*Anakin points finger at Palpatine* "Senate, I have terrible news, Chancellor Palpatine..doesnt wash his hands after using the refresher!" *loud gasps of shock and horror*
I sort of wouldn't mind seeing a What if Palpatine was just a regular power hungry guy, Basically Georges original plot for Star Wars where Palps is just a power hungry charismatic guy who manages to turn the Republic into an Empire but later gets turned into a puppet by his generals.
That would be awkward. Could you imagine if you told your nephew you were evil, then he ran off to tell you you told him you were evil? I feel bad for The Senate, having to deal with that kind of mindlessness in the Jedi Order.
What if the Jedi Council still refused to train Anakin and Padme's family fosters him? Stipulations: Count Dooku trains Anakin, either honoring the memory of Qui Gon's decision to take the boy in or combining it with Sidiouis's instructions to train him. Anakin and Padme still get together and the marriage doesn't have to be secret. Shmi is brought to Naboo to be safe and free as a favror to Anakin proposed by Queen Padme and supported by the other pilots of the battle against the droid army. Optional: Semi's new family is also invited to Naboo to live a new life with less worry.
My goodness this was great. A truly unique ending as well. Well thought out and entertaining as well as... tragic in a sense. You've convinced me to join that Patreon Quill. Your storytelling is simply superb.
What if on Mustafar Obi-Wan, instead of his original lines, said "Anakin the Jedi are evil" and Anakin would respond "From my point of view Palpatin is evil"? (Like when two people keep responding to each other with the same words and one says the others respons they will also say what the other has been saying.)
Before watching I gotta say in Cannon the Senate wouldn't have given a shit lol, most of them didn't even know what a sith was, and being a sith wasn't against any laws
1:57 The smart thing would be to throw the Lightsaber at Palpatine. If Palpatine stops it he showcases his Sith Powers in front of the whole Senate and proves them correct.
This was good! I got a suggestion tho, what if Tenebrous possessed Venamis and chose to hide in the shadows, perfected Midichlorian manipulation, and managed to resurrect Sifo Dyas as his apprentice after he commissioned the clone army?
Hi, I love your channel ❤, I subscribed to you because yours is so original and funny, But I have a request We all know that Darth Jar Jar always existed in the shadows, never interfereing, but, what if Lord Jar jar binks became a Jedi Master, and trained anakin?
You give some of the greatest what ifs I’ve seen, the amount of depth, detail and storytelling you put into your videos is amazing. Much love man, you deserve much more recognition ❤
What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
Can you do a What if Rahm Kota Died but Shaak Ti Survived The Duel On Felucia and took Rahm Kota’s place as Starkiller’s New Master and took over what was left of Rahm’s Militia?
How about What if Anakin Lost Trust in Palpatine during the Clone Wars? While you can decide which events occur differently but the idea is Anakin's experiences during the Clone Wars were different from the main canon and Legends. It could be a variety of factors such as noticing patterns in Palpatine's behavior, disagreeing with certain decisions made by the Galactic Senate under Palpatine, listening to Obi-Wan and Padme more, maybe he fought different battles and thus had very different experiences, maybe events such as Ahsoka's banishment, Fives' sudden betrayal after Tup's death, and potentially various other events affected him differently, maybe the carnage of the war made him jaded, or maybe he met (not corrupt and sane) separatists and was able to somewhat understand their motivations. The bottom line is Anakin goes through a very different character arc during the Clone Wars and by Revenge of the Sith (or something similar to it if for some reason the events that unfolded in this timeline prevent certain plot points of RotS) Anakin no longer sees Palpatine as a trustworthy father figure and even has suspicions about his true character (not necessarily of being a sith lord but at least being less than noble.) Again, I'll leave what specific events unfolded differently up to you, and I admit this one might need to be a two-parter if you want to explore the Clone Wars events more unless you're ok with a long video. Obviously this is merely a suggestion but I thought it could make for a more interesting take on most variants of Anakin not turning on the jedi.
