I pity if you think it's thought provoking, While drunk I can deliver more substance than him. To improve Pak it needs to do 5 things - 1) Ban all madrasas. 2) start friendship with India at any cost 3) Make Pak secular country 4)Start digital payment. 5) create a special commando unit whose sole Target is to kill every terrorist in country
I am from Kerala state, South India. I listened with keen interest to the discussion and I felt it was a very logical & sensible talk with many valid points.. Good wishes !!
Excellent. Very candid and blunt. This man Mr. Shabbar Zaidi speaks straight from his heart and is extremely pragmatic. Lovely and magnetic conversation.
Summary: 1. Religion should not be part of politics and state matters 2. Women should be 50% of the workforce 3. First tier judiciary (district courts) language should be Urdu 4. Document, automate, and implement the Land transfer (Registrar and Patwari should be out of scene) 5. The SHO or police head of the police station should be a local person 6. Hire deputy chairman of planning commission 7. Have 10 provinces (based on linguistic groups): Pashto, Hindko, Potohari, Saraiki, Punjab, Sind, Urdu, Brahvi, Balochi, Gilgiti 8. Tax the real estate, retailers, and agricultural sector (implement track-and-trace for manufacturers and POS for retailers) Bonus: 9. Crackdown on smugglers 10. Friday sermon should include 'tax chori is a gunaah'
You are right, but we NEED a few actions immediately; i) Bring back all the LOOTED money from foreign bank accounts of ALL money launderers including, Shahbaz, Nawaz, Maryam, Zardari, & Dar; ii) Exclude all corrupt, criminal mafias from politics; iii) Stop Police terrorism, establish rule of law, human rights, security of human life property & dignity; iv) There should be well defined JOB PLAN for all public office holders & Civil / militory public employees.
Just to add to your information. Chitral’s main spoken language is Khowar but 13 other smaller languages are spoken. Such as Farsi, Wakhi, lotkuhi and that of the Kalash. Then come to GB there is no such thing as Gilgiti: languages spoken are Khowar, burushashki, Shina, Balti, wakhi. Gujurwar (sthg similar to hindko). Each languages have so many different dialects it’s difficult to understand the other. The Shina of punial would be different to that of central Gilgit, and that different to Diamer and that different to Shina of Kohistan. GB can be treated as a country on its own.
What a fantastic podcast. So, truthfully explained . Listened 1 hour and 3 minutes but couldn't contradict a single word. This is the painful reality of Pakistan.Thanks shabbar sb for speaking out truth. We need people to speak out what actually need to done.
You have my respect Mr. Shabbar. Your analysis is based on logic and historical facts. Technology, in my opinion, is one factor that is going to determine the future of this world and Pakistan. Most problems as energy, education and security will be a thing of past in another 20-30 years. When people refuse to change then technology will help them change. When you think of technology, think about solar technology, internet, electric vehicles , block chain, AI and Fusion reaction reactors. The future of Pakistan and this world is bright.
absolutely rational ! Straight on point. We are more musalman than musalman. take the religion out of politics and ecnomy. Religion is with in. We can pray in our hearts. shukar karo asa admi hai pakistan mein.
He is a valuable person for advisory role.....he can correct and create an impact on a foundation level of pakistan....which is necessary...very inspiring
Shabir Zaidi Sahib as Head of CBR you has the chance/ the opportunity to inact all these suggestions to a fruition but you held your hands up and left the post on health grounds. Now you are almost appearing ( daily ) in various talk shows and presenting yourself as " THE man with solutions ".
Because he was not allowed to enact those changes and higher ups asked him to roll those back. Any person with integrity would choose to resign if he is not allowed to make the changes he wants to!
What an excellent interview n highlighted the real issues if we wish to save Pakistan.What he said its really heart torching & mind bowling. He should call again as yet he has a lot to say .Allah inkee Hifazat Karaay Itna Sach Bolnaay Pet. love yours sincerity Shabbar Sb.
WE HAVE ALREADY GIVEN THE PATTERN TO CIRCUMVENT CURRENT CRISES ATLEAST ONE OF OUR ADVISE WAS GIVEN FIRST PRIORITY OF JOINT ALLIANCE OF ALL NATIONAL BANKS TO DISCUSS FUND & INVEST CURRENT PRIVATE EQUITY SINCE 2019 THE BANKING SECTOR MUST BE ABLE TO SHIELD COUNTRY FROM INTERNATIONAL FLUCTUATIONS OTHER PART IS BLACK ECONOMY,OR PARALLEL ECONOMY THE TRUTH BE TOLD WHAT HAS STOPPED FLIGHT OR ATLEAST SLOWED DOWN MANY CRISES IS THIS PARALLEL ECONOMY & ROBUST MANAGEMENT OF THIS ECONOMY CAN CATER COUNTRY BARTER AS BORDER TRADE WAS ALSO ONE OF OUR ADVICES INCLUDING THE ADVICE TO CREATE ATLEAST 4 BORDER CITIES WITH DUAL CITIZENSHIP LAWS TO OFFSET CURRENT ECONOMIC STAGNATION ANOTHER ADVICE IS TO DECOUPLE INTERNAL ECONOMY OF COUNTRY FROM FOREIGN PRESSURE BY MANAGING INTERNAL DOMESTIC PRODUCTION OF GOODS & SERVICES FOR THAT WE HAVE ADVISED THAT JOINT EFFORT TURKEY,IRAN,PAKISTAN,AFGHANISTAN MAKE A RESERVE BANK IN KSA & OFFSET PURCHASING OF GOODS OR ROUTE THE PURCHASING OF ATLEAST 45% THROUGH KSA THIS MOVE ALONE WILL OFFSET & RELIEVE PRESSURE ON THESE COUNTRIES ADD