I give any combat scenario using similar weapons and tech to Thrawn. Picard is great, but not at the near-deity level of Thrawn. But using Star Trek tech vs. Star Wars tech, it'd be Picard. Teleporting torpedoes to bridges and engine compartments would work all too well.
Likely. Neiather would have and real reason to fight, unless Thrawn was attacking the Federation, and he’s not stupid, and picking a fight with a powerful civilization he knows nothing about is not a good tactic I suppose if Thawn was desperate or ordered to attack regardless. … seems unlikely.
Low-effort AI content. Downvoted and marked channel as "do not recommend." I suggest others follow suit. Together we can stem the tide of this torrent of youtube diarrhea.
Hum.. one problem is the Trek ships so wildly out gun Star Wars ships it’s laughable. A comparison between Star Destroyer cannons blast which throws folks dozens of feet. The Enterprize Ds phasers were shown burning out half mile diameter holes in Borg cubes. So a single shot would pretty much burn away a whole Star Destroyer. With a rate of fire of a Star Destroyer destroyed per secound or two…. Thrawns not got much leverage in battle. On the other hand, the Enterprize would be a staggering resource. Thrawn would really want to find a way to leverage that, and at all costs .. keep them from uniting with the rebellion. If Thrawn realizes that the democratic republic desired by the rebels, is exactly what the federation is and prefers. He’s going to sense a extreme threat. Rather then a possibility of mutual destruction. The Galaxy class could whipe out imperial fleets with little risk to itself. Thrawn manipulating Picard to stay away from the rebels, while dealing with a ship full of various races and cultures he knows nothing about … and hopefully doesn’t start a fight with.
Ahhhhahahahahahah…… you are exceptionally comedic. There is no proof a phaser is more dangerous than heavy turbolaser batteries, because they run on different power sources in different worlds fired at different enemies. I might mention that the kind of orbital bombardment enterprise D puts on planet surfaces achieves in days what a Star destroyer achieves in hours, or that a Borg Cube is not the material equivalent of a star destroyer. Not to mention the differentials in the power of their shields reactors. Enterprise is not a warship, it’s an exploratory vessel. It’s common practice to put heavier shields and weapons on warships than civilian ones, and Star Wars is a galaxy that’s been in perpetual war since the inception of the republic some tens of thousands of years prior to the movies. I can guarantee they have advancements in weapons that render anything in Star Trek obsolete just by their track record. Also, thrawn potentially has access to death stars in his fleet, with two super star destroyers outfitted with eclipse cannons. I don’t think I need to explain just how outgunned Picard would be if a single one of those ships entered the zone.
@@nathanielweber7843 Thrawn would get destroyed in a fight with the Enterprise. In fact, he would suffer that no matter which Enterprise he fought. His best chance is against Kirk, but his ship manoeuvres as well as the D did in Picard Season 3 finale. Thrawn has no chance, because all the Starfleet ships would be at warp speed firing their weapons, and had already totally scanned and prepared their most optimal tactics before firing. Any other fighting done that does not happen at warp, is because they are dealing with contemporary threats that need to be dealt with in drawn out fights. Thrawn's ship does not meet that threshold. He would get the standard warp flyby slaughter, and yes, that is a combat protocol. Especially if Troy has confirmed telepathically that Thrawn is crafty, has no intention of dealing with Picard, be completely hostile to any deals way beyond even the Romulans, and has elements available to him that would defuse her abilities.
Picard wins every time, for one simple "but all powerful" reason....Q. Q has a affinity with Picard, therefore I'm guessing he would not let Picard lose, but this is Q we are talking about, so anything goes really.
Picard stays cool headed under pressure unless the adversary is the Borg then he’ll lose his shit
I give any combat scenario using similar weapons and tech to Thrawn. Picard is great, but not at the near-deity level of Thrawn. But using Star Trek tech vs. Star Wars tech, it'd be Picard. Teleporting torpedoes to bridges and engine compartments would work all too well.
No one seems to have an idea on how they would try to outsmart each other or something?
I think Star Wars villains would be quite devious and tell you what you want to hear and then undermine you
@
That’s nothing new to the fed officers.
If they fought against each other, the forces would be 50/50.