I don't think that this is the direction Palpatine would take to respond to being accused, because the fact of the matter is that the only thing you changed was who Anakin went to with his witness testimony. He didn't have a record of his conversation with Palpatine. Additionally, being a Sith on its own hadn't been illegal since the Ruusan Reformation, so even if Palpatine was outed as a Sith without also proving that he was colluding with Dooku there would be no grounds to arrest him. As such, Palpatine doesn't need to accuse Anakin, Padme, Bail, Mon and Mace of treason in order to hurt their credibility when their accusations against him aren't properly backed to begin with. Now, if Anakin had actually recorded his previous conversation with Palpatine, _then_ Palpatine would have more of a reason to play hardball.
I'm pretty sure 99% of the Senate did not even know who Sidious even was. That was something the Jedi keeped to themselves as to not spread fear. So Anakin trying to tell the Senate that Palpatine was Sidious, all the senate members outside the Jedi would be like "Who is this Sidious person?". Yet Palpatine could still spin this in his favor, like convince everyone that the force is making the Jedi see and belive things that are not there or real.
@@starwarsquill something like that. My personal favourite idea is like a three part crossover series, Star Wars mixed with marvel. It will probably never be made but it would be really cool. The first one would feature the empire expanding into the unknown regions. Sidious put Thrawn in charge, the Chiss would lead missions into the outskirts of the galaxy, using Purgil remains and ancient night-sisters powers to develop a new hyperspace technology. This engine “folds” space time, allowing Thrawn and his fleet to cross the horizon line of black holes and other dangers. To explain, unlike the actual trilogy, Sidious momentarily got a hold of Ezra in the world between worlds, using him as a catalyst to sense his future downfall. In despair, Sidious focused on the nightsister teachings, seeing how they were able to stay alive. He plans to combine this part of the force with his master’s alchemy, hoping to retain his identity and body upon death to achieve immortality. In Plageuis’ notes, Sidious discovers a fatal flaw though, an infinite life requires something known as an infinity stone. And with Thrawn revealing that the Chiss Ascendancy had once fought against a bearer of one of these stones - dark elves - Sidious grows obsessed with reaching this other universe to unite the stones and avoid the future he foresaw. And so, Sidious and Thrawn finally breach the limit, passing Abaloth’s eternal prison which slowly transitions to the dark dimension. Finally, they pass the dark dimension, using an infinity stone tracker to exit space directly in front of Asgard’s ship currently being boarded by Thanos. While this was going on, Ezra also still sacrifices himself to free lothal, exiling himself and, in this case the last inquisitors to the unknown. However, as the rift has opened, the Purgil take a different course, drawn to earth due to the hum of the bifrost and depositing the Young Jedi next to Bruce in the Sanctum. Also, the rebels have substantially data on Thrawn’s activity and the secret mission, and they are well aware about a potential rift. Thanks to Ahsoka who saw his plans unfold in the world between worlds, the rebellion quickly activates their fleet, striking at the weakened empire and using a message from Scarif to ask all Jedi survivors to join them. The Jedi do join as the Death Star tries to maintain order, ending similarly to A New Hope. However, this time Vader is occupied with politics on Corescount, allowing Obi Wan to survive and join the rebel ranks will Luke. Here, they are entrusted with a specific mission alongside Ahsoka, Quinlin Vos, Leia, and others. They must journey with the Purgil to this galaxy far far away from a far time away, rescue Ezra, stop Sidious, and close the rift. So that would be the first one. The second one would see the empire fall into civil war, most of them fleeing under rebel onslaught and joining Palpatine in a conquest of the Marvel universe where he hopes to collect the stones. I don’t want to add too much Moree, so I’ll just leave it for now. If you do like any part, feel free to use it. And if you did read this far and this much, my respect, you have a lot of patience. Thanks.
What if Count Dooku *was* General Grevious? Either right before or during AOTC, Dooku is horrifically injured and forced to wear the suit originally intended by Grevious as a punishment by Sidious.