AZERBAIJAN,TAJISKSTAN, EVEN INDIA WE HAVE ADVISED MANY SUCH ADVISES THAT THROUGH KSA,WE CAN OFFSET TWO SIDES OF SAME COIN AMRUICA & CN OTHER PART IS SPENDING OF RESOURCES TO BOOST PRODUCTION WE MUST MAKE A LIST OF PRODUCT GLOBAL DEMAND & QUESTION OURSELVES CAN CP BE CUT DOWN & DEMAND CAN BE OFFSET TO PRODUCE FOR EXAMPLE SMALL CAPACITORS LATELY THERE WAS DEMAND DUE TO COVID INSTEAD OF ANDHA DHUN MANUFACTURING GIVING TOLIYA,KACHA BUNYAN,& STOCKING THEM,CURRENTLY THERE IS NO ACCOUNT ON THE GOODS,I CAN STILL GET HANDS ON A 25YEAR OLD BUNYAN THAT IS WASTE OF RESOURCE & IMPORT RAW WE HAVE TO CATER & MEET EFFECTIVE LOCAL DEMAND NOT STOCKPILE USELESS GOODS IF WE HAD DONE IT OBJECTIVELY PROPER SUPPLY CHAIN WOULD HAVE BEEN ESTABLISHED INSTEAD OF CURRENT MESS OTHER PART IS RETAIL ECONOMY & INFLATION & STOCKPILING OF GRAINS,ARTHI CULTURE WHICH IS STRONG ENOUGH THAT IT CAN HAVE ITS OWN ARMY EFFECTIVELY WE CAN'T GUNTA ESTABLISHMENT CAN'T DEAL WITH THEIR OWN FATHERS CHACHAS TAYA PHUPA ,SO WE DONT TOUCH THE SACRED COW BUT WE HAVE TO DRAW OR STABLISE THE PKR & MAKE RESOURCES TO SUPPORT PAKISTANI POPULATION OF 330M BY END OF 2040 THE GLOBAL AGENDA MUST ALSO CHANGE TO MEND & CREATE RESOURCES TO ACCOMODDATE ATLEAST 15B PEOPLE BY 2045 I CAN GO ON & ON ABOUT ECONOMIC SUSTENANCE & FUTURE OF PAKISTAN WE HAVE TO INITATE TO SUPPORT POPULATION OF 330M PEOPLE BY 2040 THAT SHOULD BE ON AGENDA LIST AS MBS HAS GIVEN
@hulagukhan-we3fw Everybody and their cat knows what went wrong for the past 76 years of Pakistan's miserable existence........need a different mindset (out of the usual jihadiudbarbadi, 'atmi taaqat HAH atmi taaqat HAH', yahood o hanood, ghazwa ud tamkana, ummat ka leader , toheen e risalat, do qaumi nazariat and other baqwas ideologies to reallly progress
Such a wonderful podcast. Worth giving an hour. Sir Shabbar Zaidi as always with his straight facts depicting our true picture as a nation. The best thing about him is that he has the guts to point out the real culprits behind the reason Pakistan is failing as a state. Thoroughly enjoyed this talk, would've loved it even more had it been a bit longer.
Appreciate this brain storming session by Shabbar Zaidi sb! First time ever listened so bold, brilliant, inspiring, and eye opener lecture clearly mentioning as to where this country stands today and how we can have a leap forward for progress if intend to . Thanks for organizing and share this lecture !!
Indeed it was an informative interview of brother Shabbar Zaidi. His suggestions are very valuable & can be acted upon but there is a bottleneck who will bell the cat in the form of establishment. If establishment shows political will only then Mr. Zaidi's vision can be converted into actions.
I am from India, pleased to see that this is the first Pakistani youtube channel that has brought up the subject of how to solve Pakistan's problems. There are many who talk about what's wrong in Pakistan but not one that speaks about how to solve those problems. And whoever this speaker is i don't really know his name but I guess if he was actually made the Prime Minister of Pakistan then there could be some real drastic changes in governance. These are the kind of people that should be within political circles but then choose to stay out of these circles. What a waste of talent I must say. If such people are given a chance they could be real game changers for the country.
irequest you to watch all podcast of shabbar sb. Very truthful logical based on facts n full of knowledge n info hence non convential . Love for u from Pakistan
Pakistan SHOULD invest in real education (STEM based). Pakistan SHOULD stop dealing with terrorism Pakistan SHOULD send back its army to barracks on the borders Pakistan SHOULD bring true democracy Pakistan SHOULD rewrite the constitution and follow it Pakistan should stop lying to its own people ..... and continue to do these for the next 100 years.
He said religiosity should be wiped out and in the last, he let religiosity to dictate the policy of state. When he said 'Jume ki namaz me Molivi ye Khutba dy k tax na dena Gunnah hy'. Mazhab should not be the part of state in any way, not even in that case Zaidi saab defined above. Matlab yaar tax collect krny k liye bndy ko Molvi ki kyun zarurat pary
Religiosity is the visible presentation of one's belief Vs. The actual adherence to one's religion. Using khutba as a medium of reaching masses, has nothing to do with both. Until we seperate 'being religious' from 'showing religiosity'.... nothing will change.
Meaning of Pakistan: Pure Land. Meaning of La ilaha illAllah: There is no god but Allah. When your slogan is based on a glamorous lie, do you think anything else will be based on truth?
Mulk ko barbaad karna (free me milne ke baad) koi Pakistanion se seekhe.........Alag mulk banane ke natahij: La ilaha par bana tha.........LEKIN (afsos), MAQBOOZA PAKISTAN ban gaya - do qaumi nazariat muqammal naakaam........APNE HI mard e momin, sadiq ur ameen, mard e mujahid giraye nasheman pe bijliyan..... wahid islami mulk
Absolutely 100% agree with him, especially the last words, " jis ka khana Or gaana apsy milta ho wo apka dost ho sakta hy" he's a very practical and logical person kamaal
After 1971, Pakistan's name should have been changed into Sindhudesh based on the River Indus that courses through the spine of the country. But these existential questions serve no purpose. The nation is already divided and truth will divide them further.
