Supreme Court PMLA Order Has Major Flaws, Issue Deserved More Serious Consideration-Justice Lokur
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/...
In a wide-ranging interview, one of the most illustrious former judges of the Supreme Court has said he is “disappointed” that the Supreme Court did not give “more serious consideration” to many of the amendments of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act which it has recently upheld. Justice Madan Lokur says these amendments should have been looked at in a larger context by a larger bench. He said perhaps they could have been referred to a 7-judge bench. In the interview Justice Lokur made clear he has serious reservations with the Court’s judgement thus suggesting it has major flaws. Speaking generally about the Supreme Court, he said “it seems to be accepting what the executive wants it to accept”. The impression has been created “the Court is partial to the government”.
Justice madan lokur thank you! Indeed your words,analysis approach and message even in law & order cases entails and focus on humane approach is frankly the that still hope every ordinary citizen of this country look up to supreme court again and again for the justice in his lifetimes.
Sometimes I dream of becoming so significant and impressive a personality to be interviewed by Dr. Karan Thapar. I really don't understand why so many people, so called politicians and other famous people avoid him or avoid to be on his show??
But before that I earnestly pray to God to give Karan ji, very good health, so that my dream can come true. This show inspires me to read voraciously, speak eloquently and and think astutely.
🙃🙂😊
Because the criminals can not stand tall infront of people like karan thapar... these bloody politicians can make public fool but not intellectuals and brave personalities like karan thapar
well said, may you have much success.
@@joymascarenhas3491 thank you so so much for your kind words. I shall work hard for this dream aspiration of mine incessantly! 🙂
He speaks like a legend!!!
Excellent
V.good
By giving such rulings as in the case of 'PMLA' , the Supreme court is making itself look unpredictable , unreasonable , illogical and arbitrary .
लोकुर साहब बहुत सही बातें बता रहे हैं।
I feel that like-minded legal fraternity, ex-judges should join hands to fight the might of the state in the interest of the people of India and the country.
Are we to assume that SC judges do pass judgements 'without application of their minds' ?
Before 2014, people of India had trouble with price rise, falling rupee, unemployment, corruption and border security.
Now, under the toxic influence of Hindutva, people don't care about historic prise rise, record fall of rupee, highest unemployment in history, corruption of Smriti Irani, Modi, Choksi & Adani, sky-high petrol prices, fall in press freedom index, fall in hunger index and China capturing our land in AP & Ladhak.
Outspoken should be followed with productive is important
If ED is empowered like this . ED should may made accountable. Their conviction rate is only 0.4% . How remaining 99.6 .% victims will get justice.
Indeed a qualitative discussion....but. perhaps it is better some other retired SC Judge are now volunteering themselves for interview....
Lokur and Karan do not want any law in India !!
Authorities may be under duress
Judges too might compromise
Let us mot be held to ransom
Because of the peoples cowardice
Tankhwaiahs are often confused
Religions will even criminals mollify
Nations are built by strong pioneers
Who dare at all costs do whats right
Are you aware in santhali.
Bidin and ishai.
Extremely sorry,,,factuality on record says that Supreme Court has never indicated that how constitution is being subverted by elected people,they always serve the cause of the political ruling party not of the constitution
Bewkufo....tumhe hi sara fear rehta h kya
Ha jiske pas dimag hota hai analysis ka use hi fear ya hope hota hai tum jaise brainless logo ko bs bjp ne kia hai thik hi hoga rehta hai dimag to kam nhi krta😂
The Judgment of Justice Khanvilkar on Teesta Shetalbad is very unfortunate clearly the judgment displayed the judgment given at the behest of the Modi Government and showed the court in a very poor light and typically against Muslims, whereas in the same incidents other judges relied upon the same evidence of documents and witnesses when he has come to deliver a judgment he should be fearless. should not be under any pressure.
Future RS member... khanvilkar
Not only PMLA ordered but Aadhar Ordered, Rafael Ordered to name few has major flaws.
Exactly.
Why can't the judgement of the SC regarding PMLA not be reviewed again ,and do ex-SC Judges not take up the matter if they feel that that the SC has erred in the matter.
Yes,
I wholeheartedly love and support this show. It's a class in itself, amidst the other countless crass shows which are so excruciatingly painful to watch!
And for me, I personally take this show as a learning session, a beautiful and enjoyable lecture series where all eminent personality teaches me something very special, every episode.