October hollowing ideas. Star wars zombie wars. Scenario 1. What if the Blackwing virus had an outbake on Coruscant. Scenario 2. what if the Blackwing virus had a galactic outbake, World war Z Styal. the book as well as the movie
@@starwarsquill I have just watched a heap of Death trooper material. Werther the story starts with the Vector crashing in a populated system or the our brake is in the clone wars it will be Awesome. its deadly enough that a galactic out brake is possible, but not to deadly that it can't be stopped but at a cost that will reshape the galaxy for century's. entire worlds and sectors that will be no go zones, ships traveling alone will be a death sentence as roving death ships snatch up the unsuspecting, fortress cities ready to stope any outbakes. the Jedi will perhaps have to take up positions of power they have not held since the last sith war. interesting.
I don't get the time it took for them to prepare, call the senate together and present their evidence. Shouldn't Ahsoka be back on Coruscant by that time? Going to Palpatine's office, fighting and Order 66 being called would take way less time than for "having their day in court (senate)". In the original timeline Ahsoka was onboard her ship, yet here she would either be orbiting Coruscant, landing, transitting to the Temple or at the Temple.
What if anakin was a girl? It seems like it might not change much, but it definitely will. 1. Annie (anakin) won't fall in love with padme 2. Since girls mature faster, she might not be as tempted by the dark side. 3. Luke and leia wouldn't exist. 4. You will be able to use Taylor Swift as her image. 5. And if she did turn to the dark side, the witches of dathomir might accept her as a witch, and then, with her extreme power, become mother skywalker. 6. Because she is a girl and therefore not as physically strong, she would be less likely to use form 5. This would lead her to use form 4, similar to qui gon jinn. This would lead to less anger. 7. Assuming that padme is a guy, annie would be the one getting pregnant if the relationship happens at all. 8. She would have a better relationship with Ahsoka, and they would be more comfortable around each other. 9. She might fall in love with obi Wan because young annie looks up to jedi. Palpatine would be able to use this to turn her to the dark side. 10. It would be interesting
*Anakin points finger at Palpatine*
"Senate, I have terrible news, Chancellor Palpatine..doesnt wash his hands after using the refresher!"
*loud gasps of shock and horror*
19:52 Fitso: I also lost my apprentice too (even though he wasnt killed during Order 66 but by Grevious during the war)
What if Emperor Tartpatine yelled “Unlimited sour!” while using his gummy lightning bolts?
I’ll use that in the “What If Palpatine had slight memory loss?” Video lol
Swirly Lightning~
I sort of wouldn't mind seeing a What if Palpatine was just a regular power hungry guy, Basically Georges original plot for Star Wars where Palps is just a power hungry charismatic guy who manages to turn the Republic into an Empire but later gets turned into a puppet by his generals.
What if Sidious mistakenly showed Padme dying to Jar Jar instead of Anakin
Darth binks quickly tear palpatine to peices. using the force.
"Well, well palpy misa g'oing to kill you, only Ani can touch miss Padmé, misa protect his friends"
@@guillermofernandez1047 to be honest that would be jar jar as a sith lord
This needs to be done
@@gabrielpowers9135 I have a feeling Darth Jar jar would be embracing the true ideals of the sith, like passion and love
Imma save this vid for when i have work later tonight
Haha I hope you enjoy it :)
That would be awkward. Could you imagine if you told your nephew you were evil, then he ran off to tell you you told him you were evil?
I feel bad for The Senate, having to deal with that kind of mindlessness in the Jedi Order.
What if the Jedi Council still refused to train Anakin and Padme's family fosters him?
Stipulations: Count Dooku trains Anakin, either honoring the memory of Qui Gon's decision to take the boy in or combining it with Sidiouis's instructions to train him. Anakin and Padme still get together and the marriage doesn't have to be secret. Shmi is brought to Naboo to be safe and free as a favror to Anakin proposed by Queen Padme and supported by the other pilots of the battle against the droid army.
Optional: Semi's new family is also invited to Naboo to live a new life with less worry.
My goodness this was great. A truly unique ending as well. Well thought out and entertaining as well as... tragic in a sense. You've convinced me to join that Patreon Quill. Your storytelling is simply superb.
@@thisisachannel4575 I’m glad you liked it, man :)
What if on Mustafar Obi-Wan, instead of his original lines, said "Anakin the Jedi are evil" and Anakin would respond "From my point of view Palpatin is evil"? (Like when two people keep responding to each other with the same words and one says the others respons they will also say what the other has been saying.)