Not Sindhudesh. It should be Hindustan. Even the British rulers offered Quaid e Azam that the name of newly established country should be Hindustan rather than Pakistan. But Quaid rejected the idea.
Pakistan was the name originally for present day Pak (P for Punjab, A for Afghania or NWFP, K for Kashmir, S for Sindh and TAN for Balochistan) , Bangladesh was to be a separate country back then with the name Bangalistan. Hence the name Pakistan is absolutely correct
Agree with you sir. Religion should be out of the economy plus political system and more women should come forward to join the work force and serve the country.
we have found a person who is or he is more truthful than any other person who live in pakistan . if i am in power . i will purpose him indian citizanship .he is a gold in pakistan economy . very practical and useful .
Last line on india is awesome. Captures it all. Though reality of pak is its a state for its elites..mentioned in 3rd min. And yet the guy is optimistic bcz the beard is reducing in young men..thats an interesting take
Karachi session that Mr Zaidi is talking about , was held in 1931 and not 1941. It was presided by Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. The Karachi session is memorable for a resolution on Fundamental Rights and the National Economic Programme. The resolution guaranteed basic civil and political rights to the people. It provided for the nationalization of key industries and transport, better conditions for the workers, agrarian reform, and free and compulsory primary education. It also assured that “the culture, language and script of the minorities and of the different linguistic areas shall be protected.
I wish a person like janab shabbar zaidi should come everyday on tv and educate us, instead of the so called religious hosts. I appreciate zaidi sahib’s historical knowledge as well
Pakistan should spent resources on educating its people to allow them to critically think, impart modern skills and ways of doing work and most importantly as a country value secular education. Unless the citizens are educated and have skills to create products and be productive, the country is going nowhere.
Well the foj e fquddat (uz mafurrrrrrrrrrat ud khateemat) want the bewaqoof sheikhchilli awam to stay deaf, blind and akal ke andhe so that their budget is increased and they can control the country........why would they want to educate the sheikhchilli awam and pet par laat kyon maare?
You are right. Pakistan was doing exactly that, improving Education, training, Skills, Health assurance, Housing for young graduates, Food & Shelters through Ehsas programme for homeless, improving road & transport, Industries, Agriculture development, Science & technology, trade, commerce, Tourism, tackling Climate Change & global warming with plantations, and above ALL an agenda for WORLD PEACE- reducing conflicts & resolving conflicts through dialogue BUT uneducated, sub normal & mentally retarded so called elite & political criminal mafias, derailed the country ONLY to protect their LOOTED money in foreign banks ! with the result, within a short period of 16 months, the country is economically & morally bankrupt.
@@nacpatilwhat the point of having good afterlife if you are struggling for aata dal in current life. First improve current life then think about afterlife.
@@gameaddict3884no the almighty has special interest in your back if you don’t follow him. He will pour special hot Liquid metal alloy with love! He for some reason loves doing that! Also stop playing games so you understand sercasm. The basic human congestion skill.
I want to here more from this guy. Thanks you brought this guy forward. I was expecting n at the end he well explained the Pakistan future with India. N he cleared this up that he is under threat. Stay Blessed Sabir
کیسا مسلمان ہے جو اسلام کے معاشی نظام کو سمجھے بغیر اس کی بد تعریفی کر رہا ہے۔۔ پاکستان کو اسلام سے فرار نہیں۔ اسلام ہی پاکستان کو متحد رکھنے والی واحد قوت اور بنیاد ہے۔۔ اسلام بیزار اس شخص کو کوئی حق نہیں کہ نئی نسل کو اسلام سے متنفر کرے ۔
@@sewaligoswami781 Alignment of Pakistan and Bangladesh on the guidelines of Islam and Jihad is a real threat and Nightmare for Indians. Bangladeshi brothers are even stronger Custodians of the Traditions of Islam.
@@tauqeernasir2634 bhai Jo Maan lo, lekin Islam toh intact nahi rakh paya na Jinnah ki Pakistan ko. Shayad Allah Miyan ne hi Tod Diya hoga. Kya khayal hai?
Pakistani elite & analyst always have wonderful analysis about what should have/must have been done in the past. They keep repeating their past mistakes and do not learn from them. Their plan for future is to beg & borrow and continue the show.😂😂
shabbar zaidi sb. i am big fan of you.. jo knowledge hai ap k pas. mne ap k podcasts sunay. aik yeh wala, aik junaid akram k sath or aik or tha jo 1st one tha. aik baat jo mene note ki hai wo yeh hai keh her podcast mn ap new cheezain batatay hain. her dafa bht kuch new seeknay ko milta hai jo keh prove hai es baat ka keh aap k pas knowledge hai or ground realities k mutabiq hal bhi hai or masa,il ki pehchan bhi hai.
In the Indian Civil Services, before partition, ONLY 1 person was Muszaalim and all others were mostly Hindus, because MusZaalim cannot compete with Hindus when it comes to education, academics and diligence at work.
@@shabeehsayyed3129 no he is actually right. Civil services has always been dominated by Hindus since the beginning even till today you will see only 4% Muslims are in civil service that too many from reservation.
As much as the guest is more educated, more patriotic and has more actual details, he still doesn’t have all the lower level details to solve Pakistan’s problems. Pakistan’s problems are deep rooted. It has massive issues which won’t get resolved anytime. I think a dictator who is a statesman will be the only one who can make the changes needed. Sadly, my sense is this country is finished. It has no future. It is forever cursed.
You can disagree with him, you can say he's wrong, you can call him a fool, you can hate him, you can call him a kafir but you cannot say that he isn't saying what is in his mind. He is honest to a fault and honestly he is not doing himself any favors saying what he is saying in this country that could put him in harms way.
Thank you very much for bring going Shabar Zaidi sahib as guest speaker I am a great fan of him Pray Allah Almighty for your health wealth and happy long life Ameen
highly admire the openness of Mr Shabbar Zaidi, you please do the program for the actions & recovery of NAB, also how we can degun (removal of weapons) from nation. cannot we start operation to sweep weapon from sindh and onwards to entire pakistan...