Much as I love Ol' Baldy, the win goes to Thrawn.
i think they would both negotiate a peaceful solution
Likely. Neiather would have and real reason to fight, unless Thrawn was attacking the Federation, and he’s not stupid, and picking a fight with a powerful civilization he knows nothing about is not a good tactic
I suppose if Thawn was desperate or ordered to attack regardless. … seems unlikely.
Very stupid
Cloaking capabilities on a Federation ship? Do you mean shields?
you should flag AI content. This video is 100% AI content (except for the totally inadequate clips from several Star Trek episodes / movies).
Yeah at the time this was scheduled that tag was off actually but its a blend
edit your thumbnail before you get a dmca strike
Why would it get a DMCA Strike? Its custom made and fair use protected.
Low-effort AI content. Downvoted and marked channel as "do not recommend."
I suggest others follow suit. Together we can stem the tide of this torrent of youtube diarrhea.
Umm this is custom made with footage from multiple films. I was gonna hire a British guy to do the voice over too.
Hum.. one problem is the Trek ships so wildly out gun Star Wars ships it’s laughable. A comparison between Star Destroyer cannons blast which throws folks dozens of feet. The Enterprize Ds phasers were shown burning out half mile diameter holes in Borg cubes. So a single shot would pretty much burn away a whole Star Destroyer. With a rate of fire of a Star Destroyer destroyed per secound or two…. Thrawns not got much leverage in battle.
On the other hand, the Enterprize would be a staggering resource. Thrawn would really want to find a way to leverage that, and at all costs .. keep them from uniting with the rebellion. If Thrawn realizes that the democratic republic desired by the rebels, is exactly what the federation is and prefers. He’s going to sense a extreme threat. Rather then a possibility of mutual destruction. The Galaxy class could whipe out imperial fleets with little risk to itself.
Thrawn manipulating Picard to stay away from the rebels, while dealing with a ship full of various races and cultures he knows nothing about … and hopefully doesn’t start a fight with.
th-cam.com/video/edqZK6Qitco/w-d-xo.htmlsi=y861f-XKYA_-m7Jv
It depends is it the cannon version or Disney version of Thrawn.
Ahhhhahahahahahah…… you are exceptionally comedic.
There is no proof a phaser is more dangerous than heavy turbolaser batteries, because they run on different power sources in different worlds fired at different enemies. I might mention that the kind of orbital bombardment enterprise D puts on planet surfaces achieves in days what a Star destroyer achieves in hours, or that a Borg Cube is not the material equivalent of a star destroyer. Not to mention the differentials in the power of their shields reactors. Enterprise is not a warship, it’s an exploratory vessel. It’s common practice to put heavier shields and weapons on warships than civilian ones, and Star Wars is a galaxy that’s been in perpetual war since the inception of the republic some tens of thousands of years prior to the movies. I can guarantee they have advancements in weapons that render anything in Star Trek obsolete just by their track record.
Also, thrawn potentially has access to death stars in his fleet, with two super star destroyers outfitted with eclipse cannons. I don’t think I need to explain just how outgunned Picard would be if a single one of those ships entered the zone.
*Enterprise
@@nathanielweber7843 Thrawn would get destroyed in a fight with the Enterprise. In fact, he would suffer that no matter which Enterprise he fought.
His best chance is against Kirk, but his ship manoeuvres as well as the D did in Picard Season 3 finale.
Thrawn has no chance, because all the Starfleet ships would be at warp speed firing their weapons, and had already totally scanned and prepared their most optimal tactics before firing.
Any other fighting done that does not happen at warp, is because they are dealing with contemporary threats that need to be dealt with in drawn out fights. Thrawn's ship does not meet that threshold.
He would get the standard warp flyby slaughter, and yes, that is a combat protocol. Especially if Troy has confirmed telepathically that Thrawn is crafty, has no intention of dealing with Picard, be completely hostile to any deals way beyond even the Romulans, and has elements available to him that would defuse her abilities.
Sorry, not very interesting.
Picard wins every time, for one simple "but all powerful" reason....Q. Q has a affinity with Picard, therefore I'm guessing he would not let Picard lose, but this is Q we are talking about, so anything goes really.