made to beleive the truth that I have a lower hand in the examination and the competition still remains the same.
Infact, I come from the rural areas of uttar pradesh...but since my childhood I have never seen any act of caste based discrimination in my neighbourhood and anywhere around me....and if anywhere it is even happening then government should do the work for removing this discrimination....and steps like caste based reservation will surely increase it.....thats my view on this topic.
I think there should be some changes in caste reservation system. Like the person who is economically weaker as well as belong to sc or st category should be given the advantage of reservation system.
if 70 years of quotas dint give confidence then it never will even if we have quotas for the next 500 years.
You gained confidence by oppressing them for thousands of years...Eklavya-Dronacharya...at least they deserve 500 years😂😂😂
@@nathgoody5905 yes yes I suppressed them. I kept reincarnating for 1000 years with all my memories intact and created an illuminati type organization to continue the suppression rofl.
oh fyi Eklavya was a kshatriya and son of a king but then again someone who learns about Hinduism from Missionaries or WhatsApp wouldn't know that would they.
also by your logic Hindus as a whole were butchered and hundreds of thousands of Hindu women were sold as slaves in the middle east etc in the past 500 years so is its effect still seen today or has it disappeared ? Apparently this disappeared conveniently ROFL - brainwashing taken to the next level.
No adiwasi are still away from society the need reservation
@@mohantakrushna143bun So why dont we have a rule that says only first 3 generations of a family belonging to any backward caste can use quotas so that every person gets a shot at growing. We dont have so much opportunities that every backward caste is able to use quotas right ?
If the real intent was to uplift - that would have been the rule. Now all we see is people who have already used quotas to become doctors and engineers still using the same quotas for their children. The adiwasis are still living in the mountains.
@@karthiksekar2009 yes true...but we have to impliment it only after ending caste system ..
This is why I love his views ...
This man is amazing
People were against Tina Dhabi because her father had already used caste based quote and was an IAS himself.
There are people who took caste based reservation in upsc and got IPS and then gave upsc again used their caste based benefit again and then got a better rank and became IAS lol
@@jinfin221lmao 🤣 😂 😆 💀 😭
Simple abolish the caste system so that a dalit can become the priest in a temple and a brahmin and clean the sewages. End caste and end the reservations??
Even if upper caste want they will not be able to do it....because every obc caste has become rigid with their caste identity
@@ayushbadmosh if India doesn't abolish caste system anyday there is threat from outside force. Caste identity is always threat to national identity
@@Vinnnnnnnnnn123 I know these things but still we will not be able to change it ..until and unless full force attack on hindus from muslim can dismantle caste system...when there is compulsion to be hindu first and cast come second..
@@ayushbadmosh exactly before islamic invasion 8% Kshatriyas said only i have the rights to carry weapon and fight. Were they able to protect the rest of Indians from muslim and Christians invasion.
@@Vinnnnnnnnnn123 gulami karke dimag thanda hogya hoga ab tak...agar nahi hua to fr ghulami karenge
Wow! It is nice to see our neighbour andra high caste youngster has he brain to understand the existence of the inequality in our society while he is supporting the reservation at the same time he is discouraging the ews reservation which is giving the reservation in the already privileged classes who are already enjoying all the benefits of the india have.
🙏 Sai Sir … amazing outlook …
You can only feel the discrimination when you are born in general merit!!
Getting a government seat is almost impossible in MBBS and MD. For gods sake, there is reservation in jobs too
Wonderful! I totally agree with you this time . A well thought, contemplated and a measured reply. Morally after obtaining a benifit, and achieving a certain height. It's High time to give it up. I have done it. My children were within top three. Competed in general and got IIIT A and MBBS in a govt college.
absolutely correct. I observe same things in my community being a sc.
Happy to read the comments section with more logical view points than the video itself. salute to all the people in comments.
General category needs to leave the nation, coming years and decades are horrible for us. It's not a level playing field
Exactly
I agree. There's no hope for us here.
Definitely one of the hate monger.. but he got a point on this ..completely agreed with every line he said. The concept of creamy and non creamy layer should be introduced among SC & ST community reservation.
Who is hate monger?
@@saikumarmadadi7524 Sai Deepak Iyer Brahmin doing what his forefathers did
@@HumayunMohammed And look @ ur name--humayun? where do you think you come from???
@@Balu-mj6rt definitely my fore Father were not slaves of Brahmins never were
I think u must be a brahmin so it's hurting you
If not go ask ur forefathers how they were treated by these Brahmins
Firstly, you compete adequately with your own self. Then come blaming others. You just have a privileged mind set. It's an age old one and that's why it's hard for you to digest reservation.
If at all speaking about confidence and mental state of the child is the main matter, then to think about the mental state of a parent is equally important..like what about the change in fee structure for certain course based on caste...
Like for ex, what if one comes from considerably correlated as lower cast and is rich and on the other hand if someone is associated to higher caste but poor.. so in the interest of this reservation that particular person from lower caste enjoys two benefit(reservation and lower fee) and one from the higher caste have two nightmare like first he have to study 10 times more as the cut off is 6-10 times different for open and SC (for JEE if cut off for open is 75 percentile, then for SC its just 10 at times) and also that person have to go through economic trauma as well to pay the full fee..and even after that when both are released in to society after education as citizens, the lower caste one also enjoys the reservation for job..
So I personally believe, its high time for a change, and the reservation should be just based on economical inequality..
Excellent way to justify the continuation of caste based reservation! Thanks
(I'm not whining about my circumstances; I'm just outlining a problem that my family and I have encountered.)
.
I am a 27-year-old SC citizen, and while we are currently in a mediocre financial situation, my family is still having trouble in getting a rented home due of our title i.e. Sethy, in Brahmin neighborhoods. I concur with him that, yes, discrimination still exists, which has a psychological impact on us and occasionally leads us to believe that, if we belonged to the Brahmin category, we may have a superior educational background and more tranquil minds.
100% true.
So charge the culprit with reservation. Hleding entire generations of people who got nothing to do with discrimination is plain illogical and barbaric
@@thepsschadman2662 this is a culture. Culture is for entire community.
@@sidharthapatra4296 what culture
@@sidharthapatra4296 so you are saying that culture of practicing casteism against lower castes should exist?
Hindus were slaves from over 1000 years and if I apply the same logic then all hindus should be benifitted with reservation and should be given laws sach as the sc st act no?
Incredibly accurate points 🙏
In my real life i have seen an incident, when i was giving jeemains 2016 a guy in my examination room next to my line , he completed his exam with in 1hr which is of 3hrs and he started sleeping.
Then invigilator came to him and ask why are you sleeping , in reply he gave answer like i belong to sc category and i coukd get around 100 marks which are more enough to get into any NIT , so why should i work hard.
That's it every body in the room got shocked.
I feel reservation is good but it should not make them less motivated.
That sucks.