I wish you all good luck n also wish that Pakistan Comes out of this Present mess. May good Sense Prevail n Pakistan march towards a better n bright future.
This guy has fired a lot of headshots in a way that a listener would never cried on any deadbody on ground. From making a lot of provinces to making new rules and regulations he nailed it all.
If country is to progress; i) All the Criminal/Corrupt International Money launderers MUST be excluded from politics; ii) All the International Money Launderers MUST bring back the money from their foreign bank accounts & investments to revive the economy; iii) 16 months activities of lawless Shahbaz PDM/PPP regime MUST BE investigated, and all the laws made through TRUNCATED/DISCREDITED Parliament reversed; iv) Chairman EC, andPolice heads MUST be removed; v) Basic human rights of Citizen MUST be restored; v) Number of ministers reduced, & their Salaries, allowances, free gas & electricity MUST be removed. vi) Journalists & Media MUST have Code of Conduct & ban on irresponsible loose talks
Shabbar Zaidi Sb is a real professional who has the in depth knowledge of economics really thought provoking analysis no doubt we are the worst nation at present era
I'd like to point it out being a student of CJP Justice Jawwad S Khawaja, the judge who authored the judgement directing the federal govt. to implement Urdu as a National Language was translated into Urdu by the Supreme Court.
❤ loved his references and wrote a copy notes of what ever ge said.... its truly amazing to have such productive and valued podcasts.... helps in mind maping of direction of the country.
Nobody can appoint you however POWERFUL he may be on any seat unless you are shaky about it.means yes or no from your side about appointment . I believe Mr Shabbar Zaidi is exaggaterating about appointment as FBR chairman.
Thought Provoking 👍
for the wokies yeh lmao haha
He was one sentence away from saying creating pak was a mistake and qaid was incompetent pumpkin.
Hope people in power corridors are listening g.
I pity if you think it's thought provoking,
While drunk I can deliver more substance than him.
To improve Pak it needs to do 5 things -
1) Ban all madrasas.
2) start friendship with India at any cost
3) Make Pak secular country
4)Start digital payment.
5) create a special commando unit whose sole Target is to kill every terrorist in country
You are veryyyyyyy late.
Great Pakistani 🎉Understand problems of the Citizens
( Sudhir from Mumbai)
I listened Dr Zaidi just 2, 3 times n I've become his fan. It's a treat to listen each time.
I am from Kerala state, South India. I listened with keen interest to the discussion and I felt it was a very logical & sensible talk with many valid points.. Good wishes !!
Wow brother you from Kerala
❤love from AK Pakistan. No doubt shabbar sb is a great scholer
@@ZainKhan-sn4de ME BEING FROM NAGALAND SOMETIMES LAUGH AT PAKISTAN LIKE WHAT ARMY HAD MADE MESS OF PAKISTAN 😂 BUT STILL WISH FOR YOU TO IMPROVE
Excellent. Very candid and blunt. This man Mr. Shabbar Zaidi speaks straight from his heart and is extremely pragmatic. Lovely and magnetic conversation.
Thank you for your kind words! We're glad you found the episode insightful.
@@DigiTalesER Thanks for responding to my comments.
Summary:
1. Religion should not be part of politics and state matters
2. Women should be 50% of the workforce
3. First tier judiciary (district courts) language should be Urdu
4. Document, automate, and implement the Land transfer (Registrar and Patwari should be out of scene)
5. The SHO or police head of the police station should be a local person
6. Hire deputy chairman of planning commission
7. Have 10 provinces (based on linguistic groups): Pashto, Hindko, Potohari, Saraiki, Punjab, Sind, Urdu, Brahvi, Balochi, Gilgiti
8. Tax the real estate, retailers, and agricultural sector (implement track-and-trace for manufacturers and POS for retailers)
Bonus:
9. Crackdown on smugglers
10. Friday sermon should include 'tax chori is a gunaah'
Army will huck all these rules at once
You are right, but we NEED a few actions immediately; i) Bring back all the LOOTED money from foreign bank accounts of ALL money launderers including, Shahbaz, Nawaz, Maryam, Zardari, & Dar; ii) Exclude all corrupt, criminal mafias from politics; iii) Stop Police terrorism, establish rule of law, human rights, security of human life property & dignity; iv) There should be well defined JOB PLAN for all public office holders & Civil / militory public employees.
Just to add to your information.
Chitral’s main spoken language is Khowar but 13 other smaller languages are spoken. Such as Farsi, Wakhi, lotkuhi and that of the Kalash.
Then come to GB there is no such thing as Gilgiti: languages spoken are Khowar, burushashki, Shina, Balti, wakhi. Gujurwar (sthg similar to hindko).
Each languages have so many different dialects it’s difficult to understand the other. The Shina of punial would be different to that of central Gilgit, and that different to Diamer and that different to Shina of Kohistan. GB can be treated as a country on its own.
israel @@hamzak6437
ye to India ho gaya
He said the right thing in last 5 minutes.. Satute to Shabbar zaidi sahab.. From India🇮🇳
Shabbar Zaidi Sb is a man of wisdom. We need more people like him in Pakistan.
Araaay bhie tum bhi to Shabbar Sb k Student hoo 😁👍
Wonderful session. As an Indian, I really enjoyed the show very much. I would request everyone to read the books of Iqbal Chand Malhotra also.
Very intelligent pakistani. We need such people for Indian policy planners.
Offcource he's been polishing Indian shoe like a slave 😂😅
❤from Pakistan
What a fantastic podcast. So, truthfully explained . Listened 1 hour and 3 minutes but couldn't contradict a single word. This is the painful reality of Pakistan.Thanks shabbar sb for speaking out truth. We need people to speak out what actually need to done.
Thank you for tuning in and sharing your thoughts! We appreciate your feedback.