Great video
Before watching I gotta say in Cannon the Senate wouldn't have given a shit lol, most of them didn't even know what a sith was, and being a sith wasn't against any laws
So Anakin's Alter Ego is Mechanical Dr. Gregory House? Nice
1:57 The smart thing would be to throw the Lightsaber at Palpatine.
If Palpatine stops it he showcases his Sith Powers in front of the whole Senate and proves them correct.
What if Palpatine didn't stop it? What if he took an L on that specific day?
@@CalvinNoire Then you have a dead sith lord and a couple of rogue Jedi to be arrested.
Galaxy Saved
Palpatine could just easily claim that one of the other Jedi present there stopped the saber instead of him.
Yoda in a bag... So is he now master Yoga??
Did somebody say yoga?
13:37 "They betrayed us" Agent Pepsi Said
Loving the longer length! Well done friend😊
Glad you’re enjoying them :)
This was good! I got a suggestion tho, what if Tenebrous possessed Venamis and chose to hide in the shadows, perfected Midichlorian manipulation, and managed to resurrect Sifo Dyas as his apprentice after he commissioned the clone army?
That would be cool!! Thanks!
@@starwarsquill Np! If you choose to do that I bet it would be awesome! 👍 Either way I always look forward to your videos. Keep up the great work! 👏
51:17
Did Grandpa Palpy actually feel some sense of empathy towards his grandkids? How sad
I’ve been watching since 500 subs. Good fuckin work. Keep up the long videos and I’ll keep watching. This is better than any Disney content.
A what if that's an hour long? YES. PLEASE.
Hi, I love your channel ❤, I subscribed to you because yours is so original and funny,
But I have a request
We all know that Darth Jar Jar always existed in the shadows, never interfereing, but, what if Lord Jar jar binks became a Jedi Master, and trained anakin?
Gotta love these and Agro Squirrel, great for getting good rest!
:)
Love listening to these while I work
Glad you like em, man :)
Ditto. Nothing beats listening to these over excel spreadsheets
You give some of the greatest what ifs I’ve seen, the amount of depth, detail and storytelling you put into your videos is amazing. Much love man, you deserve much more recognition ❤
that was a nice twist in the end when Luke and Leia wanted to take out the old fool and were not necessarily on his side
What if Padme's family were secretly the last followers of the ancient Revanite order and took Anakin
Oooh interesting
Lots of potential here
Would be cool aswell to see him expand on the Revanites
What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
The Senate already knows he's Sidious... He told Anakin as much himself.
😂
Exactly 🙄
Can you do a What if Rahm Kota Died but Shaak Ti Survived The Duel On Felucia and took Rahm Kota’s place as Starkiller’s New Master and took over what was left of Rahm’s Militia?
How about What if Anakin Lost Trust in Palpatine during the Clone Wars?
While you can decide which events occur differently but the idea is Anakin's experiences during the Clone Wars were different from the main canon and Legends. It could be a variety of factors such as noticing patterns in Palpatine's behavior, disagreeing with certain decisions made by the Galactic Senate under Palpatine, listening to Obi-Wan and Padme more, maybe he fought different battles and thus had very different experiences, maybe events such as Ahsoka's banishment, Fives' sudden betrayal after Tup's death, and potentially various other events affected him differently, maybe the carnage of the war made him jaded, or maybe he met (not corrupt and sane) separatists and was able to somewhat understand their motivations. The bottom line is Anakin goes through a very different character arc during the Clone Wars and by Revenge of the Sith (or something similar to it if for some reason the events that unfolded in this timeline prevent certain plot points of RotS) Anakin no longer sees Palpatine as a trustworthy father figure and even has suspicions about his true character (not necessarily of being a sith lord but at least being less than noble.)
Again, I'll leave what specific events unfolded differently up to you, and I admit this one might need to be a two-parter if you want to explore the Clone Wars events more unless you're ok with a long video. Obviously this is merely a suggestion but I thought it could make for a more interesting take on most variants of Anakin not turning on the jedi.
What Dooku secretly switched Order 65 with Order 69 while switching order 69 with order 66?