As always in his talks, LEARNED, Hon. Justice Madan Lokur, has given his perspective very clearly. In the interest of JUSTICE. Wish & Pray a larger Supreme Court bench looks into PMLA Judgement. It will shield & protect CITIZENS from worngful Trial, Jail & PERSECUTION. Thank you Justice & Karan Thapar Ji for eliciting all the important points in the Context
The very genesis of the octopus provisions brought by the amending act of 2018 is questionable as it formed part of the Finance Act. For that one reason the Hon’ble Supreme court should strike down the amendments of 2018 and it should adhere to the principles of basic structure of the Constitution thereby nullifying the evil contents in the PMLA INCLUDING THE AMENDMENTS BROUGHT IN 2013.
A very frank interview and lucid explanation of the implications of the law settled by the Supreme Court.
One of the show to watch, hear the views of imminent with high integrity personalities.
Thanks Sir for your valuable concept !!!
Every question drafted is clearly for us and on behalf of common people.
Great !!
God bless!!
Can ELECTORAL BONDS fall under PMLA act?
Can you elaborate it sir
Excellent discussion. M more informed now on the serious flaws of PMLA. Another failed judgement by the SC... appeasing the BJP Gov't, not in favour for the people. Satyamev Jayate.
JUSTICE LOKUR'S PENSION............ABOUT TO STOP
Excellent interview, Justice Lokur answered with simple examples , even non legal person can understnd. Thank u very much, very enlightening.
Mr. Karan Thapar, very good n real informative n rightly directed unterview. All of your such interviews are very highly needed to be with hindi translation or hindi sub titles, as majority of our viewers may not be knowing english n they are left out of such right knowledge.
Present track record of ED is very suspicious. Their conviction rate is only 0.4% . It means 99.6 % people is suffering without any mistakes. Therefore, this judgment is certainly condemnable.
Supreme court verdicts are final but need not be delivering justice. Most unfortunate, indeed.
khan vi kar will get govt plum posting. good job by loyal servant.
Sir, I am always watching your all bold, true facts and Best narrated videos. I am your BIG fan. Please carryon to save my beloved country. We all indian American are always stand behind you to support your every words spoken by you. Thanks. From: Manubhai Patel, Plano, Dallas, Texas, USA.
आपकी वीडियो देखने की मेरी बहुत तीव्र इच्छा होती है लेकिन समस्या ये है कि कभी हिंदी में बोलते ही नहीं। जिन्हें अंग्रेजी नहीं आती है लेकिन आपको देखना चाहते हैं मैं तो समझता हूँ उनके साथ बहुत अन्याय करते हैं आप
Abhi darjano retired judges maujood hain, lekin justice Madan B. Lokur jis tarah se janata ke issues ko address kar rahe hain, woh praiseworthy hai.
Can we have a next episode on d current economy, plz get pronab sen sir🙏
+1
Raise your voice 🗣️ against Unemployment, Inflation, Injustice, Hate. Save your Democracy save your Constitution. Live For Humanity spread only love 🕊️🙏. Jai Hind 🙏🕊️
If it is explain Hindi by other anchor of wire is a great service to mass public.
Once again,a very enlightening,elucidating and transparent talk on the agency of police like ED judgement of the honorable SC,the state of law and its dispensers in the present regime heading to total totaltarianism as prophesied by George Orwell in his satirical novel,"1984"( though about communism of the Soviet rulers),which was already latent in the Messiah cum demo-dictator coming to fascistist powers since 2014.There are no checks and balances in the four pillars of parliamentary democracy that the forefathers of our Constitution laid down.Only executive ,only executive conrolling all the institutions.True and fearless jourrnalism.All wishes of Hope and Success!!
Very illuminating and important interview 👏 lots to learn
Quality of justice in Hindu India depends upon the character, caste & religion of the judges. That's why the high caste hindus run judiciary of India rank at the bottom in the world. Sarkar e Khalsa Maharaja Ranjit Singh the Khalsa Sikh Empire had top quality justice systems & institutions but 1947 Hindu India still follow ramraaj model of low quality justice.
Didn't Sikh gurus & other leaders always justify their actions by saying that there were for the benefit of Brahmins?? Or are you against that viewpoint, sardarji ?
@@raajkumarwattal11 you must be smoking chillum or drinking somras. Sikhism is anti Brahmanism , Chandu & Gangu always attack Sikhism.