Gappe lagana ek bat h aur plan execution alag bat h. Insano ko sath lana, motivate kerna aur plan execute kerna alag bat h.
Mere bache hi meri nahi sunte per apni mummy ki her bat sunte h. Matlab saf h bhale mere bal safed ho gaye ho per administration me fail hu.
How beautifully and accurately he spitted out the facts. Listening to people like him is a treat to ears.
A light of hope shines in the gloomy despair of our bifurcated neighbor. Always stay blessed.
You have my respect Mr. Shabbar. Your analysis is based on logic and historical facts. Technology, in my opinion, is one factor that is going to determine the future of this world and Pakistan. Most problems as energy, education and security will be a thing of past in another 20-30 years. When people refuse to change then technology will help them change. When you think of technology, think about solar technology, internet, electric vehicles , block chain, AI and Fusion reaction reactors. The future of Pakistan and this world is bright.
Thank you for your kind words! We're glad you found the episode insightful
Loved every bit of this Podcast. Kudos to Shabbar Uncle, We need more people like him.
absolutely rational ! Straight on point. We are more musalman than musalman.
take the religion out of politics and ecnomy. Religion is with in. We can pray in our hearts. shukar karo asa admi hai pakistan mein.
He is right in every word of his talking ❤
Thank you for the feedback!
He is a valuable person for advisory role.....he can correct and create an impact on a foundation level of pakistan....which is necessary...very inspiring
Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
Shabir Zaidi Sahib as Head of CBR you has the chance/ the opportunity to inact all these suggestions to a fruition but you held your hands up and left the post on health grounds. Now you are almost appearing ( daily ) in various talk shows and presenting yourself as " THE man with solutions ".
Because he was not allowed to enact those changes and higher ups asked him to roll those back. Any person with integrity would choose to resign if he is not allowed to make the changes he wants to!
What an excellent interview n highlighted the real issues if we wish to save Pakistan.What he said its really heart torching & mind bowling. He should call again as yet he has a lot to say .Allah inkee Hifazat Karaay Itna Sach Bolnaay Pet. love yours sincerity Shabbar Sb.
Thank you for tuning in and sharing your thoughts! We appreciate your feedback.
تاریخ کے اوراق سے حال کے تلخ حقائق سے ہوتے ہوئے مستقبل کی ایک پور امید کرن کا امکان بہت خوب زیدی صاحب خدا سلامت رکھے
Zaidi saheb, salute to you for your depth of knowledge. Best wishes sir.
بہت عمدہ، کھری کھری، خطرناک حد تک سچی گفتگو ۔ ❤
Blindly Truthfull man....
He is a jolly good man
Thank you for the feedback!
Awesome.. worth listening.. great man
Not all ideas are agreed... I think many points need thorough discussions & deliberations
My dear Pakistani friends,
Please don't discuss what went wrong earlier, instead find a way to come out from this economic mess.
WE HAVE ALREADY GIVEN THE PATTERN TO CIRCUMVENT CURRENT CRISES
ATLEAST ONE OF OUR ADVISE WAS GIVEN FIRST PRIORITY OF JOINT ALLIANCE OF ALL NATIONAL BANKS TO DISCUSS FUND & INVEST CURRENT PRIVATE EQUITY SINCE 2019
THE BANKING SECTOR MUST BE ABLE TO SHIELD COUNTRY FROM INTERNATIONAL FLUCTUATIONS
OTHER PART IS BLACK ECONOMY,OR PARALLEL ECONOMY THE TRUTH BE TOLD WHAT HAS STOPPED FLIGHT OR ATLEAST SLOWED DOWN MANY CRISES IS THIS PARALLEL ECONOMY & ROBUST MANAGEMENT OF THIS ECONOMY CAN CATER COUNTRY
BARTER AS BORDER TRADE WAS ALSO ONE OF OUR ADVICES
INCLUDING THE ADVICE TO CREATE ATLEAST 4 BORDER CITIES WITH DUAL CITIZENSHIP LAWS TO OFFSET CURRENT ECONOMIC STAGNATION
ANOTHER ADVICE IS TO DECOUPLE INTERNAL ECONOMY OF COUNTRY FROM FOREIGN PRESSURE BY MANAGING INTERNAL DOMESTIC PRODUCTION OF GOODS & SERVICES
FOR THAT WE HAVE ADVISED
THAT JOINT EFFORT TURKEY,IRAN,PAKISTAN,AFGHANISTAN
MAKE A RESERVE BANK IN KSA
& OFFSET PURCHASING OF GOODS OR ROUTE THE PURCHASING OF ATLEAST 45%
THROUGH KSA
THIS MOVE ALONE WILL OFFSET & RELIEVE PRESSURE ON THESE COUNTRIES
ADD AZERBAIJAN,TAJISKSTAN, EVEN INDIA
WE HAVE ADVISED MANY SUCH ADVISES THAT THROUGH KSA,WE CAN OFFSET TWO SIDES OF SAME COIN AMRUICA & CN
OTHER PART IS SPENDING OF RESOURCES
TO BOOST PRODUCTION WE MUST MAKE A LIST OF PRODUCT
GLOBAL DEMAND &
QUESTION OURSELVES CAN CP BE CUT DOWN & DEMAND CAN BE OFFSET TO PRODUCE FOR EXAMPLE SMALL CAPACITORS LATELY THERE WAS DEMAND DUE TO COVID
INSTEAD OF ANDHA DHUN MANUFACTURING GIVING TOLIYA,KACHA BUNYAN,& STOCKING THEM,CURRENTLY THERE IS NO ACCOUNT ON THE GOODS,I CAN STILL GET HANDS ON A 25YEAR OLD BUNYAN
THAT IS WASTE OF RESOURCE & IMPORT RAW
WE HAVE TO CATER & MEET EFFECTIVE LOCAL DEMAND
NOT STOCKPILE USELESS GOODS
IF WE HAD DONE IT OBJECTIVELY PROPER SUPPLY CHAIN WOULD HAVE BEEN ESTABLISHED INSTEAD OF CURRENT MESS
OTHER PART IS RETAIL ECONOMY & INFLATION
& STOCKPILING OF GRAINS,ARTHI CULTURE
WHICH IS STRONG ENOUGH THAT IT CAN HAVE ITS OWN ARMY
EFFECTIVELY WE CAN'T GUNTA ESTABLISHMENT CAN'T DEAL WITH THEIR OWN FATHERS CHACHAS TAYA PHUPA ,SO WE DONT TOUCH THE SACRED COW
BUT WE HAVE TO DRAW OR STABLISE THE PKR
& MAKE RESOURCES TO SUPPORT PAKISTANI POPULATION OF 330M BY END OF 2040
THE GLOBAL AGENDA MUST ALSO CHANGE TO MEND & CREATE RESOURCES TO ACCOMODDATE ATLEAST 15B PEOPLE BY 2045
I CAN GO ON & ON ABOUT ECONOMIC SUSTENANCE
& FUTURE OF PAKISTAN WE HAVE TO INITATE TO SUPPORT POPULATION OF 330M PEOPLE BY 2040 THAT SHOULD BE ON AGENDA LIST AS MBS HAS GIVEN
@hulagukhan-we3fw Everybody and their cat knows what went wrong for the past 76 years of Pakistan's miserable existence........need a different mindset (out of the usual jihadiudbarbadi, 'atmi taaqat HAH atmi taaqat HAH', yahood o hanood, ghazwa ud tamkana, ummat ka leader , toheen e risalat, do qaumi nazariat and other baqwas ideologies to reallly progress
If you havent understood yet that this was never your land then you need that understanding first. You just thought it was yours!