What if Anakin told the senate before informing about this to Mace Windu?
this was really good
I don't think that this is the direction Palpatine would take to respond to being accused, because the fact of the matter is that the only thing you changed was who Anakin went to with his witness testimony. He didn't have a record of his conversation with Palpatine. Additionally, being a Sith on its own hadn't been illegal since the Ruusan Reformation, so even if Palpatine was outed as a Sith without also proving that he was colluding with Dooku there would be no grounds to arrest him.
As such, Palpatine doesn't need to accuse Anakin, Padme, Bail, Mon and Mace of treason in order to hurt their credibility when their accusations against him aren't properly backed to begin with.
Now, if Anakin had actually recorded his previous conversation with Palpatine, _then_ Palpatine would have more of a reason to play hardball.
This is so fire
Ankther good one.
I'm pretty sure 99% of the Senate did not even know who Sidious even was. That was something the Jedi keeped to themselves as to not spread fear. So Anakin trying to tell the Senate that Palpatine was Sidious, all the senate members outside the Jedi would be like "Who is this Sidious person?". Yet Palpatine could still spin this in his favor, like convince everyone that the force is making the Jedi see and belive things that are not there or real.
Wait... due to the Death Star not being finished, there weren't nearly as many casualties regarding the crew on the station
Anakin: "Hang this sith now! I got a rope right here!"
Would you ever consider doing a series of what ifs or crossovers
Xenomorph gets loose on Coruscant?
@@starwarsquill something like that. My personal favourite idea is like a three part crossover series, Star Wars mixed with marvel. It will probably never be made but it would be really cool.
The first one would feature the empire expanding into the unknown regions. Sidious put Thrawn in charge, the Chiss would lead missions into the outskirts of the galaxy, using Purgil remains and ancient night-sisters powers to develop a new hyperspace technology. This engine “folds” space time, allowing Thrawn and his fleet to cross the horizon line of black holes and other dangers. To explain, unlike the actual trilogy, Sidious momentarily got a hold of Ezra in the world between worlds, using him as a catalyst to sense his future downfall. In despair, Sidious focused on the nightsister teachings, seeing how they were able to stay alive. He plans to combine this part of the force with his master’s alchemy, hoping to retain his identity and body upon death to achieve immortality. In Plageuis’ notes, Sidious discovers a fatal flaw though, an infinite life requires something known as an infinity stone. And with Thrawn revealing that the Chiss Ascendancy had once fought against a bearer of one of these stones - dark elves - Sidious grows obsessed with reaching this other universe to unite the stones and avoid the future he foresaw. And so, Sidious and Thrawn finally breach the limit, passing Abaloth’s eternal prison which slowly transitions to the dark dimension. Finally, they pass the dark dimension, using an infinity stone tracker to exit space directly in front of Asgard’s ship currently being boarded by Thanos. While this was going on, Ezra also still sacrifices himself to free lothal, exiling himself and, in this case the last inquisitors to the unknown. However, as the rift has opened, the Purgil take a different course, drawn to earth due to the hum of the bifrost and depositing the Young Jedi next to Bruce in the Sanctum. Also, the rebels have substantially data on Thrawn’s activity and the secret mission, and they are well aware about a potential rift. Thanks to Ahsoka who saw his plans unfold in the world between worlds, the rebellion quickly activates their fleet, striking at the weakened empire and using a message from Scarif to ask all Jedi survivors to join them. The Jedi do join as the Death Star tries to maintain order, ending similarly to A New Hope. However, this time Vader is occupied with politics on Corescount, allowing Obi Wan to survive and join the rebel ranks will Luke. Here, they are entrusted with a specific mission alongside Ahsoka, Quinlin Vos, Leia, and others. They must journey with the Purgil to this galaxy far far away from a far time away, rescue Ezra, stop Sidious, and close the rift.
So that would be the first one. The second one would see the empire fall into civil war, most of them fleeing under rebel onslaught and joining Palpatine in a conquest of the Marvel universe where he hopes to collect the stones. I don’t want to add too much Moree, so I’ll just leave it for now. If you do like any part, feel free to use it. And if you did read this far and this much, my respect, you have a lot of patience. Thanks.