@@gurindersingh8109 You sound like a circumcised Sikh, because you know nothing about Sikhism. Sikhism is alive today only because of Brahmins. Without Brahmins this would have got wiped out. From Banda Bahadur to Satidas to Matiidas....it is only Brahmins who have supported Sikhism. Guru Gobind was very eager to keep Brahmins happy all through his life
INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS 🙏🇮🇳
खानविलकर कि राज्यसभा में सीट पक्की, 😁😁😁😁
English question:- How to take husband property.. Tell me what is the legal scope for a childless woman after 15 years of marriage to steal all or some of her husband's property. Also husband alive and separate from me.🙋!
🙋 கேள்வி :- ஒரு பெண்க்கு திருமணம் ஆகி 15 வருடம் ஆனது குழந்தை இல்லை. கணவனின் சொத்து அனைத்தையும் அல்லது கொஞ்சமாவது வாங்க வேண்டும் என்ன செய்வது சொல்லுங்கள்? என்னிடம் இருந்து கணவர் பிரிந்து இருக்கிறார்.
Modi hai to injustice hai. This party is power hungry and devides the nation on religious basis. Ver unfortunate we elected them. Change them next time. Jaago India Jaago. It's already too late. Vote judiciously next time.
Karan this discussion doesn't mean anything when the whole country is doused in corruption, you can have such discussion in UK where nobody in parliament, Govt and opposition,is corrupt. This idiot SC judge should know that, rules and regulations are Good, but with so much corruption anybody can be bought, everything falls apart. Yaar get real, you are not in UK.
Pradip. D seems to be lacking in elementary decency :
He has called Justice Lokur " this idiot judge".
The expression used is emblematic of the times we are living in.
There should be a public revolt by the public, against this nonsence practice of the Govt.. Even the Brirish Reggimne was not torturing the Indian citizens in such a inhuman way.. Are we ruled by the Govt. worst than the British regimme? In the case, Indians have lost their Independence, and what for we are celebrating the 75 th year kf Independence when practicaly it is not ?
Karan sir.
We seriously need you.
The various amendments in the PMLA have been passed treating it as Money Bill.Its Constitutionality on that ground is pending before the Constitutional bench of the apex court. What would happen to the judgment passed by the Justice Khanwilkar led bench ,if the Act is declared otherthan money Bill,that is General Bill or Act and should have been passed through procedure therefor .
😞😞😞😞😞
Present justice system has been designed and practiced more on technical and mechanical ground , which supposed to be design on human ground ! Which is resulting in frequent machanical breakdowns in delevering soulful verdicts .
Who will think about people general, when the public itself demands to be treated in mechanistic manner rather than with humanity and morality.. whatever is happening it is all with the nod of people general they think govt is right so if they make laws with mechanistic and more technical approach without taking humanity and any other aspect into consideration and neglecting ther laws. Then pointing fingers is all vain attempt. Let people first become victim unless they be victimised by their own nod they wont change their minds and by then all will be gone 😂😂😂.. so lets say good by to every possible good to happen 😂😂
Loktantra khatare me hai...
full support 👍🙏
Pavitra Shrawan Maah ke Teesre Somwaar ki Desh ke Sabhi Logon Ko Hardik Shubhkamnayen.---- Aam Jan Adhikar Manch, Buxar, Bihar.
What's sacred about Savan month, its horrifying inauspicious month of floods & misery. Brahmin lies kill people
My friend Karan, the tone of your question is very important. It cannot look like interrogation and have aggressive tone.
No his tone is always like this because he raise questions of concern and with the same fervour and valour he has to keep his question upright straight and in a assertive tone.. thats fine
Why point finger at Justice Gogoi and Arun Mishra; Justice Khanwilkar has left both of them.behind.
After stepping down from seat, all our judges become guardians of the rights of the common man. While in power,,,,,,? Why this?
Well done, Karan. Thank you, Justice Lokur for your candid answers.
Madan Lokur Former Judge of Supreme Court of India Why only this Judge always on wire ? he will get any money from WIRE ? he didn't read judgement fully ? why shouldn't consider that he is corrupt and collided with foreign agents ?