Removing Islam from Pakistan is the only way of all problems
Great .
Such a wonderful podcast. Worth giving an hour. Sir Shabbar Zaidi as always with his straight facts depicting our true picture as a nation. The best thing about him is that he has the guts to point out the real culprits behind the reason Pakistan is failing as a state. Thoroughly enjoyed this talk, would've loved it even more had it been a bit longer.
Wonderful suggestions by Mr. Zaidi. But ruling elites will not let it happen. Pakistan is bound to be destroyed, unfortunately.
Thank you for tuning in and sharing your thoughts!
Shabbat Zaidi Sahb.A great economist philosopher .As such great highest scholars is need for Pakistan.Shabbat Zaidi is a assets for this nation.
Appreciate this brain storming session by Shabbar Zaidi sb! First time ever listened so bold, brilliant, inspiring, and eye opener lecture clearly mentioning as to where this country stands today and how we can have a leap forward for progress if intend to . Thanks for organizing and share this lecture !!
Thank you for your kind words! We're glad you found the episode insightful
Comments smell set up.
@@DigiTalesER12:44 problem hain islam
Indeed it was an informative interview of brother Shabbar Zaidi. His suggestions are very valuable & can be acted upon but there is a bottleneck who will bell the cat in the form of establishment. If establishment shows political will only then Mr. Zaidi's vision can be converted into actions.
Very underrated podcast the host seems very well prepared guy.
A man of conscious and real torch bearer for salvation of problems.
This guy is genius. He has the best 8 point. First 4 points will change destiny of Pakistan. Good blog. I ll appreciate his vision for his country.
What a intelligent individual. How can someone know so many things throughly. Respect from India 🇮🇳
What a mind + knowledge💯
Nice video , worth listening. Salute to this brave person for speaking truth infront of pakistani population.
Thanks for telling us the right history. Pakistan came into being because of Ego of some leaders.
I am from India, pleased to see that this is the first Pakistani youtube channel that has brought up the subject of how to solve Pakistan's problems. There are many who talk about what's wrong in Pakistan but not one that speaks about how to solve those problems. And whoever this speaker is i don't really know his name but I guess if he was actually made the Prime Minister of Pakistan then there could be some real drastic changes in governance. These are the kind of people that should be within political circles but then choose to stay out of these circles. What a waste of talent I must say. If such people are given a chance they could be real game changers for the country.
irequest you to watch all podcast of shabbar sb. Very truthful logical based on facts n full of knowledge n info hence non convential . Love for u from Pakistan
Pakistan SHOULD invest in real education (STEM based).
Pakistan SHOULD stop dealing with terrorism
Pakistan SHOULD send back its army to barracks on the borders
Pakistan SHOULD bring true democracy
Pakistan SHOULD rewrite the constitution and follow it
Pakistan should stop lying to its own people
..... and continue to do these for the next 100 years.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
Wow. This is exactly what Saudi Arabia has done. And they are doing waaaay better than before.
Wow !!!
He said religiosity should be wiped out and in the last, he let religiosity to dictate the policy of state. When he said 'Jume ki namaz me Molivi ye Khutba dy k tax na dena Gunnah hy'. Mazhab should not be the part of state in any way, not even in that case Zaidi saab defined above. Matlab yaar tax collect krny k liye bndy ko Molvi ki kyun zarurat pary
Well noticed!
Religiosity is the visible presentation of one's belief Vs. The actual adherence to one's religion.
Using khutba as a medium of reaching masses, has nothing to do with both.
Until we seperate 'being religious' from 'showing religiosity'.... nothing will change.
He makes many self-contradictory and historically inaccurate assertions
Q@@sheerazzafar
True @@sheerazzafar
Montek Singh Ahluwalia was an Indian Economist & Civil Servant who was Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission.Prior to the same he was in IMF.
Meaning of Pakistan: Pure Land. Meaning of La ilaha illAllah: There is no god but Allah. When your slogan is based on a glamorous lie, do you think anything else will be based on truth?