What if Count Dooku *was* General Grevious? Either right before or during AOTC, Dooku is horrifically injured and forced to wear the suit originally intended by Grevious as a punishment by Sidious.
That was brilliant - "Natural causes"
October hollowing ideas. Star wars zombie wars.
Scenario 1. What if the Blackwing virus had an outbake on Coruscant.
Scenario 2. what if the Blackwing virus had a galactic outbake, World war Z Styal. the book as well as the movie
Thanks, man :)
@@starwarsquill I have just watched a heap of Death trooper material.
Werther the story starts with the Vector crashing in a populated system or the our brake is in the clone wars it will be Awesome.
its deadly enough that a galactic out brake is possible, but not to deadly that it can't be stopped but at a cost that will reshape the galaxy for century's.
entire worlds and sectors that will be no go zones, ships traveling alone will be a death sentence as roving death ships snatch up the unsuspecting, fortress cities ready to stope any outbakes.
the Jedi will perhaps have to take up positions of power they have not held since the last sith war. interesting.
1 hour, this is gonna be good
Hope so :)
The evil twins were just a treat.
What if palpatine lost his grip on anakin leg in the invisible hands elevator shaft. Then proceed to go splat
What a great video
Glad you liked it, man :)
@@starwarsquillalways enjoy a good Starwars theory
What if Anakin told Jedi master Quill that Palpatine is Sidious?
13:36 who is Agent Pepsi lol
Agent Cola’s arch nemesis.
What if an ancient cult resurrected the sith emperor vitiate during the clone wars
What if Satele returned during The Phantom Menace and trained Anakin?
what if Palpatine was with Anakin and obi wan and Ashoka on mortis
@@Someone_1994 that’s a good one!!!
The Mortis Gods would have seen right through Palpatine immediately... But the Son would take Palpatine's side... Rule of two might come into play...
This this is Interesting 👌
I seen something extremely quite similar to this on another what if? IOoOI👌
@@TenkoBerry yea, this is actually continuing of the prior video but this is watchable without having seen that one :)
@@starwarsquill ahhh Okay that makes sense now hahaha IOoOI👍👍
What if anakin told the clones that Palpatine was Darth sidious and was playing both sides of the war
3 skywalker s together is way to much power for palpatine Vader alone has a 80 percent chance to hit palpatine with the force
Even in a suit he broke through Palpatine force barrier
So the Jedi agree to work with sith in the end ?
Or were the twins just unaligned force users at the end of it ?
Good what if
Thanks :)
I don't get the time it took for them to prepare, call the senate together and present their evidence. Shouldn't Ahsoka be back on Coruscant by that time? Going to Palpatine's office, fighting and Order 66 being called would take way less time than for "having their day in court (senate)". In the original timeline Ahsoka was onboard her ship, yet here she would either be orbiting Coruscant, landing, transitting to the Temple or at the Temple.
Where is cal kestis
He was on corruscant too .
Not during order 66
where’s “what if darth plagueis trained anakin” ?
Star Wars Theory already released the best version of this
1 hour Jesus Christ 😮
What if Windu/Anakin told the Senate that Palpatine IS THE SENATE?
Where was Starkiller?
And exagol
Leia = Sith. Period.
What if anakin was a girl? It seems like it might not change much, but it definitely will.
1. Annie (anakin) won't fall in love with padme
2. Since girls mature faster, she might not be as tempted by the dark side.
3. Luke and leia wouldn't exist.
4. You will be able to use Taylor Swift as her image.
5. And if she did turn to the dark side, the witches of dathomir might accept her as a witch, and then, with her extreme power, become mother skywalker.
6. Because she is a girl and therefore not as physically strong, she would be less likely to use form 5. This would lead her to use form 4, similar to qui gon jinn. This would lead to less anger.
7. Assuming that padme is a guy, annie would be the one getting pregnant if the relationship happens at all.
8. She would have a better relationship with Ahsoka, and they would be more comfortable around each other.
9. She might fall in love with obi Wan because young annie looks up to jedi. Palpatine would be able to use this to turn her to the dark side.
10. It would be interesting
Um... Palpatine IS the senate!