I presume Justice Lakor is a learned judge and so I wonder why he is harping on the issue "guilty unless proven innocent". I happened to listen to an interview of Mr. Santosh Hegde (ex-Lok Ayukta) by Rajdeep Sardesai. What I got clearly is as follows: In a normal crime like robbery or murder, the police have to do investigation and gather evidence to prove the crime. In the case of money laundering kind of cases: i) Say I have been caught with 2 Cr cash in my house. Naturally it is for me to "prove" the source of the cash and this can be done very easily if I am innocent. OR ii) There is a discrepancy between my income and what I filed in my ITR - it is for me to provide the source of ALL incomes and prove that my ITR is fine. So I believe that in such cases it is perfectly fine that the onus of proving innocence is on the accused. Even if I am wrongly accused/arrested, if I am really innocent and have all dealings in "white", it should not take too long for me to prove that my dealings are above board.
Sir, my basic question is -
1. Unless the predicate offence is proven in a court of law, how can the offence of money laundering be presumed. In other words if the predicate offence is disproved in the trial court then the money laundering investigation done by ED is totally useless.
Money laundering proceedings must commence only when the predicate offence is proven in court of law.
Is electoral bond comes under money laundering? Is buying MLAs and forming govt comes under money laundering?
THE WIRE NEWS CHANNEL 🙏🇮🇳
I have one question, why such interviews take place only with those who appose the Modi Govt.
Why you ignore the depth and ramifications of the offences under specifies PMLA. These forces have challenged the very democracy, economic and liberal values of the nation. You are also questioning the supremacy of parliament who represents the sentiments of the nation.
Please understand offenders under PMLA are powerful and manipulative in nature. Any laxity would prove detrimental to eventual delivery of justice. After all Judge sitting in chair will apply his logic n rational in bail cases.
These laws were enacted before Modi government, why they were not objected earlier. Changes if any in are part of the process. They are made through due process.
In nutshell it's a propaganda , for sure.
As always, Kaaran's searching questions and Justice Lokur's objective answers, give us a comprehensive view of the issue. I read in newspapers that a group is filing a petition in the SC fr a review of the PMLA Order. Let us hop for the best
Justice Lokur is synonymous to Hope,
But, he also muddled the same waters, he is awe stuck now watching through magnifying glass.
Justice Khanvilkar who is going to retire in a day or two pronounced this draconian judgement. Future RS member.
Justice Lokur and Karan thapar,may I have my 2 cents,just wondering why are we discussing this issue, will it matter .government rules ,justice better take a long nap,its all over,sorry to say this.
Excellent interview! I hope many more Justices will come forward like Justice Lokur and set the right record and help restore faith in the Supreme Court!
Dear brothers I m yr fan. I always love to see yr videos. Yr way of talking and attitude i love very much
Can i meet u in person. Good bye dear. Good night.
Court is surrendered towards Govt., It is no more a public serving institute. This is the conclusion.
मी प्रयत्न करतोय. आयकन्याचा आणि समजणाचा.
खानविलकर को कुछ जल्दी मिल जाएगा
A copy of any charge , investigation or Fir should be given to the person charged . Otherwise people are at a disadvantage to protect themselves.And a good idea for bullying. Different words are just manipulation but if same intent .
Thanks for enlightening. Did we not have a law that the state has to prove the guilt not the person or society or a body of people who charge them so we will do it too
Was it so evil in the past and why is this taken as progressive that it was used in the past . So it looks like everybody is a criminal . How can we become do untrusting and untrustworthy .
Hope chief justice refers PML act to larger bench for reconsideration so that this act is not used indiscriminately against political opponents and against those whom present regime doesn't like. Further law itself seems to be flawed wherein accused has to prove his innocence without being given the proof of his guilt
👍🏻
Mr. Karan is alone bird in a country of servile, self-seeking flatterers.
Keep up the good work Karan..,we all need some ray of sunshine in this era of darkness
KT IS UNNECESSARILY CREATING CONFUSION .
Process in the Punishment, that's the agenda here .
I support your channel.
A very informarive show.
Is India becoming a Police State ?
karan is fearless but logical.
सर जी इनसे ,नूपुर शर्मा पर दिए।अनावश्यक सुप्रीम कोर्ट के बयान के बारे में तो पूछ लेते!
SC.............HAHAHAA.....JOKE?
What is dictatorship
Very exciting
What is right 😱😱😱here
1:30 start
Thanks
Thanks
Thanks!
Thanks!
V good
Excellent program.
Is there any unsupporting option in link
Learn English
👍🏼❤️ The best interviewer..!
Thanks for the VDO
The current Regime has hammered one more nail on coffin of Individual Rights; while country was busy with bar in Goa & Drama in Parliament.
The sad part is Judiciary appears to be helping them.
Nice speach