Mulk ko barbaad karna (free me milne ke baad) koi Pakistanion se seekhe.........Alag mulk banane ke natahij: La ilaha par bana tha.........LEKIN (afsos), MAQBOOZA PAKISTAN ban gaya - do qaumi nazariat muqammal naakaam........APNE HI mard e momin, sadiq ur ameen, mard e mujahid giraye nasheman pe bijliyan..... wahid islami mulk
Absolutely 100% agree with him, especially the last words, " jis ka khana Or gaana apsy milta ho wo apka dost ho sakta hy"
he's a very practical and logical person kamaal
After 1971, Pakistan's name should have been changed into Sindhudesh based on the River Indus that courses through the spine of the country. But these existential questions serve no purpose. The nation is already divided and truth will divide them further.
Not Sindhudesh. It should be Hindustan. Even the British rulers offered Quaid e Azam that the name of newly established country should be Hindustan rather than Pakistan. But Quaid rejected the idea.
Pakistan was the name originally for present day Pak (P for Punjab, A for Afghania or NWFP, K for Kashmir, S for Sindh and TAN for Balochistan) , Bangladesh was to be a separate country back then with the name Bangalistan. Hence the name Pakistan is absolutely correct
Very informative interview. Allah unki hifazat karayne. He is really a bold n learned person. I believe him as a precious 💞 person/asset of Pakistan.
He’s so intellectual yet hilarious😂
❤u can say original
Agree with you sir. Religion should be out of the economy plus political system and more women should come forward to join the work force and serve the country.
One correction India dividend is written by Dr. Rajendra Prasad and published in 1946( before partition)
we have found a person who is or he is more truthful than any other person who live in pakistan . if i am in power . i will purpose him indian citizanship .he is a gold in pakistan economy . very practical and useful .
The country created by the Elite, run by the elite for the elite. - Shabbar Zaidi
Last line on india is awesome. Captures it all. Though reality of pak is its a state for its elites..mentioned in 3rd min. And yet the guy is optimistic bcz the beard is reducing in young men..thats an interesting take
We should agree to all points suggested by Mr.Shabbar.Zaidi Saheb if we want to have prosperity
Thank you for the feedback!
Karachi session that Mr Zaidi is talking about , was held in 1931 and not 1941. It was presided by Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel.
The Karachi session is memorable for a resolution on Fundamental Rights and the National Economic Programme.
The resolution guaranteed basic civil and political rights to the people.
It provided for the nationalization of key industries and transport, better conditions for the workers, agrarian reform, and free and compulsory primary education.
It also assured that “the culture, language and script of the minorities and of the different linguistic areas shall be protected.
Sadly, RSS Modi apartheid regime, detests sardar Patel, and grants NO rights to minorities, with regards to basic rights.
I wish a person like janab shabbar zaidi should come everyday on tv and educate us, instead of the so called religious hosts.
I appreciate zaidi sahib’s historical knowledge as well
Pakistan should spent resources on educating its people to allow them to critically think, impart modern skills and ways of doing work and most importantly as a country value secular education. Unless the citizens are educated and have skills to create products and be productive, the country is going nowhere.
Well the foj e fquddat (uz mafurrrrrrrrrrat ud khateemat) want the bewaqoof sheikhchilli awam to stay deaf, blind and akal ke andhe so that their budget is increased and they can control the country........why would they want to educate the sheikhchilli awam and pet par laat kyon maare?
None of this is useful in after life. Useless stuff.
You are right. Pakistan was doing exactly that, improving Education, training, Skills, Health assurance, Housing for young graduates, Food & Shelters through Ehsas programme for homeless, improving road & transport, Industries, Agriculture development, Science & technology, trade, commerce, Tourism, tackling Climate Change & global warming with plantations, and above ALL an agenda for WORLD PEACE- reducing conflicts & resolving conflicts through dialogue BUT uneducated, sub normal & mentally retarded so called elite & political criminal mafias, derailed the country ONLY to protect their LOOTED money in foreign banks ! with the result, within a short period of 16 months, the country is economically & morally bankrupt.
@@nacpatilwhat the point of having good afterlife if you are struggling for aata dal in current life.
First improve current life then think about afterlife.
@@gameaddict3884no the almighty has special interest in your back if you don’t follow him. He will pour special hot Liquid metal alloy with love! He for some reason loves doing that!
Also stop playing games so you understand sercasm. The basic human congestion skill.
Immensely intriguing insight into Pakistan. We Indians truly wish the best for Pakistan in order to have a peaceful and progressive relations!
I want to here more from this guy. Thanks you brought this guy forward. I was expecting n at the end he well explained the Pakistan future with India. N he cleared this up that he is under threat. Stay Blessed Sabir
کیسا مسلمان ہے جو اسلام کے معاشی نظام کو سمجھے بغیر اس کی بد تعریفی کر رہا ہے۔۔ پاکستان کو اسلام سے فرار نہیں۔ اسلام ہی پاکستان کو متحد رکھنے والی واحد قوت اور بنیاد ہے۔۔ اسلام بیزار اس شخص کو کوئی حق نہیں کہ نئی نسل کو اسلام سے متنفر کرے ۔
1947 wala Pakistan ko kya hua? Islam intact rakh paya? Ajeeb hi bhasad macha k rakhhe hain.
@@sewaligoswami781 Alignment of Pakistan and Bangladesh on the guidelines of Islam and Jihad is a real threat and Nightmare for Indians. Bangladeshi brothers are even stronger Custodians of the Traditions of Islam.
@@tauqeernasir2634 bhai Jo Maan lo, lekin Islam toh intact nahi rakh paya na Jinnah ki Pakistan ko. Shayad Allah Miyan ne hi Tod Diya hoga. Kya khayal hai?
@@sewaligoswami781 This could well be a blessing in disguise. One day India will repent on her deeds that it has converted one enemy into two enemies.
@@sewaligoswami781 Zaroor Allah he ki koi hikmat ho gi. That is why it could be a blessing in Disguise.
Informative video, Shabbar sir is very brave and defiant person, he stated the significant facts and figures.
Pakistani elite & analyst always have wonderful analysis about what should have/must have been done in the past. They keep repeating their past mistakes and do not learn from them. Their plan for future is to beg & borrow and continue the show.😂😂
You are the one who is confused! Why would elites change system that favors them?
shabbar zaidi sb. i am big fan of you.. jo knowledge hai ap k pas. mne ap k podcasts sunay. aik yeh wala, aik junaid akram k sath or aik or tha jo 1st one tha. aik baat jo mene note ki hai wo yeh hai keh her podcast mn ap new cheezain batatay hain. her dafa bht kuch new seeknay ko milta hai jo keh prove hai es baat ka keh aap k pas knowledge hai or ground realities k mutabiq hal bhi hai or masa,il ki pehchan bhi hai.
Kamal person kamal discussion 12:15
This man is great, thumbs up Sir Zaidi ...
In the Indian Civil Services, before partition, ONLY 1 person was Muszaalim and all others were mostly Hindus, because MusZaalim cannot compete with Hindus when it comes to education, academics and diligence at work.
Hmm since always it's like that
😂😅kuch bhi😅
No more than one people serve in Indian civil service see history
@@manu.ba374 it's true
@@shabeehsayyed3129 no he is actually right. Civil services has always been dominated by Hindus since the beginning even till today you will see only 4% Muslims are in civil service that too many from reservation.
I have suprised this type intelligent & very true speaking person in Pakistan. HATTES OFF
As much as the guest is more educated, more patriotic and has more actual details, he still doesn’t have all the lower level details to solve Pakistan’s problems.
Pakistan’s problems are deep rooted. It has massive issues which won’t get resolved anytime. I think a dictator who is a statesman will be the only one who can make the changes needed.
Sadly, my sense is this country is finished. It has no future. It is forever cursed.
You are telling truth bravely. It is impossible to do so in this country.
Pakistan ka problem allah bhi nahi solve kar saktey,🎉🎉😅😅
fool
You can disagree with him, you can say he's wrong, you can call him a fool, you can hate him, you can call him a kafir but you cannot say that he isn't saying what is in his mind.
He is honest to a fault and honestly he is not doing himself any favors saying what he is saying in this country that could put him in harms way.
A light of hope for PAKISTAN !
Appreciated,I request Shabar Sab,to come forward and lead the country
Thank you very much for bring going Shabar Zaidi sahib as guest speaker
I am a great fan of him
Pray Allah Almighty for your health wealth and happy long life Ameen
We're thrilled to hear that you're enjoying the topics we discuss! Your support means a lot to us.
My thoughts are aligned with mr Shabbar Zaidi’s views.
Very valid point
Our court system needs to be changed
Thank you for the feedback! We're thrilled that you find our episodes engaging.
Yey log heyn Pakistan ka sarmaya, Excellent Shabbar Sb., God bless you.
highly admire the openness of Mr Shabbar Zaidi, you please do the program for the actions & recovery of NAB, also how we can degun (removal of weapons) from nation. cannot we start operation to sweep weapon from sindh and onwards to entire pakistan...
I wish you all good luck n also wish that Pakistan Comes out of this Present mess. May good Sense Prevail n Pakistan march towards a better n bright future.
Very interesting, enjoyed the whole discussion till the end. Thumbs up for Shabbar Zaidi Sb.
This guy has fired a lot of headshots in a way that a listener would never cried on any deadbody on ground. From making a lot of provinces to making new rules and regulations he nailed it all.
If country is to progress; i) All the Criminal/Corrupt International Money launderers MUST be excluded from politics; ii) All the International Money Launderers MUST bring back the money from their foreign bank accounts & investments to revive the economy; iii) 16 months activities of lawless Shahbaz PDM/PPP regime MUST BE investigated, and all the laws made through TRUNCATED/DISCREDITED Parliament reversed; iv) Chairman EC, andPolice heads MUST be removed; v) Basic human rights of Citizen MUST be restored; v) Number of ministers reduced, & their Salaries, allowances, free gas & electricity MUST be removed. vi) Journalists & Media MUST have Code of Conduct & ban on irresponsible loose talks
Shabbar Zaidi Sb is a real professional who has the in depth knowledge of economics really thought provoking analysis no doubt we are the worst nation at present era
He is also a tout of west.
Basic point is left here which is will, loyalty and sincereity may please be considered as No.1.
Very honest assessment indeed ..Hope pakistan would take some of his suggestions in letter and spirit......
Such an amazing interview. Difficult for the host when the guest is so knowledgeable, but thanks for the contribution
Good discussion. Appreciated from India.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
Very good exposure by Zaidi Sahib of Pakistan and its history.
Love and respect for zaidi sahib ❤
Totally enjoyed the enlightening conversation. Thanks for inviting him.
Bring him again bhai. Ek podcast "what should Muslims do" respect from India.
a) Separate Church and State b) Inculcate tolerance c) reform education and encourage skill building and d) respect for the rule of law.
Delighted to hear his thoughts,very interesting man
We appreciate your views with regards to giving time on khuda 's economy and economy fir betterment of all human beings
EXCELLENT in all accounts-the real truth heard.-as step 0ne make police independent to put everyone wrong notations right.
I have oustanding plan of pakistan economy growth without imposing any cruel taxes
I'd like to point it out being a student of CJP Justice Jawwad S Khawaja, the judge who authored the judgement directing the federal govt. to implement Urdu as a National Language was translated into Urdu by the Supreme Court.
❤ loved his references and wrote a copy notes of what ever ge said.... its truly amazing to have such productive and valued podcasts.... helps in mind maping of direction of the country.
Nobody can appoint you however POWERFUL he may be on any seat unless you are shaky about it.means yes or no from your side about appointment . I believe Mr Shabbar Zaidi is exaggaterating about appointment as FBR chairman.
truly respect this man❤
Very interesting discussion. I wonder why such brilliant minds are not valued? What a pity.
Wake up call for leadership. Invest in power then help manufacture and agriculture fisheries for exports.enough of this.we have hardworking people.